AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal concerns the legal question of whether a private deed of sale that has been registered qualifies as a public document under Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act, thereby attracting the provisions of Section 77 of the Evidence Act. The case arises from a conflict with a prior Single Bench decision of this Court in Md. Saimuddin v. Abezuddin (AIR 1979 Gau 14), which held that a registered private sale deed is a public record of a private document under Section 74(2). Due to disagreement with this view, the appeal was referred to a larger bench for consideration. The Courts below had also ruled that since the original sale deed was never produced and no foundation was laid for secondary evidence, the certified copy was inadmissible, leading to dismissal of the appeal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a private deed of sale that has been registered is a public document within the meaning of Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act.
  2. Whether such a document attracts the provisions of Section 77 of the Evidence Act, thereby allowing certified copies to be admissible in evidence.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Md. Saimuddin v. Abezuddin, AIR 1979 Gau 14 Held that a private sale deed registered under the Indian Registration Act is a public record of a private document under Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act, making its certified copy admissible under Section 77. The Court overruled this decision, finding that the original registered sale deed is returned to the party and thus not kept as a public record by the Sub-Registrar, so it does not qualify as a public document under Section 74(2).
Gopal Das v. Thakurji, AIR 1943 PC 83 Established that an original receipt executed by an individual and registered under the Registration Act is not a public record of a private document under Section 74(2) because the original must be returned to the party under Section 61(2) of the Registration Act. The Court relied on this Privy Council decision to support the conclusion that a registered private sale deed is not a public document under Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the meaning of "public document" under Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act, emphasizing that "public records" are those which a government entity is legally required to keep or which are necessary to keep in discharge of legal duties. The Court noted that under Section 61(2) of the Indian Registration Act, once a sale deed is registered, the original document is returned to the presenting party or their nominee and is not retained by the Sub-Registrar. Consequently, the Sub-Registrar does not keep the original sale deed as a public record. Therefore, the registered private sale deed cannot be considered a public document within the meaning of Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act. The Court found support for this interpretation in the Privy Council decision of Gopal Das v. Thakurji. Based on this reasoning, the Court rejected the contrary view taken in Md. Saimuddin v. Abezuddin. The Court also noted that the lower courts had correctly held that no foundation was laid for admitting secondary evidence since the original document was never produced, thus rendering the certified copy inadmissible.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is dismissed.

The Court overruled the earlier Single Bench decision in Md. Saimuddin v. Abezuddin, clarifying that a registered private sale deed is not a public document under Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act. Consequently, certified copies of such deeds are not admissible under Section 77 without proper foundation. The direct effect is the dismissal of the appeal for failure to produce the original document or establish admissibility of secondary evidence. No new precedent beyond this clarification was established.

    Shri Narattam Das And Ors. v. Md. Masaddar Ali Barbhuiya And Ors.

    1. In this appeal the only question which arises for consideration is whether a private deed of sale which has been registered is a public document within the meaning of Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act in order to attract section 77 of the Evidence Act.

    2. There is a decision of Single Bench of this Court reported as AIR 1979 Gau 14, Md. Saimuddin v. Abezuddin, in which it has been held that a private sale deed registered under the Indian Registration Act is public record of a private document under section 74(2) and, therefore, the certified copy of it is admissible in evidence under section 77.

    3. As a Single Bench of this Court being unable to agree with the view taken in Saimtddin's case (supra), the appeal has been referred to a larger bench. Hence, before us.

    4. Section 74 reads:

    “Public documents,—The following documents are public document:

    (1) xxx

    (2) public records kept in any state of private documents.”

    5. With regard to the ‘public records’, ‘public records’ are those records which a Government unit is requited by law 10 keep or which is necessary to keep in discharge of duties imposed by law (See Black's Law Dictionary). A “public record” is one required by law to be kept, or necessary to be kept in the discharge of a duty imposed by law, or directed by law to serve as a memorial and evidence of something written, said, or done (See Words and Phrases, Vol. 35). The records means written account of facts, etc. designed or intended to remain as a memorial or permanent evidence of the matters to which it relates, Therefore, a privats document-would be a ‘public record’ within the meaning of section 74(2), if the private document is filed, the public official is required to keep it for a memorial or permanent evidence of something written, said, or done.

    6. In so far as the original sale deed is concerned, after it is registered under the Registration Act, it is not kept in the office of the Sub-Registrar. Under section 61(2) of the Registration Act, as soon as the registration is complete as is provided under the Registration Act, the original sale deed shall be returned to the person who presented the same for registration or his nominee. Therefore, the Sub-Registrar is not required or is called upon to keep the sale deed, at all for any purpose under the law, and as such, the question of a public record of a private document does not arise. For these reasons, a private sale deed which has been registered shall not be public document within the meaning of Section 74(2) of the Evidence Act and, therefore, the provision under section 77 is attracted. This view of our finds support from a decision of the Privy Council in Gopal Das v. Thakurji, AIR 1943 PC 83. In that case, the Privy Council has held that the original receipt executed by any individual and registered under the Registration Act is not “a public record of a private document” within section 74(2) as the original has to be returned to the party under section 61(2) of the Registration Act. We are, therefore, unable with the, view expressed in the decision in Saimuddin v. Abezuddin, AIR 1979 Gau 14.

    7. For the reasons stated above, we overrule the decision of this Court reported as AIR 1979 Gau 14, Md. Saimuddin v. Abezuddin.

    8. The Courts below have held that the original sale deed has not been produced at any time and no foundation has been laid by the plaintiff-appellants for admission of secondary evidence and, therefore, the certified copy of the sale deed is not admissible in evidence. In that visw of the matter, the appeal is dismissed No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Shri Narattam Das And Ors. v. Md. Masaddar Ali Barbhuiya And Ors.
    (Dec 21, 1990)