Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Judgment and Order (Oral)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an Assam Rifles personnel who joined as Recruit (GD) on 11.11.1978 and subsequently rose to the rank of Nb. Subedar w.e.f. 01.09.2005, challenged his non-recommendation for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) held in 2012 for vacancy year 2012.

The petitioner alleged that (i) he fulfilled all eligibility criteria for promotion as on 01.01.2012 and on the date of the DPC; (ii) an adverse recording “Not Recommended for promotion” in his 2010 Annual Confidential Report (ACR) was wrongly made in violation of Record Office Instruction (ROI) No. 4/97; and (iii) that the adverse entry was not communicated to him. He sought a direction to respondents to consider him for promotion by holding a review DPC and to promote him from the same date as his juniors (respondents No. 6-13), who were promoted by Office Order dated 01.10.2012.

Notices were served; the petitioner and respondents No.1-5 appeared through counsel. Respondents No.6-13 did not appear despite service. The DPC for vacancy year 2012 had recommended the petitioner’s juniors (respondents No.6-13) for promotion. The petitioner was given a personal interview on 02.03.2013 (with the Additional Director General in lieu of the Director General), where he was informed he had two ACRs “Above Average” and three “High Average” but was verbally told he was superseded for not meeting ACR criteria and later received a letter dated 04.03.2013 confirming he had been superseded due to lacking ACR criteria.

The respondents filed an affidavit-in-opposition stating that the DPC considered the petitioner’s last five ACRs (2007–2011) and showed the grading and recommendation status, including an entry of "Not Recommended" in the 2010 ACR. The respondents' affidavit contained an apparent inconsistency: one paragraph asserted that non-recommendation need not be communicated under ROI 4/97, while another admitted that the "Not Recommended" endorsement in 2010 was inadvertently not communicated to the petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner met the eligibility and ACR criteria for promotion to Subedar (GD) for the vacancy year 2012 under the relevant Assam Rifles Record Office Instructions and promotion policy in force before the amendment that took effect 01.01.2013.
  2. Whether the adverse entry “Not Recommended for promotion” in the petitioner’s 2010 ACR was wrongly recorded in contravention of ROI No. 4/97 and whether that adverse entry was required to be communicated to the petitioner.
  3. Whether consideration of an adverse ACR entry that was not communicated to the petitioner vitiates the DPC proceedings for promotion and entitles the petitioner to a review DPC and consequential promotion (if otherwise eligible).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner asserted he fulfilled all eligibility criteria for promotion to Subedar (GD) as on 01.01.2012 and on the date of the 2012 DPC.
  • He contended the recording/grading “Not Recommended for promotion” in his 2010 ACR violated Record Office Instruction No. 4/97 (Para 6) because he had High Average grades that should have led to a recommendation for promotion.
  • He asserted that the adverse entry in the 2010 ACR was not communicated to him, depriving him of an opportunity to make representation and thereby to be fairly considered for promotion.
  • He sought a review DPC and promotion from the date his juniors were promoted if found eligible on review.

Respondents' Arguments (Respondents No.1-5)

