AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 21(3) and 35-A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949
  • Rule 8 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002
  • ARTICLE 21 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Information Companies (Regulation) Act,
  • Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 21(3) and 35-A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949
  • Rule 8 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002
  • ARTICLE 21 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • Information Companies (Regulation) Act,
  • Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State Bank of India (the ‘Bank’) obtained decrees for money against the petitioner in multiple cases filed before subordinate courts and magistrate courts concerning loan defaults and dishonour of cheques. The bank threatened to publish the photographs, names, and addresses of the petitioners in leading newspapers due to their failure to repay the loans within a specified time. The petitioners challenged this proposed publication as arbitrary, lacking legislative sanction, and violative of their fundamental rights under the Constitution of India. The bank contended it was entitled to take any lawful step to recover dues, including publication, citing precedents from other High Courts. The matter came before the court for consideration of the legality and propriety of the bank’s threatened action.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the bank has the legal authority under any statute or law to publish the photographs of loanees in newspapers as a means of debt recovery.
  2. Whether such publication infringes the fundamental rights of the loanees under Article 21 of the Constitution of India, including the right to live with dignity and the right to privacy.
  3. Whether clauses in loan agreements permitting disclosure of default information empower the bank to publish photographs of defaulters in newspapers.
  4. The validity and applicability of the Reserve Bank of India’s master circular on wilful defaulters concerning publication of photographs.
  5. The comparative legal positions and precedents from various High Courts on the permissibility of publishing photographs of defaulters.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The bank’s threat to publish photographs is arbitrary and lacks legislative sanction.
  • Publishing photographs violates their fundamental rights guaranteed under Article 21, including dignity and privacy.
  • The bank’s loan agreements do not expressly authorize publication of photographs.

Bank's Arguments

  • The bank is entitled to take any lawful step, including publication, to realise dues.
  • Such publication has been approved by some High Courts (Madras and Madhya Pradesh).
  • The terms and conditions in loan agreements grant the bank the right to disclose defaulters’ identities.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of A.PS Star Industries Ltd., (2010) 10 SCC 1 Power of RBI under Sections 21(3) and 35-A of the Banking Regulation Act to issue binding directions to banks. Confirmed that RBI’s master circulars have statutory force but do not authorize publication of photographs in newspapers.
M. Nagaraj v. Union of India, (2006) 8 SCC 212 Article 21 includes the right to live with human dignity. Supported the conclusion that publication of photographs infringes the right to dignity under Article 21.
Inspector General of Police v. S. Samuthiram, (2013) 1 SCC 598 Right to live with dignity and honour is guaranteed under Article 21. Reinforced the protection of dignity and privacy against arbitrary publication of personal information.
Mr ‘X’ v. Hospital ‘Z’, (1998) 8 SCC 296 Right to privacy as an essential component of Article 21, subject to lawful restrictions. Established that disclosure of private facts can harm tranquility and psychological well-being, supporting privacy claims.
Dr. Saurabh Jain v. State of Kerala, 2011 (1) KLT 888 Estoppel is not a defense against violation of fundamental rights. Held that even if loan agreements permit disclosure, fundamental rights cannot be overridden by estoppel.
K.J Doraisamy v. State Bank of India, (2006) 4 MLJ 1877 Bank’s entitlement to innovate methods for debt recovery. Disagreed with by this court, which rejected publication of photographs as a civilized recovery method.
Archana Chowhan v. State Bank of India, AIR 2007 MP 45 Publishing photographs of loanees is not impermissible. Disagreed with; this court found such publication illegal and arbitrary.
Ujjal Kumar Das v. State Bank of India, Calcutta High Court Publishing photographs not contemplated under SARFAESI Act. Followed by this court as the correct legal position.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the statutory framework governing debt recovery, including the SARFAESI Act and the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, and found no provision authorizing publication of loanees’ photographs as a recovery measure. The court noted that the publication is not a permissible measure under Section 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act or Rule 8 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. It emphasized that while the bank can enforce security interests or execute decrees, threatening publication lacks legislative sanction and is arbitrary.

The court analyzed the Reserve Bank of India’s master circular on wilful defaulters and concluded that it empowers dissemination of information only through authorized channels like Credit Information Companies, not newspapers. It further held that the fundamental rights under Article 21—specifically the right to live with dignity and the right to privacy—are infringed by such publication. The court cited Supreme Court precedents affirming human dignity and privacy as intrinsic to Article 21, noting that publication could cause irreparable damage and psychological harm.

