AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 24A of the C.P. Act, 1986
  • Section 2 (r) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 24A of the C.P. Act, 1986
  • Section 2 (r) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The present Consumer Complaints (CCs) were filed by the complainants against the opposite party (OP) concerning the allotment and possession of flats in the residential project "Hyde Park Terraces" at Mullanpur, New Chandigarh. The complainants booked flats and entered into Independent Floor Buyers Agreements (IFBA) with the OP, which promised possession within 30 months from the date of application. Despite payments exceeding the agreed consideration, the OP delayed possession beyond the committed date and demanded additional, allegedly illegal charges. The complainants alleged breach of contract, unfair trade practices, and sought possession, refund, compensation, and litigation costs. The OP denied these allegations, claiming delays were due to authorities' approvals, the complainants were not consumers post-possession, and the complaints were barred by limitation. Multiple related complaints with similar facts were consolidated and disposed of by a common order, treating CC No. 791 of 2017 as the lead case. Evidence was submitted by both parties, and hearings were conducted before the Commission.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the OP was liable to hand over possession of the flats within the committed period as per the Independent Floor Buyers Agreement.
  2. Whether the delay in possession entitles the complainants to compensation and interest for the period of delay.
  3. Whether the additional demands and charges raised by the OP were illegal and unjustified.
  4. Whether the complainants qualify as consumers under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 despite taking possession.
  5. Whether the complaints were barred by limitation considering the delay and cause of action.
  6. Whether the terms of the agreement, including compensation clauses, are binding and enforceable against the complainants.

Arguments of the Parties

Complainants' Arguments

  • Booked flats and entered into agreements with committed possession dates, which the OP failed to honor.
  • OP inserted illegal clauses in the agreement and threatened forfeiture if complainants did not accept them.
  • Despite multiple promises and advertisements, possession was delayed repeatedly without satisfactory explanation.
  • OP demanded illegal and additional charges at the time of possession, which were not part of the agreement.
  • Facilities and amenities promised in the brochure were not provided, including club and community hall.
  • OP did not obtain the required completion certificate from the relevant authorities.
  • Delay and illegal demands caused financial hardship, mental agony, and harassment.

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • Partial Occupation Certificate (OC) was obtained, and basic amenities were provided as per agreement.
  • The complainants challenged a binding and mutually agreed agreement, seeking impermissible modifications.
  • Complainants booked flats for investment, and after possession, they cease to be consumers.
  • Complaints were barred by limitation as the cause of action arose more than two years before filing.
  • The delay was due to unavoidable delays in obtaining approvals from authorities, beyond OP's control.
  • Compensation clause in the agreement limits liability to Rs. 10 per sq.ft. per month for delay.
  • Complainants defaulted in timely payments, which contributed to delay and breach of contract.
  • Any compensation payable should be limited to interest @6% per annum from the committed possession date till the date of offer of possession.
  • Relied on Supreme Court judgments to support the binding nature of the agreement and limitation of liability.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pioneer Urban Land & Infrastructure Ltd. v. Govindan Raglivan (2019) 2 CPJ 34 (SC) One-sided contractual terms imposed by builders constitute unfair trade practices under Consumer Protection Act. The Court rejected OP's contention that parties are bound by all agreement terms, holding that unfair clauses are not binding.
Wg. Cdr. Arifur Rahman Khan And Aleya Sultana v. DLF Southern Homes Pvt. Ltd. (2020) 16 SCC 512 Failure to comply with contractual possession obligations amounts to deficiency in service; consumer fora have jurisdiction to award compensation beyond contract terms. Supported the complainants' entitlement to compensation for delay beyond contractual terms.
Ireo Grace Realtech Pvt. Ltd. v. Abhishek Khanna (2021) 3 SCC 241 Similar principles regarding deficiency in service and consumer protection in delayed possession cases. Reinforced the applicability of consumer protection law to real estate possession delays.
R.V. Prasannakumaar v. Mantri Castles Pvt. Ltd. Civil Appeal Nos. 1232, 1443-1444 of 2019 Developer's liability to pay interest @6% p.a. continues until possession is offered to flat purchaser. Guided the calculation of delay compensation interest in the present case.
DLF Homes Panchkula Pvt. Ltd. v. D.S. Dhanda (2020) 16 SCC 318 Examined legality of various heads of compensation for delay; held some awards unsustainable. Informed the Court's approach to awarding compensation only for delay and not multiple heads.
Bharti Knitting Co. v. DHL Worldwide Courier (1996) 4 SCC 704 Binding nature of contracts and parties' obligations under agreements. Supported OP's argument on enforceability of agreement terms, though rejected by the Court in context of unfair clauses.
Secretary, Bhubaneshwar Development Authority v. Susanta Kumar Mishra (2009) 4 SCC 684 Contractual obligations and limitations on modifications of agreements. Relied upon by OP to assert binding effect of agreements.
DLF Home Developers Ltd. v. Dr. Shipra Trapathi - Civil Appeal No. 1742 of 2022 Liability to pay compensation continues only until offer of possession is made. OP relied on this precedent to limit compensation liability up to the offer of possession date.
Smita Roy v. Excel Construction (2012) 2 CPJ 204 After possession is taken, the person booking the unit no longer remains consumer. OP cited this to argue complainants ceased to be consumers post-possession.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the pleadings, evidence, and submissions of both parties. It rejected the OP's objections regarding pecuniary jurisdiction and limitation, holding that the cause of action was continuing due to delayed possession. The Court found the OP's contention that complainants ceased to be consumers after possession as untenable. It also dismissed the OP's claim that delays were due to authorities' approvals, emphasizing the builder's responsibility to deliver possession timely.

