G.C Mathur, J.:— These two writ petitions are before us for decision on reference made by S.N Singh, J. ??? question, which has necessitated the references, is
“Whether a tenant of sir, who is recorded in the records of 1356 Fasli, ??? ‘recorded occupant’ for purposes of ??? 21(1)(h) of the U.P Zamindari ??? and Land Reforms Act.”
2. Satish Chandra, J. has, in Second ??? No. 3950 of 1959 decided on October 1968, taken the view that the tenant of is not a ‘recorded occupant’ and S.N Singh, J., in the order of reference, ??? taken a contrary view.
3. In consolidation proceedings, injections were filed by Raja Ram (respondent No. 6 in Writ Petition No. ???) and by Bharat Singh (respondent No. 6 in Writ Petition No. 3171 of ??? claiming that on the date of vesting the had become adhivasis of the land in ??? and, subsequently, sirdars of the ??? and that the petitioner, who is the ???-in-interest of the original sir-hold became bhumidhar on the date of ??? but her rights were extinguished ??? Chapter IX-A of the Act. The petitioner contended that they became asamis and ??? adhivasis. The Consolidation Officer a the Settlement Officer (Consolidate decided in favour of the petitioner ??? the Deputy Director of Consolidation second appeal and the Joint Director Consolidation in revision have held favour of the contesting respondents.
4. There is no dispute about ??? facts of these cases. The admitted ??? are set out in the order of the Consolation Officer. They are:
(1) That Janki Ballabh was the ??? zamindar and the sir-holder of the ??? plots. He died in April, 1946, ??? was succeeded by his widow Srimati ??? ??? and by his pre-deceased sons' ??? Srimati Prakash Kunwar. Srimati ??? Kunwar died in 1951 and Srimati ??? Kunwar died in 1953 and the petitioner, Kumari Radha Kishori, daughter ??? Srimati Prakash Kunwar, succeeded ???.
(2) That respondents Raja Ram and ??? Singh were the original tenants of ??? but Janki Ballabh ejected them in ???, 1352 Fasli (1945). The land was ??? let out to these respondents in 1354 ??? by Srimati Kiran Kunwar and Srimati ??? Kunwar.
(3) That these two respondents were ??? of Sir on June 30, 1952.
(4) That Janki Ballabh, the original ???, and, subsequently, his successors ??? more than Rs. 800/- per annum as ??? revenue.
(5) That, in the records of 1356 Fasli, ??? contesting respondents were recorded tenants of sir.
5. On these facts, it was urged by the petitioner before the Consolidation Officer ??? the Settlement Officer (Consolidation) ???, since, at the time of letting the land-??? were disabled persons, the tenants ??? sir could only acquired asami rights under Sec. 21(1)(h) and not adhivasi ??? under Sec. 20(a)(i) of the Act. This ??? found favour with these two authorities. In second appeal, the Deputy ??? of Consolidation held that, since ??? disabled landholders were paying land ??? of more than Rs. 250/- per annum, ??? tenants of sir did not become asamis under Sec. 21(1)(h) but became adhivasis under Sec. 20(a)(i). This is also the view ??? by the Joint Director of ???. Before the Deputy Director of ??? as well as the Joint Director of ??? a new plea was raised by the petitioner, that since the contesting responds were recorded as tenants of sir in the words of 1356 Fasli, they must be deemed be recorded occupants and as such they came asamis under Sec. 21(1)(h) even ??? the landholder was paying a land ??? of over Rs. 250/- per annum. Both ??? authorities repelled this contention, holding that a tenant of sir or a sub-tenant could not be regarded as a ‘recorded occupant’. It is the correctness of the view expressed by the Deputy Director of Consolidation and the Joint Director of Consolidation on the new plea raised that has been challenged in these two writ petitions.
