Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 4(1) of the Probation of Offenders Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 4(1) of the Probation of Offenders Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

On 9 October 1982, at approximately 6:00 p.m., Panchu attempted to draw water from a common well to irrigate his land. Respondent Hanuman, along with co-accused Ganesh and Ram Kumar, objected. Ganesh allegedly held Panchu while Hanuman struck Panchu’s head three times with an axe. When Panchu’s wife, Smt Badam, and his sister, Chhoti, intervened, Ram Kumar assaulted them with a kassi. After the assailants fled, Panchu was taken first to his home and then to the Government Hospital at Kishangarh, where he was declared dead. Chhoti and Smt Badam also sustained injuries.

An FIR was lodged the same night, and police filed a charge-sheet under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC, and Sections 323 and 324 IPC, against Hanuman, Ganesh, and Ram Kumar. The Sessions Judge, Ajmer, convicted Hanuman of murder (Section 302 IPC) and sentenced him to life imprisonment with a ₹1,000 fine; Ram Kumar was convicted of lesser offences and granted probation; Ganesh was acquitted. Hanuman appealed, and the Rajasthan High Court acquitted him, primarily doubting the credibility of the eyewitnesses and noting the prosecution’s failure to explain injuries on Hanuman. The State of Rajasthan appealed that acquittal, leading to the present Supreme Court decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court erred in discarding the testimony of the two eyewitnesses, Smt Badam (PW-2) and Chhoti (PW-1), on the grounds that they were related to the deceased and their versions allegedly conflicted with medical evidence.
  2. Whether an unexplained injury on the accused mandated rejection of the prosecution case in the circumstances of this matter.
  3. Consequently, whether the acquittal of Hanuman under Section 302 IPC by the High Court should be sustained or set aside.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant — State of Rajasthan

  • The High Court wrongly treated related eyewitnesses as unreliable solely due to their relationship with the deceased.
  • There is no real conflict between the medical evidence and the ocular testimony; one fatal head injury could still result from multiple axe blows, especially if delivered with the blunt side of the weapon.
  • The prosecution was not obliged to explain every minor injury on the accused; the defence version alleging self-inflicted or incidental injuries was unsubstantiated and had already been rejected by the trial court.

Respondent — Hanuman

  • The eyewitnesses are highly interested relatives whose testimony should be viewed with suspicion.
  • The doctor found only one head injury, contradicting the claim of three axe blows.
  • The prosecution failed to explain injuries suffered by Hanuman, casting doubt on its version and supporting the defence claim that Panchu was the aggressor.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court scrutinised both the Sessions Court and High Court judgments. It reaffirmed the settled principle that testimony of related witnesses cannot be discarded merely due to the relationship, absent cogent reasons indicating false implication. The Court noted:

  • Both eyewitnesses, whose presence at the scene was undisputed, gave clear, consistent accounts, and cross-examination failed to undermine their credibility. The trial judge, who observed their demeanour, had rightly relied on them.
  • Medical evidence did not actually contradict the ocular version. Dr C.L. Sharma (PW-5) recorded a fatal lacerated wound capable of being caused by the blunt side of an axe, as well as additional abrasions. The Sessions Judge’s view that possibly only one effective blow landed was considered a minor variance, insufficient to negate the eyewitness account.
  • Regarding injuries on Hanuman, the Court reiterated that the prosecution need not invariably explain such injuries. The trial court had already found the defence story—that Panchu attacked first and sustained injury by falling on a stone—unreliable. The High Court failed to engage with those findings or the defence evidence before reversing the conviction.
  • The appellate duty requires re-appraisal of evidence to test the trial court’s conclusions; however, those conclusions should not be overturned without demonstrable misappreciation or perversity, which the Supreme Court found absent.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Allowed; High Court acquittal set aside. The conviction of Hanuman under Section 302 IPC and the sentence of life imprisonment with a ₹1,000 fine, as imposed by the Sessions Judge, are restored.

Implications: The immediate effect is reinstatement of Hanuman’s conviction and sentence. The decision reinforces established principles that (a) related eyewitnesses are not inherently unreliable, (b) minor variances between ocular and medical evidence do not automatically vitiate the prosecution case, and (c) failure to explain trivial injuries on the accused does not, in every instance, defeat the prosecution.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    State Of Rajasthan v. Hanuman .

