AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judicial Opinion (I.P. Mukerji, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The matter is an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 against an order dismissing an application under Section 34 challenging an arbitral award. The parties entered into an agreement dated 1 April 2005 which recorded an admission by the appellant that it owed Rs. 65,00,000 to the respondent. The agreement provided that the appellant would supply green tea leaves of specified quality and that payment for such supplies would be made weekly by the respondent after deduction of Re. 1 per kg as partial repayment of the outstanding loan. Minimum quantities to be supplied over specified periods were set out in the agreement, with alternative provisions for low production, and provision for return of the outstanding amount with interest in default.

Disputes arose about whether the appellant repaid the loan by supplying green tea leaves. The appellant alleged it supplied 11,35,327 kgs of green tea leaves, valued at Rs. 90,82,616 at Rs. 8 per kg, which not only repaid the Rs. 65 lakhs loan but left Rs. 25,82,616 payable by the respondent. The respondent contended that it did not receive supplies from the appellant, that the 11,35,327 kgs were received from Shankar Traders under an independent contract (and paid for by the respondent), and that Rs. 1,04,09,197 was due (comprising principal, part interest and further interest). The respondent also initiated proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 in respect of a cheque for Rs. 71,50,000 tendered by the appellant which was dishonoured for insufficiency of funds.

Because the contractual arbitration mechanism did not work, on an application under Section 11 this Court appointed Mr. Bhaskar Sen as sole arbitrator on 31 March 2010. The arbitrator conducted the reference (41 sittings from 30 April 2010 to 24 November 2013) and published an award on 4 July 2014 holding that the appellant had not discharged the liability of Rs. 65 lakhs and awarding Rs. 65 lakhs with 12% interest per annum from 1 April 2005 to date of award in favour of the claimant (respondent in the present appeal). The appellant challenged the award under Section 34 (AP No. 1677 of 2014); a learned Single Judge dismissed that challenge on 26 June 2015. This appeal under Section 37 followed. Amrita Sinha, J. concurred with the judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant had, in fact, supplied 11,35,327 kgs of green tea leaves such that the admitted debt of Rs. 65 lakhs was repaid and an additional sum became payable by the respondent.
  2. Whether the cheque for Rs. 71,50,000 dated 11 January 2007 was forged or genuine, and the implications of its genuineness for admission of liability by the appellant.
  3. Whether the arbitral award dated 4 July 2014 should be set aside under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 — in particular on grounds of conflict with public policy of India, patent illegality, perversity, or taking into account/disregarding material evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant asserted that it repaid the loan by supplying green tea leaves in the quantity of 11,35,327 kgs between March 2005 and October 2005, valued at Rs. 90,82,616 (at Rs. 8 per kg). On this account, the admitted debt of Rs. 65 lakhs was wiped out and a further amount (around Rs. 25,82,616) became payable by the respondent.
  • Implicit in the factual position was a challenge to the respondent's account that the respondent had purchased and paid for those quantities from a third party. (The opinion records the appellant's positive claim of supply and resulting credit against the loan.)

