AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1315
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not present in the text)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
007 INSC 1315
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 227 of the Constitution of India
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act (not present in the text)
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

Gajanand M. Dalwadi, the delinquent officer (now deceased), was employed in the Regional Transport Office under the Commissioner of Transport, State of Gujarat. Though originally attached to the Licence Branch, at the relevant time he was serving as a summary clerk in the Accounts Department.

An inspection conducted between 21-08-1995 and 13-09-1995 in the Licence Branch uncovered several acts of misconduct. Chief among them was the issuance of a forged duplicate driving licence to one Narendra Kumar, enabling an insurance claim related to a road accident during a period when the driver held no valid licence.

A charge-sheet was served, and after a full disciplinary enquiry the Enquiry Officer, by report dated 06-12-1997, found all charges proved. The disciplinary authority ordered Dalwadi’s removal from service on 26-10-1998.

Dalwadi challenged the order before the Gujarat Civil Services Tribunal, which set aside the punishment as “too harsh” and accepted his explanation that he acted at the behest of a colleague, Shri Dudhrechia.

The State filed a writ petition. A learned Single Judge of the High Court reinstated the penalty, holding that the Tribunal’s interference resulted in a miscarriage of justice.

On appeal, a Division Bench reversed the Single Judge and restored the Tribunal’s order.

The present judgment arises from an appeal to the Supreme Court by the State of Gujarat against the Division Bench’s decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Gujarat Civil Services Tribunal and the High Court’s Division Bench erred in setting aside the punishment of removal imposed for proven acts of forgery by the delinquent officer.
  2. Whether removal from service is a disproportionate penalty for the offence of issuing a forged driving licence in the circumstances of the case.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (State of Gujarat)

  • The Division Bench’s approach was legally erroneous and ignored the gravity of the proven misconduct.
  • Forgery intended to facilitate an unlawful insurance claim warrants the severest penalty and cannot be condoned on equitable grounds.
  • The Tribunal exceeded its limited jurisdiction by interfering with the quantum of punishment absent any finding of disproportionality.

Respondent (Estate of Gajanand M. Dalwadi)

  • Supported the Division Bench’s view that Dalwadi may have acted at the instance of a colleague and lacked complete understanding as issuance of licences was not his current function.
  • Contended that the punishment of removal was excessively harsh in the circumstances.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
U.P. State Road Transport Corporation v. Ram Kishan Arora (2007) 4 SCC 627 Removal/dismissal is an appropriate penalty for offences involving forgery. Cited to affirm that dismissal is a standard, proportionate response to forgery and similar grave misconduct.
Ramesh Chandra Sharma v. Punjab National Bank (2007) 9 SCC 15 Court’s limited scope to interfere with punishment unless it is wholly disproportionate. Relied upon to hold that the Tribunal exceeded its jurisdiction in reducing the penalty.
UCO Bank v. Rajinder Lal Capoor (2007) 6 SCC 694 Consistency in imposing severe penalties for fraudulent acts by public servants. Used to reinforce the proposition that equity cannot override proven misconduct involving dishonesty.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court held that forgery of a driving licence is a grave offence, particularly when intended to secure unlawful pecuniary gain for another and cause loss to an insurance company. The Tribunal and the Division Bench, by focusing on speculative mitigating factors, asked the wrong questions and ignored settled principles governing disciplinary control over public servants.

The Court emphasised that:

  • The finding of the Enquiry Officer—accepted by the disciplinary authority and the Single Judge—established that Dalwadi issued the forged licence “designedly”, i.e., with full knowledge and intent.
  • Even if another clerk were involved, the delinquent’s own culpability remained unaffected.
  • Tribunals are not appellate bodies on facts and cannot substitute their own view on punishment unless the penalty is shockingly disproportionate, which was not the case here.
  • Equitable considerations have little relevance when misconduct involves moral turpitude such as forgery.
  • Since Dalwadi had earlier worked in the Licence Department, the argument that he did not understand the licensing process was untenable.