  • The respondents stated the petitioner was screened by the DPC for 2012 and his last five ACRs (2007–2011) were considered; the 2010 ACR contained an entry "Not Recommended for promotion" and thus he did not meet qualitative requirements for promotion.
  • They initially asserted (para 14) that non-recommendation for promotion is not required to be communicated to the rate under paragraph 41 of ROI 4/97, and thus their action complied with instruction.
  • They later stated (para 18) that although the Initiating Officer had endorsed a weak point that should have been communicated, inadvertently the adverse endorsement was not communicated; nonetheless, the DPC considered the petitioner as "Not Recommended" for 2010.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Dev Dutt v. Union of India: (2008) 8 SCC 725 Principle that every entry in an ACR must be communicated within a reasonable period so the employee can make a representation; communication is required by fairness/transparency and Article 14 overrides rules to the contrary (paras 26, 33, 36 quoted). The court relied on Dev Dutt to hold that the uncommunicated adverse entry in the 2010 ACR could not be considered by the DPC and that non-communication violated the petitioner’s right to be considered for promotion.
Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v. Union of India: (2009) 16 SCC 146 Excerpt quoted (para 9) indicating that where a junior is promoted on a date, an immediately senior may be deemed to have been given promotion from that date (as referenced in the opinion). The court cited this passage in support of the proposition that if the petitioner is subsequently found eligible and recommended, his promotion date should be from the date his juniors were promoted.
Sukdev (Sukhdev) Singh v. Union of India: (2013) 9 SCC 566 Affirms Dev Dutt: that every ACR entry must be communicated within a reasonable period to achieve transparency, opportunity for representation and natural justice (para 8 quoted). The court relied on the principle in Sukhdev Singh to reinforce that ACR entries must be communicated and to justify interference with the DPC result where an adverse ACR entry was not communicated.
Delhi Jal Board v. Mahinder Singh: (2000) 7 SCC 210 Cited for the settled position that the right to be considered for promotion is a fundamental right of an employee who satisfies all essential criteria. The court referred to this authority to support the view that the petitioner had a right to be considered for promotion if he met the essential criteria and was deprived of that opportunity by the uncommunicated adverse entry.
Badrinath v. Government of Tamil Nadu: (2000) 8 SCC 395 Cited alongside Delhi Jal Board as authority for the principle that the right to be considered for promotion exists where essential criteria are met. The court cited this decision to support the legal principle that the petitioner’s right to be considered for promotion is enforceable when eligibility criteria are satisfied.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a focused analysis addressing whether the DPC result for vacancy year 2012 could stand when it was based on an adverse ACR entry for 2010 that had not been communicated to the petitioner and which, the court found, may have been wrongly recorded.

  1. The court recorded the factual position that the DPC for 2012 considered the petitioner’s last five ACRs (2007–2011). The respondents' affidavit expressly set out the grading and recommendation status of those ACRs: 2007 — 7 (Above Average) — Recommended; 2008 — 5 (High Average) — Recommended; 2009 — 5 (High Average) — Recommended; 2010 — 5 (High Average) — Not Recommended; 2011 — 7 (Above Average) — Recommended. Thus, the 2010 ACR had an internal inconsistency: a High Average grade with a "Not Recommended" endorsement.
  2. The court examined Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, Para 6, which provides that if a JCO is graded Outstanding, Above Average or High Average he must invariably be recommended for promotion, and Para 7 which requires communication of adverse remarks/weak points and recording of signatures. On a plain reading, the court found the 2010 entry “Not Recommended” to be inconsistent with the grading and with the ROI's mandates.
  3. The court noted the respondents’ contradictory stances in their affidavit: one paragraph (para 14) claimed non-recommendation need not be communicated under ROI 4/97, whereas another paragraph (para 18) admitted that the adverse endorsement was inadvertently not communicated. The court treated this as demonstrating that the adverse entry was not communicated.
  4. Relying on the binding principles in Dev Dutt and its judicial progeny (including Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar and Sukhdev Singh), the court held that every entry in an ACR must be communicated within a reasonable period so that the affected employee can make a representation for upgradation and be fairly considered for promotion. The court applied these authorities directly to the facts: because the adverse "Not Recommended" entry for 2010 was not communicated, it could not lawfully be taken into account by the DPC.
  5. Given that, and given that but for the adverse entry the petitioner would have satisfied the promotion criteria under the relevant Record Office Instruction (ROI No. 4/2002 / Appendix B criteria for promotion to Subedar), the court concluded there was sufficient material to interfere with the DPC proceedings of 2012.
  6. The court also considered the amendment to ACR criteria that took effect from 01.01.2013 (a later and slightly upgraded standard) and accepted that the new criteria applied from 01.01.2013 and would govern the 2013 DPC; however, the DPC complained of related to vacancy year 2012 and thus had to be assessed under pre-amendment criteria and correct ACR recording/communication.
  7. On these bases the court directed remedial steps: respondents No.1-5 were ordered to hold a review DPC for vacancy year 2012, to write/record the petitioner’s 2010 ACR grading in conformity with ROI No.4/97, to communicate the 2010 ACR entry to the petitioner to enable him to file a representation, and, if recommended on review, to give promotion from the date the juniors (respondents No.6-13) were promoted. The exercise was directed to be completed within four months from receipt of certified copy of the judgment.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The court directed respondents No.1-5 to consider the petitioner for promotion to the post of Subedar for the vacancy year 2012 by holding a review DPC, rewriting/recording the 2010 ACR in compliance with Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, communicating the 2010 ACR entry to the petitioner to enable representation, and if the petitioner is recommended, to effect promotion from the date his juniors (respondents No.6-13) were promoted. The review exercise must be completed within four months from receipt of a certified copy of this judgment.

