Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of rule 19(a) in section V at page 136, High Court's General Rules
  • Order XXVI, rule 15, Civil Procedure Code, section VII
  • section V with witnesses' expenses, section VI
  • section 35(1) of the Civil Procedure Code
  • SECTION 35 A CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • rule 28(1) in section VII
  • Rule 19(vi) in section V
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • provisions of rule 19(a) in section V at page 136, High Court's General Rules
  • Order XXVI, rule 15, Civil Procedure Code, section VII
  • section V with witnesses' expenses, section VI
  • section 35(1) of the Civil Procedure Code
  • SECTION 35 A CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE
  • rule 28(1) in section VII
  • Rule 19(vi) in section V

    Sir Kameshwar Singh v. Nebilal Mistri

    Beevor, J.:— This is an application in revision which relates only to a small item claimed as costs. The petitioner before us instituted a rent suit no. 116 of 1943 which was finally tried ex parte with other rent suits by the 2nd Munsif of Monghyr on the 17th May, 1943. On that date one Shivnandan Prasad, the petitioner's patwari, was examined as the only witness for the plaintiff now the petitioner. A bill was submitted for the sum of Rs. 3 as travelling allowance and subsistence allowance of the patwari. This was rejected by the learned Munsif without reasons. An appeal was presented to the District Judge of Monghyr who dismissed the appeal holding that although the Munsif had given no reasons he had obviously acted under section 35(1) of the Civil Procedure Code and that he had not made an improper use of his discretion.

    Section 35 of the Civil Procedure Code deals with the court's powers regarding costs, and the substantial portion of the section directs that costs shall be in the discretion of the court. Where discretion has properly been exercised the appellate court and this Court in revision will not interfere with the exercise of that discretion. The discretion given is, however, a judicial discretion to be exercised in accordance with definite principles. It has, however, been held in many cases that where a principle is involved the court will always interfere and entertain review from the decision of the Langley v. D'Arcy*(1) where the English decision, Hill v. Peel(2), is cited for this proposition and there is no doubt that where a question of principle is involved this Court will interfere in revision with orders for costs. We were referred in connection with this case to the decision of the Calcutta High Court, Hara Sundar Mazumdar v. Lahabar Singh(3) Where it was held that the successful party in a litigation is entitled as against the unsuccessful party, against whom costs are awarded, to recover all proper expenses, including travelling expenses incurred by summons of witnesses; also to the decision in Shujauddin Khan…Defendant v. Mehdi Raza…Plaintiff .(4) and another decision of the Calcutta High Court in Upendra Naraian Roy v. Bisweswar Roy Chowdhury(5), but although there are remarks in the judgments in those cases which are of general application, they do not afford a complete ground for deciding the present case because we have to take into consideration the rules framed by this Court.

    Part V, Chapter I, High Court's General Rules and Circular Orders. Civil, Volume I deals with fees and costs and is divided into nine sections. Section I deals with process fees; section II with the reduction and remission of court-fees; section III with other fees including costs of affidavits, searching fees and copying charges; section IV deals with postage, section V with witnesses' expenses, section VI with expenses of commissions under Order XXVI, rule 15, Civil Procedure Code, section VII with fees of advocates and pleaders, section VIII with mukhtars' fees, and section IX with fees of revenue agents, and in the last section appears rule 31 which clearly has a general application. The main portion of this rule says:

    “In addition to the fee hereinbefore prescribed the successful party shall, ordinarily be allowed to recover the following charges.”

    These charges are given under three heads and we are now concerned with heading no. 1 which runs as follows:

    “The party or his agent according to the circumstances of each individual case may be allowed subsistence allowance according to the scale prescribed for witnesses' expenses in rule 19 ante for such days of attendance in court as the court may direct.”

    There is no doubt that the patwari was the agent of the present petitioner for the rent suit in question and the petitioner claims that under this rule 31(1) he was entitled to subsistence allowance for his patwari.

