AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The order concerns several interlocutory applications (IAs Nos. 18, 22 and 23 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 260 of 2005 and IA No. 1 in Writ Petition (Civil) No. 115 of 2004) pending before the Supreme Court of India. The writ petitions challenge aspects of genetically engineered (GE) crop field trials overseen by the Genetic Engineering Approval Committee (GEAC). An earlier order dated 8 May 2007, reported as (2011) 12 SCC 478, had mandated a uniform 200-metre isolation distance between trial plots and neighbouring crops and required a validated protocol with a 0.01 % limit of detection (LOD) before field trials. The present order addresses requests to modify those directions and to ensure public disclosure of toxicity and allergenicity data for nine crops proposed for testing.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the previously mandated 200-metre isolation distance should instead be determined on a crop-specific basis.
  2. Whether the requirement of a 0.01 % LOD validated protocol prior to field trials should be retained, altered, or dispensed with.
  3. Whether data on toxicity and allergenicity for nine crops undergoing field trials must be placed in the public domain before trials proceed.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicants in IAs Nos. 22 & 23 (WP (C) No. 260/2005)

  • The isolation distance should vary with the biology of each crop; a fixed 200 m is unnecessarily rigid for some crops and insufficient for others.
  • The pre-trial requirement of a 0.01 % LOD validated protocol should be dispensed with, or at least reconsidered.

Applicants in IA No. 1 (WP (C) No. 115/2004) & IA No. 18 (WP (C) No. 260/2005)

  • Researchers and the public cannot make informed representations unless toxicity and allergenicity data for the nine crops are publicly disclosed.

Petitioner (Opposing Party)

  • Objects to dispensing with the 0.01 % LOD requirement, seeking its continuance.

Union of India / Additional Solicitor General (ASG)

  • Affirms that toxicity and allergenicity data for Bt cotton and Bt brinjal are already online.
  • States that data for the remaining seven crops will be uploaded once compiled.
  • Commits to producing the minutes of the 2 April 2008 GEAC meeting by the next hearing date.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
(2011) 12 SCC 478
(Order dated 8 May 2007 in the same matter)
Directed a 200 m isolation distance and a 0.01 % LOD validated protocol before GE crop field trials. The Court considered applications seeking modification of these directions and tasked GEAC with re-examining both requirements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court did not itself alter the earlier directions. Instead, it recognized that scientific parameters such as isolation distance and LOD may vary by crop and technology, and therefore delegated the technical assessment to GEAC:

  • GEAC is to examine and prescribe crop-specific isolation distances rather than a uniform 200 m standard.
  • GEAC is also to review the necessity and level of the 0.01 % LOD protocol, considering whether to retain, modify, or replace it with an alternative protocol.
  • With respect to public disclosure of toxicity and allergenicity data, the Court relied on the ASG’s representation that data for Bt cotton and Bt brinjal are already online and that data for seven other crops will be published once collected, thereby rendering further judicial intervention unnecessary at this stage.

Holding and Implications

The interlocutory applications (IAs Nos. 18, 22, 23 in WP (C) No. 260/2005 and IA No. 1 in WP (C) No. 115/2004 were DISPOSED OF.

Direct consequences:

  • GEAC must re-evaluate and report on appropriate isolation distances and LOD requirements.
  • GEAC must publish remaining toxicity and allergenicity data once available.
  • The Union of India is to furnish the minutes of the 2 April 2008 GEAC meeting by the next hearing, scheduled for the second week of August 2008.

No broader legal precedent was established; the order primarily directs administrative follow-up within the existing regulatory framework for GE crop trials.

    Aruna Rodrigues (4) And Others v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    IAs Nos. 18, 22 and 23 in WP (C) No. 260 of 2005 and IA No. 1 in WP (C) No. 115 of 2004

    1. On 8-5-2007 (2011) 12 SCC 478 this Court had directed that when field trials are conducted, there must be 200 m isolation distance between the trial fields and the neighbouring fields having cultivation of same crop, to avoid contamination. It is submitted on behalf of the applicants in IAs Nos. 22 and 23 that the distance to be maintained should depend upon the nature of the crop. It is submitted that some crops may require less than 200 m and some may require more than 200 m, GEAC will examine this issue and prescribe the isolated distance depending upon the nature of the crop.

    2. The applicants in IAs Nos. 22 and 23 have also sought modification of another direction issued under the order dated 8-5-2007 that the validated protocol should be 0.01% LOD before field trials. The submission of the applicants is that the said requirement should be dispensed with. The petitioner opposes such dispensation. GEAC may also examine and give a finding as to what should be the LOD, whether it should continue to be 0.01% or be less than 0.01% or more than 0.01% or whether it should be dispensed with altogether with an alternative protocol, and if so, what should be the alternative protocol.

    3. In IA No. 1 in WP (C) No. 115 of 2004 and IA No. 18 in WP (C) No. 260 of 2005 the applicants have complained that the data regarding toxicity and allergenicity has not been placed in public domain by those conducting the trials, in regard to nine crops to be field tested. It is submitted that unless the toxicity and allergenicity data is made known to the public, the applicants and scientists concerned in the country would not be in a position to make effective representations to the authorities concerned. The learned Additional Solicitor General submits that as regards Bt cotton and Bt brinjal, required data has already been put on the website. He also stated that in regard to other seven crops, data is being collected and as soon as the full data is available with GEAC, the same would be put on the website. In view of the said statement, it may not be necessary to further consider the said two applications.

    4. IAs Nos. 18, 22 and 23 in WP (C) No. 260 of 2005 and IA No. 1 in WP (C) No. 115 of 2004 are disposed of accordingly.

    5. The learned ASG further submits that the minutes of the meeting of GEAC held on 2-4-2008 would be made available to the Court by the next date of hearing.

    6. List in the second week of August 2008.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Aruna Rodrigues (4) And Others v. Union Of India And Others
    (Apr 8, 2008)