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent maintained that the appellant did not supply any green tea leaves and thus did not repay any part of the loan. The respondent claimed that 11,35,327 kgs received during March–October 2005 were supplied by Shankar Traders under an independent contract and that the respondent paid Shankar Traders for that supply.
  • The respondent relied on documentary evidence (challans, weighment receipts, bills, invoices and payment records) to prove receipt of the supplies from Shankar Traders and payment to them.
  • The respondent initiated prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 for dishonour of the cheque of Rs. 71,50,000 purportedly drawn by the appellant.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd. ((2003) 5 SCC 705) Interpreted the arbitrator's duty to decide domestic arbitrations in accordance with substantive law; departure could be viewed as patent illegality. The Court referred to this case when explaining the concept of patent illegality as a narrow ground to set aside an arbitral award and to consider whether any error of law appears on the face of the award.
Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority ((2015) 3 SCC 49) Held that an award based on assessment of facts can be set aside only if based on no evidence, in disregard of vital evidence, or if the finding is perverse to the extent of defying logic. The Court applied this principle to conclude that the learned arbitrator's factual findings were supported by evidence and were not perverse; therefore the award could not be set aside on re-appreciation of evidence.
K.P. Poulose v. State of Kerala ((1975) 2 SCC 236) Under the old 1940 Act, non-consideration of valuable documents by the arbitrator amounted to legal misconduct justifying setting aside an award. The case was cited as authority on misconduct under the old Act; the Court noted the historical position but observed that "misconduct" in that form is not a ground under the 1996 Act in the same terms. The ground was not invoked to set aside the present award.
Harbans Singh v. Sant Hari Singh ((2003) 8 SCC 168) Held that findings inconsistent with the ultimate award could amount to misconduct justifying setting aside. The Court noted this authority but observed that the expression "misconduct" is not used expressly in the 1996 Act as a standalone ground; it recognized the principle but did not find such misconduct in the present case.
Ravindra Kumar Gupta & Co. v. Union of India ((2010) 1 SCC 409) Held that the court could not substitute its own opinion for that of the arbitrator; the arbitrator is the ultimate master of the quantity and quality of evidence. The Court relied on this principle to refuse to re-appreciate evidence or substitute its own conclusions for those of the arbitrator where the arbitrator's view was plausible and supported by evidence.
Sutlej Construction Ltd. v. Union Territory of Chandigarh ((2018) 1 SCC 718) Recognized that an arbitrator is entitled to take a plausible view which may not be the only reasonable one. The Court invoked this authority to emphasize that the arbitrator's adoption of a plausible view (even if not the sole reasonable view) did not invalidate the award; it supported upholding the arbitrator's conclusions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first identified the narrow scope of challenge under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996: an arbitral award can only be set aside on limited grounds (including conflict with public policy, patent illegality, perversity, or disregard of vital evidence). The Court examined the issues determined by the arbitrator and the evidence presented to him.

Key factual issues before the arbitrator (and subsequently reviewed by the Court) were:

  • Whether the appellant supplied 11,35,327 kgs of green tea leaves to the respondent under the 1 April 2005 agreement such that the admitted debt of Rs. 65 lakhs was discharged and an additional sum became payable to the appellant; and
  • Whether the cheque for Rs. 71,50,000 dated 11 January 2007 was forged or genuine, the latter indicating admission of liability by the appellant.

The Court set out the factual findings of the arbitrator: the arbitrator found that the appellant had not proved that it supplied 11,35,327 kgs worth Rs. 90,82,616; the respondent had proved that the respondent purchased those quantities from Shankar Traders and paid Shankar Traders; and the appellant therefore had not discharged the admitted debt of Rs. 65 lakhs. The arbitrator also rejected the theory of fabrication of the cheque and treated the cheque as not being forged.

The Court analysed documentary and oral evidence as summarized by the arbitrator: the appellant could not produce weekly bills, invoices, challans or weighment slips that would be expected given the agreement's weekly payment arrangement; there was absence of correspondence evidencing demands for the amounts allegedly due on a weekly basis; and the respondent produced documents evidencing payment to Shankar Traders for the supplies. The Court considered that if the appellant had in fact made the supplies and been paid, its balance sheet would have reflected this, but the appellant failed to produce such account evidence.

Applying the legal standards laid down in the precedents, the Court emphasised that mere misappreciation of evidence or an error of judgment by the arbitrator does not permit setting aside an award. The Court examined whether the arbitrator's conclusions were perverse, without evidence, or in disregard of vital evidence; it found that the arbitrator's conclusions were supported by material and were a plausible evaluation of the facts. The Court further explained the narrowness of the patent illegality ground and noted the distinction between mis-declaration of law (which could be vulnerable) and mere misapplication or misappreciation (which would not). The award was thus not tainted by patent illegality, perversity or disregard of vital evidence.

Relying on the authorities cited, the Court concluded that the arbitrator had correctly evaluated the evidence and reached tenable conclusions. The Single Judge who dismissed the Section 34 challenge had applied similar reasoning; the appellate court agreed with that view.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The appeal is dismissed for lack of merit.

Implications and direct effects:

  • The arbitral award dated 4 July 2014, awarding Rs. 65,00,000 with interest at 12% per annum from 1 April 2005 until the date of the award in favour of the claimant (respondent), stands affirmed.
  • The learned Single Judge's dismissal (26 June 2015) of the Section 34 challenge is upheld by this Court.
  • There is no order as to costs.
  • The Court directed that certified photocopy of the order be supplied to the parties upon compliance with requisite formalities.
  • The judgment does not purport to lay down any new, general precedent beyond applying established principles on the narrow grounds for setting aside arbitral awards; the Court expressly treated the award as a well-reasoned and plausible evaluation of evidence rather than a decision establishing novel law.

