Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub rule (1) of Rule 14 of the Rajasthan Panchayat and Nyaya Panchayat (General) Rules, 1961 (hereinafter referred
  • 13, 197;(2) under sub-sec. (2) of sec. 19 of the Rajasthan Panchayat Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Sub-sec. (36) of sec. 3 of the Rajasthan Municipalities Act
  • provisions of sub rule (1) of Rule 14
  • sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 of the Rules
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 12
  • Rule 15 of the Rules,
  • Rule 12 of the Rules
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub rule (1) of Rule 14 of the Rajasthan Panchayat and Nyaya Panchayat (General) Rules, 1961 (hereinafter referred
  • 13, 197;(2) under sub-sec. (2) of sec. 19 of the Rajasthan Panchayat Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred to as the Act)
  • Sub-sec. (36) of sec. 3 of the Rajasthan Municipalities Act
  • provisions of sub rule (1) of Rule 14
  • sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 of the Rules
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 12
  • Rule 15 of the Rules,
  • Rule 12 of the Rules
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Gupta, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was the elected Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat, Sildar (Tehsil Sirohi). The State Government had fixed the total strength of the Gram Panchayat as 13 Panchas, besides a Sarpanch. On 28 July 1971, eight Panchas served a notice of a motion of no-confidence against the petitioner; the notice was presented to the Collector, Sirohi. The Collector forwarded the notice to the Deputy District Development Officer (D.D.D.O.), who was the competent authority. The D.D.D.O. called a special meeting of the Panchayat for 13 September 1971 and authorized the Tehsildar to preside. Notices for the meeting were sent from the D.D.D.O.'s office to all members, including the petitioner.

The meeting was held on 13 September 1971; eleven members (including the petitioner) attended. Ten Panchas voted against the petitioner and the petitioner alone dissented, resulting in the motion being carried by ten votes to one. The petitioner objected to (a) participation by two Panchas (Durjan Singh and Gulaba) on grounds they had ceased to hold office due to non-attendance; (b) the view that 3/4 of the total strength was required (arguing that the required majority would have been eleven votes); and (c) that the notice of motion was not delivered to the D.D.D.O. as required by the Rules because it was presented to the Collector.

The Tehsildar rejected these objections in a considered order. The petitioner filed the present writ petition under Article 226 challenging the Tehsildar's decision upholding that the motion of no-confidence was carried.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether two Panchas (Durjan Singh and Gulaba) had ceased to hold office for non-attendance and therefore were ineligible to participate and vote at the 13 September 1971 meeting.
  2. Whether the motion of no-confidence required the assent of 3/4 of the total strength of the Gram Panchayat as fixed by the State Government (claimed to be 14), or 3/4 of the total number of Panchas holding office at the relevant time.
  3. Whether the notice of motion of no-confidence was invalid because it was presented to the Collector rather than delivered to the D.D.D.O. as required by sub-rule (1) of Rule 14 of the Rajasthan Panchayat and Nyaya Panchayat (General) Rules, 1961.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • Durjan Singh and Gulaba had remained absent from five consecutive meetings (including a fifth meeting on 24 November 1963) and therefore had ceased to hold the office of Panch under sub-sec. (2) of Section 17 of the Rajasthan Panchayat Act, 1953 and related Rules; they should have been excluded from voting.
  • Section 19(2) required a majority of not less than three-fourths of the total number of Panchas, including the Sarpanch; because the total number of members of the Gram Panchayat was 14, the petitioner contended 11 votes were necessary and the ten votes for the motion were insufficient.
  • The notice of motion of no-confidence was neither addressed to nor delivered to the D.D.D.O. by the eight Panchas as mandated by sub-rule (1) of Rule 14; since it had been presented to the Collector instead, the notice was illegal and invalid.

