Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.2.
  • Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Sections 137 and 138 of Indian Evidence Act,
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • section 151 C.P.C
  • Order 18, Rule 17
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.2.
  • Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • Sections 137 and 138 of Indian Evidence Act,
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure
  • section 151 C.P.C
  • Order 18, Rule 17
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The plaintiff filed a suit (O.S No. 122 of 1996) in the Subordinate Court at Virudhunagar for recovery of an amount against the defendant. After the plaintiff's witnesses were examined, the defendant was examined as D.W.1. During the cross-examination of D.W.1, the plaintiff's counsel marked documents Exs.A-2 to A-4, which D.W.1 admitted authoring. Subsequently, the defendant filed an application under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure seeking to recall P.W.1, the plaintiff, for cross-examination with respect to these documents. The plaintiff opposed this, arguing that the defendant could clarify the documents during re-examination, and that Order 18, Rule 17 did not permit recalling witnesses for further cross-examination at the parties' instance. The trial court dismissed the defendant's application on the ground that there was no valid reason to recall the plaintiff who had already been cross-examined. The defendant filed this revision challenging that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the plaintiff can be recalled for cross-examination on an application filed by the defendant under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  2. Whether the trial court has the power to recall a witness for further cross-examination at the instance of a party under Order 18, Rule 17.
  3. The applicability and scope of Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure in recalling witnesses for cross-examination in light of Order 18, Rule 17.

Arguments of the Parties

Defendant's Arguments

  • The application under Order 18, Rule 17 is valid as it allows recalling witnesses for cross-examination at the parties' instance.
  • Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure also empowers the court to recall witnesses to meet ends of justice.
  • The documents Exs.A-2 to A-4 were marked only during cross-examination of D.W.1 and were not referred to in the plaint or during the plaintiff's examination.
  • It is just and necessary to recall the plaintiff to cross-examine him regarding these documents to clarify their relevance and context.
  • The trial court erred in dismissing the application, as there were valid reasons to recall the plaintiff for cross-examination.

Plaintiff's Arguments

  • The defendant could clarify the documents during re-examination; recalling the plaintiff for cross-examination is unnecessary and would only delay proceedings.
  • Order 18, Rule 17 applies only to the court's power to put questions to witnesses and cannot be invoked by parties to recall witnesses for further cross-examination.
  • There is no cross-examination of the plaintiff with reference to these documents as they were only marked belatedly through D.W.1.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Steelage Industries Limited v. Chanderbagai (A.I.R 1992 Bombay 406) Authority on recalling witnesses for cross-examination under procedural law Supported the proposition that recalling witnesses is permissible under special circumstances.
Altaf Hussain v. Nasreen Zahra (A.I.R 1978 Allahabad 515) Interpretation of powers to recall witnesses Reinforced discretionary power of courts to recall witnesses.
Palia Bewa v. Parbati Kumari Mohapatra & Others (A.I.R 1986 Orissa 62) Scope of recalling witnesses for re-cross-examination Clarified conditions under which recalling witnesses is justified.
Ulamal Ameen Sahib v. Abdulla Sahib (1989 1 L.W 504) Section 151 C.P.C powers to recall witnesses at parties' instance Held that witnesses may be recalled for re-cross-examination under Section 151 C.P.C.
Madhubhai Amthalal v. Amthalal Nanalal (A.I.R 1947 Bombay 156) Procedural powers relating to witness examination Supported discretionary recall under procedural rules.
Shankar Bhat v. Bheema Bhat & Another (A.I.R 1974 Karnataka 123) Discretion of court in recalling witnesses Affirmed the discretionary nature of recalling witnesses.
Suresh Kumar v. Baldev Raj (A.I.R 1984 Delhi 439) Recall and re-cross-examination powers Confirmed that recalling witnesses can be allowed on new factors arising.
Kulsumun-Nisa v. Ahmadi Begum (A.I.R 1972 Allahabad 219) Judicial discretion in witness recall Emphasized the careful exercise of discretion in recalling witnesses.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined whether recalling the plaintiff for cross-examination under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure was justified. It noted that the documents Exs.A-2 to A-4 were introduced only during the cross-examination of the defendant and were not mentioned in the plaint or during the plaintiff's examination. The defendant admitted authorship of these documents, which were available prior to the suit but not referred to by the plaintiff. The defendant sought to cross-examine the plaintiff to clarify the context and liability related to these documents.

