Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 102
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 246 Entry 59 of List II Schedule VII of the Constitution
  • Section 2 of the Indian Tolls Act, 1851
  • Section 8 of the Act
  • Section 2 read with Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897
  • Section 2 of the Act of 1851
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 2 of the Act, 1976 notification
  • Section 2 of the Act itself
  • Section 2 of the Tolls Act, 1851
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Neutral Citations
2000 INSC 102
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Article 246 Entry 59 of List II Schedule VII of the Constitution
  • Section 2 of the Indian Tolls Act, 1851
  • Section 8 of the Act
  • Section 2 read with Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897
  • Section 2 of the Act of 1851
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 2 of the Act, 1976 notification
  • Section 2 of the Act itself
  • Section 2 of the Tolls Act, 1851
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns the Gai Ghat Bridge constructed by the State of Uttar Pradesh over the River Sarju in 1968-69 at a cost of Rs 39,97,000. The bridge was opened to traffic in 1970, and on 7 February 1985 the State leased the right to collect tolls to a private lessee, Mr. Chhotai Yadav.

In 1988, a truck owner, Devi Dayal Singh, filed a writ petition before the Allahabad High Court challenging the State’s authority under Section 2 of the Indian Tolls Act, 1851 (“the Act”) to collect sums beyond the actual construction cost. On 21 February 1990, a Division Bench held that the State could not recover interest or maintenance charges and declared the construction cost already recouped; it directed cessation of toll collection. The High Court relied on its earlier decisions in Jiya Lal v. State of U.P. (AIR 1981 All 72) and Lal Bahadur Ram v. State of U.P. (AIR 1988 All 146).

The lessee’s review petition was dismissed on 26 April 1990. Both the State and the lessee appealed to the Supreme Court. By an interim order dated 3 September 1990, the Supreme Court stayed the High Court’s decision; by then the State had already recovered more than four times the original construction cost through tolls.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under Section 2 of the Indian Tolls Act, 1851, the State Government may levy tolls that include components beyond the bare construction cost, specifically interest on the construction cost, maintenance expenses, stationery/collection costs, and “interest on interest.”
  2. Whether the principles laid down in Jiya Lal and followed in Lal Bahadur Ram correctly limit the State’s power to levy tolls.
  3. How the State Government’s 2 June 1976 notification—permitting recovery of construction cost, interest thereon, maintenance, and collection expenses for up to 50 years or until full recovery—should be interpreted and applied.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hammerton v. Earl of Dysart (1916) 1 AC 57 (HL) Definition of “toll” as a charge in respect of a benefit from temporary use of land Used to explain that toll must correspond to a public benefit
Brecon Markets Co. v. Neath & Brecon Rly. Co. (1872) 7 CP 555 Same jurisprudential concept of compensatory toll Quoted to support compensatory nature of tolls levied under the Act
Hindustan Vanaspati Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Board, Ghaziabad AIR 1962 All 25 Indian authority on compensatory character of tolls Cited alongside English cases to ground the definition of toll in Indian law
Maheshwari Singh v. State of Bihar AIR 1966 Pat 462 Conceptual foundation of toll as quid pro quo Reinforces that a toll must relate to a benefit
Mohd. Ibrahim v. State of U.P. AIR 1967 All 24 Further Indian authority on toll jurisprudence Relied upon for characterising toll as compensatory
Kamaljeet Singh v. Municipal Board, Pilkhwa (1986) 4 SCC 174; AIR 1987 SC 56 Supreme Court affirmation of compensatory toll concept Used to buttress the requirement of correlation between toll and benefit
Jiya Lal v. State of U.P. AIR 1981 All 72 Laid down four restrictive principles on what may be recovered by toll Supreme Court analysed and rejected three of the four principles as unsupported
Lal Bahadur Ram v. State of U.P. AIR 1988 All 146 Applied Jiya Lal principles Treated as derivative; its reasoning stood or fell with Jiya Lal

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by reaffirming that, although Section 2 empowers the State to levy tolls “as it thinks fit,” such power is inherently limited by the compensatory nature of a toll; the levy must reasonably relate to the benefit conferred—here, construction and upkeep of the bridge. The 2 June 1976 notification expressly allows recovery of:

  • (i) actual construction cost,
  • (ii) interest on that cost,
  • (iii) collection expenses, and
  • (iv) maintenance,

for up to 50 years or until full recovery, whichever occurs first.

