Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 65(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), 66(1)(b), 67-1A, 72, 75, 81 and 83 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Sections 65(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), 66(1)(b), 68, 72, 75, 81 and 83 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • IPC and the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Sections 302, 307, 328, 272, 273, 201, 109, 114, 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860
  • 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text)
  • IPC (Indian Penal Code)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 65(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), 66(1)(b), 67-1A, 72, 75, 81 and 83 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Sections 65(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), 66(1)(b), 68, 72, 75, 81 and 83 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • The Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973
  • IPC and the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949
  • Sections 302, 307, 328, 272, 273, 201, 109, 114, 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860
  • 1983 Income Tax Act (not found in the text)
  • IPC (Indian Penal Code)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The decision arises out of three connected special leave petitions concerning the July 2009 “hooch tragedy” in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, in which 147 persons died and 205 sustained severe injuries after consuming spurious country-made liquor laced with methyl alcohol. Two criminal cases were registered—CR No. 252/2009 at Odhav Police Station and CR No. 161/2009 at Kagdapith Police Station—invoking numerous sections of the Indian Penal Code and the Bombay Prohibition Act.

Accused 11, Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar, was denied regular bail by the Gujarat High Court on 10-2-2012. He challenged that refusal before the Supreme Court (SLP (Crl.) No. 3334/2012).

Separately, the High Court had granted bail to Accused 2, Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar, on 29-9-2011 in both FIRs. The State of Gujarat filed two special leave petitions (SLP (Crl.) Nos. 4026 & 4027/2012) seeking cancellation of that bail.

The Supreme Court heard all three matters together and delivered a common judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Accused 11 (Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar) should be enlarged on regular bail pending trial.
  2. Whether the Gujarat High Court erred in granting bail to Accused 2 (Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar) and, if so, whether that bail should be cancelled.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (A-11 – Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar)

  • Contended that there is no material to show he had knowledge of the liquor’s poisonous nature; at most, the case falls under Section 304 IPC, not Section 302.
  • Invoked the principle of parity, asserting that co-accused with similar or graver roles had already been granted bail.

Respondent (State of Gujarat – in Appeal of A-11)

  • Emphasised appellant’s role as a principal conspirator in manufacturing and distributing spurious liquor.
  • Highlighted that he is a “habitual offender” facing more than 20 cases and may threaten witnesses or re-offend if released.

Appellant (State of Gujarat – in Appeals against A-2)

  • Asserted that A-2 supplied large quantities of ethyl/methyl alcohol, fully aware of its toxicity, thereby participating in the criminal conspiracy.
  • Pointed to seven witness statements and forensic reports confirming presence of methanol and ethanol.
  • Submitted that A-2 is a habitual offender with 22 pending cases and committed further offences while on temporary bail.

The opinion does not record any arguments advanced by Accused 2 in defence.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

Regarding Accused 11 (Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar)

  • The charge-sheet and witness statements show he was not a mere supplier but an active conspirator who procured methyl alcohol, arranged transportation, and continued selling the liquor even after fatalities emerged.
  • His criminal history and risk of tampering with evidence or threatening witnesses weigh against bail.
  • Parity was denied: (i) Bail to Accused 2 is under challenge by the State; (ii) Bail to Accused 27 was on distinct grounds (she is a woman) and therefore not comparable.
  • The grave societal impact—147 deaths in a prohibition State—justifies withholding bail despite three years of pre-trial custody.

Regarding Accused 2 (Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar)

  • Supplied hazardous chemicals knowing their lethal potential, thereby facilitating manufacture of poisonous liquor.
  • High Court’s view that his nephew managed the business and that he had sold his petrol pump was deemed a “casual” assessment insufficient to negate conspiracy.
  • His continued criminal activity while on bail and 22 pending cases confirm he is a habitual offender.
  • Given the magnitude of loss of life, the Court found the High Court erred in concluding absence of mens rea and in granting bail.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSITION: The appeal of Accused 11 is dismissed; bail remains refused. The State’s appeals are allowed; bail granted to Accused 2 is cancelled, and he must surrender within two weeks.