The court analyzed the scope of Order 18, Rule 17 and relevant precedents, concluding that the trial court does have the power to recall witnesses for re-cross-examination at the instance of a party, but such power must be exercised cautiously and only under special and extraordinary circumstances. The court emphasized that this power is discretionary and not limited to the court acting on its own motion.

Considering the facts, the court found valid reasons to recall the plaintiff for re-cross-examination because the documents were introduced belatedly and the plaintiff had not been cross-examined on them. The court further noted that recalling the plaintiff would not prejudice him and would allow clarification of substantive evidence.

Accordingly, the court held that the trial court erred in dismissing the application to recall the plaintiff and set aside the impugned order.

Holding and Implications

The revision petition is allowed.

The court set aside the trial court's order dismissing the defendant's application to recall the plaintiff for re-cross-examination under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure. This decision clarifies that a trial court has discretionary power to recall a witness for re-cross-examination at the instance of a party when valid reasons exist, particularly when new evidence or documents are introduced belatedly. The ruling does not create a new precedent but confirms the discretionary nature of such power and the necessity of exercising it with caution. The immediate effect is that the plaintiff shall be recalled for cross-examination regarding the documents Exs.A-2 to A-4, ensuring a fair opportunity for the defendant to challenge the plaintiff's claim.

    S.S.S Durai Pandian v. S.A Samuthira Pandian.

    The question posed in this Civil Revision Petition is this: Can the plaintiff be recalled for cross examination, on the application filed by the defendant under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

    2. The facts are these: The respondent herein, the plaintiff filed a suit in O.S No. 122 of 1996 on the file of the Subordinate Court. Virudhunagar for the recovery of the amount against the defendant/petitioner. After examination of the witnesses on the side of the plaintiff/respondent the defendant/petitioner was examined as D.W.1 During the course of cross of examination the counsel for the plaintiff marked Exs.A-2 to A-4 through D.W 1. D.W.1 admitted that he was the author of those documents.

    3. Immediately thereafter, the petitioner filed a petition in I.A No. 350 of 1997 before the trial Court under Order 18 Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure requesting the Court to recall P.W.1, the plaintiff/respondent, to enable him to cross examine P.W.1 with reference to those documents which were marked through the defendant/petitioner.

    4. This was resisted by the plaintiff, the respondent herein contending that the petitioner having admitted that Exs.A-2 and 3 were the letters written by him addressed to P.W.1 could very well explain those documents in reexamination, and that the plaintiff need not be recalled for cross examination, and that it would merely help the defendant only to drag on the proceedings.

    5. It was also further contended that the provision of law under Order 18, Rule 17, quoted in the petition has no application to the facts stated therein and that it applies only to the Court to exercise its jurisdiction to put any question to the witness and that the said provision cannot be invoked by the parties in the suit, to recall the witnesses already cross examined for further cross examination.

    6. After having considered the submissions made by both the parties, the trial Court passed the impugned order dismissing their application filed for recalling the plaintiff mainly on the ground that there was no valid reason to recall the plaintiff who had already been cross examined. Hence this revision.

    7. Mr. Sivaji, counsel for the petitioner would press into service the following submissions:

    (i) The application under Order 18, Rule 17 is perfectly valid in law as it provides the cross examination of the witnesses by recalling at the instance of the parties to the suit. Even otherwise Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure confers powers to the Court to make such an order to meet the ends of justice, to recall the witnesses for cross examination.