Concurrence: Amrita Sinha, J. recorded her agreement with the judgment.

    Tonganagaon Tea Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Associated Tea Industries

    I.P Mukerji, J.:— This is an appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    2. An award was made by Mr. Bhaskar Sen, Bar at Law and Senior Advocate on 4th July, 2014. It was in relation to disputes between the parties that had arisen out of their agreement dated 1st April, 2005. It contained an arbitration clause which is as follows:

    “In case of any dispute arising relating to this agreement the same shall be referred to arbitration of O.P Jhunjhunwalla, Solicitor & Advocate, whose decision shall be binding on both the parties.”

    3. It appears that the mechanism provided in that clause did not work. On an application under Section 11 of the said Act, on 31 March, 2010, this Court appointed Mr. Sen as the sole arbitrator.

    4. His award of 4 July, 2014 was challenged before this Court in an application under Section 34 of the said Act. On 26 June, 2015 a learned Single Judge of this Court dismissed the application.

    5. Hence this appeal.

    6. The appellant is the owner of a tea garden by the name of “Tonganagaon”.

    7. On 1 April, 2005 an agreement was executed between the parties. A very special feature of this agreement was that the admission of the appellant that they owed Rs. 65 lakhs to the respondent was recorded therein. The appellant was to supply green tea leaves of specified “fine percentage”. The payment for these items would be made by the respondent on a weekly basis after deduction of Re. 1/- per kg., from April, 2005. This would be only partial repayment of the outstanding loan of the appellant. The minimum quantity of green tea leaves to be supplied by the appellant was 15 lakh kgs. at the prevailing market price between March, 2005 and December, 2005, March, 2006 to December, 2006, March, 2007 to December, 2007 and 20 lakh kgs. of the same tea for the period of March, 2008 to December, 2008. In case of low production alternative provisions were made. In default, the appellant was required to return the outstanding amount with interest as provided in the agreement.

    8. According to the appellant, they were repaying this loan by supply of tea to the respondent. The tea was not paid for by the respondent. They alleged that they had supplied a total quantity of 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves. Its value was, at the prevailing market rate of Rs. 8/- per kg., Rs. 90,82,616/-. Not only the loan advanced by the appellant stood repaid, Rs. 25,82,616/- became payable by the respondent.

    9. According to the respondent, the appellant neither supplied any green tea leaves nor repaid any part of the loan. As a result of this, Rs. 71,50,000/- was due and outstanding on account of principal and part interest and Rs. 32,59,197/- on account of further interest as on the date of filing of the Statement of Claim, the total claim aggregating to Rs. 1,04,09,197/-. The appellant on 10 January, 2007 purported to make payment of this sum of Rs. 71,50,000/- by a cheque drawn on Union Bank of India, Tinsukia Branch. It was dishonoured for insufficiency of funds.

    10. The respondent's case was during March, 2005 to October, 2005, it did receive 11,35,327 kgs. of green leaves but not from the appellant. They received it from one Shankar Traders under an independent contract. They paid Shankar Traders for this supply.

    11. Meanwhile, the respondent initiated proceedings against the appellant under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, 1882 in respect of the dishonour of the said cheque.

    12. On this dispute the parties went to arbitration.

    13. The learned arbitrator entered upon the reference on 30 April, 2010. 41 sittings were held. The arbitration ended on 24 November, 2013. The award was made and published on 4 July, 2014.

    14. The learned arbitrator passed the following award:

    “I also hold that the respondent has not been able to prove that they had supplied 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves for the value of Rs. 90,82,616/- to the claimant. I do not find any material to hold that the respondent had discharged its liability towards the claim of Rs. 65 Lacs.

    I, accordingly, hold that the sum of Rs. 65 Lacs, is due from the respondent to the claimant as on 1 April, 2005. The claimant is also entitled to interest on the said amount at the rate of 12% per annum from the date of the second agreement i.e 1.4.2005 till the date of the Award.