Respondents' Position (as recorded in the opinion)

  • The respondents accepted in their reply that the notice of motion of no-confidence was presented to the Collector, who forwarded it to the D.D.D.O.
  • Proceedings were taken by the competent authority (the D.D.D.O.) after the notice reached him, notices for the special meeting were issued, and the meeting was held where the votes were cast.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Nand Ram v. The State of Rajasthan That disqualification under sub-section (2) of Section 17 (cessation of office for absence) is not automatic after five absences; Rule 12's procedure and a declaration are required. The Court relied on this decision to hold that absent Panchas do not cease to hold office automatically; in the absence of due service of notices under Rule 12 and a declaration by the D.D.D.O., Durjan Singh and Gulaba continued to hold office and could vote.
Banshidhar v. State of Rajasthan Interpretation that the phrase “total number of Panchas” in sec. 19(2) refers to the total number of members holding office at the relevant time (including the Sarpanch). The Court adopted this principle to determine that the requisite three-fourths majority should be calculated with reference to members holding office at the relevant time, not the strength fixed by the State Government.
Chander Singh v. The Collector, Sikar Support for the view that “total number of members” refers to members holding office at the relevant time. The Court cited this single-judge decision as further authoritative support for calculating the three-fourths majority with reference to members in office on the date of voting.
Nandlal v. The State of Rajasthan (Sachar J.) Reiteration by Sachar J. of the interpretation that “total number of Panchas” means those holding office at the relevant time. The Court cited this later decision to confirm the settled nature of the interpretation used to calculate the requisite majority under Section 19(2).
Bhoore Khan v. The State of Rajasthan The principle that courts should be reluctant to entertain technical pleas to allow a person who has lost the confidence of a democratic institution to retain office; judicial relief by writ is discretionary and not to be used to subvert the expressed will of the majority. The Court applied this democratic principle to refuse to overturn the result of a clear majority vote on purely technical grounds and to justify reluctance to assist the petitioner under Article 226.
Bhure Khan v. State of Rajasthan (Division Bench on appeal) Confirmation on appeal of the approach that courts should not aid a person who has lost the confidence of a Panchayat by technicalities. The Court relied on the appellate confirmation of Bhoore/Bhure Khan to underscore the institutional reluctance to reverse a majority decision of a Panchayat on technical grounds.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court considered the petitioner's three objections in sequence and applied statutory provisions and prior authorities as follows.

1. Eligibility of Durjan Singh and Gulaba to Vote

- Sub-section (2) of Section 17 of the Rajasthan Panchayat Act provides that a Panch who absents himself from five consecutive meetings without giving written information shall cease to hold office. However, the Rules (Rule 12) prescribe an elaborate procedure before a seat is declared vacant: after four absences a notice must be served informing the absentee that his seat will become vacant if he fails to attend the fifth meeting; if the absentee then fails to attend, the Panchayat must pass a resolution and send the record to the D.D.D.O.; the D.D.D.O. must then consider the record, make any necessary enquiry after giving the member an opportunity of hearing, and then declare the seat vacant.

- Sub-rule (3) of Rule 12 provides that if an absentee refuses to receive notice, the notice may be deemed served by affixing it at a conspicuous place of his dwelling in the presence of two local witnesses. In the present case no such affixation was proved.

- There was no proof produced before the Court that notices were duly served on Durjan Singh and Gulaba in accordance with Rule 12, nor any declaration by the D.D.D.O. under sub-rule (5) that their seats had become vacant.

- Relying on Nand Ram v. State of Rajasthan, the Court held the disqualification under Section 17(2) is not automatic and follows only after the Rule 12 procedure and a declaration by the D.D.D.O. Accordingly, Durjan Singh and Gulaba continued to hold office and were entitled to vote at the 13 September 1971 meeting.

2. Proper Basis for Calculating the Required 3/4 Majority

- The Court examined the meaning of “total number of Panchas” in Section 19(2). It relied on prior decisions (Banshidhar; Chander Singh; and Nandlal) and statutory cross-references (sec. 2(16) of the Act and sub-sec. (36) of sec. 3 of the Rajasthan Municipalities Act as cited) to conclude that the phrase refers to the total number of members holding office at the relevant time (including the Sarpanch), not the total strength fixed by the State Government.

