CAV JUDGEMNT
(PER: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE JAYANT PATEL)
1. As in all the petitions, common questions arise for consideration, they are being considered simultaneously.
Relevant legal background (general):
2. The Government of India has placed on the statute book the first piece of legislation pertaining to cooperative societies which was known as the Cooperative Credit Societies Act, 1904. The necessity of such legislation was felt because there was no other Act at the time under which an association or a society could be formed for the purposes of promoting the economic interest of its members in accordance with the well-recognised cooperative principles and therefore, the cooperative societies had to be organised under the Indian Companies Act. Thereafter, it was found that it was desirable to confer upon such societies certain kind of privileges and facilities so as to encourage and assist the formation and working of such societies and therefore, a separate legislation was found to be needed. There is history of formation of committee. The basis was taken under Act of 1904 from English Friendly Societies Act, 1896. But thereafter, there were changes made and the Cooperative Societies Act, 1912 was enacted. Thereafter, there were also changes brought about in the year 1919 and during the period of erstwhile State of Bombay, Bombay Cooperative Societies Act, 1925 was enacted. The changes were also made in the said Act by amending Act of 1948. However, so far as Gujarat State is concerned, after bifurcation of Bombay State, need was felt by the State of Gujarat to consolidate and amend the law relating to cooperative societies in the State of Gujarat and therefore, Gujarat Cooperative Societies Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as the “Act of 1961”) was enacted and put on the statute book. It appears that thereafter, sea change was made in the Act by amending it by Act of 1982 (hereinafter referred to the “Act of 1982”), whereby a certain class of societies were specifically identified as specified societies on account of its operation involving huge public interest. Initially, as per the Act of 1961, the managing committee of the society was to be constituted in accordance with the Act, Rules and bye-laws. However, by the Act of 1982, the proviso was inserted to the effect that so far as the committee of a society falling in the category of section 74C(1), the rotation for retirement, if provided by the bye-laws of a particular number of the members of the managing committee shall cease to remain in force. Further, as per the Act of 1982, section 74C together with the other provisions of the amending Act was brought on the statute book which provided that the election of the members of the committee and the officers on the committees of such specified societies shall be conducted in the manner laid down by or under Chapter XI-A which was also simultaneously inserted by the Act of 1982. Chapter XI-A was inserted in the statute book by the Act of 1982 for election of the committees and officers of certain societies which are so specified under section 74C(1) of the amending Act of 1982. As per the scheme of the said Chapter, the election of such specified societies are to be held on such date or dates as the Collector may fix under his control. As per the Act of 1961, the election of the managing committee was to be held by the Society itself as per the bye-laws. Whereas, so far as the societies included as specified societies under section 74C of the Act are concerned, a separate mode of conducting election was provided and the power of conducting the election was given to the Collector notwithstanding anything contained in the bye-laws of the societies. The said aspect was apparently made clear by virtue of the provisions of section 74C(2) and (3) inserted by the amending Act of 1982. The said Chapter XI-A provided for separate mode for deciding the election dispute by election tribunal as per section 145U and it also provided for rule making power to the State Government to provide for and to regulate all or any of the other matters relating to the various stages of elections including preparation of the list of voters.
3. In exercise of the powers conferred upon the State Government under section 168 read with section 145G read with sections 145U and 145Y, the Government of Gujarat has framed the Rules known as the Gujarat Specified Cooperative Societies Election to Committee Rules, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as the “Rules of 1982”). These Rules provided for various stages of election from the stage of preparation of the voters list until the result is declared and further consequential steps are taken. However, in the year 1987, Rules 3-A and 3B were inserted by Rule making authority which provided for delimitation of the constituencies for the purpose of election and a separate procedure for election of the members reserved in sub-section (1) of section 74-B.
4. After amending the Act of 1982, the constitutional validity of all the provisions of the Act of 1982 was brought under challenge before this Court and the Division Bench of this Court as per its decision in the case of Amreli District Cooperative Sale & Purchase Union Ltd. v. State of Gujarat reported at 1984 (2) GLR 1244, declared sections 17A, 24, 51(2), 69 and also proviso to section 74 as ultra vires to the Constitution. However, so far as sections 74-A, 74-B, 74C, 74D, 76A, 76B, 80(2), 80A were upheld. The matters were carried before the Apex Court but subsequently, all litigations before the Apex Court came to be withdrawn. As a result thereof, the decision of this Court in the case of Amreli District Cooperative Sale & Purchase Union Ltd. (supra) became final and has operated. There are other minor amendments made in the Act subsequently which are not relevant for the purpose of the controversy involved in this group of petitions and therefore, we may not refer to the same. The pertinent aspect is that the proviso to section 74 of the Act stood deleted but section 74C and other provisions relating thereto for the conduct of the election including Chapter XI-A and also the rules remained in the statute book. Therefore, the said legal position remained as per the Gujarat Cooperative Societies Act (after amendment of 1982 and others) (hereinafter referred to as the “Act”). The election of the members of the managing committee of a society other than specified societies are to be held as per the bye-laws of such societies whereas, so far as the specified societies covered by section 74C(1) of the Act are concerned, the election is to be held as per Chapter XI-A read with the Rules of 1982.
5. It could also be said that the bye-laws, if any, of the specified cooperative societies for the election of the members of the managing committee may operate, if not inconsistent with the provisions of the Act or Rules of 1982, but if found to be inconsistent with the provisions of the Act or Rules of 1982, such bye-laws would not operate to that extent and has to make room for operation and implementation of the provisions of the Act or the Rules of 1982, as the case may be.
The relevant case laws:
6. In the case of Antakampa Milk Producers Coop Soc. Ltd. v. Sabarkantha Dist. Coop. Milk Producers Union Ltd. reported at 2004 (1) GLR 310, the question arose for giving interpretation to rule 3-A (8) and also for the validity of the bye-law no. 35(1)(A) of Sabarkantha District Cooperative Milk Producers' Union Ltd. which is a specified society. The learned Single Judge of this Court (one of us - Jayant Patel, J.) found that on plain reading of section 74C(3) of the Act, there is overriding effect on any other bye-laws of such society. It was also found that as per Rule 3-A(8), the number of constituencies has to be equal to the total number of seats excluding two reserved seats under section 74-B. The learned Single Judge found that bye-law no. 35(1)(A) of the Sabarkantha District Milk Producers' Union Ltd (a specified society) provided for the seats more than one person for each constituency and therefore, the bye-law was not in conformity with Rule 3-A(8) and it was also found that the bye-law can operate to the extent of 7 representative to be elected from 7 separate constituencies and therefore, held to be valid to that extent only.
