Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act because(a) of the enforcement of Section 259-A, U.P Tenancy Act,
  • Section 20(a)(ii). Under Section 240-A of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Re-forms Act
  • Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act.12. Chapter VIII of the U.P Tenancy Act
  • provisions of Section 20(a)(ii) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • Sections 240-A, 240-B etc. to the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act.
  • Section 20(b) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • Section 201 of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Re-forms Act.9.
  • SECTION 111 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Section 231 of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • Section 45, U.P Tenancy Act (hereafter referred to as the Act)
  • provisions of Section 295-A of the U.P Tenancy Act
  • provisions of Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act,
  • Sections 18(c) and 83 of the Agra Tenancy Act
  • Section 111 of thi Transfer of Property Act.
  • provisions of Section 176, U.P Tenancy Act.
  • Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • provisions of Section 45, U.P Tenancy
  • Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act
  • provisions of the U.P Tenancy Act
  • Section 295-A in the Tenancy Act
  • Section 180 of the Tenancy Act
  • provisions and Section 20(b)
  • Section 175 to Section 179,
  • Section 163 to Section 179,
  • Section 20(b). Question No. 3
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • U.P Tenancy (Amendment) Act
  • grounds.13. Section 17, 5
  • Section 20(b) of U.P Act
  • 30, 1952, see Section 176),
  • Section 45. Section 47
  • Section 20(b) of Act
  • 14, 1947. Section 27
  • U.P Tenancy Act
  • Section 20(b).23.
  • Section 20(b)(i)
  • Section 240-B.
  • Section 20(b)
  • Section 18(1)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act because(a) of the enforcement of Section 259-A, U.P Tenancy Act,
  • Section 20(a)(ii). Under Section 240-A of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Re-forms Act
  • Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act.12. Chapter VIII of the U.P Tenancy Act
  • provisions of Section 20(a)(ii) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • Sections 240-A, 240-B etc. to the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act.
  • Section 20(b) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • Section 201 of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Re-forms Act.9.
  • SECTION 111 TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • Section 231 of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • Section 45, U.P Tenancy Act (hereafter referred to as the Act)
  • provisions of Section 295-A of the U.P Tenancy Act
  • provisions of Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act,
  • Sections 18(c) and 83 of the Agra Tenancy Act
  • Section 111 of thi Transfer of Property Act.
  • provisions of Section 176, U.P Tenancy Act.
  • Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act
  • provisions of Section 45, U.P Tenancy
  • Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act
  • provisions of the U.P Tenancy Act
  • Section 295-A in the Tenancy Act
  • Section 180 of the Tenancy Act
  • provisions and Section 20(b)
  • Section 175 to Section 179,
  • Section 163 to Section 179,
  • Section 20(b). Question No. 3
  • TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT
  • U.P Tenancy (Amendment) Act
  • grounds.13. Section 17, 5
  • Section 20(b) of U.P Act
  • 30, 1952, see Section 176),
  • Section 45. Section 47
  • Section 20(b) of Act
  • 14, 1947. Section 27
  • U.P Tenancy Act
  • Section 20(b).23.
  • Section 20(b)(i)
  • Section 240-B.
  • Section 20(b)
  • Section 18(1)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

On May 14, 1946 Bhagwan Das (a fixed-rate tenant) sublet the disputed land to defendants 1 and 2 for five years, the term to expire on May 13, 1951. On August 27, 1947 Bhagwan Das transferred all his rights in the land to the plaintiff. The U.P. Tenancy Act was amended by insertion of Section 295-A (by the U.P. Tenancy (Amendment) Act No. X of 1947), which granted sub-tenants who were sub-tenants on June 14, 1947 a right to retain possession for a period of five years from June 14, 1947 (subject to certain qualifications derived from Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act).

After expiry of the written sub-lease, the plaintiff served a notice to quit and, on defendants' failure to respond, filed a suit for ejectment on August 31 (year partly illegible in the opinion). While that suit was pending the U.P. Tenancy Act was repealed and the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act (hereafter "Zamindari Act") came into force on July 1, 1952. Under the Zamindari Act, fixed-rate tenants became bhumidhars (Section 18(1)) and sub-tenants became adhivasis (Section 20(a)(ii)); subsequently, after the enactment of Act No. XX of 1954 (adding Sections 240-A and 240-B), adhivasis could become sirdars.

The trial court dismissed the plaintiff's suit, holding that the defendants had become sirdars. The appellate court, however, decreed the suit with respect to some plots. Defendants 1 and 2 filed the present second appeal. Mithan Lal, J. referred several specific questions to a larger bench; this bench (including Desai, C.J., Oak, J., and Pathak, J.) answered the referred questions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether notwithstanding the expiry of the term of qabuliat on May 13, 1951 the defendants-appellants continued to be sub-tenants of the plots in suit till the commencement of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act because (a) of the enforcement of Section 295-A, U.P. Tenancy Act, till June 6/7th (?) 1952, and (b) the sub-tenancy has not been extinguished as required by the provisions of Section 45, U.P. Tenancy Act.
  2. Did the appellants become adhivasis of the disputed land under the provisions of Section 20(a)(ii) of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act from the commencement of that Act and then become sirdars after proceedings under Chapter IX-A of that Act?
  3. Alternatively, have the appellants become adhivasis under Section 20(b) of the U.P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act and thereafter sirdars under Chapter IX-A of that Act?
  4. Whether even if the defendants-appellants became adhivasis, are they liable to be ejected under Section 231 as they cannot be deemed to have held the land within the meaning of Section 240-A?

