AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Oil and Natural Gas Commission (ONGC) awarded Hindustan Shipyard Ltd. (HSL) a contract for fabrication, skidding, sea-fastening, transportation and allied works at various coastal stations. In accordance with a contractual liberty to engage sub-contractors, HSL sub-contracted a part of this work to Essar Oil Ltd. (Essar).

To facilitate cash flow, ONGC occasionally made direct payments to Essar, debiting HSL’s account. A dispute arose when Essar alleged non-payment by HSL and invoked the arbitration clause contained solely in the sub-contract between Essar and HSL. An Arbitral Tribunal, by majority, held that:

  • There was no privity of contract between Essar and ONGC.
  • HSL alone was liable to pay Essar.

The dissenting arbitrator opined that ONGC was the proper debtor. HSL challenged the majority award under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 before the Principal District Judge, Visakhapatnam, who largely upheld the award. On appeal, the Andhra Pradesh High Court (29-9-2004) reversed, treating ONGC as a contracting party, setting aside the award and remanding Essar to sue ONGC. Essar appealed to the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether ONGC, by virtue of direct payments and correspondence, became a contracting party liable to Essar, creating a tripartite agreement.
  2. Whether the Arbitral Tribunal’s majority view—fixing liability on HSL alone—was vulnerable to being set aside under Section 34, Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Essar Oil Ltd.)

  • No privity of contract existed between Essar and ONGC; direct payments were only for expediency and always debited to HSL’s account.
  • No document evidenced any tripartite agreement; therefore the majority arbitral award was correct and immune from High Court interference.

Respondent (Hindustan Shipyard Ltd.)

  • Contractual relationships need not be in writing; conduct and correspondence revealed an implied contract making ONGC liable.
  • Letters—including HSL’s letter of 25-10-1991 and ONGC’s subsequent correspondence—show ONGC undertook to pay Essar, relieving HSL of liability. The High Court therefore rightly directed Essar to proceed against ONGC.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised:

  • The sub-contract between Essar and HSL, noting ONGC was not a signatory.
  • Correspondence relied upon by HSL and the High Court. The Court found that, at most, the letters evidenced an operational understanding allowing ONGC to pay Essar on HSL’s behalf, not a contractual undertaking by ONGC to assume primary liability.
  • The arbitration agreement, which bound only Essar and HSL; ONGC, not being a party, could not be saddled with liability by the Tribunal, nor could its absence render the award void.
  • The practice of ONGC debiting HSL’s account whenever it paid Essar, reinforcing that payments were made on HSL’s behalf.

Consequently, the Court agreed with the majority arbitral view. It held that the High Court erred in extrapolating an implied tripartite contract and in setting aside a legally sustainable award.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed; High Court judgment set aside. The majority award is restored: Hindustan Shipyard Ltd. must pay Essar Oil Ltd.; ONGC bears no liability.

Implications: The decision reinforces the principle that occasional direct payments and facilitating arrangements do not create contractual privity or liability absent clear intent. It underscores judicial deference to arbitral awards where the arbitral reasoning is rooted in established contractual relationships.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Essar Oil Limited v. Hindustan Shipyard Limited And Others

    Anil R. Dave, J.— Being aggrieved by the common judgment dated 29-9-2004 delivered in Hindustan Shipyard Ltd. v. Essar Oil Ltd. 2004 SCC OnLine AP 745 by the High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad, these appeals have been filed by M/s Essar Oil Ltd., who had been given a sub-contract by the first respondent, Hindustan Shipyard Ltd., in respect of a contract which was given to it by the Oil and Natural Gas Commission.

    2. The facts giving rise to the present litigation, in a nutshell, are as under: the Oil and Natural Gas Commission (hereinafter referred to as “ONGC”) had given a contract to Hindustan Shipyard Ltd. to carry out work of fabrication, skidding, sea fastening, transportation, etc. at various stations located in the coastal areas of India. It is pertinent to note that the contractor, Hindustan Shipyard Ltd., who is Respondent 1 in both the appeals, had been permitted to avail services of any other person for doing the aforestated work entrusted to it. In other words, it was open to Respondent 1 to engage a sub-contractor for getting the work done. Other respondents in these appeals are the arbitrators, who are formal parties.

