The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
F.M Ibrahim Kalifulla, J.— The first accused is the appellant. The challenge is to the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court of Rajasthan at Jodhpur dated 16-2-2005 passed in Shanti Devi v. State Criminal Appeal No. 517 of 2002. Altogether four accused were involved in the crime. The trial court convicted the appellant for the offences under Sections 302 and 201 IPC while the other three accused were found guilty for the offence under Section 201 IPC alone. The appellant was imposed with the punishment of sentence for life for the offence under Section 302 IPC apart from a fine of Rs 100 and in default thereof further one month's rigorous imprisonment, for the offence under Section 201 IPC the appellant was imposed with the rigorous imprisonment for five years along with the fine of Rs 100 and in default of the payment of fine to undergo one more month's rigorous imprisonment. The other three accused were awarded rigorous imprisonment for five years each and a fine of Rs 100 and in default of the payment of fine to undergo further period of rigorous imprisonment for one month. The sentences awarded against the appellants were directed to run concurrently.
2. The Division Bench while upholding the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant for the offence under Section 302 IPC modified the punishment so far as it related to be one under Section 201 IPC to the effect that the period already undergone would be sufficient in the interest of justice. Similarly, in respect of other three accused also while confirming the conviction against them under Section 201 IPC, the substantive sentence was modified to be one which was already undergone by them. Aggrieved against the same appellant preferred this appeal.
3. Shorn of unnecessary details, the case of the prosecution as projected before the sessions trial was that the father of PW 2 went to the house of the appellant on 22-8-1997, that he had a sum of Rs 300 with him on that day, that he frequently used to visit the house of the appellant and that the appellant used to call him as her brother. According to PW 2, after his father, the deceased Om Prakash went to the house of the appellant on 22-8-1997 he did not return back. PW 2 went to the house of the appellant thrice and the appellant informed him that his father, the deceased, was entangled in a case of charas and that she is taking every effort to get him released. Subsequently, on 1-9-1997 the postman delivered a letter in his house which was purportedly in the handwriting of Accused 3 (A-3), the son of the appellant, and that on that very day the appellant visited the residence of PW 2 and asked for a sum of Rs 5000 stating that the money was required in order to enable her to get his father released from the criminal complaint. Believing her words PW 2 stated to have borrowed a sum of Rs 5000 from PW 13, Tersem Ram and gave it to her.
4. In the abovestated background PW 2 lodged a complaint with Gharsana Police Station which was registered as FIR No. 535 of 1997 under Ext. P-2. PW 20, the investigating officer, arrested the appellant and three accused persons, namely, Maniram, Shankar Lal and Jagdish. Based on the admissible portion of the said statement of the appellant the body of the deceased Om Prakash was recovered from a place near her house. The body was found buried in that place. Post-mortem was conducted on the dead body. Two photographs were also seized during the course of investigation. The handwriting of A-3, Jagdish was compared. Based on the final report, charges were framed against the appellant and other accused for the offences under Section 302 IPC read with Sections 302/120-B, 364, 364/120-B and 201 IPC. The accused having denied the charges, the case went into trial and 24 witnesses were examined on the side of the prosecution apart from 50 documents marked and 14 articles were produced. On the side of the defence one witness was examined and eight documents were marked.
5. The trial court after detailed consideration of both oral and documentary evidence as well as after noting the chain of circumstances alleged against the appellant and other accused, held that the offences under Section 302 read with Section 201 IPC as against the appellant and the offence under Section 201 IPC as against the rest of the accused were conclusively proved. Consequently, the sentences as described in the earlier part of the judgment were imposed. The appellants preferred an appeal before the High Court of Rajasthan at Jodhpur in which the impugned judgment Criminal Appeal No. 517 of 2002 came to be delivered as against which the appellant has come forward with this appeal.
6. We have heard Mr Ravindra Bana, learned counsel for the appellant and Dr Manish Singhvi, learned Additional Advocate General for the respondent State.
7. Mr Bana in his submissions contended that there was inordinate delay of 52 days in the registration of FIR and, therefore, the story of the prosecution was unbelievable. The learned counsel then contended that the post-mortem report has not mentioned the cause of death and, therefore, death cannot be held to be one of murder. By referring to the alleged extra-judicial confession stated to have been made by the appellant, the learned counsel contended that the appellant stated to have used a kassi but the post-mortem report did not reveal any injury on the body of the deceased and that no blood was also found on the kassi. It was also contended that the body of the deceased was exhumed only from a nearby place and not from the house of the appellant. The learned counsel, therefore, contended that in a case of circumstantial evidence, having regard to the above infirmities existing in the case of the prosecution, the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant should be set aside.
