Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 165A of the Code.17. Explanation 4 to section 108 of the Code
  • sections 18 and 37 of the Punjab Weights and Measures Act, 1951,
  • section 165-A of the Indian Penal Code, hereinafter referred
  • him.24. Illustration (c) to section 161 of the Code reads:A,
  • section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Pritam
  • section 165-A read with section 116 of the Code
  • section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • appellants.20. Section 161 of the Code
  • (section 161, Indian Penal Code)
  • section 161 of the Code
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • section 165A of the Code.17. Explanation 4 to section 108 of the Code
  • sections 18 and 37 of the Punjab Weights and Measures Act, 1951,
  • section 165-A of the Indian Penal Code, hereinafter referred
  • him.24. Illustration (c) to section 161 of the Code reads:A,
  • section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Pritam
  • section 165-A read with section 116 of the Code
  • section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure
  • appellants.20. Section 161 of the Code
  • (section 161, Indian Penal Code)
  • section 161 of the Code
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

These are appeals by Tarlok Nath (Criminal Appeal No. 116 of 1954) and Pritam Singh (Criminal Appeal No. 100 of 1954) from convictions by the Special Judge in criminal case No. 17 of 1953. The Special Judge convicted Tarlok Nath under section 165-A of the Indian Penal Code and Pritam Singh under section 165-A read with section 116 of the Code, sentencing each to rigorous imprisonment for six months.

The prosecution's factual narrative (as recorded in the opinion) is: on 13 December 1952 Ghasita Ram (P.W. 2) borrowed Rs. 40 from Pritam Singh on security of two gold rings (Exhibits P.3 and P.4). Pritam Singh allegedly sub-pawned those rings with Sain Das (D.W. 3). On 29 July 1953 Ghasita Ram paid Rs. 48 (principal and interest) and received receipts. On 18 August 1953 an altercation occurred at Pritam Singh's shop when Ghasita Ram demanded return of the rings and disputed their weight with Pritam Singh. Head Constable Gurcharan Singh (P.W. 1) arrived, examined the weighing scale (Exhibit P.1), found it defective and said he would report to the police station. The prosecution records that Pritam Singh handed four currency notes (Exhibits P.2/1–4) to Tarlok Nath and asked him to give them to Gurcharan Singh as a bribe so that no report would be made; Gurcharan Singh did not accept the money and made a police report (Exhibit P.C). Memos of seizure for the notes and the scale were attested by Lambardar Pritpal Singh (P.W. 3) and Ghasita Ram.

Investigation was authorised on 19 August 1953. Tarlok Nath was arrested on 19 August 1953; Pritam Singh absconded but was arrested on 7 September 1953. The rings were recovered from Sain Das on 12 September 1953. Prosecution witnesses included Gurcharan Singh (P.W. 1), Ghasita Ram (P.W. 2) and Lambardar Pritpal Singh (P.W. 3). Defence witnesses included Lal Chand (D.W. 1), Sant Singh (D.W. 2) and Sain Das (D.W. 3).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellants were rightly convicted under section 165-A of the Indian Penal Code (and, in Pritam Singh's case, section 165-A read with section 116).
  2. Whether there can be abetment of an offence punishable under section 165-A of the Code (the contention raised by counsel Mr. K.L. Jagga).
  3. Whether the alleged inability of the public servant (Head Constable Gurcharan Singh) to perform the official act or to show the requested favour (by reason of the relevant provincial Weights and Measures law) negates the criminality of offering gratification; i.e., whether the public servant must in fact be in a position to do the official act for the offence to be made out.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' / Defence Arguments

  • Pritam Singh, in examination under section 342 Cr.P.C., denied owning a shop in Katra Kanhayan and denied ownership of the scale (Exhibit P.1). He stated that Ghasita Ram had borrowed Rs. 40 on 13 December 1952, pawned the rings with him, and repaid principal and interest; the rings had not been returned because they were with Sain Das. He did not admit that the currency notes (Exhibits P.2/1–4) belonged to him or that he gave the notes to Tarlok Nath to pass to Gurcharan Singh as a bribe.
  • In formal statements under section 342, Pritam Singh's defence was a simple denial; he also pleaded an alibi that he was in village Rajla (PEPSU State) on the day of the occurrence.
  • Counsel Mr. K.L. Jagga advanced two legal submissions: (a) that there can be no abetment of the offence punishable under section 165-A; and (b) relying on sections 18 and 37 of the Punjab Weights and Measures Act, 1941 (as invoked), that Head Constable Gurcharan Singh was not in a position to show any official favour to Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath, and therefore the facts did not fall within section 165-A.
  • Defence witnesses (Lal Chand and Sain Das) gave evidence suggesting Pritam Singh had said on 15 August 1953 he was to go to Rajla and would be absent for 18–20 days; the court notes that this does not prove he was at Rajla on 18 August 1953 and that no evidence from Kajla was examined.

