Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Devadoss, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The opinion concerns property rights and a family settlement (rajinamah/razinamah) made following a 1911 suit. Appalaraju (the appellant's father) had been taken into the family of his father-in-law Subbaraju and lived there as a family member. After Subbaraju's death the three sons effected a division of family property and Appalaraju was given one-fourth of that property. In 1911 defendants 1 and 2 brought suit against Appalaraju seeking recovery of 9 acres on the ground that Appalaraju was not a member of the joint family and therefore the grant of a share was not binding on them. Other family members were parties to that suit.

The 1911 suit was compromised and a razinamah decree was passed on 22 January 1912. Under the razinamah the plaintiff was to adopt Thimmaraju (the second son of the 1st plaintiff in the earlier suit) within two months; if adoption occurred, the adopter (Appalaraju) and adopted son would enjoy the property that fell to Appalaraju's share. If adoption did not take place, the appellant would retain only one-half of the roughly 27 acres and the other half would go to the plaintiffs.

The appellant failed to adopt within the stipulated time and subsequently sued to recover half of the 27-odd acres on the ground that the razinamah was invalid because it was brought about by fraud. The question of fraud was found against the appellant, leaving him to argue that the razinamah (specifically the adoption condition and associated provisions) was opposed to public policy. On initial hearing Madhavan Nair J. held that the razinamah was a bona fide family settlement and could not be impeached by the appellant. The present opinion disposes of the appeal from that decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the razinamah (family settlement) containing a condition requiring the adopter to take a specific boy in adoption in order to retain the property is opposed to public policy.
  2. Whether an adoption induced by a promise of property or payment (an inducement/consideration) is invalid under Hindu law or public policy.
  3. Whether the clause in the razinamah that reduces the appellant's beneficial enjoyment if he fails to adopt is a penal clause against which relief should be granted.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant (through Mr. T. M. Krishnaswami Aiyar) contended that adoption must be a voluntary act and no one can be compelled or coerced into making an adoption.
  • It was argued that any consideration paid for taking a boy in adoption is illegal and opposed to Hindu law; consequently the adoption required by the razinamah was said to be opposed to public policy.
  • The appellant relied upon authority (specifically Eshan Kishar Acharjee Chowdhry v. Haris Chandra Chowdry) for the position that a consideration for taking a boy in adoption could render the adoption invalid or the arrangement unenforceable.
  • The appellant also argued that requiring adoption of a particular boy restrained his freedom to adopt whomsoever he liked and thus fettered his discretion.

Respondents' / Petitioners in 1911 (as reflected in the record)

  • The record shows that defendants 2 to 7 wished the appellant to adopt a son of the family so that the appellant would remain in the family and his line be perpetuated; the settlement was sought to preserve family peace and to prevent further litigation and loss.
  • The terms of the compromise allowed the appellant to retain the property if he adopted the specified boy; if he declined, the plaintiffs would recover part of the estate—reflecting a negotiated tradeoff rather than coercion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hammmersley v. De Biel (Lord Chancellor Lyndhurst) Equitable principle that when one party deliberately induces another to a marriage by promise, equity will enforce or give effect to the proposal so the promisor cannot disappoint the promisee. The court analogised the equitable principle to adoption inducements: if a party is induced by a clear promise to do a religious/familial act (here, adoption), equity will not allow the promise to be frustrated. The principle supported the view that inducement to adopt a proper boy does not render the adoption invalid.
Shri Sitaram Pandit v. Shri Harihar Pandit (Chandavarkar J.) Statement that adoption by a sonless Hindu serves sacred purposes (perpetuation of line, salvation), and thus adoption is a sacred act under Hindu shastras. The court relied on this to support the proposition that an inducement to adopt a proper boy is not improper or illegal and that adoption for sacred purposes should not be invalidated by the fact of inducement.
Eshan Kishar Acharjee Chowdhry v. Haris Chandra Chowdry Held that an adoption of a son after payment of price is not recognised in the present Kaliyuga; a contract to give a son in adoption in consideration of an annual allowance is void under Section 23 of Act IX of 1872 (Indian Contract Act) because it would injure the person and property of the adopted son and defeat Hindu law provisions. The court distinguished this case: the cited case concerned enforcement of a collateral contract (payment/allowance) and the plaintiffs seeking to sue on such a contract. The present court held that even where such collateral agreements are unenforceable, the adoption itself (if otherwise valid) need not be set aside and is to be treated as separable from illegal collateral bargains.
Murugappa Chetti v. Nagappa Chetti Held that receipt of money by the natural father in consideration of giving his son and payment of such by the adoptive father, though illegal and opposed to public policy, do not make the adoption invalid; the gift and acceptance of the boy is distinct and separable from the illegal agreement. The court relied on this pronouncement to support the proposition that illegal payments or collateral agreements do not invalidate an otherwise valid adoption, and that setting aside an adoption would harm the adopted child who had no control over antecedent agreements.
Venkata Kristnayya v. Lakshmi Narayana Although a marriage in the Asura form may be valid, an agreement to pay the father any consideration for such a marriage is not valid and the money cannot be recovered; if the money had been paid and the marriage solemnized, recovery of the money was denied. The court cited this to illustrate the principle that proper acts (marriage/adoption) should not be invalidated by collateral arrangements or payments; once the substantive act is done, courts are reluctant to set it aside on account of unenforceable side agreements.
Devarayan v. Mutturaman Holds that an arrangement that conditions marriage and payment by one party to another is opposed to public policy and void under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act. The court used this case as further illustration of the general rule that collateral, enforceable contracts that offend public policy may be void, but that this principle does not automatically invalidate a substantive family act (like adoption) which is otherwise valid and separately executed.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the razinamah and the adoption condition against the factual matrix and the cited authorities. The reasoning can be summarized in sequential points that follow the opinion:

  1. Context and purpose: The settlement was the product of family arbitration to bring peace and avoid further litigation. It was negotiated to preserve family harmony and protect property interests of various members; the appellant benefited under the arrangement by being allowed to retain property on making the adoption.
  2. Voluntariness and inducement: The court noted that the appellant was childless and that defendants 2 to 7 desired him to adopt a family boy so that he would remain in the family and perpetuate his line. The court emphasised that adoption is a religious act and performs sacred functions (citing Shri Sitaram Pandit). The judge reasoned that a proper inducement to adopt a proper boy is not illegal: inducement that is reasonable or intended to benefit the adopter and the adoptive arrangement does not invalidate the adoption.
  3. Distinguishing cases that condemn bargains: The court distinguished Eshan Kishar Acharjee Chowdhry and similar authorities by observing that many such cases concerned attempts to enforce collateral contracts (payments/allowances) and the validity of enforcing those contracts under Section 23 of the Indian Contract Act. The court accepted that a collateral contract to give consideration for adoption might be void or unenforceable, but held that this does not necessarily invalidate an otherwise valid adoption. The adopted child's position and rights would be harmed if adoption were set aside on grounds of antecedent illegal bargains between third parties.
  4. Separation of transactions: Relying on Murugappa Chetti, the court reasoned that the gift and acceptance of the boy (the adoption) is a distinct transaction separable from any illegal collateral agreement between the natural and adoptive fathers. Therefore, illegality in a side agreement does not automatically convert the adoption into an invalid "affiliation by sale."
  5. Penal clause argument: The court considered whether the razinamah clause reducing the appellant's full beneficial enjoyment if he failed to adopt was a penal clause warranting relief. The rasinamah provided that if the 1st defendant failed to adopt, he would "enjoy as rightful owner only one half out of the entire property mentioned ... and deliver possession of the remaining half" to plaintiffs. The court observed that if the appellant had lost the suit he would have lost the entire property; by the arrangement he was allowed to retain the whole if he adopted. Thus the arrangement advantaged him and could not be fairly characterized as penal—the appellant's position was not worsened beyond what it could have been if litigation had succeeded against him.
  6. Equitable considerations and freedom to refuse: The court emphasised that the appellant could have refused the condition; it was not coercion in the sense of depriving him of choice—he consented to the arrangement as an equitable tradeoff. The settlement was therefore an equitable family compromise that required strong grounds to upset, which were not present.
  7. Conclusion as to public policy: On the totality of the above, the court concluded that the razinamah's adoption condition was not opposed to public policy, did not invalidate the adoption (where otherwise valid), and did not constitute a penal clause deserving relief.

