AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • SECTION 6 LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 142 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (in short, "the MRTP Act").
  • Section 19 of the "2013 Act". 4 (2015)11 SCC 554 5 WP (ST) No.1497 of 2020 10
  • section 6 of the 1894 Act/section 19 of 2013 Act.
  • 2013 Act though, the provisions of Sections 125 and 126 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 19 of the 2013 Act
  • subsection 4 of section 126 of the said Maharashtra Act read with subsection (1) of section 19 of the 2013 Act
  • section 6 declaration/section 19
  • sub-section (4) of section 126 of the MRTP Act read with sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land 5 Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short, "the 2013 Act")
  • Section 127 of the M.R.T.P. Act
  • sub- section (3) of section 126 of the MRTP Act. Unless and until section 6 declaration/section 19
  • section 126(1) (c) read with section 127
  • sub-section 4 of Section 126 read with sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the 2013 Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • SECTION 6 LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • ARTICLE 142 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • LAND ACQUISITION ACT
  • Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (in short, "the MRTP Act").
  • Section 19 of the "2013 Act". 4 (2015)11 SCC 554 5 WP (ST) No.1497 of 2020 10
  • section 6 of the 1894 Act/section 19 of 2013 Act.
  • 2013 Act though, the provisions of Sections 125 and 126 of the MRTP Act
  • Section 19 of the 2013 Act
  • subsection 4 of section 126 of the said Maharashtra Act read with subsection (1) of section 19 of the 2013 Act
  • section 6 declaration/section 19
  • sub-section (4) of section 126 of the MRTP Act read with sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land 5 Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short, "the 2013 Act")
  • Section 127 of the M.R.T.P. Act
  • sub- section (3) of section 126 of the MRTP Act. Unless and until section 6 declaration/section 19
  • section 126(1) (c) read with section 127
  • sub-section 4 of Section 126 read with sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the 2013 Act
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Writ Petition No.2450 of 2016 (Bombay High Court)

Factual and Procedural Background

(Facts and procedural history stated exactly as in the provided opinion.)

The petitioners are the heirs and owners of land described as Final Plot No.646, T.P.S. No. III, Bandra, corresponding to CTS Nos. F/189, F/190, F/191 and F/192, admeasuring 900 sq. yards (752.49 sq. metres) along with structures. The Development Plan (DP) for the area was sanctioned on 7 May 1992 and the said property was reserved for a Municipal Primary School.

The reservation was not acted upon by the respondents for a period of ten years (from 7 May 1992 to 6 May 2002). The petitioners served a purchase notice under Section 126 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 ("MRTP Act") on 22 August 2007, calling upon respondent No.1 to acquire the property within six months (the statutory period ending 21 February 2008). The petitioners allege that no steps required by Section 127 were taken by the authority within that six-month period, and therefore the reservation lapsed on 22 February 2008.

The petitioners initially filed the writ petition on 30 July 2014 seeking a declaration that the property stood released from reservation with effect from 22 February 2008. Subsequently, respondent Nos.4 and 5 issued a notification dated 27 July 2018 under subsection (4) of Section 126 of the MRTP Act read with subsection (1) of Section 19 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 ("2013 Act") declaring the land needed for a Municipal Primary School; DP 2034 (sanctioned on 1 September 2018) also showed the property as reserved. The petitioners amended the writ petition on 5 January 2019 to challenge that 27 July 2018 notification.

Procedurally, the matter was heard by a Division Bench (Kamal Khata and R.D. Dhanuka, JJ.). The rule was made absolute and the Writ Petition was allowed in specified terms. An application for stay of the order was rejected.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the reservation of the petitioners' land under the Development Plan sanctioned on 7 May 1992 had lapsed by operation of law on 22 February 2008, on account of the respondents' failure to take the steps required under Section 127 of the MRTP Act within six months of service of the purchase notice dated 22 August 2007.
  2. Whether subsequent actions taken by respondents (including committee resolutions in February 2008, application to the Collector on 13 February 2008, payments, joint measurements and later notification dated 27 July 2018 under the 2013 Act) constituted the "steps" required by Section 127 to prevent the lapse of reservation.
  3. Whether, once a reservation has lapsed by operation of law under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, the land can be re-reserved subsequently (for example by modification or by a new Development Plan or by notifications under the 2013 Act).
  4. Whether the petitioners' letter dated 25 March 2013 withdrawing the purchase notice (and the petitioners' later letter of 11 June 2014 cancelling that withdrawal) had any effect on the legal consequence of the reservation having lapsed on 22 February 2008.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners asserted that because the respondents failed to take the requisite steps under Section 127 of the MRTP Act within six months of the purchase notice (22 August 2007), the purchase notice became absolute on 22 February 2008 and the reservation lapsed by operation of law.
  • The petitioners contended that subsequent acts by respondents (including actions after 22 February 2008) cannot cure the lapse and that there is no provision in the MRTP Act by which land de-reserved by operation of law can be again reserved.
  • The petitioners argued that their letter dated 25 March 2013 withdrawing the purchase notice could not revive or prevent the legal effect of the reservation having already lapsed, and that their later cancellation of that withdrawal (11 June 2014) does not alter the legal effect of the lapse.
  • The petitioners relied on a line of authorities (including Girnar Traders and Shrirampur Municipal Council) to argue that steps toward acquisition mean publication of a declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act (or Section 19 of the 2013 Act) and that procedural steps short of that do not prevent lapse.
  • The petitioners claimed violation of Articles 14 and 300A if the respondents were allowed to re-impose reservation after it had lapsed by operation of law.