- It was undisputed that on 13 September 1971 the total number of Panchas holding office was 12 (including the Sarpanch) because one Panch had died and another resigned. Three-fourths of 12 is nine; ten Panchas voted in favour of the motion. The Court therefore concluded the motion met the requisite three-fourths majority and was properly carried.

3. Validity of the Notice of Motion (Presentation to Collector vs. Delivery to D.D.D.O.)

- Sub-rule (1) of Rule 14 requires that a notice of motion of no-confidence in writing shall be delivered or caused to be delivered to the D.D.D.O. The Rule allows either personal delivery by the mover or that the mover may cause it to be delivered.

- In the present case the notice was presented to the Collector, who forwarded it to the D.D.D.O. The respondents admitted these facts in their reply, and the D.D.D.O. proceeded on the basis of the notice (calling and issuing notices for a special meeting under Rule 15).

- The Court held the requirement of Rule 14(1) was substantially complied with because the movers had “caused” the notice to reach the competent authority: forwarding by the Collector resulted in the notice reaching the D.D.D.O., who took action on it. Any irregularity in presentation was therefore merely technical.

Consideration of Institutional and Discretionary Principles

- The Court reiterated the democratic principle, supported by Bhoore/Bhure Khan decisions, that courts should be slow to use extraordinary writ jurisdiction to protect an office-holder who has lost the confidence of an overwhelming majority of the members of a democratic institution. The Court emphasized reluctance under Article 226 to assist such person by technicalities.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition is DISMISSED. The Court upheld the Tehsildar's conclusions that (a) Durjan Singh and Gulaba had not ceased to hold office in the absence of due service and a declaration by the D.D.D.O.; (b) the three-fourths majority required by Section 19(2) is to be calculated with reference to the total number of Panchas holding office at the relevant time (including the Sarpanch), and the motion satisfied that requirement; and (c) the notice of motion, though presented to the Collector and forwarded, was substantially delivered to the competent authority and any irregularity was merely technical.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the motion of no-confidence carried by ten votes to one stands, and the petitioner’s writ challenging that result is dismissed.
  • The decision applies and reinforces existing interpretative rulings concerning (i) the procedural requirements under Rule 12 for declaring a Panch seat vacant and (ii) the construction of “total number of Panchas” in Section 19(2) as referring to members holding office at the relevant time. The Court declined to overturn the Panchayat's clear majority verdict on technical grounds.
  • The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel principle of law beyond applying settled authorities; its result is the direct affirmation of the Tehsildar's order and the vindication of the Panchayat's majority decision.

This summary is strictly confined to the statements and holdings contained in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.

    Bhawani Singh v. The State Of Rajasthan

    Gupta, J.:— The facts of this case lie in a narrow compass. The petitioner was elected as a Sarpanch of the Gram Panchayat, Sildar in Tehsil Sirohi. The total strength of the aforesaid Gram Panchayat as fixed by the State Government is 13 Panchas, besides a Sarpanch. On July 28, 1971, eight of the Panchas of Gram Panchayat, Sildar gave notice of a motion of no confidence against the petitioner in respect of the office of Sarpanch. The aforesaid notice of motion of no confidence was addressed to the Collector, Sirohi and the case of the petitioner is that it was presented by the eight Panchas before the Collector, Sirohi. It appears that the Collector forwarded the aforesaid notice of motion of no-confidence to be the Deputy District Development Officer, (hereinafter referred to as ‘the D.D.D.O’) Sirohi who was the compent authority in the matter and the D.D.D.O on receiving the aforesaid notice of motion of no-confidence, called a special meeting of the Panchayat on September 13, 1971 for consideration of the motion of no confidence and authorised the Tehsildar, Sirohi, to preside over the said meeting of the Gram Panchayat. Notices in respect of holding of the special meeting of the Panchayat for considering the motion of no confidence against the petitioner from the office of Sarpanch were sent by D.D.D.O to all the members of the Gram Panchayat, Sildar, including the petitioner. The meeting took place on September 13, 1971 as scheduled and 11 members of the Panchayat, including the petitioner, were present at the said meeting, out of whom, ten Panchas cast their votes against the petitioner, while the petitioner was the lone dissenter. The result was that the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner was carried by ten votes to one.