Arguments of the Parties

Defendants' Arguments (as presented)

  • The defendants contended that they held over as sub-tenants and consequently became adhivasis under Section 20(a)(ii) of the Zamindari Act and later became sirdars under Section 240-B.
  • They relied on the protection afforded by Section 295-A of the U.P. Tenancy Act to retain possession until June 14, 1952 (and, by virtue of related provisions, through June 30, 1952) and thus argued continuity of their sub-tenancy up to the date relevant for transition under the Zamindari Act.

Plaintiff's Arguments (as presented)

  • The plaintiff argued that the defendants were not in possession of the plots in respect of which the suit was decreed because they had sublet them to other persons, and therefore could not claim the benefit of Section 295-A.
  • The plaintiff contended that a sub-tenant from a fixed-rate tenant automatically ceased to be a sub-tenant on expiry of the sub-tenancy period, so the defendants were not sub-tenants on June 30, 1952 and could not claim adhivasi rights under Section 20(a)(ii).
  • The plaintiff further argued that the defendants, not being recorded occupants, could not claim adhivasi rights under Section 20(b)(i).
  • Finally, the plaintiff contended that even if the defendants became adhivasis, by virtue of Section 231 of the Zamindari Act they remained subject to all liabilities to which they were subject on June 30, 1952 (implying possible exposure to ejectment liability).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Jalesar Sahu v. Raj Mangal Walsh, J.'s observation that certain sections (Sections 18(c) and 83 of the Agra Tenancy Act) were not exhaustive. The Court found that the decision had no applicability to the present case because the aspect held not exhaustive in Jalesar Sahu related to surrender, not the extinguishment of tenancy rights; the Court therefore did not adopt that reasoning here.
Nanhumal v. Muloo (Second Appeal No. 1978 of 1954) Treatment of the rights and liabilities of bhumidhars against adhivasis and the effect of Act No. XX of 1954 (Sections 240-A, 240-B). The Chief Justice referred to this decision (decided the same day) for the proposition that Act XX of 1954 resulted in the plaintiff ceasing to be bhumidhar and the defendants becoming sirdars, leaving the plaintiff with no right to possession and removing liability to ejectment except as provided in Section 201 of the Zamindari Act.
Bhal Singh v. Bhop Earlier treatment of the expression "was recorded as occupant" occurring in Section 20(b) (previously Court had held an entry as occupant includes an entry as occupant as a tenant or under lawful title). The Chief Justice indicated that on reconsideration he thought part of the earlier statement was not correct in scope (that an entry as occupant includes tenant entries). He nevertheless stood by the final decision in that case but clarified the present interpretation of "recorded as occupant" in light of other authorities and records practice.
Kamta Pande v. Banarsi Chaube Support for the narrower meaning of 'occupant' — that 'occupant' does not mean a tenant or sub-tenant in possession. The Court expressly agreed with the reasoning in Kamta Pande and used it to support the interpretation that entries of tenants/sub-tenants in Khasra/Khatauni columns are not entries of occupation for purposes of Section 20(b).
Lalta Pande v. Mahendra Nath Pande Statement (by Dhavan, J.) that 'occupant' does not mean a tenant or sub-tenant in possession. The Court found Dhavan, J.'s statement persuasive and adopted the view that entries of tenants/sub-tenants in their respective Khasra/Khatauni columns are not the "recorded as occupant" entries referred to in Section 20(b).

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds in distinct, statute-focused steps, applying provisions of the U.P. Tenancy Act and the Zamindari Act to the factual matrix:

  1. Governing law for agricultural leases: The Transfer of Property Act's general rules on leases (e.g., Section 111) do not apply to agricultural leases (Section 117 of the Transfer of Property Act), so the relationship and rights are governed by the U.P. Tenancy Act.
  2. Extinguishment by efflux of time under the Tenancy Act: Under Sections 45 and 47 of the U.P. Tenancy Act, the interest of a tenant and of a sub-tenant is extinguished only in the specified circumstances listed in Section 45; efflux of time (expiry of lease term) is not one of the enumerated modes of extinguishment. Sections 48 and related ejectment provisions further demonstrate that a sub-tenant's interest is not extinguished merely by expiry of the sub-lease term; instead, expiry exposes the sub-tenant to a particular ejectment remedy (Section 175(b)) but does not automatically convert him to a trespasser or extinguish his tenancy interest.
  3. Effect of Section 295-A (U.P. Tenancy Act amendment): Section 295-A (inserted by the 1947 Amendment) expressly granted every person who was a sub-tenant on June 14, 1947 the right to retain possession for five years from that date (subject to the proviso linked to Section 27(3) where relevant). The Court interprets the phrase "entitled to retain possession of his holding" as meaning the sub-tenant retained possession in the capacity of sub-tenant — the sub-tenancy was prolonged because the possession logically continued in the capacity from which it originally arose, with continued liability to pay rent and subject to the remedial regime of the Tenancy Act.
  4. Timing and immunity from ejectment: Because Section 295-A gave a right to remain in possession until June 14, 1952, and because Section 176 (and the procedural scheme, including the window for applications under Section 175) prevented applications for ejectment on the basis of expiry of lease during the relevant period up to June 30, 1952, the defendants remained sub-tenants and were immune from ejectment on the ground of efflux of time during that period. In consequence, they were sub-tenants on the critical date (June 30, 1952).
  5. Conversion under the Zamindari Act: When the Zamindari Act came into force on July 1, 1952, the statutory mechanics made sub-tenants into adhivasis under Section 20(a)(ii), and fixed-rate tenants into bhumidhars under Section 18(1). Because the defendants were sub-tenants on June 30, 1952, they acquired adhivasi rights on commencement of the Zamindari Act.
  6. Effect of Act No. XX of 1954 (Sections 240-A, 240-B): The Court (via the Chief Justice and as referenced by Nanhumal v. Muloo) states that the later amendments (Act XX of 1954) caused adhivasis to become sirdars and resulted in the plaintiff ceasing to be bhumidhar, thereby altering the possession/entitlement landscape; the plaintiff was left without a right to possession and defendants were no longer liable to ejectment except as provided by the Zamindari Act (Section 201).
  7. Interpretation of "recorded as occupant" in Section 20(b): The Chief Justice analyzed the Land Records Manual for the Khasra and Khatauni of 1356 Fasli and concluded that names entered in columns for tenure-holders or sub-tenants (columns 5 and 6) are entries of entitlement, not entries of occupation. Only entries in the remarks column marked "Dawedar Qabiz" or "Qabiz" are entries of occupation simpliciter. Therefore, persons recorded only as sub-tenants in the relevant registers are not "recorded as occupant" within Section 20(b) and cannot claim adhivasi rights under that subsection on that basis.
  8. Separate analysis by Oak, J.: Oak, J. agreed with the Chief Justice on questions 1, 2 and 4 but emphasized that the omission of "efflux of time" from Section 45 was deliberate. Oak also provided a practical, register-focused exposition for Section 20(b), explaining three types of Khasra entries and concluding that a claimant need only prove that his name was recorded as occupant in the Khasra (the primary register). Oak observed that, depending on the nature of entries against particular plots, appellants might obtain the benefit of Section 20(b) for plots where they were recorded as occupants (and he estimated appellants might get benefit for about 13 plots).

Holding and Implications

The Court's formal answers to the referred questions (as set out in the opinion) are:

  • Question 1(a): Yes.
  • Question 1(b): Yes.
  • Question 2: Yes.
  • Question 4: No.
  • Question 3: The Chief Justice and Pathak, J. answered No (i.e., the appellants were not entitled under Section 20(b) because they were recorded as sub-tenants, not as occupants). Oak, J., while concurring on Questions 1, 2 and 4, answered Question 3 differently in substance: he held that for those specific plots where the appellants were recorded as occupants in the Khasra (as explained in his analysis), they were entitled to benefit under Section 20(b) and subsequently became sirdars for those plots; Oak indicated appellants may get benefit for approximately 13 plots.

Direct Consequences / Implications Recounted in the Opinion

  • Because the defendants were sub-tenants on June 30, 1952 and by operation of the Zamindari Act became adhivasis (Section 20(a)(ii)), they could not be ejected on the ground of expiry of their sub-lease (i.e., the efflux-of-time ground under Section 175(b) of the U.P. Tenancy Act did not attach as a liability surviving under Section 231 of the Zamindari Act).
  • After enactment of Act No. XX of 1954 (Sections 240-A, 240-B), the defendants' adhivasi rights ripened into sirdari; the plaintiff ceased to be a bhumidhar and was left without a right to possession in the manner described in the Court's reasoning (as further explained in the contemporaneous Nanhumal v. Muloo decision).
  • The Court's disposition means that, at least as to the plots in which the defendants were sub-tenants on the relevant date, defendants obtained statutory protection and rights under the Zamindari Act; the plaintiff's claim to ejectment on the ground of expiry of the sub-lease fails.

The opinion contains divergent answers among the judges on Question 3: the Chief Justice and Pathak, J. answered it negatively on the facts (no Section 20(b) benefit for those recorded only as sub-tenants), while Oak, J. allowed Section 20(b) benefit for plots where the Khasra recorded the appellants as occupants (he indicated this might apply to 13 plots). This factual differentiation as to specific plots remained to be applied to the record of entries in the Khasra.

No additional precedents or party arguments beyond those contained above were inferred or added. If any statutory subsection or entry year was partially illegible in the provided opinion text (for example, a year in the plaint filing), that uncertainty has been preserved rather than supplemented.

    Ram Dular Singh And Others v. Babu Sukhu Ram And Others

    Desai, C.J:— This case has been referred by Mithan Lal, J. to a larger bench for decision of the following questions:—

    “2. Did the appellants become adhivasis of the disputed land under the provisions of Section 20(a)(ii) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act from the commencement of the said Act and then became sirdars after proceedings under Chapter IX-A o??? the said Act?

    3. Alternatively have the appellants become adhivasis under Section 20(b) of the U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act and thereafter sirdars under Chapter IX-A of the said Act?

    4. Whether even if the defendants-appellants became adhivasis are they liable to be ejected under Section 231 as they cannot be deemed to have held the land within the meaning of Section 240-A?”

