AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Mukerji, J. (with Bartley, J. concurring)

Factual and Procedural Background

These four appeals arise from apportionment proceedings before the Land Acquisition Judge of 24-Parganas under Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act. The dispute concerns compensation awarded in respect of a ganti interest (a portion of village lands apportioned to several touzis). The ganti comprised lands of Rahara village apportioned among seven amalgamated touzis, including touzi No. 188. The respondents were owners of touzi No. 188 and gantidars with a three annas gantidari interest under that touzi.

Relevant chronology (as stated in the opinion):

  • 11 December 1924: Declaration under the Land Acquisition Act (some lands within the ganti were subject to acquisition).
  • 28 March 1925: Default in revenue assessment by the proprietors; the respondents' estate/interest was determined by reason of non-payment.
  • 16 September 1925: Collector made awards and took possession in respect of the lands concerned in Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148.
  • 18 September 1925: Revenue sale took place; the appellant purchased at that sale (touzi No. 188 interest).
  • 3 October 1925: Appellant applied to the Collector, claiming all amounts awarded (both proprietary and gantidari portions) and seeking reference to be allowed those amounts (an attempted annulment of the ganti).
  • 22 December 1925: Collector made awards and took possession in respect of the lands of Appeal No. 149.

At first instance, the Land Acquisition Judge awarded compensation for the proprietary interest to the appellant but awarded the compensation for the gantidari interest to the respondents. The appellant appealed, and there are cross-objections in three appeals directed against the compensation awarded to the appellant for his proprietary interest in the touzi.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 28 of the Revenue Sale Law (Act 11 of 1859), the appellant — whose title on purchase was said to relate back to the date of default — was entitled to the entire compensation for the lands (both proprietary and gantidari portions), because his purchase "annulled" the ganti.
  2. Whether, where certain lands were acquired under the Land Acquisition Act before the revenue sale (and awards/possession had been effected), the appellant (having bought at a later revenue sale) purchased the touzi as diminished by the acquired lands and therefore lacked title to claim compensation for those acquired lands.
  3. Whether the petition of 3 October 1925 by the appellant was sufficient to constitute an annulment of the ganti so as to entitle him to the gantidari portion of compensation in cases where the land purchased at the sale was subsequently acquired under the Land Acquisition Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended he was entitled to the entire compensation for the lands (both proprietary and gantidari amounts) because Section 28 of the Revenue Sale Law (Act 11 of 1859) makes his title as purchaser relate back to the date of the default; therefore, by his purchase he annulled the ganti at the earliest opportunity.
  • The appellant also argued (and some submissions attempted to dispute) that the ganti in question was under touzi No. 188 — the court found, however, that the existence of a three annas ganti interest under touzi No. 188 had been established beyond doubt and was not disputed below.

Respondents' Arguments

  • For Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148: Respondents argued that, because the lands had been acquired under the Land Acquisition Act and so "lost to the touzi" before the revenue sale, the appellant purchased not the full touzi but the touzi minus the acquired lands; consequently, the appellant was not entitled to the amounts awarded as compensation for those acquired lands.
  • In all appeals (including Appeal No. 149): Respondents contended that the appellant's petition of 3 October 1925 was not sufficient to annul the ganti.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Surja Kanta Acharjya v. Sarat Chandra Roy, AIR 1914 PC 82 The Judicial Committee observed that on failure of an owner to pay the Government assessment, his estate or interest in the land is forfeited (determined), and that under such a sale what is sold is not the interest of the defaulting owner but the interest of the Crown subject to payment of the Government assessment. The court relied on this principle to conclude that the appellant purchased the Crown's interest at the revenue sale (subject to payment of revenue) rather than the respondents' pre-default proprietary interest; this supported the view that the purchaser's acquisition did not necessarily confer rights to compensation for lands already acquired by the Collector.
Narayan Das v. Jatindra Nath, AIR 1927 PC 135 The Judicial Committee expressed the same view as in Surja Kanta: sale conveys the Crown's interest subject to the Government assessment; the defaulting owner's estate is determined by failure to pay assessment. The court cited this case to reinforce the principle that a revenue sale passes the Crown's interest only, supporting the conclusion that the appellant did not obtain the respondents' pre-default proprietary interest in lands that had already been acquired.
Shyam Kumari v. Rameswar Singh, 1904 32 Cal. 27 (p. 39) The proposition that when an Act speaks of a sale or purchase in connexion with time, the time meant is that at which the sale takes place in fact, not that to which its operation is carried back by relation. The court used this principle to distinguish the legal effect of the appellant's title (which related back to the date of default) from the moment when the operation of the sale actually produced its practical effects — relevant to whether acquisition by the State prior to the sale deprived the purchaser of rights in the acquired lands.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeds from statutory provisions and the authorities cited. Key statutory provisions invoked in the opinion include:

  • Section 28 of the Revenue Sale Law (Act 11 of 1859) — relied upon by the appellant to assert title dating back to the date of default;
  • Section 15, and the guidance to follow Ss. 23 and 24, of the Land Acquisition Act — dealing with the manner of determining compensation (market value at date of declaration under S. 6; and disregarding improvements made without sanction since that date);
  • Section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act — providing that on the Collector taking possession after an award under S. 11, the land vests absolutely in Government free from all encumbrances;
  • Section 31 of Act 11 of 1859 — referenced as giving the late proprietors a right to surplus purchase money where lands are sold for arrears.

Applying these statutory principles together with the authorities, the court reasoned as follows:

  1. The authorities establish that on default the defaulting owner's interest is determined and the sale transfers the Crown's interest subject to payable revenue — the purchaser does not, by the revenue sale alone, step into the exact position of the pre-default proprietor in respect of land already acquired by the Collector.
  2. For Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148:
    • The lands in those appeals had been subject to acquisition and the Collector had made awards and taken possession on 16 September 1925 — two days before the revenue sale (18 September 1925).
    • On those awards, abatement of Government revenue was allowed for the acquired lands and the capitalized value of the Government revenue on them had already been realized under the awards.
    • Therefore, by the time of the revenue sale the acquired lands were no longer subject to Government assessment and the appellant, who bought the Crown's interest on 18 September 1925, did not purchase those acquired lands.
    • Consequently the appellant could not be regarded as having acquired any interest in those acquired lands by his purchase and could not annul the ganti so as to claim the compensation awarded for those lands. The late proprietors (the respondents) remained entitled to the surplus of the purchase money under S. 31 and to compensation for the lands that could not be sold because they had been acquired in the meantime.
  3. For Appeal No. 149:
    • The award and Collector's taking of possession in that case occurred later (22 December 1925) — after the revenue sale of 18 September 1925.
    • Because the appellant had purchased at the sale the lands which were subsequently acquired, his purchase covered those lands (subject to his right to annul the ganti).
    • The appellant filed his petition on 3 October 1925 in which he claimed the compensation for the ganti, thereby signifying his intention to annul the ganti before the award was made while the ganti was still subsisting.
    • The court held that the appellant's title as proprietor related back to the date of default but that the annulment could operate only from the date it was made (i.e., from the moment of annulment). Applying the authorities and statutory framework, the court concluded that in this appeal the appellant was entitled to the proprietary compensation and to a portion of the gantidari compensation (specifically 3/16ths of the gantidari award) because he had validly signified annulment in time.
  4. The court also noted that the statutory rules in S. 23 and S. 24 of the Land Acquisition Act set out how market value and improvements are to be treated for determining compensation, but these rules govern valuation and do not themselves create proprietary rights to compensation as at the date of declaration; the practical effect of vesting in the Collector under S. 16 must be considered.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148: Dismissed. The court held that the appellant did not acquire the acquired lands by his purchase (because those lands had vested in the Collector on 16 September 1925) and therefore could not claim the compensation awarded for those lands; the respondents (late proprietors) are entitled to the surplus and to compensation for lands already acquired. The cross-objections in these appeals are allowed to the extent of the entire amounts claimed by the respondents.
  • Appeal No. 149: Allowed in part. The court held that the appellant, having purchased on 18 September 1925 and having petitioned on 3 October 1925 to annul the ganti before the award (which was made on 22 December 1925), was entitled to the proprietary compensation for those lands and to 3/16ths of the compensation awarded for the gantidari interest.
  • No order as to costs was made in any of the appeals or cross-objections.

Implications: The decision applies established principles (as cited) about the effect of revenue sales and the consequence of State acquisition prior to such sales. The opinion resolves the parties' rights in the particular factual matrix: where State acquisition and Collector's taking of possession and awards occurred before the revenue sale, the purchaser does not obtain rights to compensation for those acquired lands; where acquisition follows a purchaser's valid step to annul the ganti made while the ganti was still subsisting, the purchaser may obtain the proprietary compensation and an apportioned share of the gantidari compensation. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying these principles to the facts before the court.