    D.P Mohapatra, J.— This appeal filed by the State of Rajasthan is directed against the judgment of the High Court of Rajasthan in Criminal Appeal No. 147 of 1985 acquitting the respondent Hanuman of the charge under Section 302 IPC on setting aside the judgment and order of conviction passed by the learned Sessions Judge, Ajmer, in Sessions Case No. 49 of 1983.

    2. Shorn of unnecessary details the prosecution case may be stated thus:

    On 9-10-1982 at about 6.00 p.m when Panchu, the deceased tried to draw water from the common well to irrigate his lands and change the course of the water towards his fields the respondent Hanuman and co-accused Ganesh and Ram Kumar forbade him from doing so. Ganesh caught hold of Panchu and Hanuman gave three blows on his head with an axe held by him. When Smt Badam, wife of Panchu and his sister Chhoti intervened to save him from the assault of Hanuman, Ram Kumar assaulted them with a kassi. On hearing the cry of Chhoti, Arjun came to the spot from the field nearby and on seeing him the accused persons fled away. Chhoti immediately rushed home and reported the incident to her brother Balu who on reaching the spot found Panchu lying on the ground with serious head injury. He took Panchu home in a cart and from there he was taken to the government hospital at Kishangarh where the doctors declared him dead. Smt Badam and Chhoti who had also sustained injuries, accompanied Panchu to the hospital. They were examined by Dr C.L Sharma (PW 5) who also conducted the autopsy on Panchu. Balu lodged an FIR in Kishangarh Police Station at about 10.00 p.m on 9-10-1982. The police sprung into action, conducted investigation and on completion of the investigation charge-sheet was submitted under Section 302 read with Section 34, and Sections 323 and 324 against Hanuman, Ganesh and Ram Kumar.

    3. The accused persons having denied the charges, faced trial.

    4. The prosecution examined in all 12 witnesses including Chhoti, PW 1 and Smt Badam, PW 2, who are the eyewitnesses to the occurrence, Balu, PW 3 and Arjun, PW 6 who are post-occurrence witnesses, Dr C.L Sharma, PW 5, who conducted the post-mortem examination and Dayal Singh, PW 10, and the investigating officer. The learned Sessions Judge on appreciation of the evidence accepted the ocular evidence of PWs 1 and 2 which was corroborated by the medical evidence and convicted Hanuman, the respondent herein, under Section 302 IPC and sentenced him to life imprisonment and a fine of Rs 1000, acquitted the accused Ram Kumar of the charge under Section 302 read with Section 34 IPC but held him guilty under Sections 323 and 324 IPC and gave him benefit of Section 4(1) of the Probation of Offenders Act subject to the condition that he produces one surety of Rs 1000 and more surety with the condition that he will maintain good conduct for a period of one year and will not disturb the peace and will present himself for suffering the punishment whenever required. The accused Ganesh was acquitted of all the charges framed against him.

    5. Against the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge the accused Hanuman filed the appeal in the High Court which was disposed of by the impugned judgment in the manner noted earlier.

    6. The High Court set aside the judgment of the learned Sessions Judge on two grounds — that both the eyewitnesses PWs 1 and 2 are highly interested persons and since their evidence is in direct conflict with the medical evidence the same cannot be relied upon, and that the prosecution has not explained the injuries found on the accused persons.

    7. We have carefully perused the judgments passed by the learned Sessions Judge and by the High Court. We are of the view that both the reasons stated by the High Court in the impugned judgment are unsustainable. The position is well settled that evidence of eyewitnesses cannot be discarded merely on the ground that they are relatives of the deceased. Normally close relations of the deceased are not likely to falsely implicate a person in the incident leading to the death of the relation unless there are very strong and cogent reasons to accept such criticism. Further, from the testimony of the two ladies Smt Badam and Chhoti whose presence at the spot was not disputed by the defence, it is clear that they have described the incident in a clear and graphic manner. They have categorically asserted that respondent Hanuman gave three blows with his axe on the head of Panchu. Though the witnesses were subject to searching cross-examination nothing material could be elicited from them which may cast a doubt on their credibility. The learned trial Judge who had the opportunity of marking their demeanour in the court assessed their evidence and did not find any good reason to discard their testimony. In the circumstance the High Court committed an error in discarding their testimony on this ground.