    2. Question No. 1, which is

    “1. Whether notwithstanding the expiry of the term of qabuliat on May 13, 1951 the defendants-appellants continued to be the sub-tenants of the plots in suit till the commencement of U.P Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act because

    (a) of the enforcement of Section 259-A, U.P Tenancy Act, till 6/7th June, 1952, and

    (b) the sub-tenancy has not been extinguished as required by the provisions of Section 45, U.P Tenancy Act?”

    has not been specifically referred to a larger bench because this question arising in the connected second appeals already stands referred to a larger bench. In effect, therefore, all the four questions are for answers by this bench.

    3. On May 14, 1946, Bhagwan Das, who was the fixed rate tenant of the land in dispute, sublet it to defendants 1 and 2 for a period of five years. The lease was due to expire on May 13, 1951, but on August 27, 1947, Bhagwan Das transferred all his rights in the land to the plaintiff. The U.P Tenancy Act which was in force then was amended by the U.P Tenancy (Amendment) Act No. X of 1947; one of the amendments was to insert Section 295-A in the Tenancy Act laying down that every person, who on June 14. 1947 was a Sub-tenant was, subject to the provisions of Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act, entitled to retain possession of his holding for a period of five years from June 14, 1947. Section 27 dealt with reinstatement of certain tenants who had been ejected from their holdings; a tenant who had been ejected under Section 165 or 171 or any person who was, ejected under Section 180 of the Tenancy Act was given a right to apply for reinstatement within six months. Similarly a tenant of sir who had become a hereditary tenant under Section 16(1) and was ejected from his holding or any tenant who was dispossessed in consequence of any fraud or misrepresentation or undue influence was given a right to apply for reinstatement within six months. Sub-section (3) dealt with the procedure to be followed by the Court; it was to give notice of the application to the landholder and to the tenant, if any, in possession of the holding. The proviso to sub-section (3) was to the effect that, if the holding was in the possession of any person to whom the landholder had let it out before September 1, 1946, the court instead of ordering his ejectment was to declare him to be the sub-tenant of the applicant and he was not liable to ejectment until after the expiry of three years from the date of the declaration. Thus the right granted by Section 295-A to a sub-tenant to remain in possession upto June 14, 1952 was subject to the condition that the right was reduced to a right to remain in possession for three years from the date of the declaration, if any, made under Section 27(3) of the Amendment Act on an application by an ejected tenant or person. Defendants 1 and 2 were sub-tenants on June 14, 1947 and by virtue of Section 295-A they became entitled to remain in possession upto June 14, 1952, even though the sub-lease was to expire on May 13, 1951. On the expiry of the sub-lease the plaintiff gave to them a notice to quit and, on their failing to respond, filed a suit on August 31, 19 for their ejectment. A large number of persons were joined as defendants on the ground that they were related to defendants 1 and 2 or that they were recorded as Dar Shikmis on their behalf over some of the land in dispute. While the suit ??? pending the U.P Tenancy Act was repealed and the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act came into force with effect from July 1, 1952. A fixed rate tenant became entitled to take or retain possession as a bhumidhar under Section 18(1) and a sub-tenant became entitled to take or retain possession as an adhivasi under Section 20(a)(ii). Under Section 240-A of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Re-forms Act the right, title and interest of a bhumidhar in land held or deemed to be held by an adhivasi ceased and vested in the State with effect from October 30, 1954 and the adhivasi became sirdar under Section 240-B. The suit was contested by defendants 1 and 2 who claimed that they became adhivasis and subsequently sirdars. It was dismissed by the trial court, which held that the defendants had become sirdars, but the appellate court decreed it with respect to some of the plots. This second appeal was filed by defendants 1 and 2 against the decree. The contention of the defendants is that they held over as sub-tenants and consequently became adhivasis under Section 20(a)(ii) and later sirdars under Section 240-B. On behalf of the plaintiff it was contended that the defendants were not in possession of the plots in respect of which the suit was decreed because they had sublet them to other defendants and, consequently, they could not claim the benefit of Section 295-A, that a sub-tenant from a fixed rate tenant automatically ceased to be a sub-tenant on the expiry of the period of sub-tenancy, that the defendants were not sub-tenants on June 30, 1962 and could not claim adhivasi rights under Section 20(a)’(ii), that they not being recorded occupants could not claim adhivasi rights also under Section 20(b)(i) and that even if they became adhivasis, they were by virtue of Section 231 of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act subject to all liabilities to which they were subject on June 30, 1952. These contentions gave rise to the questions reproduced above. The law regarding leases of immovable property contained in the Transfer of Property Act is as follows. Under Section 108(q) a lessee is bound, on the termination of the lease, to put the lessor into possession of the property. A lease of immovable property determines vide Section 111, by efflux of the time limited thereby, surrender, forfeiture etc. Section 116 lays down that if a lessee………………………. of property remains in possession thereof after the determination of the lease granted to the lessee and the lessor or his legal representative accepts rent from the lessee………………….. or otherwise assents to his continuing in possession, the lease is……………….. renewed from year to year. A lease includes an under-lease or sublease and the doctrine of holding over is applicable to a sub-tenant also. The effect of all this law is that a sub-lease for a fixed term determines when the term expires and, if the sub-tenant remains in possession thereafter and the tenant-in-chief accepts rent from him, or otherwise assents to his remaining in possession, the sub-lease is renewed from year to year. The law contained in the Transfer of Property Act, however, does not apply to leases for agricultural purposes, vide Section 117, and, therefore, it does not govern the cases before us. They are governed by the law contained in the U.P Tenancy Act.

