AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 162
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 116-A of the Act
  • Sections 100(1)(d)(iii), 101 and 102 of the Act and Rule 93 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961
  • Section 100 of the Act, clause (d), sub-section (1)
  • Section 134 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 116-C of the Act
  • Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
  • Section 100(1)(d)(iii) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2002 INSC 162
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 116-A of the Act
  • Sections 100(1)(d)(iii), 101 and 102 of the Act and Rule 93 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961
  • Section 100 of the Act, clause (d), sub-section (1)
  • Section 134 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 116-C of the Act
  • Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
  • Section 100(1)(d)(iii) of the Representation of the People Act, 1951
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeal was filed under Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 against the judgment of the Bombay High Court dated 29 June 2001, which had dismissed an election petition. The petition challenged the election of Shri Ajit Anantrao Pawar from the 255 Baramati Assembly Constituency held on 11 September 1999. The petitioners were (i) a voter from the constituency and (ii) the counting agent of the defeated candidate, Shri Chandrakant K. Teware, who lost by 50,366 votes. Allegations centred on malpractices during counting, including the sudden shifting of ballot-box storage, suspected substitution of genuine ballots with fake ones, unsigned ballot papers, and the discovery of a ballot paper from another constituency.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the circumstances alleged by the appellants warranted inspection of ballot papers under Section 100(1)(d)(iii) of the Act and Rule 93 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961.
  2. Whether the alleged irregularities—particularly the shifting of ballot-box storage, unsigned ballot papers in Booth No. 234, and the presence of a ballot paper from another constituency—materially affected the result of the election.
  3. Whether the High Court had erred in its appreciation of evidence such that the Supreme Court should overturn its factual findings.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Returning Officer shifted ballot boxes from MES High School to the Recreation Hall, MIDC, without informing candidates, facilitating possible substitution of ballots.
  • Many ballot papers bore similar signatures and ink, suggesting their fabrication.
  • In Booth No. 234, 455 ballot papers lacked the Presiding Officer’s signature, proving substitution.
  • One ballot paper from Khed Parliamentary Constituency found in the boxes showed manipulation.
  • Sought court-ordered inspection of all ballot boxes to uncover further irregularities.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The shift in storage location was compelled by heavy rain and water-logging at MES High School, making safe custody imperative.
  • Notice of the shift was given to polling and counting agents.
  • Physical and temporal constraints made large-scale substitution of ballots impossible (opening 251 boxes would require roughly 125 hours).
  • Even if 455 unsigned ballots were rejected, the result would not be materially affected given the winning margin of over 50,000 votes.
  • The respondent’s party was not in power; therefore, influence over election machinery was unlikely.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Sewak Yadav v. Hussain Kamil Kidwai, AIR 1964 SC 1249; (1964) 6 SCR 238 Conditions for ordering inspection of ballot papers: (i) adequate pleading of material facts, and (ii) prima facie necessity to do complete justice; courts must guard the secrecy of the ballot. The Court applied these conditions to hold that the appellants had not established a prima facie case; inspection would amount to a fishing inquiry.
Sumitra Devi v. Sheo Shanker Prasad Yadav, (1973) 3 SCC 330 Supreme Court’s consistent practice not to interfere with concurrent findings of fact unless there is a grave or palpable error. The Court relied on this principle to defer to the High Court’s factual determinations, finding no grave error in its appreciation of evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court first reiterated the stringent standards governing inspection of ballot papers, citing Ram Sewak Yadav. It held that the petition’s allegations did not meet those standards; they were either speculative or unsupported by material facts.

On the shifting of ballot boxes, evidence showed heavy rainfall on 9 September 1999 and water-logging at MES High School. Witness testimony (PW 5 and others) confirmed that ballot-box relocation was communicated to election personnel, undermining claims of secrecy or bad faith.

The Court endorsed the High Court’s calculation that substituting ballots in 251 boxes would require approximately 125 hours—an impossibility within the brief storage period at MIDC. No evidence indicated interference by the respondent or his family.

Regarding the 455 unsigned ballot papers in Booth No. 234, the Court noted: (i) the Presiding Officer faced pending criminal proceedings and his testimony lacked credibility; (ii) counting agents raised no contemporaneous objection; and (iii) rejection of these ballots would not narrow the 50,366-vote margin enough to affect the result. Similarly, the solitary ballot paper from a different constituency could not materially influence the outcome.

Finally, the Court rejected the appellants’ request for blanket inspection of all ballot boxes as a classic fishing expedition, inconsistent with the secrecy of the vote and the principles in Ram Sewak Yadav.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED.