Respondents' Arguments (MCGM and State)

  • The respondents contended the petition involved disputed questions of fact not suitable for adjudication under Article 226 and argued for dismissal on that ground.
  • The Municipal Corporation (MCGM) argued that it took a number of actions (improvement committee resolution ICR No.157 dated 14 February 2008; Corporation resolution CR No.1277 dated 15 February 2008; application to the Collector dated 13 February 2008; payment for joint measurement on 24 March 2011; deposit of 50% of acquisition cost in February 2012; subsequent compliance and resubmission steps) which, they submitted, showed that they had taken requisite steps toward acquisition within the statutory period or were actively pursuing acquisition.
  • The respondents asserted that delays when they existed were attributable to the Collector (MSD) or SLAO and that the Corporation had complied with procedural formalities required to acquire the land.
  • The respondents argued that even if reservation had lapsed, acquisition could still be initiated afresh under the 2013 Act (though Sections 125 and 126 of MRTP Act may not be available) and relied on an unreported precedent to that effect.
  • The respondents also sought to rely on unreported decisions and decisions addressing delay/laches to urge that the writ should be declined or that the petitioners had delayed in prosecuting rights.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Girnar Traders v. State of Maharashtra (2007) 7 SCC 555 Held that an application under Section 126(1)(c) can be a step for acquisition only if moved within statutory time; acquisition under the MRTP Act commences with the declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act. The Court held itself bound by Girnar Traders and applied its principle to conclude steps required under Section 127 were not taken within six months; therefore reservation lapsed.
Shrirampur Municipal Council v. Satyabhamabai Bhimaji Dawkher (as cited) Reiterated that steps towards acquisition commence when State Government takes active steps culminating in publication of declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act. The Court relied on this authority to reject respondents' contention that resolutions and communications to the Collector sufficed to prevent lapse.
Bhavnagar University v. Palitana Sugar Mills Pvt. Ltd. (2003) 2 SCC 111 Principle that rights (private or public) cannot be taken away or hampered by implication; statutory authority required to act in the manner prescribed if consequences are to follow. Cited in support of petitioners' argument that statutory requirements must be followed expressly and cannot be circumvented by implication.
Godrej & Boyce Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (2015) 11 SCC 554 Held it is not open to the State to modify the Development Plan to impose a fresh reservation after the original reservation has lapsed following expiry of the statutory period and six months notice. Applied to hold that respondents could not re-reserve the land in the new Development Plan and that the 27 July 2018 notification was impermissible as to the lapsed plot.
Ramakant Vasudeo Pai v. State of Maharashtra (W.P. (ST) No.1497 of 2020, Division Bench) Held that steps towards acquisition commence when the State Government permits acquisition and publishes declaration under Section 6 (1894 Act) / Section 19 (2013 Act). The Court followed this Division Bench decision to conclude that none of the Municipal Corporation's measures in this case amounted to commencement of acquisition as contemplated by statute.
Anil Dattatraya Girme & Ors. v. State of Maharashtra (2020) 3 Bom CR 353 Held that reservation lands in a revised DP were declared inoperative where acquisition was not completed within the statutory period and the land automatically stood released from reservation. The Court applied the principle that release follows lapse and that planning authorities are obliged to recognise such lapse.
Atul Vamanrao Joshi & Anr. v. State of Maharashtra (Order dated 13 Oct 2021, Writ Petition No.6297 of 2019) Holds that once reservation has lapsed under Section 127, consequential effects under the scheme of Section 127 must follow and land becomes available to owner for development. Cited to support the proposition that subsequent re-reservation by planning authority is unsustainable.
Bombay Salesian Society (Fr. Manuel Murzullo) v. State of Maharashtra (2020) 1 Bom CR 235 Held that there is no prescribed format of the notice in Section 127 and the owner is not required to call upon the authority to take steps within the stipulated period; if no steps are taken, reservation lapses. Applied to support petitioners' contention and the conclusion that the reservation lapsed and could not be revived by subsequent acts of the planning authority.
Suraiya Akbarali Jetha & Ors. v. MCGM & Ors. (2008 OnLine Bom 532) Held that if no steps are taken within prescribed time to acquire land, reservation shall be deemed to have lapsed and land becomes available to owner for development; reservation cannot be re-imposed in revised DP. The Court relied on and applied this reasoning to hold the MCGM could not re-reserve the petitioners' plot in DP 2034.
Satish Prakash Rohra & Anr. v. Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Ors. (W.P. No.2093 of 2015, unreported) Contains paragraph stating that notwithstanding lapsing of reservation, respondents can acquire land afresh under the new Land Acquisition Act though MRTP provisions may not be available. The Court considered this unreported decision and observed it supports petitioners' position that a subsequent acquisition under new law does not validate prior lapsing; the Court held it assists petitioners rather than respondents.
Apurva Natvar Parikh & Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra (Writ Petition No.203 of 2014, unreported) Held that gross and unexplained delay can be a ground for declining exercise of writ jurisdiction; factual inquiry required to determine delay/laches. The Court distinguished the case on facts and held that the principle did not assist the respondents; the Court found the petitioners had not suffered from delay/laches in a manner that would defeat their claim.
Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhkar (Civil Appeal No.11258 of 2017, referred) Decision of the Supreme Court referenced in the context of other authorities and in discussion of unreported matters and Article 142 directions. The Court noted that some directions in that Supreme Court judgment were in exercise of Article 142 and that such directions are not precedential in the ordinary sense; it treated related Division Bench decisions as applicable to facts here.
Baburao Dhondiba Salokhe v. Kolhapur Municipal Corporation (2003 3 Mh LJ 820) Referred in a quoted passage showing principle that subsequent reservations imposed after lapsing are of no consequence. Referenced in quoted material relied upon to support conclusion that subsequent reservations cannot take away benefit of lapsing.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court conducted a step-by-step legal analysis grounded in the statutory text of the MRTP Act and existing precedents:

  1. Timeline and statutory triggers: The Development Plan containing the reservation was sanctioned on 7 May 1992; the ten-year period expired on 7 May 2002. A purchase notice under Section 126 was served on 22 August 2007 and the six-month statutory window under Section 127 ended on 21 February 2008. The Court treated 22 February 2008 as the date the purchase notice became absolute if no steps required by law had been taken.
  2. Effect of petitioners' later correspondence: The Court held that the petitioners' letter dated 25 March 2013 withdrawing the purchase notice (and their subsequent cancellation of that withdrawal on 11 June 2014) could not affect the legal consequence of lapsing, because Section 127 contemplates "steps" to be taken by the Authority alone.
  3. What constitutes "steps" under the statutory scheme: Relying on Girnar Traders and related authorities, the Court explained that the commencement of acquisition proceedings, for the purposes of preventing lapse, requires publication of the declaration under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act (or the equivalent Section 19 declaration under the 2013 Act). The Court repeatedly emphasized that internal resolutions, applications to the Collector, payments for measurement, joint measurement exercises and other preparatory acts do not amount to the statutory "steps" contemplated by Sections 126/127.
  4. Application of precedent: The Court considered several Supreme Court and Division Bench authorities (Girnar Traders, Shrirampur Municipal Council, Godrej & Boyce, Ramakant Vasudeo Pai, and several Bombay High Court decisions) and found them binding or highly persuasive. The common thread taken from those authorities was that only State action culminating in the relevant statutory declaration constitutes initiation of acquisition for the purpose of preventing lapse.
  5. On re-reservation and notification of 27 July 2018: Having concluded that reservation lapsed on 22 February 2008, the Court held that respondent Nos.4 and 5 could not validly issue the notification dated 27 July 2018 to re-impose the reservation or that the Planning Authority could re-reserve the plot in DP 2034. Such subsequent reservation was declared unsustainable in law.
  6. Delay / laches arguments: The Court examined respondents' reliance on delay and laches and unreported authorities; it distinguished cases where petitioners had surrendered rights or failed to claim entitlements, and found the delay argument did not assist respondents on the facts of this case.

Holding and Implications

Core Holding: The Writ Petition was allowed. The Court held that the reservation of the petitioners' land had lapsed by operation of law on 22 February 2008 because the requisite steps under Section 127 of the MRTP Act were not taken within six months of the purchase notice of 22 August 2007. Subsequent actions by the respondents and the notification dated 27 July 2018 could not revive or re-impose the reservation.

Direct Implications and Orders:

  • The Writ Petition was allowed in terms of the petitioners' prayer clauses (a) to (c) and (c)(i) & (c)(ii) (as stated in the judgment).
  • The State Government was directed to notify the lapsing of the reservation by an order to be published in the Official Gazette as required by Section 127(2) of the MRTP Act; this was to be done expeditiously and preferably within six months from the date of the judgment.
  • If the petitioners submit fresh plans for building permission after the Gazette notification, those plans were to be considered expeditiously.
  • Rule was made absolute and there was no order as to costs.
  • The parties were directed to act on an authenticated copy of the judgment.
  • An application for stay of the operation of the order was expressly rejected.

Broader Legal Consequence Noted by the Court: The Court applied and followed existing Supreme Court and Division Bench precedents to conclude that once a reservation has lapsed under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, the benefit of that lapse cannot be taken away by subsequent reservations or administrative steps that do not meet the statutory requirements. The judgment does not purport to create novel law but applies and reiterates the principles established in the cited authorities.

Orders signed: Kamal Khata, J. and R.D. Dhanuka, J. — Reserved 25 July 2022; Pronounced 16 September 2022.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    TRILOK SINGH PAHLAJSINGH RAJPAL AND 1 ANR. v. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION FOR GREATER MUMBAI AND 4 ORS.

    1/29 00 WP-2450.16 (OS) (J)(1).odt

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY

    ORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION

    WRIT PETITION NO.2450 OF 2016

    1. Trilok Singh Pahlajsingh Rajpal, ] adult, Indian Inhabitant, residing at ] 101, Jesal Apartments, Tagore ] Road, Santacruz (West), Mumbai. ]

    2. Hardevi Pahlajsingh Rajpal, adult, ] Indian Inhabitant, residing at 101, ] Jesal Apartments, Tagore Road, ] Santacruz (West), Mumbai. ] ... Petitioners

    Versus

    1. Municipal Corporation for Greater ] Mumbai, a statutory body ]

    constituted under the Mumbai ] Municipal Corporation Act, 1888, ] having its office at Mahapalika ] Marg, Mumbai - 400 001. ]

    2. The Municipal Commissioner, ] Municipal Corporation of Greater ] Mumbai, having his office at ] Municipal Corporation Building, ] Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai - 400 ]

    001. ]

    3. The Chief Engineer (D.P.), ] Municipal Corporation of Greater ] Mumbai, having his office at ] Municipal Corporation Building, ] Mahapalika Marg, Mumbai - 400 ]

    001. ]

    1

    4. The Special Land Acquisition ] Officer, Mumbai and Mumbai ] Suburban District, Old Custom ] House, D.B. Building, 1stFloor, ] S.B. Marg, Fort, Mumbai. ]

    5. State of Maharashtra, through the ] Government Pleader, High Court, ] Bombay. ] … Respondents

    …

    Mr. Bhushan Deshmukh with Mr. Sahil Gandhi, Ms. Dimple Vora i/b M/s. Markand Gandhi & Co. for the petitioners. Mr. Joquim Reis, senior advocate with Ms. Vandana Mahadik, Ms. Sheetal Metakari i/b Mr. Sunil Sonawane for the respondents-MCGM.

    Mr. Laxmikant Satelkar, A.G.P. for respondent Nos.4 and 5- State.

    …

    CORAM : R.D. DHANUKA &

    KAMAL KHATA, JJ.

    RESERVED ON : 25TH JULY, 2022.

    PRONOUNCED ON : 16TH SEPTEMBER, 2022.

    JUDGMENT: - [Per Kamal Khata, J.]

    1. Rule. Learned counsel for the respondents waives service. Rule is made returnable forthwith.

    2. The petitioners in this Writ Petition filed under Article 226

    2

    of the Constitution of India have prayed for a writ of mandamus declaring that with effect from 22ndFebruary 2008 the land bearing CTS No. F/189, F/190, F/191, F/192 corresponding to Final Plot No.646, T.P.S. No.III, Bandra, Mumbai admeasuring 900 sq. yards equivalent to 752.49 sq. meters along with structures standing thereon (hereinafter referred to as "the said property") is released from reservation made under the Development Plan sanctioned on 7thMay 1992.