    I, accordingly, award a sum of Rs. 65 Lacs together with interest thereon at the rate of 12% per annum from 1.4.2005 till the date of the award in favour of the claimant to be paid by the respondent to the claimant. The parties shall bear their respective cost of arbitration proceedings.

    In compliance with the provisions of Section 31 of the Act, it is recorded that the arbitration proceedings were held at the precincts of the Calcutta High Court Bar Library Club and Floatel and the same had commenced on 30 April, 2010.”

    15. Now, it is important to determine the issues that were before the learned arbitrator. That the appellant owed a sum of Rs. 65 lakhs to the respondent was more or less admitted. The issue was whether 11,35,327 kgs of green tea leaves worth Rs. 90,82,616/- were supplied by Shankar Traders, under an independent contract with the respondent and paid for by them or whether this quantity was supplied by the appellant? After this supply, according to the appellant not only the above debt was repaid but a sum in the region of Rs. 25,82,616/- became due and payable by the respondent to the appellant. The other issue which was before the learned arbitrator was whether the cheque for Rs. 71,50,000/- dated 11 January, 2007 was a forged document? If it was proved to be genuine, then it straightaway indicated admission of liability by the appellant. A somewhat special feature of the disputes between the parties in this case is like this. There is a twist in the tale when admittedly 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves were received by the respondent during the subject contract period from March, 2005 to October, 2005 as alleged. But this supply did not come from the appellant but was made by Shankar Traders under an allegedly independent contract. The supply was from the garden of the appellant.

    16. Two or three things appeared to be rather unusual to the learned arbitrator and in my opinion, rightly so. The appellant was in financial difficulty but nevertheless made supply of Rs. 90,82,616/- worth of tea leaves. So much was the supply made that not only the appellant's debt of Rs. 65 lakhs to the respondent was wiped out, but they would get Rs. 25,82,616/- from the respondent.

    17. An important term of the agreement was that the appellant would receive weekly payment. But astonishingly, no bill or weighment slip was produced by them to show that any demand was made to the respondent for Rs. 90,82,616/- or any part thereof.

    18. Furthermore, when the payment terms were weekly, why was the appellant not able to produce a single invoice, challan to substantiate delivery of goods by them (not Shankar traders)?

    19. The version of the respondent was that this entire 11,35,327 kgs. of tea was supplied by an organization, Shankar Traders. The respondent claimed to have paid Rs. 90,82,616/- to Shankar Traders which was supported by documents. The learned arbitrator noted that if the appellant had really made the supply, then the balance sheet of the appellant would have shown the supply and adjustment of the debt of the appellant. The appellant had not been able to prove the supply of 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves by themselves. On the other hand, the respondent was able to prove all the documents evidencing sale of green tea leaves, by Shankar Traders to them and for the supply by them.

    20. The appellant, aggrieved by this award preferred an application under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 to challenge the award, numbered as AP No. 1677 of 2014.

    21. On 26 June, 2015 this application was dismissed.

    22. The learned Single Judge came to inter alia the following findings:

    “6. The arbitrator has recorded the rival cases of the parties and referred to the oral evidence adduced in course of the reference. The key questions put to the claimant's witness in cross-examination have been reproduced in the award. The arbitrator has understood the claimant's witness to have said that certain supplies may have been effected during the period March to October, 2005 from the petitioner's tea garden, but such tea was purchased by the respondent from one Shankar Traders; and, the supply was neither made by the petitioner herein nor was it in discharge of the petitioner's obligation under the agreement of April 1, 2005. What is evident from the award and appears clearly therefrom is that in response to the petitioner's assertion that green tea leaves were supplied from its garden to the respondent between March and October 2005, the respondent's witness acknowledged that some of the tea received by the respondent may have been the produce of the petitioner's garden but such tea had been supplied by the petitioner herein to Shankar Traders and Shankar Traders, in turn, sold it to the respondent. The arbitrator agreed with the witness that if the respondent had to purchase the tea, notwithstanding it being produced in the petitioner's garden, from Shankar Traders, such supply could not be in discharge of the petitioner's debt to the respondent……………………..On the state of the facts and the evidence before the arbitrator, it was apparent that the debt due from the petitioner to the respondent had not been demonstrated by the petitioner to have been discharged.

