AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The Special Appeals challenge a judgment of a learned Single Judge dated 21.7.2014. The Single Judge directed the State-appellants to conclude a selection process initiated by an advertisement dated 15.1.2011 for direct recruitment of Class IV employees in the Rajasthan Secretariat and ordered the grant of bonus marks (weightage) in interview-based selections: 5 marks for contractual Class IV employees with five years' service and 10 marks for those with more than five years, in accordance with a Cabinet decision.

The underlying writ petitions were filed earlier: S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 3235/2004 (by Sachivalaya Dainik Vetan Bhogi Karamchari Union, Jaipur) and S.B. Civil Writ Petitions No. 8722/2005 & 4728/2006 by the petitioners (including Jagdish Prasad Gujar and Chhotelal). Those writ petitions sought reliefs relating to cancellation of fresh tenders for placement agencies, quashing of respondents' registration under the Contract Labour (Regulation & Abolition) Act, 1970, and challenged terminations and sought regularization. After those petitions, regular selections were advertised under the rules, including the 15.1.2011 advertisement for 289 vacancies.

The learned Advocate General (for State-appellants) contended that the Single Judge exceeded jurisdiction by granting bonus marks and directing appointments despite the original writ petitions (filed in 2005 and 2006) not seeking such reliefs or amending pleadings to place the 2011 advertisement before the court. Counsel for the respondents relied on a settlement recorded in D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9836/2002 (Vinod Kumar v. State of Rajasthan) dated 28.1.2003, which provided for weightage and relaxation for contractual Class IV employees at the time of regular selections.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the learned Single Judge exceeded jurisdiction by issuing directions to grant bonus marks (weightage) and to declare results and appoint candidates in respect of the selections advertised on 15.1.2011, when such reliefs were not sought in the original writ petitions and no amendment to pleadings was made.
  2. Whether the settlement dated 28.1.2003 (in Vinod Kumar) entitles contractual Class IV employees to weightage/relaxation in the 2011 regular selections and, if so, to what extent.
  3. Whether subsequent events and judgments (including judgments on award of bonus marks) can be taken into account by the court in deciding earlier-filed writ petitions without amendment and without giving parties an opportunity to be heard.
  4. Whether, in light of the Supreme Court decision in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi, the settlement dated 28.1.2003 could be enforced to secure regularization or confer bonus marks/weightage contrary to the rules established by that decision.

Arguments of the Parties

State-Appellants (Learned Advocate General)

  • The original writ petitions (filed in 2005 & 2006) did not seek any relief relating to the selections advertised in 2011; nor were pleadings or reliefs amended to place those events before the Single Judge.
  • The Single Judge erred in taking into account subsequent events and other judgments, and in accepting an on-record statement by an officer when advocates were on strike (21.7.2014), leading to directions that went beyond the scope of the writ petitions.
  • The Single Judge exceeded jurisdiction by directing the award of bonus marks, declaring results, and directing appointments without independent approval and without opportunity for the State to contest those matters.

Respondents (Learned Counsel for Respondents / Petitioners below)