    4. The gist of the law regarding sub-leases contained in the U.P Tenancy Act is given below. “Sub-tenant” meant a person who held land from its tenant and by whom rent was or would be payable and “tenant” included a sub-tenant except where the contrary intention appeared. The interest of a tenant was extinguished when he died heirless, when the land was sold in execution of a decree, when he was ejected in execution of a decree or order of a court, when he surrendered or abandoned it, when the land was acquired by the State Government, when he acquired the entire proprietary rights in the holding and when he was dispossessed and his right to regain the possession became barred by time; see Section 45. Section 47 provided that the extinction of the interest of a tenant operated Jo extinguish the interest of his sub-tenant. It will be noticed Sections 45 and 47, dealt with extinction of the interest of a tenant and a sub-tenant holding under him only in certain circumstances which did not include efflux of the time for which the interest was created and in this respect there was a departure from the law contained in the Transfer of Property Act. The interest of a tenant was not extinguished by efflux of the time for which the lease was granted to him. The expiry of the period of the lease bad no effect on his tenancy rights. Section 48 provided that when the interest of a sub-tenant was extinguished he was bound to vacate his holding; there is no such provision in respect of extinction of the interest of a tenant. A sub-tenant's interest also was extinguished in the manner laid down in Section 45, i.e it was not extinguished by efflux of the time for which the sub-lease was granted to him. The period of the sub-lease might have expired, but he continued to be a subtenant so long as he did not die heirless, did not surrender or abandon the holding was not ejected in execution of a decree or order of a court etc. The only effect of the efflux of time was that he became liable to be ejected under Section 175(b), but, so long as he was not ejected, he continued to be a sub-tenant, because his interest was hot extinguished. It made no difference that he was required on extinction of his interest to vacate his holding, whereas a tenant was not required to vacate his holding on extinction of his interest, because the question whether the holding should be vacated or not did hot arise so long as the interest Was not extinguished. As far as the question whether the interest was extinguished or not, the U.P Tenancy Act made no difference between interest of a tenant and interest of a sub-tenant. I do not agree with the contention that Section 45 did not exhaustively mention the circumstances in which a tenant's interest was extinguished. It was as exhaustive as Section 111 of thi Transfer of Property Act. We were referred to Jalesar Sahu v. Raj Mangal (1), in which Walsh, J. observed that Sections 18(c) and 83 of the Agra Tenancy Act were not exhaustive. What was held to be not exhaustive Was the law contained in these sections as to how a holding could be surrendered and not the law contained in Section 18 as to how a tenancy right could be extinguished. That decision has no applicability in the instant cases. Ejectment of tenants was dealt with in Section 155 to 186. No tenant could be ejected from his holding otherwise than in accordance with those provisions; see Section 157. Different kinds of tenants were liable to be ejected on different grounds. A sub-tenant was a non-occupancy tenant according to its definition in Section 31. A non-occupancy tenant was liable to be ejected under Section 171 for illegal transfer or subletting, under Section 172 for certain acts detrimental to the land or in violation of a condition of the lease or under Section 175(b) on the ground that he was a tenant holding under a lease which had expired or was to expire before the end of the current agricultural year. The effect of these provisions was that a sub-tenant after the expiry of the period of the sub-lease remained a subtenant though subject to the liability to be ejected under Section 175(b). His sub-tenancy right was not extinguished and be was not required to vacate the holding merely because the period of the sub-lease had expired. There is ho substance in the contention that a subtenant simply got a right to be in possession and not a right to be a sub-tenant after the expiry of the period of the sub-lease. If he had a right to remain in possession it must be in one capacity or another and the only capacity in which he could remain in possession was that of a sub-tenant. Since his tenancy right was not extinguished and it continued and it could not be said that with effect from the date of the expiry of the period of the sub-lease he became some other kind of tenant. The right to remain in possession carried with it the liability to pay rent; he was not to remain in possession immune from the liability. So long as he remained liable to pay rent to the tenant-in-chief it meant that he was a sub-tenant. Consequently defendants 1 and 2 would have remained subtenants, by virtue of the provisions of Sections 45, 48 and 175 read with 31, upto May 13, 1951 subject to the liability to ejectment on certain grounds and thereafter subject to the liability on one more ground, namely that the period of the sub-lease had expired. While they were sub-tenants Section 295-A was added in the Tenancy Act on June 14, 1947. This section was to apply notwithstanding any contract to the contrary or anything contained in the Act or any other law gave them a right to retain possession of their holding for a period of five years ending on June 14, 1952. It is not stated in Section 295-A in what capacity the subtenant was to remain in possession and what happened to his right, if any existing, to remain in possession upto a certain date after June 14, 1947. The words “Notwithstanding any contract ………… the time being in force” suggest that his right to remain in possession upto June 14, 1952 was in supersession of all rights existing in his lessor's favour under the contract of sub-lease or any of the provisions of the Tenancy Act, but not that his possession was to be in a different capacity. The prolongation of the right to remain in possession meant prolongation of the sub-tenancy, because the right to remain in possession could not be dissociated from the sub-tenancy right, out of which alone it arose. The liability to pay rent continued and this means that the sub-tenant was to remain a sub-tenant upto June 14, 1952. If but for Section 295-A he would have been liable to be ejected under Section 175(b) during this period of five years that liability was removed and he could not be ejected on the ground of efflux of time. No suit for his ejectment under Section 175(b) could be instituted prior to June 14, 1952. He could be ejected under that provision after June 14, 1952 (really after June 30, 1952, see Section 176), but so long as he was not ejected he continued to be a subtenant. The result was that after the enactment of Section 295-A the two defendants were to continue as sub-tenants upto June 30, 1952, immune from any liability to ejectment under Section 175(b) on the ground of efflux of the period of their sub-lease.

