Present: Joseph Mathew, Member: This petition is filed under Section 12 of Consumer Protection Act, 1986.
The petitioner is residing at Muthukad, Chakkittapara Village. His case is that, he had started construction of a residential building during the month April 2004. Due to crucial financial crisis he could not continue the construction works and so he approached the 2 opposite party for and housing loan and subject to terms and conditions the 2 opposite party sanctioned a loan fornd Rs.75,000/- and paid Rs.15,000/- as the 1 installment on 02/06/2005. While applying for thest loan the 2 opposite party instructed to insure the house as a pre-condition for obtaining loan. Asnd directed by the 2 opposite party, he approached the 1 opposite party for insuring thend st constructing house and requested them to inspect the site. As such the officials of the 1 oppositest party inspected the house and construction works, and issued a policy jointly in his and the 2 nd opposite partys name on 15/06/2005 under the Standard Fire and Special Perils Policy after receiving Rs.1,446/- as premium amount. With the financial aid of the 2 opposite party he hadnd completed the concrete works of the house during the month of September, 2005.
The petitioner sated that while so on 14/09/2005 at about 8pm night on account of a heavy rain and storm his house collapsed completely. This caused a financial loss to the tune of Rs.2,50,000/- to him. This fact was reported to the 1 opposite party on the very next day itself, but they arest reluctant in taking steps for allowing his claim or granting compensation. on 31/03/2006, they intimated him through a registered letter that they could not allow his claim as the proposal submitted and the policy issued was for a residential building and not for a building under construction and hence rejected his claim. Though he had issued a lawyer notice dated 28/11/2006 requesting them to settle his claim, they denied his request through their reply to that lawyer notice dated 30/11/2006.
The petitioner further stated that from 15/06/2005 onwards this building was under the coverage of the policy of the 1 opposite party and before issuing the policy the officials of the oppositest party came to the site and inspected the construction works and so the allegation of the opposite party that the policy was issued for a pucca residential building is baseless and against the facts also. As he was unaware of different types of policies and regarding the policy suitable for his constructing house, he had explained his need to the officials of the 1 opposite party who hadst visited the site and relied upon the skill and expertise of the official of the opposite party in selecting the suitable policy and determining the premium amount. The proposal form was filled by the agent of the 1 opposite party and he had only signed the form. He had no role in thest selection of the policy or determining the premium amount. It is further stated that for completing the construction work of his house he had availed loan from the 2 opposite party and only asnd per their direction he had applied for the policy coverage and the policy issued was not in his name alone but jointly at his and the 2 opposite partys name, and from this itself it is clear thatnd the policy was not taken for a pucca residential building as alleged but for a house under construction. Moreover as the construction was not completed, no house number was allotted to this building from the authorities and no house number was given on the proposal from also. Now the opposite party is feigning ignorance of all these facts only to evade from their liability and to deny payment.
After intimation of the incident, the surveyor of the 1 opposite party visited the premise andst after collecting all the documents from him and after enquiry to the neighbors had prepared a detailed report regarding the volume of loss sustained to him and submitted the report before the opposite party. After having done all these things, the denial of his genuine claim is against the principles of insurance law and amounts to unfair trade practice and also deficiency in service on the part of the opposite party. This caused much mental pain, huge financial loss and other difficulties to him. Hence this petition is filed to direct the 1 opposite party to allow his claimst and pay him the assured amount of Rs.2,50,000/- and Rs.20,000/- as compensation for his mental pain and other sufferings and also cost of the proceedings.
The 1 opposite party in their version contended that the petitioner is not a consumer as definedst under the Sections of Consumer Protection Act and hence he has no locus-standi to file this petition and hence this petition is not maintainable. They admitted that the petitioner had availed the Standard Fire and Special Perils Policy from them covering the period from 15/06/2005 to 14/06/2006 on payment of Rs.1,446/- as premium amount. It is also admitted that, he had taken the policy through District Co-operative Bank, Perambra branch, Kozhikode as they are the financier of the said policy. The risks covered under the policy includes storm among other perils subject to the terms, conditions and exclusions of the policy. But it is stated that in the proposal form signed by the petitioner, it is specifically mentioned that the property proposed for the insurance is a building of pucca construction and occupied as residence and hence they have issued the policy covering the risks for a residential building. The statement of the petitioner that he had availed the insurance for a house under construction and that their officers had conducted a site inspection of the house under construction before issuance of the policy and that he had depended on the expertise of them in availing the policy etc. are denied by the opposite party as not true or correct and stated that being a public sector company they are issuing policies on good faith believing the details given in the proposal form submitted by the insured and they have no role in choosing the type of policy by the insured.