The Court relied heavily on Supreme Court precedents establishing that one-sided clauses imposed by builders are unfair trade practices and not binding on purchasers. It held that failure to deliver possession within the contractual period constitutes deficiency in service, entitling the complainants to compensation. The Court noted that while compensation clauses existed in the agreement, these were minimal and did not preclude the right to claim compensation for delay.

Regarding additional charges and demands by the OP, the Court found that the complainants failed to establish which demands were illegal or unjustified. The Court also noted the complainants did not clearly specify which promised amenities were withheld. The delay between offer of possession and actual physical possession was not attributed to the OP in the evidence.

Accordingly, the Court limited the relief to delay compensation from the committed possession date to the date of offer of possession, rejecting claims for compensation beyond this period. For cases where physical possession was not yet delivered, the Court directed the OP to hand over possession within 30 days, complete with promised facilities.

Holding and Implications

The Consumer Complaints are allowed and disposed of with directions that the OP shall pay delay compensation at simple interest @ 6% per annum on the amount deposited by the complainants from the committed date of possession till the date of offer of possession.

The OP is also directed to pay Rs. 25,000/- as cost of litigation to each complainant and to make payments within two months of the order.

In cases where physical possession has not been delivered, the OP must hand over possession with all promised specifications and amenities within 30 days.

No broader precedent beyond the application of established Supreme Court principles is set by this order. The decision primarily affects the parties by enforcing compensation for delay and ensuring possession delivery.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    ANIL SEHGAL & ANR. v. DLF UNIVERSAL LTD. (PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS DLF INDIA LTD.)

    Inder Jit Singh, Member:— The present Consumer Complaints (CCs) have been filed by the Complainants against the opposite party as detailed above, inter aila praying for directing the OP to:—

    (i) hand over the physical and legal possession of the Unit complete in all respects in accordance with the allotment letter and independent floor buyers agreement with all the promised facilities and amenities mentioned in brochure/advertisement;

    (ii) pay interest calculated @15% p.a. on the amount deposited i.e. from the date of delay in handing over the possession till the date of possession.

    (iii) withdraw the illegal demand/additional charges and subsequent/consequential taxes and interest levied on the said demands.

    (iv) refund the amount charged in the name of parking.

    (v) pay compensation on account of causing financial hardship, mental agony, harassment, emotional disturbance to the complainants.

    (vi) pay litigation expenses.

    2. Since the facts and question of law involved and the reliefs prayed for in these complaints are similar/identical and against the same Opposite Party except for minor variations in the dates, events and flat numbers etc., which are summarized in the Table in para 5 below, these complaints are being disposed off by this common order. However, for the sake of convenience, Consumer Complaint (CC) No. 791 of 2017 is treated as the lead case and facts enumerated herein under are taken from CC/791/2017.

