Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges

    Ramalinga Mudali v. Ayyadorai Nainar

    Both the Courts are agreed as to the important facts in the case. Though what purports to be a sale deed for money was executed and registered by Sabapathy Pillai to the first defendant, yet the instrument was not delivered to him, but retained by Sabapathy Pillai himself who also remained in possession of the property until he made the transfer in favour of the temple represented by the plaintiffs and subsequently held possession under the temple as their tenant until his death. It was subsequently to his death, ten years after the supposed sale to him that the first defendant took possession of the property. The defendant's plea that the intended transfer to him was in consideration of Rs. 300 actually paid was untrue. The explanation on behalf of the plaintiffs of the transaction was that Sabapathy Pillai intended to marry the first defendant's daughter and that the transfer was to be in consideration of such marriage which in fact never took place and that the first defendant having refused to give his daughter in marriage, the transfer was never completed. Notwithstanding the by no means clear language used by the Munsif in that part of his judgment to which our attention has been called on behalf of the first defendant, we cannot agree with the suggestion that the plaintiff's case was that the more promise to give and not the actual gift of the girl formed the consideration for the execution of the deed by Sabapathy Pillai. It would be absurd to suppose that Sahapathy Pillai was willing to part with his property upon the mere promise to give the girl in marriage irrespective of whether that promise was to he carried out or not, and the unquestionable facts that the document was never delivered nor possession of the property given, are absolutely inconsistent with the suggestion referred to which has been accepted, by the Judge. It is therefore clear that the transfer was intended to he effected only in the event of the marriage taking place and as it did not take place, effect was not given to the intention to transfer and no property passed to the first defendant (Ponnayya Goundan v. Muttu Goundan(1)) to which the District Judge refers has no application to cases of this kind and though, in the circumstances of that case, actual handing over of the instrument after registration was not essential to vest the properly in the vendee it cannot lie laid down as a general rule that mere registration of an instrument without reference to other circumstances operates to transfer the property. See Sangu Ayyar v. Cumarasami Mudaliar(2) and Maulodan v. Raghunandan Pershad Singh(3).

    We therefore reverse the decree of, the District Judge and restore that of the District Munsif with costs in this and in the lower Appellate Court.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ramalinga Mudali v. Ayyadorai Nainar
    (Sep 21, 1904)