JUDGMENT ON 11.07.2023, THIS DAY, THE COURT, PRONOUNCED
THE FOLLOWING:
ORDER
Challenging order dated 22.11.2017 passed by XLIII Addl. City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru (CCH-44), on I.A.no.4 in O.S.no.4316/2015 (Annexure-A), this writ petition is filed.
2. Sri T.H.Avin, learned counsel for petitioner submitted that subject matter of petition was immovable property bearing BBMP no.15, PID no.89-212-15 (site formed in Sy.no.60/2 of Kacharakanahalli, Kasba Hobli, Bengaluru North Taluk), situated at Ramachandrappa road, Kammanahalli, BBMP Ward no.89, Bengaluru, measuring East - West 40ft., and North - South 30 ft., totally measuring 1200 sq. ft. with ground floor building of 1100 sq. ft. and 800 sq. ft. on first floor etc. (hereinafter referred to as 'suit schedule property').
3. It was submitted that petitioner purchased suit schedule property under registered sale deed dated 28.02.2014
- 3 -
from Smt.Roopashree, who had got it under a gift deed dated 20.01.2014 executed by her mother - Smt.Kanakarathna.
4. It was submitted that O.S.no.4316/2015 was filed by petitioner seeking for possession of suit schedule property from respondents. Though, respondents were duly served with summons, they did not file written statement. However, they filed I.A.no.4 under Section 10 read with Section 151 of CPC, for stay of further proceedings in suit in view of pendency of RFA no.502/2015 filed challenging judgment and decree dated 14.01.2015 passed in O.S.no.4356/2013. It was submitted that in affidavit filed in support of said application, it was stated that defendant no.1 - Smt.Rukmini had filed O.S.no.4356/2013 against her mother Smt.Kanakarathna and elder sister Smt.Roopashree M.A. for partition and separate possession of 1/3 share in suit schedule property. In said suit, I.A.no.2 was filed under Order VII Rule 11(d) of CPC for rejection of suit as barred by Section 14 of Hindu Succession Act, 1956 ('HS Act' of short).
5. Though, petitioner filed objection against said application, it came to be allowed by order dated 14.01.2015
- 4 -
and plaint was rejected holding that suit schedule property was absolute property of defendant no.1 - Smt.Kanakarathna and petitioner had no right to claim partition in it. And aggrieved by said order, RFA no.502/2015 was filed before this Court and same was pending.
6. It was further stated that right claimed by plaintiff was under registered sale deed dated 28.02.2014 allegedly executed by Smt.Roopashree claiming right under alleged gift deed 20.01.2014, whereas right of Smt.Kanakarathna to execute gift deed was disputed. Since said dispute was to be resolved in RFA no.502/2015, present suit could not proceed until final resolution of said dispute. It was stated that issue in present suit was substantially same as in Appeal and hence, present suit could not continue.
7. It was submitted that petitioner was bonafide purchaser of property from his vendor which was her self- acquired property. Prior to filing suit, petitioner had issued legal notice to respondent on 01.04.2014 to deliver possession, which was not complied. It was submitted that in view of rejection of their plaint, respondents had no right over suit
- 5 -
schedule property. Since respondents had filed I.A.no.4 under Section 10 of CPC, at fag end of suit i.e. when matter was posted for cross-examination of plaintiff - PW.1, application was neither bonafide nor tenable on merits. Trial Court allowed application without considering nature of right under which plaintiff's vendor had executed sale deed. It was submitted that suit schedule property standing in name of Smt.Kanakarathna would be her absolute property by virtue of Section 14 of HS Act. Such being case, daughters would have no claim over it during her lifetime. As such, Smt.Kanakarathna was fully competent to execute gift deed in favour of Smt.Roopashree, who was none other than her daughter. It was also contended that by virtue of order VIII Rule 5 of CPC, suit in O.S.no.4316/2015 was required to be decreed upon failure of defendants to file written statement. Failure of trial Court to follow Order VIII Rule 5 of CPC called for interference.