The High Court decisions rested on four principles extracted from Jiya Lal: limiting tolls to construction cost; disallowing interest unless money is borrowed; treating collection expenses as always includable; and distinguishing maintenance from repairs so as to exclude maintenance. The Supreme Court evaluated each principle:

  1. Limitation to construction cost. Section 2 contains no such textual limit; therefore the High Court’s reading was incorrect.
  2. Interest only if money is borrowed. Both Section 2 and the 1976 notification authorise interest on “total expenditure” without distinguishing the source of funds; the High Court’s distinction was unwarranted and ignored the State’s constitutional power to raise revenue (Entry 59, List II).
  3. Collection expenses. While legitimate in principle, in this case toll collection was outsourced; inclusion of “stationery” costs exceeded what the notification allowed because stationery was not shown to be “expenditure in realisation of toll.”
  4. Maintenance versus repair. The purported distinction was artificial; upkeep of a bridge is a public benefit that may be funded by tolls, and the notification expressly contemplates recovery of maintenance costs.

The Court also criticised the State for impermissibly levying interest on interest and for recovering stationery costs and interest thereon—items not sanctioned by the notification.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The appeals are allowed; the orders of the Allahabad High Court dated 21 February 1990 and 26 April 1990 are set aside. The Court declares that henceforth the State Government, when levying tolls under the 1976 notification, shall not include (a) stationery costs unrelated to toll realisation, (b) interest on such stationery costs or on maintenance, nor (c) interest upon interest on construction expenditure. No order as to costs.

Implications: The decision restores the State’s authority to recover construction cost, interest thereon, and maintenance expenses through tolls, while clarifying that ancillary costs and compound interest are impermissible. It prospectively overrules the restrictive principles in Jiya Lal, thereby guiding future toll-levy practices across Uttar Pradesh and potentially other States operating under similar statutory frameworks.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of U.P And Others v. Devi Dayal Singh .

    Ruma Pal, J.— These appeals relate to the extent of the State Government's power to levy toll under Section 2 of the Indian Tolls Act, 1851. Section 2 of the Act reads as follows:

    “2. Power to cause levy of tolls on roads and bridges within certain rates, and to appoint Collectors. Collector's responsibilities.—The State Government may cause such rates of toll, as it thinks fit, to be levied upon any road or bridge which has been, or shall hereafter be, made or repaired at the expense of the Central or any State Government, and may place the collection of such tolls under the management of such persons as may appear to it proper, and all persons employed in the management and collection of such tolls shall be liable to the same responsibilities as would belong to them if employed in the collection of the land revenue.”

    2. The bridge, in question, is the Gai Ghat Bridge which was constructed by the State Government on River Sarju, District Bahraich in 1968-69 at a total cost of Rs 39,97,000. In 1970, the bridge was opened to the public. On 7-2-1985, the State Government leased out the right to collect toll tax in respect of the bridge to one Chhotai Yadav.

    3. In 1988, a writ application was filed by a truck owner, Devi Dayal Singh, challenging the right of the State Government to recover by way of toll under Section 2 of the Tolls Act, 1851 any amount apart from the actual cost of construction of the bridge, viz., Rs 39,97,000.