The opposite party also admitted that the petitioner had submitted a claim intimation dated 19/09/2005 before them intimating the fact of collapse of his house on 14/09/2005 at about 8 pm night on account of heavy rain and wind and requesting to do the needful at the earliest and thereafter a claim dated 24/10/2005 was submitted by the Manager, KDC Bank. On receipt of the claim they appointed Mr. M. Raghavan, the investigator, to conduct an initial investigation into this matter. He had taken the statements of the petitioner, his wife Mrs. Sudha and also the concrete worker Mr. Mohanan and filed a report before them. Thereafter for assessing the loss, Mr. Madhu Aeran, the surveyor and loss assessor was appointed. He had inspected the collapsed residential house of the petitioner first time on 20/09/2005 and subsequently on 03/10/2005 and 29/10/2055 and after detailed investigation and taking photographs from different angles submitted his report dated 04/02/2006. As per the report the construction work of the said building was completed stage by stage ranging from the year 2000 to 2005. It is further reported that according to the insured the foundation as well as the basement was done with R.R.Mansory in mud mortar, however in the estimate submitted by him before the bank it is shown that the foundation and basement was in R.R. Mansory in cement mortar 1:6 mix. It is also reported that, the super structure wall and also RCC work of the front veranda slab and the porch slab and also beams and lintels were completely collapsed. He had also recorded the statement of the petitioner and the Branch Manager, KDC Bank, Perambera and obtained certificates from the Village Officer, Chakkittapara, S.I. of Police, Peruvannamuzhy and original plan and estimate of the collapsed building from KDC Bank. As per the reports of the Village Officer, S.I. of Police and of the Bank Manager, the collapse of the building was on account of the heavy wind and rain on 14/09/2005.
It is further contended that, the expert surveyor could not find any evidence of such a large scale storm capable of causing such havoc as alleged. Hence he obtained a report from the India Meteorological Department in respect of the weather condition on the crucial day of 14/09/2005.
As per the said report the surface wind speed at the locality where the petitioners building situated was 5 to 10 kmph on 14/09/2005 and there was showering of rain accompanied by strong winds occasionally reaching 45 kmph. So according to the expert surveyor the wind of the said magnitude cannot normally lead to collapse of any structure. Hence the surveyor ruled out the allegation that the collapse of the building was on account of the alleged rain and wind as false and baseless. So he concluded that the collapse of the building will not come within the purview of insured peril storm as envisaged under the policy condition and finally he concluded that the cause of collapse of the said build was due to the poor quality of materials used for the construction, poor workmanship and the long duration taken for constructing the building.
Anyhow after a detailed assessment the surveyor estimated the actual loss as Rs.1,22,964/-. It is stated that the petitioner has suppressed the material fact that the building which he was insuring was a building under construction instead it was mentioned in the proposal form that the building is a pucca construction and occupied as residence. The fact of repudiation and its reasons were intimated to the petitioner vide a letter dated 31/03/2006. The lawyer notice was duly replied stating all the true and correct facts. Since the claim was repudiated on valid and legal grounds, no deficiency could be attributed against them. The petitioner is not entitled to get any of the reliefs sought for in the petition and hence prayed to dismiss the petition with compensatory cost.
The 2 opposite party in their version admitted that the petitioner had approached them for and housing loan for Rs.75,000/- and they had directed him to avail insurance policy as pre-condition for obtaining the loan. It is contended that no deficiency in service is attributed against them by the petitioner and no reliefs has been sought for against them in the petition and hence they are unnecessary party to this petition and so prayed to delete them from the opposite party array with cost.
:-The points for determinations are Whether there is any deficiency in service on the part of the opposite parties? Reliefs and costs if any? Evidence consists of the affidavits filed by the petitioner, the witness of the petitioner, Ext.s A1 to A9, B1 to B8 series and testimonies of PW1, PW2 and RW1.