By applying the cited precedents, the Court concluded that removal from service is an appropriate and legally sustainable punishment for the proven misconduct.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed – Impugned judgment of the Division Bench set aside; the order of removal from service stands restored. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision reaffirms that forgery by public servants attracts the severest disciplinary penalties and that quasi-judicial bodies like service tribunals may intervene in punishment only when it is shockingly disproportionate. No new legal principle is created, but existing standards on proportionality and tribunal jurisdiction are reinforced.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Gujarat v. Gajanand M. Dalwadi (Dead) By Lrs. .

    S.B Sinha, J.— Gajanand M. Dalwadi, since deceased (delinquent officer) was working in the Regional Transport Office under the Commissioner of Transport in the State of Gujarat. He had been working in the Department for Grant of Licence. At the relevant time, however, he was serving in the Accounts Department as a summary clerk.

    2. An inspection was conducted in the Licence Branch of the Regional Transport Office during the period 21-8-1995 to 13-9-1995.

    3. Several misconducts committed by the delinquent officer came to the notice of the authorities. It was found that a forged licence was granted to one Narendra Kumar who had met with an accident although at the relevant point of time, he was (sic not) possessing a valid driving licence. A charge-sheet was issued against him. Upon holding a disciplinary proceeding, the enquiry officer submitted a report on 6-12-1997 stating that the charges against him have been proved. The disciplinary authority directed his removal from service by an order dated 26-10-1998. Aggrieved by the said order imposing punishment upon him, he filed an application before the Gujarat Civil Services Tribunal. The said application was allowed holding that misconduct on his part, if any, was committed by him at the request of another clerk viz. one Dudhrechia. It was further held:

    “15. From the Department, it is submitted that Dudhrechia has denied entrusting the work to the appellant but as stated above Dudhrechia would never admit and the submission of the appellant gets credence that this is not an afterthought in the appeal but it was put to the clerk concerned at the enquiry, at first in point of time.
    16. Also the order is too harsh. The disciplinary authority must give reasons why it is proper to pass such orders. In the discipline appeals and rules providing for major penalties step by step, the punishments are given with a view that penalty must be in consonance with the act complained or charges proved or the misconduct of the staff. The appellant is not a chip of dead wood that he must be removed. Also punishment such as harsh as this would also required (sic) to consider rising an employment in the State. Not that we want to protect dishonest or bad people but reasons must be given and satisfaction must be reached that this punishment is proper.”

    4. A learned Single Judge of the High Court allowed the writ petition filed by the appellant holding that the delinquent had all the opportunities to reply to the charge-sheet and take part in the disciplinary proceeding. The learned Single Judge held that the decision of the Tribunal resulted in miscarriage of justice warranting the Court's intervention under the supervisory jurisdiction conferred upon the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India stating:

    “It is evident that on the date when driver Narendra Kumar met with the accident, he did not possess a valid driving licence. In the circumstances the owner of the vehicle Sagarmal Bherumal, could not have claimed insurance money for the damage caused to the vehicle. With a view to facilitating the insurance claim, the said Sagarmal Bherumal arranged for issuance of a duplicate licence in the name of driver Narendra Kumar for the period covering the date of the accident. Indisputably, the duplicate licence was issued by the delinquent. Obviously, the duplicate licence was obtained by the owner Sagarmal Bherumal with an intention to defraud the insurance company. The delinquent played an important role in this fraudulent scheme by issuing duplicate licence. Indisputably, it was neither the function of the delinquent to issue such licence nor was it his defence that the said licence was issued by him at the request of the clerk concerned Shri Dudhrechia or any other officer. Such defence was taken by the delinquent at a much later stage in the disciplinary inquiry, though unsuccessfully.
    It is quite possible that apart from the delinquent, there were other persons involved in the aforesaid fraudulent scheme and a further inquiry could have revealed the names of the other persons involved. However, merely because further inquiry was not made, the delinquent cannot be exonerated even though by evidence on record the charge against him has been proved.
    As to the second charge, there is no denial by the delinquent that he had left certain licence numbers blank while issuing the licence numbers. He has not even explained why such blanks were maintained nor he has denied that the said blanks were maintained with an ulterior intention to issue bogus licence at a later date. In absence of even a bare denial, the charge has rightly been held to be proved by the disciplinary authority. The fact that no licence was issued in the said numbers at any point of time thereafter is of no consequence.
    Even the third charge has been proved by the statement of the persons concerned i.e Shri B.K Chauhan and Shri N.P Ptni. It should also be noted that even in answer to the report of the inquiry officer, the delinquent has not made out any case based on the evidence on record. Even the said reply is evasive.”

