Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 17 INDIAN REGISTRATION ACT
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C Compromise
  • Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • provisions of Order 23 of Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code
  • provisions of Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code.
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C,
  • provisions of Order 23 of the Code
  • Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C9. Consistent
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 23 of the Code
  • Rule 3(a) of Order 23 of the Code
  • Rule 1-A of Order 43 of the Code.
  • Rule 3 of Order 23 of the Code
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3
  • Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code
  • Section 93(3) of the Code
  • Section 96(1) of the Code,
  • Rule 1-A(2) of Order 43
  • Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Rule 3-A of Order 23.
  • Indian Contract Act
  • Rule 3 of Order 23
  • Order 23 Rule 3
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 17 INDIAN REGISTRATION ACT
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C Compromise
  • Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
  • provisions of Order 23 of Civil Procedure Code
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code
  • provisions of Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code.
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C,
  • provisions of Order 23 of the Code
  • Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C9. Consistent
  • sub-rule (3) of Rule 23 of the Code
  • Rule 3(a) of Order 23 of the Code
  • Rule 1-A of Order 43 of the Code.
  • Rule 3 of Order 23 of the Code
  • provisions of Order 23 Rule 3
  • Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code
  • Section 93(3) of the Code
  • Section 96(1) of the Code,
  • Rule 1-A(2) of Order 43
  • Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C
  • Rule 3-A of Order 23.
  • Indian Contract Act
  • Rule 3 of Order 23
  • Order 23 Rule 3
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This Regular Second Appeal was preferred by Chand Kaur (the appellant) against the judgment and decree dated 27.3.1995 of the learned Additional District Judge, Rup Nagar, which had affirmed the decree passed by the Additional Senior Sub Judge, Ropar dated 23.2.1995.

The appellant had instituted a suit for declaration that she is owner in possession of specified khasra/khewat/khatauni lands in village Barsalpur, Tehsil and District Ropar (entries in Jamabandi for 1983–1984 are set out in the record). The suit was contested by multiple defendant groups: (i) Raj Kaur (defendant No.1); (ii) Sadhu Singh and others (defendants No.2–7); and (iii) Jagir Singh and Karnail Singh (defendants No.8–9).

On 23.2.1995 the learned trial Court recorded ex parte proceedings against defendants No.2–7 because nobody appeared for them and, on the same day, recorded statements said to be indicative of a compromise and passed a decree allocating 1/3 share to the plaintiff (Chand Kaur), 1/3 to Raj Kaur (defendant No.1) and the remaining 1/3 to defendants No.8 and No.9 in equal shares; the decree as to defendants No.2–7 was ex parte. Defendant No.1 expired during the pendency of this appeal and applicants in C.M. No.1018-C of 1996 were permitted to be impleaded as intermeders.