    4. On 21-2-1990, the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court allowed the writ application. The High Court held that the State Government was not entitled to realise interest on the amount spent by the State Government in the construction of the bridge by way of toll tax unless that amount had been borrowed from any financial institution. The High Court found that the bridge had been constructed by the State Government out of its own funds and that neither the interest on the expenditure nor the maintenance charges could be realised under Section 2 of the Act. The High Court found that the State Government had already recovered the original cost of construction and accordingly directed the appellants not to realise any further toll tax in respect of the Gai Ghat Bridge. In arriving at this decision, the High Court relied on two earlier decisions of the Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court, namely, Jiya Lal v. State of U.P AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 and Lal Bahadur Ram v. State of U.P AIR 1988 All 146 The order dated 21-2-1990 is the subject-matter of the first appeal before this Court.

    5. The lessee (Chhotai Yadav) who had been granted the right to collect tax in respect of the bridge, moved an application for review of the order before the High Court. The review application was dismissed on 26-4-1990. Chhotai Yadav's challenge to the orders dated 21-2-1990 and 26-4-1990 is the subject-matter of the second appeal before us.

    6. On the special leave petition being filed by the State Government, this Court, on 3-9-1990, stayed the operation of the order dated 14-2-1990 and it is not in dispute that as against the initial input of Rs 39,97,000 for construction of the bridge, the State Government has recovered more than four times that amount by way of toll.

    7. The concept of “toll” is derived from English jurisprudence. Shorn of connotations which are historically irrelevant in this country, a “toll” may be defined as a sum of money taken in respect of a benefit arising out of the temporary use of land. It implies some consideration moving to the public either in the form of a liberty, privilege or service. In other words, for the valid imposition of a toll, there must be a corresponding benefit. (See in this connection Hammerton v. Earl of Dysart (1916) 1 AC 57, 113 LT 1032 (HL), Brecon Markets Co. v. Neath & Brecon Rly. Co. (1872) 7 CP 555, Hindustan Vanaspati Mfg. Co. Ltd. v. Municipal Board, Ghaziabad AIR 1962 All 25, 1960 All LJ 651 (SB), Maheshwari Singh v. State of Bihar AIR 1966 Pat 462 (DB), Mohd. Ibrahim v. State of U.P AIR 1967 All 24, 1967 All LJ 195 and Kamaljeet Singh v. Municipal Board, Pilkhwa (1986) 4 SCC 174, AIR 1987 SC 56.)

    8. The public benefit envisaged under Section 2 of the Tolls Act, 1851 is the making or repairing of any road or bridge at the expense of the State Government. For the advantage obtained by the public by the construction of the roads and bridges, the State Government is entitled to reimburse itself for providing the service.

    9. Although the section has empowered the State Government to levy rates of tolls “as it thinks fit”, having regard to the compensatory nature of the levy, the rate of toll must bear a reasonable relationship to the providing of the benefit. No doubt, by virtue of Section 8 of the Act, the tolls collected are part of the public revenue and may be absorbed in the general revenue of the State, nevertheless by definition a toll cannot be used for otherwise augmenting the State's revenue.

    10. The State of Uttar Pradesh issued Notification No. 2174.XXIII-SN-II-62/1976 dated 2-6-1976 in exercise of the powers conferred under Section 2 read with Section 21 of the General Clauses Act, 1897. By the notification, it was ordered that with effect from the date of the publication of the notification in the Gazette, toll shall be levied and be chargeable from all persons in charge of vehicles, using all such permanent bridges notified in that behalf under the control and management of the State Public Works Department subject to certain exceptions. We are not called upon to consider the exceptions in this case.

    11. We are, for the purpose of these appeals, concerned with paras III(a) and (b) of the notification which reads:

    “(III)(a) The toll on any particular bridge shall be levied only for so long as the total cost of its construction, including interest on the total expenditure on the bridge, expenditure in realisation of toll and on maintenance, has not been realised in full or for a period of 50 years from the date of first levy of toll on the bridge, whichever is earlier.
    Explanation.—An amount equal to 0.5 per cent per annum shall be added to the cost of the bridge on account of expenditure on maintenance.
    (b) The rate of interest shall be 10% per annum on the amount invested or to be invested in future by the Government for construction of a bridge and the amount of interest shall be calculated on the balance after repayment of the instalment of the loan, if any, taken for the construction of the bridge.”

