AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5 of the Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2012 reads as follows:5. Amendment of Section 5.- In Section 5 of the principal Act, for sub-section (1), the following sub-section
  • Regulation) Act, 1957, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988,
  • SECTION 5 PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT
  • Section 109 of I.P.C. r/w 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
  • schedule of the Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2009
  • Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1988.
  • u/s 13(2) r/w Sec.13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988,
  • Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2009, No.21 of 2009
  • PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT
  • section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974),
  • Section 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act.
  • SECTION 13 PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • sub-section (2) of section 8,
  • Section 482 of Cr.P.C
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5 of the Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2012 reads as follows:5. Amendment of Section 5.- In Section 5 of the principal Act, for sub-section (1), the following sub-section
  • Regulation) Act, 1957, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988,
  • SECTION 5 PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT
  • Section 109 of I.P.C. r/w 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988
  • schedule of the Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2009
  • Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1988.
  • u/s 13(2) r/w Sec.13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988,
  • Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2009, No.21 of 2009
  • PREVENTION OF MONEY LAUNDERING ACT
  • section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974),
  • Section 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act.
  • SECTION 13 PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT
  • sub-section (2) of section 8,
  • Section 482 of Cr.P.C
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitions arise from two related Criminal Original Petitions filed under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.P.C). The first petition (Crl.O.P.No.10497 of 2017) seeks to quash the Provisional Attachment Order No.09/2017 dated 07.04.2017 passed by the second respondent in ECIR/CEZO/08/2015, Chennai Zone. The second petition (Crl.O.P.No.10500 of 2017) seeks to quash the Original Complaint in O.C.No.855 of 2017 filed by the second respondent before the Adjudicating Authority under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 (PMLA).

The first petitioner was an Assistant Commissioner of Customs and Central Excise who resigned in 2011. An FIR was registered in 2005 against the first petitioner and others for alleged possession of assets and pecuniary resources under Section 13(2) read with 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. A charge sheet was filed in 2009 and trial is ongoing in the court of the XIV Additional Special Judge for CBI cases.

Subsequently, the second respondent registered an Enforcement Case Information Report (ECIR) and issued summons to the petitioners under the PMLA, alleging money laundering offences related to the same period (1997 to 2005) that predated the enforcement of the PMLA. The petitioners contended that the PMLA was not in force during the period of the alleged offences and that the relevant provisions of the Prevention of Corruption Act were only added to the scheduled offences under the PMLA in 2009. The provisional attachment order attached properties in the names of the petitioners, including minor petitioners 3 and 4, who were not accused in any charge sheet.