    3. In pursuance of the aforestated understanding arrived at and the contract entered into between ONGC and Hindustan Shipyard Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as “the respondent”), the respondent had entered into a contract with M/s Essar Oil Ltd., who is the appellant in both these appeals. Thus, the appellant was a sub-contractor in respect of the contract which the respondent had to fulfil for ONGC.

    4. It appears that for the sake of convenience and so as to obviate certain financial difficulties of the respondent, certain payments had been made to the appellant directly by ONGC. The appellant, upon getting certain work done under the sub-contract and upon getting necessary certificates with regard to the quality and quantity of the work done from the respondent, had received some payment from ONGC on the strength of those certificates.

    5. In the process of carrying out the contract, the appellant was not paid by the respondent for the work done and therefore, a dispute had arisen between the appellant and the respondent. Let us not look at the nature of the dispute or the amount claimed or the liability with regard to making payment to the appellant at this stage, suffice it to state that there was an arbitration agreement between the appellant and the respondent and therefore, the dispute had been referred to the Arbitral Tribunal. Respondents 2, 3 and 4 are the arbitrators, who had made the award with regard to which we will discuss presently.

    6. Thus, the dispute with regard to non-payment and some other disputes had been referred to the Arbitral Tribunal consisting of Respondents 2, 3 and 4. It is pertinent to note here that ONGC, who had given a contract to the respondent, was not before the Arbitral Tribunal because ONGC was not a party to the arbitration agreement entered into between the appellant and the respondent. The question which was involved in the said dispute was not only with regard to determination of the amount to be paid to the appellant, but was also with regard to determination of a person who was liable to make payment to the appellant.

    7. After hearing the parties concerned, the Arbitral Tribunal made an award, but all the three members of the Tribunal could not come to the same conclusion. The majority i.e two members of the Tribunal came to the conclusion that there was no privity of contract between the appellant and ONGC; and ONGC was not a party to the contract between the appellant and the respondent. In the aforestated circumstances, ONGC, according to the majority view, could not be held liable for making payment to the appellant and the liability to make payment to the appellant was that of the respondent. It was also held by the majority that the appellant could not even sue ONGC for the unpaid amount. Accordingly, the award was made. At this stage, we are not concerned with the other facts and the amount awarded by the majority of the Tribunal.

    8. On the other hand, the dissenting member, who was in minority, was of the opinion that there was a contract between the appellant and ONGC and therefore, ONGC was liable to make payment to the appellant, but he expressed an opinion to the effect that the respondent should be directed to make payment to the appellant only if the respondent is paid the unpaid amount by ONGC. Thus, the minority view was that the liability to make payment to the appellant was that of ONGC, but as ONGC was not a party before the Tribunal, the proper course open to the appellant was to take appropriate legal action against ONGC for recovery of the amount due and payable to the appellant.

    9. The respondent was aggrieved by the award of the Arbitral Tribunal as according to the majority view of the Tribunal, the respondent was liable to make payment to the appellant. In the circumstances, the respondent filed OPs Nos. 989 of 2001 and 96 of 2002 before the Principal District Judge, Visakhapatnam, under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

    10. The Principal District Judge, Visakhapatnam, decided both the original petitions by orders dated 10-10-2002 and 1-11-2002, respectively. The learned Principal District Judge confirmed the award on the issues with which we are concerned, but he remanded the matter to the Arbitral Tribunal on the issues regarding counterclaim, etc. with which we are not concerned in this case.

    11. Being aggrieved by the aforestated two orders passed in two original petitions, the respondent filed appeals against Orders Nos. 255 and 624 of 2003 before the High Court of Andhra Pradesh and the High Court allowed the appeals by a common judgment dated 29-9-2004, validity of which has been challenged before this Court in these appeals.

    12. The High Court came to a conclusion that there was a tripartite agreement among ONGC, the appellant and the respondent. The High Court had relied upon some letters written by the appellant to ONGC and therefore, ONGC was also treated as a party to the contract. It also held that as ONGC was a party to the contract, it ought to have been made a party before the Arbitral Tribunal but as ONGC was not represented before the Arbitral Tribunal, the award made by the Tribunal was bad in law. The award deserved to be set aside by the Principal District Judge but he did not and therefore, the orders passed in the original petitions filed before the learned Principal District Judge were also bad in law and accordingly the award and the orders passed in the original petitions were quashed and set aside.