7. In the case of Shri Sadvadar Seva Sahkari Mandali Ltd. v. State of Gujarat, reported at 2010 (3) GLH 117, one Division Bench of this Court had an occasion to consider once again the question for holding of the election of the Bank in accordance with Rule 3-A(8) of the Rules. The Division Bench found that when Rule 3-A(8) and Rule 43 are examined in juxtaposition, it emerges that the object as well as the field of operation of the said two provisions are different inasmuch the former deals with the “constituencies” bifurcated on the territorial/zone basis. The Division Bench did consider the view taken by the learned Single Judge of this Court in the case of Antakampa Milk Producers Coop Soc. Ltd. (supra) but found that in the said case, the constituencies were bifurcated zone or territory wise and therefore, tested on different set of facts than the facts posed before it.
8. Once again the question arose for considering the provisions of Rule 3-A(8) read with section 74C of the Act in the case of Khanodar (Old) Milk Producers Cooperative Society Ltd. v. State of Gujarat and reported at 2013 (1) GLH 245 before this Court. The second Division Bench of this Court found that the bye-law providing more than one representative to be elected in one constituency would be in contravention to Rule 3-A(8) and it was found that the decision in the case of Shri Sadvadar Seva Sahkari Mandali Ltd. (supra) was a case where the members of the society were comprised of various classes of societies. Whereas the decision of this Court in the case of Antakampa Milk Producers Coop Soc. Ltd. (supra) was a case where the members constituted homogeneous group and not heterogeneous group. Therefore, the decision of Antakampa Milk Producers Coop Soc. Ltd. (supra) would govern the present case before the Division Bench. Ultimately, the Division Bench set aside the bye-law no. 35(1) providing for voting right for more than one seat in one constituency.
9. The constitutional validity of Rule 3-A(8) was also challenged before this Court in the case of Banaskantha District Coop. Milk Producers Union ltd. v. State of Gujarat reported at (2012) 2 GLR 1522. The third Division Bench of this Court in its decision held that if any of the rules lawfully framed under the provisions of the Act creates a restriction in relation to the subject matter of any of the clauses of the bye-laws, such restriction must be adhered to and any such clause in violation of the restriction imposed by the rules should be deleted. It was also held that the State Government while enacting the impugned provisions of the Rule has not deviated from the principles mentioned under section 74C (3) of the Act, but has only created a position by making provisions of the election of members from the general body It was also held that even by way of creation of constituency and allowing its members to participate as provided in the Rule, the committee of the management will still be elected by the general body of the members and not in any way otherwise than by general body of the members. The Division Bench found no substance in the contention that the act of creation of constituencies is inconsistent with any of the provisions of the Act and thus curtails the purposes of the Act. Ultimately, Rule 3-A(8) is held to be not in conflict with any of the provisions of the Act nor it was held suffering from want of authority of the delegated legislation and Rule 3-A(8) was held to be legal and valid.
Legal Issues:-
10. When the present group of petitions came up before the fourth Division Bench of this Court on 21.09.2012, the following legal issues are formulated and referred to the larger bench -
(1) Whether Rule 3-A of the Rules introduced by the Amendment dated 10.8.1987, could be applied to the Societies bye-laws of which provide for a single constituency?
(2) Whether the scheme of the Rules permits the specified Societies having a single constituency, more than one seat for one constituency; and whether members of such society can legally be permitted to vote for more than one seat?
(3) Whether Collector has jurisdiction to make an order for delimitation of the constituencies, in absence of any proceeding undertaken in accordance with Section 14 of the Act?
(4) Whether delimitation of the constituencies under Rule 3-A of the Rules can only be territory-wise and/or whether delimitation of the constituencies can be based upon objects and activities of the member societies or classes of individual members?
Accordingly, all matters are before us.
11. It would be relevant to record the following aspects-
12. The constitutional validity of Rule 3-A(8) is already upheld by the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Banaskantha District Coop. Milk Producers Union Ltd. (supra) and no one in the present group of petitions has questioned the constitutional validity of Rule 3-A or more particularly sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A or sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A.
13. It is well settled legal position and rather not challenged by any of the learned counsel appearing for respective parties that the bye-laws of any cooperative society cannot operate in contravention to any of the provisions of the Act or the Rules and in the event any question arises for operation of the bye-laws, coming in conflict with the provisions of the Act or Rules, the bye-law has to make room for operation of any of the provisions of the Act or Rules. To say in other words, the provisions of the Act would prevail over the provisions of the Rules or the bye-laws and the provisions of the Rules would prevail over the provisions of the bye-laws.
14. The learned counsels appearing for both the sides have made submissions on the point of true and correct interpretation of Rule 3-A, its applicability, the powers of the Collector under sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A and the exercise of the power available to the Registrar under section 14 for amendment of the bye-laws and the incidental questionthereof.
Findings:- I
15. We may now refer to the provisions of the Act in order to properly consider the legal issues referredtous-
Section 2(2) of the Act defines bye-laws, which reads as under:
“(2)”bye-laws” means bye-laws registered under this Act and for the time being in force, and included registered amendments of such bye-laws;”
The aforesaid shows that the bye-laws are those which are registered under the Act and it includes registered amendments of such bye-laws.
Section 2(9) provides for a “federal society” which should not have less than five of its members which are themselves societies.
Section 2(14) provides for the definition of the word “officer”, which reads as under:
“(14) “officer” means a person elected or appointed by a society to any office of such society according to its bye-laws; and includes a chairman, vice-chairman, president, vice-president, managing director, manager, secretary, treasurer, member of the committee, and any other person elected or appointed under this Act, the rules or the bye-laws, to give directions in regard to the business of such society”
The aforesaid shows that the person so elected or appointed by the society according to its bye-laws has to be under the Act, Rules or by-laws. 1
Section 2(18) provides that the “rules” means the rules made under this Act.
Section 2(19) provides that the “society” means a cooperative society registered, or deemed to be registered under this Act.
Section 4 of the Act provides that a society may be registered. However, the requirement for registration is provided as per section 9 which reads as under:
“9. Registration and provisional registration, Certificate of registration.(1) On receipt of an application of registration from a society -
(a) if the Registrar is satisfied that the society has complied with the provisions of this Act and the rules as registration and that its bye - laws are not contrary to this stand the rules, he shall register the society and its bye - laws; and
(b) if the Registrar is of opinion that the application complies with the requirements of section 8 but that its bye - laws are not in conformity with the provisions of this Act and the rules, he may provisionally register the society and by an order in writing permit the society to perform such functions subject to such conditions as he may specify in the order and may also by an order in writing direct the society to amend within the period prescribed in this behalf its bye - laws so as to bring them in conformity with this Act and the rules.
(2) When a society has been provisionally registered, the Registrar shall, on its compliance with the order made under clause (b) of sub - section (1) finally register it and bye - laws; and on its failure to comply with the order shall cancel its provisional registration.
(3) provisionally registered society shall not be deemed to be a society registered under this Act.
(4) On the registration of a society, the Registrar shall issue to it a certificate of registration signed by him.