    3. It is averred/stated in the complaint that:—

    i) That the complainants booked a flat admeasuring 1881 sq.ft. on 29.08.2012 in the residential Project launched by the OP in the name of “Hyde Park Terraces” situated at Mullanpur, New Chandigarh. Floor Buyers Agreement dated 12.03.2013 was entered between the parties. The total consideration for the flat was Rs. 77,36,860/-. However, the OP issue final statement of account to complainants in which the price of the flat was indicated as Rs. 91,30,955/-, out of which, the complainants paid Rs. 91,16,717/- till 02.11.2016. The Independent Floor Buyers Agreement was executed on 12.03.2013 whereby a unit bearing No. R 2-F 812 FF (First Floor) with parking number P-1F was allotted to the complainants. The OP was liable to handover the possession of the unit within 30 months from the date of application, i.e. by 28.02.2015. The OP inserted many illegal clauses in the floor buyer agreement and on raising the objection by the complainants the OP informed the complainants to forfeit their complete amount alongwith booking about, in case the complainant does not enter in agreement with the OP and thus, the complainant had no option except just to sign the agreement with many arbitrary clause.

    ii) Despite promising several times and written commitments made in the independent Floor Buyers' Agreement, the OP failed to deliver the possession as promised and a new date of delivery of the unit was informed to the complainants whenever the complainants visited their office. The OP office also published an advertisement in newspaper Hindustan Times dated 13.01.2014 wherein OP again made another promise to handover the possession in 2014 but also failed to handover the possession in 2014. The complainants visited the office of the OP to know the date of possession but no satisfactory answer was given by the OP. The OP also promised to complainants to pay the compensation for delaying the possession as per clause 14 of the agreement, which is very meagre and just inserted while taking the benefit of their dominant position. Vide letter dated 28.09.2016, the OP offered physical possession of the unit while admitting the fact of the receipt of OC and asked the complainants to deposit amount of Rs. 19,23,303/- within one month with a condition that non submission of payment within 30 days of final statement of account would attract interest “Holding Charges” @ Rs. 10/- per sq.ft. per month as per the terms and conditions of clause 13 of the Floor Buyer Agreement. The OP vide letter dated 28.09.2016 asked the complainants to deposit the amounts on various heads. On receiving the huge, illegal and additional demands, the complainants inquired the office of OP and asked clarification qua all the illegal additional demands but the OP failed to clarify such demands with proper justification and further warned the complainants that in case complainants does not deposit the amount, the complainants have to pay holding charges as per agreement and furthermore their allotment of unit may be cancelled. As per clause 14 of the agreement, the OP did not pay compensation @ Rs. 10 per sq.ft. for delay in handing over the possession which is around more than one and half year.

    iii) The OP was supposed to give the possession on 28.02.2015 from the date of application and thus in that eventuality complainants are not liable to pay any other taxes and charges which occurred due to delay of the OP in handing over the possession. The OP raised the demands to make the profit at the cost of hard earned money of the complainants is illegal, unethical and liable to be quashed.

    iv) The OP has not received any completion certificate from Punjab Country Town Planning Department. It is also stated by the complainants that the State Commission also in CC/87/2016 decided on 27.05.2016 -Pardeep John David v. DLF Universal held against the same builder qua same project that basic construction work and amenities are not provided.

    v) The OP has not provided several facilities, as promised initially. The complainants are not liable to pay the club charges as till date no club and community hall and other promised facilities available in the township. The OP had given false promises and assurances to the complainants and had malafide intention with the motive to cheat and extract money on various illegal grounds from the complainants and further the OP's dealings were vague from the very inception resulting into harassment and mental agony to the complainants and also amounts to breach of trust. Furthermore the OP is giving the possession without promised facility while demanding the illegal payments under many heads which were never part of agreement, thereby allowing the complainants to take legal possession of the independent floor. Hence, the complainants are before this Commission.

    4. OP in their written statement/reply stated that:—

    i. OP received a Partial OC on 10.09.2014.Basic amenities such as roads, sewerage, drinking water, electricity, street lights, drainage etc. etc. have been provided in terms of the agreement. The partial OC is issued to the promoter only when the conditions were fulfilled.It is also contended by the OP that the complainants have challenged the mutually agreed and concluded and binding Agreement entered into between the parties. The complainants have made baseless allegationsof unfair trade practice etc. with an ulterior motive to amend/modify or re-write any concluded agreement/contract duly executed between the party to illegally invoke jurisdiction of this Commission. This Commission cannot adjudicate upon the matter where the prayers are for modification of the Clauses of the Independent Floor Buyer's Agreement. The complainants are virtually inviting the Commission to assume the powers conferred on the Fora under the Competition Act and/or under Civil Court. The complainants are not the Consumers and booked the Floor for investment purpose. The OP relied upon the judgment passed by this Commission in Smita Roy v. Excel Construction (2012) 2 CPJ 204 that after possession is taken, the person booking the unit no more remains consumer. The possession of the said floor was handed over to the Complainants on 17.05.2018.