The petitioners challenged the attachment order and the complaint on grounds of invalid retrospective application of the PMLA and procedural impropriety.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Provisional Attachment Order passed under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, relating to offences allegedly committed before the Act came into force, is valid and sustainable in law.
  2. Whether the Original Complaint filed under the PMLA based on offences prior to the enactment of the Act and prior to the inclusion of the Prevention of Corruption Act in the scheduled offences list, is maintainable.
  3. Whether the attachment of properties belonging to minors who were not accused is legally permissible.
  4. Whether retrospective or retrospective application of penal provisions under the PMLA violates Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The alleged offences occurred between 1997 and 2005, before the PMLA came into force on 1.7.2005; hence, the Act cannot be applied retrospectively.
  • The Prevention of Corruption Act was included in the schedule of offences under the PMLA only from 1.6.2009, so no penal action under the PMLA can apply to offences prior to that date.
  • The provisional attachment order improperly included properties held by minors (3rd and 4th petitioners), who were not accused in any charge sheet.
  • All original documents and properties were seized and are in custody of the CBI Court, negating any reason to believe that the properties would be concealed or transferred.
  • The attachment order was passed without proper exercise of power or sufficient reasons recorded in writing.
  • Retrospective application of penal law violates Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The offence of money laundering is a continuing offence, and therefore the PMLA can be applied even if the principal offence predates the Act.
  • The Provisional Attachment Order and complaint are valid and maintainable, and the petitioners must appear before the Adjudicating Authority instead of the High Court for quashing the proceedings.
  • The PMLA can have retrospective effect with regard to continuing offences.
  • Relied upon several Supreme Court judgments to support their submissions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Solidaire India Ltd. vs. Fair Growth [AIR 2001 FC 958 : JT 2001(2) SC 642] General principles regarding legal proceedings cited by respondents in support of maintainability of petitions. The Court found these judgments not relevant to the issue of scheduled offences under PMLA and thus not helpful.
Bank of India vs. Ketan Parekh [2008 (8) SCC 148 : AIR 2008 SC 2361] Legal principles cited by respondents regarding procedural aspects. The Court did not find these applicable to the retrospective applicability of scheduled offences under PMLA.
Union of India vs. Hassan Ali Khan and another [C.A.No.1883 of 2011, Supreme Court] Referenced by respondents to support their contention of continuing offence and retrospective application. The Court held these judgments were not on point regarding scheduled offences under PMLA.
Gokak Patel Volkart Ltd. vs. Dundayya Gurushiddaiah Hiremath [1991 SCR (1) 396, 1991 SCC (2) 141] Procedural and substantive legal principles cited by respondents. Not found relevant by the Court to the issue of retrospective application of PMLA.
M/s Obulapuram Mining Company Pvt. Ltd. vs. Directorate of Enforcement (Karnataka High Court) Held that offences not included in the schedule of PMLA at the relevant time cannot be prosecuted under PMLA; retrospective application violates Article 20(1). Court relied on this judgment to hold that the Enforcement Case Information Report and attachment order were without jurisdiction and liable to be quashed.
Mahanivesh Oils & Foods Pvt. Ltd. v. Directorate of Enforcement (Delhi High Court) Clarified that power to attach property under PMLA arises only if the offence is a scheduled offence; the offence of money laundering is linked to a scheduled offence. Used by Court to emphasize that no proceeding can be sustained under PMLA if the scheduled offence is not established or included at the relevant time.
Arunkumar Mishra v. Directorate of Enforcement (Delhi High Court) Reiterated that Article 20(1) bars ex-post facto penal laws and retrospective prosecution under PMLA is impermissible. Supported the Court's conclusion that retrospective application of PMLA provisions violates constitutional protections.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the timeline of alleged offences and the enforcement of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, noting that the Act came into force on 1.7.2005, after the period of the alleged offences (1997 to 2005). Furthermore, Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, under which the offences were charged, was included in the schedule of offences under the PMLA only on 1.6.2009.

The Court observed that the PMLA is a penal statute and thus cannot have retrospective or retroactive operation without violating Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India, which protects against ex-post facto penal laws. The Court relied on authoritative judgments, including those of the Karnataka and Delhi High Courts, which held that offences not scheduled under the PMLA at the relevant time cannot be prosecuted under it.

The Court also noted that the provisional attachment order included properties of minors who were not accused, and that all original documents and properties were in the custody of the CBI Court, negating any reason to believe that the properties would be concealed or transferred. The attachment order was passed without sufficient reasons recorded in writing, as required under Section 5 of the PMLA.

The Court found that the respondents failed to properly consider these aspects and that the attachment order and complaint were not sustainable in law.

Holding and Implications

The Court quashed the Provisional Attachment Order No.09/2017 dated 07.04.2017 and the Original Complaint in O.C.No.855 of 2017 filed under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.

The direct consequence of this decision is that the attachment of properties, including those in the names of minors not accused in any charge sheet, is set aside, and the complaint proceedings under the PMLA are invalidated on grounds of retrospective application and lack of jurisdiction. The Court did not establish any new precedent beyond applying existing constitutional protections against retrospective penal legislation. The petitions are disposed of accordingly.

    Shri Ajay Kumar Gupta & Others v. Adjudicating Authority (Pmla), New Delhi & Others

    (Prayer in Crl.O.P.No.10497 of 2017 : Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C to call for the records in Provisional Attachment Order No.09/2017 dated 07.04.2017 in ECIR/CEZO/08/2015 Chennai Zone passed by the Second Respondent and quash the same

    Prayer in Crl.O.P.No.10500 of 2017 : Criminal Original Petition filed under Section 482 of Cr.P.C to call for the records in Original Complaint in O.C.No.855 of 2017 filed by the Second Respondent before the Hon'ble Chair person Adjudicating Authority, the first respondent under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 and quash the same.)