The Supreme Court affirmed the Bombay High Court’s dismissal of the election petition. The result of Shri Ajit Anantrao Pawar’s election stands, and the Registry is directed to take follow-up action under Section 116-C(2) of the Act. No new legal principle was established; the judgment reinforces existing standards for ordering inspection of ballot papers and the Court’s reluctance to disturb factual findings absent palpable error.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Rajankumar Shankarrao Teware And Another v. Ajit Anantrao Pawar .

    S.N Phukan, J.— This appeal under Section 116-A of the Representation of the People Act, 1951 (for short “the Act”) arises from the judgment dated 29-6-2001 of the High Court of Judicature at Bombay. By the impugned judgment, the High Court dismissed the election petition.

    2. The election petition was filed challenging the election of the respondent from 255 Baramati Assembly Constituency, which was held on 11-9-1999. The petition was filed by two persons, one was a voter of the constituency and the other was the counting agent of the defeated candidate viz. Shri Chandrakant K. Teware. In the said election respondent Shri Ajit Anantrao Pawar defeated his immediate rival candidate, Shri Teware by a margin of 50,366 votes. The petition was filed alleging that certain malpractices were committed at the time of counting of the votes, under Section 100(1)(d)(iii) of the Act.

    3. The allegations, which are relevant for the present purpose, are stated below:

    After the polling, the ballot boxes were to be kept in MES High School, Baramati as per programme and when the ballot boxes arrived at the said School and were in the process of unloading, all the boxes were shifted to the Recreation Hall, MIDC area at Baramati. According to the appellants, this change was made by the Returning Officer without informing the contesting candidates. As the said MIDC area is adjacent to the premises of Vidya Pratisthan Shikshan Sansthan, which was fully controlled by the family of the respondent and in fact the respondent was one of the office-bearers of the said Pratisthan, this sudden change caused an apprehension in the minds of the appellants that it was so done with the oblique motive of replacing genuine ballot papers by fake ones. We find from the counter that there was heavy rain at Baramati on 9-9-1999 and rainwater also collected around the said High School. Apprehending that there might be rain on subsequent days and the said High School area might be flooded, the Returning Officer changed the venue of keeping the ballot boxes for safe custody of the boxes as in the event of rain the school area might be flooded. It was also alleged that during counting of votes it was noticed that in the majority of ballot papers there were signatures on the back side of the ballot papers which were similar in nature with the same ink and character. It was, therefore, suspected that genuine ballot papers were substituted by fake ones. In Polling Booth Nos. 235, 455 ballot papers were used and there was no signature of the Presiding Officer on the reverse side of the ballot papers as required under the Rules, whereas according to the Presiding Officer of the said booth he signed on all the ballot papers on the previous day of polling, suggesting that ballot papers might have been substituted. In this polling booth one ballot paper of Khed Legislative Constituency was found inside the ballot boxes which was brought to the notice of the Returning Officer by filing a written complaint (Annexure P-21A) and according to the appellants the complaint was filed at 2.30 p.m, on 6-10-1999 i.e while the counting process was going on but the Returning Officer refused to receive the same. It was alleged that subsequently the Returning Officer recorded a note at 3.30 a.m on 7-10-1999 and, thereafter, passed necessary orders. On these facts it was also alleged that the Returning Officer was influenced by the respondent in the conduct of election and counting of the votes.

    4. Before we proceed to examine the facts of the present appeal, we may refer to the position of law. In Ram Sewak Yadav v. Hussain Kamil Kidwai AIR 1964 SC 1249, (1964) 6 SCR 238 a Constitution Bench of this Court held that power to order inspection of ballot papers is clearly implicit in Sections 100(1)(d)(iii), 101 and 102 of the Act and Rule 93 of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961 and an order for inspection under the Act may not be granted as a matter of course, having regard to the insistence upon the secrecy of the ballot papers. It was further held that the Court would be justified in granting an order for inspection provided two conditions are fulfilled: (AIR p. 1252, para 7)

    (i) the petition for setting aside an election contains an adequate statement of the material facts on which the petitioner relies in support of his case; and
    (ii) the Election Tribunal is prima facie satisfied that in order to decide the dispute and to do complete justice between the parties, inspection of ballot papers is necessary.

    5. The Constitution Bench also held that an order for inspection of ballot papers could not be granted to support vague pleas made in the petition not supported by material facts or to fish out evidence to support such pleas.

    6. In Sumitra Devi v. Sheo Shanker Prasad Yadav (1973) 3 SCC 330 a three-Judge Bench of this Court held in an appeal under Section 116-A of the Act that it has been the consistent practice of the Supreme Court not to interfere with findings on questions of fact unless there is some grave or palpable error in appreciation of the evidence on the basis of which the findings were arrived at.