The court also considered the contractual clauses in loan agreements, finding that they allow disclosure of names and credit information to authorized agencies but do not authorize publication of photographs in newspapers. Moreover, estoppel cannot be invoked by the bank to justify actions violating fundamental rights.

Regarding conflicting High Court decisions, the court respectfully disagreed with the Madras and Madhya Pradesh High Courts that permitted such publication, aligning instead with the Kolkata High Court’s view that publication is not a mode contemplated by law. The court underscored the civilizational principle that shaming persons in public for financial incapacity is unacceptable.

Holding and Implications

The writ petitions are allowed. The court issued a writ of prohibition restraining the bank from publishing the photographs of the petitioners in leading newspapers for failure to repay the debt within a specified date.

The decision prevents the bank from resorting to publication as a recovery measure, thereby protecting the fundamental rights of loanees under Article 21. However, the bank remains free to pursue all other legally sanctioned proceedings for recovery of dues. No costs were imposed, and no new precedent beyond this case was established.

    Venu P.R v. The Assistant General Manager, State Bank Of India & Anr.

    V. Chitambaresh, J.:— “Every life deserves a certain amount of dignity, no matter how poor or damaged the shell that carries it said the Pulitzer Prize winning writer Mr. Rick Bragg in his book-All Over But the Shoutin’. The propriety of the bank publishing the photograph of loanees in newspapers prejudicially affecting their dignity falls for consideration in these two writ petitions.

    2. The State Bank of India (the ‘Bank’ for short) has obtained a decree for money against the petitioner in WP(C) No. 10864/2013 and another in O.S No. 643/2010 on the file of the court of the Subordinate Judge of Ernakulam. The same petitioner has also been convicted for dishonour of cheque at the instance of the bank in S.T No. 4388/2010 on the file of the court of the Judicial First Class Magistrate, Kolenchery. Similarly the bank has filed a suit for realisation of money against the petitioner in WP(C) No. 10781/2013 and two others on the file of the court of the Subordinate Judge of Kottayam wherein the written statements are yet to be filed It is at this juncture has the bank issued notices to the petitioners threatening to publish their photographs, names and addresses in the leading newspapers. The petitioner challenge the proposed action of the bank as arbitrary and without any legislative sanction besides being violative of the fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution of India. The bank maintains that it is entitled to resort to any step for realisation of the amount due including publishing the photographs of the petitioners so long as the same is not forbidden by law. The bank points out that such a course has been approved by the High Courts of Madras and Madhya Pradesh even though frowned upon by the High Court of Kolkata. I heard Mr. Praveen Hariharan, Advocate and Mr. Abraham Mathew, Advocate on behalf ofthe petitioners and Mr. R.S Kalkura, Advocate on behalf of the bank. I also heard Mr. P. Deepak, Advocate as Amicus Curiae who deserves a rich encomium for the able assistance rendered to court.

    3. No doubt the bank is entitled to file a suit or initiate proceedings under the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest (SARFAESI) Act, 2002 for realisation of its dues. The bank can also resort to proceedings under the Kerala Revenue Recovery Act, 1968 for realisation of its dues in respect of certain categories of loans advanced. The decree obtained from the civil court can be put to execution or the security interest enforced under the SARFAESI Act or coercive revenue recovery steps initiated against the defaulter. But there is no provision in any ofthe enactments enabling the bank to threaten the loanees about its intention to publish their photographs in leading newspapers on failure to repay the debt within a specified date. It is to be noticed that publishing the photographs of loanees in newspapers is not a measure permitted under Section 13(4) against which only an appeal would lie under Section 17 of the SARFAESI Act. The property could be restored possession of to the loanees depending on the outcome of the appeal against the decree in the suit or the appeal in the Debts Recovery Tribunal under the SARFAESI Act. But the damage would have already been done by publishing the photographs ofthe loanees in the newspapers in the interregnum which cannot be undone even if a verdict favourable to them is rendered in appeal. The notice contemplated under Rule 8 of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002 is only intended to notify the details of the property offered as security interest. It may at best caution the public from entering into any transaction with the loanees in respect ofthe property notified and does not permit the publishing ofthe photographs of loanees. Apublic authority like the bank has the power to realise the dues only in a manner authorised by law quite unlike a private financier who can resort to any step unless forbidden by law. Situation may be different where the loanees are proclaimed offenders and are absconders fleeing away from the clutches of law in which case the publishing of their photographs might be justified. Otherwise the threat held out by the banks to publish the photographs of loanees in leading newspapers on their failure to repay the debt within a specified date lacks legislative sanction and is wholly illegal and arbitrary.