  • The settlement dated 28.1.2003 (recorded in Vinod Kumar v. State of Rajasthan and connected matters) binds the State as a model employer; it provides that when regular selections are made the petitioners (contractual Class IV employees) shall be given weightage as well as relaxation in eligibility conditions, subject to satisfactory performance and competition.
  • Contractual Class IV employees who have served for many years (allegedly 10–15 years) are entitled to benefit of that settlement in the regular selections, and thus the reliefs granted by the Single Judge flow from the settlement and prior decisions upholding award of bonus marks.
  • The 2011 selections were held up by judicial decisions regarding the award of bonus marks; respondents pointed to a judgment (Archana v. State of Rajasthan) in which award of bonus marks was upheld (confined to 15 marks) and which had a pending Special Leave Petition in the Supreme Court.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (2006) 4 SCC 1 Constitution Bench ruling that courts should not regularize employees except in accordance with the Rules; the law on regularization was revisited and settled. The Court held that the settlement dated 28.1.2003 preceded Uma Devi and observed that the settlement could not be enforced in view of the conclusive judgment in Uma Devi. The Court refused to enter into adjudication that would effectively regularize employees or validate weightage contrary to Uma Devi.
Sheshambal (Dead) Through LRs v. Chelur Corporation Chelur Building (2010) 3 SCC 470 Principle that in certain control litigation (e.g., rent and eviction matters) subsequent events may be taken into account to do substantial justice; but subsequent events should be considered only after appropriate amendment and opportunity to respondents. The Court relied on this principle to state that subsequent events can be considered only upon appropriate amendment of pleadings and with time given to respondents to reply; it distinguished the present matter and found that the Single Judge could not collect such subsequent facts in the absence of amended pleadings and without counsel being present.
Gaiv Dinshaw Irani v. Tehmtan Irani (Civil Appeal No. 4888 of 2014, decided 25.4.2014) Similar view to Sheshambal about taking notice of subsequent events in certain matters (context given in text). The Court cited this decision as supporting the limited principle that subsequent events may be considered in appropriate contexts, but reiterated that such consideration requires amended pleadings and due opportunity to the parties—something not done here.
Vinod Kumar v. The State of Rajasthan (D.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 9836/2002) — settlement dated 28.1.2003 The recorded settlement provided (inter alia) that on regular selections contractual employees would be given weightage as well as relaxation in eligibility conditions; also provided for consideration of a specified circular by the Government. The respondents relied on this settlement to claim entitlement to weightage in subsequent regular selections. The Court reviewed the settlement but held that it did not specify the extent of weightage, that it preceded Uma Devi, and that its enforcement is constrained by the law in Uma Devi; the Court declined to adjudicate the precise extent or percentage of weightage under the settlement.
Archana v. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 4144/2013) Referred to as a judgment of this Court upholding the award of bonus marks (confined to 15 marks instead of 30); the State had filed a Special Leave Petition in the Supreme Court which was pending. The Court noted that the 2011 selections were held up because of decisions like the Archana judgment and that the State had an SLP pending; the Court did not decide the correctness of award of bonus marks relied upon in Archana but observed the pendency of further proceedings.
Jagdish Prasad Gujar v. State of Rajasthan (S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 8722/2005) and Chhotelal v. State of Rajasthan & Ors. (S.B. Civil Writ Petition No. 4728/2006) These writ petitions challenged termination of petitioners serving on contract through placement agencies and sought regularization; they form part of the factual and procedural background. The Court treated these petitions as part of the background and noted that the Single Judge's directions went beyond the reliefs sought in those petitions. These cases were not relied upon as legal precedent to support the Single Judge's bonus-mark directions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded through several linked steps, grounded in the record and the precedents cited in the opinion:

  1. Scope of pleadings and reliefs: The Court examined the reliefs sought in the writ petitions filed in 2004–2006 and noted that no application was made in those writ petitions to seek reliefs relating to the 2011 advertisement, nor were the pleadings amended to bring facts about the 2011 selections and the desired award of bonus marks on record. Thus, the Court held that the Single Judge's directions awarding bonus marks and directing appointment went beyond the scope of the original petitions.
  2. Procedural fairness and consideration of subsequent events: The Court accepted the principle (from Sheshambal and Gaiv Dinshaw Irani) that subsequent events may be considered in appropriate litigation, but emphasized that such consideration must be on an appropriate amendment application so that respondents have time and opportunity to reply. The Court criticized the Single Judge for accepting facts gathered on the record (including a statement by an officer on 21.7.2014 when advocates were on strike) and for acting without giving the State an opportunity to contest matters relating to bonus marks and appointments.
  3. Nature and content of the settlement (Vinod Kumar): The Court reviewed the settlement dated 28.1.2003 which provided that contractual employees would be given weightage and relaxation when regular selections occurred. The Court observed that the settlement did not specify the extent (percentage) of weightage to be given and that the settlement predated the Supreme Court's decision in Uma Devi.
  4. Impact of Uma Devi: The Court applied the principle from Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi that courts cannot regularize employees except according to the Rules. Given that the settlement predated Uma Devi, the Court viewed the enforceability of the settlement as constrained by Uma Devi and declined to enforce the settlement in a manner that would conflict with that Supreme Court precedent.
  5. Judicial restraint on awarding weightage: The Court expressly refrained from adjudicating the precise percentage or validity of bonus marks/weightage (including whether bonus marks awarded post-Uma Devi are valid). It allowed the State discretion to consider (or not) giving weightage in selections in accordance with law and statutory rules, but rejected the Single Judge's exercise of jurisdiction to impose a specific award of bonus marks and direct appointments.
  6. Conclusion on Single Judge's order: For these reasons—exceeding jurisdiction, absence of amended pleadings to place subsequent events before the court, procedural unfairness, and constraints posed by Uma Devi—the Court concluded the Single Judge's directions could not be sustained.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The Special Appeals are allowed and the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 21.7.2014 (which directed conclusion of the 2011 selection process and ordered the award of bonus marks and consequential declarations/appointments) is set aside.

