Chamier, C.J:— The plaintiff in the present suit, which is for the rent of certain lands for the years 1318, 1319, and 1320F., brought a previous suit or the years 1315, 1316, 1317 and 1318F. He asked for permission to withdraw that suit and bring another suit and the Court passed the following order: “The plaintiff has filed a petition to withdraw the suit with permission to bring a fresh suit on the ground of errors in the plaint. Ordered that the plaintiff may withdraw the suit and bring a fresh suit if not otherwise barred. The defendent is allowed costs against the plaintiff and the payment of costs is made a condition precedent to the institution of a fresh suit.” That order was dated 25th March, 1914. The present suit was instituted on 8th September, 1914, which was exactly three years after the expiry of 1311 F., the first of the years now in suit. The Munsif decreed the claim, but on appeal the District Judge, though holding in favour of the plaintiff, on the merits, allowed the appeal and dismissed the suit on the ground that it was barred by the order recited above.
2. In second appeal it is contended that the District Judge's order is wrong. Similar orders were considered by the Calcutta High Court in the cases of Abdul Aziz Molla v. Ebrahim Molla(1) and Shital Prasad Mondal v. Gaya Prosad Dingal [Sadhu Charan Tewari v. Baikuntha Nath Madak(2)] In the earlier case the order passed was almost in exactly the same terms as the order which we have to consider in the present case. At the time when the second suit was instituted the costs of the first suit had not been paid, but they were paid before the suit came on for trial. The High Court held that the suit was maintainable. In the latter case also the order passed was particularly in the same terms as the order which we have to consider in this case, and the High Court held that as the plaintiff had obtained leave to withdraw with permission to bring a fresh suit on payment of the costs of the first suit, the Court ought merely to have regarded S. 10 as a bar to its proceeding with the trial of the second suit and that it should have proceeded with that trial when the costs of the first suit were paid. The result of these rulings is curious, but it is difficult to resist the reasoning on which the decisions are based. The condition of the permission to withdraw the first suit and bring a fresh suit was the payment of costs only. Until the costs were paid the permission was not operative, and therefore there was no withdrawal with liberty to bring a fresh suit, and the result was that until there was such a withdrawal the former suit remained pending and was, under S. 10 of the Code, a bar to the trial of the second suit. The difficulty which has arisen in the present case is due to the incompleteness of the order passed in the first suit.
3. The order in such circumstances should limit the time within which costs should be paid and should go on to direct that on failure to pay costs within that time the original suit shall stand dismissed with costs. In my opinion, it is not possible to distinguish the present case from the cases cited, and I would therefore hold that the District Judge was wrong in dismissing the suit. I would allow htis appeal, set aside the decree of the District Judge, and give the plaintiff a decree for three years' rent at the rate of Rs. 9-8-0 per annum plus 25 per cent damages. In the circumstances I would make no order as to costs in any Court.
4. Sharfuddin, J.:— I agree.
V.S/R.K
5. Appeal allowed.