    2. The petitioner raised the following, three objections before the Tehsildar, Sirohi, who presided over the aforesaid meeting of the Panchayat, convened to consider the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner, namely:—

    (1) two of the Panchas, Durjan Singh and Gulaba had ceased to hold the office of Panchas and as such, they were not eligible to take part in the proceedings of the Panchayat and they should have been excluded from the said meeting held on September 13, 197;

    (2) under sub-sec. (2) of sec. 19 of the Rajasthan Panchayat Act, 1953 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’) the motion of no-confidence against a Sarpanch must be carried by majority of not less than ¾th of the total number of Panchas, including the Sarpanch and as the total number of members of the Gram Panchayat, Sildar was 14 the minimum number of Panchas who should have voted in favour of the motion of no-confidence so that the same could be carried, should have been at least 11. As only ten Panchas had voted in favour of the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner, it could not be declared to have been carried; and

    (3) the notice to move the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner was neither addressed to nor it was delivered to the Deputy District Development Officer by the eight Panchas, as required by sub rule (1) of Rule 14 of the Rajasthan Panchayat and Nyaya Panchayat (General) Rules, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Rules’) and as such the said notice was illegal and invalid.

    3. All these three submissions made by the petitioner were held to be untenable by the Tehsildar, who wrote a rather well considered order rejecting these objections. In the present writ petition, which has been filed by the petitioner in this Court challenging the aforesaid decision of the Tehsildar, Sirohi holding that the motion of no-confidence was carried against the petitioner, the very same three grounds which were urged by the petitioner before the Tehsildar have been reiterated. I shall presently consider the said three grounds in seriatim.

    4. As regards the first contention, it was argued by the learned counsel that two of the Panchas namely, Durjan Singh and Gulaba did not attend four consecutive meetings of the Panchayat and as such, they were removed from the membership of the Panchayat and they ceased to hold office as Panchas because they remained absent even in the fifth meeting of the Panchayat held on November 24, 1963.

    5. The submission of the learned counsel is that on account of the aforesaid two persons remaining absent in five consecutive meetings of the Panchayat, their seats became vacant and these two persons could not have taken part in the meeting of the Gram Panchayat held on September 13, 1978 at which the motion of no-confidence was passed against the petitioner. The Tehsildar, Sirohi rejected this contention on the ground that it was not proved before him that motion in accordance with the rules were duly served on the two absentes Panchas and as no declaration was made by the D.D.D.O that the seats of such Panchas had become vacant, it cannot be held that the aforesaid two persons ceased to hold office of Panchas in the absence of such a declaration. In this petition, the very same allegations have been repeated by the petitioner but no proof has been produced on behalf of the petitioner even before this Court to show that the absentee Panchas namely, Durjan Singh and Gulaba were duly served with notices in accordance with Rule 12 of the Rules nor it has been shown that the D.D.D.O made any declaration to the effect that the seats of the aforesaid two persons have become vacant. It cannot, therefore, be held that the two persons had ceased to hold office of Panchas as alleged by the petitioner.