    ii. The complaint was filed in March 2017.As per Section 24A of the C.P. Act, 1986 the complaint can be filed within two years from the date when the cause of action arose.In the present case, the complaint has been filed in March, 2017, whereas the reliefs sought are such that the alleged cause of action in relation thereto arose more than two years prior to the filing of the complaint.As such, the entire complaint in relation to the allegation contained therein and alleged relief sought, are completely barred by limitation. The present complaint is a challenge to the binding inter-se agreement entered into between each allottee and the OP, and the reliefs sought would virtually amount to amendment/modification/re-writing of the said agreement as per the whims and wishes of the complainants. The agreement was entered in 2013, which is three years prior to filing of the complaint.As such, the complaint on this count is ex-facie barred by limitation. The complainants in the complaint have vaguely stated about the limitation and cause of action to be continuing one without stating or disclosing as to when it first arose and how it is continuing. The complaint is liable to be set aside on the sole ground of limitation alone.

    iii. It is also contended by the OP that the parties are bound by the terms and conditions mentioned in the agreement. The Buyers Agreement was entered between the parties on 12.03.2013.The said agreement was duly signed by the complainants after going through the same and understanding each and every clause contained in the Agreement and agreed to perform his obligations as per the conditions stipulated in the Agreement. The said agreement is binding between the parties and the same cannot be withdrawn/modified by the complainants as per their own convenience. The OP has relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Bharti Knitting Co. v. DHL Worldwide Courier (1996) 4 SCC 704 and in the case of Secretary, Secretary, Bhubaneshwar Development Authority v. Susanta Kumar Mishra . (2009) 4 SCC 684.

    iv. It is also contended by the OP that there is no deficiency in service or unfair trade practice on the part of the OP. The delay, if any, has been caused due to time taken by the appropriate authorities in granting the approvals, which was much beyond the normal course and procedure. The OP has been pursuing the matter with various authorities and OP has suffered much loss, financially and otherwise, on account of such delay in grant of approvals. No case for unfair trade practice can be alleged unless it is proved that the trade practice is for the purpose of promoting the sale or services. The restrictions alleged in the present complaint do not prove promotion of sale or services ad contemplated which defines unfair trade practice. The OP made an endeavour to offer possession of independent floor within 30 months from the date of application. In case of delay in delivery of possession, delayed compensation for the same has been fully accounted for in the agreement itself.

    v. It is further contended by the OP that the party in breach cannot insist that the non-defaulting party perform its obligations in the time frame originally contemplated in the agreement, when a contract consists of reciprocal promises. In cases where the consumer has defaulted in making the payments, the consumer cannot insist that the builder perform its obligations. The complainants in breach of the terms of the agreement as they defaulted in payment of instalments. Despite the complainants being defaulters in timely payment of instalments, OP has compensated the complainants and paid Rs. 3,88,683/-. The OP submitted that the timely payment of instalments is the essence of agreement.

    vi. It is further contended by the OP that in accordance withclause 14 of the terms of the agreement, compensation clause has been duly incorporated. If the OP fails to offer possession of the said floor, within 30 months from the date of application, the intending allotteee having made all the payments as per payment plan and subject to the terms and conditions set out in the Agreement and barring force majeure conditions, the company shall pay compensation at the rate of Rs. 10/- per sq.ft. of the super area per month. The delay in offering the possession of the independent floor to the complainants, which was beyond the control of the OP, a remedy for breach has already been incorporated in the agreement executed between the parties. The OP also submitted that the complaint cannot be adjudicated under summary jurisdiction. The complaint be dismissed with costs.

    5. Evidence by way of affidavit was filed by the complainants as well as by the OP broadly on the lines of averments made in the complaint. The details of the floors allotted to the Complainants/other relevant details of the case are given in the Table below:—

