AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Economics lecturer.2. Section 18 of the U.P Secondary Education Service Commission and Selection Board Act, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as Act)
  • clause (b) of Sub-section (1) of Section 18
  • Sub-section (1) of Section 18
  • Education Act, 1921
  • Section 18(1)(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Economics lecturer.2. Section 18 of the U.P Secondary Education Service Commission and Selection Board Act, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as Act)
  • clause (b) of Sub-section (1) of Section 18
  • Sub-section (1) of Section 18
  • Education Act, 1921
  • Section 18(1)(b)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On account of the retirement of the Economics lecturer on 30.6.1985 the post fell vacant at Shri Krishna Pathshala Intermediate College, Azamgarh. The Committee of Management notified the vacancy to the District Inspector of Schools (D.I.O.S.) on 1.7.1985. By letter dated 31.10.1985 the D.I.O.S. recommended a reserve-pool teacher, who declined the appointment; the D.I.O.S. then sent a requisition to the Secondary Education Commission through the Deputy Director of Education for selection.

Under Section 18(1)(b) of the U.P. Secondary Education Service Commission and Selection Board Act, 1982, a management may make an ad hoc appointment if the post has actually remained vacant for more than two months. As no selection was made by the Commission and the post remained vacant for over two months, the management decided to make an ad hoc appointment and invited applications on 1.4.1986 for direct recruitment on an ad hoc basis.

Shri Narendra Singh (respondent No. 4) was selected on 6.7.1986 and an appointment letter dated 8.7.1986 was issued. The petitioner, a teacher at the same college, filed a writ petition seeking quashing of respondent No. 4's appointment and seeking consideration for promotion to the Economics lecturer post. The petitioner contended he was the senior-most teacher eligible for promotion and relied on a Division Bench decision (Charu Chandra Tiwari) to argue that ad hoc vacancies under Section 18(1)(b) should be filled by promotion. Respondent No. 4 contended the petitioner was not eligible on the relevant date.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether an ad hoc vacancy under Section 18(1)(b) of the U.P. Secondary Education Service Commission and Selection Board Act, 1982 must be filled by promotion, and whether direct recruitment is permissible only if no eligible teacher for promotion exists (as contended by the petitioner relying on Charu Chandra Tiwari).
  2. What is the relevant date for determining a teacher's eligibility for promotion under Section 18(1)(b) — specifically, whether eligibility should be judged as of the date the management decides to make the ad hoc appointment (the "relevant date").
  3. Whether the petitioner, whose M.A. result was declared after the selection of respondent No. 4, can be treated as eligible for promotion by virtue of the doctrine that examination results "relate back" to the date of the examination.
  4. Whether the selection of respondent No. 4 (a direct recruitment) can be quashed and replaced by promoting the petitioner.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Relying on Charu Chandra Tiwari v. District Inspector of Schools, the petitioner argued that vacancies under Section 18(1)(b) must be filled by promotion and direct recruitment may be used only if no eligible teachers for promotion are available.
  • The petitioner asserted he was the senior-most teacher eligible for promotion and should therefore have been promoted instead of the Management selecting respondent No. 4 by direct recruitment.
  • The petitioner further contended that his M.A. examination was held in April 1986 and, under the principle that examination results relate back to the date of the examination, he should be deemed to have been eligible before respondent No. 4's selection (selected on 6.7.1986), because his examination took place earlier even though the result was declared on 11.7.1986.

