Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 302/149 IPC to Section 304 Part II read with Section 149 IPC
  • Section 302 IPC read with Section 149 to Sections 304 Part II/149 IPC.
  • SECTION 320 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • provisions of the Penal Code, 1860 including Section 308
  • provisions of Section 360 CrPC.8.
  • Section 320 nor Section 360 CrPC
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 302/149 IPC to Section 304 Part II read with Section 149 IPC
  • Section 302 IPC read with Section 149 to Sections 304 Part II/149 IPC.
  • SECTION 320 CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE
  • provisions of the Penal Code, 1860 including Section 308
  • provisions of Section 360 CrPC.8.
  • Section 320 nor Section 360 CrPC
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The judgment disposes of two connected matters before the Supreme Court:

  • Criminal Appeal No. 207 of 2011 – Preferred by eight accused (two of whom died pending appeal) challenging their conviction and sentence. The trial court had convicted them under, inter alia, Section 308/149 IPC and imposed four years’ rigorous imprisonment. The High Court altered the conviction to Sections 325/149 IPC and reduced the sentence to one year’s rigorous imprisonment. The incident arose out of a 1997 dispute over possession of an open plot (“gher”), culminating in a mutual fight in which members of the complainant side (PW 1 Ameer Ahmed and PW 2 Musharraf) sustained injuries, including a fracture amounting to “grievous hurt.”
  • Criminal Appeal No. 208 of 2011 – Filed by the State questioning only the adequacy of sentence after the High Court altered the respondents’ conviction from Sections 302/149 IPC to Section 304 Part II/149 IPC and reduced the punishment from life imprisonment to the custody already undergone (approximately 2½ years). The incident is the same 1997 mutual fight; the opposing side (appellants in Appeal 207) had also been tried and convicted for causing injuries.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants in Criminal Appeal No. 207 could claim the right of private defence so as to negate criminal liability under Sections 325/149 IPC.
  2. If liability were affirmed, whether the offences should be compounded under Section 320 CrPC or the appellants released on probation under Section 360 CrPC.
  3. In Criminal Appeal No. 208, whether the sentence of “period already undergone” (≈2½ years) for an offence under Section 304 Part II/149 IPC was grossly inadequate in light of the statutory maximum of ten years.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants – Criminal Appeal No. 207

  • The confrontation arose while exercising their right of private defence over the disputed “gher,” hence no offence was committed.
  • Alternatively, the offences could be compounded with payment of compensation to the injured persons.
  • Even if conviction stands, the Court should invoke Section 360 CrPC and release them on probation of good conduct.

State/Respondent – Criminal Appeal No. 207

  • Both groups voluntarily confronted each other; it was a “free fight,” so the right of private defence is unavailable.
  • Section 325 IPC is a serious offence; the reduced sentence of one year is already lenient, hence neither Section 320 nor Section 360 CrPC should apply.

State/Appellant – Criminal Appeal No. 208

  • Without challenging alteration of conviction to Section 304 Part II, the State argued that a sentence of only 2½ years is manifestly inadequate when the statute permits up to ten years.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Criminal Appeal No. 207

  • The trial court and High Court had concurrently found that injuries to PW 1 and PW 2 occurred during a mutual fight, a finding supported by the evidence; the Supreme Court saw no ground to disturb it.
  • Because the fight was mutual, the statutory right of private defence could not exonerate the appellants.
  • Medical evidence showed a fracture injury to PW 2, amounting to “grievous hurt”; punishment therefore falls under Section 325 IPC (maximum seven years).
  • The one-year sentence imposed by the High Court was deemed “lenient enough.”
  • Victims were unwilling to compound, and no “special circumstance” justified invoking Sections 320 or 360 CrPC.

Criminal Appeal No. 208

  • The incident occurred in 1997 during a mutual fight; members of the complainant side had also been convicted for causing injuries, underscoring mutuality.
  • Given the passage of time and interconnected convictions (Appeal 207), the Court found no justification to enhance the sentence.
  • The principles governing appellate interference with sentencing did not warrant revisiting the High Court’s discretion.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED – Both Criminal Appeal No. 207 of 2011 and Criminal Appeal No. 208 of 2011 were dismissed, affirming the High Court’s judgment dated 21-5-2010.

Implications: The appellants in Appeal 207 must undergo the remaining portion of the one-year rigorous imprisonment; no probation or compounding is permitted. The respondents in Appeal 208 will not face any additional custody beyond the 2½ years already served. The decision turns on factual concurrence and applies existing statutory provisions, setting no new legal precedent.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Maqsood And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .

    Ranjan Gogoi, J.—

    Criminal Appeal No. 207 of 2011

    1. Out of the eight appellants who have filed this appeal challenging their conviction, inter alia, under Section 325 IPC as made by the High Court by the impugned judgment and order dated 21-5-2010 2010 SCC OnLine All 1064 , (2010) 92 AIC 849, Appellants 2 and 6 (Shakeel and Haneef) have died during the pendency of the present appeal. We will, therefore, be concerned with the case of the remaining appellants before us.

    2. The learned trial court had convicted the appellants under different provisions of the Penal Code, 1860 including Section 308 thereof and sentenced the appellant-accused to undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of 4 years under the aforesaid section of the Code. In appeal, the High Court while maintaining the conviction and sentence awarded for the lesser offences altered the conviction under Sections 308/149 IPC to Sections 325/149 IPC. The sentence of four years' rigorous imprisonment was also reduced to a period of one year. It is against the aforesaid order of the High Court that the appellants have filed the present appeal.