Waller, J. (concurring) delivered a concise concurrence: he found nothing contrary to public policy, observed that the appellant gained no more by adopting than by refusing (he would, in either event, end up with half the property) and therefore there was no improper inducement or penalty; he agreed the appeal must be dismissed with costs.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The court affirmed that the razinamah was a bona fide family settlement and that its condition requiring adoption of a particular boy (as part of the compromise) was not opposed to public policy and was not a penal clause warranting relief. The decree dismissing the appeal was entered with costs awarded to respondents 1 and 2.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the appellant's challenge to recover the half of the 27-odd acres (the portion claimed to have been lost by enforcement of the razinamah) fails, and the family settlement stands.
  • The court treated collateral agreements or payments related to adoption as potentially unenforceable but did not accept that such collateral illegality automatically invalidates an otherwise valid adoption; the adopted child's rights must not be defeated by antecedent side-agreements between third parties.
  • The opinion does not announce a novel rule of law beyond applying established principles (equitable enforcement of inducements in analogous contexts and the separability of adoption from illegal collateral bargains); it affirms the court's reluctance to upset equitable family settlements absent strong grounds. No broader new precedent was framed by the court in this opinion beyond its application of the cited authorities to the facts before it.

Disposition: Appeal dismissed with costs to respondents 1 and 2.

    Pendmasta Subbaraju v. Indukuei Narayanaraju

    Devadoss, J: — The appellant's father Appalaraju was taken into the family of his father-in-law and he lived with him as a member of the family, Appalaraju and his 3 brothers-in-laws effected a division of the family properties and Appalaraju was given ¼th share in them. In 1911 defendants 1 and 2 herein instituted a suit against the appellant for the recovery of 9 acres of land on the ground that the granting of a share of the joint family property by their father was not binding upon them as Appalaraju was not a member of the joint family. To that suit the other members of the family were parties. The suit was compromised and a rajinamah decree was passed on 22nd January, 1912. According to the terms of the razinamah the plaintiff should adopt Thimmaraju, the second son of the plaintiff (1st plaintiff in the previous suit) within two months from the date of the razi and if he did so he should enjoy the entire property which fell to his father Appalaraju's share and if he should fail to take the boy in adoption he should retain only one-half of the 27 and odd acres and the other half should go to the plaintiffs. The appellant failed to take the boy in adoption and he now sues for the recovery of half of the 27 odd acres on the ground that the razinamah is not binding on him as it was brought about by fraud. The question of fraud is found against and the only point that is now urged for setting aside the razinamah is that it is opposed to public policy and, therefore, the appellant is entitled to get back the 14 acres of which he was dispossessed in execution of the rajinamah decree. Madhavan Nair J., held that the razinamah was a bona fide family settlement and it could not be impeached by the appellant.

    The main contention urged on behalf of the appellant is that the term as regards taking the boy in adoption is opposed to public policy as no one can be compelled to make an adoption and any consideration paid for taking a boy in adoption is illegal and opposed to the Hindu law. The admitted facts are, the appellant's father Appalaraju was the son-in-law of Subbaraju. He belonged to a different family and on his marrying the daughter of Subbaraju he was asked to live in the family and look after the cultivation. It is immaterial to consider now whether Appalaraju brought the properties of his own family and made them part of his joint family property. After the death of Subbaraju the three sons effected a division of the family property and gave Appalaraju a fourth share. The grandsons by one of the three sons of Subbaraju attacked the arrangement on the ground that their father had no right to give away a portion of the family property to a stranger of the family and the other members of the family supported the contention of the plaintiff. In order to bring about peace in the family and in order to prevent further litigation and loss, arbitrators settled the disputes between the parties in a way which was considered satisfactory to all of them.

    If the suit went against the present plaintiff, the 1st defendant in the suit of 1911 be would have lost not only the 9 acres claimed by the plaintiffs in their suit but the 18 and odd acres which represented the share of the two brothers-in-law of Appalaraju. The appellant was allowed to retain all the properties that were given to his father by his maternal uncles on condition that he should adopt the second son of the first plaintiff within two months and if he did so all the properties which fell to the share of Appalaraju should be enjoyed as the joint family property of the plaintiff and his adopted son and that if he failed to do so, half of the property in his possession should be delivered to the plaintiffs. When an arrangement of this kind is brought about in the interests of the members of a family, it would require very strong grounds to set it aside at the instance of any one of the parties to the arrangement.