    3. The petitioners have also prayed for a writ of mandamus for an order and direction to respondent Nos.1 to 3 and 5 to take all necessary steps to amend the necessary records including Development Plan sanctioned on 7thMay 1992 and quashing the acquisition proceedings commenced before respondent No.4 pursuant to the Application dated 13thFebruary 2008 in respect of the said land.

    4. The petitioners are the owners of the piece and parcel of land bearing final plot no. 646, TPS III Bandra viz. the said land. It is the case of the petitioners that the requisition has lapsed as the respondents have failed to take steps to acquire the said land under Section 127 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town Planning Act, 1966 (in short, "the MRTP Act").

    5. The factual aspects stated in the Writ Petition are as under:-

    3

    (a) By a Deed of conveyance dated 17 July 1978, registered with the sub registrar of assurances under No. 1348 of 1978 made and executed between one Devraj Ranka and others (Vendors) and Pahlajsing Tulsidas Rajpal (Purchasers), the vendors sold all that piece and parcel of land bearing CTS No. F/ 189, F/190, F/191, F/192 corresponding to final plot No. 646, TPS III, Bandra admeasuring about 900 sq. yards equivalent to

    752.49 sq. metres along with structures standing thereon. The name of Pahlajsingh Tulsidas Rajpal was duly mutated on the property card, the town planning records in respect of the said property maintained by respondent no.1. The said property is occupied by tenants/occupants.

    (b) On 25th December 1998 Shri Pahlajsingh Rajpal expired leaving the petitioners herein as the only heirs and legal representatives. The petitioners are thus the owners of the said property and their names are duly mutated in the property register card as the owners thereof.

    (c) The draft Development Plan was prepared by respondent no. 1 for the entire Greater Mumbai under the provisions of the MRTP Act and in respect of the said property was finally sanctioned by respondent no.5 and brought into force on 7th May 1992. The said property was reserved for a Municipal Primary School as a part of a larger reservation.

    4

    (d) Since the respondents failed to acquire the property within 10 years i.e. from 6thMay 1992 to 6thMay 2002, the petitioners served a purchase notice on 22nd August 2007 calling upon the respondent no.1 to acquire the property within a period of 6 months thereof in accordance with the prevailing law.

    (e) The respondent no.1 failed to take any steps to acquire the said property within 6 months i.e. 22nd August 2007 to 21st February 2008.

    (f) The petitioners issued a letter dated 25th March 2013 to respondent no.1 to withdraw the purchase notice. Thereafter on 11th June 2014 addressed a letter to respondent no.1 to treat the letter dated 25th March 2013 as cancelled.

    (g) On 30th July 2014 the petitioners filed this writ petition seeking a declaration that with effect from 22nd February 2008 the said property along with the structures standing thereon stand released from reservation made under the Development Plan sanctioned on 7th May 1992.

    6. After filing of the petition, the respondent nos. 4 & 5 issued a notification dated 27thJuly 2018 in the official Gazette dated 2nd- 8thAugust 2018 under sub-section (4) of section 126 of the MRTP Act read with sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land

    5

    Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (for short, "the 2013 Act") declaring that the said land is needed for Municipal Primary School and the compensation would be awarded against the acquisition of the said land under the 2013 Act. The new Development Plan (DP 2034) was sanctioned on 1st September 2018 showing the said property reserved for Municipal Primary School. In view of the said notification the petitioners amended the present writ petition on 5thJanuary 2019 to challenge the said notification dated 27thJuly

    2018.

    7. The learned counsel submitted that no steps were taken even during the 6 months after the purchase notice i.e., 22nd August 2007 to 21stFebruary 2008. It is submitted that, although the purchase notice was issued on 22ndAugust 2007 and was received by the planning authority on the same date i.e., on 22nd August 2007 itself, the respondents failed to take the required steps under section 127 of the MRTP Act, within a period of 6 months, which expired on 21stFebruary 2008 and consequently on 22ndFebruary 2008, the purchase notice became absolute and the reservation on the subject land lapsed. In view of the reservation having lapsed by operation of law, the said land deserves to be released and returned to the petitioners.

    8. The learned counsel drew our attention to the Notification dated 27thJuly 2018 published in the Official Gazette dated 2nd -

    6

    8thAugust 2018, issued under sub-section 4 of Section 126 read with sub-section (1) of Section 19 of the 2013 Act and submitted that the petitioners have accordingly challenged the notification dated 27thJuly 2018 on the ground that the respondents have taken the purported steps for acquisition only after a period of 10 years of lapsing that is contrary to the provisions of law and, therefore, to be declared as non-est and not binding upon the petitioners.

    9. The learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that there is no provision in the MRTP Act by which, land de-reserved by operation of law, can be again reserved. It is submitted that the letter dated 25th March 2013 addressed by the petitioners to the respondents recalling the purchase notice cannot be the basis of initiating re-reservation since the petitioners had by their letter dated 11th June 2014, cancelled their letter dated 25thMarch 2013 as it was addressed under misconception and a mistaken belief of law. It is submitted that, any subsequent act on the part of the petitioners including addressing a letter for cancellation of the purchase letter as was done by the petitioners, will not nullify or change the legal effect of lapsing of reservation, which ensued on 22nd February 2008.

    10. The learned counsel submitted that all actions taken by the respondents, ignoring the lapsing, are completely in violation of law and without authority and their subsequent conduct of

    7

    issuing a notification would deprive the petitioners of their rightful enjoyment of the property, which they are entitled under Articles 14 and 300A of the Constitution of India.

    11. The learned counsel submitted that the writ property was reserved in the Development Plan sanctioned on 07thMay 1992, and 10 years lapsed on 07thMay 2002; the purchase notice was issued on 22ndAugust 2007 and the notification for acquisition was issued on 27thJuly 2018 consequently the petitioners were deprived of their property for more than 26 years. He submitted that the respondents ought to have taken steps as required under Section 127 of the Act, to acquire the said property within six months from the date of service of the purchase notice i.e. on or before 21st February 2008 and consequently the reservation of the said plot is deemed to have lapsed and the said plot is deemed to have been released from the reservation/designation and the said plot has become available to the petitioners for the purpose of development as permissible under law.

