Pradeep Nandrajog, J.:— As per judgment of Supreme Court reported as AIR 1997 SC 3611, Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, pertaining to sexual harassment of working women, aimed at providing a healthy and safe work environment to women, employers of private and public sector undertakings are obliged to take appropriate steps to prevent sexual harassment. Whether or not such conduct (act of sexual harassment) constitutes an offence under law or a breach of service rules, the employer is enjoined to create in the organization a redressal mechanism to ensure time bound treatment of complaints. A complaint committee headed by a woman and consisting of not less than 50% women members should be constituted. Involvement of a third party familiar with the issue of sexual harassment should be there on the committee. The victim should have a right to seek her own transfer or the transfer of the perpetrator. Where the conduct which results in sexual harassment constitutes misconduct as defined by the rules, appropriate disciplinary action has to be initiated against the employee. To put it pithily, if the act is misconduct as per rules, disciplinary action has to be taken, if it is not misconduct as per rules, appropriate and adequate steps have to be taken to protect the dignity of the woman concerned and a safe and healthy work environment provided to her. Needless to state that the healthy and safe work environment would be provided as per the suggestions and recommendations of the committee.
2. Present case relates to the grievances of the petitioner against respondent No. 5, then working as Divisional Railway Manager of Ferozepur Division. Petitioner was at that time heading the Ferozepur Divisions Accounts and Finance Officer.
3. As per the petitioner, she was administratively reporting to respondent No. 5 who was the divisional head.
4. Allegations pertaining to the alleged acts constituting sexual harassment as stated in the petition are to be found in paras 6 to 13 of the writ petition. Be noted:
“6. On 18.12.97, the Chairman Railway Board alongwith senior Railway Officers of Railway Board, Northern Railway Headquarters and Ferozepur Division alongwith the General Manager of Northern Railway were on a visit to Beas for the inaugurationof Beas-Goindwal Section. Respondent No. 5, who is the Executive Director (Industrial Relations), Railway Board presently was the then Divisional Railway Manager of Ferozepur Division, Northern Railway at that point of time and the petitioner was reporting to him directly (adminsitratvely) in his capacity as Divisional Head. The respondent No. 5 was also therefore, accompanying the aforementioned senior officers of the Railways at the time of inauguration of Beas-Goindwal Section.
7. The aforesaid officials including Respondent No. 5, visited the residence of the religious head of Radar Soami sect at Beas for a meeting and the petitioner also, being a member of the official team accompanied the aforesaid officers including respondent No. 5 at such call. In the course of this meeting the petitioner was seated next to respondent No. 5 on the sofa. While other officers were engrossed in discussions, respondent No. 5 made repeated physical gestures of pressing his thigh against the petitioner and brushing his arms and body against the petitioner. He tried to put his arm around the petitioner and made physical and sexual gestures. The petitioner was so taken aback and seeing the sombre atmosphere could not react immediately and just got up from the Sofa during the Swamiji's discourse and discussions with the Chairman. Railway Board and in an extremely disturbed state of mind, made an abrupt exit. The petitioner was shell shocked and did not know what she ought to do. The petitioner was in tears and rushed to the bathroom in Swamiji's house so as to control and compose herself. The petitioner came out and while she was standing outside the house of Swamiji, respondent No. 5 came up to the petitioner and told the petitioner that she should not have run out and stayed inside and enjoyed herself.
8. the petitioner was so shaken that she could not contemplate as to how to deal with the situation and gathered all her courage and reported the matter to Mr. S. Murali, FA&CAO, respondent No. 4 who was also present there. Mr. Murali assured the petitioner that he would inform the General Manager immediately about the incident and would also arrange a meeting with the General Manager in Delhi to enable the petitioner to tell the General Manager everything in person.
9. Nothing happened about the assured meeting with the General Manager upto 22.12.97 on which date there was a General manager's Annual inspection of Ludhiana-Ferozepur line of Ferozepur Division. At the time of such inspection, Shri Gurdip Singh, FA&CAO/B&E who had acompanied the General Manager vice Shri Murali was accompanying the General Manger's Inspection Team. The petitioner told Shri Gurdip Singh that she desired to meet the General Manager and appraise him of the full facts of the incident of 18th December, 1997 whether at Ferozepur or by coming to Delhi. Mr. Gurdip Singh informed the petitioner that the FA&CAO, Mr. Murali had already discussed the matter pertaining to the Beas incident with the General Manager and appropriate action was being taken. He also informed the petitioner that the petitioner's meeting with the General Manager at Delhi was being arranged and the petitioner need not visit Delhi immediately.