Implications: The ruling keeps both principal accused in custody and directs the trial court to conduct proceedings on a day-to-day basis, with liberty to move for bail only if the trial exceeds one year. The judgment reinforces a stringent stance on offences involving spurious liquor, especially in jurisdictions with prohibition, but sets no new legal precedent beyond the facts of the case.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Ravindersingh Alias Ravi Pavar v. State Of Gujarat .

    P. Sathasivam, J.— Leave granted in all the special leave petitions. Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar has preferred appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 3334 of 2012 before this Court against the final judgment and order dated 10-2-2012 passed by the High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad in Ravindrasingh v. State of Gujarat whereby the High Court dismissed his application filed under Section 439 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in short “the Code”) seeking regular bail in CR No. 252 of 2009 registered with Odhav Police Station, Ahmedabad for the offences punishable under Sections 302, 307, 328, 272, 273, 201, 109, 114, 120-B of the Penal Code, 1860 (“IPC”, for short) and Sections 65(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), 66(1)(b), 67-1A, 72, 75, 81 and 83 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949.

    2. The State of Gujarat, aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 29-9-2011, passed by the High Court in Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar v. State of Gujarat whereby the High Court enlarged one Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar (A-2) on bail in connection with CR No. 161 of 2009 registered with Kagdapith Police Station, Ahmedabad for the offences punishable under Sections 120-B, 302, 307, 328, 272, 273, 201, 217, 221, 109 and 114 IPC and Sections 65(a), (b), (c), (d), (e), 66(1)(b), 68, 72, 75, 81 and 83 of the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949 and CR No. 252 of 2009 registered with Odhav Police Station, Ahmedabad for the very same offences, has filed the other two appeals arising out of Special Leave Petitions Nos. 4026 and 4027 of 2012.

    3. Since the subject-matter of all the three appeals is one and the same, they are being disposed of by this common judgment.

    SLP (Criminal) No. 3334 of 2012

    4. The case relates to the hooch tragedy which resulted into the death of 147 persons and serious physical injuries to 205 others after consuming spurious country-made liquor consisting poisonous chemical methyl alcohol in different parts of Ahmedabad City, Gujarat, in July 2009 for which case has been registered against several accused persons under various sections of IPC and the Bombay Prevention Act, 1949 with Odhav and Kagdapith Police Stations vide CRs Nos. 252 and 161 of 2009 respectively.

    5. The charge framed against Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar (Accused 11) is that he was a party to a meeting held with other accused persons prior to the date of the incident wherein they conspired to manufacture and distribute country-made liquor consisting poisonous chemical methyl alcohol, in order to gain financial benefit, by selling the same due to its low cost. The charge-sheet further proceeds that as a part of criminal conspiracy, he along with other accused, agreed to manufacture and distribute/sell such liquor to suppliers in spite of the knowledge that on consumption of the same, it can cause death or severe physical damage/injury to the consumer.

    6. When the appellant-accused moved an application under Section 439 of the Code in connection with CR No. 252 of 2009, before the High Court, on going into the specific allegations against him, his role and involvement in the hooch tragedy which resulted into more than 147 deaths in the city of Ahmedabad and after satisfying prima facie case as well as considering the gravity of the crime punishable under Section 302, etc. the High Court rejected his third successive bail application.

    7. Mr K.T.S Tulsi, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant, after taking us through the allegations in the charge-sheet and connected materials submitted that in the absence of any material that the appellant had any knowledge that illicit liquor was poisonous or that he had any intention to cause the death of the deceased persons at the most it is the case under Section 304 IPC and not under Section 302 IPC. He further submitted that the High Court failed to consider that the co-accused, alleged to be having similar role as that of the appellant as well as those accused allegedly having graver role, have already been granted bail and, therefore, on the ground of parity also, the appellant-accused deserves to be enlarged on bail on the same terms and conditions.

    8. Ms Hemantika Wahi, learned counsel appearing for the State, by taking us through the allegations mentioned in the charge-sheet, statement of witnesses and the gravity of the offence submitted that in view of the appellant's association with the main accused, namely, Vinod alias Dagri (A-1) and also taking note of the fact that he is a “habitual offender” involved in many similar offences, it is not desirable to enlarge him on bail and according to her, the High Court was fully justified in dismissing his bail application.