Aggrieved by the trial Court's judgment and decree, Chand Kaur preferred a first appeal before the learned Additional District Judge, Rup Nagar. The First Appellate Court affirmed the decree, treating it as a consent (compromise) decree under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC (and alternatively as a decree under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC), and held the appeal not maintainable under Section 96 in that posture. The present Court (Swatanter Kumar, J.) heard this Regular Second Appeal and addressed the legal validity of the decree and the appellate court's approach.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the decree dated 23.2.1995 is a valid compromise decree under Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) when no written, signed compromise agreement was produced and some defendants were proceeded against ex parte on the same day.
  2. Whether mere recording of statements in Court (even if signed) satisfies the requirement of a written, signed compromise under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC.
  3. Whether the First Appellate Court erred in treating the trial court's decree as a decree on admission under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC.
  4. Whether a decree that creates new rights in immovable property for the first time must be stamped and registered under Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act, and the consequences of failure to do so.
  5. Whether an appeal against the decree was maintainable in light of the First Appellate Court's view that it was a consent decree under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • Chand Kaur asserted that her case was that she was owner in possession of the entire land and that she never made any statement conceding a lesser share.
  • She contended that no compromise as required by Order 23 CPC (in writing and signed) was recorded or produced; the trial Court could not lawfully pass a decree on the basis of an oral or casual recording of statements.
  • It was alleged that the Court itself initiated the terms of compromise and that the appellant, an apparently illiterate 60‑year‑old, was pressured into accepting terms without time or opportunity to reflect.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents relied upon a judgment of the Punjab & Haryana High Court (Smt. Raksha Rani @ Rakha Devi… v. Ram Lal) to contend that the decree was a consent decree under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC and therefore not appealable; they also argued that substantial compliance occurred because statements of the parties were recorded and signed in Court.
  • Other respondents (defendants No.2–7) stated that they had been contesting the suit and came to know of the decree only when notice of the present appeal was served; they expressed grievance and were said to be at liberty to take appropriate legal steps.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel, (1988) 1 SCC 270 (AIR 1988 SC 400) Rule: A compromise under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC must be in writing, signed by the parties, and constitute a completed agreement capable of being embodied in a decree. The Court relied on this Supreme Court decision to hold that a written, signed compromise is required and that mere reflection of terms in the order is insufficient; it treated the decision as authoritative.
Banwari Lal v. Chando Devi (through LRs), (1993) 1 SCC 581 (AIR 1993 SC 1139) Rule: The Court must apply its judicial mind before accepting a compromise; casual recording is insufficient; post-amendment remedies available to challenge recorded compromises. The Court cited the judgment to emphasize the requirement of judicial application of mind and to note that remedies exist to challenge compromises under the amended rules; used to reject the respondents' reliance on older local precedent.
Smt. Rani Bai v. Yadunandan Ram, (1969) 1 SCC 604 (AIR 1969 SC 1118) Rule: Indicates that where partial compromise prejudicially affects rights of non‑joining parties the compromise may not be recognized. The Court cited this authority to support the proposition that partial compromises affecting absent parties must be examined with caution and may be invalid.
Gopika Raman Roy v. Atal Singh, AIR 1926 Calcutta 193 (DB) Rule: Supports the view that compromises that prejudice non‑joining parties may not be acceptable. Used alongside Rani Bai to show precedents where partial compromises were not recognized because of prejudice to non‑consenting parties.
Manohar Lal v. Surjan Singh, 1991 (1) RRR 286 (P&H) Rule: Authority relied upon to support the proposition that a compromise decree must be preceded by a written compromise recording terms. The Court notes that the appellant relied upon this decision; it is recognised as authority cited by counsel though the opinion does not elaborate additional application beyond that reliance.
Sumer v. Vijay Singh, 1990 (1) RRR 214 (P&H) : 1990 P.L.J 68 Rule: Mere recording of statements (even if signed) is not sufficient compliance with Order 23 Rule 3 CPC. Quoted to support the proposition that recording of oral statements in Court does not substitute for a written signed compromise.
Sarup Chand v. Jagdish Chand, 1990 (2) RRR 90 (P&H) : 1990 P.L.J 366 Rule: Similar principle that settlements must be reduced to writing as required by Order 23 Rule 3 CPC. Relied on by the Court to underscore that mere court‑recorded statements do not satisfy the statutory requirement for a written compromise.
Manohar Parshad Kapoor v. Virendra Parshad, 1986 (1) Andhra Law Times 347 Rule: An endorsement or court endorsement alone cannot substitute for a bilateral agreement/compromise. The Court invoked this case to show that endorsement unaccompanied by a genuine agreement cannot form the basis of a lawful compromise decree.
Bhoop Singh v. Ram Singh Major, (1995) 5 SCC 709 Rule: Where a decree creates new rights in immovable property of value Rs.100 or above, the document is compulsorily registrable under Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act. The Court applied this principle to hold that the decree, which created rights for the first time, required registration and stamping; lack of registration/stamp means the decree does not presently vest rights.
Smt. Raksha Rani @ Rakha Devi v. Ram Lal…, 1986 (2) P.L.R. 504 Rule: Local authority held that consent decree under Order 23 Rule 3 is not appealable and that recording of statements may suffice. The respondents relied on this decision; the Court distinguished it and held it was not good law in view of subsequent Supreme Court pronouncements.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court first examined the record of the trial Court and concluded that the decree of 23.2.1995 is, on its face, a compromise decree between those parties who had their statements recorded on that date. The trial Court's order itself states that "Court has got effected compromise between the parties" and records statements accepting a division of the land in dispute. The decree was therefore passed on the basis of the alleged compromise.

