Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The deceased was shot at about 12:00 p.m. while leaving a market shop after purchasing a bundle of bidi. According to the prosecution, the appellant fired a single shot from a licensed .12-bore rifle, striking the deceased above the waist on his backbone. The appellant was allegedly accompanied by his brother-in-law Giriraj (armed with a katta), his father (carrying a gupti) and his brother (also carrying a katta). The deceased died almost immediately and an FIR was recorded within minutes on the basis of a statement (Ex. P-3) made by his son, Mahesh (PW-4), at the hospital.

The appellant and Giriraj were tried for murder. During trial, PW-4 submitted in writing that the appellant’s father and brother had been wrongly named, resulting in no proceedings against them. The Sessions Court convicted the appellant under Section 302 IPC but acquitted Giriraj for want of proof of intention. The High Court affirmed the conviction and the sentence of life imprisonment. The present appeal before the Supreme Court challenges that affirmation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the sole eyewitness, PW-4, should be treated as wholly unreliable—thus requiring acquittal—or partly reliable, in which case his testimony could be accepted if corroborated in material particulars.
  2. Whether the corroborative evidence (FIR timing, medical findings, ballistic report, recovery of the weapon and cartridge) is sufficient to sustain the conviction despite alleged discrepancies raised by the defence.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • PW-4 is a close relative of the deceased, shared longstanding enmity with the appellant’s family, and falsely implicated the appellant’s father, brother and Giriraj; therefore, his testimony is wholly unreliable.
  • The FIR is “ante-timed” and discrepancies exist regarding the time of its recording, the mention of the bidi bundle, and overwriting in documents, undermining their credibility.
  • Only three of the four live cartridges allegedly recovered were deposited with the court, suggesting manipulation of evidence to link the appellant’s gun to the crime.
  • In the absence of corroboration on material particulars, a conviction based solely on PW-4’s testimony is unsustainable.

State's Response

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the State’s specific arguments. The Court’s reasoning, however, relies on the evidence cited by the prosecution and accepted by the lower courts.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras, AIR 1957 SC 614; 1957 SCR 981; 1957 Cri LJ 1000 Classification of witnesses into wholly reliable, wholly unreliable and partly reliable; testimony of a partly reliable witness may be accepted if corroborated on material particulars. The Court treated PW-4 as a partly reliable witness and looked for corroboration through medical, ballistic and seizure evidence before affirming conviction.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court reiterated that the maxim “falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus” does not apply in India. A witness who is partly reliable may still be believed on those portions of testimony that find independent corroboration.

Key analytical steps:

  • Assessment of PW-4: The Court deemed PW-4 neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable. His testimony was subjected to cautious scrutiny for corroboration.
  • Timeliness and Content of the FIR: The FIR was recorded minutes after the incident, specifically naming the appellant, the weapon (.12-bore gun), the site of injury, and the presence of other eyewitnesses. Allegations of ante-timing were unsupported by cross-examination.
  • Medical and Ballistic Corroboration: Medical evidence confirmed a single close-range gunshot injury at the exact situs described by PW-4. Forensic analysis matched the empty cartridge recovered from the scene with the appellant’s licensed gun seized six weeks later.
  • Handling of Discrepancies: Minor documentary inconsistencies—such as overwriting of time or omission of the bidi bundle—were held immaterial because they did not affect critical facts. The fourth live cartridge was belatedly deposited in court, a lapse explained and accepted by the trial court.
  • Hostile Witnesses: PW-5 and PW-6 turned hostile, but their hostility did not negate PW-4’s direct account, especially once corroborated by objective evidence.
  • Separation of Grain from Chaff: Even though PW-4 initially implicated additional family members, the courts below justifiably acquitted them while retaining the conviction of the appellant, demonstrating selective reliance consistent with settled principles.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed; conviction and life sentence under Section 302 IPC upheld.

The decision reinforces the approach that testimony of a partly reliable eyewitness can ground a conviction when corroborated by independent evidence. It leaves intact existing principles rather than creating a new precedent, and its direct effect is the continued incarceration of the appellant for life.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Amrita Alias Amritlal v. State Of M.P .