    5. The words “entitled to retain possession of his holding” support my conclusion that they were to remain sub-tenants because “holding” meant, as defined in Section 2(7), a parcel of land under one lease, engagement or grant. If the land in their possession was to remain their holding, it meant that they were to remain in possession as sub-tenants. They were not ejected prior to June 30, 1952 and they continued to be sub-tenants on June 30, 1952, even though the instant suit for their ejectment was pending. The pendency of the suit did not affect their rights. On the date on which the suit was instituted they had already acquired the right conferred by Section 295-A to remain in possession as sub-tenants upto June 30, 1952 and the suit could, and should have been, dismissed on the ground that the plaint did not disclose any cause of action but it continued and they continued as sub-tenants.

    6. The Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act came into force on July 1, 1952 and the defendants acquired adhipasi rights under Section 20(a)(ii) and the plaintiff acquired bhumidhari rights under Section 18(i) as said in the beginning. This was the state of the parties rights upto October 10, 1954 when Act No. XX of 1954 came into force adding Sections 240-A, 240-B etc. to the Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act. As adhi- vasis the defendants were by virtue of Section 231 subject to all the rights and all the liabilities which they possessed, or were subject to, in respect of the land on June 30, 1952. On that date they were not liable to ejectment on the ground of efflux of time under Section 175(b). They were immune from this liability upto June 14, 1952 on account of the provisions of Section 295-A of the U.P Tenancy Act and between June 14, 1952 and June 30, 1952 on account of the provisions of Section 176, U.P Tenancy Act. Since no suit could be brought between these two dates, it meant that they were immune from the liability. They could become liable on July 1, 1952, but before this date the U.P Tenancy Act was repealed and they ceased to be sub-tenants and became adhivasis. The liability that was attached to their adhivasi rights was the liability existing on June 30, 1952 and this did not include the liability to be ejected under Section 175(b). Therefore, as adhivasis they could be ejected on certain grounds but not on the ground of the expiry of the period of their sub-lease, or the period of five years prescribed by Section 295-A. In Second Appeal No. 1978 of 1954 (Nanhumal v. Muloo) decided today I have dealt with the rights and liabilities of bhumidhars against adhivasis.

    7. The Removal of Difficulties Order does not help the plaintiff, because under the provisions of the U.P Tenancy Act itself his suit was liable to be dismissed as the defendants were not liable to be ejected.

    8. The effect of the enforcement of Act XX of 1954 was, as stated in Nanhumal's case (supra), that the plaintiff ceased to be a bhumidhar and the defendants became sirdars, the plaintiff was left with no right to possession and the defendants were no longer under any liability to ejectment except as provided in Section 201 of the Zamindari Abolition and Land Re-forms Act.

    9. My answers to the questions are as follows:

    Question 1(a).—Yes.

    (b)—Yes,

    Question 2—Yes

    Question 4—No.