    13. The main issue which is involved in these appeals is about ascertainment of a person who is liable to make payment to the appellant. There is no dispute with regard to quality or quantity of the work done by the appellant at this stage. It is not in dispute that the appellant has not been paid the amount payable to it. It is also not in dispute that the appellant had been engaged by the respondent in pursuance of a contract entered into between the respondent and ONGC and it was open to the respondent to avail services of any other person for doing the work entrusted to it by ONGC.

    14. In the light of the aforestated undisputed facts, the question is only with regard to determination of liability of the person who has to make payment to the appellant.

    15. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant had vehemently submitted that the view taken by the majority of the Arbitral Tribunal being correct, the High Court ought not to have interfered with the said view. So as to substantiate his submission, the learned counsel had mainly submitted that there was no privity of contract between the appellant and ONGC. The appellant had performed the work of ONGC in pursuance of a contract given to it by the respondent, which was a sub-contract in nature. In the absence of any contract between ONGC and the appellant, the appellant could not have made any claim before ONGC and as there was no contract between them, it was also not possible for the appellant to make ONGC a party before any court or authority for recovery of the amount payable to it in pursuance of the sub-contract given by the respondent.

    16. It had been fairly admitted by the learned counsel appearing for the appellant that very often payments were made to the appellant by ONGC. It had further been submitted that the payments were made by ONGC so as to facilitate the appellant and to get the work of the contract done smoothly. Every time when payment was made by ONGC to the appellant, ONGC used to debit the account of the respondent i.e the amount so paid by ONGC to the appellant was treated by ONGC as if the said payment was made by ONGC to the respondent. Thus, so as to obviate a long procedure and to expedite payment to the appellant, who was actually doing the job for ONGC, instead of ONGC paying to the appellant through the respondent, ONGC was paying directly to the appellant.

    17. The learned counsel for the appellant had with great stress submitted that there was not a single contract between the appellant and ONGC and there was no tripartite contract among the appellant, the respondent and ONGC, whereby ONGC was made liable to pay the appellant in respect of the work done by it.

    18. For the aforestated simple reason, it had been submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that the majority view of the Arbitral Tribunal was correct and the respondent is liable to make payment to the appellant with whom it had entered into the contract. It had been further submitted by the learned counsel that in view of the aforestated factual and legal position, the appeals deserve to be allowed and the respondent should be made liable to make payment to the appellant.

    19. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent had submitted that ONGC was liable to make payment to the appellant and therefore, there is no liability on the part of the respondent to make payment to the appellant. It had further been submitted by the learned counsel for the respondent that it is not necessary that in each and every case the contract should be in writing. The contract can be very well inferred by the act or conduct of the parties, whereby impliedly a party undertakes to make good a liability to make payment to someone. According to the learned counsel, even in the instant case, there was an implied contract amongst the appellant, the respondent and ONGC and therefore, it was the liability of ONGC to make payment to the appellant.

    20. The learned counsel for the respondents had drawn our attention to the correspondence exchanged between ONGC and the respondent. He had specially referred to a letter dated 25-10-1991 addressed by the respondent to ONGC, wherein it was stated that ONGC had desired to make payment directly to the appellant in pursuance of meetings convened among the representatives of the respondents and ONGC. He had also submitted that some of the letters written by ONGC to the respondent clearly denoted that ONGC had accepted the liability to make payment to the appellant and therefore, there was no liability on the part of the respondent to make any payment to the appellant. He had further submitted that the subsequent conduct of ONGC of making direct payment to the appellant established the fact that ONGC had undertaken the liability to make payment to the appellant. The aforestated letter dated 25-10-1991 and other letters which had been exchanged between the respondent and ONGC were placed on record to show that there was a contract between ONGC and the appellant.

    21. For the aforestated reasons, it had been submitted by the learned counsel for the respondent that the view of the High Court that ONGC was liable to make payment to the appellant is correct and therefore, the appellant should take appropriate action against ONGC for recovery of the unpaid amount. The learned counsel had, therefore, submitted that the view taken by the High Court is absolutely correct and the respondent is no more liable to make any payment to the appellant.