    Common Order:

    Crl.O.P.No.10497 of 2017 is filed to quash the Provisional Attachment Order No.09/2017 dated 07.04.2017 in ECIR/CEZO/08/ 2015 Chennai Zone passed by the second respondent, whereas Crl.O.P.No.10500 of 2017 is filed to quash the Original Complaint in O.C.No.855 of 2017 filed by the second respondent under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.

    2. The brief facts leading to file these petitions are as follows:

    2.(a) The first petitioner was working as an Assistant Commissioner of Customs and Central Excise, Customs House, Chennai and he resigned from the services with effect from 14.4.2011. While he was working as an Appraiser in the Customs House, Chennai, the 3rd respondent, Deputy Superintendent of Police, CBI had filed an FIR No.RCMA1/2005A/0031 on 29.06.2005 for alleged possession of assets and pecuniary resources in the name of First Petitioner and in the name of his family members for alleged commission of offences under Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1988. A final report under Section 173(2) of Cr.P.C.was also filed on 13.01.2009 by 3rd respondent before the Principal Special Judge for CBI Cases, Chennai, in C.C.No.18 of 2009 for the offences punishable under Section 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 against 1st petitioner and Section 109 of I.P.C. r/w 13(2) r/w 13(1)(e) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 against 2nd petitioner. Check period was shown as 01.05.1997 to 30.06.2005. 3rd and 4th petitioners were not arrayed as accused in the above C.C.No.18 of 2009.

    2.(b) Trial is under progress in the Court of XIV Additional Special Judge for CBI Cases. Presently the Investigating Officer, P.W.74 of the case is being cross-examined by the defence side. In the meanwhile, after six years of the aforesaid alleged offence u/s 13(2) r/w Sec.13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, which is a Scheduled Offence under Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2nd respondent registered an Enforcement Case Information Report and also sent summons to the petitioners 1 & 2.

    2.(c) It is the contention of the petitioners that the alleged offences as per the charge Sheet have allegedly committed between 1.5.1997 to 30.06.2005 and during this period Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 was not even in force. The Act came into force on 01.07.2005 through the notification published in the Gazette of India dated 1.4.2005. The petitioners also gave a reply to the effect that as on 1.7.2005 Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act do not find place in the scheduled offences list under Prevention of Money Laundering Act. It was also pointed out to the office of the 3rd respondent by the petitioners' reply that Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act 1998 was added in the list of scheduled offences only on 1.6.2009. The first petitioner appeared before the Assistant Director on 20.06.2016 and his statement was recorded and the 2nd petitioner appeared on 21.6.2016 and her statement was also recorded. She has stated that all the original documents of properties were seized by the CBI, ACB, Chennai and the same are in the custody of the 14th Additional Special Judge for CBI Cases. However, 1st and 2nd respondents did not consider any of the submissions made by the petitioners and the above impugned Provisional attachment order has been passed. 3rd and 4th petitioners were minors, born on 14.08.1993 and 5.4.1996 respectively.

    2.(d) The second respondent provisionally attached movable properties in the name of 3rd and 4th petitioners. 3rd and 4th petitioners were minor at the time of the alleged offence. The list of properties provisionally attached in the name of 3rd petitioner is as follows:

    Sl.NoReferred in CBI Charge Sheet in CC 18/2009DescriptionHeld in Name/NamesAmount

    185STDR No.356494 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchShri Ajay Kumar Gupta, Smt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Vishakha Gupta33,000.00

    286STDR No.356485 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchShri Ajay Kumar Gupta, Smt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Vishakha Gupta33,000.00

    387STDR No.356493 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchSmt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Vishakha Gupta33,000.00

    489STDR No.3564835 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchShri Ajay Kumar Gupta, Smt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Vishakha Gupta33,000.00

    5978 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 924858 dated 01.02.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Vishakha Gupta10,000.00

    61018 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 924842 dated 25.01.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Vishakha Gupta10,000.00

    71058 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 925215 dated 08.02.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Vishakha Gupta10,000.00

    81088 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 929096 dated 12.04.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Vishakha Gupta10,000.00

    91098 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra No.90 BB 770972 dated 18.04.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Vishakha Gupta5,000.00

