O R D E R (ORAL)
PER: JUSTICE S. SUJATHA, MEMBER (J)
This application is filed by the applicant under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following reliefs:
"I. Direct the respondents to adhere to the DOPT OM No. 22011/4/2013-Estt(D) dated: 8-5-2017, regarding model calendar for DPCs vide Annexure-A5 and further issue direction to convene the DPC for vacancies of 2019 vide Annexure-A5.
II. Further direct the respondent to consider applicant's representations on 22-3-2019 and 24-5-2019 vide Annexure-
A6.
III. Grant any other relief as deemed fit into facts and circumstances of the case, in the interest of justice and equity."
2. Briefly stated the facts as narrated by the applicant are that he was appointed as Assistant Fireman on regular basis from 20.11.2008 at Naval Dock Yard, Mumbai. Thereafter, the applicant was transferred to Naval Ship Repair Yard, Naval Base, Karwar.
3
He had completed 14 years of service in Fireman cadre. The Fireman cadre is the feeder cadre for promotion to the cadre of Driver. In accordance with the Recruitment Rules, the eligibility is, completion of 10 years of service in Fireman Level-1 cadre for promotion to the cadre of Driver. The mode of filling up the Driver post is promotion for Fireman, failing which by direct recruitment. There were vacancies available for the post of Driver from 2016 onwards but the respondents failed to adhere the model calendar for DPC issued by DOPT vide OM dated 08.05.2017. The representation submitted by the applicant in this regard has not yielded any response. Being aggrieved by non-convening of DPC and non-consideration of the representation submitted by the applicant, the applicant has preferred this OA.
3. Learned counsel Shri Kamalesan representing the applicant submitted that the applicant fulfils the eligibility condition prescribed in the Recruitment Rules for the promotion of Engine Driver post and eligible for consideration for promotion from 2019 as he was appointed as Assistant Fireman on 20.11.2008 on regular basis vide order dated 19.11.2008 issued by the office of the Admiral Superintendent, Naval Dockyard, Mumbai
4
(Annuexure-A1). The applicant was eligible for consideration for promotion to the cadre of Driver as on 20.11.2018 after completing 10 years in Fireman grade. No DPC was convened since 2019. The representation submitted by the applicant remained unconsidered. Hence, seeks for the reliefs claimed.
4. Learned counsel Shri Sayed S. Kazi representing the respondents, referring to the reply statement filed on behalf of the respondents, submitted that the mode of filing up Engine Driver post as per SRO 39/2017 was through promotion from Fireman, failing which by direct recruitment. The applicant has been transferred from Naval Dockyard, (Mumbai) to Naval Ship Repair Yard, Karwar on 21.08.2013, on his own request, on compassionate grounds with zero seniority. The requirement of 10 years commences from 21.08.2013, hence, the applicant is eligible for promotion to Engine Driver, only from 21.08.2023. The original sanction for the cadre of Engine Driver grade is 19, 8 employees have been promoted/recruited to the post of Engine Driver as per the Roster/Recruitment Rules. 10 posts of Engine Driver were abolished and revised sanction for Engine Driver is 9 as on date. 8 number of Engine Drivers being borne presently, there is one
5
vacancy in the grade of Engine Driver due to abolition of 10 posts vide letter No. CP (P&P)/4519/RC/BP dated 31.05.2022. Though the applicant possesses all qualification for the post of Engine Driver, the applicant's tenure in the base roster, which is minimum 10 years of qualifying service is not completed. As such, request of the applicant will be considered for promotion after 21.08.2023 depending upon availability of vacancies and SRO in force. Learned counsel has placed reliance on the order of this Tribunal in OA No. 422/2020 (DD 11.01.2023).
5. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and perusing the material on record, the moot question that arises for our consideration is, whether the service rendered by an employee in other naval department, from where he has been transferred on compassionate grounds, has to be reckoned for the purpose of eligibility for promotion?
6. The issue involved herein is no more res integra in view of the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pratibha Rani and
6
Ors. vs Union of India and Ors1. The Hon'ble Apex Court in para 5 has held thus:
"5. Thus, it is quite clear that insofar as issue of eligibility of promotion is concerned, the service rendered in the previous region, prior to transfer on compassionate ground, will be counted towards service for eligibility for consideration of such promotion. That it is a non- transferable job, makes no difference on this aspect as service is rendered in the same cadre."
7. In the light of this judgment, the defence taken by the respondents inasmuch as the applicant's ineligibility for promotion to the post of Engine Driver before 21.08.2023 is wholly untenable. Eligibility and seniority being two different aspects, cannot be mixed up.
8. In OA No. 422/2020, supra, this Tribunal has examined the claim of the applicant therein regarding seniority in the rank and consequently the promotion. Referring to the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Union of India and Ors. vs Deo Narain and Ors.2, in para 12 has observed thus:
"12. There are a plethora of cases which have spelt out the law applicable in such cases. These clearly specify that consequent to transfer on compassionate grounds to a new
7
cadre, the applicant loses his seniority and is consequently placed at the bottom of the seniority list in the new unit. His regular service in the old cadre is to be counted for the purpose of his eligibility while considering him for promotion by the competent authority."
It is thus held that the service rendered in the previous cadre is to be counted as regular service for the purpose of considering the applicant's eligibility for promotion in cases where certain minimum years of service is required for the purpose of making a person eligible for promotion. However, the service rendered in the earlier cadre is not to be counted for the purpose of seniority in the new cadre.
9. The entire approach of the respondents in refuting the claim of the applicant on the ground that the applicant is not eligible for promotion prior to 21.08.2023 in view of non- completion of 10 years regular service from the date of reporting to Commander of Yard (Karwar) is wholly unjustifiable and runs contrary to the legal principles enunciated by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Pratibha Rani, supra. No explanation is offered by the respondents for not convening the DPC for the available vacancies of Engine Driver since 2019. The issue whether the applicant is
8
coming under the zone of consideration for promotion with respect to his seniority and other aspects has to be considered by the DPC and not by this Tribunal. In the absence of convening the DPC, merely on the eligibility aspect, the candidature of the applicant for promotion cannot be denied.
10. For the reasons aforesaid, we pass the following:
:ORDER:
1) Respondents are directed to convene the DPC for the vacancies of 2019 for the post of Engine Driver/Engine Driver Grade-II, as expeditiously as possible, in any event, not later than 8 weeks from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this order.
2) OA stands disposed of accordingly. No order as to costs.
(RAKESH KUMAR GUPTA) (JUSTICE S. SUJATHA)
MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J)
/ksk/