Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section not specified of the Act not specified (year not specified)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section not specified of the Act not specified (year not specified)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This order forms part of continuing proceedings in which the Supreme Court of India is supervising governmental action aimed at curbing acid attacks. An earlier order dated 18-7-2013 (reported at 2014 4 SCC 427) directed every State and Union Territory to frame rules, in line with Central Government “Model Rules,” to regulate the sale of acid and other corrosive substances within three months of receiving the draft. The present order notes that, despite that direction, no State or Union Territory has operational rules in place. The Court therefore issues further mandatory directions and sets a fresh deadline. The order also addresses interim arrangements for compensation, treatment, and rehabilitation of acid-attack victims, with specific reference to an affidavit filed by the State of Haryana announcing that it will bear 100 % of such victims’ medical costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the States and Union Territories can be compelled to frame and implement rules regulating the sale of acid and other corrosive substances in conformity with Central Model Rules.
  2. What obligations the States and Union Territories have to fund medical treatment, rehabilitation, and compensation for victims of acid attacks.
  3. What monitoring mechanisms should exist at the police-station and Sub-Divisional Magistrate levels to trace the procurement of acid used in attacks.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Order dated 18-7-2013 (2014 4 SCC 427) Directed States/UTs to frame rules regulating sale of acid; laid down interim compensation measures for acid-attack victims. The Court relies on this earlier order to reiterate its directions, fixes a new deadline of 31-3-2014, and extends monitoring to ensure compliance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court records that acid attacks are increasing and considers regulation of acid sale a “necessary step” toward minimising such crimes. Noting that no State or Union Territory has yet operationalised the required rules, the Court deems continued non-compliance unacceptable and therefore:

  • Directs Chief Secretaries and Union Territory Administrators to enact and operationalise rules consonant with the Central Model Rules on or before 31-3-2014.
  • Observes that interim directions about victim compensation were earlier issued and that a comprehensive framework for treatment and rehabilitation is still required.
  • Takes cognisance of an affidavit from the State of Haryana declaring it will bear 100 % of medical costs for acid-attack victims, and instructs Haryana to file the full scheme and governmental order within four weeks.
  • Orders the Union of India to circulate Haryana’s scheme to all other States/UTs, and requires those jurisdictions to file affidavits indicating whether they will adopt comparable 100 % cost coverage and formulate similar treatment schemes.
  • Mandates that police stations, upon registering an FIR for an acid attack, must inform the jurisdictional Sub-Divisional Magistrate (SDM), who shall inquire into the source of the acid and take appropriate action.

The Court schedules the matter for further hearing on 15-4-2014, thereby retaining supervisory jurisdiction.

Holding and Implications

INTERIM DIRECTIONS ISSUED AND FRESH DEADLINES FIXED

States and Union Territories must operationalise rules regulating the sale of acid by 31-3-2014, explore full financial coverage for victim treatment, and implement police-SDM coordination to trace acid procurement. Non-compliance will be reviewed at the next listing on 15-4-2014. The decision imposes no new substantive precedent but strengthens and time-bounds earlier directives, signalling the Court’s readiness to continue active monitoring to protect acid-attack victims.

    Laxmi v. Union Of India And Others

    Order

    1. It was observed in the order dated 18-7-2013 (2014) 4 SCC 427 that the States and Union Territories which have not yet framed rules to regulate sale of acid and other corrosive substances in line with the Model Rules framed by the Central Government shall do the same within three months from the receipt of the draft Model Rules from the Central Government. Three or four States have sought response from the public with regard to the proposed rules to regulate sale of acid and other corrosive substances, but the progress made by other States in this regard is not yet known.

    2. The framing of rules to regulate sale of acid and other corrosive substances is one of the necessary steps for minimising the acid attacks which, of late, are on the rise. It was after a series of hearings and orders passed by this Court that finally the Central Government came out with the Model Rules in consultation with the State Governments/Union Territories. The Court hoped, when it passed the order on 18-7-2013 (2014) 4 SCC 427, that within three months therefrom, all the States and Union Territories shall comply with the directions and put in place the rules to regulate sale of acid and other corrosive substances. It appears that in none of the States and Union Territories such rules are operational. In the circumstances, we direct the Chief Secretaries of the States and the Administrators of the Union Territories to comply with the directions given in the order dated 18-7-2013 (2014) 4 SCC 427 and put in place the rules in line with the Model Rules framed by the Central Government to regulate sale of acid and other corrosive substances at the earliest and positively before 31-3-2014.

    3. In the order dated 18-7-2013 (2014) 4 SCC 427, the Court has given certain directions, by way of interim arrangement, with regard to payment of compensation to the acid victims by the States/Union Territories. The Court has to finally take a call on the measures for the proper treatment, after care and rehabilitation of the acid attack victims and the States' responsibility in making payment of compensation to them.

    4. Ms Aparna Bhat, learned counsel for the petitioner, has brought to our notice an affidavit filed on behalf of the State of Haryana through Smt Sarita Malik, Under-Secretary, Women and Child Development Department wherein it is stated that the Government of Haryana is in the process of framing a scheme for the medical treatment, short term as well as long term, for specialised plastic surgery, corrective surgeries, providing specialised psychological treatment to the acid victims to help them to come out of the horror and trauma of the acid attack and, their rehabilitation. It further transpires from that affidavit that a decision has been taken by the State Government to bear 100% cost of treatment on the above account. The government resolution/order which incorporates the decision of the Government of Haryana to bear 100% cost of treatment of the acid victims is not available on record nor the entire scheme for the medical treatment of the acid victims by the Government of Haryana has been placed. We direct the Advocate-on-Record for the State of Haryana to place on record within four weeks the State Government's decision to bear 100% cost of treatment of acid victims and also the scheme for medical treatment for the acid victims. The copy of such decision and the scheme shall also be given to the Advocate-on-Record for the Union of India. The Advocate-on-Record for the Union of India shall then circulate to all the Chief Secretaries of the States (other than Haryana) and the Administrators of the Union Territories, the copy of the scheme framed by the Government of Haryana for medical treatment of acid victims and the copy of the government resolution/order issued by the Government of Haryana with regard to the State Government bearing 100% cost of treatment of the acid victims.

    5. We direct the Chief Secretaries of the States (other than Haryana) and the administrators of the Union Territories to file affidavit and indicate to this Court, the State's view in bearing 100% cost of treatment of the acid victims in line with the decision taken by the Government of Haryana and also with regard to framing of scheme on the lines of Haryana Government for the medical treatment at specialised hospitals having facility for plastic surgery, corrective surgery and psychological as well as other treatment to the acid victims.

    6. If any other State or Union Territory has taken a decision to provide free medical treatment to acid attack victims, the Advocate-on-Record for such State/Union Territory shall also supply copy thereof to the Advocate-on-Record for the Union of India. The Advocate-on-Record for the Union of India shall forward the decision of such State/Union Territory to the Chief Secretaries of other States and Administrators of Union Territories as well.

    7. In addition to the directions already issued on 18-7-2013 (2014) 4 SCC 427 and the above directions, the Chief Secretaries of the States and Administrators of the Union Territories are directed to issue necessary instructions to the police stations within their respective State/Union Territory that as and when an FIR is lodged with the police relating to acid attack, the police station concerned will send a communication to the jurisdictional SDM about receipt of such information. Upon receipt of such information, the jurisdictional SDM shall then make inquiry into the procurement of acid by the wrongdoer and take appropriate action in the matter.

    8. List the matter on 15-4-2014.

    Court Masters

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Laxmi v. Union Of India And Others
    (Dec 3, 2013)