    3. We have heard Shri Siddhartha Dave, learned counsel for the appellants and Shri Ratnakar Dash, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent.

    4. The learned counsel for the appellants has vehemently argued that the acts committed by the appellant-accused were in the exercise of their right of self-defence inasmuch as the complainant party which had comprised of as many as 8 persons had come to assert their right over the gher (open area of land), ownership and possession of which was disputed between the parties. On the said basis it is contended that no offence can be attributed to the accused on account of the overt acts committed by them, the same being in exercise of their right of self-defence. Alternatively, it is argued that if this Court is to hold that the appellant-accused are guilty of commission of the offences in question the said offences may be compounded and the accused may be directed to pay compensation to the injured. Additionally, it is urged that the provisions of Section 360 CrPC may be invoked and while maintaining the conviction the accused may be released on probation of good conduct.

    5. The arguments advanced on behalf of the appellants have been resisted by the learned counsel appearing for the State who contends that the benefit of right of private defence would not be available to the accused inasmuch as both parties had come to the disputed gher and there was a mutual altercation leading to a free fight between the two groups. The above is a finding of fact recorded by the learned trial court and affirmed by the High Court. The learned counsel for the respondent has urged that the offence under Section 325 IPC being grave and the sentence imposed (one year's rigorous imprisonment) by the High Court being sufficiently lenient, in the facts of the present case, the provisions of neither Section 320 nor Section 360 CrPC ought to be invoked.

    6. We have considered the submissions advanced on behalf of the parties. We have also looked into the evidence and materials on record. The trial court and the High Court have concurrently held that the injuries sustained by PW 2, Musharraf and PW 1, Ameer Ahmed have been caused by the accused in the course of a mutual fight. The said finding of fact is supported by the evidence and materials on record. This Court, therefore, will have no occasion to arrive at any contrary finding. What would follow from the above is that the accused persons must be held liable for the acts committed and the consequential injuries suffered by PW 2 Musharraf and PW 1 Ameer Ahmed.

    7. We have considered the medical evidence on record which shows that PW 2 Musharraf, had suffered a fracture injury which would bring the same within the expression “grievous hurt” as appearing in Section 320 IPC. Punishment for the said offence would, therefore, be covered by Section 325 IPC which contemplates a period of imprisonment up to 7 years along with fine. Having regard to the above, the punishment of imprisonment of one year imposed by the High Court, in our view, is lenient enough and, therefore, will not justify our interference. The injured Musharraf (PW 2) and Ameer Ahmed (PW 1) who are represented in the connected appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 208 of 2011) are not willing to compound the offence in question. It is also our considered view that the present case is devoid of any special circumstance which would justify invocation of the provisions of Section 320 of the Criminal Procedure Code or the release of the appellant-accused on probation by invoking the provisions of Section 360 CrPC.

    8. For the aforesaid reasons, we find no merit in this appeal. Consequently, the same is dismissed and the order 2010 SCC OnLine All 1064 , (2010) 92 AIC 849 of the High Court is affirmed.

    Criminal Appeal No. 208 of 2011

    9. This appeal is filed by the State against the alteration of the conviction of the respondent-accused under Sections 302/149 IPC to Section 304 Part II read with Section 149 IPC as well as the reduction of the sentence of life imprisonment to the period of custody undergone by the accused which is about 2½ years. There are certain other offences under the Code for which the respondent-accused have been found guilty and have been accordingly convicted and sentenced. However, the same would not be very significant and it is the conviction under Section 304 Part II and the sentence imposed which may be treated as the principal offence.

    10. Shri Ratnakar Dash, learned counsel for the appellant, has argued that the State would truncate the scope of the present appeal and not question the correctness of the alteration of the conviction from Section 302 IPC read with Section 149 to Sections 304 Part II/149 IPC. It is urged that the only question, therefore, would be the correctness of the sentence imposed (period already undergone) on the respondent-accused following the alteration of their conviction to Section 304 Part II IPC. Shri Dash has submitted that the respondent-accused had undergone custody for a period of about 2½ years and as the maximum sentence imposable under Section 304 Part II is 10 years, the sentence awarded in the present case is grossly inadequate.

    11. For the purpose of deciding the above contention advanced on behalf of the State, it is not necessary for us to enter into a detailed discussion on the nature of the sentencing power and the principles governing its exercise as also the parameters for interference in the case of inappropriate sentencing. All that would be required to be noticed is that, though not specifically mentioned in the order of the High Court, the incident had occurred in the year 1997 and that death had occurred in the course of a mutual fight. The party of the complainant had also been tried for injuries caused to some of the present accused and have been found guilty and convicted under Section 325 IPC which conviction and the sentence imposed (one year's rigorous imprisonment) has been challenged in the connected appeal (Criminal Appeal No. 207 of 2011). Taking into account all the said facts and the long efflux of time that has occurred, we are of the view that no interference with the sentence imposed by the High Court would be justified. Accordingly, we dismiss this appeal and affirm the order 2010 SCC OnLine All 1064 , (2010) 92 AIC 849 of the High Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Maqsood And Others v. State Of Uttar Pradesh .
    (Oct 9, 2015)