    10. There is no infirmity in the inference drawn by the arbitrator from the material before him. Indeed, it may have been the only conclusion possible on the basis of the evidence adduced in course of the reference. At any rate, even if the arbitrator inferred incorrectly or made a mistake, it was a mistake within the jurisdiction of the arbitrator and not an error of jurisdiction.”

    23. The ground for any possible challenge to the award was indeed very narrow. It was an admitted position that Rs. 65 lakhs was advanced by the respondent to the appellant. It was admitted as due and owing by them to the respondent. The only subject matter of challenge could be the correctness of analysis, appreciation and interpretation of the learned arbitrator of the evidence produced before him, reflected by the findings reached by him.

    24. If on the basis of the said admitted outstanding sum of Rs. 65 lakhs the respondent claimed an award by the ordinary rules of evidence, the onus was on the appellant to show how that money had been repaid. The method of repayment of that loan was contained in the agreement dated 1 April, 2005 itself. Green tea leaves were to be supplied by the appellant to the respondent on a regular frequency against weekly bills. The bills would be paid after deduction of Re. 1/- per kg. This Re. 1/- per kg. would be the part repayment by the appellant of this loan. The appellant claimed that it had supplied so much green tea that the price receivable by them for the above supply after wiping out the debt of Rs. 65 lakhs was Rs. 25,82,616/-. Astonishingly, they could not produce any bills/invoice claiming payment of the money they were to receive weekly according to the agreement of 1 April, 2005. If the terms were for weekly payment, in ordinary course of things there would have been some correspondence on record demanding this amount. There was none. The respondent's case was that during March, 2005 to October, 2005 it received 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves not from the appellant but from Shankar Traders whom they have duly paid. They had been able to prove before the learned arbitrator the factum of supply by Shankar Traders and receipt of payment by them from the respondent. Therefore, it was amply clear that this quantity of 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves did not aid in adjusting the said loan of Rs. 65 lakhs. Moreover, the respondent had been able to establish that this 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves came from an outside source and were duly paid for by them. Had there been any strength in the case of the appellant that tea leaves were procured from Shankar Traders, they would have surely called someone from Shankar Traders as witness to demonstrate that they were supplying tea in fulfilment of the agreement dated 1 April, 2005. After a thorough analysis of the oral evidence, the documentary evidence in the shape of challans, weighment receipts, bills, invoices, the learned arbitrator came to the conclusion that:

    “In this backdrop, I can only hold that respondent has not discharged their onus and has not been able to prove that they had supplied 11,35,327 kg. green tea leaves to the claimant under the agreement dated 1.4.2005 of a sum of Rs. 90,82,616/-. Thus, the admitted liability of the respondent to the extent of Rs. 65 Lacs which was there at the time of entering into the contract of 1.4.2005, remains due and payable by the respondent to the claimant.

    I also hold that the respondent has not been able to prove that they had supplied 11,35,327 kgs. of green tea leaves for the value of Rs. 90,82,616/- to the claimant. I do not find any material to hold that the respondent had discharged its liability towards the claim of Rs. 65 Lacs.”

    25. The grounds on which an arbitral award can be set aside are very limited. In the situation at hand, the arbitral award could only be vulnerable if it was in conflict with the public policy of India. [Sec. 34(b)(ii)]. Two explanations were added to explain what was against the public policy of India, to introduce, inter alia, awards which were in contravention with the fundamental policy of Indian law or was in conflict with the basic notions of morality or justice.

    26. Then again an award could be set aside if it was patently illegal. In Oil & Natural Gas Corporation Ltd. v. Saw Pipes Ltd. reported in (2003) 5 SCC 705 followed in Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority reported in (2015) 3 SCC 49, the Supreme Court interpreted the requirement of Section 28 of the said Act imposing a duty on the arbitrator to decide domestic arbitrations in accordance with the substantive law for the time being in force in India and if there was departure from this, it could be viewed as a patent illegality calling for rescission of the award. However, the proviso to Sub-section 2A of Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 clarifies that the patent illegality should appear on the face of the award. Furthermore, the erroneous application of the law or failure to appreciate evidence shall not be a ground for setting aside of the award. Sub-section 2A was introduced by an amendment with effect from 23rd October, 2015. This award was made on 4 July, 2014. Nevertheless, this amendment is to be taken as declaratory or clarificatory and to be a declaration of the intention of the parliament from the time of enactment of the original section. Applying ordinary principles, an error of law on the face of the record would imply some premises of law on which the arbitrator has proceeded and which premises is absolutely erroneous. In my opinion, any mis-appreciation of the law or misapplication of it in the body of the award would not render the award liable to be set aside but any mis-declaration of the law would have this effect.