Implications:

  • The direct, operative consequence is that the respondents must conduct the specified review process and ensure compliance with ROI No.4/97 in relation to the petitioner’s 2010 ACR and the 2012 DPC outcome.
  • If, on the review DPC, the petitioner is recommended, his promotion must be backdated to the date on which his juniors were promoted (as per the court’s direction and consistent with the authorities cited).
  • The court's decision rests on existing precedents requiring communication of ACR entries and the right to be considered for promotion; the judgment does not purport to lay down a new principle beyond applying those precedents to the facts of this case.

This summary strictly reflects the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion. No facts, arguments, or legal holdings beyond those expressly set out in the opinion have been added.

    Karan Singh v. Union Of India

    JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)

    In this writ petition, non-recommendation of the petitioner for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) by the Departmental Promotion Committee (for short ‘DPC’) held in the year 2012 for the vacancy year 2012 is challenged on the inter-alia grounds:- (i) the petitioner had fulfilled all eligible criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) as on 01.01.2012 and also on the date of holding the DPC for the vacancy year 2012 (ii) the concerned authority had wrongly made the recording or grading i.e “Not Recommended for promotion” in the ACR for the year 2010 inasmuch as, that recording is in violation of the Record Office Instruction of the Directorate General, Assam Rifles i.e (No. 4/97) and (iii) adverse entry in the ACR “Not Recommended for promotion” for the year 2010 was also not communicated to the writ petitioner and prayed for a direction to the respondents to consider his case for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) for the vacancy year 2012 by holding review DPC basing on the relevant requirement prevailing at that time w.e.f his juniors i.e respondents No. 6-13 were promoted to the posts of Subedar (GD).

    2. Heard Mr. N Mozika, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. A Khan, learned CGC appearing for the respondents No. 1-5. None appears for the respondents No. 6-13 without showing any reasons inspite of proper service of notice of the present writ petition to them.

    3. The only facts sufficient for deciding the matter in issue in the present writ petition are briefly noted. The petitioner initially joined in the Assam Rifles on 11.11.1978 as Recruit (GD). Taking into consideration of his sincere service as Recruit (GD), the petitioner was promoted to the rank of L/Nk w.e.f 05.09.1992 and to the rank of Nk w.e.f 01.04.1997 The petitioner was further promoted to the rank of Havildar (GD) w.e.f 01.10.1998 In consideration of his dedicated service as a Havildar (GD), the petitioner was again promoted to the rank of Nb. Subedar w.e.f 01.09.2005 It is also stated that the petitioner was one of the first persons to hold the post of Battalion Havildar Major (BHM) for continuously 3 (three) years from 2002-05 after raising of the Battalion in the year 2002. The next higher promotion is to the post of Subedar. Under the Assam Rifles, Record Office Instruction No. 4/2002, promotion policy of the Assam Rifles personnel, ACR criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar are as follows:-