    6. Sub-sec. (2) of Section 17 of the Act provides that if a Panch, during the term of his office absents himself from five consecutive meetings of the Panchayat without giving information in writing to the Panchayat, he shall scese to hold office of a Punch. However, alaborate procedure in this respect has been laid down in Rule 12 of the Rules, which requires that after a Panch absents himself in four consecutive meetings of the Panchayat and before the fifth meeting takes place, a notice shall be given to the absentee Panch informing him that he has not attended four immediately preceding meetings inspite of due notice and that his seat would become Vacant if he does not attend the fifth meeting. If, after Such notice is duly served upon the absentee Panch, he fails to attend the fifth meeting, the Panchayat shall pass a resolution to the effect that the absentee Panch has remained absent from five consecutive meetings of the Panchayat. The resolution along with the concerned record shall then he sent to the D.D.D.O, who shall serutingze the record, consider the recommendation of the Panchayat and after making such further enquiry as he may consider necessary, and after giving the absentee member an opportunity of hearing, the DDCO shall declare such meet to have become vacant. In the present case, it appears from the order passed by the Tehsildar, Sirohi that the notices were not duly served on the two absentee members and they are alleged to have orally refused to receive such notices. However, sub-rule (3) of Rule 12 provides that in case the absentee member refuses to receive such notice, then it shall be deemed to be duly served if the messenger affixes the said notice at some conspicuous place of his dwelling house, in the presence of two witnesses of the locality. No affixation is allegal to have been made in the present case on the refusal of the absentee Panchas to receive the notices in question and, therefore, it cannot be held that there was proper notice to Durjan Singh and Gulaba, who are alleged to have absented themselves in the earlier four meetings of the Panchayat. Moreover, it is also not disputed that the D.D.D.O did not make any declaration under sub-rule (5) of Rule 12 of the Rules to the effect that the seats of the aforesaid two persons have become vacant In the absence ol such a declaration, the two persons named above cannot be deemed to have ceased to held office of Panshes. In Nand Ram v. The State of Rajasthan (1), it was held by this Court that after the coming into force of Rule 12 of the Rules, the disqualification specified in sub-section (2) of Section 17 of the Act is not automatic but it could be incurred only after a declaration is made to that effect. Thus, in the absence of due service on the two absentee Panchas and in the absence of a proper declaration by the D.D.D.O Durjan Singh and Gulaba continued to hold the office of Panchas and they could take part in the voting in respect of motion of no-confidence against the petitioner.

    7. As for the second submission of the learned counsel, the matter now stands well settled. In Banshidhar v. State of Rajasthan (2), it was held by this Court that the expression “total number of Panrhas” occurring in sub-section (2) of Sec. 19 of the Act referred to the total number of members of the Panchayat, including the Sarpanch, holding office at the relevant time. The aforesaid wards have not been defined in the Act, but in sec. 2(16) of the Act, it has been provided that words and expressions used but not defined in it and defined in the Rajasthan Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads Act, shall have the meanings assigned to them in that Act Similarly, sec. 2(16) of the Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads Act also lays down that words and expressions used therein but not defined in that Act shall have the meaning assigned to them in the laws for the time being in force relating to the Panchayats, Municipalities and District Beards. Sub-sec. (36) of sec. 3 of the Rajasthan Municipalities Act defines a the words “whole number” or “total number”, when used with reference to the members of the Municipal Board, as referring to the total number of members holding office at the relevant time. The same view was also taken by another learned Single Judge of this Court in Chander Singh v. The Collector, Sikar and it was held that the expression “total number of members” in the Panchayat, used in sub-sec. (2) of sec. 19 of the Act refers to the total number of members of the Panchayat, holding office at the relevant time. Recently, the matter was again examined by Sachar J. in Nandlal v. The State of Rajasthan (4) and he also agreed with the view expressed by the two learned Judges of this Court in the earlier decisions referred to above Thus, there could be no doubt now that the expression “total number of Panchas” occuring in Section 19(2) of the Act should be taken to refer to the total number of Panchas, including the Sarpanch, holding office at the relevant time and not the total strength of the Gram Panchayat, as fixed by the State Government. It is not in dispute that the total number of Panchas holding office on September 13, 1971 when the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner was considered by the Panchayat was 12, including the Sarpanch, because one of the Panchas had expired and another had resigned from his office ¾th of the total number of Panchas voting for the motion of no-confidence could have carried the same, in accordance with the provisions of sub-section (2) of Section 19 of the Act. In the present case, ten Panchas had voted in favour of the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner and as such, it cannot be held that the said motion was not passed by the requisie 3/4 majority of the total number of Panchas, as provided in Sec. 19(2) of the Act.