10. On finding that no officer was taking cognizance of her grievance and fearing further sexual harassment at the hands of respondent No. 5, feeling insecure at her work place, the petitioner was constrained to proceed on leave w.e.f 23.12.97 Thereafter, the petitioner continued to pursue the matter with Mr. Murali, FA&CAO and on 1.1.98 in the course of telephonic discussion between the petitioner and Mr. Murali the petitioner was informed by Shri Murali that appropos her discussions with Mr. Gurdip Singh, the petitioner should not think of taking leave but the petitioner informed Mr. Murali that she could not continue working under the highly demeaning circumstances and insecurity to her person. Even after this discussion, nothing happened so far as her complaint was concerned.
11. On finding that nothing seems to be shaking the Railway administration about such a serious matter relating to a senior woman employee like the petitioner, the petitioner wrote a letter dated 7.1.98 to Shri Murli requesting him for an immediate action in the matter about the incident which took place on 18.12.97 at Beas. In an emotionally disturbed state of mind. In the said letter, the petitioner made an error of giving the date of incident as 22.12.97 whereas it was actually 18.12.97 This fact was duly communicated to Mr. Murali in the petitioner's letter of 30.1.98 True copies of the petitioner's letters dated 7.1.98 and 30.1.98 are annexed hereto and marked as Annexure A and B respectively.
12. As on 1.1.98, Shri Murali in the course of his conversation with the petitioner had expressed his unwillingness to grant leave to the petitioner, the petitioner was compelled to joint back the service which she did on 1.1.98 itself. On 17.1.98, the Divisional Railway Manager's Annual inspection had been planned at Ferozepur Division. Still under a state of trauma on account of the incident on 18.12.97, the petitioner only on account of the refusal of leave and sheer constraint of disciplined behaviour was compelled to go for the inspection. Interestingly, on earlier occasions as well, respondent No. 5, knowing fully well that the petitioner was the only lady officer, had attempted to club the petitioner with male officers even during night travel in the same carriage. This previous attempt also made the petitioner extremly apprehensive about the impending inspection which was to take place w.e.f 17.1.98
13. Compelled to do so, the petitioner went on the inspection in the special train reluctantly. The petitioner was not to be proved wrong. On 17.1.98, much to the horror and disgust, respondent No. 5 once again acted in a debased manner and made provocative sexual statements when the petitioner went to pick up her belongings from the carriage at Kotkapura Station. The reluctance of the petitioner who joined the inspection from is clearly evident from the fact that the petitioner did not join the inspection team which started from Ferozepur. Respondent No. 5 sent a message to the Control Room in the effect that the petitioner had not joined the inspection team and that she should join the inspection team immediately. By that time, the Inspection Special had already left Ferozepur and the petitioner, much against her wishes, went by road alongwith one Mr. Harsh Kumar, Senior Divisional mechanical Engineer to Guru Harsahai Station. A true copy of the inspection note No. RK/4/98 is annexed hereto and marked as Annexure-B1. She joined all the officers in the Inspection Carriage and had got down at Kotkapura Station and had left all her personal belongings including her files and purse in the same carriage. At Kotkapura, the Engine of the Train was to be reversed as the inspection was complete and the Inspection Team had to return to Ferozepur, the petitioner got down from the carriage wherein all the officers were seated during the inspection. The petitioner went back to the same carriage where her bag, purse and official files were lying, to her horror, she found that respondent No. 5 was sitting alone in the Lounge of the Carriage. The petitioner hasitly tried to grab her belongings which were lying on a Table in the lounge and rushed towards the exit door as she was already petrified of the respondent No. 5 due to the earlier incident. The respondent No. 5 immediately moved and tried to stop the petitioner by catching her arm and asked her to sit on the sofa next to him. With great effort, the petitioner managed to extricate herself from the situation and escaped by jumping down from the carriage. As the train had started moving, the petitioner rushed towards the next carriage and with great difficulty boarded the same. In the process, the petitioner even injured her ankle. The petitioner's state of distress was obviously beyond imagination.