The Court then set out the statutory scheme under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC and related explanations, stressing that the legislative intent is to require a lawful, written, and signed compromise before a Court may pass a decree on its basis. The Court emphasised several legal principles derived from the statutory provision and precedent:

  • The minimum prerequisite for a valid compromise under Order 23 Rule 3 is that it be a lawful agreement in writing, signed by the parties, and capable of being embodied in a decree.
  • The Court must record its satisfaction, after applying judicial mind, that the compromise is voluntary, lawful, and reflects true agreement (ad idem) free of pressure or influence.
  • The explanation to sub‑rule (3) clarifies that any agreement void or voidable under the Indian Contract Act cannot be treated as lawful for the purposes of Rule 3.
  • Mere oral statements recorded in Court, even if signed, do not substitute for the written instrument mandated by Rule 3; endorsements alone cannot be treated as a bilateral written compromise.

Applying those principles to the facts before it, the Court found multiple infirmities in the trial Court's handling of the matter:

  • Defendants No.2–7 were proceeded against ex parte on the same day, and yet the Court immediately recorded a compromise and passed a decree affecting their rights; this procedure prejudicially affected absent parties whose interests were intermingled with those of the parties who purportedly compromised.
  • No written compromise instrument signed by the parties was produced or exhibited; the terms of the alleged compromise were not recorded in a manner that satisfied the statutory requirements.
  • The circumstances suggested possible coercion or pressure upon the appellant (described as an illiterate 60‑year‑old) and a lack of time to consider the purported settlement; the Court noted the trial Court's language that "Court has got effected compromise between the parties," underscoring judicial initiation rather than voluntary meeting of minds.
  • The First Appellate Court's alternative conversion of the decree into a decree on admission under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC was incorrect in law because the record showed a decree based on a recorded compromise, and Order 12 Rule 6 applies only where a clear admission exists on record as to the claim; here, the trial Court recorded a compromise and did not pass a decree on admissions in pleading or otherwise.
  • The decree purportedly created new rights in immovable property for the first time and therefore fell within the scope of Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act; since the decree had not been stamped or registered as required, it did not presently vest any enforceable rights in favour of the decree‑holders.

On these bases the Court concluded that the trial Court had failed to comply with the mandatory safeguards required by Order 23 Rule 3 CPC and that the First Appellate Court erred in its legal characterization and conclusion regarding appealability and the nature of the decree.

Holding and Implications

Core Ruling: Judgments and decrees of both Courts below are set aside and the case is remanded to the trial Court for further proceedings.

Direct consequences and instructions given by the Court:

  • The judgments and decrees of the trial Court (dated 23.2.1995) and the First Appellate Court (dated 27.3.1995) are set aside.
  • The case is remanded to the trial Court to take further proceedings in accordance with law as on 23.2.1995; the parties are directed to appear before the trial Court on 29.8.1996.
  • There shall be no order as to costs.
  • The Court held that the First Appellate Court erred in treating the decree as one on admission under Order 12 Rule 6 CPC and in holding that the appeal was not maintainable as against a consent decree; the matter of appealability was addressed in light of subsequent Supreme Court rulings and amendments concerning remedies to challenge recorded compromises.
  • The Court further held that because the decree purported to create rights in immovable property for the first time, it was required to be stamped and registered under Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act; the decree had not been stamped or registered and thus did not vest rights in the decree‑holders at present.

No broader precedent beyond the legal principles applied was created by this single‑case disposition; the Court applied established principles under Order 23 Rule 3 CPC, Order 12 Rule 6 CPC, and Section 17 of the Registration Act and remanded the matter for proper application of those principles.