    “RESTRICTED

    Appendix ‘B’ to ROI 04/2002

    EDUCATIONAL AND ACR CRITERIA FOR VARIOUS PROMOTION GD PERSONNEL

    Ser No.Promotional fromEducational criteriaLength of ServiceACR criteria last five years(a)(b)(c)(d)(e)1.Rfn/Lnk to HavACE - II MR - II8 YearsACR criteria is not applicableTT - II Promotion Cdre N 1 & N2 Pass2.Hav to Nb SubACE - II MR - I TT - I Promotion Cadre ‘S’ pass5 yrs service as Hav/GD with total length 18 years of service(a) Three (3) out of last five (5) reports should not be below “High Average.” (b) Remaining two (2) reports should not be below ‘Average.’ (c) Out of last five (5) reports, two reports must be from Bn/ARTC & S/NSG (Not applicable to GD pers forming part of any AR team of any discipline att to AR/Army fmn). (d) Should have been recommended for promotion in the last three (3) reports.3.Nb Sub to SubACE - II MR - I TT - I3 Yrs service as Nb Sub (GD)(a) Three (3) out of last five (5) reports should not be below “High Average.” (b) Remaining two (2) reports should not be below ‘Average.’ (c) Out of last five (5) reports, two reports must be from Bn/ARTC & S/NSG (Not applicable to GD pers forming part of any AR team of any discipline att to AR/Army fmn). (d) Should have been recommended for promotion in the last three (3) reports.

    4. Under the said criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar, only Nb. Subedar having three years service as Nb. Subedar/GD (a) Three (3) out of last five (5) reports should not be below “High Average”; (b) remaining two (2) reports should not be below “Average”; (c) out of last five (5) reports, two reports must be from Bn/ARTC & S/NSG (not applicable to GD pers forming part of any AR team of any discipline att to AR/Army fmn) and; (d) should have been recommended for promotion in the last three (3) reports. It is the case of the petitioner that he had fulfilled all eligible criteria mentioned above for promotion to the higher post of Subedar (GD). Inspite of having all essential criteria, the petitioner was not considered for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) by the DPC held on 01.12.2012 for the vacancy year 2012. The said DPC for the year 2012 had recommended his juniors i.e respondents No. 6-13 to the higher post of Subedar by Office Order No. I. 119012/38AR/120/2012.Admn-I(A)/342 dated 01.10.2012 The petitioner being aggrieved by the said order dated 01.10.2012 for promoting his juniors i.e respondents No. 6-13 to the higher post of Subedar, the petitioner under his letter dated 07.02.2013 requested for a personal interview with the Director General, Assam Rifles and accordingly, permission was granted for personal interview with the Director General, Assam Rifles on 02.03.2013 However, on the said day, the Director General, Assam Rifles (respondent No. 2) was out of station and as such, the petitioner was given an opportunity of personal interview with the Additional Director General, Assam Rifles (respondent No. 3). It is stated that in that interview, the petitioner was verbally informed that he was superseded due to not meeting the ACR criteria. Further the petitioner was informed that he had 2(two) ACRs “Above Average” and 3(three) ACRs “High Average”. The petitioner was further informed by the Additional Director General, Assam Rifles in the said personal interview on 02.03.2013 that as per revised criteria of promotion from Nb. Subedar to Subedar, three out of last five ACRs should not be below “Above Average” and the two remaining ACRs should not be below “High Average”

    5. After that personal interview, the petitioner had been informed by a letter dated 04.03.2013 that he was superseded for promotion to the rank of Subedar (GD) due to lacking of ACR criteria and the same was explained to him during open forum on 02.03.2013 (Annexure-6 to the writ petition). It is the further case of the petitioner that the criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) under the said Assam Rifles, Record Office Instruction No. 4/2002, had been amended by an amendment which had been circulated under letter dated 29.06.2012 (Annexure-3 to the writ petition). The new amended criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar read as follows:-

    “Appx

    (Refers to para 2 of HQ DGAR (Records Branch)

    Letter No. 1.17033.ACR-SEC/2011-12/620

    dated 25 Jun 2012)