    Sr. No Particulars Case No/ Complainant Case No/ Complainant Case No/ Complainant CC/791/2017 Anil Sehgal & Anr. CC/792/2017 B.S. Ahlawat & Anr. CC/814/2017 Gauri Sharma 1 Project Name/Location etc. “Hyde Park Terraces” Mullanpur New Chandigarh “Hyde Park Terraces” Mullanpur New Chandigarh “Hyde Park Terraces” Mullanpur New Chandigarh 2 Apartment no. R 2-F 812 FF R 2-F 812 GF R 2-F 812 SF 3 Size (Built up/Covered/Super Area) 1881 sq.ft. 1881 sq.ft. 1881 sq.ft. 4 Date of application 29.08.2012 18.08.2012 16.08.2012 5 Date of signing Independent Floor Buyers' Agreement(IFBA) 12.03.2013 23.09.2013 23.09.2013 6 Committed date of possession as per Independent Floor Buyers' Agreement (with Grace period, if any) (30 months from the date of application) 28.02.2015 18.02.2015 16.02.2015 7 D/o Offering Possession 28.09.2016 28.09.2016 28.09.2016 8 Actual D/o Physical Possession 17.05.2018 - - 9 Total Consideration as per IFBA Rs. 77,36,860/- Rs. 79,24,960/- Rs. 76,42,810/- 10 Amount Paid Rs. 91,16,717/- Rs. 93,34,527/- Rs. 90,15,340/- 11 D/o Filing CC in NCDRC 21.03.2017 21.03.2017 23.03.2017 12 D/o Issue of Notice to OP(s) 06.08.2018 04.07.2018 31.08.2017 13 D/o Filing Reply/Written Statement by OP 08.10.2018 29.08.2018 08.11.2017 14 D/o filing Rejoinder by the Complainants 13.11.2018 16.01.2019 30.10.2018 15 D/o Filing Evidence by way of Affidavit by the Complainants 13.11.2018 16.01.2019 30.10.2018 16 D/o Filing Evidence by way of Affidavit by the OP 24.12.2018 28.02.2019 23.01.2019 17 D/o filing Written Synopsis by the Complainant 22.01.2020 22.01.2020 22.01.2020 18 D/o filing Written Synopsis by the OP 21.11.2022 21.11.2022 21.11.2022

    6. Heard counsels of both sides.

    7. The contention of OP that this Commission lacks pecuniary jurisdiction is not valid. Under Section 21 of the Act, Commission has the jurisdiction where value of goods and services and compensation, if any, claimed exceeds Rs. one crore. The objection that the Complaint is barred by limitation is also not accepted. The OP failed to deliver the possession of the unit to the complainant as per committed date, therefore, the cause of action is continuing. The contention that complainant is not a consumer as he has already taken possession, is also rejected. The plea of OP that delay was due to delay in getting approvals of authorities, is not valid. The contention of the OP that the parties are bound by the agreement is also not acceptable. Hon'ble Supreme Court in Pioneer Urban Land & Infrastructure Ltd. v. Govindan Raglivan (2019) 2 CPJ 34 (SC) decided on 02.04.2019 held that “a term of a contract will not be final and binding if it is shown that the flat purchasers had no option to sign on the dotted line, on a contract framed by the builder ……… the incorporation of one sided clause in an agreement constitute an unfair trade practice as per Section 2 (r) of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 since it adopts unfair methods or practices for the purpose of selling flats by the builder ………, the appellant-builder cannot seek to bind the respondent with such one sided contractual terms.” Hon'ble Supreme Court in Wg. Cdr. Arifur Rahman Khan And Aleya Sultana v. DLF Southern Homes Pvt. Ltd. (2020) 16 SCC 512 and in Ireo Grace Realtech Pvt. Ltd. v. Abhishek Khanna (2021) 3 SCC 241, held that failure of the developer to comply with contractual obligations to provide flats within contractually stipulated period would amount to deficiency in service and thus amenable to the jurisdiction of consumer fora. Further the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Wg. Cdr. Arifur Rahman Khan case (supra) also observed that “to uphold the contention of the developer that the flat buyer is constrained by the terms of the agreed rate irrespective of the nature or extent of delay, would result in miscarriage of justice jurisdiction of the consumer forums to award just and fair compensation as an incident of its power to direct the removal of deficiency in service is not constrained by terms of a rate which is prescribed in an unfair bargain there is no absolute embargo on the award of compensation beyond the rate stipulated in the flat buyers agreement where handing over of the possession of a flat has been delayed”. In this case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court also held that execution of conveyance deed would not operate to preclude the flat buyers from claiming compensation. In R.V. Prasannakumaar v. Mantri Castles Pvt. Ltd. Civil Appeal Nos. 1232, 1443-1444 of 2019, decided on 08.06.2018, it was held that “the liability of the developer to pay interest @6% p.a. shall continue to operate until the date on which each of the respective flat purchaser is offered possession”. In DLF Homes Panchkula Pvt. Ltd. v. D.S. Dhanda (2020) 16 SCC 318, Hon'ble Supreme Court examined the legality and justifiability of grant of compensation under different heads for delay over possession of flats and held that the award of compensation under different heads is not sustainable.

