AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Court's Order

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal arises from an order dated 01.11.2010 of the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT), Lucknow (I.T.A. No.66/Luc/2007) for assessment year 1999-2000, challenged by the department under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961. The assessee is a company engaged in manufacturing and sale of pan masala. It filed a return for the year on 12.11.1999 which was processed under section 143(1). Following a Central Excise search and seizure at the assessee's premises on 04.07.2001 and impounding of books and documents, the Assessing Officer issued a notice under section 148 on 25.02.2004. An assessment order under sections 143(3)/147 was passed on 28.03.2005 with various additions.

On appeal, the first appellate authority rejected the assessee's appeal by order dated 28.12.2006. The assessee filed a second appeal to the Tribunal, which by order dated 26.10.2007 remanded the matter to the Assessing Officer (A.O.) to pass a fresh order. The assessee filed a miscellaneous application (MA 131/Luc/2008) before the Tribunal seeking recall of that order for the limited purpose of deciding the validity of service of the section 148 notice dated 25.02.2004. The Tribunal, by the impugned order dated 01.11.2010, held that there was no valid service of the section 148 notice and therefore the A.O. lacked jurisdiction to make the reassessment. The department filed the present appeal by special leave.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, after service of notice and where the assessee participated voluntarily in proceedings without objection, an appellate forum was correct in later recording a finding that the notice was not validly served and thereby vitiating the proceedings?
  2. Whether the ITAT was right in holding that no proper service of notice under section 148 was made when the person receiving the notice had previously received several other departmental notices whose service was not challenged by the assessee?
  3. Whether the ITAT was justified in law and on facts in ignoring the provisions of Order 29 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which allow service of process by leaving it at the registered office of a company, thereby treating service on a person found at the registered office as valid?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Revenue / Department) — Principal Submissions

  • O.P. Nehru, who received the section 148 notice on 25.02.2004 at the assessee's premises, was the legal officer of the company and had on earlier occasions received departmental notices; his prior receipt and legal competence imply implied authority to receive notices.
  • Even if O.P. Nehru was not strictly authorised to accept the notice, service was nevertheless valid under Order 29 Rule 2 CPC because the notice was left at the assessee's registered office/principal place of business and was acknowledged; leaving at the registered office is a mode of service contemplated by Order 29 Rule 2.
  • The department acted in good faith and could have used alternative modes of service if the recipient had refused the notice; the objection regarding service was raised belatedly before the Tribunal by way of a miscellaneous application.
  • Counsel relied on precedents (noted in the record) in support of the proposition that such service and acknowledgement suffice.