8. It was further submitted that when defendants had failed to file written statement, they had no right to file application under Section 10 of CPC. It was further submitted that RFA no.502/2015 was in any case stood dismissed for non-
- 6 -
prosecution by order dated 07.04.2016 and therefore, could not be stated to be pending as on date of passing impugned order.
9. It was also contended that Section 10 of CPC would not apply in instant case, as parties in O.S.no.4316/2015 and O.S.no.4356/2013 were different and even relief claimed were different and distinct. It was submitted that petitioner had purchased suit schedule property on assurance of his vendor that possession of suit schedule property would be delivered within one month of execution of sale deed on ground that no other than vendor's sister was occupying it.
10. It was submitted that if impugned order was allowed to be sustained, petitioner, who was bonafide purchaser for value would be made to await final disposal of appeal, which was not even being pursued in all earnest. Same would subject to irreparable loss and injury to petitioner and also amount to permitting respondents to abuse process of law.
11. In support of his submission, learned counsel relied upon following decisions:
i) Sakina Bee Vs. Mohamed Amir Saheb and Ors.
reported in AIR 1976 KAR 226, and Srinivas Vs. Venkatappa reported in ILR 1988 KAR 748, for
- 7 -
proposition that if defendant does not deny allegations of fact made in plaint either by specific averments or by necessary implication, said allegations were to be taken as admitted by defendants and applying provisions of Order VIII Rule 5 of CPC, suit could be decreed. It was also observed that for such consideration, whether defendant had filed written statement or not, would not be relevant.
ii) Smt.Sushila Jain Vs. Rajasthan Financial Corporation, Jaipur reported in AIR 1979 Rajasthan 215, for proposition that where defendants failed to file written statement despite providing sufficient opportunity and at fag end moved application for stay of suit and sought adjournment for questioning order rejecting application, High Court of Rajasthan had upheld order passed by trial Court for forfeiting defendant's right to file written statement. And on decision of High Court of Patna in Nathuni Sah v. Kashi Nath Mishra, reported in 2002 SCC OnLine Pat 655, wherein an order decreeing suit relying on Order VIII Rule 5 (2) of CPC on non-filing of written statement by defendants was upheld.
iii) M/s Kuvarp Industries and Anr. Vs. State Bank of Mysuru, reported in ILR 1984 KAR 1086, for proposition that a decree passed invoking Order VIII Rule 10 would be an ex-parte decree and thus amenable to either provisions of Order IX Rule 13 of CPC of an Appeal under Section 96.
iv) Mallayya Vs. Totayya reported in ILR 1989 KAR 807, for proposition that Division Bench of this Court had held that language employed in Order VIII Rule 10 of CPC, after amendment of year 1976 would indicate that Court would be empowered to pass decree on very date on which defendant failed to file written statement; and on decision of learned Single Judge in
Mahantaswamigalu Guru Vs. Chairman Gram Panchayat of Managoli reported in ILR 1989 KAR 1942 reiterating it.
- 8 -
v) Rajendr Kumar Vs. Kuldip Singh and Ors. reported in 2014 (15) SCC 529, for proposition that merely on ground that suit in O.S.no.4356/2013 was rejection of plaint, would not render it any less a decree than one passed on merits and defendants therein cannot raise such contentions against it.
vi) Shantilal Gulabchand Mutha Vs. Tata Engineering and Locomotive Co. Ltd. and Anr. reported in 2013
(4) SCC 396, for proposition that even in case of failure to file written statement, power of Court under Order VIII Rule 10 would not be to discharge obligation on plaintiff to prove facts mentioned in plaint, unless it was satisfied that there is no fact that required to be proved inspite of provision for deemed admission.
vii) Vinayak Shreedhar Kulkarni Vs. Chintaman Vaman Kulkarni reported in AIR 1938 Bombay 470, for proposition that merely on ground that defendant did not file written statement, Court would not be justified in proceeding to hear suit ex-parte, but should be posted for hearing in default of filing written statement, wherein he was required to be granted opportunity of advancing contentions against decreeing suit.
viii) Om Prakash Gupta Vs. Union of India reported in
AIR 2000 SC 3585, for proposition that where defendant failed to file written statement inspite of repeated opportunities, Hon'ble Supreme Court had allowed application filed under Order VIII Rule 10 ad directed trial Court to dispose of suit.