    101108 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra No.90 BB 770973 dated 18.04.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Vishakha Gupta5,000.00

    11119Balance in SB Account No.4754 in A/c of Central Bank of India, Anna Nagar Branch as on 30.06.2005Shri Ajay Kumar Gupt & Miss Vishakha Gupta37,039.56

    12131Amount in PPF A/c.No.01P00900383 at SBI, Anna Nagar West Branch as on 30.06.2005Miss Vishakha Gupta80,000.00

    Total2,99,039.56

    2.(e) Similarly the list of properties provisionally attached in the name of 4th petitioner is as follows:

    Sl.NoReferred in CBI Charge Sheet in CC 18/2009DescriptionHeld in Name/NamesAmount

    181STDR No.356496 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchSmt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Saloni Gupta33,000.00

    283STDR No.356495 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchShri Ajay Kumar Gupta, Smt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Saloni Gupta33,000.00

    388STDR No.356492 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchSmt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Saloni Gupta33,000.00

    490STDR No.356483 Dated 26.12.2003 maturing on 26.12.2006 at SBI, Kodambakkam BranchShri Ajay Kumar Gupta, Smt. Veenita Gupta & Miss Saloni Gupta33,000.00

    5988 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 924859 dated 01.02.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Saloni Gupta10,000.00

    61028 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 924843 dated 01.02.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Saloni Gupta10,000.00

    71048 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 924908 dated 08.02.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Saloni Gupta10,000.00

    81078 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra N.51 CD 929095 dated 12.04.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, ChennaiMiss Saloni Gupta10,000.00

    91118 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra No.90 BB 770974 dated 18.04.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Saloni Gupta5,000.00

    101128 Years 7 Months Kisan Vikas Patra No.90 BB 770975 dated 18.04.2005 issued by Sub-Post Master, Sowcarpet NDSO, Chennai - 79Miss Saloni Gupta5,000.00

    11130Amount in PPF A/c.No.01P00900382 at SBI, Anna Nagar West Branch as on 30.06.2005Miss Saloni Gupta80,000.00

    Total2,62,000.00

    2.(f) The Provisional Attachment Order suffers from serious infirmity. The 3rd and 4th petitioners were never arrayed as accused in any case and they were school going children and now they are studying in college and without considering the same, they have now been summoned toappear before the 1st respondent. The Provisional Attachment Order No.9/2017 relates to the properties possessed or acquired by the petitioners 1 and 2 during the period 1.5.1997 to 30.06.2005 and during such material period the Prevention of Money Laundering Act was not in force. The Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002 was came into force only on 1.7.2005. Whereas final report was submitted by CBI on 13.01.2009. Similarly, Prevention of Corruption Act was included in the Scheduled List of Offences only with effect from 01.06.2009 and it can have no retrospective or retroactive operation and any penal action for alleged offences committed prior to the enactment and operation of law is violative of the Article 20 (1) of the Constitution of India.

    2.(g) Hence, Challenging the Provisional Attachment Order passed by the 2nd respondent dated 7.4.2017 Criminal Original Petition No.10497 of 2017 has been filed. The petitioners also filed Criminal Original Petition No.10500 of 2017 to quash the Original Complaint in O.C.No.855 of 2017 filed by 2nd respondent before the 1st respondent.

    3. Heard the learned counsel for the petitioners, learned Special Public Prosecutor for Enforcement Directorate appearing for R1 and R2 and also the learned counsel appearing for the 3rd respondent, who is a formal party in these cases.

    4. The main contention of the of the petitioner is that when the alleged offence itself was prior to 01.07.2005, when the Prevention of Money Laundering Act was not in force, attaching the properties under the amended Act is not valid in law. Prevention of Money Laundering Act is penal stature, therefore, can have no retrospective or retroactive operation and any penal action for alleged offences committed prior to the enactment and operation of law is violative of the Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India. The second respondent has not considered this aspect and simply passed the order attaching the properties including the minors i.e., 3rd and 4th petitioners, who have no way connected with the alleged offences. It is the further contention of the learned counsel for the petitioners that while all the properties in Provisional Attachment Order were seized by CBI, ACB, Chennai and the same are in the custody of 14th Additional Special Judge Court for CBI cases, the question of summoning or transferring the properties does not arise at all. He further submitted that the 2nd respondent has not properly exercised his power to pass the attachment order.