    7. While interpreting clause (d) of sub-section (1) of Section 100 of the Act, this Court has consistently held that in view of the clear language of the provision even if the allegations in the election petition are found to be proved, the election petitioner should also establish that the result of the election was materially affected.

    8. Drawing our attention to paragraph 30 of the impugned judgment, Mr Lalit, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that the High Court proceeded on a wrong legal proposition. In the said paragraph the learned Judge took the view that in order to succeed in the election petition, the appellants have at least to create a genuine doubt in the mind of the court by establishing circumstances alleged in the election petition beyond all reasonable doubt. This approach was wrong in view of the settled position of law but we find from the impugned judgment that subsequently, the learned Judge after discussing various decisions of this Court recorded the finding that after going through the records it could not be said that even a genuine suspicion about alleged malpractice of substituting the valid votes with spurious votes could be established. We have also perused the impugned judgment and we find after discussing the law and evidence on record, the election petition was dismissed holding that the appellants failed to make out a prima facie case and could not be allowed to embark upon a fishing inquiry.

    9. At the outset we may state here that all the allegations were made against the Returning Officer and though initially he was impleaded as a respondent, subsequently, his name was deleted by the order of the court. The High Court has noted that during the trial the Returning Officer was present in court and he was also shown as a witness in the list of witnesses submitted by the appellants. Subsequently, his name was struck off from the said list and was not examined. The defeated candidate, Shri Teware did not appear as a witness to support the allegations made in the election petition.

    10. The first contention of Mr Lalit, learned counsel for the appellants is that the ballot boxes were to be collected at MES High School and instead boxes were collected at the Recreation Hall, MIDC without information to the candidates/agents about such shifting of ballot boxes and this was done in order to replace ballot papers in the ballot boxes.

    11. The High Court has recorded in the impugned judgment that it has come out from the oral evidence of PW 4 that “there was rain and there was waterlogging in MES High School …”. Mr Lalit has rightly pointed out that no such statement was made by PW 4. On the contrary, Mr Ashok Desai has submitted that it was a genuine mistake on the part of the learned Judge and he has drawn our attention to the evidence of PW 5, the Presiding Officer of the booth. PW 5, in the cross-examination has stated that when they went to MES High School on 9th September, rainwater had collected there. We agree with Mr Desai that it was a genuine mistake.

    12. We have already noted that shifting of the collection centre was for safe custody of the ballot boxes. In the evidence it has come out that on 9-9-1999 there was heavy rain at Baramati. PW 2, the Principal of the School has stated that when it rains in Baramati, rainwater gets collected in some areas of the School. It is the responsibility of the Returning Officer to keep the ballot boxes in safe custody, therefore, the Returning Officer rightly shifted the collection centre for ballot boxes for safe custody and we reject the contention of the appellants that it was so done with an ulterior motive.

    13. From the evidence of PW 1, the polling agent of Shri Teware who is Appellant 2 herein, it has come out that at MES High School he waited for 15 minutes and saw that the boxes were reloaded in the vehicle. He has stated that the Assistant Returning Officer who was present at MES High School informed him that boxes were being shifted as per the orders of the Returning Officer. PW 3, the Presiding Officer of Booth No. 234 who arrived at MES High School has deposed that he and other Presiding Officers were informed about the shifting of the collection centre for the ballot boxes. Therefore, the submission that no notice was given is contrary to the evidence on record. In absence of the evidence of defeated candidate Shri Teware, we cannot accept the submission that no notice was given to the candidates about such shifting.

    14. The Recreation Hall, MIDC, which was under the control of the State Government, was adjacent to Vidya Pratisthan Shikshan Sansthan, which was under the control of the family of the respondent. The appellants have not adduced any evidence to support the allegation that any attempt was made by the respondent or any member of his family to substitute the ballot papers in the ballot boxes.

    15. Mr Ashok Desai, learned Senior Counsel for the respondent has rightly pointed out that the party on whose ticket the respondent contested the election was not in power at the relevant time and BJP and Shiv Sena were in power. This was in reply to the contention made in the election petition that the respondent was a nephew of Shri Sharad Pawar, ex-Chief Minister of Maharashtra who also contested the election for the parliamentary constituency and got elected.