This summary is restricted to the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

    Nrishinha Charan Nandi Chaudhuri v. Nagendra Bala Debee And Another

    Mukerji, J.:— These four appeals have arisen out of four apportionment cases dealt with by the Land Acquisition Judge of 24-Parganas under Section 30 of the Land Acquisition Act. The claim of the appellant for being awarded the compensation in respect of a ganti interest has been disallowed and hence these appeals. There are cross-objections in connexion with three of these appeals, the same being directed against the compensation, which has been awarded to the appellant on account of his proprietary interest in the touzi. The facts are quite simple. The ganti consists of the lands of a certain village named Rahara, which appertains to seven amalgamated touzis, of which touzi No. 188 is one. The respondents were the owners of the said touzi and were also gantidars in the lands of the said village, having a three annas gantidari interest under their touzi No. 188. For arrears of revenue defaulted on 28th March 1925, the touzi was sold on 18th September 1925. In pursuance of a declaration, dated 11th December 1924, some lands were acquired under the Land Acquisition Act. In respect of the lands concerned in Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148 the Collector made his awards and took possession on 16th September 1925, and as regards the lands of Appeal No. 149 he did so on 22nd December 1925. In the awards so made, certain amounts were awarded to the respondents as proprietors of the touzi, and some further amounts were awarded to them for their gantidari interest. The appellant, after his purchase at the revenue sale, applied to the Collector on 3rd October 1925, for a reference praying to be allowed all the amounts so awarded. The Judge, as already indicated, awarded the compensation for the proprietary interest to the appellant and that for the gantidari interest to the respondents.

    2. Some argument has been addressed to us on behalf of the appellant to establish that there was no ganti under touzi No. 188, and that the ganti, that there was, was under the other six touzis or some of them. We think the existence of three annas ganti interest under touzi No. 188 has been established beyond doubt, and indeed its existence was not a matter disputed in the Court below. As regards all the appeals, the substantial contention, urged on behalf of the appellant, is that he is entitled to the entire compensation for the lands, that is to say the amounts awarded both to the proprietors and to the gantidars, because, under Section 28 of the Revenue Sale Law (Act 11 of 1859), his title as purchaser dated back to the date of the default and, as such purchaser, he annulled the ganti at the earliest possible opportunity.

    3. On behalf of the respondents, it has been urged, so far as Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148 are concerned, that, inasmuch as before the sale these lands had been acquired under the Land Acquisition Act and so lost to the touzi, what the appellant purchased was not the touzi, but the touzi minus the acquired lands, and consequently he was not entitled to get either of the amounts awarded as compensation. In the aforesaid appeals as well as in Appeal No. 149, a further argument was advanced on behalf of the respondents, namely, that what was said in the petition of the appellant of 3rd October 1925, was not sufficient to annul the ganti. Now, Section 15 of the Land Acquisition Act, says that

    “in determining the amount of compensation, the Collector shall be guided by the provisions contained in Ss. 23 and 24.”

    4. Under S. 23(1), Cl. 1, the market value at the date of the publication of the declaration under S. 6 has to be taken, and under S. 24, Cl. 7, any outlay, for improvements or disposal since that date, but without the Collector's sanction, is not to be regarded. These sections, however, only lay down rules for determining the market value and do not create any right on the part of the owners of the lands or the holders of interest therein to obtain compensation on the footing of their respective rights as at the date of the declaration. In the case of Surja Kanta Acharjya v. Sarat Chandra Roy . AIR 1914 PC 82, the Judicial Committee observed that, on the failure of an owner to pay the Government assessment, his estate or interest in the land is forfeited, or rather determined, and that, under such a sale, what is sold is not the interest of the defaulting owner, but the interest of the Crown subject to the payment of the Government assessment. The same view has also been expressed by their Lordships in the case of Narayan Das v. Jatindra Nath . AIR 1927 PC 135 And under S. 28 and Sch. A, Revenue Sale Law (Act 11 of 1859), the title of the purchaser is to be deemed to have vested in him on the date of default. But, as observed by their Lordships of the Judicial Committee in the case of Shyam Kumari v. Rameswar Singh . 1904 32 Cal. 27 at p. 39:

    “When the Act is considered as a whole it seems clear that when a sale or purchase is spoken of in connexion with time, the time meant is that at which the sale takes place in fact, not that to which its operation is carried back by relation.”

