Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The respondent, a resident of Kurnool, sued the defendants, commission agents conducting business in Madras, for damages. The claim arose from the defendants allegedly selling the respondent's goods at undervalued rates without the respondent's knowledge, consent, or instructions, contrary to established business practice. The agency contract was formed through postal communications, whereby the respondent sent goods to the defendants in Madras, who advanced money, honored hundies, sold the goods as commission agents, and appropriated the balance of sale proceeds after deducting commissions. The suit was instituted in the District Court of Kurnool. The District Judge held that the court had jurisdiction and ruled in favor of the plaintiff on merits. The appeal solely contested the jurisdiction of the District Court of Kurnool.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the District Court of Kurnool had jurisdiction to entertain the suit.
  2. If the suit is regarded as founded on tort, where did the cause of action arise for jurisdictional purposes?
  3. If the suit arises out of contract, whether Kurnool was the place where the contract was made, to be performed, or where the amount sued for was payable.
  4. Whether the contract was made at Madras or Kurnool under the provisions of the Indian Contract Act and the Civil Procedure Code.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent's pleader contended that the amount sued for was payable at Kurnool in performance of the contract, relying on clauses (i) and (iii) of explanation III to section 17 of the Civil Procedure Code.
  • Argued that under section 218 of the Contract Act, the agent was bound to pay the principal at his residence, implying payment was due at Kurnool.
  • Maintained that the contract was made at Kurnool or that the amount was payable there, justifying jurisdiction.

Court's Observations on Arguments

  • The court rejected the applicability of clause (iii) as the amount claimed was damages for breach, not an amount payable in performance of the contract.
  • Clarified that section 218 refers to balances due after accounting for advances and remuneration, whereas the suit was for damages under section 212 for agent's neglect or misconduct.
  • Held that no authority supports the position that damages for breach must be paid at the principal's residence.
  • Determined the contract was made at Madras where the acceptance was posted and came to defendants' knowledge.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Newcomb v. DeRoos Contract is made where acceptance is posted and received, determining place of contract and cause of action. Supported the court's conclusion that contract was made at the place where acceptance was posted (Madras).
Taylor v. Jones Contract made and cause of action arose at place where offer was made and accepted by conduct. Illustrated that contract formation depends on place of offer and acceptance, reinforcing the court's jurisdictional analysis.
Savigny on Conflict of Laws (Guthrie's Translation) Contract concluded where first letter is received and assenting answer dispatched by receiver; contract completion location. Used to analyze and confirm the principle that contract is made where acceptance is posted, despite theoretical exceptions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed the jurisdiction issue by first distinguishing whether the suit was founded on tort or contract. It held that as a tort, the cause of action arose in Madras, not Kurnool. Considering the suit as contractual, the court examined explanation III to section 17 of the Civil Procedure Code to determine the place of contract formation or performance. The court rejected the argument that the amount sued for was payable at Kurnool, clarifying that the claim was for damages (unliquidated) under section 212 of the Contract Act, not for sums payable under section 218. The court then applied sections 4, 5, and 6 of the Contract Act, concluding that the contract was made in Madras where the plaintiff's proposal was received and the defendants' acceptance was posted, thereby completing the contract at that place. The court acknowledged that under Indian law the contract becomes complete when acceptance is posted, although it remains voidable by the acceptor until the proposer receives the acceptance. The court found the respondent's contention that the contract was made at Kurnool untenable, emphasizing established legal principles and precedents supporting contract formation at the place of acceptance posting.

Holding and Implications

The court ALLOWED THE APPEAL, set aside the decree of the District Court of Kurnool, and held that the District Court of Kurnool had no jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The plaint was directed to be returned for presentation to the proper court competent to try the matter, presumably in Madras.

The decision directly affects the parties by requiring the suit to be pursued in the appropriate jurisdiction. The court did not establish any new precedent but reaffirmed existing principles regarding jurisdiction and contract formation under the Indian Contract Act and Civil Procedure Code.

    Kamisetti Subbiah v. Katha Venkatasawmy

    JUDGMENT

    The respondent a resident, of Kurnool, sues the defendants, who are commission agents carrying on business in Madras, for damages alleged to have been caused to the plaintiff inconsequence of “the unwarranted action of the defendants in selling the plaintiff's goods at rates at which they ought not to have sold, without the knowledge, consent and instructions of the plaintiff and contrary to the course of business always followed.” The contract of agency was concluded by postal communications between the plaintiff and the defendants and the dealings consisted “in the plaintiff sending goods to the defendants (at Madras) from time to time and the defendants making advances or lending moneys or honouring and paying plaintiff's hundies drawn on them in Madras on the security of the said goods and selling the same in Madras as plaintiff's commission agents,” and appropriating the balance of sale proceeds (after deducting the commission due to them) towards the amounts due to them.

