AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 INSC 1113
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India, Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India
  • Articles 16(4), 16(4-A) and 16(4-B) of the Constitution of India
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2017 INSC 1113
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India, Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India
  • Articles 16(4), 16(4-A) and 16(4-B) of the Constitution of India
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This order concerns a set of cases raising questions on the interpretation of Articles 16(4), 16(4-A), and 16(4-B) of the Constitution of India, primarily in the backdrop of three Constitution Bench decisions: Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, E.V. Chinnaiah v. State of A.P., and M. Nagaraj v. Union of India.

A key aspect highlighted is that while Nagaraj and Chinnaiah deal with the disputed subject of “backwardness” of SC/STs, Chinnaiah (which was earlier) was not referred to in Nagaraj. The order notes that extensive arguments were advanced by both sides and that additional questions arose regarding the application of Article 16(4-A) and the “creamy layer” concept within SC/ST groups notified under Articles 341 and 342.

Procedurally, the court directs that the matter be placed for hearing before a Constitution Bench under Article 145(3) and further states that even interim relief, though pressed, should be considered by the Constitution Bench.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. How Articles 16(4), 16(4-A), and 16(4-B) should be interpreted in light of the decisions in Indra Sawhney, E.V. Chinnaiah, and M. Nagaraj, including the significance of Chinnaiah not being referred to in Nagaraj.
  2. Whether the “test of backwardness” ought to be applied to SC/STs for the purpose of Nagaraj and Article 16(4-A), in view of Indra Sawhney and Chinnaiah.
  3. What further and finer interpretation is required regarding the application of Article 16(4-A).
  4. How the principle of “creamy layer” applies in situations of competing claims within the same races, communities, groups, or parts thereof of SC/STs notified by the President under Articles 341 and 342.
  5. Whether, given the nature of the questions involved, the matter must be heard by a Constitution Bench under Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Sought a relook of M. Nagaraj v. Union of India (2006) 8 SCC 212.
  • Argued specifically that the “test of backwardness” ought not to be applied to SC/STs, relying on Indra Sawhney v. Union of India 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 and E.V. Chinnaiah v. State of A.P. (2005) 1 SCC 394.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Contended that the request to revisit the issue cannot be entertained repeatedly (“ad nauseam”), relying on:
    • Suraj Bhan Meena v. State of Rajasthan (2011) 1 SCC 467
    • U.P. Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Rajesh Kumar (2012) 7 SCC 1
    • S. Panneer Selvam v. State of T.N. (2015) 10 SCC 292
    • Central Bank of India v. SC/ST Employees Welfare Assn. (2015) 12 SCC 308
    • Suresh Chand Gautam v. State of U.P. (2016) 11 SCC 113

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 Cited in support of the contention that the “test of backwardness” ought not to be applied to SC/STs. Treated as one of the three principal Constitution Bench decisions forming the backdrop for interpreting Articles 16(4), 16(4-A), and 16(4-B); also referenced in recording petitioners’ grounds for seeking a relook of Nagaraj.
E.V Chinnaiah v. State of A.P, (2005) 1 SCC 394 Referenced regarding the disputed subject of “backwardness” of SC/STs and to support the petitioners’ argument against applying a backwardness test to SC/STs. Noted as an earlier decision on the subject that was not referred to in Nagaraj, contributing to the need for Constitution Bench consideration.
M. Nagaraj v. Union of India, (2006) 8 SCC 212 Central precedent sought to be revisited; associated with applying the “test of backwardness” to SC/STs in the context of the disputed subject as recorded in the order. Identified as crucial to the interpretive questions; the court records that a relook is sought and that further questions on Article 16(4-A) arise, warranting Constitution Bench hearing.
Suraj Bhan Meena v. State of Rajasthan, (2011) 1 SCC 467 Cited to contend that repeated requests to revisit the issue should not be entertained. Recorded as authority relied upon by respondents opposing repeated revisits; the order does not decide the merits at this stage.
U.P Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Rajesh Kumar, (2012) 7 SCC 1 Cited to contend that repeated requests to revisit the issue should not be entertained. Recorded as authority relied upon by respondents; no merits determination is made in this order.
S. Panneer Selvam v. State of T.N, (2015) 10 SCC 292 Cited to contend against entertaining revisits “ad nauseam.” Recorded as part of respondents’ opposition; the court proceeds to refer the matter to a Constitution Bench given the nature of questions.
Central Bank of India v. SC/ST Employees Welfare Assn., (2015) 12 SCC 308 Cited to contend against repeated revisiting of the issue. Recorded as respondents’ authority; not substantively applied beyond noting the contention.
Suresh Chand Gautam v. State of U.P, (2016) 11 SCC 113 Cited to contend against repeated requests for revisit. Recorded as respondents’ authority; the order focuses on referral to a Constitution Bench rather than adjudicating the contention.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court notes that the cases raise substantial interpretive questions concerning Articles 16(4), 16(4-A), and 16(4-B) in light of major Constitution Bench rulings. It specifically records that one relevant aspect is the relationship between Chinnaiah and Nagaraj, including that Chinnaiah was not referred to in Nagaraj despite both dealing with backwardness of SC/STs.