    27. Learned Counsel for the parties took the help of various authorities either to support or oppose the award. In K.P Poulose v. State of Kerala reported in (1975) 2 SCC 236 the Supreme Court was dealing with an award under the old Act of 1940 which did not tolerate misconduct of the arbitral proceedings by an arbitrator. Non-consideration of valuable documents by the arbitrator, amounted to legal misconduct for which the award was set aside.

    28. In Harbans Singh v. Sant Hari Singh reported in (2003) 8 SCC 168 the Supreme Court opined that if any finding of the learned Arbitrator was inconsistent with the ultimate award it amounted to misconduct, calling for setting aside of the award. In that case, the first respondent had been granted damages suggesting breach of contract. Thereafter, grant of damages to the appellant could not be sustained. I do not know why these two cases were cited at the bar. Misconduct of the arbitrator or the proceedings was one of the grounds to set aside the award under the Arbitration Act, 1940. This ground is not taken to challenge the award in question. The expression “misconduct” is not used in the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 as one of the grounds to challenge the award. Certain acts of misconduct by the arbitrator in conducting himself or the proceedings have been recognized in Section 34 as grounds to challenge the award.

    29. In Associate Builders v. Delhi Development Authority reported in (2015) 3 SCC 49 the Supreme Court ruled that an award based on assessment of facts could only be set aside if it was based on no evidence or in disregard of vital evidence or had taken into account something irrelevant. The finding had to outrageously defy logic. Otherwise, the arbitrator was the ultimate master of the quantity and quality of evidence. An award which did not measure up in quality to a trained legal mind could not be held to be invalid unless it was found to be arbitrary or capricious. In other words, the findings or the ultimate award had to be perverse. The award had to be so bad so as to shock the conscience of the Court.

    30. Hence, an award could not be set aside on mere re-appreciation of the evidence led by the parties. The court could not substitute its own opinion in place of the finding of the learned arbitrator, as pronounced by the Supreme Court in Ravindra Kumar Gupta and Company v. Union of India reported in (2010) 1 SCC 409.

    31. The arbitrator was entitled to take a plausible view which may or may not be the only reasonable view of the matter as held by the Supreme Court in Sutlej Construction Limited v. Union Territory of Chandigarh reported in (2018) 1 SCC 718.

    32. In this case, the learned arbitrator rightly decided that Rs. 65 lakhs was admittedly taken by the appellant from the respondent. A cheque of the said amount together with interest was sought to be tendered by the debtor to the creditor which was dishonoured for insufficiency of funds. He rightly rejected the theory of fabrication of the cheque.

    33. The learned arbitrator rightly inferred that if under the agreement dated 1 April, 2005 the appellant had supplied tea, it would have surely raised weekly bills. No such bills could be produced by the appellant which suggested that no supply had been made. Hence, there was no question of adjustment of the loan @ Re. 1/- per kg. of tea sold on the basis of challans, bills, lorry weighment certificates etc. produced by him. The learned arbitrator had very rightly come to the conclusion that 11,36,729 kgs. of tea were purchased by the respondent from Shankar Traders and were paid for by them under an independent contract. It follows that the learned arbitrator had very rightly rejected the counter claim of the appellant that 11,36,729 kgs. of tea were supplied by them to the respondent, after which not only Rs. 65 lakhs loan was wiped out, but a sum of Rs. 25,82,616/- became due and payable by the respondent to the appellant.

    34. In my opinion, the learned arbitrator has correctly evaluated the relevant evidence and come to the right conclusion. There is no element of perversity involved in the finding of the learned arbitrator. On the contrary, it is a very well reasoned award.

    35. The learned Judge hearing the Section 34 application had also taken the same view. Or rather, I take the same view as the learned Single Judge.

    36. In those circumstances, there is no merit in the appeal. The same is dismissed. No order as to costs.

    37. Certified photocopy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance with all requisite formalities.

    Amrita Sinha, J.:— I agree.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Tonganagaon Tea Co. Pvt. Ltd. v. Associated Tea Industries
    (Feb 22, 2019)