    4. The Reserve Bank of India has issued a master circular (DBOD No. CID.BC 10/20.16.003/2012-13 dated 02.07.2012) on wilful defaulters to all the scheduled commercial banks and notified financial institutions. The term ‘wilful default’ has been defined therein and the penal measures to be adopted for realisation of the dues by the bank have been illustrated with a note that it is not exhaustive. The master circular of the Reserve Bank of India also provides for reporting the details of accounts of wilful defaulters to the Reserve Bank of India as also the Credit Information Companies. The Credit Information Companies like the Credit Information Bureau (India) Ltd. (CIBIL) have been registered under the Credit Information Companies (Regulation) Act, 2005. The Credit Information Companies have been advised to disseminate information pertaining to the accounts of wilful defaulters and the recovery steps initiated on their respective websites. This also enables any bank to log into the website of Credit Information Companies and verify the credentials of the person applying for fresh loan on the security of the property offered. The power of the Reserve Bank of India to issue such circulars or directions can be traced to Sections 21(3) and 35-A of the Banking Regulation Act, 1949 as has been judicially noticed even recently. The Supreme Court in ICICI Bank Ltd. v. Official Liquidator of A.PS Star Industries Ltd. [(2010) 10 SCC 1]; 2010 ICO 1969 held as follows:

    “Under Section 21(3) every banking company is bound to comply with directions given by RBI at the peril of penalty being levied for non compliance. Section 35-A says that where RBI is satisfied that in the interest of banking policy, it is necessary to issue directions to banking companies, it may do so from time to time and the banking companies shall be bound to comply with such directions. Thus in exercise of the powers conferred by Sections 21 and 35-Aof the said Act, RBI can issue directions having statutory force of law”.

    5. Thus the circular issued by the Reserve Bank of India does not also clothe the bank with the power to publish photographs of loanees in newspapers though entitled to disseminate information in the website of Credit Information Companies.

    6. It remains to be seen as to whether the publishing by the bank of the photographs of the loanees would infringe the fundamental rights guaranteed to them under Article 21 of the Constitution of India. The Supreme Court referring to the human dignity as an intrinsic value of every human being has held in M. Nagaraj v. Union of India [(2006) 8 SCC 212]; 2006 ICO 7216 as follows:

    “The expression of ‘life’ in Article 21 does not connote merely physical or animal existence. The right to life includes right to live with human dignity.”

    7. Mr. Justice K.S.R Radhakrishnan speaking for the Bench in Inspector General of Police v. S. Samuthiram [(2013) 1 SCC 598]; 2012 ICO 1507 has observed as follows as regards the right to live with dignity:

    “Every citizen in this country has the right to live with dignity and honour which is a fundamental right guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India”. Even the right to privacy of the loanees enshrined under Article 21 of the Constitution of India is infringed to a certain extent as is evident by the following observations in Mr. ‘Mr ‘X’ v. Hospital ‘Z’’ [(1998) 8 SCC 296]:

    “Disclosure of even true private facts has the tendency to disturb a person's tranquility. It may generate many complexes in him and may even lead to psychological problems. He may, thereafter, have a disturbed life all through. In the face of these potentialities, and as already held by this court in its various decisions referred to above, the Right of Privacy is an essential component of right to life envisaged by Article 21. The right however, is not absolute and may be lawfully restricted for the prevention of crime, disorder or protection of health or morals or protection of rights and freedom of others”.

    8. There is nothing immoral in being unable to repay the loans availed of owing to the floundering of business or due to some other unavoidable reason which can enable the bank to infringe the right to privacy of loanees. There is no compelling public interest warranting the publishing of the photographs of the loanees in newspapers in which case only the right to privacy has perhaps to give way. Some of the loanees may even be driven to commit suicide for fear of ignominy on publishing their photographs in newspapers at the instance of the bank and it will remain a permanent taboo for their family. The publishing of the photographs in newspapers for the inability to clear the loan arrears to the bank in time is clearly an affront to the right to live with dignity and honour as well as the right to privacy of the loanees. I have no hesitation to hold that publishing the photographs by the bank under such circumstances is violative of the rights guaranteed to the loanees under Article 21 of the Constitution of India.