When she entered the next carriage, to her further embarrassment, she found that all other officers were playing cards. As the only lady officer, she was feeling totally out of place in that state of mind. The petitioner went into one of the cabins adjacent to the lounge in the same carriage in which the officers were playing cards and locked herself in there.”
5. As per the petitioner, on 23.1.1998 she met the General Manager Northern Railway who suggested that petitioner should seek transfer. Petitioner was also informed that respondent No. 5 was shortly going to be transferred out from Ferozepur Division by Feb./March, 1998. In view of said fact, petitioner applied for leave. Petitioner received a transfer order dated 27.1.1998, she had completed just 8 months at Ferozepur. Petitioner relinquished charge on 2.2.1998 After availing medical leave she joined at Delhi on 2.3.1998
6. On finding that the administration was taking no action against respondent No. 5, petitioner addressed a detailed letter to the General Manger (NR) on 10.3.1998 On 1.4.1998, petitioner submitted a representation to the National Commission for Women.
7. On 2.4.1998, petitioner received a letter dated 2.4.1998 to appear before a fact finding committee consisting of Sh. R.K Sarkar, Chief Administrative Officer (NR), Mr. I.P.S Anand (SDGM) and Dr. (Mrs.) Meena Murthy (Chief Health Director). She appeared on 3.4.1998, her father and husband accompanied her. Petitioner claims that the committee, in an insulting and rude manner told her father and husband to leave the room, threatening that if they did not do so, enquiry would not proceed. Thereafter, petitioner claims that she was questioned by the committee, which questioning, far from being in the nature of an inquisitorial questioning took colour of virtual cross examination. Petitioner claims that she was brow beaten. No written record was maintained. Everything was oral.
8. Petitioner received a letter dated 16.4.1998 from the committee informing her that the next date fixed for further proceedings was 21.4.1998 Petitioner makes a grievance here too. In the letter dated 16.4.1998 it was written that the next date fixed was as desired by the petitioner. Petitioner denies that the date was fixed as per her desire. On 20.4.1998 she wrote a letter clarifying the position. Petitioner states that on 21.4.1998, the enquiry committee compelled her to take back the letter. She was thus forced to take back the original letter.
9. Further proceedings were held on 27.4.1998 No witnesses were examined in the presence of the petitioner and no written record was maintained as per the petitioner. In any case, none were given to the petitioner. According to the petitioner she made a complaint to the National Commission for Women but they too did not intervene. Petitioner claims that she received blank and indecent calls over the telephones.
10. Petitioner claims to be further harassed, in that, no house was alloted to her at Delhi and allotment of residential accommodation at Ferozepur was cancelled. So much stressed was she, claims the petitioner, that she had to undergo an abortion and had to go on leave without pay. She claims that during leave without pay period, she was denied an increment.
11. Much belatedly, claims the petitioner on 3.7.1998, the National Commission for Women wrote to the Railway authorities to reconstitute the Committee as per Supreme Court guidelines, having 50% women members and headed by a woman.
12. On 21.8.1998, petitioner learnt that a new committee had been constituted. She claims that this was done without informing her. Petitioner wrote a letter dated 27.8.1998 wanting to know as to under that authority the new committee had been constituted. She also wanted to know the findings of the earlier committee. On 4.9.1998 petitioner was informed as under:
“Smt. Manisha Sharma
IRAS Officer, NR
106, Church Road
Firozepur Cantt (Punjab)
Sub Ref: Your letter No. Nil dated 27.8.98 addressed to Shri Sudhir Mathur, Convenor, Complaints Committee and FA&CAO/WST, N. Rly, New Delhi
This is in reference to your letter quoted above and to intimate that a Complaints Committee consisting of the following members has been nominated to go into your complaint of sexual harassment against the then DRM/FZR Shri Raj Kumar:
1.
Chairperson:
Smt. Padmakshi Raheja,
SAG/IRTS Officer NR.
2.
Convenor:
Sh. Sudhir Mathur
FA&CAO/WST, NR.
3.
Members:
a) Smt. Dipali Khanna
EDF/B, Rly Board
b) Shri Pradeep Bhatnagar
CFTM-I, NR.
4.
Representative of NGO :
Dr. Manorama Bawa,
Secy. Genl. All India
Women's Conference.
You have in your letter raised several issues viz.
Non-communication of authority constituting the committee and its membership, etc.