    16. The ballot boxes were received at the Recreation Hall, MIDC, Baramati on 11-9-1999 and were dispatched on the next day i.e 12-9-1999 to the Storage Centre, Pune. All ballot boxes were dispatched by 7.30 a.m, except the ballot boxes of Baramati Constituency, which were dispatched at 9.30 a.m The High Court has recorded that there were 251 ballot boxes for this assembly constituency and on the basis of evidence of PW 10 it came to the conclusion that it would require 30 to 35 minutes for sorting out ballot papers in each ballot box. On these premises, the High Court rightly was of the opinion that it would require 125 hours for opening 251 ballot boxes, sorting out ballot papers of the Lok Sabha and the assembly constituency and substituting ballot papers by different set of ballot papers. Therefore, it would not be possible to substitute ballot papers during the period the boxes were kept at the Recreation Hall, MIDC and rejected the plea holding that it was a “fertile imagination of the witnesses”. We agree with the above finding of the learned Single Judge.

    17. We have perused the written complaint filed before the Returning Officer in which two allegations were made viz. absence of signature of the Presiding Officer on the ballot papers and one used ballot paper for Khed Lok Sabha Constituency was found in the ballot boxes. A prayer was made before the Returning Officer that the ballot papers of the entire legislative constituency be scrutinised and verified. The said complaint was filed by Shri Arun Chandrao Teware, PW 7 and time was noted at 2 p.m The Returning Officer in his order stated that he found in Polling Booth No. 234 that there were no signatures of the Presiding Officer on the back side of the ballot papers and he checked the numbers of the ballot papers, thereafter he informed the counting representative that the said ballot papers were from the said polling centre and the counting agents did not make any objection and gave consent for counting of votes. After going through the report we do not accept the contention that the Returning Officer refused to accept the complaint as alleged. We may state here that no prayer was made either by the defeated candidate or any counting agent for re-count.

    18. The second contention of Mr Lalit is that the absence of signature of the Presiding Officer in Booth No. 234 on the back of 455 ballot papers, would show that they were substituted.

    19. According to the High Court, since only 455 ballot papers were found without the signature of the Presiding Officer and assuming that the ballot papers ought to have been rejected, it would not affect materially the result of the election as the respondent won by a huge margin of about 50,000 votes. We agree with the above finding of the High Court. PW 5 was the Presiding Officer at Booth No. 234 and according to him he put his signature on all ballot papers of the Lok Sabha constituency and in 500 ballot papers of the assembly constituency on 10-9-1999 and the Polling Officers checked each and every ballot paper. PW 6, the Polling Officer of the said booth has supported PW 3 on this point. According to Rule 38 of the Conduct of Elections Rules every ballot paper before it is issued to the electorate, the counterfoil attested thereto shall be signed by the Presiding Officer on its back. PW 5 could not explain why he signed the ballot papers on the previous day. A criminal proceeding has been initiated against him under Section 134 of the Act for his omission to sign the ballot papers and is pending and, therefore, according to the High Court he could not have deposed otherwise. Therefore, on this ground, the High Court disbelieved PW 5, as it was his endeavour to justify his action to absolve himself of the criminal charge. This finding of the High Court cannot be faulted.

    20. The respondent defeated Shri Teware by a huge margin of more than fifty thousand votes. Only 455 ballot papers without signature of the Presiding Officer were found in Booth No. 234. These ballot papers were counted and as the Returning Officer has recorded in his order, there was no objection by the counting agents. Had these ballot papers been rejected, it would not have also materially affected the result of the election in view of the above huge margin. Regarding the finding of one ballot paper of another constituency in the ballot box, we are also of the view that this would also not materially affect the result of the election.

    21. Regarding the allegation that the signatures of the Presiding Officers in various polling booths on the ballot papers appeared to be similar in character, the High Court took note of the fact that not a single counting agent in the hall or any other counting agent raised any objection in writing to the Returning Officer. In the report of the Returning Officer, it was recorded that he verified the signatures and was satisfied that the objection raised was unfounded. In the absence of evidence of the Returning Officer, the High Court rightly drew adverse inference.

    22. Mr Lalit, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that as ballot papers without the signature of the Presiding Officers were found in Booth No. 234, the appellants may be allowed to inspect ballot boxes in other polling booths to find out whether there was such omission by the Presiding Officers in other booths. This submission has to be rejected, as it will amount to allowing the appellants to fish out evidence to support the contention of the appellants.

    23. After perusing the evidence which is available on record and also the impugned judgment, we are of the opinion that the High Court has not committed any grave or palpable error in appreciation of the evidence. We are also of the opinion that the appellants have failed to establish a prima facie case for inspection of ballot papers.

    24. In the result, appeal is dismissed. Registry shall take follow-up action in terms of sub-section (2) of Section 116-C of the Act. Costs on the parties.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Rajankumar Shankarrao Teware And Another v. Ajit Anantrao Pawar .
    (Mar 20, 2002)