    5. The learned Special Public Prosecutor for Enforcement Directorate appearing for Respondents 1 and 2 would submit that the Money Laundering offence is continuing offence. Once Provisional Attachment is passed, the petitioner has to appear before the Adjudicating Authority and not before this Court for quashing the entire proceedings and though in the Schedule of offences the Prevention of Corruption Act was included later, Money Laundering offence is continuous one and retrospective effect can be given to the Act. Hence, the learned Special Public Prosecutor submitted that the petitions for quashing Original Complaint and also for quashing the Provisional Attachment Order of the second respondent are not maintainable and both the petitions are liable to be dismissed. The Learned Special Public Prosecutor for Enforcement Directorate also relied upon the Judgments reported in

    1. Solidaire India Ltd., Vs. Fair Growth [AIR 2001 FC 958 : JT 2001(2) SC 642; ],

    2. Bank of India vs. Ketan Parekh [2008 (8) SCC 148 : AIR 2008 SC 2361; ],

    3. Union of India Vs. Hassan Ali Khan and another [C.A.No.1883 of 2011 of Honourable Supreme Court ]and

    4. Gokak Patel Volkart Ltd., Vs. Dundayya Gurushiddaiah Hiremath [1991 SCR (1) 396, 1991 SCC (2) 141].

    6.In the light of the above submissions, now the point that arise for consideration in these Criminal Original Petitions is:

    whether the order of Provisional Attachment made and the Original Complaint filed before the Adjudicating Authority, under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, by the second respondent are in accordance with law or liable to be quashed?

    7. It is not disputed that the 1st petitioner was charge sheeted by the CBI, Anti Corruption Branch for the alleged possession of assets and pecuniary resources and the 2nd petitioner was prosecuted for abetment in the above offence. It is also not in dispute that the alleged offences against the petitioners 1 and 2, related to the period from 01.05.1997 to 30.06.2005 and 3rd and 4th petitioners have not been made as accused in the charge sheet filed by the 3rd respondent before the XIV Additional Special Judge for CBI Cases. Further, it is also not in dispute that in C.C.No.18 of 2009 trial also commenced and 74 witnesses were examined. The provisional Attachment Order was passed by the 2nd Respondent on 07.04.2017 to attach the properties of the petitioners including 3rd and 4th petitioners, in whose name the properties were shown to the value of Rs.5,61,039.36 in the form of some Fixed Deposits, Kisan Vikas Patras, Savings Bank Account and PPF, etc., It is also not in dispute that based on the charge sheet filed by the CBI Anti Corruption Branch, an Enforcement Case Information Report No.CZO/08/2015 dated 20.02.2015 was registered by the Directorate of Enforcement, Chennai and filed before Adjudicating Authority under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002. Accordingly Provisional Attachment order passed under the Prevention of money Laundering Act attaching all properties of the petitioners, in fact, which also subject matter of CBI Case. It is relevant to mention Section 5 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002:

    5. Attachment of property involved in money-laundering.-

    (1) Where the Director, or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director authorised by him for the purposes of this section, has reason to believe (the reason for such belief to be recorded in writing), on the basis of material in his possession, that-

    (a) any person is in possession of any proceeds of crime; and

    (b) such proceeds of crime are likely to be concealed, transferred or dealt with in any manner which may result in frustrating any proceedings relating to confiscation of such proceeds of crime under this Chapter, he may, by order in writing, provisionally attach such property for a period not exceeding one hundred and eighty days from the date of the order, in such manner as may be prescribed:

    Provided that no such order of attachment shall be made unless, in relation to the scheduled offence, a report has been forwarded to a Magistrate under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), or a complaint has been filed by a person authorised to investigate the offence mentioned in the Schedule, before a Magistrate or court for taking cognizance of the scheduled offence, as the case may be or a similar report or complaint has been made or filed under the corresponding law of any other country:

    Provided further that, notwithstanding anything contained in [first proviso], any property of any person may be attached under this section if the Director or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director authorised by him for the purposes of this section has reason to believe (the reasons for such belief to be recorded in writing), on the basis of material in his possession, that if such property involved in money-laundering is not attached immediately under this Chapter, the non-attachment of the property is likely to frustrate any proceeding under this Act.]