There is no dispute with regard to the coverage of policy. There is also no disputePoint No. 1: regarding the collapse of the disputed building. According to the opposite party one of the ground for the rejection of the petitioners claim is that there is suppression of material facts. According to them the proposal submitted was for a pucca residential building and based in this proposal they have issued the policy for a residential building with at most good faith. But the claim was made for the collapse of a building under construction and such a building was not covered by the said policy. They produced the proposal form submitted by the petitioner and was marked as Ext. B1.
In Ext. B1 it is written that the property proposed for insurance is a pucca residence. But it is to be noted here that in the place of Door No. in the proposal form it is seen written as unsurveyed.
Every residential house should have a house number allotted by the concerned authority. The lack of house number in Ext. B1 clearly shows that the said building proposed for the policy was not a residential building as stated by the opposite party. Why they have issued the policy to a residential building without building number is not explained by the opposite party also. The specific case of the petitioner is that he took the policy for the house under construction was only as a pre-condition for obtaining a housing loan from the 2 opposite party bank as per theirnd direction. He produced the copy of the policy and was marked as Ext. A4. Ext. A4 shows that the said policy was issued in the name of the petitioner as well as in the name of the bank also. In cross PW1, the petitioner, would say that, he had approached the 1 opposite party with thest letter given by the 2 opposite party bank and requested to the 1 opposite party to inspect thend st (Page 2-PW1). Insite and within 2 days the officers of the 1 opposite party had visited the site. st the petition the petitioner made it clear that he was unaware of the different types of policies and the policy which is suitable for the building under construction and hence he took the said policy only on the advice of the 1 opposite party and relying on the skill and expertise of the officers ofst the 1 opposite party in this field. It is also stated that the proposal form was not filled by him,st but it was filled by the agent of the 1 opposite party and he had only signed the form and thest premium amount was also determined by the 1 opposite party. The opposite party has notst adduced any evidence or examined anybody from their side to rebut the above said averment of the petitioner. Moreover one cannot believe that as a layman, the petitioner himself had filled the proposal form using the words like knowing very well that hisPucca Residential building house is under construction. So the facts stated above would lead us to the conclusion that, the said form was filled by the agent of the 1 opposite party as stated by the petitioner and that if thest policy issued vide Ext. A4 does not cover the risk of the petitioner house under construction it is the fault on the part of the opposite partys agent who had filled the proposal form. The petitioner cannot be let to suffer for the fault on the part of the opposite partys agent. From the facts stated we are of the view that the petitioner has not suppr3essed any material facts while taking the policy as alleged. Hence the plea of suppression of material facts will not sustain.
Another reason stated by the 1 opposite party for the repudiation of the claim is that, asst per the investigation report of their surveyor Ext. B6, there was no circumstantial evidence of any torrential rain or heavy wind capable of causing such a havoc. In support of this contention the opposite party produced the weather report form India Metrological Department in this regard and was marked as Ext. B7. In Ext. B7 it is reported that From the weather charts and other records available in this office, it is inferred that the following weather conditions would have prevailed over Muthukad and neighbourhood in Kozhikode District on 14/09/2005 around 8 pm. Surface So according to the opposite partywind direction From west. Surface wind speed 5-10kmph.
winds of such magnitude cannot lead normally collapse of any structures. But in Ext. B7 it is also stated that Ina shower accompanied by strong winds of speed occasionally reaching 45 kmph.
cross examination RW1, the surveyor of the 1 opposite party admitted that st Strong wind stated (Page 9-RW1). So from Ext. B7 itself it can bein Ext. B7 is normally called storm in English.
seen that there was a storm reaching 45 kmph speed in that locality during that day. Moreover it is also stated in Ext. B7 that there is no Meteorological observatory functioning at Muthukad. The . In crossrainfall reported is by the nearby rain gauge observatory at Vadakara and Quilandy examination RW1 would say that the place of occurance is at about 30 km away from So the finding in Ext. B7 from such a far distance of the place of occurrence may notVadakara.
be correct always and hence is not dependable as such. The petitioner had produced the copy of the certificates issued by the nearby Village Officer, Chakkittapara and S.I. of Police, Peruvannamuzhi to substantiate his averments and was marked as Ext. A6 and A5. In Ext. A5 and A6 it is clearly stated that the petitioners house under construction has been collapsed due to heavy rain and storm and natural calamities. Moreover PW2 Sri. Andrews the neighbor of the petitioner in his testimony also has stated that there was a heavy storm and rain at the locality during the night of 14/09/2005 and there was landslide at the nearby place Pashukkadavu and . (Page 3-PW2). Thus Ext. A5 and A6, B7 and testimonytwo persons were died in that incident of PW2 proved that there was a heavy rain and storm at the locality of the petitioners residence and that caused destruction to the petitioners building.