    Chand Kaur v. Raj Kaur

    Swatanter Kumar, J.:— Chand Kaur has preferred the Regular Second Appeal against the judgment and decree dated 27.3.1995 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Rup Nagar, affirming the decree passed by the Additional Senior Sub Judge, Ropar dated 23.2.1995

    2. As the present appeal raises substantial questions of law, it will be appropriate to refer to the necessary facts. The plaintiff Chand Kaur, hereinafter referred to as the appellant, had filed a suit for declaration that she is the owner in possession of the land comprising of Khewat/Khatauni No. 218/318, Khasra No. 34, 23/6/2, 8/4, 27//15/1, 15/2, Khewat Khatauni No. 219/319, 320, Khasra No. 23/14/1 min, 17/2, 23/14/1 min as entered in the Jamabandi for the year 1983–1984 of village Barsalpur, Tehsil and District Ropar.

    3. Defendant No. 1 Raj Kaur in the suit expired during the pendency of the present appeal and vide the order dated 7.3.1996 the Court had permitted the applicants in C.M No. 1018-C of 1996 to be impleaded as intermeders leaving the question of validity and any other challenges to the will open to be determined in appropriate proceedings.

    4. This suit was contested seriously by three different groups of defendants, namely, (i) Raj Kaur; (ii) Sadhu Singh and others being defendants No. 2 to 7 in the suit; and (iii) Jagir Singh and Karnail Singh defendants No. 8 and 9 in the suit. All these different sets of defendants had filed their respective written statements and were contesting the suit. The learned trial Court vide order dated 23.2.1995 passed an order directing ex parte proceedings to be taken against defendants No. 2 to 7 as nobody had appeared on their behalf in spite of the fact that the case had been called out time and again. Vide the same order the learned trial Court proceeded to decree the suit in favour of parties on the basis of a compromise. It will be appropriate to reproduce the judgment passed by the learned trial Court dated 23.2.1995 hereunder:—

    “None has appeared on behalf of defendants No. 2 to 7. Case called time and again. It is now 3.15 p.m Hence ex parte proceedings are taken against defendants No. 2 to 7.

    Case is fixed for evidence of the defendants and today is the last opportunity, but compromise between the parties has been effected. Statement of Chand Kaur plaintiff on S.A recorded. She has stated that Court has got effected compromise between the parties and as per the compromise she may be declared owner in possession to the extent of ⅓ share out of land in dispute, while Raj Kaur defendant No. 1 be declared owner in possession to the extent of 173 share out of the land in dispute and Jagir Singh and Karnail Singh defendants No. 8 and 9 be declared owners in possession in equal share of the remaining ⅓ share of the land in dispute and that suit be decided accordingly. Separate statement of Raj Kaur defendant No. 1 recorded. She has accepted the statement of Chand Kaur plaintiff and stated that suit be decided as per her statement. Separate statement of Darshan Singh attorney of Karnail Singh defendant No. 9 on S.A and Shri Bhupinder Singh Advocate counsel for the Defendants No. 8 and 9 also recorded. They have stated that they have heard the statements of Chand Kaur plaintiff and Raj Kaur defendant No. 1 and they accept the same as correct and suit be decided accordingly.

    In view of statements of the parties recorded today a decree for declaration that Chand Kaur plaintiff is owner in possession of the ⅓ share out of the land in dispute and that Raj Kaur @ Laj Wanti defendant No. 1 is owner in possession to the extent of ⅓ share out of the land in dispute and that defendants No. 8 and 9 are owners in possession in equal share of the remaining ⅓ share of the land in dispute, is passed in their favour and against defendants No. 2 and 7. Decree against defendants No. 2 and 7 is, however, ex parte. Parties are left to bear their own costs. Counsel fee is assessed at Rs. 500/-. Decree sheet be prepared and file be consigned to record room.”