    (2) The Director, or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director, shall, immediately after attachment under sub-section (1), forward a copy of the order, along with the material in his possession, referred to in that sub-section, to the Adjudicating Authority, in a sealed envelope, in the manner as may be prescribed and such Adjudicating Authority shall keep such order and material for such period as may be prescribed.

    (3) very order of attachment made under sub-section (1) shall cease to have effect after the expiry of the period specified in that sub-section or on the date of an order made under sub-section (2) of section 8, whichever is earlier.

    (4) Nothing in this section shall prevent the person interested in the enjoyment of the immovable property attached under sub-section (1) from such enjoyment.

    Explanation.— For the purposes of this sub-section “person interested”, in relation to any immovable property, includes all persons claiming or entitled to claim any interest in the property.

    (5) he Director or any other officer who provisionally attaches any property under sub-section (1) shall, within a period of thirty days from such attachment, file a complaint stating the facts of such attachment before the Adjudicating Authority.”

    8. These provisions of Section 5 remained in force till 30.05.2009 as Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2009, No.21 of 2009 came into force on 01.06.2009. The charge sheet was filed by the CBI before the said Court on 13.01.2009. At the relevant time, Section 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act was not in the list of schedule under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. Section 5 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act was further amended by the Act 2 of 2013. The amended Section 5 of the Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2012 reads as follows:

    5. Amendment of Section 5.- In Section 5 of the principal Act, for sub-section (1), the following sub-section shall be substituted, namely:-

    “(1) Where the Director or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director authorised by the Director for the purpose of this section, has reason to believe (the reason for such belief to be recorded in writing), on the basis of material in his possession, that-

    (a) any person is in possession of any proceeds of crime, and

    (b) such proceeds of crime are likely to be concealed, transferred or dealt with in any manner which may result in frustrating any proceedings relating to confiscation of such proceeds of crime under this Chapter, he may, by order in writing, provisionally attach such property for a period not exceeding one hundred and eighty days from the date of the order, in such manner as may be prescribed.

    Provided that no such order of attachment shall be made unless, in relation to the scheduled offence, a report has been forwarded to a Magistrate under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (2 of 1974), or a complaint has been filed by a person authorised to investigate the offence mentioned in the Schedule, before a Magistrate or court for taking cognizance of the scheduled offence, as the case may be or a similar report or complaint has been made or filed under the corresponding law of any other country:

    Provided further that, notwithstanding anything contained in clause (b), any property of any person may be attached under this section if the Director or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director authorised by him for the purposes of this section has reason to believe (the reasons for such belief to be recorded in writing), on the basis of material in his possession, that if such property involved in money-laundering is not attached immediately under this Chapter, the non-attachment of the property is likely to frustrate any proceeding under this Act.”

    9. On a careful perusal of the above section after amendment, makes it clear that even any person having convicted for an offence and any person is in possession of any proceeds of crime, the Director or any other officer not below the rank of Deputy Director authorised by him has reason to believe (the reasons for such belief to be recorded in writing), on the basis of material in his possession, that if such property involved in money laundering is not attached immediately, the non attachment of the property is likely to frustrate any proceedings under the said Act. Though there are two provisions subsequently amended, what is required is that, the attaching officer has reason to believe the reasons and such belief to be recorded in writing and the other condition is charged offence must be a scheduled offence. Similarly Section 8 also amended under the Amended Act of 2009. As per the amendment, even if the case instituted in respect of scheduled offence results in acquittal of the accused, a person could still be prosecuted under Section 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act. In nut shell, this amendment has made the Prevention of Money Laundering Act an independent Act. Section 5 clearly stipulated that there is a requirement of law that before any attachment, reasons in writing to be recorded by the officer concerned. It is to be noted that in this case, admittedly the offence is related to the check period from 01.05.1997 to 30.06.2005 and even at that time, the Prevention of Money Laundering Act was not in force and came into force only on 1.7.2005 and the Section13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act was included in the schedule, in the year 2009.

