AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 154 CrPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Judges
Acts
  • Article 226 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 154 CrPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners lodged four complaints dated 1-2-2012, 2-2-2012, 15-2-2012 and 15-3-2012 with the Commissioner of Police, Mumbai, alleging commission of cognizable offences by the respondents. When no first information report (FIR) was registered, the petitioners filed Criminal Writ Petition No. 1608 of 2012 before the Bombay High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, seeking a writ of mandamus directing the police to register an offence.

During the High Court proceedings, the respondents—who were named as accused in the complaints—moved applications to intervene. By order dated 10-4-2013 in Sunil Gangadhar Karve v. State of Maharashtra, a Division Bench of the High Court (A.R. Joshi & P.V. Hardas, JJ.) allowed the intervention applications.

The petitioners challenged that order by filing Special Leave Petitions (Civil) Nos. 4264-66 of 2013 in the Supreme Court of India. At the Supreme Court hearing, counsel for the State of Maharashtra confirmed that the police would act in accordance with law following the Constitution Bench decision in Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P. (2014 2 SCC 1). In view of this statement, the petitioners sought leave to withdraw both the SLPs and the writ petition pending in the High Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether persons named as accused in an unregistered complaint are entitled to intervene in a writ petition seeking a mandamus for registration of an FIR.
  2. Whether, in light of Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P., the police are mandatorily required to register an FIR under Section 154 CrPC when information discloses a cognizable offence.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners’ Arguments

  • The respondents had no right to intervene because, at the relevant time, no FIR had been registered under Section 154 CrPC.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Since the writ petition in the High Court sought coercive directions against them, they were entitled to intervene at that stage to rebut allegations made in the petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Lalita Kumari v. Government of U.P. (2014 2 SCC 1) Registration of an FIR under Section 154 CrPC is mandatory when information discloses a cognizable offence; no preliminary inquiry is permissible in such cases. The Court relied on this ruling to ask the State whether the police would proceed in accordance with the mandatory duty to register an FIR, leading to the State’s assurance and the subsequent withdrawal of the SLPs.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court noted the recent Constitution Bench judgment in Lalita Kumari, especially clauses (i) and (ii) of paragraph 120, which clarify the mandatory nature of FIR registration. The Bench queried the State of Maharashtra on whether the police would comply with this mandate regarding the petitioners’ complaints. State counsel affirmed that the police would “certainly take steps in accordance with law.”

Given this assurance, the Court observed that the primary relief sought by the petitioners—direction to register an FIR—would be addressed administratively. Consequently, the petitioners expressed their intention to withdraw the SLPs as well as the writ petition pending before the High Court. The Court therefore saw no reason to adjudicate the substantive challenge to the High Court’s intervention order.

Recognising that the complaints had been pending since early 2012, the Court directed the “appropriate police officer” to decide on them in light of Lalita Kumari within eight weeks.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Special Leave Petitions are dismissed as withdrawn.

Implications: The petitioners will withdraw the writ petition before the Bombay High Court, and the police are required to take a decision on the four complaints within eight weeks in accordance with the principles laid down in Lalita Kumari. The decision sets no new precedent but reinforces the binding nature of the Constitution Bench ruling on mandatory FIR registration.

    Sunil Gangadhar Karve v. Chagan Chandrakant Bhujbal And Others

    1. Heard Mr. Rohatgi, learned Senior Counsel, in support of SLP (C) No. 4264 of 2013, Mr. Venugopal, learned Senior Counsel, in support of SLPs (C) Nos. 4265-66 of 2013.

    2. Mr. Dave, Mr. Lalit and Mr. Singh, learned Senior Counsel, appear for the contesting respondents and Mr. Mike Desai, appears for the State of Maharashtra.

    3. These petitions seek to challenge the order passed by the Bombay High Court dated 10-4-2013 in Sunil Gangadhar Karve v. State of Maharashtra, whereby the High Court has allowed the respondents to intervene in the petition filed by the petitioner(s) seeking a direction that the complaints filed by the petitioner(s) against the contesting respondents be proceeded in accordance with law.