Respondent No. 4's Arguments

  • Respondent No. 4's pleaded position was that the petitioner was not eligible on the relevant date and therefore not entitled to promotion.
  • It was averred in the counter affidavit that the petitioner did not possess an M.A. degree and was teaching Science and Mathematics (M.Sc. and B.Ed.), and therefore, was not eligible for the Economics lecturer post on the dates when eligibility needed to be assessed.
  • Implicitly, respondent No. 4 relied on the principle that once the selection process for direct recruitment has commenced and rights are created in favour of applicants, those rights cannot be destroyed by subsequent events such as a later declaration of an exam result in favour of another candidate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Charu Chandra Tiwari v. District Inspector of Schools (1990 L.B & E.C 160) Holding that a vacancy under Section 18(1)(b) should be filled by promotion; direct recruitment is permissible only if eligible teachers for promotion are not available. The Court relied on this decision to frame the primary issue: if an eligible teacher existed on the relevant date, he must be promoted and direct recruitment would be impermissible.
A.A. Calton v. Director of Education (1983 3 SCC 33) Principle that the process of selection—from calling applications up to the date employer is entitled to make selection—is integrated; at every stage rights are created in favour of some candidates. The Court applied this principle to hold that once the management initiated the process of direct recruitment and applicants had been called and considered, rights had been created in favour of those applicants and the process could not be reversed.
P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka (1990 1 SCC 411) Reaffirmation that a candidate acquires a right to be considered for selection in accordance with the recruitment rules once he applies in response to an advertisement; the right to consideration is protected. The Court quoted and relied on this authority to support the proposition that applicants acquire a right to be considered and that such rights cannot be taken away absent law to the contrary.
Hari Nath Dubey v. Deputy Director of Education (1986 L.B & E.C 128) Observed that declaration of the result of an examination dates back to the date on which the examination was held (i.e., result may be treated as relating back to examination date). The Court noted this authority but distinguished it on facts: where a selection process had already been commenced and rights had vested in another candidate before a result was declared, that result could not unsettle the vested rights.
Sangam Lat/Lal Pandey v. State of U.P. (W.P. No. Nil of 1990) Held, in the facts of that case, that a petitioner will be deemed to have passed the M.A. Final examination on the date when the examination was held, rendering him eligible by a later vacancy date. The Court cited this decision as an instance where the "relates back" principle entitled a candidate to be treated as qualified on a prior date, but distinguished it because in the present case a selection by direct recruitment had already been made before the petitioner's result was declared.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by identifying the statutory framework: Section 18(1)(b) of the U.P. Secondary Education Service Commission and Selection Board Act, 1982 permits the management to make an ad hoc appointment if a post has actually remained vacant for more than two months. The Court accepted the settled principle from Charu Chandra Tiwari that, in such circumstances, preference is to promote an eligible teacher from the institution; direct recruitment may be utilized only if no eligible teacher for promotion exists.

The Court then analysed what constitutes the relevant date for assessing eligibility. It held that the relevant date is the date on which the management, after the post has remained vacant for more than two months, decides to make the ad hoc appointment (i.e., the date on which the management becomes entitled to make the ad hoc appointment). If on that date a teacher is eligible for promotion, the teacher must be promoted; if no eligible teacher exists on that date, the management may proceed by direct recruitment.

Applying these principles to the present facts, the Court observed: (a) the petitioner did not possess an M.A. degree at the times when the management decided to make the appointment and when it invited applications (the opinion records that the petitioner "was not having M.A" and "not being M.A was not eligible on or before 1.4.1985" as pleaded); (b) the management was therefore justified in inviting applications for direct recruitment; and (c) once the process for direct recruitment was initiated and candidates applied, rights to be considered were created in favour of those candidates, relying on A.A. Calton and P. Mahendran for the legal proposition that the selection process is integrated and that application creates a right to be considered which cannot be taken away arbitrarily.

The petitioner asserted that his M.A. examination had been held in April 1986 and that, because declaration of results relates back to the examination date, he should be treated as eligible before respondent No. 4's selection (6.7.1986). The Court noted there was no material in the writ petition specifying the dates of the M.A. examination; the rejoinder alleged only that the petitioner appeared in April 1986 and that the result was declared on 11.7.1986.