(5) A certificate of registration issued under sub - section (4) shall be conclusive evidence that the society therein mentioned by duly registered, unless it is proved that the registration has been cancelled.
(6) If the Registrar refuses to register the society, he shall forth with communicate has decision with reasons therefore, to the person who has signed first on the application.”
The aforesaid section shows that the Registrar has to be satisfied that the society has complied with the provisions of the Act, Rules as to the registration and its bye-laws are not contrary to this Act and the Rules and if he is of the opinion that the bye-laws are not in conformity with the provisions of the Act and the Rules, he may direct the society to amend the bye-laws so as to bring them in conformity with the Act and Rules.
Section 14, which is also relevant for the issues involved, reads as under:
“14. Power to direct amendment of bye-laws -(1) If at appears to the Registrar that an amendment of the bye-laws except in respect of the name or objects of a society is necessary or desirable in the interest of such society, he may call upon the society, in the prescribed manner, to make the amendment within such time as he may specify.
(2) If the society fails to make the amendment within the time so specified, the Registrar after giving the society an opportunity of being heard and with the prior approval of the State Cooperative Council may register the amendment and shall thereupon issue to the society a copy thereof certified by him. With effect from the date of the registration of the amendment in the manner aforesaid, the bye - laws shall be deemed to have been duly amendment accordingly; and the bye - laws a amended shall be binding on the society and its members.”
The aforesaid section shows that if it appears to the Registrar that the amendment in the bye-laws is necessary or desirable, he may call upon the society to make the amendment and if thereafter, there is failure on the part of the society, the Registrar after giving opportunity of hearing to the society and with the prior approval of the State Cooperative Council, may register such amendment and consequently, the bye-laws shall stand deemed to have been amended accordingly and binding to the society and its members.
The aforesaid provisions in our view clearly goes to show that a society cannot be registered with bye-laws which are not in conformity with the provisions of the Act and the Rules and if the bye-laws are not in conformity with the provisions of the Act or the Rules, the bye-laws may be directed to be amended and if not amended, the registration may not be granted or the Registrar will have the power to ensure the amendment is so carried out in the bye-laws.
Section 74(1) reads as under:
“74(1) -The management of every society shall vest in a committee, constituted in accordance with this Act, the rules and bye - laws, which shall exercise such powers and perform such duties as may be conferred or imposed on it respectively by this Act, the rules and the bye - laws:”
Since the proviso to section 74(1) has been struck down by this Court in the case of Amreli District Cooperative Sale & Purchase Union Ltd. (supra), we need not discuss the same, but even if it is considered as it is, the power with the managing committee of every society shall be conferred and enforced on it as per the provisions of the Act, Rules and bye-laws.
Section 74C provides for conduct of the election of the committees and officers of certain societies in terms of office of the members of such committees. The same for ready reference reads as under:
“74C. Provisions for conduct of elections and officers of certain societies and term of office of members of committees.-(1) The election of the members of the committees and of the officers by the committee, of the societies of the categories mentioned below shall be subject to the provisions of Chapter XI - A and shall be conducted in the manner laid down by or under that Chapter:-
(i) Apex societies mentioned in the Scheduled and such other apex societies as the State Government may, by general or special order, published in the Official Gazette, from time to time specify in this behalf, having regard to financial position and share capital of such societies;
(ii) all District Central Co - operative Banks;
(iii) all Primary Land Development Banks;
(iv) (a) all District Co - operative Sale and Purchase Organisations
(b) all Taluka Co - operative Sale and purchase Organisations; (v) all Co - operative Sugar Factories;
(vi) all Co - operative Spinning Mills.
(vi-a) all district co - operative milk unions (vi-b) all taluka co-operative processing societies; (vii) any other society or class of societies, which the State Government may, by general or special, order published in the Official Gazette, from time to time specify in behalf, regard being had to the financial position and share capital of such institutions.
(2) When the election of all the members of the committee of any such societies held at the same time, the members elected on the committee at such general election shall hold office for a period of three years from the date on which the first meeting is held and shall continue in office until immediately before the first meeting of the members of the new committee.
(3) Notwithstanding anything in the bye-laws, of any such society, the committee of management shall be elected by a general body of members of the society and all other committees authorised by or under the bye-laws may be constituted by electing or appointing persons from among the persons who are members of the committee of management, and all such committees shall be sub - committees of the committee of management, and shall be subordinate to it:
Provided that it shall be lawful for the State Government,-
(a) to nominate its representative on a Committee of any such society under section 80, or (b) to nominate the first Committee of Management of any such society where the bye-laws of such society so provide.)
[Provided further that it shall be lawful for any body or authority to nominate its representative on a committee of such society where the bye - laws of such society so provide.]”
The aforesaid section provides for a certain class of the societies to be identified as specified societies and the election is to be held as per the provisions of Chapter XI-A. The another relevant aspect is that sub-section (3) of the aforesaid section makes it clear that notwithstanding anything contained in the bye-laws of any such societies, the committee of management shall be elected by the general body of the members of the society. This shows an express intention of the legislature to dilute the effect of the bye-laws for the purpose of election of the members of the managing committee of all such specified societies covered by the provisions of section 74C(1) of the Act.
It may be recorded that the validity of the aforesaid provisions of section 74C has been upheld by this Court in its decision in the case of Amreli District Cooperative Sale & Purchase Union Ltd. (supra). Chapter XI-A inserted by the amending Act of 1982 for the election of all specified cooperative societies provides for various aspects pertaining to the election as per section 145A to 145Y.
Section 145Y provides for power of the State Government to make Rules consistent with the Act generally to provide for and regulate all or any of the other matters relating to various stages of elections including preparation of the voters list.
As recorded earlier, Rules of 1982 have been framed by the State Government in exercise of the power under section 168 read with section 145G(2) read with section 145U(4) read with section 145 Y of the Act.
Rule 2(b) defines constituency, which reads as under:
“(b) “constituency” means an electoral division, if any, as specified in the bye-laws of the specified society;”
But the pertinent aspect is that earlier society was not defined under Rule 2 but by amendment of 1987 in the Rules, Society has been defined as per section 2(ia) which reads as under:
“(ia) “Society” means a society specified under sub-section (1) of section 74-C”
Rule 3 provides for the intimation by the District Registrar to the Collector the names and address of the Societies whose elections are to be held within 90 days before drawing up of the accounts of such societies. Rule 3-A which calls for consideration in the issues involved in the present matter reads as under:
“3-A. Delimitation of constituencies for purpose of election.-
(1) In every society where there are more than one constituencies, the Secretary or where there is no post of Secretary, the Chief Executive Officer of every such society shall, in the year in which election to the Committee is scheduled to be held, prepare a provisional list of the constituencies.
(2) Such list shall describe the limits of each constituency. A copy of the provisional list shall be displayed with a notice to be signed by the Secretary or where there is no post of Secretary, the Chief Executive Officer of the society on the. notice board of every office or sub-office of the society. A copy of such provisional list along with the notice shall also be sent to the Registrar and to the Collector.