Implications and immediate consequences:

  • The directions issued by the Single Judge to award specific bonus marks and to declare results and appoint selected candidates within two months cannot be sustained and are vacated.
  • The State Government retains discretion, in accordance with applicable Rules and law, to consider whether to grant any weightage to contractual Class IV employees in regular selections; the Court declined to prescribe the quantum of such weightage.
  • The Court refrained from expressing any final opinion on the validity of bonus marks awarded after the Supreme Court's decision in Uma Devi, noting that the settlement dated 28.1.2003 preceded Uma Devi and could not be enforced contrary to that conclusive Supreme Court ruling.
  • No new legal rule or precedent was established by this decision beyond applying the settled principles (notably Uma Devi and the procedural constraints on taking subsequent events into account). The immediate effect is to set aside the Single Judge's order; a copy of this judgment will be placed in all connected files.

This summary is confined to the information expressly contained in the provided opinion and does not infer facts or legal propositions beyond the text.

    The State Of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Sachivalaya Dainik Vetan Bhogi Karamchari Union, Jaipur

    1. We have heard learned Advocate General appearing for the State-appellants and learned counsel appearing for the respondents.

    2. In these Special Appeals, a judgment of learned Single Judge dated 21.7.2014 is under challenge, by which learned Single Judge has issued directions to the State-appellants to conclude the selection process initiated by the advertisement dated 15.1.2011, for direct recruitment of Class IV employees in the Secretariat of the Government of Rajasthan, and to grant bonus marks, in the selections, which is to be held by way of interviews; for 50 marks to be given to each of the candidate, in accordance with the decision taken by the State Cabinet, providing for award of 5 bonus marks to those contractual Class IV employees, who have completed five years of service, and 10 bonus marks to those, who have completed more than five years of service.

    3. Learned Advocate General states that S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 3235/2004 was filed by Sachivalaya Dainik Vetan Bhogi Karamchari Union, Jaipur and S.B Civil Writ Petitions No. 8722/2005 & 4728/2006 by the petitioners, with the prayers that fresh tenders for placement agencies, to provide services of Class IV employees on contract, be cancelled, and that, the condition, providing for such number of employees as are required, be declared to be illegal. Prayers were also made that the registration of the respondents as a registered employer under the Contract Labour Regulation and Abolition Act, 1970 (Central Act) be quashed, and that, the respondents be restrained from proceeding with the tender dated 8.4.2004, till such time as condition No. 3 is not modified in terms of the order dated 28.1.2003 The S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 8722/2005 (Jagdish Prasad Gujar v. State of Rajasthan) and S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 4728/2006 (Chhotelal v. State Of Raj. & Ors.—(143)) were filed, challenging the orders of the termination of the petitioners serving on contract, through placement agencies, and for their regularization.