    12. In the writ application filed by Devi Dayal Singh, the notification dated 2-6-1976 has not been challenged. An interpretation of the relevant paragraph of the notification makes it clear that the intention to levy the toll is to financially self-liquidate the construction and upkeep of bridges and roads. The notification thus allows toll to be collected only for a specified period viz. 50 years from the date of first levy or until the total cost of its construction is realised, whichever is earlier. The total cost of construction has been defined in para (III)(a) of the notification as including (i) interest on the total expenditure on the bridge, (ii) expenditure in realisation of toll, and (iii) maintenance. No interest is recoverable on (ii) or (iii). In terms of the notification, it is also not permissible to recover any amount of interest on the interest chargeable on (i).

    13. However, the State Government has under cover of the notification, levied toll to recover not only (a) the actual cost of construction, but also (b) the expenditure on account of stationery, (c) maintenance, (d) interest on the cost of construction, stationery expenditure and maintenance, as well as (e) interest on the balance remaining after recovery of toll tax in any particular year. In calculating the balance, the State Government has included the stationery expenditure, maintenance and the interest charged on all the items. In other words, the State Government has charged interest on interest.

    14. Clearly, in terms of the notification, the State Government could not levy toll and reimburse itself on account of stationery, nor could it charge interest on maintenance and stationery costs. While there is also no provision in the notification for charging interest on interest, the State Government could in terms of the notification, certainly recover by way of toll from the public, the actual expense of construction, interest on such actual expense and the cost of maintenance. However, by the judgments under appeal, the right to levy the last two items was negatived.

    15. The reasons which led to such denial were based on the Bench decision in Jiya Lal AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470. Jiya Lal case AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 laid down the principles for charging toll tax in the State. The subsequent decision referred to by the High Court, namely, Lal Bahadur Ram AIR 1988 All 146 merely followed the principles enunciated in Jiya Lal AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470.

    16. The decision in Jiya Lal AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 for the most part proceeded on certain premises which were neither supported by authority nor any principle of interpretation. Of the four principles deducible from the judgment of Jiya Lal AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 we are unable to accept three.

    17. The first principle has been stated in para 9 of the judgment which reads as under:

    “The language of Section 2 of the Act of 1851 is peremptory. The collection of tolls under the said provision is permissible only to meet the cost of construction of the bridge or its approach road. It can also be levied to meet any extraordinary repair which it is considered necessary to carry out in order to maintain the stability of the bridge or road, as the case may be.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    18. Section 2 of the Act itself contains no such limitation. Section 2 enables the State Government to levy toll at such rates “as it thinks fit”. It is only with reference to the jurisprudential meaning of the word “toll” that the State Government must justify the levy with reference to the benefit conferred on the public by the construction of the bridge. Besides, Jiya Lal case AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 did not at all consider the contents of the 1976 notification.

    19. The second principle has been enunciated in para 11 of the judgment as:

    “Construction of roads and bridges is a part of the welfare activity of the State. In order to promote trade, commerce and free intercourse, it is incumbent on the State to construct more roads and bridges. With a view to usher an era of prosperity and well being, this activity must continue to be performed by the State. If a road or bridge, as the case may be, is constructed by the State from its general revenues, it is not called upon to pay interest to anybody. In making the constructions, the revenues of the State are being legitimately spent in fostering the well being of the people. There may be cases where in order to construct a bridge or a road, the Government or its instrumentality borrows money from a financial institution and agrees to pay interest thereon. It is only in such case that the interest paid by the Government or its instrumentality can be said to be included in the cost of the construction of the bridge or road.”
    (emphasis supplied)