    Y.K Sabharwal, J.— The conviction of the appellant for offence under Section 302 IPC has been confirmed by the impugned judgment of the High Court. The main question to be determined in this appeal is whether the sole eyewitness on whose testimony the conviction is primarily based is partly reliable or wholly unreliable.

    2. Facts in brief are that on the date of incident, the deceased went with his elder son Mahesh (PW 4) to market and when at about 12.00 noon, he was coming out from a shop after purchasing a bundle of bidi, the appellant fired at him from .12 bore rifle. The shot hit the deceased above the waist on his backbone. The appellant was accompanied by his brother-in-law, Giriraj who had a katta, father, who had a gupti and brother who also had a katta. The incident was seen by PW 6 and PW 5. The deceased was taken to a hospital but seems to have died on the spot.

    3. The appellant and Giriraj, his brother-in-law were put up for trial. In respect of the father and brother of the appellant, the informant (PW 4) gave in writing that their names had been wrongly mentioned and, therefore, no action be taken against them.

    4. The Sessions Court, on appreciation of evidence, in particular, the testimony of PW 4, the medical evidence, the evidence of the ballistic expert and that of seizure, came to the conclusion that the prosecution has proved beyond reasonable doubt that the gunshot injury which resulted in death of the deceased was inflicted by the appellant. Giriraj was given benefit of doubt since neither was any injury attributed to him nor was katta recovered and it was held by the Sessions Court that the intention of Giriraj to commit the murder of the deceased had not been proved. The State did not challenge the acquittal of Giriraj. The High Court, on reappreciation of evidence, has confirmed the appellant's conviction and sentence of life imprisonment.

    5. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that PW 4 had falsely implicated the father and brother of the appellant as also Giriraj who stands acquitted. It is further submitted that admittedly there was enmity between the family of the deceased and that of the accused. The deceased was accused in a case of murder of the brother of the appellant, but was acquitted in the said case. In view of the enmity, the close relationship between the witness (PW 4) and the deceased and false implication of the appellant's other family members, it is submitted that PW 4 is a wholly unreliable witness and conviction based on the testimony of such a witness is unsustainable.

    6. PW 4 is not wholly reliable has been noticed by the High Court and keeping in view the said factor the evidence was analysed. We, however, find it difficult to accept the submission that PW 4 is wholly unreliable. He is neither wholly reliable nor wholly unreliable is evident from the evidence on record. PW 4 is partly reliable and partly unreliable and the effect of it is that the Court to rely on his testimony has to look for corroboration in material particulars. (See Vadivelu Thevar v. State of Madras AIR 1957 SC 614, 1957 SCR 981, 1957 Cri LJ 1000.) The testimony of PW 4 does not deserve to be entirely rejected. A cautious approach is necessary. Such a testimony has to be examined carefully and with caution. The testimony of PW 4, therefore, cannot be rejected on the ground of it being wholly unreliable.

    7. Keeping in view the above principles, we have examined the record. The FIR was recorded minutes after the commission of the offence. It names the appellant, the nature of the weapon with which the shot was fired by him, the situs of injury and the names of the other eyewitnesses who were present. It is, however, a different matter that those eyewitnesses (PW 5 and PW 6) did not support the prosecution and were declared hostile.

    8. It has also to be borne in mind that in India the maxim “falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus” has no application. It is not the law that if the witness has spoken some falsehood, his entire testimony has to be discarded. Testimony of such a witness requires care and caution at the time of its analysis. The tendency of the closely related witnesses to involve all family members in the commission of offence, when there is severe enmity between the deceased and the accused does not mean that the entire testimony shall be rejected and, thus, acquitting even those who committed the crime. The extent to which the evidence is worthy of acceptance depends upon facts of each case. In such cases, it is the duty of the courts to separate the grain from the chaff where it is so possible and to convict the accused if called for on the basis of evidence despite the fact that the same witness also falsely implicated others. Mere acquittal of some of the accused on the same evidence by itself does not lead to a conclusion that all deserve to be acquitted in case appropriate reasons have been given on appreciation of evidence both in regard to acquittal and conviction of the accused. In the present case, the courts below have given appropriate reasons.