    4. Learned Advocate General states that after filing of the writ petitions, regular selections were advertised under the Rules to fill up substantive vacancies. An advertisement dated 15.1.2011 was issued to fill up 289 vacancies. There was no application filed in the writ petitions, filed in the years 2005 & 2006, nor any amendment was sought in the pleadings, grounds or reliefs. Learned Single Judge erred in exceeding his jurisdiction, in taking into consideration the subsequent events as well as the judgments of this Court, regarding award of bonus marks, as also Special Leave Petitions filed by State of Rajasthan, and thereafter, with reference to Cabinet's decision taken with regard to award of 5 bonus marks to the contractual employees of Class IV in the subject selection, who have completed five years of service and 10 bonus marks to those, who have completed more than five years of service, directed the grant of bonus marks, for which independent approval. It is submitted that learned Single Judge erred in law in giving directions to award bonus marks, and further, to declare the results, and pass appropriate orders of appointment of selected candidates within two months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of the order. It is submitted that the entire discussion made in the judgment and the directions given, have no foundation in the writ petitions. The State Government did not get an opportunity to contest the matter. The Court accepted the statement given by the officer incharge on 21.7.2014, when the Advocates were on strike and the lawyers were not appearing, in deciding the writ petitions.

    5. Learned counsel for the respondents states that the State Government, as a model employer, is bound by the settlement, which was arrived at in D.B Civil Writ Petition No. 9836/2002 (Vinod Kumar v. The State of Rajasthan) and other four connected writ petitions, which were disposed of, in terms of the settlement dated 28.1.2003 The Settlement reads as follows:-

    “Learned counsel for the parties submit that the parties have settled the matter and the terms of settlement have been reduced in to writing. The learned counsel for the parties have presented the same before us for being kept on record and for passing appropriate directions.

    Having regard to the terms of settlement, we direct as follows:-

    (1) As per condition No. 4 of the conditions of Tender, it would be incumbent upon the contractor (New Contractor) to continue with the services of the existing employees (petitioners) upon the award of the contract to him subject to their identity being verified and subject also to verification of their suitability.

    (2) In the event of the Government making regular selections for the vacant posts of Farrash/Sweeper/Class IV/Helper etc. the petitioners shall be given weightage as well as relaxation in the eligibility condition keeping in view their long duration of past services subject to their satisfactory performance.

    (3) Subject to the giving of weightage and relaxation in the eligibility condition, the petitioners will have to compete with others, in case, the Government intends to make regular selections on the vacant posts of Farrash/Sweeper/Class IV/Helper etc. and

    (4) In case, the petitioners make applications or file representation before the Government, requesting it to grant benefit of Circular No. F.1(5) FD/Rules/2002 dated 13.01.2003 to them the same shall be considered by the Government within a reasonable period of time. Any decision taken by the Government on the applications or representations of the petitioners shall be binding on the contractor(s).

    Both the parties have agreed to the passing of the aforesaid directions.

    Keeping in view the directions issued by us and the settlement arrived at between the parties, the petitioners wish to withdraw the writ petitions.

    Accordingly, the writ petitions are allowed to be withdrawn. The withdrawal of these writ petitions however, will not affect the directions contained in the order and the department will be free to call for fresh tenders.

    The writ petitions stand disposed of.”

    6. It is submitted that though the settlement was arrived at on 28.1.2003 and that the new contractor continued upto the year 2006, in the regular selections, the Class IV employees engaged through placement agency, are entitled to the weightage and relaxation in the eligibility conditions in terms of paragraphs 2 & 3 of the settlement agreement, whenever the regular selections take place on the vacant posts of Farrash/Sweeper/Class-IV/Helper etc. The selections advertised in the year 2011, have been held up, on account of the decision taken by this Court, in which, while upholding the award of bonus marks, confined it to 15 as against the 30 marks, in selections. The State Government has filed a Special Leave Petition against the judgment of this Court in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 4144/2013 (Archana v. State of Rajasthan), in the Apex Court, which is still pending.