    20. Apart from the observations being contrary to the express language of the 1976 notification issued by the State Government, the limitation on the power of the State Government to recoup fully the investment made overlooks the power conferred on the State Government generally to levy toll as a means of revenue collection under Article 246 Entry 59 of List II Schedule VII of the Constitution. The notification in terms allows toll to be levied so as to recover the cost of construction including interest on the “total expenditure” of the bridge. No distinction has been drawn between expenditure incurred out of the State Government's own revenue and expenditure incurred by borrowing money from financial institutions and others. Para III(b), although unhappily drafted, also allows the Government to recover interest on all “amounts invested” in the construction of the bridge. It, however, clarifies that if the investment is made with borrowed money and the borrowed money is repayable in instalments, then interest shall be charged only on the balance of the borrowed sum after repayment of the instalment of the loan.

    21. The third principle enunciated in Jiya Lal case AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 is found in para 12 of the judgment:

    “The collection of tolls has necessarily to be entrusted to a separate staff and the cost incurred in employing such staff is a legitimate charge which should be taken into account in working out the actual amount realised by the Government towards the cost of construction.”

    22. There can be no quarrel with this proposition except that in the case before us, no recovery was sought to be made under this head as the collection of tolls has been leased out to a private agency. The cost of stationery which the State Government has included is not shown to fall within the definition of the phrase “expenditure in realisation of toll” in para III(a) of the section.

    23. The fourth and final principle enunciated in Jiya Lal case AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 has been set out in para 13 of the judgment:

    “There is a real distinction between the cost incurred in the maintenance and the repair of a structure. The maintenance of a structure is a routine activity which has to be distinguished from its repairs. ‘Maintenance’ means ‘to preserve or to keep in good condition’. The object of the maintenance of a structure is to prevent its falling into decay. On the other hand, the word ‘repair’ indicates the restoration to a good and sound condition of a structure which has been decayed or damaged. Section 2 of the Act of 1851 permits the levy of toll only if the road or bridge is repaired. It does not contemplate of a levy of toll merely on the ground of its maintenance. We are, therefore, of the opinion that the amount spent towards the cost of the construction of a bridge will not include any sum which had been spent in its maintenance. No toll is chargeable under Section 2 of the Act of 1851 to meet the expenses incurred in the maintenance.”
    (emphasis added)

    24. As already noted, Section 2 of the Act does not in any way restrict the discretion of the State Government to levy toll. It only sets out the preconditions when toll may be levied. Neither of the preconditions set the limit on the amount of toll which may be recovered. The only restriction is latent in the word “toll” itself. The maintenance of the bridge in a good condition is certainly a benefit the cost of which may validly be recovered by the levy of toll. We are also of the view that the distinction sought to be drawn between “maintenance” and “repair” in the context of construction is virtually without any difference. For maintaining a bridge one would have to keep it in good repair and by repairing a bridge it is also maintained. Finally, and in any event, the cost of maintenance is expressly recoverable under the 1976 notification, which, as already noted, was not the subject-matter of challenge at any stage of these proceedings.

    25. We have been informed by learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants that during the pendency of these appeals the State Government has stopped collecting any toll tax in respect of the Gai Ghat Bridge. Even if that be so, it is necessary to resolve the issues raised, albeit to operate prospectively, as it would not do to allow the principles enunciated in Jiya Lal AIR 1981 All 72, 1981 UPTC 470 to continue to hold the field.

    26. In the circumstances, we dispose of the appeals by setting aside the impugned orders of the High Court but at the same time declaring that the State Government may not hereafter take into account for the purpose of levying any toll under the notification in respect of a road or bridge constructed by it, stationery cost (unless incurred in realisation of the toll), interest on stationery cost and maintenance, and interest on the interest payable on account of the actual expenditure incurred in the construction of the road or bridge. There will be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of U.P And Others v. Devi Dayal Singh .
    (Feb 25, 2000)