    The appellant was childless at the time. His wife is a daughter of one of the sons of Subbarajn. As he was childless he would have naturally liked to adopt some boy and defendants 2 to 7 wished that the appellant should adopt one of the sons of the family so that the appellant might remain in the family and that his line should be perpetuated without in any way disturbing the peace of the family. Can it be said in these circumstances that the arrangement was illegal and one that was opposed to public policy? It is argued by Mr. T. M. Krishnaswami Aiyar for the appellant that the adoption should be a voluntary act) that no person should be forced or coerced into making an adoption, and that no inducement should be held out for making an adoption. The adoption of a boy is a religious act and is one which is necessary for the salvation of the soul. If a person is induced to do what is necessary for his salvation and the salvation of his ancestors, could his act be considered illegal? If a person is asked to adopt a boy by the promise of sufficient means to maintain himself and the boy, I do not think the adoption induced by such promise would be invalid or would militate against the rules of Hindu Law governing adoptions. If an inducement is made to a man to adopt a boy whom he could not adopt or whose adoption would be of no avail to him the matter would be different-But where the boy suggested is a proper person to be adopted, any proper inducement to him would not invalidate the adoption. It is well settled that if a person promises to settle some property or give a sum of money on condition or in case that the other person marries the promissor's daughter or any girl in whom he is interested not only would the marriage be valid but the promisee would be entitled to enforce against the promisor the promise whereby he was induced to marry the girl. This principle is stated by Lord Chancellor Lyndhurst in Hammmersley v. De Biel,(1):

    “The principle of law, at least of equity, is this, that if a party holds out an inducement to another to celebrate a marriage and holds them out deliberately and plainly, and the other party consents, and celebrates the marriage in consequence of them, if he had good reason to expect that it was intended that he should have the benefit of the proposal which was so held out, a Court of equity will, take care that he is not disappointed, and will give effect to the proposal.”

    The promise to settle some property or to give a certain sum of money on the promisee marrying a particular individual is enforceable in law both in England and in India. It is difficult to see why an adoption which takes place by reason of a promise to pay a certain sum of money or settle some property on the adopter is opposed to public policy. As observed by Chandavarkar J., in Shri Sitaram Pandit v. Shri Harihar Pandit,(2).

    “A boy is adopted by a sonless Hindu for perpetuating his line; paying off his dues to his ancestors, keeping up his name, and securing for him and his ancestors a place in heaven. These are sacred purposes, according to Hindu shastras.”

    That being the object of an adoption, an inducement to a man to adopt a proper boy is not an improper or an illegal act, and an adoption taking place under an inducement is not invalid.

    What is urged before us is that it restrains the plaintiff appellant from adopting whomsoever he liked and such a restraint is improper. There was no restraint on the appellant's adopting anybody before the razinamah was entered into. It was only for the sake of the peace of the family and for the benefit of the appellant that be was asked to take the second son of the 1st plaintiff in adoption. It was open to him to have refused to consent to such a condition in which case the plaintiffs in that suit might have succeeded in getting a decree in their favour. It cannot, therefore? be said that the appellant's discretion was fettered by any arrangemant as that evidenced in the razinamah.

    Great reliance is placed upon Eshan Kishar Acharjee Chowdhry v. Haris Chandra Chowdry for the position that no consideration should be given for taking a boy in adoption and that taking a boy in adoption for a consideration paid to the father would make the adoption invalid. In that case it was held that:

    “An adoption of a son after payment of price is not recognised in the present Kaliyuga. The only adoption now recognised is that of the dattaka son, or son given. A contract to give a son in adoption, in consideration of an annual allowance to the natural parents is void under Sect. 23 of Act IX of 1872, in asmuch as the contract, if carried out, would involve an injury to the person and property of the adopted son, and would defeat the provisions of the Hindu Law.”

    The plaintiffs therein wanted to enforce a contract which was entered into at the time when the boy was given in adoption. The adoption itself was not declared invalid but it was held that the plaintiffs could not sue on the contract. An adoption cannot be declared invalid by reason of any collateral arrangement or contract entered into between the adoptor and the adoptee's natural father, for it would do incalculable harm to the adopted boy if the adoption is to be declared invalid by reason of any arrangement between persons over whom he had no control. By adoption the adopted boy loses his rights in the natural family and if the adoption is declared invalid he could not acquire any rights in the adoptive family, and it would not be proper to visit on the adopted boy the sins of the natural father and the adoptive father, for the adoptee in the dattaka form is a minor and is not in a position to have a say in the matter of the arrangement between them. It is upon this principle that a boy who is taken in adoption under an agreement which is unenforceable in law is held good and the arrangement is considered to be collateral. If the adoption is otherwise good, that is to say, if the adoptor could make a valid adoption, if the adopted boy was a proper person and if the ceremony of adoption was properly performed, it is opposed to natural justice that the adoption should be set aside for anything which preceded the adoption. In Murugappa Chetti v. Nagappa Chetti it was held that:

    “the receipt of money by the natural father in consideration of giving his son and the payment of such by the adoptive father though illegal and opposed to public policy, do not make the adoption invalid, as the gift and acceptance of the boy is a distinct transaction clearly separable from the illegal agreement and payment. Such payment has not the effect of converting the adoption into an ‘affiliation by sale.’ a form now obsolete”.