    5. Aggrieved from this judgment and decree Chand Kaur had preferred a regular first appeal before the learned Additional District Judge, Rup Nagar, a copy of which has been placed on record. Appellant had stated that the case of the appellant was specific that she was owner in possession of the entire land and she never made any statement anywhere to the contrary. Amongst other grounds it was also specifically alleged that no compromise as required under the provisions of Order 23 of Civil Procedure Code was recorded and that the trial Court could not have decreed the suit in the present manner. The learned First Appellate Court noticed in its judgment that the case was fixed for recording of evidence of the defendant on the date when these statements in question were recorded and on that basis the trial Court decreed the suit vide impugned judgment. The trial Court on the basis of these statements of some of the parties to the suit held that plaintiff was entitled to ⅓rd share of the entire land and possession there of and further held on the one hand defendant No. 1 and defendants Nos. 8 and 9 jointly to be owners in possession of ⅓rd share each respectively. While passing this decree as already noticed, on the same day the learned trial Court had passed an order directing ex parte proceedings against defendants Nos. 2 to 7 but passed the decree against them in the above terms on the basis of the statement of other parties. The learned First Appellate Court while holding that there could be no dispute regarding the legal proposition argued by the learned counsel for the appellant before it, still held that the provisions of Order 23 of the Code postulate an oral compromise which was permissible, as in the present case, and consequently the trial court had not erred in passing a decree. It was also held by the Court that the appear itself was not maintainable because it was a consent decree under Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C and no appeal against a compromise degree was permissible under Section 96 of the Code. The Appellate Court was further of the view that even if the compromise was not in conformity with the provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C still in the alternative the present decree a decree was under the provisions of Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code and was based upon admission of the parties.

    6. The learned trial court in its judgment and decree has specifically noticed that the parties have compromised their disputes and statement of Chand Kaur plaintiff has been recorded on S.A The order in fact shows that according to the plaintiff the Court has got effected compromise between the parties and as per the terms of the compromise she was declared owner in possession to the extent of ⅓ share out of the entire land in dispute while giving ⅔rd share of the land to the other defendants as afore-stated. Defendants No. 2 to 7, as already observed had been proceeded against ex parte vide the same order and statement of defendant No. 8 was not recorded but statement of his counsel is stated to have been recorded. It was in view of the statements of the parties that a decree was passed as aforestated.

    7. A bare perusal of the record and orders passed by the trial Court including order dated 23.2.1995 leaves on doubt of any kind that the decree in question is a compromise decree between the parties who made statements before the Court on that date. Rule 3 of Order 23 of the Code governs and controls compromise of suits. The term ‘compromise’ has to be understood in its true meaning and cannot be given a construction which would frustrate the very intention of the Legislature behind this provision. The intention of this provision is to achieve the object of recording of a lawful compromise or settlement and passing a decree with the free consent of the parties and to achieve ends of justice. Defeating of ends of justice and mere disposal of a matter by using this provision as an instrument for such purposes certainly is not an underlying feature of this provision. The Legislature has intentionally imposed, by use of specific language, certain in-built safe-guards and obligations upon the Court before a decree on the basis of a compromise between the parties can be passed. One of such conditions which is of paramount consideration is the satisfaction of the Court in regard to the adjustment of the entire or part claimed by means of a lawful agreement or compromise in writing and signed by the parties. Thus, upon recording of such satisfaction alone, the Court can pass a decree on the basis of such a lawful compromise in a suit pending before it. A compromise is a settlement of differences by concession of each party. For such concession of either side an agreement of mind, free from pressure and’ influence, is essential. Every compromise un-disputedly is a form of contract, which, thus, must essentially fulfil the ingredients for entering into a lawful contract and agreement.

    8. The provisions of Order 23 of the Code postulate that it is only some forms of compromises or agreements which, subject to their being in writing and lawful, can be recorded by a Court and a decree passed in terms thereof provided they judiciously satisfy the court of these ingredients. The minimum pre-requisite for a valid compromise is that it must emerge from a willing and voluntary act of the parties and an act which is forced on the parties loses the very essence of it being a valid and lawful agreement. The parties have to be ad idem with regard to the terms which emerge from a valid consent and terms which are lawful. The provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code cast a duty upon the Court that to record its satisfaction with regard to these various ingredients as a precedent to passing of a decree as the basis of such a compromise under Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C

    9. Consistent views taken by various Courts by now have clearly spelled the conditions which normally must be satisfied for validly invoking the provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code and for passing of such a decree, which are as under:—

    (i) There should be a lawful agreement or compromise;

    (ii) This compromise has to be in writing and signed by the parties;

    (iii) The compromise must be recorded by the Court.

    (iv) A decree on such compromise can be passed so far it relates to the parties to the suit but may extend to a special matter which is not the subject matter of the suit.