    10. In this regard it is useful to refer the judgment of the Division Bench of Karnataka High Court in the case of M/s Obulapuram Mining Company Pvt. Ltd., vs. Directorate of Enforcement in W.P.Nos.5962 of 2016, 11442 of 2016 and 11440-11441 of 2016 the Division Bench held as follows:

    “10. It can be seen from the records that all the offences allegedly committed by the writ petitioner were earlier to the insertion of the provision in the schedule of the Prevention of Money Laundering (Amendment) Act, 2009 and as such, they have no application.

    11. Therefore, the Enforcement Case Information Report and the order of attachment are without jurisdiction and are liable to be quashed. As we have, already, held that the writ petitioner cannot be prosecuted for the offences alleged, as they are not the scheduled offences under the PML Act. Those offences under the Mines and Geology (Development and Regulation) Act, 1957, the Forest (Conservation) Act, 1980, the Indian Penal Code and the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, were included in the PML Act declaring them as scheduled offences only with effect from June 1, 2009. Hence, the Enforcement Directorate Could not have invoked the provisions of the PML Act with retrospective effect.

    12. The petitioner cannot be tried and punished for the offences under the PML Act when the offences were not inserted in the schedule of offences under the PML Act. This would deny the writ petitioner the protection provided under Clause (1) of Article 20 of the Constitution of India. Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India prohibits the conviction of a person or his being subjected to penalty for ex-post facto laws. Consequently, the order of attachement is, also, liable to be set aside.”

    11. In the case of Mahanivesh Oils & Foods Pvt. Ltd., V. Directorate of Enforcement in W.P.(C)1925/ 2014 and C.M.No.4017/2014 the Delhi High Court has held thus:

    “19. Section 2(u) of the Act defines proceeds of crime and reads as under:-

    "proceeds of crime" means any property derived or obtained, directly or indirectly, by any person as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence or the value of any such property;"

    20. Thus, a conjoint reading of 5(1) read with Section 2(u)of the Act clearly indicates that the power to attach is only with respect to the property derived or obtained directly or indirectly by any person as a result of criminal activity relating to a scheduled offence or the value of such property.

    21. Thus, plainly, the occurrence of a scheduled offence is the substratal condition for giving rise to any proceeds of crime and consequently, the application Section 5(a) of the Act. A commission of a scheduled offence is the fundamental pre-condition for any proceeding under the Act as without a scheduled offence being committed, the question of proceeds of crime coming into existence does not arise.

    22. In view of the above, the contention that the Act is completely independent of the principal crime (scheduled offence) giving rise to proceeds of crime is unmerited. It is necessary to bear in mind that the substratal subject of the Act is to prevent money-laundering and confiscate the proceeds of crime. In that perspective, there is an inextricable link between the Act and the occurrence of a crime. It cannot be disputed that the offence of money-laundering is a separate offence unde Section 3 of the Act, which is punishable under Section 4 of the Act. However as stated earlier, the offence of money-laundering relates to the proceeds of crime, the genesis of which is a scheduled offence. In the aforesaid circumstances, before initiation of any proceeding under Section 5 of the Act, it would be necessary for the concerned authorities to identify the scheduled crime. The First Proviso to Section 5 also indicates that no order of attachment shall be made unless in relation to a schedule offence a report has been forwarded to a Magistrate under Section 173 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 or a complaint has been filed by a person authorised to investigate the scheduled offence before a Magistrate or Court for taking cognizance of the scheduled offence. Thus, in cases where the scheduled offence is itself negated, the fundamental premise of continuing any proceedings under the Act also vanishes. Such cases where it is conclusively held that a commission of a scheduled offence is not established and such decision has attained finality pose no difficulty; in such cases, the proceedings under the Act would fail.