The court further notes that, beyond the demand for revisiting Nagaraj, additional questions arise about the application of Article 16(4-A) and the “creamy layer” principle in the context of competing claims within SC/ST groups notified under Articles 341 and 342.

Having regard to the questions involved, the court concludes that the matter must be heard by a Bench consistent with the constitutional mandate under Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India, and directs that the files be placed before the Chief Justice of India immediately for appropriate constitution of the Bench. The court also reasons that even interim relief should be considered by the Constitution Bench, and leaves it open to the parties to mention urgency before the Chief Justice of India.

Holding and Implications

REFERRED TO A CONSTITUTION BENCH under Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India; the files were directed to be placed before the Chief Justice of India immediately.

Interim relief was not granted at this stage; the court stated that the question of interim relief should also be considered by the Constitution Bench, and permitted the parties to mention urgency before the Chief Justice of India.

The direct implication is that no final determination on the merits of revisiting Nagaraj, or on the interpretation of Articles 16(4), 16(4-A), and 16(4-B), was made in this order. The order operates procedurally to ensure adjudication by the appropriate larger bench, and does not set any new precedent on the substantive constitutional questions.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Tripura And Others v. Jayanta Chakraborty And Others

    Order

    1. The questions posed in these cases involve the interpretation of Articles 16(4), 16(4-A) and 16(4-B) of the Constitution of India in the backdrop of mainly three Constitution Bench decisions — (1) Indra Sawhney v. Union of India 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217, (2) E.V Chinnaiah v. State of A.P (2005) 1 SCC 394, and (3) M. Nagaraj v. Union of India (2006) 8 SCC 212. One crucially relevant aspect brought to our notice is that Nagaraj (2006) 8 SCC 212 and Chinnaiah (2005) 1 SCC 394 deal with the disputed subject, namely, backwardness of the SC/STs but Chinnaiah (2005) 1 SCC 394 which came earlier in time has not been referred to in Nagaraj (2006) 8 SCC 212. The question of further and finer interpretation on the application of Article 16(4-A) has also arisen in this case.

    2. Extensive arguments have been advanced from both sides. The petitioners have argued for a relook of Nagaraj (2006) 8 SCC 212 specifically on the ground that test of backwardness ought not to be applied to SC/STs in view of Indra Sawhney 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 and Chinnaiah (2005) 1 SCC 394. On the other hand, the counsel for the respondents have referred to Suraj Bhan Meena v. State of Rajasthan (2011) 1 SCC 467; U.P Power Corpn. Ltd. v. Rajesh Kumar (2012) 7 SCC 1; S. Panneer Selvam v. State of T.N (2015) 10 SCC 292; Central Bank of India v. SC/ST Employees Welfare Assn. (2015) 12 SCC 308 and Suresh Chand Gautam v. State of U.P (2016) 11 SCC 113 to contend that the request for a revisit cannot be entertained ad nauseam. However, apart from the clamour for revisit, further questions were also raised about application of the principle of creamy layer in situations of competing claims within the same races, communities, groups or parts thereof of SC/STs notified by the President under Articles 341 and 342 of the Constitution of India.

    3. Having regard to the questions involved in this case, we are of the opinion that this is a case to be heard by a Bench as per the constitutional mandate under Article 145(3) of the Constitution of India. Ordered accordingly. Place the files before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India immediately.

    4. Though the learned counsel have pressed for interim relief, we are of the view that even that stage needs to be considered by the Constitution Bench. The parties are free to mention the urgency before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice of India.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Tripura And Others v. Jayanta Chakraborty And Others
    (Nov 14, 2017)