    12. The learned counsel referred to the judgement in the case of Girnar Traders versus State of Maharashtra1 and submitted that since no notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act was published as required under Section 127 of the MRTP Act within the said period no "steps" could be said to have been taken by the respondents and consequently, the

    8

    reservation in respect of the said property has lapsed as contemplated under Section 127 of the MRTP.

    13. The learned counsel referred to the judgement in the case of Shrirampur Municipal Council, Shrirampur versus Satyabhamabai Bhimaji Dawkher and others2 and more particularly paragraphs 33, 34, 41, 42 and 43 and submitted that this judgement followed Girnar Traders (supra). He further submitted that if the scheme of sections 126 and 127 as contemplated by Girnar Traders (supra) was not followed, the landowners will be deprived of the right to use the property for an indefinite period without being paid compensation and that would amount to depriving the citizens of the property without the sanction of law and would result in violation of Article 300-A of the Constitution.

    14. The learned counsel referred to the judgement in the case of Bhavnagar University versus Palitana Sugar Mills Private Limited and Others3and more particularly paragraphs 28, 34, 40, 41 and 42 and submitted that rights, whether private or public, cannot be taken away or hampered by implication from the language employed in the statute, unless the legislature clearly and distinctly authorises the doing of a thing which is physically inconsistent with the continuation of an existing right and when statutory authority is required to do a thing in a

    2 (2 013) 5 SCC 62 7

    3 (2003 ) 2 SCC 111

    9

    particular manner, the same must be done in that manner or not at all and when consequence for inaction on the part of the statutory authorities within such specified time is expressly provided, it must be held to be imperative.

    15. The learned counsel referred to the judgement in the case of Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Co. Ltd. versus State of Maharashtra and others4and submitted that it is not open for the State Government to issue the impugned notification proposing to modify the Development Plan from deleting for the purpose of the Railways and adding to the Development Plan for the formation of Development Plan of road after the lapse of 10 years and expiry of 6 months notice served upon the state government.

    16. The learned counsel then referred to the judgement in the case of Ramakant Vasudeo Pai versus State of Maharashtra and others5and submitted that this Court had considered all the relevant judgements of the Supreme Court as well as of this Court and held that the step towards acquisition as contemplated under Section 127 of the MRTP Act, means when the State Government permits the acquisition and as a result thereof publishes the declaration under Section 6 of the "1894 Act" and now under Section 19 of the "2013 Act".

    4 (2015)11 SCC 554

    5 WP (ST) No.1497 of 2020

    10

    17. The learned counsel then referred to the judgement in the case of Anil Dattatraya Girme and others versus State of Maharashtra and others6and submitted that this Court has held that the reservation lands in the 2ndrevised Development Plan impugned in the said petition was declared inoperative and inefficacious since the respondents therein had failed to acquire the land within the statutory period as contemplated under section 127 of the act and it automatically stood released from the reservation and obligation was cast upon the municipal Council to notify the same.

    18. The learned counsel then referred to the unreported case of

    Atul Vamanrao Joshi & Anr. versus State of Maharashtra and Ors.7and submitted that once reservation is lapsed in view of contingencies mentioned in Section 127 of the MRTP Act, the necessary consequence under the scheme of Section 127 of the MRTP Act must follow.

    19. The learned counsel then referred to the judgement of this Court in the case of Bombay Salesian Society, through Secretary, Fr. Manuel Murzullo versus State of Maharashtra & Ors8and submitted that that there is no prescribed format qua the content of the notice set out in Section 127 of the MRTP Act and the owner is not required to call upon the authority to take

    6 (2020) 3 Bom CR 353

    7 Order dated 13thOctober 2021 in Writ Petition No.6297 of 2019 filed in High Court of Bombay Nagpur Bench

    8 (2020) 1 Bom CR 235

    11

    steps to acquire the land within stipulated period.

    20. The learned counsel also relied upon the judgment of this Court in the case of Suriaya Akbarali Jetha & Ors. versus Mumbai Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Ors.9 and submitted that the respondents having failed to take steps to acquire the land in the stipulated period of time under the MRTP Act cannot justifiably raise a plea of delay and laches against the petitioners.

    21. The learned counsel brought to our notice the order passed by the Supreme Court in the case of Kukreja Constructions Company & Ors versus State of Maharashtra10and submitted that the Supreme Court was pleased to issue notice to the respondents and the same is pending hearing.

    22. Mr. Reis, learned senior counsel for the respondents submitted that the present writ petition involves various disputed questions of fact which cannot be gone into by this Court under Article 226 of Constitution of India and writ petition deserves to be dismissed on this ground alone. The learned counsel submits that the land under reference is reserved for Municipal Primary School and was proposed to acquire the adjoining plots bearing F.P. Nos. 644 and 645 which were also reserved to enable the corporation to develop the Municipal Primary School. He

    9 (2008) 5 Bom CR 127

    10 Order dated 18-12-2018 in W.P No. 1898/2009 passed by High Court of Judicature at Bombay

    12

    submitted that the improvement committee and the Corporation sanctioned the proposal vide the resolution ICR No.157 dated 14thFebruary 2008 and CR No.1277 dated 15thFebruary 2008 respectively and accordingly, an application to the collector was made with all the requisite documents dated 13thFebruary 2008 and the collector was requested to start the proceedings of acquisition proposal and to publish the notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act which was well within the period of six months from the date of the notice.

    23. The learned senior counsel further submitted that the Additional Collector, (MSD) vide its letter dated 1stApril 2019 informed the respondents herein that they had appointed SLAO 3 for acquisition proceeding of land under reference. He submitted that on receipt of the challan received from the City Survey Officer, an amount of Rs.21,000/- was paid on 24thMarch 2011 by the respondents for carrying out joint measurement. The joint measurement was carried out on 23rdMay 2011.