(3) A copy of such list along with notice shall also be sent to every member of the society by registered post.
(4) The notice referred to in sub-rules (2) and (3) shall clearly lay down that any objections or suggestions in respect of the provisional list may be sent by any person to the Secretary or where there is no post of Secretary to the Chief Executive Officer of the society within a period of 15 days from the date on which the provisional list is displayed on the notice board of the office of the society.
(5) Any member of the society may bring to the notice of the society any omission or error in respect of the name or address or other particulars shown in the provisional list.
(6) Any person raising any objection or making a suggestion shall send such objection or suggestion with grounds therefore in writing within 15 days from the date on which the provisional list is displayed on the notice board of the office of the society.
(7) The society shall after considering every objection, suggestion or any error in the provisional list indicated by any member under Sub-rule (5), prepare the final list. The final list shall be displayed on the notice board of the office of sub-office of the society and a copy of such final list shall be sent to the Registrar and also to the Collector.
(8) Where the area of operation of a society is in more than one village, the number of constituencies shall be equal to the total number of seats excluding two seats reserved under sub-section (1) of section 74-B.
(9) Notwithstanding anything contained in these rules and the bye-laws of the society, where the elections to the members of any Committee are scheduled to be held before the ending of the accounting year of the society, the delimitation of the constituencies shall be made by the Collector prior to the publication of the list of voters.”
The aspects which need to be considered is that
Rule 3-A which has been inserted in the year 1987 by way of amendment in the said Rules with the other amendment in the said Rules.
Since the aspects of single constituency are also to be considered, Rule 43 would be relevant and the same reads as under:
“43. Procedure for voting where there are no separate constituencies or more than one seat to be filled in one constituency.-In cases where there are no constituencies defined in the bye-laws or where more than one seat is authorised in the bye-laws for a constituency, voting in so far as these seats are concerned shall be recorded in accordance with the following provisions, namely:-
(a) Every voter shall be entitled to give as many votes as there are seats for filling which votes are to be taken but no voter shall give more than one vote to any one candidate.
(b) The voter shall make a mark on the ballot paper with the instrument supplied for the purpose on or near the symbols of the candidate or candidates for whom he intends to vote, so however, that no part of any mark so made shall appear in the space provided for other candidate. The voter shall thereafter fold the marked ballot paper so as to conceal his vote and insert the folded ballot paper into the ballot box and without undue delay leave the polling station.”
If Rule 43 is read independently, in exclusion to Rule 3-A, one may say that if the bye-laws provide for a single constituency, the procedure for voting shall be as provided under Rule 43(a). However, we have to see the effect of Rule 4 3 which did exist when the Rules were framed in the year 1982, after the insertion of rule 3-A in the Rules of 1982.
We shall now consider Rule 3-A. The perusal of Rule 3-A(1) shows that it begins with the words “In every society where there are more than one constituencies”. The provisional list of constituencies will be required to be prepared. Sub-rule(2) provides that such list shall describe the limits of each constituency. Sub-rule (3) provides that such list with the notice shall be sent to every member cooperative societies. Sub-rule (4) provides for intimation, to submit the objections if any. Sub-rule (5) provides that any member of the Society may bring to the notice of the Society any omission or error in respect of names or addresses or other particulars shown in the provisional list. Sub-rule (6) provides for filing of the objections. Sub-rule (7) provides for consideration of the objections and preparation of the final voters list and to be displayed on the notice board.
The aforesaid procedure as provided under Rule 3(1) to Rule 3(7) would apply to all specified cooperative societies, be it a society having bye-laws for a single constituency or a society having bye-laws of more than one constituency.
16. Now the question comes up for consideration for interpretation of sub-rule (8) and sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A. sub-rule (8) provides that where the area of operation of the society is more than one village, the number of constituencies shall be equal to the total number of seats excluding the two seats reserved under section 74-B. To say in other words, once the area of operation of any society is more than one village, sub-rule (8) would come into play. It is not possible for us to accept the contention raised by Mr. Kavina, learned Senior Counsel, that sub-rule (8) will have no applicability in a case where though area of operation of a society may be more than one village but the bye-laws provide for only a single constituency. The said contention can be accepted only if we proceed on the basis that Rule 3-A would apply to only such societies where the bye-laws provide for more than one constituency and it would not apply to society where under bye-laws there is a single constituency. As such, the nomenclature of Rule 3-A is “delimitation of constituencies for the purpose of election”, which would mean the delimitation of the constituencies of all specified cooperative societies. Nowhere it has been provided under Rule 3-A that, ‘Rule 3-A, for delimitation of constituency as a whole including all its sub-rules would apply only in a case where the bye-laws of the society provides for more than one constituency’. The overall reading of Rule 3-A shows that sub-rule (1) to Sub-rule (7) are general in nature for the procedure for preparation of the voters' list which may apply to all specified societies irrespective of the fact that whether the bye-laws of such societies provide for a single constituency or more than one constituency. However, so far as sub-rule (8) and (9) are concerned, we find that both are independent, in order to see that there is proper delimitation of constituency of such specified cooperative society, so as to allow its members to give proper representation through their electorate by maintaining the democratic principles.
Under these circumstances, we find that sub-rule
(8) of Rule 3-A being independent in nature, expressly provides that where the area of operation of any society is more than one village, the number of constituencies shall be equal to the total number of seats, excluding two seats reserved under section 74-B.
17. The attempt was also made by the learned counsel Mr. Kavina as well as Mr. D C Dave for the respective parties, to contend that even if the seats are reserved under section 74-B of the Act for scheduled caste and scheduled tribe and small and marginal farmers, there could be only one constituency as per the bye-law.
18. We are unable to accept the said submission. section 74-B of the Act for ready reference reads as under:
“74-B. Reservation of seats on committees of certain societies, for Scheduled Castes and Tribes and small and marginal farmers. (1) On the committee of such society or class of societies as the State Government may, by general or special order direct, two seats shall be reserved as follows, namely:-
(a) one for the persons belonging to the Scheduled Castes or the Scheduled Tribes or to both the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes as the State Government may, having regard to the population of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes in the area of operation of the society, specify, and
(b) one for the persons who are small farmers and marginal farmers.
(2) Where any of such reserved seats is not filled by election or appointment the committee shall fill such seat by co-option of a member on the committee from amongst other members”
Explanation. - For the purpose of this section-
(1) the expressions “marginal farmer” and “small farmer” shall have the meanings respectively assigned to them in clauses (g) and (p) of section 2 of the Gujarat Rural Debtors Relief Act, 1976;
(1A) the expression “population” in relation to the area of operation of a society means the population of that area as ascertained at the last preceding census.)
