The question is whether a money-lender whose income is below Rs. 30 a month is chargeable with any tax under section 53 of the District Municipalities Act. There is no doubt that he exercises one of the trades specified in schedule A. A part from the proviso, that schedule does not include persons whose income is under Rs. 30. It is said that the proviso has the effect of bringing such persons within the schedule, because, as it is argued, every money-lender shall be placed at least in Class VII irrespectively of his income.
If the income was not under Rs. 30 no doubt that would be the feet of the proviso, and that is all we think that the Legislature ???, but not to bring within one of the classes persons who, apart from the proviso, would be in no class at all. This is ??? by the words immediately preceding the proviso, viz., every person described in Class I whose pay, salary or pension amounts, or whose income is estimated to amount to Rs. 30 a month of ???—Re. 1.
The result would probably have been otherwise if those words had been fitted, and the phrase “Provided that” substituted.
The petition is dismissed with costs.