    ACR CRETERIA FOR PROMOTION

    Ser No.RankACR Creteria for last 5 yearsRemarksFromTo1.Nb SubSub(a) Three (3) out of last five (5) reports should not be below “Above Average”. (b) Remaining two (2) reports should not be below “High Average”. (c) Out of last five (5) reports, three reports must be from bn/ARTC & S/NSG(Not applicable to GD Pers forming part of any AR team of any discipline att to AR/Army/fmn) (Applicable to GD pers only) (d) Should have been recommended for promotion in the last five (5) reports.2.SubSub Maj(a) Four (4) out of last five (5) reports should not be below “Above Average”. (b) Remaining one (1) report should not be below “High Average”. (c) Out of last five (5) reports, three reports must be from bn/ARTC & S/NSG (Not applicable to GD Pers forming part of any AR team of any discipline att to AR/Army/fmn). (Applicable to GD pers only) (d) Should have been recommended for promotion in the last five (5) reports.

    6. It appears that under the new amended criteria, the requirement for promotion from the post of Nb. Subedar to Subedar had been slightly upgraded. It is admitted case of both the parties that the new amended criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar came into effect from 01.01.2013 and the DPC for the year 2013 is to be held basing on the said new criteria, which came into force w.e.f 01.01.2013 It is also stated in the writ petition that the petitioner had never been informed of any adverse entry in the ACRs of five years i.e ACRs before the date of holding the DPC for the vacancy year 2012 i.e 01.01.2012 and as such, the petitioner is eligible and qualified for promotion to the rank of Subedar, as there is no weak points in his ACR.

    7. The official respondents had filed joint affidavit-in-opposition wherein, it is stated that the petitioner was screened by the DPC for the year 2012 for promotion to the rank of Subedar alongwith his counter parts and his last ACRs for the year 2007 to 2012 were also considered and grading obtained in the last five years are also mentioned in Para 8 of the affidavit-in-opposition. For easy reference, Para 8 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the official respondents is quoted hereunder:-

    “8. That the answering respondent with regard to the statement made in paragraphs 10 begs to state that the petitioner was screened by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) for the year 2012 for promotion to the rank of Subedar alongwith his counterparts. His last five Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs) for the year 2007 to 2011 were considered and the grading obtained are as under:-

    S/NoYearPoints/GradingRecommendation(a)20077 (Above Average)Recommended for promotion(b)20085 (High Average)Recommended for promotion(c)20095 (High Average)Recommended for promotion(d)20105 (High Average)Not recommended for promotion(e)20117 (Above Average)Recommended for promotion

    The petitioner's contention that he was ‘Recommended’ in all last five Annual Confidential Reports (ACRs) is not correct. It is evident from the above that he was ‘Not Recommended’ (NR) for promotion in the Annual Confidential Report (ACR) for the year 2010. Thus the petitioner did not meet the requisite qualitative requirements (QR) for promotion. As per qualitative requirements (QR) he ought to have recommended for promotion in last three reports.”

    8. In Para 14 of the affidavit-in-opposition, the official respondents i.e respondents No. 1-5 stated that “non-recommendation for promotion” recorded in the ACR of the petitioner of the year 2010 is not required to be communicated to the petitioner at any rate. But in Para 18 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the official respondents No. 1-5, it is stated that through inadvertently, the said adverse entry i.e “Not Recommended” in the ACR of 2010 was not communicated to the petitioner. Therefore, it appears that the stand of the official respondents No. 1-5 in Para 14 of the affidavit-in-opposition is quite contrary to their stand taken in Para 18 of the affidavit-in-opposition. On conjoint reading of Paras 14 & 18 of the affidavit-in-opposition, it is clear that the adverse entry i.e “Not Recommended” recorded in the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010 was not communicated to the petitioner. For easy reference, Paras 14 & 18 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the official respondents No. 1-5 are also quoted hereunder:-

    “14. That the answering respondent in reply to the statement made in paragraphs 17 and 18 begs to state that though, there is an endorsement by the Initiating Officer (IO) in pen picture, but the same do not have adverse effect on promotion as the petitioner has been graded ‘High Average’ by initiating Officer and Senior Reviewing Officer (SRO). However, the petitioner has not been recommended for promotion and as such he was found unfit for promotion by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) for the year 2012. Also as per paragraph 41 of the Record Office Instruction (ROI) 4/97 ‘Non Recommendation’ for promotion is not required to be communicated to the rate. Hence, action of respondents is as per the instruction on rendering of Annual Confidential Report (ACR) and promotion.