The Court distinguished earlier decisions (Hari Nath Dubey and Sangam Lal Pandey) which accepted that a result may relate back to the date of the examination, on the ground that those authorities did not involve situations where a process of direct selection had already been commenced and where rights had vested in another candidate. In the present case, respondent No. 4 was selected on 6.7.1986 and the appointment letter issued on 8.7.1986, whereas the petitioner's M.A. result was declared on 11.7.1986. As rights had vested in respondent No. 4 before the petitioner's result was declared, those rights could not be destroyed by the subsequent declaration of the petitioner's result.

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the petitioner was not eligible on the relevant date and that the management had lawfully proceeded with direct recruitment; the selection and appointment of respondent No. 4 could not be set aside by the late declaration of the petitioner's examination result.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is dismissed. The selection and appointment of respondent No. 4 (Shri Narendra Singh) by direct recruitment stand and are not invalidated by the subsequent declaration of the petitioner's M.A. result. There will be no order as to costs. (Paragraph 11: "Petition Dismissed.")

Implications:

  • The immediate practical consequence is that respondent No. 4's appointment remains valid and the petitioner is not entitled to promotion to the Economics lecturer post on the basis of the subsequently-declared M.A. result.
  • The Court reaffirmed two key procedural principles (as applied to the facts): (a) eligibility for promotion under Section 18(1)(b) must be judged as of the date on which the management decides to exercise its ad hoc appointment power (after the post has been vacant for the requisite period); and (b) once the process of direct recruitment has been initiated and selections are made, rights are created in favour of applicants which cannot be destroyed by subsequent events such as a later declaration of examination results in favour of another candidate.
  • The opinion did not purport to lay down a new precedent beyond applying and distinguishing existing authorities; its effect is a factual determination upholding the selection that had already been made.

    Hans Raj Singh v. U.P Secondary Education Service Commission, Allahabad And Others

    R.A Sharma, J.:— On account of retirement of Economics lecturer on 30.6.1985 the post of lecturer in Economics fell vacant in Shri Krishna Pathshala Intermediate College Azamgarh (hereinafter referred to as the college). On 1.7.1985 the Committee of Management sent a requisition to the District Inspector of Schools (hereinafter referred to as D.I.O.S) for selection of a lecturer in Economics by Secondary Education Commission. The D.I.O.S by letter dated 31.10.1985 recommended the name of reserve pool teacher for appointment against the aforesaid vacancy, but the teacher declined to join the college, and D.I.O.S thereupon sent a requisition to the Secondary, Education Commission, through Deputy Director of Education for Selection of Economics lecturer.

    2. Section 18 of the U.P Secondary Education Service Commission and Selection Board Act, 1982 (hereinafter referred to as Act) provides for the appointment of a teacher on ad hoc basis if the management has notified the vacancy to the Commission under Act and the Commission has failed to recommend a suitable candidate for appointment within one year or the post of such teacher has actually remained vacant for more than two months. Sub-section (1) of Section 18 is quoted below:

    “(1) Where the management has notified a vacancy to the Commission in accordance with the provisions of this Act, and—

    (a) the Commission has failed to recommend the name of any suitable candidate for being appointed as a teacher specified in the Schedule within one year from the date of such notification; or

    (b) the post of such teacher has actually remained vacant for more than two months, then, the management may appoint, by direct recruitment or promotion, a teacher on purely adhoc basis from amongst the persons possessing qualifications prescribed under the Intermediate Education Act, 1921 or the regulation made thereunder.”