12. On other hand, Sri Abhinav R., learned counsel for respondents sought to support impugned order. It was submitted that admittedly, O.S.no.4356/2013 was filed for partition and separate possession in respect of suit schedule
- 9 -
property. Therefore, one of necessary findings required to be given is about plaintiff's interest in suit schedule property and also about exclusive right of petitioner's vendor to alienate suit schedule property. Therefore, subject matter of present suit was substantially same as that in pending appeal, trial Court was fully justified in allowing I.A.no.4 and no interference warranted. It was also pointed out that present suit for possession filed by petitioner herein was subsequent to suit filed by respondents for partition. In any case, since possession of suit property continued with defendants, application under Section 10 was maintainable.
13. It was further submitted that though RFA no.502/2015 was dismissed for non-prosecution, application for its restoration was filed and same was pending.
14. Referring to I.A.no.4 and affidavit filed in support thereof, it was submitted that suit schedule property in O.S.no.4316/2015 was same as in O.S.no.4356/2013 and as parties in present suit were claiming rights under parties in earlier suit, all necessary ingredients of Section 10 of CPC were
- 10 -
satisfied and only after duly verifying same, trial Court allowed application. Hence, same did not call for interference.
15. In support of his submission, learned counsel relied upon decision of this Court in M. Narayanaswamy (dead) by LRs Vs. M. Narayanappa and Ors1., and Babu Mother Savavva Navalgund and Ors Vs. Gopinath2, for proposition that a gift by co-parcenor of his undivided interest in co- parcenary property without consent of all co-parcenors would be void as against other co-parcenor/s.
16. Learned counsel also relied upon decisions in case of Sri Rama Tiwary and Anr. Vs. Beholi Devi and Anr.3, and M/s. RUP Chand Dharma Chand Vs. M/s Banarsi Lal4 for proposition that there was no legal bar against entertaining application under Section 10 of CPC without filing written statement by defendant.
17. Relying upon decision in National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences Vs. C.Parameshwara5,
- 11 -
it was contended that main purpose of Section 10 of CPC as held by Hon'ble Supreme Court was to avoid adjudication of same issues in two parallel proceedings.
18. Heard learned counsel and perused impugned order.
19. From above submission, it is seen that in instant case, petitioner's suit for possession of suit schedule property is based on title stated to be acquired by petitioner under registered sale deed dated 28.02.2014 executed by Smt.Roopashree, who got it under registered gift deed dated 20.01.2014 executed by her mother - Smt.Kanakarathna. Defendants in present suit are Smt.Rukmini and her husband - Sri C. Vallinayagam.
20. Admittedly, no written statement was filed. When suit was listed for cross-examination of plaintiff, I.A.no.4 invoking bar against proceeding for trial under Section 10 of CPC was filed, alleging that subject matter of present suit was substantially same as in earlier instituted suit i.e. O.S.no.4356/2013 in respect of same suit schedule property. Earlier suit was filed by Smt.Rukmini against her mother
- 12 -
Smt.Kanakarathna and elder sister Smt.Roopashree alleging that suit schedule property was joint family property and she also had 1/3rdshare in it. Therefore execution of Gift Deed dated 20.01.2014 by Smt.Kanakarathna without obtaining her consent and sale deed dated 28.02.2014 executed by Smt.Roopashree in favour of present petitioner would be void.
21. Though her plaint in O.S.no.4356/2013 was rejected on ground that appeal was filed against rejection of plaint and was pending and as appeal would be continuation of suit, bar under Section 10 was invoked by filing I.A.no.4.
22. As per respondents herein, decision in earlier suit on issue whether suit schedule property was absolute property of Smt.Kanakarathna, would bind purchaser of suit schedule property i.e. petitioner herein. Therefore, petitioner herein could not seek for relief of possession on basis of sale deed, validity of which was in question in earlier suit.