Respondent (Assessee) — Principal Submissions

  • The assessee challenged the validity of the initiation of proceedings under section 148 on the ground that the notice dated 25.02.2004 was not validly served; this objection was raised before the Appellate Authority and before the Tribunal.
  • The section 148 notice was served through a process server on O.P. Nehru, who was neither the principal officer nor authorised to receive such notice; thus the service was defective.
  • The Chartered Accountant, Sri Dinesh Singh, who represented the assessee on earlier occasions, came into the picture only after a section 143(2) notice dated 30.06.2004 was served on him; at the time of service of section 148 notice (10.03.2004 in record) he had no authority to receive it.
  • Reliance was placed on authorities that treat valid notice for reassessment as a condition precedent and require explicit proof of authority where notices are accepted by agents or representatives.
  • The assessee contended that the Tribunal correctly found want of proper service and that no error was committed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Y. Rajendra, Dy. CIT v. Khoday Eshwarsa & Sons [2005] 272 ITR 448/144 Taxman 629 (Kar) The opinion records that the department relied on the ratio in this case; the text does not specify the exact principle from this authority. The case was cited by counsel for the department; the Court's summary of reliance is limited to noting that counsel invoked this authority in support of validity of service.
Sohan Singh Basi v. Inspecting Asstt. CWT [1992] 194 ITR 339 (Delhi) Where a chartered accountant receives a notice and the assessee thereafter participates and raises no objection, it is difficult to hold the chartered accountant lacked authority; conduct can preclude equitable relief. The Court relied on this ratio to support the proposition that voluntary participation by the assessee after receipt of notice by a representative tends to validate service and disentitles the assessee to later equitable relief challenging service.
Harsingar Gutkha (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2011] 336 ITR 90/[2012] 20 taxmann.com 713 (All.) The Tribunal must examine material and give a basis for concluding whether a chartered accountant possessed the requisite authority; reference to Order V Rule 12 CPC (service of summons) is relevant. Quoted by the assessee's counsel to insist that the Tribunal should have examined whether the CA had authority; the Court recorded this submission but ultimately found other facts (voluntary participation; receipt at registered office) persuasive.
Laxmi Narain Anand Prakash v. CST [1980] 46 STC 71 (All.) Observes that issuance and service of notice is a condition precedent; mere issuance without valid service makes proceedings and consequential orders illegal and void. Relied on by the assessee to emphasise that valid service is a condition precedent; the Court noted the submission but concluded that participation and acknowledged delivery at the registered office cured the defect in this case.
CIT v. Shital Prasad Kharag Prasad [2006] 280 ITR 541/[2005] 147 Taxman 441 (All.) The opinion records this authority as supporting the proposition that a valid notice for reassessment is a condition precedent; details of the rule are stated only as counsel's reliance. Cited by the assessee's counsel to support the condition-precedent argument; the Court considered it but preferred the view that voluntary participation validated the proceedings on the facts.
Addl. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Lucknow v. Prem Kumar Rastogi [1980] 124 ITR 381 (All.) Similarly cited for the proposition that valid service (notice) is a condition precedent to reassessment proceedings. Referenced by the assessee; the Court noted this authority but resolved the dispute on the basis of participation, prior receipt by an in-house representative and service at the registered office.
Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Smt. Kanti Devi Gupta [2005] 274 ITR 526/[2006] 156 Taxman 77 (MP) Supports that service may be sufficient where employees/consultants (who are family members) are the persons receiving process at the business premises. The Court invoked this authority in support of the conclusion that service was sufficient where company employees/consultants (family members) received notices at the business premises.
CIT v. Uttam Chand Nahar [2007] 295 ITR 403 (Raj) Holds that participation in appellate proceedings is sufficient for the validity of notice/service. The Court relied on this authority to reinforce the proposition that the assessee's voluntary participation in appellate proceedings validated service.
K.J. Thomos v. CIT [2008] 303 ITR 301 (Ker.) Where notice under section 143(2) was not received but the opportunity was availed, reassessment can be valid. Invoked by the Court to support the proposition that availing opportunity on merits can validate reassessment despite defective notice.
CIT v. T.C.P. Ltd. [2010] 323 ITR 346 (Mad.) Echoes the view that availing opportunity may validate reassessment in the absence of formal service. Cited alongside K.J. Thomos to support the court's view that participation/availing opportunity cures defects in service.
Areva T. & D. India v. Asstt. CIT [2007] 294 ITR 233/165 Taxman 123 (Mad.) Procedural irregularity may render proceedings irregular but not void; such irregularity can be rectified later. The Court relied on this principle to hold that any technical defect in service could be treated as irregularity amenable to rectification and not as rendering the reassessment void where participation followed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

(Step-by-step exposition of the court's analytical path as recorded in the opinion; limited strictly to the reasoning stated in the text.)

1. Examination of record facts: The Court observed that the notice dated 25.02.2004 was received at the assessee's premises by Sri O.P. Nehru. The record indicated that Nehru was the legal officer of the assessee company and had previously received departmental notices. Sri Dinesh Singh, a chartered accountant, had represented the assessee on earlier occasions. The notice had been served at the registered office of the company.

2. Good faith of process server and subsequent conduct: The Court recorded that the departmental process server served the notice in good faith. The Court placed weight on the fact that the assessee thereafter participated voluntarily in the appellate proceedings without contemporaneously objecting to service.

3. Reliance on analogous statutory/legal principles: The Court noted that Section 292BB (though not applicable to the assessment year under consideration) supports the general proposition that acknowledgement/participation can validate service; the Court treated this as persuasive by way of analogy to demonstrate that voluntary participation is material.

4. Precedential support for curing defects by participation: The Court applied precedents (such as Sohan Singh Basi; Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Smt. Kanti Devi Gupta; CIT v. Uttam Chand Nahar; K.J. Thomos; CIT v. T.C.P. Ltd.; and Areva T. & D. India) to the effect that where a representative receives notice and the assessee participates on merits (or avails opportunity), a subsequent technical objection to service may not invalidate the proceedings. The Court treated procedural/technical irregularity as removable or curable where the assessee has voluntarily engaged with the process.