    The learned District Judge considered that the Munsif in disallowing the petition had obviously taken into consideration the paltry amount which was claimed and the fact that the suit was uncontested. I do not think that these could be valid grounds for disallowing an item of costs.

    It is clear that a very wide discretion is given to the courts under section 35 of the Civil Procedure Code, and that discretion extends not only to the question which party should bear the costs of a suit or proceeding or in what proportion but also in many instances to the question whether a particular item should be allowed as costs of a party and, if so, for what sum. This is clearly recognised by the High Court Rules. To give one or two examples out of many, I may refer to rule 28(1) in section VII of the Chapter already mentioned which states that the advocates' and pleaders' fees shall be in the discretion of the court, and then provides a scale on which such fees shall ordinarily be allowed. Rule 19(vi) in section V dealing with witnesses' expenses provides that for witnesses following any profession such as medicine or law special allowance shall be given according to circumstances.

    Without attempting to lay down any hard and fast rule I think that in practice it will be found convenient to keep separate any question regarding the exercise of a general discretion given to the court to determine to what extent a successful party should be allowed to recover his costs and from whom from any question relating to the exercise of the discretion to determine whether a particular item should be allowed as costs and, if so, for what sum. No doubt in some cases the same circumstance may afford a ground both for disallowing a portion of the costs of the successful party and for disallowing a particular item. This will not, however, affect the principle.

    When the words of rule 31(1) are considered, there may at first appear to be a conflict between the words

    “for such days of attendance in court as the court may direct”

    and the words in the main part of the rule

    “the successful party dial ordinarily be allowed to recover the following charges”,

    and it may be suggested that unless the court directs that a party or his agent shall be allowed subsistence allowance for any particular day, the party shall not ordinarily be allowed to recover anything on that account. In my opinion this is incorrect. I have no doubt that in most suits and proceedings the party or his agent does attend on a number of days other than the date on which his evidence is taken, and the meaning of the rule is that the party is not to be granted subsistence allowance automatically for all such days but only for such days as the court may direct. Where the party himself or his agent is a necessary witness in the suit his attendance is essential on the date of hearing if on no other date and I do not think that it is a proper exercise of judicial discretion to disallow the subsistence allowance for that date except for definite reasons. No definite reason has been suggested in this case for disallowing the subsistence allowance of the patwari on the date of hearing.

    For these reasons I hold that the learned Munsif did not exercise a judicial discretion in disallowing the subsistence allowance of the patwari on the date of hearing. I do not, however, think that the claim of Rs. 3 was justified. Prima facie I think that the proper amount was Re. 1 under the provisions of rule 19(a) in section V at page 136, High Court's General Rules and Circular Orders, Civil, Volume I.

    I would ordinarily direct that the decree be altered in accordance with the above directions but the petitioner's advocate has made it clear that he is not concerned with the small sum now in question but merely to establish the principle for the future. The judgment-debtor has not at any stage appeared to contest the petitioner's claim and was not at fault in this respect. It might, I think, cause some hardship to the judgment-debtor if the decree of the trial court were now varied, and I would, therefore, refuse to vary the decree and reject this application subject to the remark that, for the reasons already given, the learned Munsif did not exercise a proper judicial discretion in rejecting altogether the claim for subsistence allowance of the patwari.

    Manohar Lall, J.:— I agree. My learned brother has shown in detail how the question of costs should have been disposed of. In the present case the learned Munsif has given no indication as to whether he applied his mind to decide whether in the circumstances of this case the plaintiff ought not to have been allowed the costs claimed by him. All that is stated in the order is:

    “The petition for passing the bill is rejected”.

    It may be that the learned Munsif had in mind that the same patwari was present on behalf of the plaintiff not only in suit no. 116 of 1943 but in a number of other rent suits, e.g, nos. 117, 119, 120, 121 and 122 of 1943 which were disposed of at the same time. The learned Munsif should have indicated in the order the reasons which led him to refuse subsistence costs to the patwari in this case.

    H.R.K
    Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Sir Kameshwar Singh v. Nebilal Mistri
    (Sep 13, 1944)