    9. We have carefully considered the allegations, materials placed, gravity of the offence, etc. in detail.

    10. Normally, while considering the application for bail, it is not necessary for the court to assess the materials placed by either side, to discuss and arrive at a definite conclusion. However, taking note of the gravity of the offence, we have no other option except to deal with those aspects confining to the disposal of the bail application.

    11. The charge-sheet (Annexure P-3) filed along with the special leave petition gives the details of involvement/role played by the accused persons. The role of the present appellant (A-11) reads as under:

    “Accused 11 Ravindersingh alias Ravi s/o Jayramsingh Pavar mentioned in Column 1 who was doing the business of country and foreign liquor with his partners, Column 1 Accused 29 and 30 and having the criminal history and remaining in contact with Accused 1 for obtaining cheap country liquor having methyl alcohol made the partnership with Accused 1 and obtained county liquor having methyl alcohol from Accused 1 and in spite of being aware of the fact that it caused physical harm which cause caused death of the persons brought it from Vanthvadi Village on 6-7-2009 through his persons, Accused 32 and 33 and sold it on cheap rates to Column 1 Accused 27, 28 and 31 and Column 2 Accused 1 and 2 and also selling it at his own liquor stand place situated in Bapunagar area behind General Hospital through his persons and on drinking caused the death of the persons and also causing the serious injuries to the people fulfilled the criminal conspiracy and on 6-7-2009 lots of people died in Ahmedabad City drinking the poisonous liquor and admitted into the hospitals and in spite of knowing the said facts continued to sell the poisonous country liquor, committed the serious nature offence and thereafter disposed off the evidence had disposed off the chemicalised poisonous liquor which is in his possession.”

    12. Mr Tulsi, learned Senior Counsel for the appellant-accused has contended that the only allegation against him is that he has simply sold the country-made liquor and prima facie no case is being made out against him for manufacturing spurious liquor and, therefore, he cannot be charged under Sections 302, 307 and 328 IPC. On going through the entire materials, we are unable to accept the same.

    13. The materials placed by the prosecution show that the appellant was not just a supplier of alcohol but was one of the main conspirators along with Vinod alias Dagri (A-1) in the manufacture of spurious alcohol along with other co-accused. It is the case of the prosecution as established by the statement of witnesses that the appellant, along with main accused, with a view to earn easy money, hatched a conspiracy for manufacturing spurious alcohol from methyl alcohol, very well knowing that it is poisonous and can cause death or severe physical damage/injury on consumption. The statements of various persons relied on by the prosecution support the above stand. The investigation further revealed that on the next day of the hooch tragedy in July 2009, the appellant and his two associates had gone to one Farzana Banu to sell the huge stock of spurious liquor, since the premises of the appellant was raided by the police.

    14. A perusal of the reasoning of the High Court as well as the materials placed by the prosecution prima facie establish that the appellant was not a mere supplier of spurious alcohol but he was involved in the criminal conspiracy of manufacturing spurious liquor along with the main co-accused Vinod alias Dagri (A-1) and selling the same at various places through his men. The statements of various persons including one Dahiben support the greater role played by the appellant-accused.

    15. Mr Tulsi, learned Senior Counsel has also claimed parity with the co-accused Jayesh Hiralal Thakker (A-2), who has been granted bail by the High Court, vide order dated 29-9-2011, in the similar offence and claimed similar order in respect of the present appellant Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar. He also brought to our notice that bail has been granted to one Minaben (A-27) on 20-7-2011 and the State has not filed any special leave petition before this Court. As far as grant of bail to Jayesh Hiralal Thakker is concerned, the State has filed Special Leave Petitions (Criminal) Nos. 4026 and 4027 of 2012, which we are going to consider after the conclusion of the present appeal. Hence, the appellant cannot claim parity with the co-accused Jayesh Hiralal Thakker. Insofar as the order granting bail to A-27 is concerned, we were taken through the reasons appended to her bail application and also of the fact that she being a lady, we are of the view that the appellant cannot claim parity with the said accused in claiming bail.

    16. Apart from the above materials, the learned counsel for the State has also brought to our notice that the appellant is a “habitual offender” and is facing more than 20 cases including similar cases under the various provisions of IPC and the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949. It is further pointed out that there is every likelihood that if the appellant-accused is released on bail, he would threaten the witnesses and again indulge in sale of spurious liquor.