    10. The Court has to record its satisfaction with regard to adjustment of the whole or part of the claim in terms of such lawful compromise.

    11. The explanation to sub-rule (3) of Rule 23 of the Code further makes legislative intent more clear by specifying that an agreement or compromise which is void or violable under the Indian Contract Act shall not be deemed to be lawful within the meaning of the rule. The purpose of effecting a compromise between the parties is to put an end to the various disputes pending before the Court of competent jurisdiction fully and finally.

    12. Finality of decisions is an underlying principle of all adjudicating forums. Thus creation of further litigation should never be the basis of a compromise between the parties. Rule 3(a) of Order 23 of the Code further provides that no suit shall lie to set aside a decree on the ground that the compromise on which the decree is based was not lawful. The scheme of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code is to avoid multiplicity of litigation and permit parties to amicably come to a settlernent which is lawful is in writing and a voluntary act on the part of the parties. The Court can be instrumental in having an agreed compromise effected and finality attached to the same. The Court should never be party to imposition of a compromise upon an unwilling party.

    13. In the present case the Court had proceeded against some of the defendants ex parte on the same day and immediately proceeded to pass a decree on the alleged compromise, which definitely prejudicially affected the rights and contentions of the said defendants. A compromise decree has to be between the parties to the suit and the Court must apply its mind and use its judicial discretion if the case is otherwise. Obviously the suit was being contested by different set of defendants, and compromise between some of them adversely affecting the rights of another set of defendants, had to be looked into by the Court with caution. Compromise between some of the parties to the suit and prayer for passing of a decree affecting rights of all, the Court had a discretion to accept or reject such a request. In fact in some of the cases where partial compromise would be prejudicial to the interests of the parties not joining such a compromise, the Court has gone to the extent of holding that such compromise cannot be recognised. In this regard reference can be made to Smt. Rani Bai v. Yadunandan Ram, (1969) 1 SCC 604 : AIR 1969 Supreme Court 1118 and Gopika Raman Roy v. Atal Singh, AIR 1926 Calcutta 193 (DB).

    14. In the suit it had been admitted that defendants No. 2 to 6 were also in possession of the property in question. Thus, their interests were inseparable and were intermingled with the stands and rights of other defendants. Postulation of their rights and consequently extinguishment by the consent decree does not appear to be very fair in the facts and circumstances of the case.

    15. The ground taken before this Court in the present appeal is that the Court initiated the terms of compromise and the poor lady who is stated to be an illiterate of 60 years old and succumbed to the pressure of the Court and no time was given to her to think over the matter. The order dated 23.2.1995 also indicates that Court has got the compromise effected between the parties. The parties had admittedly neither signed any agreement nor had executed any document or compromise in writing. No such agreement was produced in the Court. Even the terms and conditions of the compromise are not clear from the order itself. The learned Subordinate Judge passed an order taking ex parte proceedings against defendants No. 2 to 7 and instantly proceeded to record the compromise and decreed the suit leaving the parties to bear their own costs, but still went to assess the counsel fee. The Court passed no further directions upon the passing of the compromise decree dated 23.2.1996 with regard to payment of Court-fee, stamp duty and registration.

    16. It will also be doubtful if a decree in favour of the other defendants could be passed for ownership and possession in a suit for declaration by a plaintiff. The present suit was certainly not one for partition where every party to the suit is to be treated as a plaintiff. The suit was being seriously contested by the parties and it was expected that the Court would have adhered to compliance of the basic requirements stipulated under Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code in the facts and circumstances of this case rather than acting in such a haste.

    17. The learned counsel for the appellant has relied upon various judgments to support his contention that a compromise decree must precede by a written compromise recording the terms and conditions of the settlement. He relied upon the authority of Manohar Lal v. Surjan Singh, 1991 (1) RRR 286 (P&H) : 1990 P.L.J 480 (D.B).