    The suit was brought in the District Court of Kurnool, and the first issue framed in the case was whether the District Court of Kurnool had jurisdiction to entertain the suit. The District Judge held that be had jurisdiction inasmuch as the dealings of the parties were begun and carried on by letters written from Kurnool to Madras and from Madras to Kurnool and therefore the suit could be instituted at either place, and gave a decree in favour of the plaintiff on the merits. The only point argued in the appeal is the question of jurisdiction. We are unable to concur in the view taken by the District Judge and must hold that the District Court of Kurnool had no jurisdiction to entertain the suit. If the suit is regarded as one founded on tort, by reason of the defendants' neglect or misconduct in selling the plaintiff's goods at an undervalue, it is clear that the cause of action arose [(vide section 17(a), Civil Procedure Code] in Madras and not in Kurnool. But viewing the suit as one arising out of contract, within the meaning of explanation III to section 17, Civil Procedure Code, and this, we think, is the character of the suit for purposes of determining the forum the question is whether it can be held upon the admitted facts that Kurnool was (I) “The place where the contract was made” or (II) “the place where the contract was to be performed” or its performance completed, or (iii) “the place where in performance of the contract” the amount sued for was expressly or impliedly payable. Clause (ii) of explanation (iii) is clearly inapplicable to the case and the respondent's pleader did not rely upon it; but be relied upon both clause (i) and clause (iii) We are clearly of opinion that clause (iii) is also inapplicable to this suit, inasmuch as the amount sued for is really, as it purports to be, in the nature of damages for alleged breach of contract and not an amount payable in performance of the contract. The respondent's pleader argued as if the amount, which the plaintiff seeks to recover in this action were a sum which the agent was bound, under section 218 of the Contract Act, to pay to his principal; and on this footing he contended that the agent was bound to seek the principal and pay or tender the money and that therefore the money was payable at Kurnool, in performance of the contract of agency. But a reference to sections 217 and 218, of the Contract Act will clearly show that the sum referred to in section 218 is the balance remaining with the agent out of the sums “received on account of the principal in the business of the agency” (after deducting therefrom, all moneys due to the agent in respect of advances made or expenses incurred by him in conducting the agency business and also such remuneration as may be payable to him for acting as agent). The present suit is one brought really under section 212 of the Contract Act for compensation which the agent is bound to make to his principal “in respect of the direct consequences of his own neglect or want of skill or misconduct.” It is therefore unnecessary to consider the various cases cited on both sides and decide in this appeal whether an agent is bound to render on demand proper accounts to has principal at the place of residence of the latter and seek his principal and pay at his residence, the sums payable to him under section 218 of the Contract Act. There, is no authority whatever for the position that a party committing a breach of contract should seek, the other party to the contract and pay him, at his residence, compensation or damages for such breach of contract—which of course is an unliquidated amount, not to say that clause (iii) of section 17, Civil Procedure Code, refers only to an amount payable in “performance of the contract.” The only question that has to be decided therefore is whether the “contract was made” in Madras or in Kurnool; and this depends principally upon sections 4, 5 and 6 of the Contract Act. In our opinion the contract was made in Madras, where the plaintiff's proposal—sent by post—came to the knowledge of the defendants and where the defendants' acceptance was posted and was thus put in a course of transmission to the plaintiff so as to be out of the power of the defendants. Under the Indian Contract Act, it is true that the contract is not complete in the sense that neither party can recede therefrom until the acceptance comes to the knowledge of the proposer. But at the time when the acceptance is posted, the contract becomes complete as against the proposer and any communication (from the proposer) which reaches the acceptor after this moment, revoking, the proposal, is altogether inoperative. As against the acceptor, however, the contract is not complete at that moment and can be avoided by him by communicating to the proposer, a revocation of the acceptance, before the acceptance reaches him. Under the English law, this seems to remain still an open question (see Pollock on ‘Contracts,’ seventh edition, page 35), though in all probability, English Courts may now be bound to hold that an unqualified acceptance once posted cannot be revoked even by a telegram or special messenger outstripping its arrival (ibid., page 36). The learned pleader, for the respondents, argues that the contract could not be held to have taken place at the moment of the posting of the acceptance inasmuch as the acceptor could have receded from it before the acceptance reached the proposer. There is, however, the anomaly—if it be an anomaly—that the other party could not recede from it. If a contract be not concluded it should, of course, be open to either party to recede from it; and this being so it cannot successfully be contended that the contract is not concluded when the letter of acceptance is posted for admittedly the proposer is no longer at liberty to recede. The conclusion, we came to is that the contract is made at the time and at the place when and where the letter of acceptance is posted, but that, under the Indian Contract Act, at any rate, the contract is voidable at the instance of the acceptor by communication of his revocation before the acceptance has come to the knowledge of the proposer. In Newcomb v. DeRoos(1), the offer was made by the defendant from London by letter addressed to the plaintiff at Stampford. It was received by the plaintiff at Stampford and the letter of acceptance also posted there. It was held that the contract was made at Stampford; and it was further held in that case that the whole cause of action, i.e, the contract as well as the work to be done thereunder, arose at Stampford. In Taylor v. Jones, the converse of this case, where an offer to buy goods was made by letter posted in the City of London and was accepted not by a letter but by sending the goods to the proposer's place of business in the city, it was held that the contract was made and the whole cause of action arose in the City of London. The question as to where a contract is made is fully considered and discussed by Savigny in has treatise on the Conflict of Laws—Guthrie's ‘Translation,’ second edition, pages 214 and 215, etc., and he answers it without hesitation, as follows:—

    “The contract is concluded where the first letter is received and the assenting answer is dispatched by the receiver for at this place a concurrent declaration of intention has been arrived at. The sender of the first letter is therefore to be regarded as if he had gone to meet the other, and had received his consent. This opinion has been adopted by several. But many have suggested the following doubts. The assenting letter, they think, may he recovered before its arrival, or annulled by a revocation therefore the contract is first completed at the place where the sender of the first letter has received the answer, and has thus become aware of the other's agreement. But it is quite wrong to reject the true principle in consideration of such very rare cases; In far the greater number of instances both intentions will be declared without such a wavering of resolution; but where that does happen, the question can only be decided by taking into account a multitude of particular circumstances, so that, even then, the arbitrary rule proposed by our opponents is by no means sufficient” [vide also footnote (c) at page 215 in which all the authorities bearing on the question are summarised and collected].

    We, therefore, allow this appeal with costs throughout, and setting aside the decree appealed against, direct the plaint to be returned to be presented to the proper Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kamisetti Subbiah v. Katha Venkatasawmy
    (Oct 27, 1903)