    10. Question 3—As regards question No. 3 the defendants were not recorded as occupants in the Khasra or Khatauni of 1356 Fasli; they were instead recorded as sub-tenants. In order to understand what is meant by “recorded as occupant” in Section 20(b) one must necessarily refer-to the provisions of the Land Records Manual in force in 1356 Fasli, because entries in Khasras and Khataunis were to be made in accordance with its provisions. Paragraphs 83(ii) and (iii), 84(a)(ii)(c), etc. and 85 contained provisions regarding Dawedar Qabiz and Qabiz entries in the remarks column in addition to entries of names of tenure-holders and subtenants in columns 5 and 6 of the Khasra. As there are no other provisions regarding entries or occupation barring this, “recorded as occupant” must mean recorded as Qabiz or Dawedar Qabiz as provided in these provisions. Tenure-holders and subtenants names are entered in columns 5 and 6 of the Khasra even if they are not in possession; their names are entered there because they possess certain rights. An entry of Dawedar Qabiz or Qabiz is an entry of occupation simpliciter. According to the Land Records Manual sit and khudkasht holders, tenants and subtenants were to be entered in column 5 of the Khasra and if other persons were in actual occupation they were to be recorded as “occupants” in the remarks column in accordance with the provisions of the paragraphs mentioned above. Entries were made in columns 5 and 6 on the basis of entries in the previous papers legardless of actual occupation; even if a sir or khudkasht holder or a tenant, or a sub-tenant was not in actual possession his name would be entered in column 5 or 6 and the name of the person in actual occupation would be entered in the remarks column. Consequently entries made in columns 5 and 6 were not entries of occupation at all and only the entries in the remarks column made with the words “Dawedar Qabiz” or “Qabiz.”, were entries of occupation and they are the entries referred to in Section 20(b). They are entries in respect of persons having no right to be in occupation either as a proprietor or as a tenant or as a sub-tenant. When a tenure-holder's name was recorded in the papers and no one else was recorded to be in occupation it meant that he himself was in occupation, but Section 20(b) clearly was not meant to apply to him. He was granted new tenancy rights under other provisions and Section 20(b) was meant for persons who were not granted tenancy rights under them. As I pointed out in Nanhumal's case (supra) an adhivasi has no tenure like the one possessed by a bhumidhar or a sirdar and has simply occupation subject to all previously existing rights and liabilities. Adhivasi rights were created for certain sub-tenants and for persons who had occupation and no proprietary or tenancy right on June 30, 1952. Therefore, the words “recorded as occupant” mean “recorded as nothing more than an occupant”. They do not necessarily mean that the person is a trespasser or in un-lawful occupation; an entry of occupation of a trespasser or a person in unlawful occupation is undoubtedly an entry of occupation within the meaning of the words, but they are not confined to such persons. Any person in occupation, whether adverse or under licence, lawful or unlawful, is within the meaning of the words. Section 20 presupposes that it was possible for a person to acquire bhumidhari rights under Section 18(2) or asami rights under Section 21(h) in the land in which he could acquire adhivasi rights; the Legislature did not contemplate that it was possible that any other right, such as bhumidhari rights under Section 18(1) or sirduri rights or asami rights under other provisions of Section 21, or hereditary right accrued in the land in which adhivasi right accrued. This confirms that Section 20 was meant to cover cases other than those covered by Sections 18, 19 and 21, i.e persons recorded as sir or khudkasht holders, tenants, sub-tenants in the Khasra or Khatauni of 1356 Fasli were not within the meaning of the words “persons recorded as occupant” in those records. In Bhal Singh v. Bhop (2), my brother Pathak and I had to deal with the words “was recorded as occupant” occurring in Section 20(b). We said at page 211 Column 1, 4th line that “an entry as occupant includes an entry as occupant as a tenant or under lawful title”. On reconsideration I think that it is not correct and that an entry of occupation as a tenant or as a sir or khudkasht holder is outside the scope of the words. I stand by the final decision in that case (which was to the effect that a person who was recorded as an occupant could get adhivasi rights even though he was not in actual occupation and the entry was correct. I now agree with Kamta Pande v. Banarsi Chaube (3) and with the statement to the effect that ‘occupant’ does not mean a tenant or sub-tenant in possession made by our brother Dhavan in Lalta Pande v. Mahendra Nath Pande (4). Therefore when the defendants were entered as sub-tenants in the Khasra and the Khatauni of 1356 Fasli they could not be said to have been recorded as occupants and they could not claim adhivasi rights under Section 20(b). Question No. 3 must therefore be answered in the negative.

    Oak, J.:— I have read the judgment prepared by the learned Chief Justice. I was at first inclined to take the view that, although Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act does not in terms apply to agricultural leases, the principle under lying clause (a) of Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act applies to agricultural leases. But on further consideration, I have come to the conclusion that, the omission to mention efflux of time in Section 45, U.P Tenancy Act (hereafter referred to as the Act) was deliberate and not accidental.

    11. Chapter IV of the Act dealt with devolution, transfer, extinction, division, exchange and acquisition of tenancies. Section 45 of the Act provided for extinction of tenancies. Section 45 enumerated six circumstances, under which the interest of a tenant was extinguished. Efflux of time was not mentioned in Section 45. It was not seriously disputed that Section 45 applied to a sub-tenant also. Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act provides for determination of a lease of immovable property. According) to clause (a) of Section 111, Transfer of Property Act, a lease of immovable property deter-mines by efflux of the time limited thereby. The Transfer of Property Act was in force in India for many years before the U.P Tenancy Act was enacted. The general principle that the right of a lessee comes to an end at the end of the period fixed in the lease was not, likely to have escaped the notice of the Legislature, especially as the rule has received statutory recognition in Section 111 of the Transfer of Property Act.

    12. Chapter VIII of the U.P Tenancy Act dealt with ejectment. Section 157 of the Act stated:

    “No tenant shall be ejected from his holding otherwise than in accordance with the provisions of this Act.”

    Section 163 to 170 dealt with ejectment for arrears of rent. Sections 171 to 174 dealt with ejectment for illegal or detrimental acts. Obviously, these were provisions for ejectment of tenants. The headnote appearing above Section 175 was “ejectment on other grounds”.

    13. Section 17, 5 provided for ejectment of a non-occupancy tenant on application. A sub-tenant was a non-occupancy tenant. Section 175 ran thus:—

    “Subject to the provisions of Section 19 a non-occupancy tenant shall also be liable to ejectment on the application of the landholder on any of the following grounds, namely:

    (a) that he is a tenant holding from year to year;

    (b) that he is a tenant holding under a lease or for a period which has expired or will expire before the end of the current agricultural year.”