    18. It will be appropriate to refer to the principles governing the application of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C as settled by the Supreme Court of India in the case of Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel., (1988) 1 SCC 270 : AIR 1988 Supreme Court 400. In unambiguous language the Court rejected the contention raised that a compromise between the parties need not be in writing where terms are reflected in the order itself and while entertaining this principle the Supreme Court has specifically overruled judgment of this Court in AIR 1983 Punjab & Haryana 393 and the Court held as under:—

    “Under Rule 3 as it now stands, when a claim in suit has been adjusted wholly or in part by any lawful agreement or compromise, the compromise must be a in writing and signed by the parties and there must be a completed agreement between them. To constitute an adjustment, the agreement or compromise must itself, be capable of being embodied in a decree. When the parties enter into a compromise during the hearing of a suit or appeal, there is no reason why the requirement that the compromise should be reduced to writing in the form of an instrument signed by the parties should be dispensed with. The Court must, therefore, insist upon the parties to reduce the terms into writing.

    19. Even this Court time and again has held that mere recording of statements of parties in Court even if they are signed by the parties and their counsel, it is not a sufficient compliance of provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C Compromise must be reduced into writing in the form of an instrument duly signed by the parties. Reference can be made to Sumer v. Vijay Singh, 1990 (1) RRR 214 (P&H) : 1990 P.L.J 68 and Sarup Chand v. Jagdish Chand, 1990 (2) RRR 90 (P&H) : 1990 P.L.J 366, and the Court held as under:—

    “Even otherwise if there was a settlement between the parties, that was required to be reduced into writing, as provided under Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure. It has been so held by the Supreme Court in Gurpreet Singh v. Chatur Bhuj Goel., 1988 PLJ 118 as well as by this Court in Sumer Singh v. Vijay Singh, 1990 PLJ 68. Gurpreet Singh's case was relied upon and it was further held that mere recording of statements of the parties in Court if they were signed by them and their counsel was not if they were signed by them their counsel was not sufficient compliance of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code.”

    20. While emphasising the need for proper application of mind while passing the decree(s) under the provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 C.P.C, the Supreme Court in the case of Banwari Lal v. Chando Devi (through LRs), 1993 (3) RRR 685 (SC) : (1993) 1 SCC 581 : AIR 1993 Supreme Court 1139, held as under:—

    “The present case depicts as to how on 27.2.1991 the Court recorded the alleged agreement and compromise in a causal manner. It need not be impressed that Rule 3 of Order 23 does not require just a seal of approval from the Court to an alleged agreement or compromise said to have been entered into between the parties. The statute requires the Court to be first satisfied that the agreement or compromise which has been entered into between the parties is lawful, before accepting the same. Court is expected to apply its judicial mind while examining the terms of the settlement before suit is disposed of in terms of the agreement arrived at between the parties.”

    21. A compromise between the parties presupposes a bilateral agreement or understanding. Such bilateral agreement or understanding by necessary implication precludes an order on the basis of an endorsement. An endorsement unaccompanied by an agreement or compromise of an adjustment cannot be made the basis for passing of a lawful decree under these provisions. In this regard reference can be made to the case of Manohar Parshad Kapoor v. Virendra Parshad, 1986 (1) Andhra Law Times 347. The facts of the present case viewed from any angle in their entirety lack bona fides on the part of the parties who negotiated the present compromise in absence of other defendants. In spite of the fact that the Court had directed exparte proceedings against other defendants still it could have used the judicial discretion cautiously to accept or decline such a compromise affecting the rights of all the parties.

    22. In this view of the matter the trial Court was expected to adhere to the settled principles of law governing the procedure to be complied with under Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code.

    23. The learned First Appellate Court erred in law in converting it as a decree of admission and, therefore, upholding the decree as a decree passed under the provisions of Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code. Firstly from the record it is clear that the trial Court itself did not pass any decree on admission but passed a decree on the basis of the compromise between the parties. The judgment and decree of the trial Court as well leaves no doubt in this regard. Thus, I find that the approach of the First Appellate Court is legally not correct. Even otherwise the provisions of Order 12 Rule 6 of the Code are attracted only when an admission in pleading or otherwise exists on the record of the Court before passing the decree. In the present case no such admission was made on record because the parties had entered into a compromise as recorded by the trial Court. This could not be twisted to be termed as an admission within the perview of Rule 6. If the compromise as recorded by the Court was lawful, was in consonance with the provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 pf the Code and there was no challenge to the same, the parties would be bound by such compromise, but by no stretch of imagination it could be treated as a judgment on admission in the facts and circumstances of the present case and which fact was not even intended by the trial Court.