8. As against the above submissions, Dr Singhvi, learned Additional Advocate General by referring to Sections 24, 30 and 133 of the Evidence Act contented that so far as the extra-judicial confession is concerned, so long as the said piece of material was corroborated with material evidence and it was voluntary and truthful it can be relied upon. As far as the corroboration was concerned, the learned Additional Advocate General referred to the recovery of the dead body based on the disclosure statement of the appellant which is fully governed by Section 27 of the Evidence Act. He also contended that the version of PW 24, SDM was that she was present throughout the process of exhuming the body of the deceased along with two independent witnesses, namely, PWs 6 and 11 and also that the body was exhumed from a place adjacent to the house of the appellant which piece of evidence was clinching as against the accused.
9. The learned Additional Advocate General also pointed out that on the body of the deceased the articles which were worn by him such as a wristwatch, shoes, etc. were recovered and those articles were identified by PW 2, the son of the deceased. He also contended that though no blood was found on the kassi, Injury 2 to a great extent would confirm the use of kassi in the performance of the crime by the appellant. Apart from the above, the learned counsel contended that the conduct of the appellant after 1-9-1997 and her dealing with PW 2 as well as the letter written by PW 7 were all corroborative piece of evidence strongly supporting the chain of circumstances in establishing the offence alleged against the appellant. Though the extra-judicial confession made by the appellant was relied upon by the courts below, the learned Additional Advocate General, however, submitted that the said part of the evidence was referred to only to confirm the motive which was twofold, namely, the demand for repayment of Rs 15,000 paid by the deceased apart from the alleged illicit relationship of the appellant with the fourth accused. The learned counsel relied upon Ratan Gond v. State of Bihar AIR 1959 SC 18, 1959 Cri LJ 108 and Wakil Nayak v. State of Bihar (1971) 3 SCC 778 in support of his submissions.
10*. Having heard the learned counsel for the respective parties and having bestowed our serious consideration to the judgment impugned Criminal Appeal No. 517 of 2002 before us and other material papers, as it is a case of circumstantial evidence, we wish to quote the well-settled principles laid down by this Court in various decisions which are to be applied in order to examine the conclusions arrived at by the courts below while convicting the accused based on circumstantial evidence. The principles laid down in those decisions can be mentioned before finding out whether or not the conviction and sentence on the appellant can be held to have been established as stated in the judgment of the High Court as well as that of the learned trial court. The principles can be set out as under:
10.1 The circumstances from which an inference of guilt is sought to be proved must be cogently or firmly established.
10.2 The circumstances should be of a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused.
10.3 The circumstances taken cumulatively must form a chain so complete that there is no escape from the conclusion that within all human probability, the crime was committed by the accused and none else.
10.4 The circumstantial evidence in order to sustain conviction must be complete and incapable of explanation of any other hypothesis than that of the guilt of the accused and such evidence should not only be consistent with the guilt of the accused but should be inconsistent with his innocence.
11. Keeping the above tests in mind when the circumstances enumerated in the case on hand as against the appellant are examined, we find the following circumstances existing as against the appellant:
(i) The deceased Om Prakash went to the house of the appellant on 22-8-1997 when he was last seen.
(ii) The deceased did not return back to his house even after a week's time.
(iii) When the son of the deceased, namely, PW 2 approached the appellant to find out his father's whereabouts he was told by the appellant that his father was involved in the case of charas and that she is taking efforts to get him released.
(iv) On 1-9-1997 the appellant herself approached PW 2 and asked for a sum of Rs 5000 in order to enable her to get his father released from the criminal case.
(v) PW 13 Tersem Ram deposed that the said sum of Rs 5000 was borrowed from him by PW 2 which was paid to the appellant.
(vi) On 1-9-1997 Ext. P-19, letter was delivered in the house of the deceased purportedly to have been written by the deceased himself mentioning that he was entangled in the case of charas and was lodged in Bikaner Police Station. In the said letter it was also mentioned that the said information should not be revealed to his own brothers and that he was likely to get released very soon.
(vii) The address on Ext. P-19 was found to be in the handwriting of A-3 which was also established by legal evidence. The trial court also found as a matter of fact that the letter was got written by the appellant while the address was written by the co-accused, namely, A-3.