    9. The bank desperately wants to justify its proposed step of publishing the photographs of loanees in newspapers by relying on the terms and conditions in the loan agreements which however do not advance its case. The relevant clause in the loan agreement entered into by the petitioner in WP(C) No. 10864/2013 with the bank is as follows:

    “13(a) The borrower (s) hereby further agree that as precondition of the loan advances given to me/us by the Bank, that in case of default to repayment of the loan/advance or in the repayment of the interest thereon or any of the agreed instalment of the loan on due date/s, the Bank and/or the Reserve Bank of India will have an unqualified right to disclose or publish my/our name(s) as defaulter in such manner and through such medium as the Bank or Reserve Bank of India in their absolute discretion may think fit.

    13(b) The borrower/s hereby agree and give consent for disclosure by the Bank all or any (a) information and data relating to the borrower/s (b) information or data relating to any credit facility availed or/to be availed by the borrower/s and default, if any, committed by the borrower/s in discharge of his/her such obligation s the Bank may deem appropriate and necessary, to disclose and furnish to Credit Information Bureau (India) Ltd. and any other agency authorized in this behalf by RBI. Further, the borrower/s declare that the information and data furnished by him/them to the Bank are true and correct and also agree that the Credit Information Bureau (India) Ltd. and any other agency so authorized may use, process the said information and data disclosed by the Bank in the manner as deemed fit by them and further that the Credit Information Bureau (India) Ltd. and any other agency so authorized may furnish for consideration, the processed information and data or products thereof prepared by them to Banks/Financial Institutions and other credit grantors or registered users, as may be specified by the Reserve Bank in this behalf.”

    10. Similarly the relevant clause in the loan agreement entered into by the petitioner in WP(C) No. 17081/2013 with the bank is as follows:

    “2. Accordingly, I/We, hereby agree and give consent for the disclosure by the State Bank of India Bank of all any such;

    (a) Information and data relating to me/us

    (b) the information or data relating to any credit facility availed of/to be availed by me/us, and

    (c) default, if any, committed by me/us, in discharge of my/our such obligation, as the State Bank of India Bank may deem appropriate and necessary, to disclose and furnish to Credit Information Bureau (India) Ltd. and any other agency authorised in this behalf by RBI.”

    11. The above clause in the agreements at best empowers the bank to reveal the name of the loanees in the print media or to disclose the information and data relating to credit facility to the Credit Information Companies. The loan agreements no where enable the bank to publish the photographs of the loanees in newspapers on their failure to repay the debt within a specified date as threatened. The loanees are also not estopped from challenging the action of the bank in publishing their photographs in the newspapers even if there is such a permissive clause in the loan agreement. This is because estoppel is not a defence available to the bank when its action is challenged on the ground of violation of the fundamental rights of the loanees. A reference in this context to the dictum laid down by the Full Bench of this Court in Dr. Saurabh Jain v. State of Kerala [2011 (1) KLT 888]; 2010 ICO 1880 is very much apposite.

    12. The High Court of Madras in K.J Doraisamy v. State Bank of India [(2006) 4 MLJ 1877] held that the bank is entitled to invent novel methods to recover its dues if the loanees find newer methods to avoid repayment. The High Court of Madhya Pradesh in Archana Chowhan v. State Bank of India [AIR 2007 MP 45] held that publishing the photographs of loanees cannot be said to be an impermissible mode. The High Court of Kolkota in Ujjal Kumar Das v. State Bank of India held that publishing the photographs of loanees is not a mode contemplated under the SARFAESI Act. I respectfully disagree with the conclusion of the High Courts of Madras and Madhya Pradesh and prefer to follow the decision of the High Court of Kolkata although for different reasons as stated supra. The practice of exhibiting a photograph of a person and shaming him in public for the sin of being in an impecunious condition cannot be encouraged in a civilised society like ours. A writ of prohibition is therefore issued restraining the bank from publishing the photographs of the petitioners in the leading newspapers for failure to repay the debt within a specified date. This will not however disable the bank from surging ahead with the proceedings already initiated or anew for realisation of its dues from the petitioners in any manner sanctioned by law.

    13. The Writ Petitions are allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Venu P.R v. The Assistant General Manager, State Bank Of India & Anr.
    (Aug 13, 2013)