Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    M/S. Shrinathji Sadi v. M/S. Sadi Sansar

    ORDER

    This order will govern disposal of Arbitration Appeals No. 29/2011 and 30/2011 since both these appeals have been filed against similar order passed by Additional District Judge on similar facts situation against the common respondents.

    These appeals under Section 37 of Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (for short the Act) have been filed against the order of Additional District Judge Indore dated 1/4/2011 passed on an application under Section 34 of the Act. For convenience, the facts have been noted from Arbitration Appeal No. 30/2011.

    In brief, the appellant had filed statement of claim before the arbitrator under Section 23 of the Act stating that the appellant is engaged in the business of cloths and that respondents had purchased the cloths on credit by accepting the conditions in advance mentioned in the bill and related documents but had not made the payment, therefore, the dispute had arisen between the parties and a claim of Rs. 33,196/- was filed before the arbitrator. The arbitrator had proceeded exparte against the respondents and had passed the award of Rs. 24,071/- alongwith interest @ 1.5% per month from the date of claim i.e 5/8/2008 with cost. The respondents had filed application under Section 34 of Act before Additional District Judge and the Additional District Judge by the impugned order dated 1/4/2011 has allowed the objection and has set aside the ex-parte award on reaching to the conclusion that there was no arbitration agreement between the parties.

    Learned counsel for appellant submits that in terms of the invoice issued to the respondents mentioning about arbitration, the arbitration clause existed between the parties and that no evidence was led by the respondents in support of their claim before the learned Additional District Judge. He further submits that respondents had not raised any objection before the arbitrator therefore, in terms of Section 4 of the Act he had waived his right to raise the objection that arbitration agreement does not exist.

    I have heard learned counsel for appellant and perused the record.

    The learned Additional District Judge has elaborately dealt with the the issue of absence of the arbitration agreement between the parties. It has been noted that the appellant had not filed any arbitration agreement between the parties and that the matter can be referred to the arbitration only if the arbitration agreement exists between the parties. In absence of any written agreement it has been found that the claim was contrary to Section 7(3) of the Act. It has also been noted that the claim of appellant is based upon the invoice stating about the arbitration but there is no signature of the respondents in the said invoice. There is also no proof that in terms of the said invoice the delivery of goods was done. No delivery challan was proved before the arbitrator. There was no material produced before the learned Additional District Judge to come to the conclusion that a concluded arbitration agreement existed between the parties therefore, the learned Additional District Judge had reached to the conclusion that though no arbitration agreement exist between the parties yet the arbitrator had passed the impugned award. The Additional District Judge has accordingly set aside the arbitral award.

    I have perused the original record of arbitration proceeding. In the statement of claim filed before the arbitrator the appellant has not stated anywhere that there was any arbitration agreement by virtue of the conditions contained in the invoice or the said arbitration clause was accepted by the respondent or there was any arbitration agreement as required by section 7 of the Act. There was no mention of any arbitration agreement between the parties in the statement of claim. The reference of the alleged arbitration clause in the invoice by the arbitrator is on his own without there being any plea in this regard.

    Counsel for appellant has also placed reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme court in the matter of Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd. v. Motorola India Pvt. Ltd., reported in AIR 2009 SC 357 but in that case also it has been held that inspite of knowledge of non compliance of requirement under the arbitration agreement if a party proceeds with the arbitration without raising objection, then it waives the right but in the present case arbitration agreement itself has not proved. Counsel for appellant referring to the invoice filed before the Arbitrator has also submitted that in the sale invoices there is a clear mention that “all payments and disputes are handled by arbitrator which is accepted by both the parties under Arbitration Act” and therefore, there was an arbitration agreement between the parties but such a submission has rightly been rejected by the learned Additional District Judge by noting that the invoices do not contain the signature of the respondent and there is no proof of delivery of goods in pursuance to the invoice. Arbitrator has also not recorded any finding in respect of acceptance of such an arbitration condition by the respondent.

    Counsel for appellant has failed to point out any material indicating that the arbitration clause mentioned in the invoices was accepted by the respondents, to result into arbitration agreement in terms of section 7. Thus, merely on the basis of the arbitration clause mentioned in the invoices without any proof of acceptance of that clause, it cannot be held that any arbitration agreement had come into existence between the parties. Thus, the learned Additional District Judge has not committed any error in holding that no arbitration agreement exists between the parties.

    Counsel for the appellant has also relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the matter of Gas Authority of India Ltd. v. Keti Construction (I) Ltd., reported in (2007) 5 SCC 38 but the benefit of the said judgment cannot be granted to him considering the circumstances in which the respondent has failed to appear before the Arbitrator and also considering the fact that arbitration proceedings were conducted without there being an arbitration agreement.

    Keeping in view the above analysis, I also do not find any substance in the argument advanced on the basis of Section 4 of the Act.

    Hence, I am of the opinion that the appeals are devoid of any merit, which are accordingly dismissed. The signed order be placed in the record of A.A No. 30 of 2011 and a copy thereof be kept in the file of A.A No. 29 of 2011.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    M/S. Shrinathji Sadi v. M/S. Sadi Sansar
    (Dec 2, 2014)