5. Assessment of competing authorities: The Court acknowledged the assessee's reliance on authorities (e.g., Harsingar Gutkha; Laxmi Narain Anand Prakash; Shital Prasad Kharag Prasad; Prem Kumar Rastogi) which emphasize that valid service is a condition precedent and that the authority to accept notice must be demonstrated where notices are accepted by representatives. The Court recorded these submissions but ultimately concluded that the facts (acceptance at registered office, previous receipt by the same in-house legal officer, and active participation) weighed in favour of validating the service.

6. Conclusion of analysis: On the integrated view of facts and precedents recorded, the Court concluded that the procedural defect (if any) did not render the proceedings void because the assessee's voluntary participation and the circumstances of acknowledged delivery at the registered office cured the defect. Accordingly, the Court set aside the Tribunal's order that had held the service invalid and remanded the matter back to the A.O. for fresh adjudication on merits.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court allowed the department's appeal and set aside the impugned Tribunal order dated 01.11.2010 in MA 131/Luc/2008. The matter is remanded to the Assessing Officer as originally directed by the Tribunal on 26.10.2007, with a direction to decide the matter strictly on merits preferably within three months.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The Tribunal's finding that there was no valid service of the section 148 notice is reversed; the reassessment proceedings are to proceed on merits before the A.O. as remanded by the Court.
  • Substantial question answered: The Court recorded that the answers to the substantial questions of law admitted were in favour of the revenue and against the assessee.
  • Broader implications: The opinion grounds its decision on factual findings (acknowledged delivery at registered office and voluntary participation) and on precedents to the effect that participation can cure procedural defects. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new general legal rule beyond applying existing authorities to the facts of the case; no express new precedent or rule was announced in the text beyond the application to these facts.

This summary is strictly confined to the matters and reasoning recorded in the provided opinion. No information has been added beyond what appears in the text of the judgment.

    Commissioner of Income-tax v. Harsingar Gutkha (P.) Ltd.

    ORDER

    Dr. Satish Chandra, J. - Present Appeal is filed by the department under Section 260-A of the Income Tax Act, 1961, against the judgment and order dated 01.11.2010 passed by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Lucknow in I.T.A. No.66/Luc/2007 for the assessment year 1999-2000.

    2. On 06.09.2011, a coordinate Bench of this Court has admitted the instant appeal on the following substantial questions of law:

  • "1. Whether after service of notice and keeping in view the fact that the assessee has participated in the proceedings voluntarily without making any objection, then at later stage, the appellate forum was not right to record a finding that the notice was not validly served, hence the proceedings vitiates ?
  • 2. Whether on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the ITAT was right in holding that no proper service of notice u/s 148 was made on assessee when the person receiving the notice u/s 148 is the same person who has received several other notices, service of none of which has been challenged by the assessee.
  • 3. Whether ITAT was justified in law as well as in the circumstances of the case in ignoring the provisions of Order 29 Rule 2 of the CPC, 1908 that service of notice on Sh. O.P. Nehru for A.Y. 1999-2000 was valid as the relevant provision envisaged that notice may be treated as served by mere leaving it at the registered office of the assessee company or if there is no registered office then at the place where the assessee company carried on business."
  • 3. The brief facts of the case are that the assessee is a Company engaged in the manufacturing and sale of Pan Masala. For the assessment year under consideration, the assessee has filed its return on 12.11.1999. The return was processed under section 143 (1) of the Act. However, during the assessment proceedings, for the assessment year under consideration, it was informed by the Central Excise Authority that search and seizure operation was conducted by them at the business premises of the assessee and its sister concerned on 04.07.2001. During search operation, books of accounts and other relevant documents were impounded. On the basis of incriminating material, it appears that there was a suppression of production and clandestine/ unaccounted sale.

    4. In these circumstances, the A.O. has issued the notice under section 148 on 25.02.2004, which was duly served on the assessee. The assessment order was passed under section 143(3)/147 of the Income Tax Act on 28.03.2005, where the various additions were made.

    5. The first appellate authority has rejected the appeal vide order dated 28.12.2006 (Appeal No.45 of 2005). Not being satisfied, the assessee has filed Second Appeal before the Tribunal who vide its impugned order dated 26.10.2007 has remanded the matter back to the A.O. to pass the assessment order denovo. The assessee has moved an application under section 254 of the Income Tax Act (MA 131/Luc/2008) before the Tribunal, where the order dated 26.10.2008 was recalled for the limited purpose i.e. validity of the service of notice under section 148 of the Act. Hence, by the impugned order dated 01.11.2010, the Tribunal has decided the validity of the notice issued under section 148 dated 25.02.2004 and finally observed that since there was no valid service of notice, so, the A.O. does not get the jurisdiction to make the assessment. Being aggrieved, the department has filed the present appeal.