2. Mis-reporting by the Convenor of the discussions held with you.
3. Non-communication of the outcome of the earlier inquiry and the basis of the present inquiry.
4. Inadequate notice and your personal extenuating circumstacnes.
5. The seniority of Committee members vis-a-vis the officer complained against.
6. Complaints Committee to conduct inquiry de novo and not be biased by the earlier report.
7. Delay in the case on the part of the Railways and the bias of the convenor Shri Sudhir Mathur.
8. Harassment by the administration and a compaign of defamation launched against you by the administration;
9. That the inquiry sittings may beheld in FZR with at least a week's notice to you.
The issues raised by you have been gone into and it is found that no charge is made out against the Convenor Shri Sudhir Mathur. The committee has been constituted as per the directives of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India dated 13.8.97 in Writ Petition (Criminal) Nos. 666-70 of 1992 in the case of Vishaka and others v. State of Rajasthan and others. This committee has been constituted on receipt of instructions and guidelines from the Railway Board in July, 98. The proceedings of the fact finding committee have been made available to the Complaints Committee along with your complaint so that the whole matter could be gone into in its entirely by this Committee. You are hereby advised to cooperate with the Committee and attend its sittings, as and when called by the Committee. You will agree that the venue and the dates of sittings have to be decided by the committee as considered appropriate. No directions are being given to the Committee on this score.
The committee has been asked to submit its report within a specified time frame and hence is required to work urgently. The National Commission for Women has also desired that the outcome in the case be made known to the Commission during this month.
Kindly acknowledge receipt of this letter.”
13. In response, petitioner wrote on 9.9.1998 demanding complete record of the earlier committee and its report. She demanded a de novo enquiry. Petitioner claims that she repeated her demands, which letters were ignored. On 23.10.1998 she appeared before the new committee under protest. Petitioner claims that proceedings were informal. She was examined. No witness was examined in her presence.
14. On 3.3.1999 petitioner claims to have received a letter forwarding conclusions and recommendations of the new committee. Vide letter dated 13.3.1999, petitioner demanded complete report. Same was not furnished. Present petition was filed praying:
“a) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of certiorari directing the respondents to call for records and proceedings of the Fact Finding Enquiry Committee and the Standing Complaints Committee;
b) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of certiorari quashing the proceedings and findings of the Fact Finding Enquiry Committee and the Standing Complaints Committee;
c) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of mandamus to take appropriate disciplinary action against respondent No. 5 for his acts of moral turpitude and sexual harassment of the petitioner and against respondent Nos. 2, 3 and 4 for their failure to take timely action against respondent No. 5 in respect of petitioner's complaints of her sexual harassment by respondent No. 5;
d) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of mandamus directing respondent Nos. 1 to 4 to issue orders posting the petitioner back to Ferozepur Division as Senior Divisional Accounts Officer, the position she was holding at the time of incidents of her sexual harassment by Respondent No. 5;
e) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of mandamus directing respondent Nos. 1 to 4 to pay to the petitioner her entire salary for the period during which she was compelled to proceed on leave subsequent to her illegal and manipulative transfer to Delhi;
f) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to pay punitive compensation to the petitioner for the mental trauma, hardship, agony and social embarassment suffered by her due to the illegal actions of the respondents;
g) pass a writ, order or direction in the nature of a writ of mandamus directing the respondent Nos. 1 and 2 to grant increments due to the petitioner and being withheld on account of the petitioner being on leave without pay for reasons wholly attributable to the respondents and also to count her period of leave without pay for the purposes of qualifying service for promotion and retirement benefits.”
15. Counter has been filed. It is stated that the second committee set up as per Vishakha guidelines conducted an enquiry de-novo. Petitioner's averments in paras 6 to 13 of the writ petition (noted by me in para 4 above) have been replied to as under:
“10. That as regards the averments contained in paras 5, 6, and 7 of the Writ Petition, the respondents most respectfully submit that the Chairman, Railway Board, General Manager, Northern Railway alongwith all Principal Heads of Departments had gone to Beas in connection with the opening of Beas-Govindwal new railway line to traffic. The DRM/Ferozepur, respondent No. 5 had arranged for an audience with Huzur Saheb, head of the Radha Soami Satsang, Beas, who is revered by lakhs of devotees. After the function at about 11.00 hours, they went to the house of Babaji and were seated in the drawing room of the Hazur Saheb. Since there were limited seats and everybody was wearing black woolen clothes, only the Chairman, Railway Board, General Manager, Dy. Commissioner Amritsar/Punjab and Principal Heads of Departments from Delhi only could be seated on sofa and all other officers from the division had to remain standing. The Petitioner being the only lady officer was also asked to sit down. The rest of the averments in these paragraphs do not call for any comments from the answering respondents except that the occasion, the atmosphere and surroundings being so solemn and also considering the fact of the presence of the Chairman, Railway Board and other senior officers and distinguished guests in the room, any incident of the nature alleged by the petitioner could not have gone unnoticed but, on the contrary, would have created quite a commotion.