    24. The learned Counsel for the respondents before this Court has relied upon a judgment of this Court in the case of Smt. Raksha Rani @ Rakha Devi… v. Ram Lal…., reported as 1986 (2) P.L.R page 504 to contend that as this was a consent decree under the provisions of Order 23 Rule 3 of the Code, no appeal could lie and that there was substantial compliance that the statement of the parties was recorded by the Court which was signed. This judgment is on distinguishable facts but in any case is not a good law in view of the subsequent judgments pronounced by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India as referred to above. To make this controversy clear beyond doubt it will be appropriate to refer to recent judgments of the Supreme Court in the case of Banwari Lal v. Chan-do Devi (Smt.) (Through LRs), 1993 (3) RRR 685 (SC) : (1993) 1 Supreme Court Cases 581 where the Court held as follows:—

    “After the amendments which have been introduced, neither an appeal against the order recording the compromise nor remedy by way of filing a suit is available in cases covered by Rule 3-A of Order 23. As such a right has been given under Rule 1-A(2) of Order 43 to a party, who challenges the recording of the compromise to question the validity thereof while preferring an appeal against the decree. Section 93(3) of the Code shall not be a bar to such an appeal because Section 96(3) is applicable to cases where the factum of compromise or agreement is not in dispute. As such a party challenging a compromise can file a petition under proviso to Rule 3 of Order 23, or an appeal under Section 96(1) of the Code, in which he can now question the validity of the compromise in view of Rule 1-A of Order 43 of the Code.”

    25. Thus the observations of the First Appellate Court that appeal itself was not maintainable is also erroneous and, therefore, cannot be sustained.

    26. Another factor which must weigh against the respondents herein is that even if decree is held to be valid, it was required to be compulsorily registered in accordance with the provisions of Section 17 of the Indian Registration Act and appropriate stamp duty ought to have been paid on this decree. The decree certainly created rights which were not pre-existing. In fact there was a definite dispute between the parties with regard to title and possession. It was for the first time during the pendency of the suit that the parties are stated to have compromised the matter on 23.2.1995 and it was for the first time that the their rights of possession and title in the land in question were agreed to be given and created. It was not an affirmation of existing rights, but was creation of rights for the first time in an immovable property which valued more than Rs. 100/-. As such the decree of the present kind would attract the payment of appropriate stamp duty and would be hit by the provisions of Section 17 of the Act, requiring the decree to be registered. In Bhoop Singh v. Ram Singh Major, 1995 (3) RRR 541 (SC) : (1995) 5 Supreme Court Cases 709, the Court held as under:—

    “It would, therefore, be the duty of the Court to examine in each case whether the parties have pre-existing right to the immovable property, or whether under the order or decree of the Court one party having right, title or interest therein agreed or suggested to extinguish the same and created right, title or interest in praesenti in immovable property of the value of Rs. 100/- or upwards or favour of other party for the first time, either by compromise or pretended consent. If latter be the position, the document is compulsorily registrable.”

    27. The present decree till date has neither been stamped in accordance with law nor has been registered according to law. The result of both these basic infirmities in the document is that the decreed does not vest any right in the parties in whose favour the same was passed at present.

    28. Respondents No. 2 to 7 (defendants No. 2 to 7 before the trial Court) have also appeared before this Court and the learned counsel appearing on their behalf argued that they were seriously contesting the suit and came to know of the passing of the decree when notice of the present appeal was served upon them and they have also been aggrieved by the said judgment and decree. The said respondents have not preferred any appeal before this Court and they are at liberty to take such appropriate steps as are permissible to them in accordance with law.

    29. For the reasons aforestated the judgments and decrees of both the Courts below are set aside. The case is remanded to the trial Court for taking further proceedings in accordance with law as on 23.2.1995 and subject to the above directions. The parties are directed to appear before the trial court on 29.8.1996 There shall be no orders as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Chand Kaur v. Raj Kaur
    (Aug 1, 1996)