    17. It is a well-known fact that methanol is a poisonous substance and by adding the same while manufacturing spurious alcohol, it can have devastating results and can cause death or severe damage to health or injuries to anyone who consumes it. Further, such type of offences, as in the case on hand, are against the society at large and who commit the same do not deserve any leniency, particularly, in the State of Gujarat where complete prohibition is being followed. Merely because the appellant-accused had spent three years as an undertrial prisoner, taking note of the gravity of the offence, he is not entitled for bail. As observed earlier, in view of the gravity of the offence, death of a number of persons, injury to several others and the impact on the society as a whole, we hold that the appellant is not at all entitled to bail at this stage and the High Court has rightly denied his application for bail, consequently, the appeal of the accused fails and the same is dismissed.

    Appeals filed by the State

    SLPs (Criminal) Nos. 4026 and 4027 of 2012

    18. The abovementioned appeals have been preferred by the State wherein the respondent Jayesh Hiralal Thakker (A-2) is an accused in CR No. 161 of 2009 registered with Kagdapith Police Station, Ahmedabad and CR No. 252 of 2009 registered with Odhav Police Station, Ahmedabad and in both the cases, he has been charged under various sections of IPC and the Bombay Prohibition Act, 1949, as mentioned earlier and was granted bail by the High Court.

    19. The respondent is Accused 2 in CR No. 252 of 2009 and CR No. 161 of 2009 registered at Odhav and Kagdapith Police Stations respectively wherein total of 147 persons died and 205 persons were seriously injured after consuming spurious liquor prepared from chemicals like ethanol and methanol, which were supplied by the respondent-accused, who was trading in those hazardous chemicals, to Vinod alias Dagri (A-1) for the preparation of country-made liquor. It is highlighted by the prosecution that during the course of investigation, it was revealed that the respondent (A-2) is a prime conspirator and had indulged in supplying methyl alcohol for manufacturing country-made liquor. According to the prosecution, the statements recorded from seven witnesses reveal about the involvement of the respondent. It is also projected by the prosecution that one of the witnesses stated that near the petrol pump at Mogar, there is a godown and two barrels were put in his vehicle to be delivered to A-1, who was the mastermind in preparation of country-made liquor out of methyl alcohol, supplied by A-2 at Village Vanthwadi. It is also their case that the respondent (A-2) had purchased about 500-600 plastic and iron barrels as per his requirement and again in the month of July, he purchased 70 more barrels. The prosecution has also projected that A-2 had sufficient knowledge about the properties of methyl alcohol and that it is poisonous to use in the preparation of country liquor. Despite this, the respondent used to obtain the same illegally from the tankers coming from Kutch and Mumbai through the absconding co-accused and kept the same in his custody without permit and supplied it to Vinod alias Dagri (A-1) for the preparation of liquor. All these particulars form part of the charge-sheet filed on 5-9-2009.

    20. The specific allegations in the charge-sheet about the respondent (A-2) are as under:

    “Accused 2 Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar stated in Column 1 having the criminal antecedents who is running illegal business of chemicals at the godown situated at the petrol pump located at Village Mogar, in company of the Accused 3 named in Column 1 and through Accused 3, 4 and 5 mentioned in Column 2 had illegally obtained the poisonous methyl alcohol from the tankers coming from Bombay and Kutch, possessed the same without any pass or permit, and in spite of having knowledge regarding poisonousness of methyl alcohol and that it is to be used in preparing liquor Accused 4, 5, 6, 7 and 8 had sold the poisonous methyl alcohol to Accused 1 for manufacturing degenerated poisonous country liquor and thereby have played active role in the conspiracy with the view to earn monetary profit and after the declaration of hooch tragedy disposed of the methyl alcohol within their possession and had gone on run and thereby have committed serious offence.”