6. In Ram Dular Singh v. Babu Sukhu Ram 1963 A.L.J 667 F.B. a Full Bench of this Court took the view that a person entered as a sub-tenant in the khasra or khatauni or 1356 Fasli could not be said to have been recorded as an occupant. The Supreme Court has taken a different view in The Upper Ganges Sugar Mills Ltd v. Khalil-Ul-Rahman 1961 A.L.J 27. and Amba Prasad v. Mahboob Ali Shah 1964 A.L.J 805.. The Supreme Court has held that the entry of a sub-tenant is an entry of an occupant qua the tenant-in-chief and the entry of a tenant is an entry of an occupant qua the landlord. It, therefore, follows from the Supreme Court judgments that the entry of a tenant or sub-tenant in the records of 1356 Fasli can amount to an entry of occupant; but it does not follow from this that every entry of tenant or subtenant in the records of 1356 Fasli must necessarily amount to an entry of occupant. In Pir Khan v. Deputy Director of Consolidation 1965 A.L.J 591., a Division Bench of this Court, after considering the above mentioned two decisions of the Supreme Court, held that an entry of sub-tenant in 1356 Fasli in favour of a person, who was, in fact, a subtenant, did not amount to an entry of occupant and that such a person did not acquire adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(b) but could acquire such rights only under Sec. 20(a)(ii). The reason given for the view was that a person, who was, in fact, a sub-tenant, held the land on behalf of the tenant and, therefore, he could not be treated as a mere occupant. S.N Singh, J. has observed that the decision in Pir Khan's case has been overruled by a Full Bench of this Court in Chobey Sunder Lal v. Sonu 1967 A.L.J 960 F.B.. The maim question for Consideration before the Full Bench was whether, in view of the Supreme Court decisions referred to above, the decision of the earlier Full Bench in Ram Dular Singh v. Babu Sukhu Ram was still good law or not. The Full Bench held that the decision in Ram Dular Singh's case was no longer good law. The Full Bench was not called upon to decide whether a person, who was, in fact, a sub-tenant and was so recorded in 1356 Fasli, could be treated as a ‘recorded occupant’. So far as we can see, the 1967 Full Bench deals with a different question and has not overruled the decision of the Division Bench in Pir Khan's case. An occupant can only be against the zamindar or the tenant or sub tenant of the land, i.e, against some one holding the legal title in the land. If the land has been let out to a tenant, then the occupant can only be against the tenant. If the name of the tenant is recorded in the records of 1356 Fasli and he can be considered to be a recorded occupant also, then he will be an occupant against himself. Sec. 20(b) does not contemplate a rightful tenureholder being an occupant—it contemplates an occupant as some one other than the rightful tenureholder who is capable of acquiring adhivasi rights against him. However, in the view which we are taking, it is neither necessary to examine this question any further nor to refer the matter for decision to a larger Bench.
7. The relevant part of Sec. 20 reads as follows:—
“20—Every person who—
“(a) On the date immediately preceding the date of vesting was or has been deemed to be in accordance with the provisions of this Act—
(i) except as provided in sub-clause (1) of clause (b), a tenant of Sir other than a tenant referred to in clause (ix) of Sec. 19 or in whose favour hereditary rights accrue in accordance with the provisions of Sec. 10, or
(ii) except as provided in sub-clause (i) of clause (b), a sub-tenant other than a sub-tenant referred to in proviso to sub-sec. (3) of Sec. 27 of the United Provinces Tenancy (Amendment) Act, 1947, or sub-sec. (4) of Sec. 47 of the United ??? Tenancy Act, 1939, of any land other than groveland;
(b) was recorded as occupant:—
(i) ……………………….
(ii) ………………………..
shall, unless he has become a bhumidh of the land under sub-sec. (2) of Sec. ??? or an asami under Clause (h) of Sec. ??? be called adhivasi of the land and ??? subject to the provisions of this Act, entitled to take or retain possession thereof.”
8. In the present cases, the contesting respondents were admittedly tenants of sir land Admittedly, they were not tenants ??? to in clause (ix) of Sec. 19 or tenants whose favour hereditary rights ??? under Sec. 10; nor are they tenants was have become bhumidhars under sub-sec. (2) of Sec. 18. Therefore, they ??? adhivasis under Sec. 20(a)(i) unless the can be held to have become asamis under Sec. 21(1)(h) of the Act. Sec. 21(1)(1) reads thus:—
“21(1)—Notwithstanding anything ??? in this Act, every person who, ??? the date immediately preceding the ??? of vesting, occupied or held land as—
(h) a tenant of sir land referred ??? in Sub-clause (a) of clause (i) of ??? Explanation under Sec. 16, a sub-tenant referred to in sub-clause (ii) of clause ??? of Sec. 20 or an occupant referred to ??? sub-clause (i) of clause (b) of the ??? section where the landholder, or, if the are more than one landholder, all of the were person or persons holding—
(a) if the land was let out or ??? to the ninth day of April, 1946, ??? on the date of letting or occupation, ??? the case may be, and the ninth day ??? April, 1946, and
(b) if the land was let out or ??? on or after the ninth day of April 1946, on the date of letting or ??? to any one or more of the clauses mentioned in sub-sec. (1) of Sec. 157.
……………………………
…………………………….
shall be deemed to be an asami thereof.”