23. As per petitioner, application was not bonafide and filed with sole intention of harassing petitioner. And since, plaint in earlier suit was rejected on finding that suit schedule property was absolute property of Smt.Kanakarathna, there
- 13 -
was no cloud on petitioner's title and as appeal was in fact dismissed for non-prosecution, Section 10 of CPC would not apply.
24. While passing impugned order, trial Court observed that I.A.no.4 was filed by defendants under Section 10 of CPC alleging that subject matter of earlier instituted suit i.e. O.S.no.4356/2013 and present suit i.e. O.S.no.4316/2015 was same land. It observed that applicant's claim that even parties were same as petitioner herein was claiming title under sale deed executed by Smt.Roopashree, who was defendant no.2 in earlier suit.
25. It also took note of petitioner's contention that though both suits were in respect of same property, nature of interest espoused in respective suits were different. Even contention that in view of dismissal of RFA no.502/2015 for non-prosecution on 07.04.2016, application under Section 10 of CPC would not be tenable.
26. It observed that though, petitioner was not party to earlier suit, filed for partition of 1/3rdshare of Smt.Rukmini in suit schedule property. It observed that present petitioner was
- 14 -
claiming right under sale deed executed by Smt.Roopashree on basis of gift deed executed by Smt.Kanakarathna in her favour. Rejection of plaint in earlier suit was on finding that suit schedule property was not joint family property, but absolute property of Smt.Roopashree in view of Section 14 of H.S. Act. Since, finding on issue in earlier suit, whether suit property was absolute property of Smt.Kanakarathna, would apply to subsequent suit, Section 10 of CPC would come into play and stayed subsequent suit.
27. Admittedly, in present suit, petitioner - plaintiff is claiming right to possession on basis of title acquired by him under registered sale deed dated 28.02.2014 executed by Smt.Roopashree, who got title over suit schedule property under gift deed dated 20.01.2014 executed by Smt.Kanakarathna in her favour. To be entitled for relief of possession, plaintiff would be required to establish that he acquired valid title in respect of suit schedule property. As such it would appear that there is some overlapping of issues in both suits.
28. But, plaint in earlier suit came to be rejected with finding that suit schedule property was absolute property of
- 15 -
Smt.Kanakarathna and suit was barred under Section 14 (1) of HS Act. Indeed, against said rejection, an appeal in RFA no.502/2015 is filed. However, same is admittedly dismissed for non-prosecution on 07.04.2016. It was claimed that application for restoration was filed and pending.
29. To a query, learned counsel for respondents submitted that appeal was not yet restored and that even petitioner herein had filed application for impleading himself in said appeal. Therefore, it was evident that outcome of earlier suit would non-suit petitioner in subsequent suit.
30. One of main grounds for opposing application was that application was not bonafide and filed only with intention to harass petitioner by dilating suit after having failed to file written statement. In this regard, petitioner has specifically contended before trial Court that despite sufficient opportunity being granted, defendants failed to file written statement. And only when matter had progressed to stage of cross-examination of plaintiff, i.e. at fag end of suit, they filed instant application.
- 16 -
31. Thus, there is no dispute about suit schedule property in both suits being same. There is also no serious dispute about parties.
32. But plaint in earlier suit was rejected with finding that suit schedule property was absolute property of Smt.Kanakarathna and therefore suit was barred under Section 14 (1) of HS Act. Said finding would benefit petitioner herein. On ground that order of rejection of plaint was challenged in appeal, which was stated to be pending, trial Court proceeded to stay subsequent suit.
33. However, RFA no.502/2015 is admittedly dismissed for non-prosecution on 07.04.2016. Though application for recalling is stated to have been filed, appeal is not yet restored. Thus, it would be evident that respondents are not diligently pursuing appeal, resulting in dilation of suit proceedings.
34. While explaining contours of Section 10 of CPC, Hon'ble Supreme Court in ASPI Jal And Another Vs. Khushroo Rustom Dadyburjor6, held as follows:
6 2013 (4) SCC 333,
- 17 -
"9. Section 10 of the Code which is relevant for the purpose reads as follows:
"10.Stay of suit.—No court shall proceed with the trial of any suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties, or between parties under whom they or any of them claim litigating under the same title where such suit is pending in the same or any other court in India having jurisdiction to grant the relief claimed, or in any court beyond the limits of India established or continued by the Central Government and having like jurisdiction, or before the Supreme Court.