(2) the expression “Scheduled Castes” means such castes, reaches or tribes or parts of, or groups within, such castes, races or tribes as are deemed to be Scheduled Castes in relation to the State of Gujarat under article 341 of the Constitution of India;
(3) the expression “Scheduled Tribes” means such tribes or tribal communities or parts of, or groups, within, such tribes or tribal communities as are deemed to be Scheduled Tribes in relation to the State of Gujarat under article 342 of the Constitution of India.”
It is an admitted position that the Government issued orders for making reservation of seats for scheduled caste and schedule tribe and small and marginal farmers in certain classes of the societies. If the bye-laws provide for a single constituency, no effect can be given to the seats reserved under section 74-B because the seats specifically reserved for members of scheduled caste and scheduled tribe, as well as small and marginal farmers will be required to be filled up by formation of their own separate constituency, viz., one member would have to be elected belonging to scheduled caste or scheduled tribe or both, as the case may be, and the another member would be from the persons who are small and marginal farmers. Therefore, as such, once the reservation of the seat is so declared in certain societies, there is bound to be two separate constituencies, one for the member of scheduled caste and scheduled tribe and another for small and marginal farmers. The aforesaid constituencies shall be in addition to the other constituencies, may be one or more than one as per the bye-laws of such societies. This would mean that in case of specified societies where the reserved seats are so declared for scheduled caste and scheduled tribe or small and marginal farmers by the Government in exercise of the power under section 74-B of the Act, such societies in any case will have more than one constituency. Once it is held that such society will have more than one constituency, the argument would not stand that the bye-laws provides for only single constituency and not more than one. But in any case, the applicability of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A is dependent on the area of operation of such society having more than one village. To say in other words, even if there is more than one constituency in any society, where the area of operation is not more than one village, sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A may have no applicability and the bye-laws may operate as it is, if otherwise not in conflict with any of the other provisions of the Act or the Rules. However, once the area of operation of any society is more than one village, sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A would come into play and the requirement of number of constituency equal to the total number of seats has to be satisfied, of course, excluding two seats reserved under section 74-B of the Act.
sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A again would independently apply in contradiction to sub-rule (1) to sub-rule (8). The language of sub-rule (9) is clear inasmuch as the rule making authority has clothed the Collector with the power to delimit the constituencies prior to the publication of the list of voters. It is true that the question of delimitation of the constituencies would arise only in a case where there is more than one constituency, but at the same time, while exercising the power under sub-rule (9), the Collector has to keep in mind the provisions of sub-rule (8) inasmuch as in a case where the area of operation of any society is ‘more than one village’, the number of constituencies has to be equal to the total number of seats. In our view, the delimitation of the constituency would be prior to the preparation of the voters' list and/or in any case simultaneous with the preparation of preliminary voters' list but the final voters' list has to be as per the delimitation of the constituencies. It would be fair and proper for conducting the election, if the delimitation of the constituencies takes place prior to the preparation of the preliminary voters' list. Once it is found that the delimitation of the constituencies has to proceed prior to the preparation of the preliminary or final voters list, sub-rule (9), though provided at the end of Rule 3-A, has to be complied with in the beginning of the process for preparation of the voters' list. Be that as it may, from express language of sub-rule (9) it is clear that when the election of any specified society is scheduled to be held, the delimitation of the constituency is required to be made by the Collector prior to the publication of the list of voter.
The conjoint reading of sub-rule (8) and sub-rule (9) would mean that in a case where the society has the area of operation exceeding one village, even if the bye-laws provide for single constituency, the seats provided by the bye-laws has to be equal to the number of constituency and therefore, for each seat, separate constituency would be required to be delimited and if not so delimited by the society, of its own, it would be required for the Collector to exercise the power under sub-rule(9) for delimitation of constituency in accordance with the mandate of sub-rule (8) and thereafter, the process for publication of the voters' list is to be given effect.
19. It was submitted by the learned counsel for the respective parties by Mr. Kavina as well as Mr. Dave that if the bye-laws provide for single constituency, though the area of operation is more than one village, is already registered by the Registrar of Cooperative Societies, the same is required to be given effect to. Further, if the Registrar is of the view that the bye-laws of a particular society is not in conformity with the provisions of the Act or the Rules, the obligation is cast upon him as per the scheme of section 14 to direct the society to amend the bye-laws accordingly. If the bye-laws are not amended by the society after direction is given, the Registrar has the power to direct the amendment so carried out, but it was submitted that in absence of such direction, so long as bye-laws operate, the power cannot be exercised by the Collector for delimitation of the constituency in contravention of the bye-laws.
20. In our view, the said contention is misconceived inasmuch as the power of the Registrar under section 14 for directing the amendment in the bye-laws is different than the power provided with the Collector for delimitation of the constituency under sub-rule (9) of the Rules of 1982. It is true that the power available to the Registrar under section 14 may include all amendment in the bye-laws including those so as to bring in conformity with the provisions of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A. But such power is in respect of all cooperative societies, whether covered by section 74C(1) or not and further such power is not dependent upon any contingency of holding election. One may say that generally power is vested with the Registrar under section
14 to direct an amendment in bye-laws of any society so as to bring them in conformity with the provisions of the Act or the Rules, as the case may be including Rules of 1982. However, the power conferred upon the Collector by sub-rule (9) is independent and separate inasmuch such power is available to the Collector only when election of members of any committee of specified society is scheduled to be held. Further, as per the language used in sub-rule (9), such power is to be exercised notwithstanding anything contained in the bye-laws of such society. Therefore, by sub-rule(9), the bye-laws are not being amended but the rule making authority has made it clear that notwithstanding anything contained in the bye-laws, the Collector has to exercise the power for delimitation of the constituencies prior to the publication of the list of voters. It is hardly required to be stated that when specific power is conferred in a specific contingency to a different authority, such power is to be read in addition to the general power for amendment in the bye-laws.
21. As per the scheme of the Act, as such, the bye-laws of any society have to be in conformity with the provisions of the Act and the Rules. As we have discussed earlier, the historical background shows that after the enactment of the Act of 1961, it continued upto 1982 with minor amendments, but the sea change by the amendment Act of 1982 was made for specified cooperative societies due to their operation involving public interest and therefore, in a given case, a society may have been registered prior to 1982 with the bye-laws, which may not be in contravention to the provisions of the Act and the Rules prevailing then and in any case prior to the amendment Act of 1982 came in to force. But after the amending Act of 1982 came into force, and more particularly after the Rules of 1982 amended in the year 1987, it is obligatory on the part of any specified society to bring about the amendment in the bye-laws in conformity with the provisions of the Rules and more particularly rule 3-A (8) which is under consideration in the present group of petitions. If there is failure on the part of any society, the Registrar is required to exercise the power so as to direct the society to amend the bye-laws to bring in conformity with Rule 3-A(8), but merely because there is inaction on the part of the Registrar or when the Registrar has so directed but inspite of the same, the Society has not amended the the bye-laws to be in conformity with Rule 3-A(8), the effect of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A would not stand diluted or nullified. To meet with such situation, the rule making authority in order to ensure the election of specified society in a particular manner has clothed the election authority/the Collector, under sub-rule (9), with the power to delimit the constituency notwithstanding anything contained in the Rules or the bye-laws of the society. The language used in sub-rule (9) is clear. There is no conflict with Rule 43 because Rule 43 would apply in a case where bye-laws provide for a single constituency but such single constituency has to meet with the test of Rule 3-A(8) too. Once the area of operation of any society exceeds more than one village as per sub-rule (8), the number of constituencies is required to be bifurcated so as to make it equal total number ofseats.