That as regards the averments contained in para 8 of the Writ Petition, it is most respectfully submitted that the petitioner did not inform about any such incident immediately at Beas. However, at Ludhiana she informed briefly about the alleged misbehaviour of the DRM (Respondent No. 5) at the residence of the Beas Religious Head, just before the departure of the Special Train from Ludhiana. The respondent No. 4 was concerned about this and told her that he would apprise the General Manager as the allegation made by the petitioner was against a Divisional Railway Manager (DRM), a senior officer reporting to the General Manager. The respondent No. 4 also advised the petitioner that she should come to Delhi and apprise the General Manager personally. The General Manager was also duly apprised of this conversation on return to Delhi.
That as regards the averments contained in para 9 of the Writ Petition, it is submitted that immediately after the petitioner's conversation with the respondent No. 4 at Ludhiana Station and on being apprised of the said conversation by the respondent No. 4, a preliminary formal inquiry was conducted by the General Manager in which the then DRM, Ferozepur (respondent No. 5) was also called by him. Taking all pertinent factors into account, it was felt that the entire episode had arisen due to some misunderstanding. Subsequently, the Petitioner had met the General Manager along with her husband and the FA&CAO (Respondent No. 4) on 23.1.1998 and among other things her request for transfer in Delhi was noted. The allegation of the petitioner that she was told by Shri Gurdeep Singh, FA&CAO (B&E) not to come to Delhi is totally false and is denied.
That as regards the averments contained in paras 10, 11 and 12 of the Writ Petition, it is most respectfully submitted that in these paragraphs, the petitioner has made an attempt to show that the respondent No. 4 had refused permission for proceeding on leave to the petitioner. The respondents most humbly submit that the position has been twisted out of context by the petitioner. The petitioner was advised not to waste her leave if she, any way, wished to come out of the Ferozepur Division. The petitioner was also informed that her request for transfer out of Ferozepur Division and posting at Delhi was under active consideration and that if the petitioner felt that she could not continue working at Ferozepur, these orders could be expedited. The petitioner did not press for leave after this. That as regards the petitioner's letter dated 7.1.1998, the General Manger was apprised of the position and the petitioner was advised to come to Delhi. The allegation that because of unwillingness on the part of the respondent No. 4 to sanction leave, the petitioner was forced to join duties on 1.1.1998 is totally baseless and is therefore emphatically denied.
That as regards the allegations contained in para 13 of the writ petition, the respondents most respectfully submit that the same are totally false and are therefore denied. It is submitted that the matter has been got investigated by the Standing Complaints Committee which was nominated in terms of Railway Board's instructions based on the judgment of the Apex Court in Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan and others and the said Committee had found that the charges leveled against the respondent No. 5 (Shri Raj Kumar) were not established.”
16. On the issue of transfer of the petitioner in Delhi, it was stated that it was at her own request made verbally. Regarding grievance of not allotting house at Delhi, it is stated that none was available. Regarding non sanctioning of an increment during period of leave without pay, it is stated that rules prohibited the same. Same was intimated to the petitioner vide letter dated 15.2.1999 Regarding the grievance of the petitioner that during the period when the first committee was functioning she received blank and indecent calls, it is stated that when petitioner made such a grievance her two telephones were put under observation for a month and no such calls were detected. Learned counsel for the respondents contended that the petitioner had totally misunderstood the nature of the enquiry to be conducted by the committee. She wanted to be assigned the role of a prosecutor. She was treating her complaint as if it was a charge sheet against respondent No. 5. Counsel contended that even as per guidelines in Vishaka's case, the grievance committee was to evolve a fair procedure to go into a complaint received and by the very nature of the proceedings, some form of confidentiality has to be maintained. After all, dignity and reputation of the other side was also at stake. Counsel contended that proceedings were akin to a fact finding proceedings which precede a formal indiciment. Therefore, there was no question of cross-examining witnesses nor was a copy of the report to be furnished.
