Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act

    Bejoy Chand Mohatab Bahadur v. Sarat Chandra Adhya

    1. This appeal arises out of a suit brought by plaintiff-appellant to recover arrear of rent due for the years 1313 to 1316 in respect of a certain tenure known as Lot Tajpur and to enforce a charge upon another property (a 4-annas share in Sandhya Bazar) hypothecated by way of security for the rent. Both properties have passed out of the hands of the persons who may be spoken of as the original owners and the question for our consideration in this appeal is whether the hypothecated share of Sandhya Bazar in the hands of the new owners continues liable for the rent of Lot Tajpur. In both cases the transfers, it should be observed, were by private sales. The answer to the question propounded depends in the first instance upon the construction of a kabuliyat executed on 12th December 1891 by the original tenants, Udoy Chand and Pran Krishna Mukherjee. The relevant petitions of the kabuliyat run thus:

    “If default be made in the payment of rent, you (i.e, the landlord) will realize the arrears by instituting suits…..and by auction sale of the said Lot. If the whole be not realized by the auction sale then we shall be liable for the balance and shall pay the amount from our own pockets. If we do not do so, you will realize the same by the attachment and sale of our property hypothecated as security and of our moveable and immovable properties…..so long as we are not released from the liability to pay the rent of this mukarrari mahal, we shall not be able to transfer in any manner the property mortgaged as security for the rent of the Lot…The terms of the kabuliyat thus executed by us shall, on our death be binding equally on our heirs, successors and representatives.”

    2. It may be conceded that the words “successors and representatives” include assignees or transferees, but even so I am of opinion that on the true construction of the kabuliyat, if the liability of the Mukherjees to pay the rent of Lot Tajpur has ceased, the mortgage or charge on Sandhya has been extinguished. Now the tenure in question, it is not disputed, is a permanent tenure to which the provisions of the Bengal Tenancy Act are applicable.

    3. In a large number of cases decided in this Court, for instance, in the cases Kristo Bulluv Ghose v. Kristo Lal Singh (1), Chintamony Dutt v. Rash Behari Mondul (2) and Rup Chand v. Narendra (3), it has been held that where the provisions of S. 12 of the Act have been com plied with, the transferor of a permanent tenure ceases to be liable for subsequent rent. In this case the transfer took place in December 1903 and was well known to the landlord, who after the transfer and before the present suit has brought three successive rent suits against the transferees. On the authority of the cases cited lam therefore of opinion that the Mukherjees have long ceased to be liable for the rent of Tajpur aud that the charge or mortgage on Sandhya has been extinguished.

    4. It has been urged by the appellant that this view of the law makes the taking of security nugatory. That no doubt is so. The demand of security appears to have been based on the provisions of S. 5, Bengal Putni Taluk Regulation, 1819, there being many putnis in this Burdwan Zamindari. But the permanent tenure now in question is not a Putni Taluk, the Mukherjees who were themselves purchasers, were not required to furnish security and the zamindar was not entitled to make the furnishing of security a condition of recognition. I should therefore dismiss the appeal with costs. It should be here observed that it is conceded the Khan defendants have bought only two-thirds of the mortgaged share and that therefore in any view in this suit the charge could be enforced only to the extent of two-thirds of the claim.

    V.B/R.K

    5. Appeal dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bejoy Chand Mohatab Bahadur v. Sarat Chandra Adhya
    (Dec 18, 1918)