    3. As no selection has been made by the Commission and the post remained vacant for more than two months, the management decided to make adhoc appointment and applications were accordingly invited on 1.4.1986 for appointment of a lecturer in Economics by direct recruitment on adhoc basis. Shri Narendra Singh, respondent No. 4, was selected on 6.7.1986 as lecturet in Economics and appointment letter dated 8.7.1986 was issued to him by the management. The petitioner, who is a teacher in the College, has filed this writ petition for quashing the appointment letter issued to respondent no. 4 and for consideration of his name for promotion to the post of lecturer in Economics. Relying on the decision of a Division Bench of this Court in Charu Chandra Tiwari v. District Inspector of Schools . 1990 L.B & E.C 160., the learned counsel for the petitioner has argued that a vacancy on adhoc basis under Section 18 has to be filled by promotion and the method of direct recruitment can be adopted only if eligible teachers for promotion are not available and as the petitioner is senior most teacher eligible for promotion to the post of lecturer, he should have been promoted and selection by direct recruitment of respondent no. 4, as such, is void. The contention of learned counsel for respondent no. 4, on the other hand, is that the petitioner was not eligible on the relevant date and is not entitled to be promoted.

    4. Under clause (b) of Sub-section (1) of Section 18 a person in order to be appointed must possess the qualifications prescribed in the Intermediate Education Act or Regulations made thereunder. Appendix—A to Chapter II of Regulations framed under the Intermediate Education Act lays down minimum qualifications for appointment of a teacher in Intermediate College. For lecturer minimum qualification is M.A The petitioner was not having M.A degree but his case is that he appeared in M.A examination sometime in April, 1986 and was declared pass on 11.7.1936, the consequence of which is that the petitioner shall be deemed to have passed the M.A examination some time in April, 1986, as the result of the examination dates back to the date of the examination.

    5. It has already been settled by a Division Bench of this Court in Charu Chandra Tiwari v. District Inspector of Schools (supra) that vacancy under Section 18(1)(b) has to be filled by promotion and direct recruitment cannot be made unless a teacher in the institution is not eligible for promotion. The questions for consideration are whether the petitioner was eligible on the relevant date and what is relevant date with reference to which eligibility has to be seen. Under Section 18(1)(b) the management gets rights to make adhoc appointments, if the post has actually remained vacant, for more than two months The date on which the management, after expiry of more than two months from the date of vacancy, decides to make adhoc appointment under Section 18(1)(b), is the relevant date with reference to which eligibility for purposes of promotion is to be seen. If on this date a teacher is eligible for promotion, he has got to be promoted and no appointment by direct recruitment can be made under this provision. However, if eligible teacher for promotion is not available on the aforesaid date the management will have full right to make ad hoc appointment by direct recruitment

    6. In the instant case the exact date on which the management decided to make ad hoc appointment has not been disclosed by the parties, but it is clear from paragraph 15 of the counter affidavit of respondent no. 4 that on 1.1??? the vacancy was notified for inviting applications in pursuance of which the respondent No. 4 and others applied. The petitioner not being M.A was not eligible on or before 1.4.1985, and could not have been promoted The management was, as such, fully justified to invite applications for making appointment by direct recruitment. Once the process for direct appointment has been initiated, it cannot be reversed. As held by Hon'ble Supreme Court in A.A Calton v. Director of Education . 1983 3 SCC 33 process of selection, commencing from a stage of calling for the applications for a post upto the date on which the employer becomes entitled to make selection, is an integrated one and at every stage in that process certain rights are created in favour of one or the other of the candidates. It is true that by making application for the post, one does not get right for the same; but a right to get his case considered in accordance with the terms and conditions of advertisement is created in his favour. This right cannot be taken away unless there is the law which provides otherwise. This principle has been reaffirmed by Hon'ble Supreme Court in P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka . 1990 1 SCC 411. The relevant extract from page 412 of this decision is quoted below;

    “It is true that a candidate does not get any right to the post by merely making an application for the same, but a right is created in his favour for being considered for the post in accordance with the terms and conditions of the advertisement and the existing recruitment rules. If a candidate applies for a post in response to advertisement issued by Public Service Commission in accordance with the recruitment Rules he acquires right to be considered for selection in accordance with the then existing Rules.”