Explanation — The pendency of a suit in a foreign court does not preclude the courts in India from trying a suit founded on the same cause of action."
From a plain reading of the aforesaid provision, it is evident that where a suit is instituted in a court to which provisions of the Code apply, it shall not proceed with the trial of another suit in which the matter in issue is also directly and substantially in issue in a previously instituted suit between the same parties. For application of the provisions of Section 10 of the Code, it is further required that the Court in which the previous suit is pending is competent to grant the relief claimed. The use of negative expression in Section 10 i.e. "no court shall proceed with the trial of any suit" makes the provision mandatory and the court in which the subsequent suit has been filed is prohibited from proceeding with the trial of that suit if the conditions laid down in Section 10 of the Code are satisfied. The basic purpose and the underlying object of Section 10 of the Code is to prevent the courts of concurrent jurisdiction from simultaneously entertaining and adjudicating upon two parallel litigations in respect of same cause of action, same subject-matter and the same relief. This is to pin down the plaintiff to one litigation so as to avoid the possibility of contradictory verdicts by two courts in respect of the same relief and is aimed to protect the defendant from multiplicity of proceeding."
- 18 -
35. It further held in Pukhraj D. Jain v/s G. Gopalakrishna7, as follows:
"… … It is not for a litigant to dictate to the court as to how the proceedings should be conducted, it is for the court to decide what will be the best course to be adopted for expeditious disposal of the case. …
… However, where a subsequently instituted suit can be decided on purely legal points without taking evidence, it is always open to the court to decide the relevant issues and not to keep the suit pending which has been instituted with an oblique motive and to cause harassment to the other side."
36. From above decisions, for invocation of Section 10 of CPC, following factors require to be established:
i) That subject matter of subsequent suit should be directly and substantially in issue in earlier suit;
ii) Both suits should be between same parties
iii) Both suits should be pending.
iv) But determining factor would be whether decision in earlier suit would non-suit subsequent suit.
37. High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Smt.Shankutala Vs. Latesh (in W.P.no.4113/2016 D.D. 23.01.2017, Indore Bench), has held as follows:
"The condition precedent to stay of subsequent suit is that earlier suit must be pending. Here, the suit has been decided and the appeal has been dismissed and the second appeal has not been admitted so far. Therefore, as on today no proceedings are pending in respect of same
- 19 -
property. However, Trial Court while rejecting the application under Section 10 of CPC has granted liberty to the petitioner to revive her application after admission of second appeal No.28/2014. Trial Court has not committed any error of law while rejecting the application and granting liberty to the petitioner."
38. Similar view is also expressed by High Court of Andhra Pradesh in case of Manta Subramanayya and others vs. Batchu Narasimha Swam and another8.
39. In view of dismissal of appeal and non-restoration even up to date of hearing this petition, it has to be held that above necessary precondition was lacking and requirements of Section 10 would not be satisfied. It is also seen that when contention against application being dilatory is canvassed, Trial Court would be under duty to verify whether defendants- applicants were pursuing appeal in bonafide and diligent manner or application was filed merely with intention of protracting proceedings. There is apparent failure by trial Court in this regard. Trial Court passed impugned order merely on basis of application for restoration having been filed and
- 20 -
requirements of Section 10 of CPC would not be met and as such, application could not be entertained at that stage.
40. In view of said finding, ratio laid down in aforesaid decisions relied upon by respondents would not come to their aid. Impugned order would thus call for interference. Consequently, following :
ORDER
i) Writ petition is allowed, impugned order dated 22.11.2017 passed by XLIII Addl. City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru (CCH- 44), on IA.no.4 in O.S.no.4316/2015 (Annexure-A) is set aside. I.A.no.4 filed by defendants is rejected for failure to meet requirements of Section 10 of CPC.
ii) Trial Court shall continue with suit in accordance with law, but keeping in mind ratio laid down in Sakina Bee and Srinivas's cases (supra).
Sd/-
JUDGE
psg*