    29. The Act is a penal statute and, therefore, can have no retrospective or retroactive operation. Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India expressly forbids that no person can be convicted of any offence except for the violation of a law in force at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence. Further, no person can be inflicted a penalty greater than what could have been inflicted under the law at the time when the offence was committed. Clearly, no proceedings under the Act can be initiated or sustained in respect of an offence, which has been committed prior to the Act coming into force. However, the subject matter of the Act is not a scheduled offence but the offence of money-laundering. Strictly speaking, it cannot be contended that the Act has a retrospective operation because it now enacts that laundering of proceeds of crime committed earlier as an offence. In The Queen v. The Inhabitants of St. Mary, Whitechapel (1848) 12 QB 120, the Court pointed out that "The Statute which in its direct operation of prospective cannot be properly be called a retrospective statute because a part of the requisites for that action is drawn from the time antecedent to its passing". Thus, with effect from 1st June, 2009 laundering proceeds of crime under Section 420 of the IPC is enacted as an offence of money-laundering punishable under Section 4 of the Act. It is important to note that the punishment under Section 4 of the Act is not for commission of a scheduled offence but for laundering proceeds of a scheduled crime. The fact that the scheduled crime may have been committed prior to the Act coming into force would not render the Act a retrospective statute as only the offence of money-laundering committed after the enforcement of the Act can be proceeded against under the Act.

    34. In the circumstances, it cannot be readily accepted that any offence of money-laundering had been committed after the Act coming into force. This Act cannot be read as to empower the authorities to initiate proceedings in respect of money-laundering offences done prior to 01.07.2005 or prior to the related crime being included as a scheduled offence under the Act.”

    12. From the above judgments and also the fact that the offences allegedly committed by the first and second petitioners prior to 1.7.2005, the Prevention of Money Laundering Act was not in force. Even after 1.7.2005, the offences were not included in the scheduled offences till 1.6.2009. Since the charge sheet dated 13.1.2009, even on that date, Prevention of Corruption Act has not included in the scheduled list of offences. Therefore, this court is of the view that if retrospective effect is given to any statute of any penal nature, it will be directly in conflict with the fundamental rights of the citizen enshrined in Article 20(1) of the Constitution of India. Admittedly, 2nd respondent filed the case only based on the charge sheet of the CBI, who have not conducted any enquiry on their own. In fact, all the documents are original documents of the alleged proceeds of crime, which are in the custody of the CBI Court. When the entire documents are in the custody of the Court, there cannot be any reason to believe that the properties will be dealt with in any other manner. The impugned order was as if 1st petitioner not able to offer any satisfactory explanation during examination. Therefore, the attachment officer has passed an order without a reason to believe that the proceeds of crime are likely to be transferred or disposal. In the absence of any sufficient reason, arriving to such conclusion by mere reproducing the words “reason to believe”, it cannot be stated that the order has been passed after considering the entire gamut of materials. Admittedly, in this case, entire documents are available and the properties are in the custody of the court. Therefore, the order of attachment is not maintainable.

    13. Similarly, the charge sheet was filed on 13.1.2009 under Section 13 of Prevention of Corruption Act, but this section was included in the list of Scheduled Offences under Prevention of Money Laundering Act is only on 1.6.2009. Therefore subsequent amendment cannot be given any retrospective effect. It is also categorically held by the Karnataka High Court in M/s Obulapuram Mining Company Pvt. Ltd.case, referred above. The Delhi High Court in Arunkumar Mishra v. Directorate of Enforcement case in Crl.M.C.No.5508 of 2014 has held as follows:

    “21. It is settled principle of law that the provisions of law cannot be retrospectively applied, as Article 20(1) of the Constitution bars the ex-post facto penal laws and no person can be prosecuted for an alleged offence which occurred earlier, by applying the provisions of law which have come into force after the alleged offence.”

    14. Though the learned Special Public Prosecutor for Enforcement Directorate appearing for Respondents 1 and 2 relied upon the citations of the Honourable Supreme Court, on a careful perusal, the judgments are not with regard to the applicability of Scheduled offences of the Money Laundering Act. Therefore, the authorities cited by the learned counsel for respondents is no way helpful to the respondents, to establish their case.

    15. In view of the above, the Provisional Attachment Order No.09/2017 dated 7.4.2017 in ECIR/CEZO/08/2015 and the Original Complaint in O.C.No.855 of 2017 are quashed. The point is answered accordingly.

    16. In the result, the petitions are ordered as prayed for. Connected M.P are closed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Ajay Kumar Gupta & Others v. Adjudicating Authority (Pmla), New Delhi & Others
    (Jul 13, 2017)