ORAL JUDGMENT
(PER: HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE Mr. VIJAY MANOHAR SAHAI)
We have heard learned senior advocate Mr. S.N Shelat assisted by learned advocate Mr. Hriday Buch for the petitioners. This petition has been filed for the following reliefs:
(A) Issue a writ of declaration, declaring that:
(a) Section 5(3)(iii)(a) and 29A of the Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 and
(b) Sections 2 and 3 of the Gujarat Local Authorities Laws (Amendment) Act, 2009, as being ultra vires the Constitution of India as it violates one member one ward mandate;
(B) Issue a writ of declaration declaring that Rule 4 and Rule 5 of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporation (Delimitation of Wards in the City and Allocation of Reserved Seats) Rules, 1994 (including amendment of 2015) as being ultra vires the Constitution of India;
(C) Issue a writ of declaration, declaring Notification No. KV-194 of 2014-ELE-102014-1701-P dtd. 4.12.2014 as well as other Notification dated 15.1.2015 issued by State of Gujarat as ultra vires the Constitution of India and/or Gujarat Local Authorities Laws (Amendment) Act, 2009 and/or Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949;
(D) Quash and set aside the order dated 11.12.2014 passed by the State Election Commission under Section 5(3)((iii)(b) of the Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949.”
2. The petitioners have challenged vires of Section 5(3)(iii)(a) and Section 29A of the Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949 and Sections 2 and 3 of the Gujarat Local Authorities Laws (Amendment) Act, 2009 as being ultra vires to the Constitution of India as it violates one member one ward mandate. The petitioners have challenged Rules 4 and 5 of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporation (Delimitation of Wards in the City and Allocation of Reserved Seats) Rules, 1994 including amendment of 2015 as being ultra vires to the Constitution of India. The petitioners have also challenged Notification dated 14.12.2014 and 15.1.2015 issued by State of Gujarat as ultra vires to the Constitution of India as well as Gujarat Local Authorities Laws (Amendment) Act, 2009 and Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949.
3. Earlier also before this Court the vires of Section 5(3)(iii)(a) and Sections 29A(2)(a) and 29A(3)(a) of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporation Act, 1949, as also Rule 4 of the Bombay Provincial Municipal Corporations (Delimitation of Wards in the City and Allocation of Reserved Seats) Rule, 1994 and Rule 2(b) of Gujarat Municipal Corporation Wards Committee Functions, Duties, Territorial Areas and Procedure for Transaction of Business Rules, 2007 were challenged and the Division Bench in paragraph No. 14 of its judgement at page 147 has upheld validity of the Sections and the Rules. The petitioners have tried to raise the same issue with slight modification that now they are challenging the amendment made on 15.1.2015 by which the number of councillors in a particular ward has been increased to 4 under Section 5(3)(iii)(a) of the Gujarat Provincial Municipal Corporation Act. Since the validity of the Rules has already been upheld by the Division Bench and only in numbers of members have been increased from three to four, in our opinion, this will not be invalid and unconstitutional. The issue in this petition is covered by the Division Bench judgement of this Court in the case of Pankajsinh Waghela v. State Election Commission through Election Commissioner decided on 13.8.2010 reported in 2010 (3) GLH 523. In that petition the argument of the petitioner that one ward one councillor has not been accepted by the Division Bench.
4. For the aforesaid reasons, we do not find any merit in this petition. This writ petition fails and is accordingly dismissed.