    (ii) The documents in favour of the plaintiff Exs.A-2 to A-4, admittedly, were marked only during the cross examination through D.W.1 There is no reference about these documents in the plaint. The plaintiff also did not speak about these documents, while he was in the box, either during chief examination or during cross examination. For the first time the question has been put to D.W.1 with reference to those documents and the same had been marked. In the situation, it is just and necessary that P.W.1 has to be recalled for putting questions on behalf of the defendant with reference to those documents. Therefore, the lower Court is not correct in saying that there was no valid reasons to accept the request of the defendant, the petitioner herein, to recall the witness.

    8. These submissions were refuted by the counsel for the respondent/plaintiff by filing counter. Mr. Sivaraman, representing Mr. N. Damodaran, the counsel for the respondent/plaintiff would reiterate in support of the impugned order that this could be clarified even in the re-examination, and that there was no necessity to recall the witness. He would also further submit that the provision of law quoted in the application before the trial Court would apply to the Court alone, to put questions and not for cross examination at the instance of the defendant.

    9. Before adverting to the maintainability of the petition, with reference to the question posed in this case, as referred earlier, let me at the outset consider the question as to whether there is any necessity for recalling P.W.1 the plaintiff for cross examination regarding Exs.A-2 to A-4.

    10. As correctly pointed out by the counsel for the petitioner, these Exhibits were suddenly brought to be marked in the Court only during the course of cross examination of D.W.1, even without making any reference about the same either in the deposition of the plaintiff or in the plaint. Further more, D.W.1 in the box admitted that he was the author of those documents which were sent by him to the plaintiff. This would show that these documents were very much available with the plaintiff even before filing the suit. Despite this, the details of these documents were not mentioned in the plaint. In addition to this, the plaintiff did not think it fit to refer to these documents in his chief examination. Now, it is sought to be proved through these documents that the defendant admitted his liability with reference to the suit amount.

    11. The case of the defendant is that he is not liable to pay any amount to the plaintiff. Therefore, the defendant now wants to prove, by putting questions in the cross examination to P.W.1 that the liability, as admitted in Exs.A2 to A4 would not relate to the suit transaction. In such a situation, it is just and necessary to give an opportunity to the defendant to cross-examine P.W.1, who admittedly received these documents, more particularly when these documents were not filed through the plaintiff when he was put in the box.

    12. Added to this, the trial court thus observed:

    13. This would show that the learned District Munsif was under the impression that these documents have already been marked through P.W.1 which is not factually correct. Even according to the plaintiff, there is no cross examination of the plaintiff by the defendant with reference to those documents as these documents only were marked belatedly through D.W.1

    14. In view of the fact situation, there is no difficulty in coming to the conclusion that there was a valid reason to recall the witness for cross-examination by the defendant with reference to these documents.

    15. The main question that has been posed is whether the trial court has got powers to invoke Order 18, Rule 17 to recall the witness at the instance of the defendant for cross-examination.

    16. The counsel for both the parties cited the following decisions to enable the court to answer the question posed before this court: —

    1) Steelage Industries Limited v. Chanderbagai (A.I.R 1992 Bombay 406)

    2) Altaf Hussain… v. Nasreen Zahra…. (A.I.R 1978 Allahabad 515).

    3) Palia Bewa… v. Parbati Kumari Mohapatra & Others…Opp. Parties. (A.I.R 1986 Orissa 62).

    4) Ulamal Ameen Sahib v. Abdulla Sahib (1989 1 L.W 504).

    5) Madhubhai Amthalal v. Amthalal Nanalal (A.I.R 1947 Bombay 156).

    6) Shankar Bhat… v. Bheema Bhat & Another… (A.I.R 1974 Karnataka 123).

    7) Suresh Kumar… v. Baldev Raj…. (A.I.R 1984 Delhi 439).

    8) Kulsumun-Nisa v. Ahmadi Begum (A.I.R 1972 Allahabad 219).

    17. The reading of these judgments would make it clear that the trial court is well within its powers to invoke Order 18, Rule 17 to recall the witness for re-cross-examination but under special and extraordinary circumstances.