    4. Mr. Venugopal, and Mr. Rohatgi, submitted that these respondents had no reason to intervene at a stage when the complaint was yet to be registered under Section 154 CrPC. Mr. Dave, learned Senior Counsel, for the respondents, on the other hand, submits that the matter was in the High Court, and at that stage the respondents were entitled to make an application for intervention inasmuch as the petitioners had approached the High Court for an order against the respondents.

    5. In any event, as far as the registration of the complaints and FIR are concerned, a Constitution Bench of this Court has very recently held on 12-11-2013 in Lalita Kumari v. Govt. of U.P, that registration of FIR is mandatory under Section 154 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The operative directions are in para 120 of the judgment (2014) 2 SCC 1. Clause (i) thereof states that if the information discloses commission of a cognizable offence, no preliminary inquiry is permissible in such a situation. Clause (ii) of these operative directions mentions that if the information received does not disclose a cognizable offence but indicates the necessity for an inquiry, a preliminary inquiry may be conducted only to ascertain whether cognizable offence is disclosed or not.

    6. In view of this judgment, we asked the learned counsel appearing for the State that since these complaints have been lodged with the Commissioner of Police/officer concerned, whether the police will take necessary steps in accordance with law. The counsel Mr. Desai stated that the police officer concerned will certainly take steps in accordance with law.

    7. In view of the statement of Mr. Desai, learned counsel for the State of Maharashtra, the counsel for the petitioner(s) state that they do not press these special leave petitions and also state that they will withdraw the writ petition filed in the High Court.

    8. These four complaints are dated 1-2-2012, 2-2-2012, 15-2-2012 and 15-3-2012. We expect the appropriate police officer concerned, to take a decision on these complaints in the the light of law laid down by this Court in Lalita Kumari case (2014) 2 SCC 1. Inasmuch as these complaints are pending for a long time, the police officer concerned will take necessary decision within eight weeks hereafter.

    9. The special leave petitions are accordingly dismissed as withdrawn.

    IMPUGNED ORDER OF THE HIGH COURT

    (BEFORE A.R JOSHI AND P.V HARDAS, JJ.)

    10. These three applications are filed by the applicants seeking to intervene in Criminal Writ Petition No. 1608 of 2012. Since a common question is raised in respect of these applications, they are being decided by this common order.

    11. The petitioner has filed Criminal Writ Petition No. 1608 of 2012 under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying therein, in essence, for issuance of a writ of mandamus directing Respondent 4 to register an offence against the accused, who were named in the complaint filed by the petitioner. In the petition certain averments are made against the present applicants, who have sought to intervene in the petition. The learned counsel for the applicants as well as Mr. Merchant, learned counsel representing the petitioner, has placed reliance on the judgment of the Supreme Court to urge before us that the applicants, who are named as accused in the complaint/report filed by the petitioner, are not necessary parties to the present petition and, therefore, the applications filed by the applicants, seeking to intervene in the petition deserve to be dismissed. The learned counsel representing the applicants have urged before us that the applicants, though, may not be necessary parties to the petition, need to be permitted to intervene in the petition, as, firstly, certain averments are made against the applicants and secondly, the applicants have been participating in the proceedings before the court and this is apparent from the order-sheets of the writ petition.

    12. According to us, at this stage, it is not necessary for us to decide the question as to whether the applicants are necessary parties or proper parties and, therefore, have a right to intervene in the petition. According to us, the applicants can be permitted to intervene in the petition as, firstly, the applicants have been participating in the proceedings and this is evident from the perusal of the order-sheets. Though the applications filed by the applicants were pending consideration before the court, the applicants have been participating in the proceedings before the court. Secondly, certain averments are made against the applicants in the petition and, therefore, it would be appropriate that an opportunity is given to the applicants to rebut the allegations made against the applicants in the petition.

    13. For the aforesaid reasons, therefore, in our opinion, the applications filed by the applicants, seeking to intervene in the petition, need to be allowed and accordingly, the applications are allowed and the applicants are permitted to intervene in the petition as intervenors.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sunil Gangadhar Karve v. Chagan Chandrakant Bhujbal And Others
    (Nov 22, 2013)