    5. The Division Bench of the High Court, however, on an appeal preferred by the delinquent officer, allowed the said appeal holding:

    “Yes, the deceased Gajanand Dalwadi should have been more careful while preparing the duplicate licence, he may have acted designedly. After all, he may not have understood the nature of work and manner of transacting it since it was not his function since he was working in the accounts. Therefore, the conclusions drawn by the Tribunal were justified and there could be no reason to upturn them.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    6. Mr Yashank Adhyaru, the learned Senior Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant submitted that the approach of the Division Bench of the High Court is wholly erroneous and thus is liable to be set aside.

    7. Mr H.K Puri, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent, on the other hand, would support the judgment.

    8. Forgery of a licence is a serious charge. It cannot be condoned only because it has been done at the instance of a colleague, even if it be so assumed. As noticed hereinbefore, even the employee concerned has denied that the licence was issued at his instance.

    9. The learned Tribunal as also the Division Bench of the High Court, with respect, misdirected themselves in law, as they posed unto themselves wrong questions. Misconduct, of such a magnitude, when proved, cannot be ignored on surmises and conjectures. Equity, in a case of this nature, would have no role to play.

    10. When a forgery is committed with a view to assist a person to make unlawful gain for himself or to cause unlawful loss to another, the matter should be viewed seriously. The Tribunal is not an appellate authority, its jurisdiction was also limited. It could not have ordinarily interfered with the quantum of punishment unless it was held to be wholly disproportionate to the imputation of charges. If ordinarily in regard to the commission of the offence of forgery, an order of dismissal/removal is an appropriate punishment, as has been held in a large number of cases, the same could not have been sidetracked. (See U.P SRTC v. Ram Kishan Arora (2007) 4 SCC 627, (2007) 6 Scale 721, Ramesh Chandra Sharma v. Punjab National Bank (2007) 9 SCC 15, (2007) 8 Scale 240 and UCO Bank v. Rajinder Lal Capoor (2007) 6 SCC 694.)

    11. The approach of the learned Single Judge, in our opinion was the correct one.

    12. Once it was held that the delinquent had acted designedly, it could not have also been held that he might not have understood the nature of work or manner of transacting it, since it was not his function as he had been working in the accounts. Finding of fact arrived at by the enquiry officer which was accepted by the learned Single Judge, was that the issuance of licence, which was not his job, was itself a misconduct. The Division Bench of the High Court clearly overlooked the fact that it is the positive case of the State that the delinquent officer was working in the Licence Department prior to his transfer to the Accounts Department and, therefore, he knew about the modalities of grant of licence. An application for grant of licence must be processed having regard to the provisions of the Central Motor Vehicles Rules. An application in Form 4 is required to be filed as envisaged under Rule 14. Only, upon proper scrutiny thereof, a licence could be granted in Form 6 as envisaged under Rule 16 of the Rules. Issuance of a forged licence, having regard to the said provisions, is a serious matter, which could not have been ignored on the ipse dixit of the Tribunal.

    13. For the reasons aforementioned, the impugned judgment cannot be sustained which is set aside accordingly. Appeal is allowed. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Gujarat v. Gajanand M. Dalwadi (Dead) By Lrs. .
    (Dec 14, 2007)