The 3 reason raised by the 1 opposite party in denying the claim is that, according to therd st survey report, the reason for the collapse of the building is due to the poor quality materials used for the construction as well as poor workmanship which well not came under Insured Perils and hence they have no liability under the policy to compensate the petitioner. But it is to be considered here that, the survey report in this regard is not prepared after scientific examination of the materials used for the construction or regarding the workmanship and hence the findings of the surveyor in Ext. B6 report in this regard is not reliable at all, further PW2 in his deposition clearly stated that This statement alsoMy house is also constructed by the same quality materials.
disproves the above said inference of the surveyor in Ext. B6 report.
Considering all the facts stated and documents placed on record it is found that the petitioner has not suppressed any material facts while taking the policy as alleged by the 1 opposite party andst the said building was collapsed due to heavy rain and storm during the night of 14/09/2005 and hence it will come under the definition of in the policy. Hence we are of theInsured Perils considered view that the repudiation of the petitioners claim is based merely on probability and hence not justified. It is also found that the 2 opposite party has no role in the issuance of thend policy or its repudiation and hence they are not liable in any way to compensate the petitioner for his losses. Point No. 1 found accordingly.
: In view of the finding in Point No. 1, this petition is to be allowed and the petitionerPoint No.2 is entitled to get reliefs . Ext. B6 is the report filed by the surveyor and loss assessor deputed by the 1 opposite party. He had worked out the net amount of money if payable to the petitioner onst account of the insurance claim at Rs.1,22,964/-. Ext. A2 is the copy of cost estimate of the petitioners house. It shows that the total cost estimated for completing the whole works of that building as Rs.25,000/-. Admittedly the building was collapsed after completing concrete work of its roof ie. before completing its finishing works. So the petitioner is not entitled to get the insured amount of Rs.25,000/- as sought for in the petition but entitled to get the sum Rs.1,22,964/- as per the loss assessed by the surveyor in Ext. B6.
In the result, the following order is passed.
The 1 opposite party is ordered to pay to the petitioner Rs.1,22,964/- (Rupees one lakh twentyst two thousand nine hundred sixty four only), the loss assessed by their surveyor with 9% interest from the date of filing of this petition till payment and Rs.8,000/- (Rupees eight thousand only) as cost of the proceedings. As interest is allowed, not separate compensation.
Dated this the 10 day of October, 2017th Date of filing: 23/09/2008 SD/-MEMBER SD/-PRESIDENT SD/-MEMBER APPENDIX Documents exhibited for the complainant: A1. Copy of Building plan of the complainant A2. Copy of cost estimate of proposed house A3. Copy of premium receipt issued by 1 opposite partyst A4. Copy of Policy schedule A5. Copy of Certificate issued by S.I. of Police, Peruvannamuzhi A6. Copy of certificate issued by Village Officer, Chakkittapara A7. Copy of repudiation letter issued by 1 opposite partyst A8. Copy of lawyer notice sent to the opposite party No. 1 A9. Copy of reply notice received from 1 opposite partyst Documents exhibited for the opposite party: B1. Copy of Proposal for Standard fire and special perils policy B3. Statement of the complainant B4.affidavit filed by the complainant B5. Photographs B6. Final survey report submitted by Madhu Aeran B7. Weather report obtained from India Meteorological Department B8. Specification report by Registered Supervisor, Govt. of Kerala Witness examined for the complainant: PW1. Kunhikrishnan Nambiar(Complainant) PW2. Andrews, Thayyil House, P.O. Muthukad, Kozhikode Dist.
Witness examined for the opposite party: RW1. Madhu Aeran, Narayaneeyam, 42, Puzhathi Housing Colony, Kannur 2.
Sd/-President //True copy// (Forwarded/By Order) SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT [HON'BLE MRS. ROSE JOSE] PRESIDENT [HON'BLE MRS. BEENA JOSEPH] MEMBER [HON'BLE MR. JOSEPH MATHEW] MEMBER