    8. In respect of the third submission, the provisions of sub rule (1) of Rule 14 require that any Panch of a Panchayat, desiring to move a motion of no-confidence against its Sarpanch, shall deliver or cause to be delivered a notice of such motion in writing to the D.D.D.O The requirement of the Rule is that the notice of motion of no-confidence should be in writing and should be delivered either personally by any Panch desiring to move such motion to the D.D.D.O or should be caused by him to be delivered to the aforesaid officer. The notice of motion of no-confidence thus would not in any manner be invalidated merely because it was addressed to the Collector, Sirohi, The other submission in this respect is that the notice of motion of no-confidence was not delivered by the eight Panchas to the D.D.D.O, but it was delivered to the Collector and that it appears to have been forwarded by the Collector to the D.D.D.O The respondents in their reply have also accepted the fact that the notice of motion of no-confidence was presented to the Collector, who forwarded the same to the D.D.D.O In my view, the provisions of sub-rule (1) of Rule 14 were substantially complied with in the present case, in asmuch as the crux of the matter is that the notice of motion of no-confidence should either be delivered by the mover thereof personally to the D.D.D.O or the mover may cause it to be delivered to the said officer. In the present case, the notice of motion of no-confidance, though presented by the eight Panchas before the Collector, was forwarded by him to the competent authority, namely the D.D.D.O and thus it can be said that it was caused to be delivered by the movers of the said motion to the D.D.D.O Moreover, as the motion of no confidence actually reached the competent authority and he took proceedings in respect thereof and issued notices for holding a special meeting of the Panchayat for the consideration of the said motion of no-confidence, in accordance with Rule 15 of the Rules, the irregularity in the presentation of the motion, if any, was merely of a technical nature. It must be kept in view that out of eleven Panchas, who were present at the meeting to consider the motion of no-confidence, all voted against the petitioner, except the petitioner himself. In Bhoore Khan v. The State of Rajasthan (5), Joshi J. made the following observations:—

    “It is well settled principle of democracy that the person who has lost the confidence of the members of a democratic institution should not be allowed to stay against the will of the members of that institution. The writ of mandamus or certiorari does not issue as a matter of course but is a writ of discretionary nature. Looking to the facts and circumstances of the case, this Court is not at all inclined to entertain the plea of technical nature to permit the petitioner who has lost the confidence of the members of the Panchayat. This Court is, therefore, not disposes to help such a person in the exercise of its extra-ordinary jurisdiction.”

    9. This view was confirmed on appeal by a Division Bench of this Court in Bhure Khan v. State of Rajasthan (6), while dismissing the appeal of Bhure Khan. There is no doubt that in order to create healthy conventions for the functioning of democratic institutions in this country, this Court should be slow in helping a person in his attempt to stick to an elective office even after the unequivocal declaration by an overwhelming majority of the members that he has lost their confidence. The Court, in its extra-ordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, should be rather reluctant in helping such a person in his attempt to cling to an elective office. In the present case, as I have already mentioned above, ten out of twelve members of the Panchayat, holding office at the relevant time, had voted in favour of the motion of no-confidence against the petitioner and it would not be just and proper for this Court to interfere on a mere technical ground with the verdict of such a vast majority of the members of the Panchayat.

    10. In view of the aforesaid discussion, there is no merit in the writ petition and the same is hereby dismissed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhawani Singh v. The State Of Rajasthan
    (Apr 7, 1977)