Prosecution Case and Evidence

  • The prosecution's case was set out through witnesses Gurcharan Singh (P.W. 1), Ghasita Ram (P.W. 2) and Lambardar Pritpal Singh (P.W. 3): they gave evidence about the loan, the pawning/sub-pawning of the rings, the altercation about weight, the defective scale, the offer of the currency notes as a bribe and the seizure memos. Gurcharan Singh testified that he did not accept the bribe and made a report at the police station.
  • It is recorded that Tarlok Nath did not cross-examine the prosecution witnesses.
  • The court recorded that there was no evidence of animus on the part of the prosecution witnesses to falsely implicate the appellants and that Ghasita Ram and Lambardar Pritpal Singh were not known to Gurcharan Singh prior to the incident.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Crown v. Phul Singh, I.L.R. 23 Lah. 402 Authority for the proposition that no distinction should be drawn between cases where the public servant is actually in a position to do the official act and those where he is not but is believed to be; the culpability lies in the bribe-giver's intention to corrupt. The court relied on this statement (quoted in the opinion) to reject the argument that the culpability of the appellants depends on whether the public servant was actually able to do the official act sought.
State v. Mahadeo Daunappe Gunaki, 1954 B.L.R. 153 Support for the proposition that section 161 I.P.C. does not require that the public servant himself be in a position to perform the act or show favour/dishonour for which the bribe is offered. The court cited this case (Chainani, J., with Bavdekar, J., concurring) to reinforce the principle that the actual ability of the public servant to perform the act is not a prerequisite for criminal liability for offering gratification.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, stated in the opinion:

  1. Evaluation of Evidence and Credibility: The court reviewed the prosecution testimony (Gurcharan Singh, Ghasita Ram, Lambardar Pritpal Singh) and the defence evidence (Lal Chand, Sant Singh, Sain Das). It observed that Tarlok Nath did not cross-examine prosecution witnesses and that there was no evidence of malice or animus on the part of the prosecution witnesses to falsely implicate the appellants. The court found that the defence evidence did not rebut the prosecution case, noting, for example, that statements that Pritam Singh intended to go to Rajla did not prove he was in Rajla on the 18th of August and that no evidence from Kajla was examined.
  2. On the Submission that There Can Be No Abetment of an Offence Under Section 165-A: The court considered Mr. K.L. Jagga's contention that there can be no abetment of the offence punishable under section 165-A. The court invoked Explanation 4 to section 108 of the Code (which provides that the abetment of an offence being an offence, the abetment of such an abetment is also an offence) and concluded that this disposes of the argument; the court therefore "repel[led] the argument raised."
  3. On the Submission that the Public Servant Was Not in a Position to Do an Official Act: Counsel argued, based on sections 18 and 37 of the Punjab Weights and Measures Act, that Head Constable Gurcharan Singh could not have shown any official favour and therefore the case did not fall within section 165-A. The court observed that even if the Head Constable was not in a position to take the specified action under the provincial Act, that would not affect the appellants' guilt. The court then examined the statutory text of section 161 I.P.C., noting that it requires only that "gratification" be offered to a public servant as a motive or reward for doing or forbearing to do any official act or for showing or forbearing to show favour or disfavour. The court held — relying on the statutory text, the illustration to section 161, and supporting authorities — that section 161 (and the like) does not require that the public servant must in fact be in a position to perform the act at the time, and that the state of mind of the person offering gratification is not conditioned by the public servant's actual ability to perform the act.
  4. Reliance on Authorities and Illustration: The court quoted Crown v. Phul Singh and State v. Mahadeo Daunappe Gunaki to the effect that the offence is complete where the bribe-giver intends to corrupt a public servant, even if the public servant is not actually able to perform the official act. The opinion also invoked illustration (c) to section 161 (which deals with a public servant inducing another to believe he has influence with the Government and being given money) as an example where the public servant need not actually possess the power described.
  5. Conclusion on Conviction: Applying the evidential findings and the legal principles summarized above, the court concluded that the appellants had been rightly convicted.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath were rightly convicted under the offences charged. It, however, reduced the sentence imposed upon each appellant to the period of imprisonment already suffered by them.

Consequences and implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: Convictions were maintained — Tarlok Nath under section 165-A of the Indian Penal Code and Pritam Singh under section 165-A read with section 116 of the Code — but the period of imprisonment was reduced to the amount already undergone by each appellant.
  • On legal principle: The court applied established authority and statutory interpretation to confirm that offering gratification with the intention to influence a public servant constitutes an offence even if the public servant is not actually in a position to perform the official act or show the requested favour. The opinion relied on prior decisions and illustration (c) to section 161 in support of that principle.
  • Precedential effect: The opinion does not state that it is laying down any new principle beyond the application of existing provisions and authorities; the decision enforces established rules concerning the offence of offering gratification and the law on abetment as discussed in the body of the judgment.

Disposition: Convictions affirmed; sentences reduced to time already suffered. "Sentence reduced." (as recorded in the opinion)

    Pritam Singh (Convict) v. The State .