    14. The language of clause (b) of Section 175 was significant. The language of clause (b) suggests that, although the period fixed under a lease had expired, the defendant was treated as a tenant on the date of the application. Under Section 179, the application was converted into a suit. From Section 175 to Section 179, the defendant has all along been described as a tenant. The headnote to Section 180 was: “ejectment of person occupying land without title”. That head-note suggests that, having dealt with ejectment of tenants from Section 163 to Section 179, the Legislature now took up the question of ejectment of a trespasser. According to Section 176, an application under Section 175 had to he moved between July 1 and September 30. It was laid down in Section 178 that the tenant was not liable for costs incurred by the landholder in the application under Section 175. No such consideration was shown for a trespasser, when he was sued under Section 180 of the Act.

    15. The language of Section 45 of the Act and the various provisions contained in Chapter VIII of the Act indicate that, the Legislature was anxious to maintain continuity of possession of a tenant even after the expiry of the period fixed in the lease. Tenancy was not extinguished except in accordance with a method expressly recognised by the statute. In the present case, although the period fixed in the lease expired on the May 13 or May 14, 1951, the appellants rights as subtenants continued after May 14, 1951 —at least till August 31, 1951, when the suit for ejectment was filed.

    16. At this stage, Section 295-A of the Act came to the assistance of the appellants. Under Section 295-A, the appellants became entitled to retain possession till June, 1952. It is true that it was not expressly stated under Section 295-A that, such possession would be as subtenants. But the reference to Sections 44 and 171 of the Act, contained in Section 295-A, indicates that, such possession was to be as sub-tenants. The defendants-appellants were, therefore, entitled to retain possession till the middle of June, 1952.

    17. It is true that the respondents filed a suit for possession in August, 1951. But, in view of Section 295-A of the Act, the suit was premature. In view of Section 176 of the Act, an application for ejectment under Section 175 of the Act was not maintainable up to June 30, 1952. The net result was that, the appellants were entitled to retain possession as subtenants until June 30, 1952. So they became adhivasis under U.P Act No. I of 1951. Subsequently, the appellants rights as adhivasis ripened into sirdari.

    18. I, therefore, agree that, questions Nos. 1, 2 and 4 should be answered in the manner indicated by the learned Chief Justice.

    19. As regards question No. 3 the answer will depend upon the nature of entry against a particular plot. The plaintiff claimed possession, over 91 plots. The dispute is now confined to 60 plots. In his order of reference, the learned single Judge has pointed out that, there were entries of various types against different plots. Against some plots, the appellants were recorded as sub-tenants without any qualification. Against other plots, although the appellants were recorded as sub-tenants, certain other persons were recorded as Darshikmis. In the former case, the appellants were the recorded occupants. But in the latter case, the appellants were not the recorded occupants.

    20. According to one view, in order to get the benefit of Section 20(b) of U.P Act No. I of 1951, the claimant must have some right to hold the land. According to another view the provision is meant for the benefit of trespassers. In my opinion, the question whether a person has a title to hold certain land is irrelevant for purposes of Section 20(b) of Act No. I of 1951. The expression used in Section 20(b) is: “recorded as occupant”. All that a claimant need prove for this purpose is that, his name was recorded as occupant. It is not sufficient that that claimant's name should somehow appear in the Khasra. The entry must indicate that the claimant occupied the field. Section 20(b) refers to entries in the Khasra and Khatauni of 1356 Fasli. Usually, entries in the Khasra and Khatauni are consistent with each other. But one can readily conceive conflicting entries in the two registers. The Khasra is the primary register about possession or occupation. The Khatauni is prepared later. In the case of a conflict between the two registers, the entry in the Khasra should prevail for purposes of Section 20(b). It will, therefore, be sufficient to discuss the various types of entries in the Khasra for 1356 Fasli.

    21. The simplest case is where the name of a person P was recorded in the column for tenant; and the column for sub-tenants and the column for remarks or blank. Here P was recorded as a tenant without any encumbrance. There is in law a presumption that possession follows title. The entry, therefore, indicates that, P was in possession over the plot in 1356 Fasli. In other words, he was recorded as occupant. He is fully entitled to the benefit of Section 20(b) of Act No. I of 1951.

    22. Secondly, we may consider a case where P's name appeared in the column for tenants. Q's name appeared in the column for sub-tenants, and the column for remarks is blank. In this case Q, the sub-tenant, was entitled to actual cultivation of the land. The entry indicates that, although P was the tenant-in-chief, the recorded occupant was Q. So, Q is entitled to the benefit of Section 20(b).

    23. Thirdly, let us suppose that, P's name was entered in the column for tenants; Q's name was recorded in the column for sub-tenants; and R was recorded in the column for remarks as Dave dar Qabiz or trespasser. In this case P and Q are supposed to have certain rights in the land; and R has no title. Nonetheless, the actual possession was of R. R being the recorded occupant, he is entitled to the benefit of Section 20(b). I have not examined the entries against the 60 plots in dispute in the Khasra of 1356 Fasli. But I gather from the order of reference that, the appellants may get the benefit of Section 20(b) with respect to 13 plots.

    24. My answer on question No. 3 is as follows:

    “The appellants are entitled to the benefit of Section 20(b) of U.P Act No. I of 1951 for those plots only, against which their names were recorded as occupants in the sense explained above. Subsequently, the appellants became sirdars of those plots.”

    Pathak, J.:— I entirely concur with the answers proposed by my Lord the Chief Justice.

    U.P Tenancy Act

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ram Dular Singh And Others v. Babu Sukhu Ram And Others
    (May 10, 1963)