Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicants, impleaded as accused nos. 7 and 8, are prosecuted under Sections 255 to 260, 465, 467, 468, 471, 420, and 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860, in two cases registered as CR Nos. 91 of 2004 and 337 of 2014. The prosecution case arises from an investigation initiated by the Chief Manager of State Bank of Indore, Bhuleshwar Branch, Mumbai, who discovered that several persons, including the applicants, had obtained housing loans but failed to pay installments equally. Further inquiry revealed that the builder had not received the loan amount and the borrowers had not obtained possession of the premises. It was also found that forged and fabricated documents were produced to obtain loans in 2003, involving about eighteen persons. Following investigation, a charge sheet was filed. The applicants and others filed applications for discharge, which were rejected by the Sessions Court by order dated 1 September 2015.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there is sufficient evidence to frame charges against the applicants under Section 255 of the Penal Code, 1860, relating to counterfeiting government stamps.
  2. Whether the rejection of the discharge application by the Sessions Court was justified given the prosecution's material.
  3. Whether the offence under Section 255 of IPC is properly triable by the Sessions Court and whether other offences charged are triable by the Magistrate Court.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants' Arguments

  • No evidence exists to support the charge under Section 255 of the IPC, as there was no recovery of materials used for counterfeiting stamps.
  • To frame a charge under Section 255, the accused must be shown to have counterfeited stamps or knowingly engaged in the process of counterfeiting government revenue stamps, which is absent here.
  • The applicants relied on the precedent of Manmit Saggu v. State of Maharashtra, 2009-All.M.R. (Cri.)-735, to support their contention.

Prosecution's Arguments

  • Grounds raised by the applicants are premature and cannot be considered at the discharge stage.
  • The prosecution should be allowed to lead evidence to prove the charges.
  • The accused used forged and fabricated documents with stamps applied mechanically, supporting the charge under Section 255 of IPC.
  • The application for discharge should be rejected.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Manmit Saggu v. State of Maharashtra, 2009-All.M.R. (Cri.)-735 Requirements to frame charge under Section 255 IPC regarding counterfeiting stamps. The Court considered this precedent but found it inapplicable given the prima facie evidence in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the materials on record, focusing on whether a prima facie case was made out to proceed against the applicants under Section 255 of IPC, which is triable by the Sessions Court. The Court noted that no recovery of counterfeiting instruments from the accused was made, but the prosecution's evidence included statements from witnesses and a sub-registrar indicating that the sale deeds executed by the applicants were forged and fabricated, with forged franking, stamp duty receipts, rubber stamps, and signatures. The Court emphasized that at the discharge stage, the inquiry is limited to whether there is sufficient material to proceed, not to adjudicate the merits. It found that the accused had counterfeited government revenue stamps/franking and consciously defrauded the payment of stamp duty. The Court also referred to previous rejected applications for discharge by other accused and the rejection of related Criminal Revision Applications, reinforcing the view that a prima facie case exists. Consequently, the Court held that the decision relied upon by the applicants was not applicable to the present facts and that the discharge application was rightly rejected.

Holding and Implications

The Criminal Revision Application No. 509 of 2015 is rejected and disposed of.

The Court clarified that its observations are confined to the present application and shall not influence the Trial Court at trial. The direct effect is that the applicants remain charged and the trial will proceed. No new precedent has been established by this decision.

    Dina Vasant Shah v. State Of Maharashtra

    Prakash D. Naik, J.:— The applicants are prosecuted for offence under Sections 255 to 260, 465, 467, 468, 471, 420, 120-B of Penal Code, 1860. The offences were registered vide CR Nos. 91 of 2004 and 337 of 2014. The applicants are impleaded as accused nos. 7 and 8 in the said proceedings. The application for discharge filed by the applicants was rejected by the Sessions Court vide order dated 1 September 2015.