    7. There are about 158 persons working as Class IV employees in the Secretariat on contractual basis. They are being paid Rs. 166/- per day, on the days they are allowed to work. It is alleged that they are waiting for regular employment for last 10 to 15 years, and that even if they were appointed dehors the Rules through placement agency, the award of bonus marks is provided to be given by way of weightage under the settlement dated 28.1.2003

    8. We do not find any force in the submission made by the respondents. In the settlement dated 28.1.2003, it was provided that whenever regular selections are made, weightage will be given to the contractual employees. The settlement was arrived at before the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (2006) 4 SCC 1, in which the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court revisited and settled the law with regard to regularization and stopped the Courts, from regularizing the employees, except in accordance with the Rules. In the present case, the Court was not concerned, nor any prayers were made to regularize the employees working on contract. The question relates to giving weightage to them for their services, in the regular selections. The questions, that have been decided by learned Single Judge beyond the scope of the writ petition. The judgment relied on by learned counsel for the respondents, in Sheshambal (Dead) Through LRs v. Chelur Corporation Chelur Building (2010) 3 SCC 470, and the judgment of the Supreme Court in Gaiv Dinshaw Irani v. Tehmtan Irani (Civil Appeal No. 4888 of 2014, decided on 25.4.2014).

    9. In Sheshambal (Dead) Through LRs v. Chelur Corporation Chelur Building (supra), the Court was dealing with a control litigation. It is fairly well settled that in the rent and eviction matters, unless the Court takes notice of the subsequent events, substantial justice cannot be done with the parties. Same view was taken by the Supreme Court in Gaiv Dinshaw Irani v. Tehmtan Irani (supra). It cannot however be denied that subsequent events can be taken into consideration by the Court only on an appropriate amendment application, which may amend the pleadings, and for which sufficient time is given to the respondents, to reply. The Court cannot, on its own, gather facts by asking parties, in the absence of their counsels, and to take note of the judgments, which have been rendered in the cases, which do not have bearing on the case, in deciding the issues, which have material bearing on the rights of the parties.

    10. In the present case, the petitioners, who are respondents before us, did not care to amend the writ petition. The record shows that an application was filed, in which the facts relating to the advertisement were brought on record, and that, in para 5, a reference was made to the judgment rendered in S.B Civil Writ Petition No. 4144/2013 (Archana v. State of Rajasthan) decided at Jodhpur on 25.9.2013

    The application was made with the following prayer:-

    “It is, therefore, prayed that the application filed by the petitioner may be allowed and respondents may be directed to declare the result of Class-IV employees and give appointment to the members of the petitioner Union who are continuously discharging their duties as class IV employees from last 15-20 years on daily wages basis.”

    11. Apart from the aforesaid application, there is nothing on record to support the observations and the findings recorded by learned Single Judge.

    12. We are of the view that the question of award of bonus marks was entirely beyond the powers of adjudication of learned Single Judge, inasmuch as, neither the selections were challenged, nor any prayer was made to award bonus marks to the petitioners. No such facts or prayer could be foreseen, when the writ petition was filed, nor the writ petitions were amended, bringing these facts on record.

    13. The settlement dated 28.1.2003, was arrived at prior to the filing of the writ petition. The entire object to file the writ petition was to restrain the service providers to recommend fresh names, or the names, excluding the petitioners. They had claimed weightage to be given in pursuance to the settlement dated 28.1.2003 in regular selections. The extent of weightage, which may be given by the State Government, was not provided in the settlement, nor the parties joined issue on the point.

    14. We do not propose to adjudicate over the percentage of bonus marks. The State Government, may consider to give, or may not give any weightage to the petitioners in the selections or may adopt a principle that, all things being equal, the person with experience may be preferred for employment. No such matter could have been adjudicated by learned Single Judge. We are also restraining ourselves from expressing any opinion as to whether the award of bonus marks, after the judgment in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (supra), will be valid. In Supreme Court, an application has been filed by the State of Rajasthan to withdraw the Special Leave Petition. Learned Advocate General states that the application is still pending.

    15. Be that as it may, the question of weightage in regular selections in accordance with law, may also depend upon statutory Rules. We may also observe here, that the settlement could not be enforced, in view of the conclusive judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (supra).

    16. In view of the above discussion, the directions issued by learned Single Judge cannot be sustained.

    17. The Special Appeals are allowed. The judgment of learned Single Judge is set aside.

    A copy of this judgment will be placed in all the connected files.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    The State Of Rajasthan & Ors. v. Sachivalaya Dainik Vetan Bhogi Karamchari Union, Jaipur
    (Nov 27, 2014)