(viii) Based on the information furnished by the appellant herself the body of the deceased was recovered from a place which was adjacent to her house.
(ix) The body was identified by PW 2 in the presence of PW 24 SDM, Anoopgarh on which the personal articles worn by him such as shoes, watch, bag, etc. were also found and recovered.
(x) The last of the circumstance was the extra-judicial confession of the appellant before the members of the panchayat, namely, PW 8 and PW 9.
12. When the above circumstances placed before the trial court are considered and the various tests relating to the circumstantial evidence were applied there can be no difficulty in holding that the chain of circumstances had every definite link, namely, from the date the deceased was stated to have gone to the residence of the appellant and, thereafter, when his death was discovered based on the information furnished by the appellant herself pursuant to which the body of the deceased was recovered from a place which was adjacent to her house.
13. In between 22-8-1997 and the date of recovery of the body of the deceased, the appellant met PW 2 once at her residence and, thereafter, the appellant herself approached PW 2 asking for a sum of Rs 5000 to enable her to get his father released from the criminal case.
14. After 22-8-1997, having been known that the deceased had gone to the residence of the appellant and since he did not return back for about seven days, PW 2 in the natural course of events had gone to the residence of the appellant to find out his whereabouts. This particular fact was spoken to by PW 1, the wife of the deceased and PW 2, the son of the deceased. The trial court has noted that the said version of PW 1 and PW 2 was not in any manner dislodged at the instance of the appellant.
15. PW 2 was a minor, aged about 14 years. Therefore, when the appellant, who was known to his father who was frequently visiting her, informed him that his father was involved in a criminal case relating to charas, believing her words PW 2 returned back with the fond hope that the appellant would take every effort to get his father released from the custody of the police. Not stopping with that the appellant herself approached PW 2 on 1-9-1997 with a demand for payment of Rs 5000 for the purpose of getting his father released from the criminal case. The sequence of events narrated by PW 2 as from 22-8-1997 till the demand of Rs 5000 was cogent and convincing.
16. The further fact that PW 2 in his anxiety to get his father released, succumbed to the demand of the appellant by raising funds for the payment of Rs 5000 by borrowing the same from PW 13 who supported the said fact by deposing before the court. The court has noted that his testimony was perfect in every respect and nothing could be brought out in the cross-examination to discredit his version. According to PW 13, the sum of Rs 5000 borrowed by PW 2 from him was handed over to the appellant. When the said circumstance was found proved and since there was no other explanation other than what was demonstrated before the court by the prosecution through PW 2 and PW 13, the said circumstance was in addition to the earlier set of circumstances which linked the involvement of the appellant in the crime alleged against her.
17. The subsequent factum of recovery of the body of the deceased at the instance of the appellant was one other strong circumstance against the appellant in roping her involvement in the elimination of the deceased and thereby providing no scope for any other hypothesis other than her guilt in the killing of the deceased. The other recoveries made from the body of the deceased duly identified by PW 2 was yet another relevant circumstance to show that the deceased was none other than the father of PW 2 and husband of PW 1.
18. Therefore, the analysis of the above circumstances alleged and found proved definitely formed a chain of circumstances having been closely linked together without giving any scope for any other conclusion than a definite tendency unerringly pointing towards the guilt of the accused.
19. When we consider the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, according to the learned counsel there was inordinate delay of 52 days in the registration of the FIR and, therefore, the story of the prosecution was unbelievable.
20. It is true that between 22-8-1997 and the date of the registration of the crime, there was a considerable delay. However, after the deceased went to the house of the appellant i.e on 22-8-1997 which happened to be his usual routine as spoken to by the prosecution witnesses in particular PW 1 and PW 2, no fault can be found in the conduct of PW 1 and PW 2 in having waited for a minimum period of a week for the deceased to return back. Thereafter, as rightly observed by the courts below, it was the game plan of the appellant in having misdirected PW 1 and PW 2, whereby believing her words that the deceased was involved in a criminal case relating to charas they were waiting for his arrival, as informed to them by the appellant.
21. It was quite natural that the wife of the deceased, PW 1 who was dependent on her minor son, PW 2, aged about 14 years was waiting in the fond hope that her husband would have been involved in the criminal case that too relating to charas, it would take some time for him to get out of the clutches of the police. PW 2 was also in a similar state of mind especially when the appellant was further reinforcing her misdirection by collecting a sum of Rs 5000 in order to enable her to get the deceased released from the police.