    2. The case of the prosecution is that the complainant is the Chief Manager of State Bank of Indore, Bhuleshwar Branch, at Mumbai. It was noticed by the complainant after verifying the documents of some of the persons including the applicants and other accused that they had obtained housing loan from the bank but they were not paying the equal monthly installments. On further investigation it was noticed that the accused had taken loan from State Bank of Indore and it was revealed that the builder had not received the loan amount and that the borrowers had not received the possession of premises. It was also noticed that the accused had produced forged and fabricated documents to obtain loan in the year 2003. There were about eighteen persons who had obtained the loan from the said bank by relying upon the forged documents. After completing the investigation, the charge sheet was filed.

    3. The applicants as well as other accused filed an application for discharge which has been rejected by the Sessions Court.

    4. The learned counsel for the applicants submitted that there is no evidence against the applicants to support the charge under section 255 of Penal Code, 1860. It is submitted that to frame the charge under section 255 of IPC, there has to be recovery of material used by the accused for counterfeiting the stamp which is totally absent in the present case. It is submitted that to substantiate the offence under section 255 of IPC, the accused are required to counterfeit the stamps or knowingly perform any part of process of counterfeiting any stamp issued by Government for the purpose of revenue and there is no evidence to support the said charge. The learned counsel placed reliance on the decision in the case of Manmit Saggu v. State of Maharashtra, 2009-All.M.R. (Cri.)-735.

    5. Learned APP opposed the application. It is submitted that the grounds raised by the applicants cannot be considered at this stage. The case for discharge was not made out. The prosecution should be given an opportunity to lead the evidence to prove the charge against the accused. The accused had used forged and fabricated documents which shows that the stamps were pasted on the documents by mechanical process. It is, therefore, submitted that the application may be rejected.

    6. I have perused the documents on record. The primary contention of the applicants is that offence under section 255 of IPC is not made out since there is no evidence to establish the alleged offence of counterfeiting stamps. The offence under Section 255 is the only offence triable before Sessions Court amongst the offences charged against the accused. It has been contended that there is no recovery of any such instruments from the accused nor they were found counterfeiting the government stamps. It is further submitted that the offence under section 255 of IPC is triable by the Sessions Court and the other offences are triable by the Court of Magistrate. It is therefore contended that in the absence of any evidence to frame charge under section 255 of IPC, the applicants be discharged in relation to charge under section 255 of IPC. It is submitted that the applicants have not committed any offence. The Sessions Court has rejected the application filed by the accused including the applicants. While rejecting the application the Court has assigned reasons which does not require interference by this Court. The prosecution case is that the accused no. 1 has disbursed the loan of about Rs. 1,05,96,000/- to various borrowers i.e. accused persons. The accused no. 1 had authority to sanction loan up to Rs. 10 lakh. The said borrowers did not repay the loan amount. The loan was disbursed without verifying the genuineness of margin money. The pay orders were directly handed over to the accused. The investigation authority had recorded the statements of various witnesses including the sub-registrar to substantiate the charge that sale deeds which were executed by the applicants, were forged and fabricated documents. The franking on the said documents was forged. The receipt of stamp duty, rubber stamps and signatures were also forged. At the stage of deciding an application for discharge, the Court is required to look into the material on record and whether prima facie case is made out for proceeding against the accused. From the statements of witnesses it is manifest that the accused had counterfeited the government revenue stamps/franking and knowingly performed the acts and consciously defrauded to pay the stamp duty. The other accused had also preferred similar application before the Trial Court which were rejected by common order dated 1 September 2015. Some of the accused had preferred Criminal Revision Application Nos. 552 of 2015 and 561 of 2016 before this Court which are rejected vide order dated 3 August 2017. Considering the fact that prima facie case is made out to constitute the offence, the decision relied upon by the applicants, cannot be applied in the facts of present case. Hence, the appliction is required to be rejected.

    7. Hence, I pass following order:

    (i) Criminal Revision Application No. 509 of 2015 is rejected;

    (ii) It is clarified that the observations made in this order are only for considering the present application and the Trial Court shall not be influenced by the same at the time of trial;

    (iii) Criminal Revision Application No. 509 of 2015 is disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Dina Vasant Shah v. State Of Maharashtra
    (Feb 7, 2018)