    5. Also, under Section 16 of the Land Acquisition Act, on the Collector taking possession of land after making an award under S. 11, the land vests absolutely in Government free from all encumbrances. If these propositions are applied to the concrete facts of these cases, the position seems to be the following: So far as the lands of all the four cases are concerned, the respondents' interest as proprietors of the touzi and so of all the lands thereof was forfeited or rather determined on 28th March 1925. The acquired lands of Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148 vested in the Collector free from incumbrances on 16th September 1925, and those of Appeal No. 149 on 22nd December 1925. At the sale, which took place on 18th September 1925, the appellant purchased the interest of the Crown in the lands of the touzi, which were subject to the payment of the Government assessment. By the awards that were made, on 16th September 1925, in the cases, out of which Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148 have arisen, abatement of Government revenue was allowed for the acquired lands from the kist previous to the date of taking possession; and so, at the time of the sale, the said lands were no longer subject to the payment of Government assessment and the capitalized value of the Government revenue due on them had already been realized under the award that had been made. The appellant never purchased the said acquired lands, though, in respect of the lands that he purchased, his title on purchase related I back to the default. In our opinion therefore the appellant cannot be regarded as having acquired any interest, in the lands of Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148 by the purchase that be made. The late proprietors, that is to say, the respondents, were entitled to the surplus of the purchase money under S. 31, Act 11 of 1859 as regards the lands that were sold. They are, in our opinion, the persons also entitled to compensation for what could not be sold, the acquisition having taken place in the meantime. So far as these three appeals are concerned, no question of annulment of the ganti arises, because the appellant never purchased the lands themselves.

    6. As regards Appeal No. 149, the award not having been made for possession taken by the Collector till 22nd December 1925, and the sale having taken place on 18th September 1925, the appellant purchased at the sale the lands which were subsequently acquired. He was therefore clearly entitled to the compensation in respect of the proprietary interest in the lands as lands of the tauzi. On 3rd October 1925, he made the petition, in which he claimed the compensation that was to be awarded for the ganti, and thus signified his intention to annul the ganti. As he did so before the award was made and when the ganti was yet subsisting, though liable to annulment at his option, he was entitled to get the compensation for the land which the award, subsequently made, divided into two parts, one for the proprietary interest and the other for the gantidari interest. His title as proprietor related back to the date of default, but the annulment could only operate from the date it was made the result, in our opinion, is that Appeal No. 149 should be allowed to the extent of 3/16ths of the compensation awarded for the gantidari interest, and Appeals Nos. 146, 147 and 148 being dismissed, the cross-objections therein should be allowed to the extent of the entire amounts claimed. There will be no order for costs in any of these appeals and cross-objections.

    Bartley, J.:— I agree. Appellant bought estate No. 188 at a revenue sale on 18-9-1925. What then passed was the interest of the Crown subject to the payment of revenue, the estate on which the Crown assesses revenue and which can be sold for arrears. This estate has been limited to the land, which is subject to the payment of revenue and in respect of which the proprietor is entered in the general register of revenue paying estates: Narayan Das Khettry v. Jatindra Nath Roy Chowdhury. Now in three of these appeals, there was acquisition on 16th September 1925, two days before appellant bought certain lands of the estate vested absolutely in the Crown, and the interests then existing in these lands were assessed at a money value payable to the respective owners. At the same time an abatement of land revenue was granted. I take the effect of this to have been that, on the one hand, the amount of land subject to the payment of revenue decreased, and on the other, the interest of the Crown diminished, as is evidenced by the fact that the Crown assessed that interest, the land revenue, at a lower figure.

    7. The appellant, who, on 18th September 1925, bought the interest of the Crown, bought something less than had existed before 16th September 1925, the date of the acquisition, though his title to what he bought related back to March. In this view of the matter, appellant is entitled to nothing in respect of the lands acquired on 16th September 1925. In the last case, he took the interest of the Crown, with a right to annul the ganti. If his claim to the value assessed on it in the subsequent land acquisition proceedings is construed as a formal annulment, he gets both sums and I accept this construction.

    M.N

    8. Order accordingly.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Nrishinha Charan Nandi Chaudhuri v. Nagendra Bala Debee And Another
    (Jul 5, 1932)