    24. Learned senior counsel submitted that the SLAO calculated the acquisition cost of Rs.11,07,37,200/- and requested the respondent Nos.1 to 3 herein to deposit fifty percent of amount i.e., Rs.5,53,68,600/- vide the letter dated 15th June 2011. He submitted that the report was submitted to the Municipal Corporation under No. CHE/4505/ACQ/WS/H&K dated 9thAugust 2011. He submitted that the land cost was

    13

    considered at 40% on account of their being encumbrances on the plot and accordingly 50% of the deposit amount was worked out at Rs.2,21,47,440/-.

    25. Learned senior counsel submitted that on 18thFebruary 2012 an amount of Rs.2,21,47,440/- was deposited after having obtained a sanction from the Municipal Commissioner under MCP/7167 dated 25thAugust 2011 and the SLAO 3 was requested to publish a notification under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act. The balance payment was made by the SLAO 3's office on 18thJuly 2013, amounting to Rs.3,32,21,160/- and the SLAO 3 was requested to publish notification under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act.

    26. Learned senior counsel submitted that, in spite of having requested the Collector, (MSD), on account of delay on the part of the Collector (MSD) and SLAO 3, the notification under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act was not published by the SLAO 3. He submitted that his clients have complied with all the procedural formalities as per law for acquiring the land in question and there has been no delay on the part of the respondents in any manner whatsoever.

    27. Learned senior counsel submitted that the Dy. Collector (L.A.-4) vide letter dated 23rdFebruary 2015 had forwarded the copy of the order issued by the Collector (M.S.D) dated 16th

    14

    February 2015 thereby seeking to return the acquisition proposals to the acquiring body, where notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 has not been issued and to inform the MCGM to submit fresh proposals for acquisition as per the provisions of the 2013 Act. The Collector vide letter dated 7thDecember 2015 informed the MCGM about the new procedure that was required to be followed for acquisition as per the 2013 Act.

    28. Learned senior counsel submitted that, vide letter dated 18thJuly 2017, the MCGM re-submitted the acquisition proposal to the office of the Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition 4, Bandra, as per their requisition. The learned counsel states that by the letter dated 17thNovember 2017, the Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition 4 raised certain points which were complied with by the respondent MCGM by letter number CHE23059/DP/ WS dated 28thNovember 2017. The learned senior counsel states that by letter dated 19thApril 2018, MCGM was directed to deposit the balance amount of Rs.8,59,70,602/- corresponding to the ready reckoner rate of 2017 i.e. Rs.1,89,900/- per square meter.

    29. Learned senior counsel submitted that on 9thMay 2018, the MCGM informed the Deputy Collector, Land Acquisition 4 to

    15

    process the subject proposal. Further, as the respondent, MCGM had already made payment of Rs.5,53,68,600/- in the year 2013, the joint measurement of the plot was done on 24thMay 2018 by the City Survey Office, Bandra. This was recorded in the letter dated 9thMay 2018.

    30. The learned counsel submitted that the petitioner's land under acquisition for which a purchase notice was served was shown as a part to the larger reservation namely Municipal Primary School in SRDP 1991 and is also shown as Municipal School under RE 1.1 in the revised Development Plan 2034. The learned counsel further submitted that the reservation of municipal school is continued by the planning committee appointed by the State Government and the Urban Development Department of the State Government, and the said reservation is unchanged while sanctioning the Draft Development Plan of 2034 which came into force from 1stSeptember 2018.

    31. Learned senior counsel further submitted that in addition to the land under acquisition i.e., FP No.646 of TPS 3 Bandra, MCGM has also initiated the acquisition proceedings for the entire land under the reservation of Municipal Primary School which include the adjacent plots bearing numbers FP No.644 and 645 to develop the same as per the reservation. He submitted that on 27thJuly 2018, the collector (MST) has issued the notification declaring the land bearing final plot number 644,

    16

    645 and 646 of TPS 3, Bandra corresponding to CTS numbers, F/197, F/196 and F/192 of village Bandra as required for the public purpose of Municipal Primary School. The learned counsel submitted that the said notification is published in Maharashtra State Gazette Part 1 Konkan division on 2nd August 2018 to 8thAugust 2018 and also published in local Marathi newspapers on 4thAugust 2018.

    32. Learned senior counsel submitted that they had issued a notification on 27thJuly 2018 under Section 19 of the 2013 Act and is willing to acquire this said reserved land under reference by following the due process of law and thus the writ petition deserves to be dismissed.

    33. Learned senior counsel submitted that although the acquisition has lapsed, the respondents could always acquire the land by taking recourse under the 2013 Act though, the provisions of Sections 125 and 126 of the MRTP Act will not be available for such acquisition in view of lapsing of the reservation. In support of this submission, he relied upon an unreported case of Satish Prakash Rohra versus Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai and Ors. 11and more particularly paragraph 26 of the said judgement, which is as under:

    "Notwithstanding the lapsing of reservation, the respondents can always acquire the land subject matter of these two petitions

    11 Writ Petition No.2093 of 2015

    17

    by taking recourse to the new Land Acquisition Act, though the provisions of sections 125 and 126 of the MRTP Act will not be available for such acquisition in view of lapsing of the reservation…"

    34. Learned senior counsel relied on an unreported case of

    Apurva Natvar Parikh & Co. Private Limited versus State of Maharashtra & Ors.12and submitted that gross and unexplained delay is always a ground on which a Writ Court can decline to exercise its jurisdiction even if existence of a right is established by the petitioners. According to the learned senior counsel in the present case too there was a gross delay since the alleged lapsing was in the 2002 whilst the petition was filed in 2016 after a period of 14 years.

    REASONS AND CONCLUSIONS:

    35. We have heard the learned counsel and have considered their rival contentions. The counsel sought to tender additional judgements, which was permitted by us.

    36. The respondents failed to acquire the property for a period of 10 years i.e., from 7thMay 1992 to 6thMay 2002. The Purchase notice under Section 126 of the MRTP Act was served upon the respondents on 22ndAugust 2007. The statutory period of 6 months expired on 21st February 2008. In our view the letter dated 25thMarch 2013 issued by the petitioners withdrawing their purchase notice would have no effect on the

    12 Writ Petition No. 203 of 2014

    18

    lapsing of the reservation as Section 127 of the MRTP Act contemplates "steps" to be taken by the Authority alone.