    18. It is held in 1989 (1) L.W 504 (supra), that the witness could be re-called and re-cross-examined at the instance of the parties under Section 151, C.P.C However, on going through the other decisions it is manifestly clear that there is no bar for the trial court to re-call the witness already cross-examined for the purpose of further cross-examination on the new factors that have been brought to light subsequent to the cross-examination of the witnesses.

    19. Some of the decisions would say that under Order 18, Rule 17, the witnesses could be re-called by the court on its own motion and put questions with reference to the clarification of any ambiguity that arises in a case. It is also held in those decisions that after putting those questions it could very well permit the parties to make further cross-examination.

    20. Therefore, this would make it clear that the powers under Order 18, Rule 17 for recalling the witness for re-cross-examination at the instance of the parties are very much in existence.

    21. It is also brought to my notice through some decisions that when there are specific powers conferred under Order 18, Rule 17 for re-calling the witness, the invoking section 151 C.P.C is not permissible under law.

    22. However, in the light of the facts of this case, I ma not inclined to go into the question, whether Section 151, C.P.C could be invoked for re-calling the witness. But, in my view, on the basis of the interpretation of Order 18, Rule 17 as given by the various authorities referred to above, the powers for recalling the witnesses for cross-examination at the instance of the defendant can be exercised by the trial court, since there are valid reasons as discussed above to re-call.

    23. In the Commentary by ‘Sarkar on Evidence’, while dealing with Sections 137 and 138 of Indian Evidence Act, it is observed as follows: —

    “Recall tor Re-cross Examination — A re-call for re-cross-examination will ordinarily be unnecessary, except in the rare cases where the direct examination of an intervening witness has brought out new tacts upon which the prior witness may throw light, and for this the matter can always be left in the hands of the trial court (Wigs 1899). This is second cross-examination, a matter which rests entirely with the discretion of the court.”

    24. The careful reading of the decisions and commentary referred above makes it obvious that the trial court has got powers to re-call the plaintiff for re-cross-examination under Order 18, Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure on the application filed by the defendant independent of Section 151, C.P.C so, to say-that the powers of the court to act under Order 18, Rule 17 are very wide. It is also clear that this power is purely discretionary. However, the same ought to be exercised with the greatest care and only in the most peculiar circumstances. The right of the court to act under this rule is not restricted to action of its own motion.

    25. I do not see any fetter on the rights of the either party or the powers of the court in coming to the conclusion that a party can ask the court to exercise the power. At the risk of repetition, I may mention that this power under Order 18, Rule 17, is clearly, discretionary, as appears from the use of the word “may”, not once but twice, as I think that power exists and the same ought to be exercised with the care and caution

    26. Admittedly, in this case, as earlier indicated, there is no reference about Exs.A-2 to A4 in the plaint. There is also no evidence with reference to these documents in the form of the deposition either in the chief or in the cross-examination by the plaintiff. These documents on behalf of the plaintiff have been marked only during the cross-examination of the defendant by the plaintiffs counsel.

    27. The defendant, of course, admits that he is the author of those documents and that they are the letters which have been written by the defendant to the plaintiff. Now, the endeavour by the defendant is to put questions with reference to those documents to the plaintiff under what circumstances these letters have been written by the defendant to the plaintiff.

    28. The re-calling of the plaintiff for re-cross-examination would not, in any way, prejudice the interest of the plaintiff because the plaintiff also would be in a position to refer about the documents filed on behalf of the plaintiff through D.W.1 which would make the evidence substantive.

    29. Therefore, in the light of the facts of the case, I am of the view that the impugned order rejecting the prayer of the petitioner to re-call the plaintiff for re-cross-examination for putting questions with reference to the documents Exs.A-2 to A-4, suffers with the infirmity and the same is liable to be set aside and accordingly it is set aside.

    30. In the result, the revision is allowed. There is no order as to costs. Consequently, no separate order is necessary in C.M.P No. 10118 of 1997.

    RR/VCS

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    S.S.S Durai Pandian v. S.A Samuthira Pandian.
    (Feb 12, 1998)