17. From the perusal of the guidelines laid down in Vishaka's case, it is apparent that the nature of proceedings by the committee to which a complaint of sexual harassment is referred to is more in the nature of an inquisitorial proceedings and not adjudicatory proceedings. There is no lis. The enquiry has all the characteristics of a fact finding committee. The person against whom allegations are made is not a delinquent officer nor is the person making the complaint a prosecutor. Honour of the lady is at stake, but at the same time reputation of the person against whom allegations are made is also at stake. By the very nature of the proceedings, confidentiality has to be maintained. The grievance of the petitioner, therefore, that witnesses should be examined in her presence and she be allowed to cross-examine them, cannot be accepted. Nor can the grievance of the petitioner pertaining to non-supply of the entire report to her, be accepted. The committee has to arrive at the truth. How it arrives at the truth to be determined by the committee. Material in the form of evidence may not be confined to legal evidence in the strict sense. Scrutiny of evidence is not as if anybody is on trial. Of course, minimum requirements of natural justice have to be met. The person making the allegation has to be allowed to lead evidence and present her case. In the conduct of the enquiry, the committee would be entitled to make discrete enquiry, contents whereof need not be disclosed to either party. It is not to be forgotten that the enquiry pertains to an act of sexual misconduct amounting to sexual harassment as defined in Vishaka's judgment. Right to be heard is a well established part of Natural Justice. However, what does this exactly mean has vexed the courts time and again. 4 decades ago, in 1964 AC 40, Ridge v. Baldwin. Lord Reid very succinctly described it as not being capable of exact definition but what a reasonable man would regard as a fair procedure in particular circumstances. In AIR 1973 SC 389, Keshor Mills Co. Ltd. v. UOI. adverting to the attributes of the doctrine, it was held:
“The second question, however, as to what are the principles of natural justice that should regulate an administrative act or order is a much more difficult one to answer. We do not think it either feasible or even desirable to lay down any fixed or rigorous yard stick in this manner. The concept of natural justice cannot be put into a straitjacket. It is futile, therefore, to look for definitions or standards of natural justice from various decisions and then try to apply them to the fact of any given case. The only essential point that has to be kept in mind in all cases is that the person concerned should have a reasonable opportunity of presenting his case and that the administrative authority concerned should act fairly, impartially and reasonably.”
18. Even the applicability of the concept of fair play requires real flexibility. Everything would depend on the actual facts and circumstances of a case. In (1949) 1 All ER 109, Russel v. Duke of Norfolk Tucker L.J observed:
“The requirement of Natural Justice must depend on the circumstances of the case, the nature of the enquiry, the rules under which the tribunal is acting, the subject matter that is being dealt with and so forth.”
19. At my asking, at the hearing a copy of the report was handed over for my perusal. Report shows that there were 5 members of the committee namely Smt. Padmakshi Raheja-Chairperson, Sh. Sudhir Mathur-Convenor, Dr. Manorama Bawa-Member (from an NGO All India Womens Conference), Smt. Dipali Khanna-Member and Sh. Pradeep Bhatnagar-Member. The committee was, therefore, constituted as per Vishaka's judgment. Though, records of the previous committee were handed over to the new committee, the new committee, de-novo examined the entire matter. The report of the committee records that the methodology adopted by the committee to conduct the enquiry was:
“(i) Having regard to the sensitive nature of the assignment the Committee needs to have a human approach to unravel the truth.
(ii) In view of the specific doubts raised by Mrs. Manisha Sharma regarding the appointment of the Committee, its objectivity etc. and proceed independent of the Fact Finding Report in a de novo fashion.
(iii) To in-still confidence in the mind of the complainant by keeping a close liaison with her telephonically and personally to the extent possible.
(iv) To examine key witnesses and officials named by the complainant in the case de novo and obtain their written depositions.
(v) To keep NCW, Rly. Board and GM informed about the progress in the case.
(vi) In order to give reasonable opportunity to Sh. Raj Kumar to prepare his defence a copy of Mrs. Manisha Sharma's complaint was given to him.