    37. In our view, the sanctioning of proposal by the improvement committee and the corporation on 14thand 15th February 2008 or the application made to the collector with the documents on 13thFebruary 2008 to publish the notification under Section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act or the Additional Collector's letter on 1stApril 2019 appointing SLAO or amounts paid on 24thMarch 2011 for joint measurements or deposit of 50% of acquisition cost on 18thFebruary 2012 or steps taken before the issuance of notification on 27thJuly 2018 cannot be construed as "steps" taken as contemplated for acquisition of the property.

    38. The unreported case of Satish Prakash R ohra (supra)

    relied upon by the respondents supports the case of the petitioners and not the respondents. The respondents have invoked the powers delegated under subsection 4 of section 126 of the said Maharashtra Act read with subsection (1) of section 19 of the 2013 Act after lapsing of reservation. Paragraph 27 of the said judgement reads thus:

    "As regards subsequent reservations imposed by the notification dated 8th May 2018, the law is well settled. Once there is a lapsing of reservation imposed by the earlier Development Plan, the benefit of lapsing cannot be taken away

    19

    by imposing the subsequent reservations. The said principle has been laid down by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Baburao Dhondiba Salokhe V/s Kolhapur Municipal Corporation and another reported in 2003 3 Mh LJ 820. The Apex Court in the case of Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited V/s State of Maharashtra and others reported in (2015) 11 SCC 554 dealt with a case where after lapsing of reservation under section 127 of the MRTP Act, an attempt was made to impose a reservation by modification of the sanctioned Development Plan by taking recourse to section 37 of the MRTP Act. The Apex Court held that statutory right accrued to the owners cannot be taken away by making an attempt to impose a fresh reservation. Therefore, subsequent reservation imposed on 8th May 2018 is of no consequence."

    39. The reliance placed on the unreported case of Apurva Natvar Parikh & Co. Private Limited (supra) by respondent Nos.1 to 3 in support of their contention that the petitioners have approached the court after a huge delay and which would amount to the petitioners having abandoned their right is misplaced as the said case was not of lapsing but a case where the petitioners had surrendered their lands and never claimed TDR in respect of amenity developed by them till 17 thFebruary

    2012.

    40. Supreme Court in case of Girnar Traders (supra) has held that the application under section 126 (1) (c) could be said to be a step taken for acquisition of the land if such application is moved within the period of one year from the date of publication of regional plan

    20

    and not otherwise. The acquisition cannot be left for a time immemorial in the hands of the authority concerned. The commencement of the period of six-months is from the date the owner or any person interested in the land serves a notice on the planning authority, development authority or appropriate authority expressing his intent claiming de-reservation of the land. The acquisition under the MRTP Act commences with the publication of declaration under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 and not prior to that.

    41. In our view, various so called steps taken by the Municipal Corporation in this case were not the steps contemplated under the provisions of sections 126 and 127 of the MRTP Act and in accordance with the principles laid down by the Supreme Court in case of Girnar Traders (supra) . Admittedly in this case, the notification under section 6 was not issued within six months from the date of service of the purchase notice i.e. 22ndAugust, 2007. The principles laid down by the Supreme Court in case of Girnar Traders

    (supra) apply to the facts of this case. We are respectfully bound by the said judgment.

    42. The Supreme Court in case of Shrirampur Municipal Council, Shrirampur (supra) after adverting to its earlier judgment in case of Girnar Traders (supra) has reiterated that the steps towards acquisition can only be said to really commence when the State Government takes active steps for acquisition of the particular piece of land which leads to publication of declaration under section 6 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894.

    21

    43. In the said judgment, the Supreme Court held that the reservation of the land will be deemed to have lapsed on expiry of six months from the date of receipt of purchase notice as the steps contemplated under section 126(1) (c) read with section 127 were not taken before expiry of the said period. The Supreme Court held that the resolutions passed and communication sent to the District Collector by the authorities for commencement of acquisition proceedings were after service of purchase notice by orders of the reservation of land under section 127. Thus, it did not amount to requisite steps to prevent lapsing of reservation. The arguments advanced by the learned senior counsel for the Corporation in this case are similar to the arguments advanced by the Government before the Supreme Court in case of Shrirampur Municipal Council, Shrirampur (supra) and the same were rejected.

    44. In our view the arguments advanced by the learned senior counsel for the respondent Corporation are contrary to the principles laid down by the Supreme court in case of Girnar Traders (supra) and in case of Shrirampur Municipal Council, Shrirampur (supra) and are thus rejected.

    45. The Division Bench of this Court in case of Ramakant Vasudeo Pai (supra) after adverting to various judgments held that the steps towards acquisition would really commence when the State Government permits the acquisition and as a result thereof publishes the declaration under section 6 of the 1894 Act/section 19 of 2013 Act. It is section 6 declaration/section 19 declaration which would

    22

    commence the acquisition proceedings under the MRTP Act and would culminate into passing of an award as provided under sub- section (3) of section 126 of the MRTP Act. Unless and until section 6 declaration/section 19 declaration is issued, it cannot be said that the steps for acquisition have commenced. None of the steps taken by the Municipal Corporation in this case would amount to taking steps to prevent lapsing of reservation of the plot of the petitioners. The principles of law laid down by this Court in case of Ramakant Vasudeo Pai (supra) apply to the facts of this case. We are respectfully bound by the said judgment. We do not propose to take any different view in the matter.

    46. The Supreme Court in case of Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited (supra) held that the State Government had not commenced the proceedings to acquire the land by following the procedure as provided under sections 4 and 6 of the repealed Land Acquisition Act, 1894 after expiry of 10 years from the date of reservation made in the Development Plan. A six months prior notice had expired, the reservation stood lapsed and it enured to the benefit of the owner of the land. It is not open for the State Government to issue the impugned notification proposing to modify the Development Plan for deleting the purpose originally shown and by reserving it for another purpose. The principles laid down by the Supreme Court in case of Godrej and Boyce Manufacturing Company Limited (supra) apply to the facts of this case.