    8. It is admitted by the OP that as per IFBA the committed date of possession was 28.02.2015 (30 months from the date of application), O.C. was obtained on 17.02.2016, offer of possession was made on 28.09.2016 and physical possession was taken on 17.05.2018. OP admits a delay of 1 year 7 months in offer of possession and states that an amount of Rs. 3,88,683/- has been credited by way of delay compensation and also an early payment rebate of Rs. 14237/- was granted by the OP. OP further contended that any compensation, if payable to complainant, should be interest @6% from 28.02.2015 till 28.09.2016 and nothing beyond that. Relying on judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in DLF Home Developers Ltd. v. Dr. Shipra Trapathi - Civil Appeal No. 1742 of 2022 dated 30.09.2022, the OP contended that liability to pay compensation would continue only so long as no offer of possession was made, in the instant case, valid offer of possession was made after receipt of O.C., thus liability to pay compensation by the developer has to be restricted till offer of possession.

    9. Complainant on the other hand argued that OP while allegedly handing over possession had asked complainant to make payments which were arbitrary and illegal and not borne out of the agreement, for instance, the payment towards ‘other charges’, which is vague as complainants were already paying payments including all taxes, contingent deposit of VAT, payment for parking space, club charges etc. Complainants contend that at the time of alleged handing over possession, OP had not received completion certificate from Govt.

    10. Perusal of offer of possession letter dated 28.09.2016 shows that OP has given the details of amount demanded under various heads, stating also that they have received the OC and that there is an increase of 19 sq. ft. of area. Complainants have not been able to establish as to which payments have been wrongly demanded/taken by the OP. Further, the complainants have not been able to clearly pinpoint as to which of the promised amenities/facilities have not been provided by the OP. Complainants have also not been able to establish whether the delay between the period of offer of possession i.e. 28.09.2016 and date of actual possession i.e. 17.05.2018 is attributable to OP. Hence, possession having been already taken by the complainants, the only relief which complainants are entitled to is delay compensation from the committed date of possession till the date of offer of possession. In CC/791/2017, the OP has stated that physical possession was taken by the complainants on 17.05.2018, but in CC/792/2017 and 814/2017, both the parties are silent on whether the physical possession has been taken by the complainants or not, if yes, on which dates. Hence, if in any of these cases, the physical possession has not been given by the OP yet, the same shall be given, complete in all respects, as per specifications and along with facilities/amenities promised in the brochure/agreement, within 30 days of this order.

    11. For the reasons stated hereinabove, and after giving a thoughtful consideration to the entire facts and circumstances of the case, various pleas raised by the learned Counsel for the Parties, the Consumer Complaint is allowed/disposed off with the following directions/reliefs:—

    CONSUMER COMPLAINT NO. 791 OF 2017

    i. The OP shall pay delay compensation in the form of simple interest @ 6% per annum on the deposit of the complainants from the committed date of possession viz 28.02.2015 till the date of offer of possession viz 28.09.2016.

    ii. The OP shall pay a sum of Rs. 25,000/- as cost of litigation to the complainants.

    (iii) The payment in terms of this order shall be paid within two months from today.

    CONSUMER COMPLAINT NO. 792 OF 2017

    i. The OP shall pay delay compensation in the form of simple interest @ 6% per annum on the deposit of the complainants from the committed date of possession viz 18.02.2015 till the date of offer of possession viz 28.09.2016.

    ii. The OP shall pay a sum of Rs. 25,000/- as cost of litigation to the complainants.

    (iii) The payment in terms of this order shall be paid within two months from today.

    CONSUMER COMPLAINT NO. 814 OF 2017

    i. The OP shall pay delay compensation in the form of simple interest @ 6% per annum on the deposit of the complainant from the committed date of possession viz 16.02.2015 till the date of offer of possession viz 28.09.2016.

    ii. The OP shall pay a sum of Rs. 25,000/- as cost of litigation to the complainant.

    iii. The payment in terms of this order shall be paid within two months from today.

    12. In case, in any of the cases, physical possession has not been handed over yet, the OP shall hand over the physical possession of the unit(s), as per specifications and with facilities/amenities promised in the brochure/agreement, within 30 days of this order.

    13. The pending IAs, if any, also stand disposed off.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    ANIL SEHGAL & ANR. v. DLF UNIVERSAL LTD. (PREVIOUSLY KNOWN AS DLF INDIA LTD.)
    (Jan 16, 2023)