22. It appears to us that the aforesaid could be one of the object for bringing about amendment in the year 1987 of sub-rule(8) of section 3-A with the further compliance through the Collector as provided under sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A.
23. At this stage, we may advert to certain observations of the Apex Court in its decision in the case of Ziley Singh v. The Registrar, Cane Coop. Societies reported at AIR 1972 SC 758, wherein the question arose for consideration before the Apex Court as to whether the District Registrar of the Cooperative Societies could give direction to the society allowing all members of the general body to exercise their right to vote in filling up of the seats of the elected Directors or not, wherein the Apex Court at paragraph 11, inter alia, observed as under:
“11……The entire purpose of division of membership into different groups and specifying suitable representation of such group on the committee of management is to emphasise the, right of the particular group to send its representative to the committee. To illustrate if a society is divided into 14 separate groups on a territorial. basis and one member of the committee of management is allotted to each group and if delegates of one group have the right to cast 14 votes two consequences will follow. First, the right of i choosing a representative of the constituency will be not confined to that constituency but will be enlarged to outsiders in other constituencies. Secondly, a member of the committee from one constituency may be elected by a majority of votes from delegates of other constituencies. If delegates residing outside a territorial constituency take part at the election for member of a committee from territorial constituency within which he is not a resident it will not only amount to enlarging the right of representation beyond ones territorial basis but also deny the delegates within the constituency the right of electing their own representative.”
Further, at paragraph 13, it was inter alia observed as under:
“13 ….. First, the society will divide the constituencies on territorial basis or any other rational basis. By territorial basis is meant territory where the member will reside. Residence is therefore the relative requirement of territorial basis. If any other rational basis like occupation or vocation is determined to be the basis of a constituency the persons falling within the constituency will satisfy that test.
Secondly, the society will specify the proportion of members of the committee in such a manner that different areas or interests may get suitable representation. The inherent idea is that such areas or interests will obtain representation. If membership is on territorial basis, the different areas will get representation according to the interest of such territories.”
24. In view of the aforesaid observations and discussions, we find as under:
The decision of the learned Single Judge of this Court (one of us - Jayant Patel, J.) in the case of Antakampa Milk Producers Coop Soc. Ltd. (supra) holding that the bye-law of any specified society cannot be permitted to prevail over statutory Rule 3-A(8) cannot be said to be incorrect. However, the other questions as we have considered in the present matter did not arise for consideration before the learned Single Judge, including that of exercise of the power independently available to the District Collector under sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A for delimitation of the constituency keeping in view the provisions of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A read with the provisions of the bye-law to the extent and not in conformity with the scheme of sub-rule(8) of Rule 3-A.
The decision of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Shri Sadvadar Seva Sahkari Mandali Ltd. (supra) would hold good only if the condition is satisfied that the area of operation of that particular society whose election is to be held is not that of more than one village but limited only to one village. The moment the area of operation of any specified society exceeds one village, sub-rule(8) of Rule 3-A would come into play irrespective of the fact that whether members of such society constitutes homogeneous group or heterogeneous group. Therefore, the view taken by the Division bench of this Court in the case of Shri Sadvadar Seva Sahkari Mandali Ltd. (supra) that, ‘there can be one constituency for the purpose of heterogeneous group even if the area of operation is more than one village’ cannot be said to be correct proposition of law if the area of operation of such society is exceeding one village.
The decision of the Division Bench of this Court in the case of Khanodar (Old) Milk Producers Cooperative Society Ltd. (supra) to the extent that as per the scheme of sub-rule (8) there has to be one member for one constituency once the area of operation is more than one village, is a correct proposition of law. However, at paragraph 24 of the said decision, the observations have been made by the Division Bench that Rule 4 3 is for women and reserved category as per the provisions of section 74-B, does not appear to be correct view because rule 4 3 is applicable to cases ‘where either no constituencies are defined in the bye-laws or where there are more than one seats are authorised in the bye-laws for single constituency’. Both the contingencies are not dependent on the seats reserved for women or seats reserved under Rule 74-B only. Rule 4 3 may apply to any society where single constituency is provided by the bye-laws. But if read conjointly with sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A, it may stand good only if the area of operation of such society is not exceeding one village. The moment the area of operation exceeds one village, sub-rule(8) of Rule 3-A would come into play excluding for the seats reserved by section 74-B. Hence, the view taken by the Division Bench of this Court in the said case would stand diluted to the extent that Rule 43 will apply to a Society having single constituency provided by the bye-laws but only if the area of operation of such society is not more thanonevillage.
Conclusions for legal issues:-
25. In view of the aforesaid observations and discussions, we find that the issues referred to us can be answered as under:
(1) Rule 3-A of Rules of 1982 could be applied to the societies bye-laws which provides for a single constituency because Rule 3-A is essentially for delimitation of the constituencies and preparation of the voters' list. But we clarify that sub-rule(1) to sub-rule(7) would apply in case of all specified societies, whether bye-laws provide for a single constituency or more than one constituency. Sub-rule(8) would apply to all specified societies having bye-laws for single constituency only if its area of operation is in more than one village. Sub-rule(9) would apply to all specified societies where delimitation of the constituencies are required to be made by the Collector.
(2) The scheme of the Rules of 1982 do permit specified societies having single constituency, provided the area of operation is limited to one village and in those circumstances, more than one seat may be provided under the bye-laws for one constituency. The members of such societies can legally be permitted to vote for more than one seat.
(3) The Collector has the power to pass an order for delimitation of the constituency, even in absence of any proceedings undertaken in accordance with section 14 of the Act.
(4) The delimitation of constituency under Rule 3-A of the Rules can also be territory-wise. The delimitation of the constituencies can be based upon the objects and activities of the societies for the classes of individual members since each electorate is to represent the respective members of a particular area or a particular class, as the case may be.
Consideration of merits of each matter:-
26. As all the matters are placed before us for appropriate final decision as per the submissions of the learned counsels appearing for both the sides, we shall now proceed to consider the facts of each case petitionwise for appropriate decision in light of the legal position narrated and the answer by us on the legal issues.