    22. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties at length and have also considered some judgments cited by them and the documents which had been placed on record and relied upon by them.

    23. Upon hearing the learned counsel and looking at the contract entered into between the appellant and the respondent and upon perusal of other letters, we believe that the view expressed by the High Court cannot be accepted.

    24. It is true that ONGC had made payment to the appellant directly on several occasions. Upon perusal of the correspondence, we find that some understanding, but not amounting to any agreement or contract, was arrived at between ONGC and the respondent for making direct payment to the appellant, possibly because the respondent was not in a position to make prompt payments to the appellant. It also appears that on account of the delay in making payment to the appellant, the work of ONGC was likely to be adversely affected. ONGC was interested in getting its work done promptly and without any hassles. In the circumstances, upon perusal of the correspondence, which had taken place between ONGC and the respondent, it is clear that so as to facilitate the respondent, ONGC had made payments on behalf of the respondent to the appellant directly.

    25. Simply because some payments had been made by ONGC to the appellant, it would not be established that there was a privity of contract between ONGC and the appellant and only for that reason ONGC cannot be saddled with a liability to pay the amount payable to the appellant by the respondent.

    26. It is also pertinent to note that the arbitration agreement was only between the appellant and the respondent. ONGC was not a party to the arbitration agreement. When a dispute had arisen between the appellant and the respondent in relation to payment of money, the appellant had initiated the arbitration proceedings. As ONGC was not a party to the arbitration agreement, it could not have been represented before the Arbitral Tribunal. If ONGC was not a party before the Arbitral Tribunal, the Tribunal could not have made any award making ONGC liable to make payment to the appellant. In the aforestated factual and legal position, the Arbitral Tribunal could not have made ONGC liable in any respect and rightly, the majority view of the Arbitral Tribunal was to the effect that ONGC, not being a party to any contract or arbitration agreement with the appellant, could not have been made liable to make any payment to the appellant.

    27. We are in agreement with the view expressed by the majority of the Arbitral Tribunal. In our opinion, the High Court had committed an error by not considering the above facts and by observing that the appellant will have to take legal action against ONGC for recovery of the amount payable to it. If one looks at the relationship between the appellant and the respondent, it is very clear that the respondent had given a sub-contract to the appellant and in the said agreement of sub-contract, ONGC was not a party and there was no liability on the part of ONGC to make any payment to the appellant. Moreover, we could not find any correspondence establishing contractual relationship between ONGC and the appellant. In the circumstances, ONGC cannot be made legally liable to make any payment to the appellant. As stated hereinabove, only for the sake of convenience and to get the work of ONGC done without any hassle, ONGC had made payment to the appellant on behalf of the respondent without incurring any liability to make complete payment on behalf of the respondent.

    28. The learned counsel appearing for the appellant failed to show any document in the nature of a contract entered into between the appellant and ONGC whereby ONGC had made itself liable to make payment to the appellant. Even when the payment had been made by ONGC, it was very clear that the payments were made on behalf of the respondent as ONGC was debiting the account of the respondent by the amount paid to the appellant. It is important that the payment was made to the appellant only upon certification of work done by the respondent. ONGC had given a contract to the respondent. ONGC had never entered into any contract with the appellant and therefore, it did not rely upon any certification or any statement made by the appellant in relation to quantum of work done by the appellant. This fact also shows that ONGC was concerned with the work which had been approved by the respondent and instead of making payment to the respondent, ONGC had made payment to the appellant on behalf of the respondent, though there was no legal obligation on the part of ONGC to make such a payment to the appellant.

    29. For the aforestated reasons, we do not agree with the view expressed by the High Court and the impugned judgment delivered by the High Court is set aside. ONGC shall not be liable to make payment, as rightly decided by the Arbitral Tribunal, to the appellant but the payment shall have to be made by the respondent, who had given a sub-contract to the appellant. Majority view of the Arbitral Tribunal on the above issue is confirmed and the view of the High Court is not accepted. The respondent shall accordingly make payment to the appellant.

    30. For the reasons enumerated hereinabove, the appeals are allowed with no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Essar Oil Limited v. Hindustan Shipyard Limited And Others
    (Jul 2, 2015)