    Mr. Justice Subrahmania Aiyar who delivered the judgment in that case referred to the practice which prevailed among a certain class of people of taking money consideration for giving a boy in adoption. In every case of adoption the natural father expects some benefit for himself or for his son and nobody would think of giving a boy in adoption to a pauper. Mercenary consideration enters into most transactions like adoption and marriage, and the adoption or marriage is not rendered invalid merely because persons other than the contracting parties or persons interested in them have a mercenary motive. What the law refuses to recognise is the contract or agreement whereby third persons who are not parties to the transaction try to acquire monetary benefit by promoting it.

    Even the adoption of an only son has now been held to be valid, however reprehensible that may be according to the strict notions of Hindu Jurists. The Courts always try to give effect to an arrangement which is irrevocable, and are very reluctant to set aside such an arrangement, unless the arrangement itself is illegal or opposed to public policy. In Venkata Kristnayya v. Lakshmi Narayana it was held that, although a marriage when performed in the Asura form is valid, an agreement to pay to the father any consideration for such marriage is not valid and the money cannot be recovered by a suit. If the money had been paid and the marriage solemnized, the money could not be recovered. In Devarayan v. Mutturaman it was held:

    “an arrangement between A and B that B's daughter shall marry A's son and that, if she fails to do so, B shall pay a sum of money to A, is opposed to public policy and void under Sect 23 Indian Contract Act.”

    These cases illustrate the principle that a proper act when properly done should not be declared invalid or set aside by reason of anything which took place not between the contracting parties but between 3rd persons interested in the contracting parties.

    The next contention urged is that the clause in the razinamah is a penal clause and, therefore, should be relieved against. The clause is:

    “If for any reason the 1st defendant should fail to make an adoption in the said manner, the 1st defendant should enjoy as rightful owner only one half out of the entire property mentioned in the plaint schedule, that is acres 21. 79½ and the house according to good and bad qualities, that the 1st defendant should deliver possession of the remaining half of the property to the plaintiffs for being enjoyed by them.”

    The appellant if he failed in the suit of 1911 would have lost the whole of his property. By the arrangement he was allowed to retain the whole of the property if he adopted the boy. By adopting the boy the appellant's share would be one half of 27 odd acres as the adoptive son would be entitled to an equal share and by not adopting the boy his share is not taken away. It is to his advantage to make an adoption and if he adopted the particular boy he would get for the boy half the suit property. Whether he makes an adoption or not the share to which he would be entitled would be the same. It is, therefore, not easy to conceive how the clause could be said to be a penal clause.

    It is next urged that the plaintiff if he succeeded would be only entitled to one third of 29.79 acres and his share being one half, nearly 14 acres, if the adoption did not take place, the clause should be considered a penal clause. As already pointed out it was a family arrangement and it must have been considered an equitable arrangement at the time. It is suggested that for costs and other reliefs 5 acres more were arranged to be given to the plaintiffs in case the adoption did not take place, and as we have no materials before us as to why 6 more acres were to go to the plaintiffs in the suit in case the adoption did not take place, we cannot consider the contention and family arrangementi such as this should not be lightly upset. We concur in the reasoning of the learned Judge and the conclusion he arrives at, namely, that this is an equitable arrangement. There was no conflict between duty and interest in this case. On the other hand, the appellant of his own free will consented to make the adoption and in order to benefit the boy to be taken in adoption the plaintiffs agreed to allow him to retain the property in the suit and if he did not make the adoption he was to lose the advantage which was promised to him.

    In the result the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs of 1 and 2 respondents.

    Waller, J.—There is to my mind, nothing that is contrary to public policy in the agreement, which was intended to settle a family dispute. It cannot be said that the appellant was either induced or forced by it to make an adoption. If he adopted he took half the property and the adopted son took the other half. If he failed to adopt, he still took half the property. Whichever course he followed, the result was, as tar as he was concerned, the same. He gained no more by adopting than he did by refusing to adopt. There was, therefore, no improper inducement to adopt. He lost nothing by adopting. There was therefore no penalty for this failure to do so. I agree that the Appeal must be dismissed with costs of respondents 1 and 2.

    C. K.Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pendmasta Subbaraju v. Indukuei Narayanaraju
    (Mar 3, 1926)