27. SCA No. 12067/12 - The facts of this case shows that bye-law no. 34.1 of Vadodara District Cooperative Milk Producers Union Ltd, provides for 15 members to be elected as the members of the managing committee from amongst affiliated milk producers societies. The perusal of the copy of the order dated 30.06.2012 passed by the Collector shows that the area of operation of the said society is more than one village, viz., the affiliated cooperative societies are spread over different taluka, i.e, Vadodara, Padra, Savli, Karjan, Dabhoi, Vaghodia, Shinor, Tilakwada, Sankheda, Jetpurpavi, Nasvadi, Chhota Udaipur and Kwant. Therefore, though bye-laws provided for single constituency, as the area of operation was exceeding one village, it appears that general directions issued by the Registrar dated 06.07.2011, copy whereof is produced at Annexure-D to the petition, were applicable to the said society for amendment in the bye-laws so as to bring them in conformity with the provisions of Rule 3-A(8). However, no action was taken for amendment in the bye-laws but the members of the managing committee on the contrary resolved vide resolution dated 05.06.2012 that the amendment in the bye-laws are not required. It appears that thereafter, the District Collector vide order dated 30.06.2012 (Annexure-A to the petition) ordered for delimitation of the constituencies and it is under these circumstances, the petitioners in capacity as members of the Managing Committee have preferred the petition for setting aside the general instructions issued by the Registrar, Cooperative Societies, dated 06.07.2011 and the order dated 30.06.2012 passed by the Collector and have also consequently, prayed to quash the notification dated 29.08.2012 declaring the election. In view of the legal issues decided by us, as the area of operation of the society in question is more than one village, bye-laws providing for single constituency run counter to the scheme of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A which would be applicable to the society in question. Under the circumstances, the instructions issued by the Registrar calling upon the society to amend the bye-laws to bring them in conformity with the provisions of Rule 3-A(8) as well as the powers exercised by the Collector for delimitation of the constituency in sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A cannot be said to be without any authority or competence. Hence, the relief to quash and set aside the instructions issued by the Registrar dated 06.07.2011 (Annexure-B) and to quash and set aside the order dated 30.06.2012 (Annexure-A) passed by the Collector as well as the consequential relief to quash the notification dated 29.08.2012 for declaring the election cannot be granted. In the result, the petition fails.
28. SCA No. 8905/12 - The subject matter of this petition is the same as that of SCA No. 12067/12 since it pertains to the exercise of the power by the Collector vide order dated 30.06.2012 for bifurcation of various constituencies talukawise for the election of the Baroda District Cooperative Milk Producers Union Ltd. The only difference is that the present petition has been preferred by the said society itself, i.e, Baroda District Cooperative Milk Producers Union Ltd. through its Chairman Shri Narendrabhai Mahijibhai Patel who is also petitioner no. 1 in SCA No. 12067/12 referred to hereinabove. SCA No. 12067/12 is preferred by the members of the Managing Committee of the said society whereas the present petition being SCA No. 8905/12 has been preferred by the society itself. Since the facts are common as that of SCA No. 12067/12, we need not repeat the same. But if we consider the prayers made in the petition, the same is for seeking appropriate writ to quash and set aside the order dated 30.06.2012 passed by the Collector bifurcating the constituency talukawise. The another prayer inserted after amendment in the petition is for appropriate writ to quash and set aside the order dated 02.07.2012 and also the notification dated 02.07.2012 fixing various stages of the election. The copy of the order dated 02.07.2012 is produced on pages 122 to 124 and the same shows that they are all pertaining to the declaration of the election programme by the Collector. In view of the reasons recorded by us hereinabove while dealing with the facts of SCA No. 12067/12, since sub-rule(8) of Rule 3-A is applicable as the area of operation of the petitioner society is more than one village and consequently the Collector has power to delimit the constituency, and it appears that the Collector has delimited the constituency keeping in view the provisions of sub-rule(8) of Rule 3-A. Under these circumstances, the order passed by the Collector cannot be said to be illegal for delimitation of the constituency. The basis of challenging the election notification dated 02.07.2012 by the petitioner is that the order passed by the Collector for delimitation of the constituency is illegal. When we have found that the order passed by the Collector for delimitation of the constituency talukawise as per the provisions of Rule 3-A(8) cannot be said to be illegal, the challenge to the election program providing for different stages of election vide notification dated 02.07.2012 would fail. Consequently, no relief can be granted for setting aside the election notification declaring the various stages of elections vide order dated 02.07.2012 Hence, we find that the petition is meritless and deserves tobedismissed.
29. SCA Nos. 7009/12 with 10286/12 - These petitions have been preferred by the Ghayaj Milk Producers Cooperative Society Ltd. through its Chairman Shri Dineshbhai Balubhai Patel seeking direction to the respondents no. 1 and 2 to hold the election of the very society, i.e, the Baroda District Cooperative Milk Producers Union Ltd, Vadodara, which is also the subject matter of the above referred two petitions being SCA No. 12067/12 and 8905/12. The case of the petitioners in the present petitions is that the election of the said society be held as per the direction issued by the Registrar, Cooperative Societies, dated 06.07.2011 As considered by us while dealing with SCA No. 12067/12, we have found that the instructions issued by the District Registrar dated 06.07.2011 calling upon the Society to amend the bye-laws so as to bring them in conformity with the provisions of sub-rule(8) of Rule 3-A cannot be said as illegal since Rule 3-A(8) would be applicable to the society as the area of operation is exceeding one village. But the society in question did not amend the bye-laws and therefore the Collector in exercise of the power under sub-rule(9) of Rule 3-A has delimited the constituencies talukawise as per the scheme of Rule 3-A(8). Not only that, based on the delimited constituencies, the voters' list was prepared and the election program was also published vide order dated 02.07.2012 Under these circumstances, we find that no relief is required to be granted to the petitioners in the present petitions since the constituencies are already delimited by the Collector under sub-rule(9) as per the scheme of Rule 3-A(8) and further the election program is also published accordingly. Therefore, the petition as such can be said to have become infructuous.
So far as SCA No. 10286/12 is concerned, the same has been preferred by one Ankhi Dudh Utpadak Co-op. Society through its Chairman Shri Kantibhai Chhotabhai Patel which is a member cooperative society of Baroda District Cooperative Milk Producers Union Ltd. The prayers made in the petition are for issuance of the appropriate writ to set aside the notification dated 11.07.2012 and 13.07.2012, whereby on account of the election of legislative assembly, the exemption has been granted to all specified societies from holding the election including in case of societies where the election process had started. It appears that based on the said notification dated 11.07.2012 of the State Government for granting of exemption, the Collector has passed the order dated 13.07.2012 (Annexure-B), whereby election is postponed. No material is brought to our notice as to whether the election thereafter has been held or not but the fact remains that the life of the notification granting exemption dated 11.07.2012 was upto 31.12.2012 It has not been brought to our notice that such exemption was extended subsequently. As the exemption has expired, challenge to the notification dated 11.07.2012 would not survive and consequently, the challenge to the order dated 13.07.2012 for postponing the election would also not survive. However, it is observed that if the election has not been held pursuant to the earlier election program after the expiry of the period of exemption, the same be held in accordance with law.