    18. That the answering respondent in response to the statement made in Paragraphs 23 and 24 begs to state that although, Initiating Officer (IO) has endorsed weak point in the pen picture which should have been communicated, but inadvertently the same was not communicated. However, at the time of Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) 2012, the cognizance of weak point was not taken into account. The petitioner was not empanelled for promotion because he was ‘Not Recommended’ for promotion in the Annual Confidential Report (ACR) for the year 2010.”

    9. Further it is admitted case of the parties that the Directorate General, Assam Rifles, Record Office Instruction No. 4/97 are followed and binding to the personnel of the Assam Rifles. Under Para 6 of the said Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, if a JCO is graded outstanding, Above Average or High Average, he must invariably be recommended for promotion. It is the further case of the petitioner that under Para 6 of the Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, the petitioner who had admittedly had 5(five) High Average should have been recommended for promotion while recording his ACR for the year 2010. Again for easy reference, Para 6 of the Record Office Instruction No. 4/97 is also quoted hereunder:-

    “Recommendation for promotion

    6. (a) If a JCO is graded Outstanding, Above Average or High Average he must also invariably be recommended for promotion.

    (b) In case the performance adjudged Low or Low Average, Reporting Officers may use their discretion and exercise the option for recommendations as deemed fit.

    (c) In the event of performance adjudged Low or Below Average it is obligatory for the Reporting Officer to ensure that periodical counsellings are administrated to the concerned JCO in writing and record of such counseling is kept before grading him Low or Below Average in the ACR.

    7. Adverse remarks/weak points, irrespective of grading awarded will be communicated to the retee and his signatures with date of such communication obtained and pasted/recorded in the ACR. Adverse remarks/weak points of RO/SRO where applicable will be communicated through Initiating Officer.”

    10. On bare perusal of Para 6, which had been quoted above, of the Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, it appears that the mistake had been committed by the concerned authority in recording or grading as “Not Recommended” in the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010, inasmuch as, as per the affidavit-in-opposition filed by the official respondents No. 1-5 and also from the pleadings of the petitioner, it is crystal clear that the petitioner had 5 (five) High Average for the year 2010. The recording of the grade or entry “Not Recommended for promotion” in the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010 is an adverse entry and there is no doubt about it; now it is well settled law that any adverse entry in the ACR should be communicated to the concerned employee so as to enable the employee to file a representation. The adverse entry which is not communicated to the employee cannot be considered for higher promotion. In the present case, it is admitted case of the parties that the adverse entry “Not Recommended” in the ACR of 2010 was not at all communicated to the petitioner and the said entry i.e “Not Recommended” in the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010 was considered by the DPC held in the year 2012 for promotion to the post of Subedar (GD) for the vacancy year 2012. Regarding this position of law, it may not be required to refer to a number of cases, it will be sufficed to refer to the three decisions of the Apex Court in (i) Dev Dutt v. Union of India(2008) 8 SCC 725 (ii) Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v. Union of India(2009) 16 SCC 146 and (iii) Sukdev Singh v. Union of India(2013) 9 SCC 566.

    Paras 26, 33 & 36 of the SCC in Dev Dutt's case (Supra) read as follows:-

    “26. In our opinion, our natural sense of what is right and wrong tells us that it was wrong on the part of the respondent in not communicating the “good” entry to the appellant since he was thereby deprived of the right to make a representation against it, which if allowed would have entitled him to be considered for promotion to the post of Superintending Engineer. One may not have the right to promotion, but one has the right to be considered for promotion, and this right of the appellant was violated in the present case.