    6. With this background, Sri Prashant Kumar, learned counsel for the department submits that Sri O. P. Nehru, who received the notice, which was issued under section 148 dated 25.02.2004, at the assessee's premises was the legal officer of the assessee company and earlier, on several occasions, had received the different notices issued by the department. Being legally well versed person and considering the past record that all the notices received by him were complied with, the said person may be considered as having implied authority to receive notice. In case, had he denied or refused to receive the notice, the department had adequate time to get it served by any other alternative modes. But the objection to this effect was only raised by filing M.A. before the Tribunal.

    7. He also submits that ITAT has ignored that service of notice on Sri O. P. Nehru for assessment year 1999-2000 was sufficient under the provisions of the Order 29 Rule 2 of CPC. One of the modes of service prescribed by Order 29 Rule 2 is that summons may be served by leaving/pasting at the registered office of the assessee company. The service could be affected by merely leaving the notice at the registered office of the assessee. In the instant case, even if Sri Nehru was not authorized to receive the notice, the service is valid as he does not dispute that notice was not served on him at the registered office of the assessee i.e. the principal place of the business of the assessee company. He further submits that the acknowledgment of Sri O. P. Nehru with regard to delivery of notice at the said place is sufficient as the notice was delivered at the proper place and it will be deemed that the service of notice on the assessee was complete, proper and lawful under the provisions of the Order 29 Rule 2 CPC and it is not open to the assessee company to challenge the validity of the service.

    8. He also submits that in the present case, the notice was delivered at the registered office of the assessee company and this fact has been acknowledged by Sri Nehru under his signature. Thus, service of notice was valid under Order 29 Rule 2 of CPC. It is also a submission of learned counsel that the learned Tribunal has wrongly recalled its order dated 26.10.2007. In the appeal, the direction to the AO was issued to pass a fresh order in the light of the order passed by the Commissioner, Central Excise.

    9. Learned counsel for the petitioner in support of his arguments has relied on ratio laid down in the following cases:

  • 1. Y. Rajendra, Dy. CIT v. Khoday Eshwarsa & Sons [2005] 272 ITR 448/144 Taxman 629 (Kar); and
  • 2. Sohan Singh Basi v. Inspecting Asstt. CWT [1992] 194 ITR 339 (Delhi).
  • 10. On the other hand, Sri S. K. Garg, learned counsel for the assessee has justified the impugned order passed by the Tribunal. He submits that the assessee had raised the objection to the validity of the initiation of the proceedings under section 148, by virtue of notice (by the Assessing Officer) dated 25.02.2004 pertaining to the service of the notice. He submits that when the A.O. has not decided the objection, then the issue was raised before the CIT (A), who too rejected the same.

    11. Another fact, which remained undisputed is that the notice under section 148 dated 25.02.2004 was not served through post but through process server on one Sri O. P. Nehru, who was neither the Principal Officer of the assessee company nor had the authority to receive such notice. Even Sri Dinesh Singh whose Power of Attorney was filed, came on the scene only after the notice under section 143 (2) dated 30.06.2004 was served on him. At the time of service of notice, on 10.03.2004 Sri Dinesh Singh had no authority to receive such notice.

    12. On specific query from the Bench, he admits that Sri Dinesh Singh is a Chartered Accountant and representing the assessee company on earlier occasions. In support of his submission, he relied on the ratio laid down in the assessee's case Harsingar Gutkha (P.) Ltd. v. CIT [2011] 336 ITR 90/[2012] 20 taxmannn.com 713 (All.) , where it was observed that :

    "The notice under section 143 (2) was served on the chartered accountant in the business premises of the assessee. The Tribunal should examine the material on record and give a basis for coming to the conclusion that the chartered accountant possessed requisite authority to receive the notice. The Tribunal had not considered Order V Rule 12 of the Code which contemplates the service of summons. Moreover, the assessee had not disputed the service of notice before the assessing authority and had raised the issue for the first time before the Commissioner (Appeals). The Commissioner (Appeals) had observed that no reason had been given for not taking the ground before the Assessing Officer. The assessee had also not formulated any ground of appeal to challenge the validity of the assessment on account of want of proper service on the assessee. The Tribunal had not considered the aforesaid findings of the Commissioner (Appeals). The Tribunal had to consider these matters."

