Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (for short “FEMA”)
  • Section 47, Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
  • Section 6, clause (b) of sub-section (3), Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
  • Government of India's policy (no specific article or section mentioned)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (for short “FEMA”)
  • Section 47, Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
  • Section 6, clause (b) of sub-section (3), Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999
  • Government of India's policy (no specific article or section mentioned)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Mr. Manohar Lal Sharma (appearing in person), filed a writ petition challenging Press Notes Nos. 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 (2012 series) dated 20 September 2012 that reviewed India’s Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) policy in various sectors, including single-brand and multi-brand retail trading. He sought a declaration that the press notes were unconstitutional and issued without authority of law. During the proceedings:

  • The petitioner withdrew his rejoinder-affidavit owing to “objectionable statements”; the Court ordered that the document be excluded from the record.
  • The Attorney General informed the Court on 15 October 2012 that amendments to the Foreign Exchange Management (Transfer or Issue of Security by a Person Resident Outside India) Regulations, 2000 (“2000 Regulations”) were underway.
  • On 5 November 2012, the Attorney General produced the Foreign Exchange Management (Transfer or Issue of Security by a Person Resident Outside India) (Third Amendment) Regulations, 2012 (“2012 Regulations”), published on 30 October 2012, which formally amended the 2000 Regulations pursuant to the new FDI policy.
  • No challenge was made to the 2012 Regulations themselves.
  • Swadeshi Jagaran Foundation intervened in support of the petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Press Notes Nos. 4-8 (2012 series) lack the force of law and are unconstitutional or ultra vires for want of statutory authority and consultation.
  2. Whether the Central Government possesses the competence to formulate and implement an FDI policy permitting up to 51 % foreign investment in multi-brand retail trading.
  3. Whether the impugned FDI policy is arbitrary, irrational, or otherwise violative of the Constitution so as to warrant judicial interference.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The press notes were issued without authority of law and therefore have no legal force.
  • The FDI policy was framed without obtaining material from relevant government agencies and without extensive consultation.
  • Allowing 51 % FDI in multi-brand retail would adversely affect domestic stakeholders.

Intervenor (Swadeshi Jagaran Foundation)

  • Supported the petitioner’s position that the policy lacked adequate consultation and empirical backing.

Respondent (Union of India)

  • Highlighted benefits of FDI in multi-brand retail: increased consumer choice at affordable prices, elimination of middlemen, enlarged market access for producers, employment generation, infrastructure improvement, and better product quality.
  • Cited studies—one commissioned by the World Bank and another by ICRIER (2008)—showing higher farmer profits and coexistence of organised and unorganised retail.
  • Argued that the policy is merely enabling; individual States/Union Territories may choose whether to implement it.
  • Asserted that the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) is competent under the Allocation of Business Rules, 1961 to formulate FDI policy, and that the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) appropriately amended the 2000 Regulations to give the policy statutory footing.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court’s Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by noting the petitioner’s failure to challenge the 2012 Regulations, which incorporated the policy changes into the statutory framework under the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (FEMA). In the absence of such a challenge, the contention that the press notes lacked legal force “does not survive for any scrutiny.”

Addressing the substantive attack on the policy, the Court observed:

  • The impugned policy is “only an enabling policy”; implementation is left to the discretion of individual States and Union Territories, allowing them to account for local conditions.
  • Under the Constitution, formulation of economic policy lies primarily within the executive’s domain. Judicial review of policy is limited to instances where the policy is unconstitutional, contrary to statute, arbitrary, irrational, or abusive of power.
  • The objectives of the policy—to benefit consumers, facilitate market access for producers, and enhance employment—are matters of economic judgment on which reasonable views may differ. Such differences do not authorize judicial intervention.
  • DIPP is expressly empowered to frame FDI policy, and RBI is statutorily authorized to regulate foreign exchange transactions in accordance with that policy. Therefore, the competence of the Central Government and RBI was beyond doubt.
  • The policy did not exhibit any constitutional or statutory infirmity, nor did it appear arbitrary or irrational.

Holding and Implications

Petition Dismissed. The Supreme Court dismissed the writ petition with no order as to costs; all interlocutory applications were also disposed of.

Implications: The decision leaves the 2012 FDI policy intact, confirming the executive’s authority to allow up to 51 % foreign investment in multi-brand retail. States and Union Territories remain free to decide on local implementation. The order sets no new precedent but reinforces the Court’s consistent stance of limited interference in economic policy absent constitutional or statutory violations.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union Of India And Another

    Order

    1. We have heard Mr Manohar Lal Sharma, petitioner-in-person and Mr Goolam E. Vahanvati, learned Attorney General. We have also heard Mr Vikramjit Banerjee, learned counsel for the intervenor, Swadeshi Jagaran Foundation in IA No. 2 of 2012.

    2. Mr Manohar Lal Sharma, petitioner-in-person prays for withdrawal of the rejoinder-affidavit in its entirety in view of the objectionable statements contained therein. We allow him to do so. It is directed that no part of the rejoinder-affidavit shall be treated as part of the record.