    23

    47. The Division Bench of this Court in case of Atul Vamanrao Joshi & Anr. (supra) after adverting to various judgments of Supreme Court and this Court held that once the reservation is lapsed in view of contingencies mentioned in Section 127 of the M.R.T.P. Act, the necessary consequences under the scheme of Section 127 of the M.R.T.P. Act must follow. The land which is released from the reservation becomes available to the owner for the purpose of development. The right which is conferred or accrued to the owner of the land due to lapsing of reservation cannot be taken away by the Planning Authority by exercising power under Section 38 of the MRTP Act. The principles laid down by this Court in case of Atul Vamanrao Joshi & Anr. (supra) applies to the facts of this case.

    48. The Division Bench of this Court in case of Anil Dattatraya Girme and others (supra) after adverting to various judgments has held that the land once de-reserved from the revised development plan by operation of law cannot be reserved again, in the second revised plan with some variation in purpose. The principles laid down by this Court in case of Anil Dattatraya Girme and others

    (supra) apply to the facts of this case. We are respectfully bound by the said principles. We do not propose to take different view in the matter.

    49. In our view, the respondents no. 4 and 5 thus could not have issued notification dated 27thJuly, 2018 under section 126(4) read with sub-section (1) of section 19 of the Act of 2013 declaring the said land needed for Municipal Primary School. No such steps could have been taken by the respondents no. 4 and 5 after

    24

    reservation of the said plot stood lapsed. The respondents cannot be allowed to reserve the plot again which stood de-reserved. In our view, the act of Planning Authority subjecting the land of the petitioners once again to reserve the said land under New Development Plan 2034 is unsustainable in law and thus the said reservation is declared as unreserved and unsustainable in law.

    50. The Division Bench of this the Court in case of Bombay Salesian Society (supra) has held that if no steps are taken within the time prescribed to acquire the land which is the subject matter of notice, the reservation, allotment or designation shall be deemed to have lapsed and the land should be deemed to be released from reservation, allotment or designation and shall become available to the owner for the purpose of development. This Court also held that the reservation having lapsed, the respondents again cannot reserve the said plot in the draft revised Development Plan. The respondents cannot be allowed to take advantage of its own wrong and blame the petitioner for the delay when in fact the delay lies squarely at the doors of the respondents. The principles laid down by this Court in the said judgment apply to the facts of this case. The Division Bench of this Court in case of Suraiya Akbarali Jetha & Ors. vs. Mumbai Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai & Ors., 2008 SCC OnLine Bom 532 has taken a similar view in the matter.

    51. Insofar as judgment delivered by the Division Bench of

    25

    this Court in case of Satish Prakash Rohra & Anr. (supra) relied upon by the learned senior counsel of the Municipal Corporation is concerned, a perusal of the said judgment indicates that the Division Bench in the said judgment distinguished the judgment delivered by the Supreme Court in case of Hiraman Sitaram Deorukhkar on 24thAugust, 2017 in Civil Appeal No. 11258 of 2017 which judgment of Supreme Court is relied upon by the learned senior counsel for the Municipal Corporation.

    52. This Court after adverting to the said judgment of Supreme Court held that the directions issued by the Supreme Court in the said judgment were in exercise of powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India. This Court has also held that once there is a lapsing of reservation imposed by the earlier Development Plan, the benefit of lapsing cannot be taken away by imposing the subsequent reservations. In our view, the judgment of this Court in case of Satish Prakash Rohra & Anr.

    (supra) relied upon by the learned senior counsel for the Municipal Corporation, would assist the case of the petitioners and not the respondents. The judgment of the Supreme Court exercising powers under Article 142 of the Constitution of India is not a precedent.

    53. Insofar as judgment of this Court delivered on 18th December, 2018 in case of Apurva Natvar Parikh & Co. Private Limited (supra) relied upon by the learned senior counsel for the

    26

    Municipal Corporation is concerned, this Court in the said judgment has held that gross and unexplained delay is always a ground on which a Writ Court can decline to exercise its jurisdiction even if existence of a right is established by the petitioner. This Court held that if the petitioners in such a case were to seek monetary compensation by filing a suit, it will be governed by the law of limitation.

    54. It is held that whether there is a gross delay or not depends on the facts and circumstances of each case and, therefore, each case will have to be examined on facts because there cannot be a straight-jacket formula for deciding whether the Court should exercise its discretion or not. After considering correspondence in that matter, this Court recorded the finding of fact that the petition did not suffer from delay and latches. In our view the said judgment would assist the case of the petitioners and not the respondents.

    55. In our view, there is no merit in any of the submissions made by the learned senior counsel for the Municipal Corporation. The submissions made by the learned senior counsel for the Municipal Corporation are contrary to the principles laid down by the Supreme Court and this Court in a catena of decisions referred to the aforesaid judgments which are binding on this Court.

    27

    56. We accordingly pass the following orders :-

    : ORDER :

    (a) The Writ Petition deserves to be allowed and is accordingly allowed in terms of prayer clauses (a) to (c) & (c)(i) & (c)(ii).

    (b) The State Government is directed to notify the lapsing of the reservation by an order to be published in the Official Gazette as per the requirement of Section 127(2) of the MRTP Act which shall be done as expeditiously as possible and preferably within a period of six months from today. Thereafter, if fresh plans for building permission are submitted by the petitioners, then the same be considered expeditiously.

    57. Rule is accordingly made absolute. No order as to costs.

    58. The parties to act on the authenticated copy of this judgment.

    [KAMAL KHATA, J.] [R. D. DHANUKA, J.]

    59. At this stage, Mr. Abhijit Joshi holding for Joquim Reis, learned senior counsel for respondent Nos.1 to 3,

    28

    seeks stay of operation of this order.

    60. Application for stay is rejected.

    [KAMAL KHATA, J.] [R. D. DHANUKA, J.]

    29

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    TRILOK SINGH PAHLAJSINGH RAJPAL AND 1 ANR. v. MUNICIPAL CORPORATION FOR GREATER MUMBAI AND 4 ORS.
    (Sep 16, 2022)