9. Clause (h) seeks to confer asami rights on three classes of persons, namely, (i) ??? of sir, (ii) sub-tenants and (iii) ???. It will be noticed that it is on these three classes of persons that Sec. 20 ??? to confer adhivasi rights. In view of the words in Sec. 20 “unless he has become an asami under clause (h) of Sec. 21” ??? of the opening words of Sec. 21 “not-withstanding anything contained in this Act”, it is clear that the provisions of Sec. ???(1)(h) will override the provisions of Sec. 20 and a person, who acquires asami rights under Sec. 21(1)(h) will not ??? adhivasi rights under Sec. 20. It is, therefore, legitimate to read Sec. 20 together with Sec. 21(1)(h). Thus read together, it is apparent that a tenant of sir, who has not already become a bhumidhar, sirdari or hereditary tenant, will acquire adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(a)(i) unless he is covered by the first part of clause (h) of Sec. 21(1) and is a tenant of sir land ??? to in sub-clause (a) of clause (i) of the Explanation under Sec. 16 and his ??? is a disabled person. Likewise, sub-tenant would acquire adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(a)(ii) unless he falls in the second class of cases contemplated in clause (h) of Sec. 21(1) and his landlord is a disabled person. Similarly, a recorded ???, who is covered by the provisions of Sec. 20(b)(i) would acquire adhivasi rights under that section unless he was covered by the third class of cases mentioned in clause (h) of Sec. 21(1) and his landlord was a disabled person. Where person is a tenant of sir and claims adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(a)(i), it is only permissible to see whether, under clause (h) of Sec. 21(1), he is a tenant of sir land referred to in sub-clause (a) of clause (i) of the Explanation under Sec. ??? and has as such acquired asami rights ??? it is not permissible to consider whether he should be treated as a recorded ??? and whether, as a record occupant, he has acquired asami rights under sec. 21(1)(h). In order to defeat the acquisition of adhivasi rights under the various provisions of Sec. 20, it is only legitimate to consider whether, under the corresponding provision of Sec. 21(1)(h), he has acquired asami rights. Therefore, all that was necessary to consider in the present cases was whether the contesting respondents, who were admittedly the tenants of sir and who admittedly had not acquired bhumidhari, sirdari or hereditary tenancy rights, acquired asami rights under Sec. 21(1)(h) by virtue of the fact that they were tenants of sir land referred to in sub-clause (a) of clause (i) of the Explanation under Sec. 16. The Deputy Director of Consolidation as well as the Joint Director of Consolidation have rightly held that, since the landholders paid a land revenue of more than Rs. 250/- per annum, the sir land was not covered by sub-clause (a) of clause (i) of the Explanation under Sec. 16. In fact, this part of the decision, of the Deputy Director of Consolidation and of the Joint Director of Consolidation has not been challenged before us. The only question raised was whether the contesting respondents could, for purposes of Sec. 21(1)(h), be treated as recorded occupants and, as such recorded occupants, be deemed to have acquired asami rights.
10. Before the Joint Director of Consolidation an argument was raised that the words “except as provided in sub-clause (i) of clause (b)” occurring in Sec. 20(a)(i) indicate that a tenant of sir, who is recorded as a tenant of sir in 1356 Fasli, acquires adhivasi rights not under Sec. 20(a)(i) but under Sec. 20(b)(i) as a recorded occupant. This contention was rightly repelled by the Joint Director. What these words indicate is that, if A is the tenant of Sir on the date immediately preceding the date of vesting and B is recorded as occupant of sir in 1356 Fasli, then B will acquire adhivasi rights in preference to A. These words do not mean that a person, who is, in fact, a tenant of Sir and who is so recorded in the records of 1356 Fasli, will not acquire adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(a)(1) but will do so under Sec. 20(b)(i). A tenant of sir can acquire adhivasi rights only under Sec. 20(a)(i) and he can acquire asami rights only if he falls under the first part of Sec. 21(1)(h).
11. In our opinion, a person, who is, in fact, a tenant of sir and claims adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(a)(i), can acquire such rights only under this provision and even if he can be considered to be a recorded occupant by virtue of the fact that he is entered as a tenant of sir in the records of 1356 Fasli, he cannot acquire adhivasi rights under Sec. 20(b)(i). The acquisition of adhivasi rights by him under Sec. 20(a)(i) can only be defeated if it is shown that he is a tenant of sir land referred to in sub-clause (a) of clause (i) of the Explanation under Sec. 16 and his landholder was, on the relevant dates, a disabled person in which case he will acquire only asami rights under Sec. 21(1)(b). The question whether he can be considered to be a recorded occupant or not affect the acquisition of adhivasi or asami rights by him.
12. The Deputy Director of Consolidation and the Joint Director of Consolidation have rightly held that the contesting respondents in these two writ petitions acquired adhivasi rights on the coming into force of the Act, and, subsequently, became sirdars. Both the writ petitions are accordingly dismissed. Since no one has appeared to contest the writ petitions, there will be no order as to costs.
Petitions dismissed.