    7. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner, however, is that as the result of an examination relates back to the dates on which the examination was held, the petitioner shall be deemed to have passed M.A and became eligible for the post in question before the date of selection of respondent no. 4 on 6.7.1986 and as such, was entitled to be promoted and the selection of respondent no. 4 is invalid. There is no material or allegation in the writ petition to show the dates on which the M.A Examination of the petitioner held. No such ground has been taken in the writ petition. The averments in the writ petition are that the petitioner is working as senior most L.T grade teacher in the college and was eligible to be promoted against 40% quota reserved for promotion. In the counter affidavit of respondent No. 4, it has been averred that the petitioner is M.Sc in Mathematics and B.Ed and is teaching Science and Mathematics and is not eligible to be appointed to the post of lecturer in Economics Confronted with this difficulty, the petitioner has alleged in his rejoinder affidavit that he has appeared in M.A Examination some time in April, 1986 and he was declared pass on 11.7.1986

    8. A learned Single Judge of this Court in Hari Nath Dubey v. Deputy Director of Education . 1986 L.B & E.C 128., has observed that the declaration of the result of examination dates back to the examination to which it pertains. Similar view was taken by a Division Bench of this Court in Sangam Lat Pandey v. State of U.P . W.P No. Nil of 1990., wherein it was held that in view of the facts and circumstances of that case, the petitioner shall be deemed to have passed the examination on the date when examination was held. It is admitted that respondent No. 4 was selected on 6.7.1986 and letter of appointment was issued to the said respondent on 8.7.1986, whereas result of M.A examination of the petitioner was declared on 11.7.1986, i.e, after the selection of respondent No. 4. By selection for the post, rights were created in favour of the respondent No. 4 and these rights cannot be destroyed by subsequent declaration of the result of M.A of the petitioner. That apart, it is not disputed by the petitioner that on the date when management decided to make ad hoc appointment and on the date when management notified vacancy for inviting applications, the petitioner, not being M.A, was not eligible. If a person is not eligible on the date when occasion for making the promotion arises he cannot claim the post later on even if he attains the minimum qualifications subsequently.

    9. In the case of Hari Nath Dubey v. Sangam Lal Pandey (supra) controversies involved were different. In Hari Nath Dubey's case a learned Single Judge of this Court decided the dispute about the ad hoc appointment on the ground of seniority subject to rejection of unfit. In the case of Sangam Lal Pandey, the name of the petitioner was sent to the Secondary Education Commission for appointment as a Principal of Inter College, but his name was turned down by the Commission on the ground that on the date when the vacancy occurred, petitioner had not passed M.A Final examination and as such, cannot be treated to be qualified. In that case examination of last paper of M.A was held on 25-4-1987, vacancy was notified on 30-6-1986, the M.A result was declared on 21-7-1987 and the Secondary “Education Commission informed the Deputy Director of Education by a letter dated 6-1-1990 that the petitioner was not eligible. A Division Bench of this Court held that,—

    “having regard to the facts and circumstances of the instant case there can be no difficulty in taking the view that the petitioner will be deemed to have passed the M.A Final examination on 25th April, 1987. Thus, on 30th June, 1987, the petitioner fulfilled the requisite qualification of having in his possession a degree of Master of Arts.”

    10. In this case there was no other candidate excepting the petitioner and no right had accrued in favour of any other person. Law laid down by this Court in the aforesaid two decisions of Hari Nath Dubey and Sangam Lal Pandey will not apply to the cases in which process of selection by direct appointment has already commenced, because after the process has started, rights are created in favour of the persons, who have applied for the post. In the instant case not only the process of selection by direct recruitment has commenced but even the selection of respondent No. 4 has been made before the result of M.A examination of the petitioner was declared. Vested rights having been created in favour of the respondent No. 4, the same cannot be disturbed and destroyed by the subsequent declaration of the result of the petitioner of M.A examination. The writ petition lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed. In view of the facts and circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.

    11. Petition Dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Hans Raj Singh v. U.P Secondary Education Service Commission, Allahabad And Others
    (Jul 10, 1990)