    8. The other question that arises is whether the ocular evidence of PWs 1 and 2 is against the medical evidence in the case. The High Court has answered the question in the affirmative going by the statement of the two eyewitnesses that Hanuman gave three blows on the head of the deceased Panchu with the axe but the doctor, PW 5 found only one injury on the head of the deceased. PW 5 found the following injuries on the deceased:

    “(i) Lacerated wound of (sic) cm × 2.5 cm bone-deep on the occipital region at skull in oblique direction with multiple fractures of occipital bone in small pieces with a cut 2-cm long on skull. Small portion of brain was also seen.
    (ii) The small abrasions on the left side of forehead over an area of 4 cm × 4 cm.
    (iii) Abrasions 1.5 cm × 1 cm on the roof of nose. All the above injuries were ante-mortem in nature. As per external injury with a little clot under the scalp there were multiple fractures of the occipital bone. There was laceration of membranes under Injury 1. There was a laceration 4 cm × 2 cm × 2 cm on brain in the occipital region just below Injury 1 with a blood clot. The cause of death was shock due to severe haemorrhage from laceration of brain and multiple fracture of occipital bone. The above injuries were inflicted by a blunt weapon. These injuries could be inflicted by the blunt side of a spade or an axe. Injury 1 was sufficient in the ordinary nature to cause death.”

    9. From the evidence of PW 5 it is clear that the injury found on the head of the deceased was possible if the blow was struck with the blunt side of the axe and the said injury was sufficient in ordinary course to cause death. The learned Sessions Judge adverting to the contention of the defence regarding improbability of the version of the eyewitnesses observed that their statement to the effect that three blows with the axe dealt on the head of the deceased cannot be correct and it appears that only a single blow was given on the head. It is relevant to note here that other injuries have also been found by the doctor on the face and shoulder of the deceased. Reading the statement of the eyewitnesses and the evidence of the doctor we do not find any serious contradiction between the two which may form the basis for discarding the testimony of the eyewitnesses. The High Court, in our view, was clearly in error in rejecting the ocular evidence on that ground.

    10. Coming to the other reason stated in the judgment under challenge that the prosecution has not explained the injuries found on the respondent Hanuman the learned trial Judge had considered this question. The High Court did not accept the contention of the prosecution that there is no acceptable evidence to show that Hanuman suffered the said injuries in course of the incident giving rise to the criminal case and also that the injuries are minor in nature.

    11. The High Court did not deal with the reasons given by the trial court before casting a doubt on the prosecution case making a general observation that it has not explained the injuries found on the respondent Hanuman. The prosecution is not bound to explain the injuries found on the accused in all cases. It is to be kept in mind that according to the defence case the occurrence took place when the respondent Hanuman wanted to use the facility of drawing water from the tubewell when his turn came at 6.00 p.m on the fateful day, then Panchu assaulted him with a lathi whereafter Hanuman in his defence pushed him and Panchu fell on the ground hitting a stone which resulted in the head injury supplied by him. It was the further case of the defence that the two ladies PWs 1 and 2 pelted stones on the accused persons causing injuries to them. The learned trial Judge on discussion of the evidence of the witnesses examined on behalf of the defence had discarded the defence version. The High Court has neither discussed the evidence of the defence witnesses nor given any reason for not accepting the finding of the trial court in this regard, but merely observed that the prosecution having failed to explain the injuries on the respondent Hanuman, its case cannot be accepted. No doubt the appellate court should assess the evidence on record with a view to satisfy itself that the appreciation of evidence by the trial court is not vitiated on account of any erroneous approach or illegality and it is not palpably erroneous. The sustainability of the judgment depends on the soundness of the reasons given in support of the findings and the conclusion.

    12. On the discussions and for the reasons stated in the foregoing paragraphs the appeal is allowed, impugned judgment is set aside and the judgment of the trial court convicting respondent Hanuman under Section 302 IPC and sentencing him to undergo rigorous imprisonment for life and a fine of Rs 1000 is restored.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    State Of Rajasthan v. Hanuman .
    (Dec 4, 2000)