22. That apart, the appellant hatched a scheme of sending a letter by post as though the deceased himself was communicating to his wife and son to the effect that he got entangled in a criminal case relating to charas, that the same should not be revealed even to his own brothers and that he will be able to get himself released from the said case at the earliest possible time which was truthfully believed by PWs 1 and 2 whose innocence was fully encashed by the appellant.
23. A cumulative effect of the above factors definitely influenced the minds of PW 1 and PW 2 which resulted in reporting of the fact of missing of the deceased to the police belatedly. At one point of time they also approached the panchayat members, namely, PW 8 and PW 9 and sought for their guidance as to how they can find out the whereabouts of the deceased. Therefore, when PW 8 and PW 9 intervened and directly approached the appellant herself the game plan of the appellant came to light and, thereafter, complaint was preferred by PW 2 on 13-10-1997 which resulted in the registration of the FIR, Ext. P-2. Having regard to the above factors, we find no substance in the submission made on behalf of the appellant based on the delay aspect.
24. The learned counsel for the appellant then contended that the post-mortem report did not specify the cause of death and, therefore, it was not a case of murder. As far as the said contention is concerned, based on the information furnished by the appellant herself which was recorded under Ext. P-36, the dead body of the deceased Om Prakash was exhumed under Ext. P-30 in the presence of PW 24 SDM as well as the appellant herself who identified the place where the dead body was buried. The said place was excavated and a bundle was taken out which contained the dead body over which a white shirt and pyjamas was found. The appellant herself confirmed that it was the body of the deceased Om Prakash. The watch worn by the deceased was found on the hand of the dead body which was in a decomposed condition as noted in Ext. P-13.
25. PW 6, Kishan Lal, an independent eyewitness confirmed the digging and the excavation made from where the dead body was exhumed. Apart from the watch, a pair of shoes was also recovered under Ext. P-16. PW 11, another independent eyewitness, also confirmed the above factum and recovery of the dead body at the instance of the appellant. Ext. P-29 was the post-mortem report prepared by PW 16, Dr Om Prakash Mahayach along with PW 17, Dr Sunil Kumar Kaushik and PW 18, Dr Chander Bhan Midha. The articles which were recovered along with the dead body, namely, wristwatch, a pair of shoes, shirt, pyjamas and empty bag were all identified by PW 2, the son of the deceased. In the opinion of PW 16, the post-mortem doctor, the death could be a murder as well as natural. Therefore, it is not, as if based on the post-mortem certificate and the version of PW 16, the offence of murder can be ruled out. Since the dead body was recovered in a decomposed state, it was quite natural that the doctor could not specifically state as to the nature of injury on the body of the deceased.
26. Having regard to the clinching circumstances found proved against the appellant with the ultimate discovery of the body of the deceased at the instance of the appellant herself, who had the exclusive knowledge on that special factor, if the death of the deceased was due to any other cause the best person who could have explained could have been the appellant alone. In the circumstances, the conclusion was inescapable that the appellant was squarely responsible for the death of the deceased and the contention to the contrary made on behalf of the appellant cannot, therefore, be countenanced.
27. The learned counsel raised a contention that by the own version of PW 8 and PW 9, to whom the appellant stated to have made the extra-judicial confession, pressure was applied on her which forced her to make the said statement and, therefore, the same was hit by Section 24 of the Evidence Act. Though the said submission of the learned counsel has been satisfactorily dealt with by the courts below in particular in the order impugned in this criminal appeal even by ignoring the said aspect for the present, as we have found that the chain of circumstances established in the case on hand sufficiently established the guilt of the appellant in the killing of the deceased, we do not find the said submission causing any dent in the case of the prosecution. For the very same reason the submission that no blood was found on the kassi, also does not merit acceptance.
28. The last submission made was that the body of the deceased was only recovered from an adjacent place not from the house of the appellant herself, we do not find any substance in the said submission in order to interfere with the impugned judgment. The very fact that the recovery of the dead body came to be made at the instance of the appellant and that too from a place adjacent to the residence of the appellant was sufficient enough to rope in the appellant in the murder of the deceased.
29. Having regard to our above conclusions, we do not find any merit in this appeal, the appeal fails and the same is dismissed.
30. The appellant is on bail. The bail bond stands cancelled and she shall be taken into custody forthwith to serve out the remaining part of the sentence, if any.