    21. The information furnished by the prosecution clearly shows that in a State having complete prohibition policy, the supply of raw material for liquor, its production and distribution are illegal. It is also demonstrated that the respondent (A-2) has illegally supplied poisonous chemicals like ethyl and methyl alcohol to A-1 for the manufacture of country-made liquor. It is not in dispute that if anyone consumes liquor manufactured out of ethyl/methyl alcohol, it would have a very adverse effect on the body and can cause death or bodily injury as is likely to cause death. In spite of the abundant materials placed by the prosecution and even after taking note of the fact that the samples sent to the forensic science laboratory (FSL) for analysis confirmed the presence of methanol and ethanol and also of the fact that A-2 has supplied those materials to A-1, the claim that he had no knowledge about all these aspects is unacceptable. Though the learned Single Judge of the High Court perused and verified the expert opinion of the medical officer, the FSL report and noted that poisonous chemical is found, after casually finding that there is no “meeting of mind” and “agreement for criminal conspiracy” accepted the case of A-2 and enlarged him on bail.

    22. The other reason given by the High Court is that the whole transaction in the said business of A-2 was looked after by his nephew and in view of the fact that he has already disposed of the petrol pump, concluded that prima facie ingredients of Sections 299 and 300(4) IPC would not attract and enlarged him on bail after imposing certain conditions.

    23. We have already noted that because of the conduct of A-2 in supplying ethanol and methanol to A-1 for preparation of spurious liquor, several casualties and injuries were resulted and in view of the acceptable materials, we are unable to accept the reasoning of the High Court. We are constrained to observe that the High Court, in a casual way, has concluded that since his business was looked after by his nephew and he also disposed of his petrol pump, A-2 cannot be blamed, which according to us, is not a valid ground for enlarging him on bail.

    24. In Para 5 of the rejoinder-affidavit, the State has highlighted that A-2 is a “habitual offender” and there are 22 cases pending against him in various police stations. It is also mentioned in the counter-affidavit that during the period while he was granted temporary bail by the High Court, he indulged in an offence of theft and a case was registered against him vide ICR No. 92 of 2011 under Section 379 IPC by Vasad Police Station for which he was arrested on 10-8-2011 and later enlarged on bail. It is also brought to our notice that the respondent (A-2), while on regular bail, was arrested on 13-9-2012 in Vadodara City in connection with Javaharnagar Police Station crime registered vide ICR No. 94 of 2012 under Sections 407, 408 and 120-B and later on he was released on bail.

    25. Taking note of all these aspects, his antecedents, the gravity and nature of offence, loss of human lives, the impact on the social fabric of the society and his continuous involvement in criminal activities while on bail, we are satisfied that the respondent (A-2) does not deserve to continue to remain on bail.

    26. In a State having prohibition policy, supply of raw material for liquor, its production and distribution are illegal and A-2 has supplied those poisonous chemicals such as ethyl and methyl alcohol to A-1 for the manufacture of spurious country-made liquor. It is a matter of common knowledge that if anyone consumes liquor manufactured out of ethyl/methyl alcohol, it would have very adverse effect on the body which can cause death or bodily injury as is likely to cause death.

    27. Under these circumstances, considering the nature of the offence and the manner in which A-2 supplied those poisonous chemicals despite having full knowledge about its consequences, we are satisfied that the respondent (A-2) does not deserve liberty of remaining on bail. Accordingly, the judgment and order dated 29-9-2011 passed by the High Court in Jayesh Hiralal Thakkar v. State of Gujarat is set aside. The respondent (A-2) is directed to surrender before the court concerned within a period of two weeks from today, failing which, necessary steps be taken for his arrest in order to put him in jail.

    28. It is unfortunate to note that in a State like Gujarat, which strictly prohibits the use of alcohol in any form whatsoever, the accused caused death and injuries to several persons by supplying spurious country-made liquor. Taking a serious view of the matter, the complexity of the crime, the role played by the accused persons as well as the number of casualties, we are of the view that it is not a fit case for grant of bail.

    29. In the light of the above discussion, the appeal of the accused Ravinder Singh alias Ravi Pavar is dismissed. We direct the trial Judge to proceed with the trial on day-to-day basis avoiding unnecessary adjournments. It is made clear that if the trial continues beyond one year from today, they are free to file fresh application before the trial court. In that event, it is for the court concerned to dispose of the bail application on merits. It is made clear that whatever observations made above are only for the purpose of disposal of the bail application. It is for the trial court to decide on the basis of the materials placed before it in accordance with law.

    30. The appeal of Ravindersingh alias Ravi Pavar (A-11) is dismissed and the appeals filed by the State are allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Ravindersingh Alias Ravi Pavar v. State Of Gujarat .
    (Feb 22, 2013)