20. The committee identified the following to be determined by it :—
a) Incident at Beas at the residence of the head of Radha Swami Satsangon 18.12.1997;
b) report on verbal misbehaviour of DRM/FRZ to FA&CAO and FA&CAO/B&E during her visit to the headquarters;
c) non-provision of attached toilet facitilites:
d) allocation of inspection carriage for overnight travel;
e) inaction by FA&CAO/B&E and FA&CAO on the complaint;
f) DRM's annual inspection on 17.1.1998;
g) Unjustified transfer from Ferozabad to Delhi.
21. The report records that in pursuance of its objectives of making petitioner comfortable, it was decided to hold a meeting with her, at her convenience, at the place of her choice. The member of the committee Smt. Deepali Khanna spoke to the petitioner over telephone and informed her about the formation of the new committee. She agreed to appear before the committee on 31.8.1998 but later rang up saying that she needs time to think and would revert. Since she did not indicate a convenient date, the date was fixed. The petitioner, after much persuasion, agreed to meet the committee at Ferozpur on 23.10.1998 She was heard. The committee examined respondent No. 5 on 10.11.1998 Committee also examined various officers (for sake of confidentiality, I need not disclose their names). The vast experience and knowledge of Dr. Manorma Bawa in dealing with such cases was used by the committee to have the requisite objectivity. After referring to the deposition of various persons, who were examined by the committee, it recorded its conclusions and recommendations. Since the conclusions and recommendations were made known to the petitioner and are no longer in the realm of confidentially, I may note the same.
“7. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS.
7.1 The Committee afforded full opportunity to both Smt. Manisha Sharma and Sh. Raj Kumar to present their cases. After meeting them and other officials a consensus view point has emerged. The vast experience and knowledge of Dr. Manorama Bawa in dealing with such cases provided not only the needed objectivity but also immensely contributed in expeditiously finalising the case. The conclusions and recommendations are as follows:
(a) The charges of sexual harassment made by Smt. Manisha Sharma are indeed grave and serious, particularly centering around the incidents at Beas; in the carriage at Kotkapura and construction of toilet facilities. The Committee tried to re-construct the sequence of events and took note of the circumstantial evidence available. Having regard to the depositions of other officers particularly lady officers (contemporaries of Mrs. Manish Sharma) the Committee has come to the conclusion that the allegations of sexual harassment against Sh. Raj Kumar are not established. Also, given the track record of Sh. Raj Kumar, he does not appear to have any proclivity, whatsoever, towards sexual harassment and misconduct with women.
(b) However, evidence available, written or oral indicates that the chain of events that led to this case being referred to the Committee could have been avoided through a more mature handling of a delicate situation by the DRM, Sh. Raj Kumar. As soon Sh. Raj Kumar came to know about the charge, even though orally, he could have cleared the air by a process of reconciliation and dialogue rather than allowing things to drift along and mutual acrimony to compound.
(c) The issue relating to Smt. Sharma's transfer out of Firozpur to Delhi does not strictly fall within the terms of reference of this Committee. In any case, based on Sh. Murali's deposition and evidence given by others, the Committee is of the view that Smt. Sharma's transfer out of FZR was at her request.
There is no evidence of deliberate victimisation of Mrs. Sharma by transferring her to Delhi a place where a large number of officers of her seniority are waiting to be posted and vacancies are hard to come by.
(d) Having regard to the sensitivity of the situation and considering the immense emotional and physical trauma experienced by both the parties, more particularly Smt. Manisha Sharma, the Committee feels that a reapproachment may be attempted between them at a sufficiently senior level in order that the mis-understanding and mis-apprehensions between the two of them are sorted out. It should be endeavoured that both parties put the entire episode behind them and get back to their respective official routines with a clean slate.
(e) The Committee wishes to place on record its sympathies for the deep emotional stress experienced by Mrs. Manisha Sharma in pursuing this case. In the process she and her family have suffered hardship and inconvenience. The Committee recommends that the Administration should consider posting her to a place from where she can restart her official career with dignity and respect which she, as also other women members of the society, so richly deserve.