Under these circumstances, SCA Nos. 7009/12 and 10286/12 deserve to be disposed of accordingly.
30. SCA No. 11998/12 - This petition has been preferred by the three members and shareholders of Narmada Khand Udhyog Sahakari Mandli Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as the “society in question”). The prayers are made in the petition for seeking appropriate writ to quash and set aside the notification dated 31.08.2012 published by the Election Officer for election of the society in question. One of the principal base of the petition is that the area of operation of the society is more than one village and therefore, bye-laws for election of the members of the managing committee has to be in conformity with the provisions of Rule 3-A(8). But in spite of that, the election has been held as per the bye-law no. 21(a)(b). It has been submitted that bye-law no. 21(a) would stand in conformity with sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A. It is also submitted that the constituencies were required to be delimited by the Collector under sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A. As per the petitioners, in spite of the aforesaid, the election was scheduled to be held of the members of the managing committee as per the bye-laws ignoring the provisions of Rule 3-A(8) and inspite of the direction given by the Registrar for amendment of the bye-laws so as to bring the bye-laws in conformity with the provisions of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A. It has been therefore submitted that the election programme be set aside and appropriate direction be issued for holding the election in accordance with Rule 3-A(8) and Rule 3-A(9) of the Rules of 1982.
It may be recorded that at the time when the petitions were preferred, the election process was on. However, this Court vide order dated 20.09.2012, when admitted the petition, observed that the election shall be subject to further orders of this Court. Therefore, the question is required to be examined of the legality and validity of the election already held as per the bye-laws and further direction to hold the election. It may also be recorded that pending the petition, the petitioners have disclosed the fact that the election was held and the elected representatives are joined as parties and the additional prayers are also made by way of amendments.
31. Bye-law no. 21(a) of the society provides for election of 15 representatives out of which minimum one shall be tribal/harijan and one member shall be woman and one member shall be small and marginal farmer. The pertinent aspect is that this has been provided as per bye-law no. 21(a) for one constituency. The second constituency as per bye-law no. 21(b) is for one representative of individual members. The area of operation is within the radius of 40 km. from the factory premises located in Narmada district. If the villages are considered, the election programme shows that Schedule-A with the bye-laws itself provides for number of villages to be included in the aforesaid area of operation.
As held by us earlier while deciding the legal issues, once the area of operation is more than one village, sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A would apply and the bye-laws, of the Society, to that extent are to be given go by or the bye-laws will stand automatically annulled by virtue of the provisions of Rule 3-A(8) of the Rules and therefore, when the constituencies were not delimited as per the provisions of Rule 3-A(8), it can be said that the process of election is vitiated.
Besides, the perusal of the election programme shows that for each of the constituency, the members narrated divisionwise for Vavdi, Rajpipla, Bhadam, Amletha, Pratapnagar, Ummla, Rajpardi, Jagadia, Valia, Dehli, Netrang and Bharuch, they themselves comprise of more than one village. Under these circumstances, it was all the more required for the Collector to exercise the power under Rule 3-A(9) for delimitation of the constituencies and thereafter, to hold the election.
The learned counsel for the private respondents and the society contended that the bye-laws were already registered by the Registrar, Cooperative Societies, and the elections were held according to the bye-laws in past and therefore, this Court may not upset the election which is already held and the result is declared.
It is hardly required to be stated that if the bye-laws are not in conformity with the provisions of the statutory rules and election has been held as per the bye-laws, is an aspect which goes to the root of the matter. If the statutory rules are not followed for holding the election notwithstanding anything contained in the bye-laws, it can be said that the whole process of the election is vitiated, the reason being that the very formation of the constituencies or the delimitation of the constituencies is not done in accordance with the statutory rules. Had the constituencies delimited as per the statutory Rule 3-A(8), the position would have been different inasmuch as the voters of the said constituencies would only be in a position to cast their vote and not of any other constituencies. By implementation of the bye-laws, which are dehors the statutory Rule 3-A(8), the consequence has arisen that the voters of other constituencies residing in the separate villages have cast their vote in favour of candidates which would otherwise not be permissible as per the scheme of Rule 3-A(8). In our view, once it is found that the voters of one constituency, not otherwise provided as per sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A have cast the vote for the representative of another or separate constituency, such would materially affect the result of the election inasmuch as, for eg., Divn 1 of Vavdi comprise of 50 villages, whereas division 2 Rajpipla consists of 13 villages, etc. Under these circumstances, it appears to us that there is no proportionate representation of the voters for electing their representative of their area, hence it can be said that the result of the election is materially affected. The aforesaid is an additional aspect to the aspect that the bye-laws on the basis of which the election has been held is not in conformity with the provisions of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A and the District Collector has failed to exercise the power for delimitation of the constituencies keeping in view the provisions of sub-rule(9) of Rule 3-A. Under these circumstances, we find that when the election is vitiated and it's result is materially affected, the statutory rule is required to be given effect and the election which was held and the result declared, being not in accordance with the statutory rules is required to be set aside. Considering the facts of the present case and taking into account the legal issues decided by us, we are of the considered opinion that the contention of the respondents to allow the elected representatives to continue to hold the office on a mere ground that the election of this type were held earlier, does not deserve to be accepted.
In the result, the election held of the members of the managing committee of respondent no. 4 society, as per the notification dated 31.08.2012 which deserves to be quashed and set aside is quashed and set aside. It is further directed that the election as per the scheme of sub-rule (8) of Rule 3-A shall be held and at that stage, the delimitation of the constituencies shall be made by the Collector under sub-rule (9) of Rule 3-A and the process shall be completed preferably within a period of 6 months from the receipt of the order of this Court. Until the election is held as directed and the newly elected representatives take over the charge of the office, the present body may continue as caretaker for looking after the day to day affairs, but any policy decision shall not be taken without prior approval of the Registrar (sugar) who is the competent authority as Registrar, Cooperative Societies. We do not find that other reliefs as prayed by the petitioners deserve to be granted considering the facts and circumstances of the case and hence the same shall stand rejected.
32. In view of the aforesaid observations and discussions, legal issues shall stand answered as per the conclusion recorded by us at paras 25 of the judgment.
33. SCA Nos. 12067/12 and 8905/12 shall stand dismissed. SCA Nos. 7009/12 and 10286/12 shall stand disposed of accordingly. SCA No. 11998/12 shall stand allowed to the aforesaid extent. Rule made absolute in SCA No. 11998/12. Subject to the aforesaid observations and directions, Rule shall stand discharged in SCA Nos. 7009/12 and 8905/12. Considering the facts and circumstances, no order as to costs.
Rule 3-A(8),