    9. Taking us through evidence, Mr Singh contends that assuming PW 4 is partly reliable, there is no corroboration of the material particulars. In support, learned counsel submits that the FIR was ante-timed. The incident took place at 12 noon. Exhibit P-3, statement of PW 4 was scribed in the hand of PW 8 at 12.20 p.m Exhibit P-3 was written in the hospital. The formal FIR (Exhibit P-4) was recorded at the police station at 12.50 p.m Besides pointing out the discrepancy of the time of arrival of PW 8 at the hospital, the discrepancy being of about 1 hour, it was submitted that in Exhibit P-1 (requisition sent for the post-mortem) neither the FIR number has been mentioned nor the factum of recovery of bundle of bidi and there is cutting at one of the places where the time “3.15” has been cut and 1.30 p.m has been written. The document read as a whole shows that the cutting of time is of no consequence when examined in the light of other particulars therein. The non-mention of recovery of the bundle of bidi is again not a material discrepancy. We have also examined the inquest report (Exhibit P-16), seizure memo of empty cartridge (Exhibit P-7), seizure memo of gun (Exhibit P-12) and have also perused the opinion of the forensic laboratory (Exhibit P-18) and the testimony of Dr. Dubey (PW 3), investigating officer (PW 10) besides that of the eyewitness (PW 4). There is no material discrepancy in the evidence. It has to be kept in view that in every case, some or the other discrepancy is likely to occur. In case the discrepancy does not materially affect the case of the prosecution, it has to be ignored. We may also note that no suggestion of ante-timing of FIR was given to the witnesses.

    10. The statement recorded in the hospital (Exhibit P-3) within a few minutes of the commission of the crime and which was the basis of recording of the FIR (Exhibit P-4), on the one hand, does not attribute any role to the acquitted accused Giriraj or the other two who were not put to trial and on the other hand, gives a vivid account of the weapon used by the appellant, the part of the body where the shot hit the deceased and the name of the other two persons who were present at the place of occurrence. The appellant was absconding. He was arrested after about 6 weeks of the incident. The gun with which the shot was fired was recovered from him. The empty cartridge has been matched with the said gun. The firing from .12 bore gun has been deposed to by PW 4 and the FIR also records the firing from .12 bore gun. The medical evidence fully corroborates the situs of the injury as also the nature of the injury which also stands corroborated from the ballistic expert opinion. The evidence of examination of clothes worn by the deceased at the time of occurrence further supports the prosecution case. The 14 pellets that were recovered from the body of the deceased further lend corroboration to the case of the prosecution in material particulars. The shot was fired from close range. The FIR also notices the inflicting of one gunshot.

    11. It is pointed out by learned counsel for the appellant that according to the prosecution four live cartridges were also recovered from the appellant and only three were deposited along with the challan papers and on the basis thereof it is contended that the fourth live cartridge may have been used by the prosecution to falsely implicate his client. The judgment of the trial court, however, notices that one live cartridge was left at the police station by mistake and when that fact came to the notice of the investigating officer, the said cartridge was deposited in court. The empty cartridge which is recovered from the place of occurrence has been matched and as per the ballistic expert opinion, it was fired from the gun recovered from the appellant. It may be noticed that the gun that had been recovered was claimed to be a licensed gun of the appellant. The testimony of PW 4 insofar the appellant is concerned, has not been shaken. The said testimony has been corroborated on all material particulars by medical evidence, ballistic expert evidence and the evidence of seizure of the gun and the empty cartridge. The evidence has been properly analysed by the courts below, having regard to the well-settled principles abovenoticed.

    12. For the aforesaid reasons, the impugned judgment does not warrant any interference. The appeal accordingly fails and is dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Amrita Alias Amritlal v. State Of M.P .
    (Feb 9, 2004)