    13. It is also a submission of the learned counsel for the assessee that in the case of Laxmi Narain Anand Prakash v. CST [1980] 46 STC 71 (All.) it was observed that :

    "The word, 'after issuing' in section 21 mean the entire process of sending the notice and serving it. It cannot, therefore, be said that mere issue of notice is sufficient. Service of a notice for the purpose of initiating proceedings under Section 21 is not a mere procedural requirement but is a condition precedent. If no notice is issued or the notice issued is shown to be invalid or no notice has been served on the dealer, the proceedings and the consequential order under Section 21 will be illegal and void irrespective of the fact that the dealer gets knowledge of the proceedings under section 21."

    14. It is submitted by the learned counsel of the assessee that the valid notice for reassessment is condition precedent as per the ratio laid down in the following cases:

  • 1. CIT v. Shital Prasad Kharag Prasad [2006] 280 ITR 541/[2005] 147 Taxman 441 (All).
  • 2. Addl. Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Lucknow v. Prem Kumar Rastogi. [1980] 124 ITR 381 (All.)
  • 15. Lastly, the learned counsel submits that no error has been committed by the Tribunal and the appeal filed by the revenue deserves to be dismissed.

    16. We have heard both the parties at length and gone through the material available on record.

    17. From the record, it appears that Sri O. P. Nehru has received the notice on 25.02.2004 at the assessee's premises and he was the legal officer of the assessee company and on earlier occasions, he has received the notices from the department. Similarly, Sri Dinesh Singh, who is the Chartered Accountant of the company has represented the assessee on many occasions. A notice was served at the registered office of the assessee company. The server of the department has served the notice in good faith and now by raising the technical ground, the assessment order cannot be set aside specially when the assessee has already voluntarily participated in the appellate proceedings.

    18. Inspiration may be drawn from the Section 292 BB, though the same is not applicable during the assessment year under consideration but the fact remains that the assessee has participated voluntarily in the appellate proceedings.

    19. In the case of Sohan Singh Basi (supra), it was observed that :

    "Where, pursuant to receipt of notice by a chartered accountant, the assessee files a return of wealth and raises no objection before the wealth - tax authorities to the effect that the chartered accountant had no authority to accept notice, it is difficult for the court to believe that such a chartered accountant would accept a reassessment notice under section 17 of the Wealth Tax Act,1957, without his being authorized to do so.

    The petitioner filed a writ petition challenging a notice of reassessment under section 17 of the Wealth Tax Act, 1975 and the court found that the petitioner was guilty of mis stating of facts deliberately.

    Held, that the conduct of the petitioner was such that equitable relief under article 226 of the Constitution could not be granted to him."

    20. In the instant case, the assessee is a company whose employees/consultant are the Members of the family. Thus, service of notice is sufficient as per the ratio laid down in the case of Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Smt. Kanti Devi Gupta [2005] 274 ITR 526/[2006] 156 Taxman 77 (MP) .

    21. The assessee has participated voluntarily and peacefully in the appellate proceedings. Participation is sufficient for the validity of the notice, as per the ratio laid down in the case of CIT v. Uttam Chand Nahar [2007] 295 ITR 403 (Raj) .

    22. In the case of K.J. Thomos v. CIT [2008] 303 ITR 301 (Ker.); it was observed that no notice under section 143 (2) was received but opportunity was availed, then reassessment is valid. Similar views were expressed in the case of CIT v. T.C.P. Ltd. [2010] 323 ITR 346 (Mad.)

    23. Further, in any technical difficulty, the proceeding may be irregular but not invalid. The procedural irregularity can be rectified later as per the ratio laid down in the case of Areva T. & D. India v. Asstt. CIT [2007] 294 ITR 233/165 Taxman 123 (Mad) .

    24. In the instant case, the procedural irregularity was automatically rectified when the assessee is participated in the appellate proceedings.

    25. Thus, in the light of above discussion, we set aside the impugned order dated 01.11.2010 passed in MA 131/Luc/2008 by the Tribunal and remanded the matter back to the A.O. as directed by the Tribunal vide order dated 26.10.2007 to decide the matter strictly on merit at the earliest preferably within a period of three months.

    26. The answer to the substantial question of law is in favour of the revenue and against the assessee.

    27. In the result, the appeal filed by the department is allowed.

    S.K.J.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Commissioner of Income-tax v. Harsingar Gutkha (P.) Ltd.
    (Oct 25, 2013)