(f) With the spread of education and litracy during the past several years women have dislodged male supremacy. There is hardly any sphere of economic, social or political activity which is purely male-dominated, thanks to the awareness and opportunities which today's socio-economic milieu affords. In harmony with this favourable trend a gradual replacement of the tradition bound society with a more liberal dispensation where man and women are seen working together, virtually hand in hand has taken place. Yet, in this context, often men and women continue to be insensitive to these changes. In this environment it becomes necessary that there is gender-sensitivity in the work culture. The
Department should consider organising gender-sensitive training capsules for both middle and senior level personnel.”
22. The report of the committee runs into 15 pages and indeed each and every grievance of the petitioner has been looked into with objectivity. I have already dealt with, in para 17 above as to what should be the procedure followed when a committee has to investigate allegations of sexual harassment. Indeed the procedure has been followed.
23. It is difficult to fathom how a human mind functions. From the record of the committee, pertaining to the incident at Beas, the explanation by respondent No. 5 was that in the room, limited sitting arrangement was made where only high ranking senior officials could be accommodated. He noticed the petitioner standing being a lady, she beckoned her to occupy the only available sitting space, being the sofa where the GM (NR) and DRM were sitting. He stated that with so many people in the room, it was impossible for him to have committed the alleged mis-demenour and misconduct. In fact, in the presence of a highly religious dignitary such mis-behaviour, if done, could not have gone unnoticed. It be noted that officers above the rank of respondent No. 5 were present. It appears, petitioner read too much into the same. Everything of the past was linked up. This was the starting point of the complaint. As a flash back even the things of the past where added. It is not a case where the petitioner could be put to a disadvantageous position in connection with her employment by respondent No. 5. It is not a case where petitioner could have been put to a fear that if she did not consent, adverse consequences could flow to her through respondent No. 5. Petitioner was only administratively reporting to respondent No. 5, who was the divisional head. She was not otherwise under him. Respondent No. 5 had no role in the recording of the A.C.Rs of the petitioner. Be that as it may, the grievance committee, on a broad based investigation, found no merit in the complaint raised by the petitioner.
24. Since the complaint committee has found no merits in the allegations raised by the petitioner, no occasion arises for granting any relief as prayed for. The writ petitioner is accordingly dismissed.
25. Events during the pendency of the petition pertaining to posting of the petitioner may be noted for the sake of record and consequential directions. Report of the enquiry committee is that the petitioner was transferred to Delhi on the basis of the request which she made to the General Manager on 23.1.1998 Petitioner applied for and was granted leave without pay for two years. On 22.5.2001, petitioner was posted as Additional Registrar, Railway Claims Tribunal (Chandigarh) but could not join as the Tribunal did not agree to the petitioner's posting there. She was paid her salary for the period 25.5.2001 in 31.8.2001 (in the month of October, 2001). Posting order dated 22.5.2001 was canceled on 17.9.2001 Petitioner was issued an order dated 25.9.2001 posting her to Delhi. She has not complied with the order. Matter was examined whether the petitioner could be posted to the Railway Recruitment Board. The railway authorities filed an affidavit on 29.11.2002 placing on record that petitioner could not be posted to the Railway Recruitment Board as she was in the scale of Rs. 14300-18300 while the scale in the Railway Recruitment Board was Rs. 18400-22400. During arguments, it was stated that the petitioner's posting order dated 25.9.2001 remains in force. The post is still vacant. Petitioner was having an objection of being posted at Delhi as respondent No. 5 was also posted at Delhi. It was stated during arguments that respondent No. 5 has since retired in October, 2003 and grievance of the petitioner not to be posted at Delhi does not survive at all. In this view of the matter, it would be open to the petitioner, if she so wishes to joint at Delhi. Non-joining at Delhi would be at the risk and peril of the petitioner.
26. Respondents have not paid any salary to the petitioner after September, 2001 because of her not joining at Delhi. Petitioner was not joining at Delhi because respondent No. 5 was posted at Delhi. Though, not being posted in the same office, she could not have objected to the same, however, keeping in view the truma which the petitioner was facing [to some extent self-induced]. I deem it appropriate to direct the General Manager, Northern Railways, if the petitioner joins her place of posting at Delhi, to consider sympathetically release of salary to the petitioner after September, 2001 as well.
27. As indicated in para 24 above, the writ petition stands dismissed. Directions in para 26 above, pertaining to release of past salary be considered by the General Manager, Northern Railway if the petitioner joins at Delhi within four weeks of her joining.
28. In the facts and circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.