    33. In our opinion, fair play required that the respondent should have communicated the “good” entry of 1993-1994 to the appellant so that he could have an opportunity of making a representation praying for upgrading the same so that he could be eligible for promotion. Noncommunicating of the said entry, in our opinion, was hence unfair on the part of the respondent and hence violative of natural justice.

    36. In the present case, we are developing the principles of natural justice by holding that fairness and transparency in public administration requires that all entries (whether poor, fair, average, good or very good) in the annual confidential report of a public servant, whether in civil, judicial, police or any other State service (except the military), must be communicated to him within a reasonable period so that he can make a representation for its upgradation. This in our opinion is the correct legal position even though there may be no rule/G.O requiring communication of the entry, or even if there is a rule/G.O prohibiting it, because the principle of non-arbitrariness in State action as envisaged by Article 14 of the Constitution in our opinion requires such communication. Article 14 will override all rules or government orders.”

    Paras 9 of the SCC in Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar's case (Supra) read as follows:-

    “9. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has pointed out that the officer who was immediately junior in service to the appellant was given promotion on 28-8-2000. Therefore, the appellant also be deemed to have been given promotion from 28-8-2000.”

    Para 8 of the SCC in Sukhdev Singh's case (Supra) read as follows:-

    “8. In our opinion, the view taken in Dev Dutt: (2008) 2 SCC (L&S) 771 that every entry in ACR of a public servant must be communicated to him/her within a reasonable period is legally sound and helps in achieving threefold objectives. First, the communication of every entry in the ACR to a public servant helps him/her to work harder and achieve more that helps him in improving his work and give better results. Second and equally important, on being made aware of the entry in the ACR, the public servant may feel dissatisfied with the same. Communication of the entry enables him/her to make representation for upgradation of the remarks entered in the ACR. Third, communication of every entry in the ACR brings transparency in recording the remarks relating to a public servant and the system becomes more conforming to the principles of natural justice. We accordingly, hold that every entry in ACR - poor, fair, average, good or very good - must be communicated to him/her within a reasonable period.”

    11. It is now well settled law that the right to be considered for promotion is fundamental right of the employee provided that employee has all the essential criteria for promotion to that post. In the present case, it appears that the petitioner had fulfilled all the essential criteria for promotion to the post of Subedar under the said Assam Rifles Record Office Instruction No. 4/2002 if there is correct recording of the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010 in compliance with the said Instruction i.e Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, i.e Para 6, which had been quoted above in extenso. Regarding this settled position of law, we may refer to the decisions of the Apex Court in (i) Delhi Jal Board v. Mahinder Singh.: (2000) 7 SCC 210 and (ii) Badrinath v. Government of Tamil Nadu: (2000) 8 SCC 395.

    12. For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the considered view that the petitioner had made out sufficient materials for interfering with the DPC proceedings held in the year 2012 for promotion to the post of Subedar for the vacancy year 2012 inasmuch as, the petitioner had not been recommended by the said DPC basing on the said adverse entry which was not communicated to the petitioner and also it appears that had there be correct recording in the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010 by following the Record Office Instruction No. 4/97, the petitioner would have been recommended for promotion to the post of Subedar.

    13. In the result, this writ petition is allowed by directing the respondents No. 1-5 to consider the petitioner for promotion to the post of Subedar for the vacancy year 2012 by holding review DPC strictly following the procedures indicated above i.e by writing the ACR or recording the grading of the petitioner for the year 2010 by following the Record Office Instruction No. 4/97 and also by communicating the entry in the ACR of the petitioner for the year 2010 to the petitioner so as to enable him to file a representation and it is also made clear, if the petitioner is recommended for promotion to the post of Subedar for the vacancy year 2012, his promotion should be from the date his juniors had been promoted to the posts of Subdear i.e respondents No. 6-13. Further, it is made clear that the whole exercise should be completed within a period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this judgment and order.

    14. With the above observations and directions, this writ petition is allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Karan Singh v. Union Of India
    (Apr 10, 2014)