    3. In the writ petition, the petitioner has prayed for quashing Press Notes Nos. 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 of (2012 series) dated 20-9-2012 being unconstitutional and without any authority of law. By these press notes, the policy of foreign direct investment (FDI) in single-brand product retail trading, multi-brand retail trading, air transport services, broadcasting carriage services and power exchanges has been reviewed. In the forwarding circular, it is mentioned in Para 5 that necessary amendments to the Foreign Exchange Management (Transfer or Issue of Security by a Person Resident Outside India) Regulations, 2000 (for short “the 2000 Regulations”) are being notified separately.

    4. When the matter came up for consideration on 15-10-2012, the learned Attorney General submitted that the process for necessary amendments to the 2000 Regulations by Reserve Bank of India was on and that necessary amendments in the 2000 Regulations would be made soon.

    5. On 5-11-2012 the learned Attorney General placed for consideration of the Court a copy of the Foreign Exchange Management (Transfer or Issue of Security by a Person Resident Outside India) (Third Amendment) Regulations, 2012 (for short “the 2012 Regulations”) published in the Gazette of India, Extraordinary on 30-10-2012.

    6. By the 2012 Regulations Reserve Bank of India in exercise of the powers conferred by clause (b) of sub-section (3) of Section 6 and Section 47 of the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999 (for short “FEMA”) has made amendments to the 2000 Regulations.

    7. There is no challenge to the 2012 Regulations. In the absence of any challenge to the 2012 Regulations, the contention of the petitioner that Press Notes Nos. 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 (2012 series) dated 20-9-2012 have no force of law, does not survive for any scrutiny.

    8. Be that as it may. We have carefully considered the submissions of the petitioner and the intervenor that the impugned FDI Policy is not founded on any material obtained from the government agency and no extensive consultation was made before formulation of the impugned Policy.

    9. In the counter-affidavit filed by the Union of India, the benefits of FDI in multi-brand retail have been enumerated. The impugned FDI Policy have twin objectives, one, benefit the consumer by enlarging the choice of purchase at more affordable prices; and two, eradicating the traditional trade intermediaries/middlemen to facilitate better access to the market (ultimate retailer) for the producer of goods.

    10. It is stated that the amended FDI Policy will generate employment, improve infrastructure and provide better quality products. The farmers will benefit significantly from the option of direct sales to organised retailers. In this regard, the Central Government has relied upon the study commissioned by the World Bank indicating that profit realisation for farmers selling directly to organised retailers is about 60% higher than that received from selling in the mandi. The views in the study commissioned by the World Bank are said to be supported by the findings of a study instituted by the Government of India on the subject of “Impact of Organised Retailing on the Unorganised Sector” through the Indian Council for Research on International Economic Relations (Icrier) submitted in May 2008. According to Icrier Report, unorganised and organised retail not only co-exist, but also grow substantially in size.

    11. The salient features of the FDI Policy on multi-brand retail trading are also indicated in the counter-affidavit. The Policy mandates at least 30% of the value of procurement of manufactured/processed products purchased shall be sourced from Indian “small industries” which have a total investment in plant and machinery not exceeding US $1.00 million. It also provides that retail sales outlets may be set up only in cities with a population of more than 10 lakhs as per 2011 Census and may also cover an area of 10 km around the municipal/urban agglomeration limits of such cities. In States/Union Territories not having cities with population of more than 10 lakhs as per 2011 Census, retail sales outlets may be set up in the cities of their choice, preferably the largest city and may also cover an area of 10 km around the municipal/urban agglomeration limits of such cities.

    12. We find that the impugned Policy is only an enabling policy and the State Governments/Union Territories are free to take their own decisions in regard to implementation of the policy in keeping with local conditions. It is, thus, left to the choice of the State Governments/Union Territories whether or not to implement the Policy to allow FDI up to 51% in multi-brand retail trading.

    13. The views on the efficacy of a government policy and the objectives such policy seeks to achieve may differ. The counter-view(s) may have some merit but under our Constitution, the executive has been accorded primary responsibility for the formulation of governmental policy. The executive function comprises both the determination of policy as well as carrying it into execution. If the Government of the day after due reflection, consideration and deliberation feels that by allowing FDI up to 51% in multi-brand retail trading, the country's economy will grow and it will facilitate better access to the market for the producer of goods and enhance the employment potential, then in our view, it is not open for the Court to go into the merits and demerits of such policy.

    14. On matters affecting policy, this Court does not interfere unless the policy is unconstitutional or contrary to the statutory provisions or arbitrary or irrational or in abuse of power. The impugned Policy that allows FDI up to 51% in multi-brand retail trading does not appear to suffer from any of these vices.

    15. Notably, the Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion (DIPP) as per the Allocation of Business Rules, 1961 is allocated the subject of “Direct foreign and non-resident investment in industrial and service projects, excluding functions entrusted to the Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs”. Seen thus, the DIPP is empowered to make policy pronouncements on FDI. There is no merit in the submission of the petitioner that the Central Government has no authority or competence to formulate FDI Policy. The competence of the Central Government to formulate a policy relating to investment by a non-resident entity/person resident outside India, in the capital of an Indian company is beyond doubt. Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is empowered to prohibit, restrict or regulate various types of foreign exchange transactions, including FDI, in India by means of necessary regulations. RBI regulates foreign investment in India in accordance with the Government of India's policy.

    16. The writ petition is dismissed with no order as to costs. Interlocutory applications stand disposed of.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Manohar Lal Sharma v. Union Of India And Another
    (May 1, 2013)