    Harnam Singh, J.:— In criminal case No. 17 of 1953 the Special Judge has convicted Tarlok Nath under section 165-A of the Indian Penal Code, hereinafter referred to as the Code, and Pritam Singh under section 165-A read with section 116 of the Code and has sentenced each of them to suffer rigorous imprisonment for six months.

    2. Tarlok Nath and Pritam Singh appeal from their conviction and the sentence imposed upon them. Pritam Singh is the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 100 of 1954 while Tarlok Nath is the appellant in Criminal Appeal No. 116 of 1954. Briefly summarised the facts of the prosecution case are these: On the 13th of December, 1952, Ghasita Ram P.W 2, borrowed rupees 40 from Pritam Singh accused on the security of gold rings, Exhibits P. 3 and P. 4, agreeing to pay interest at the rate of six pies per rupee per month. Pritam Singh sub-pawned rings, Exhibits P. 3 and P. 4, with Sain Das D.W 3. On the 29th of July, 1953, Ghasita Ram paid rupees 48 on account of principal and interest to Pritam Singh and obtained receipts, Exhibits P.W 1 and P.D 2. Pritam Singh asked Sain Das to give him the rings for return to Ghasita Ram but Sain Das told him that the rings were lying with his wife who was out of station. Going to the shop of Pritam Singh, Ghasita Ram demanded the return of the rings on the 18th of August, 1953. On that occasion Tarlok Nath and Pritam Singh were present at the shop. Pritam Singh told Ghasita Ram that because Sain Das had not returned the rings he was prepared to pay the price of those rings. Ghasita Ram maintained that the rings weighed ten mashas whereas Pritam Singh said that their weight was eight mashas. That led to altercation between Ghasita Ram on the one side and Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath on the other side. Hearing the raula many persons collected at the shop of Pritam Singh. Head Constable Gurcharan Singh P.W 1 who was on patrol duty in Katra Kanhayan, Amritsar City, on that day came to the spot accompanied by Foot Constables Hans Raj and Gurbachan Singh Reaching the shop Gurcharan Singh P.W 1 heard Ghasita Ram P.W 2 saying that the rings which he had pawned with Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath weighed ten mashas and Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath saying that the weight of those rings was eight mashas. Pointing to the weighing scale, Exhibit P. 1, Ghasita Ram said that there must be some defect in that scale which Pritam Singh had used in weighing the rings. Gurcharan Singh P.W 1 took weighing scale, Exhibit P. 1, into possession and found the scale to be defective. Gurcharan Singh told Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath that he would report at the police station that the scale was defective. On this Pritam Singh gave four currency notes, Exhibits P. 2/1 to 4, to Tarlok Nath and asked him to give the notes to Gurcharan Singh P.W 1 by way of bribe so that he should not report at the police station against them. Gurcharan Singh P.W 1 took currency notes into possession on the foot of memo, Exhibit P.B, and took the scale into possession on the foot of memo, Exhibit P.A Lambardar Pritpal Singh P.W 3 and Ghasita Ram P.W 2 attested memos, Exhibits P.A and P.B Gurcharan Singh did not accept the bribe which was offered to him and made Report, Exhibit P.C, at the police station at 7 p.m

    3. On the 19th of August, 1953, Sardar Kuldip Singh, Magistrate permitted Assistant Sub-Inspector Prem Singh P.W 6 to investigate the case.

    4. Tarlok Nath was arrested on the 19th of August, 1953. Pritam Singh absconded and was arrested on the 7th of September, 1953.

    5. In the investigation rings, Exhibits P. 3 and P. 4, were recovered from Sain Das D.W 3 on the 12th of September, 1953.

    6. Gurcharan Singh P.W 1, Ghasita Ram P.W 2 and Lambardar Pritpal Singh P.W 3 gave evidence for the prosecution.

    7. In examination under section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Pritam Singh pleaded that he maintained no shop in Katra Kanhayan and that the scale, Exhibit P. 1, was not his property. In that examination Pritam Singh stated that Ghasita Ram P.W 2 borrowed rupees 40 from him on the 13th of December, 1952, and pawned gold rings, Exhibits P. 3 and P. 4, with him as security for that debt and that he had sub-pawned rings, Exhibits P. 3 and P. 4, with Sain Das D.W 3. Pritam Singh then stated that some time after the 13th of December, 1952, Ghasita Ram paid him rupees 40 on account of principal and rupees 8 on account of interest in full satisfaction of his claim but rings, Exhibits P. 3 and P. 4, were not returned to Ghasita Ram on the discharge of the debt for the rings were with Sain Das. Pritam Singh did not admit that the currency notes, Exhibits P. 2/1 to 4, belonged to him or that he gave currency notes, Exhibits P. 2/1 to 4, to Tarlok Nath for passing them on to Gurcharan Singh by way of bribe. In statements under section 342 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the defence of the accused was denial simpliciter, Pritam Singh pleading that he was in village Rajla in PEPSU State on the day of the occurrence.

    8. Lal Chand D.W 1, Sant Singh D.W 2 and Sain Das D.W 3 gave evidence in defence.

    9. From a perusal of the record it appears that Tarlok Nath accused did not cross-examine the prosecution witnesses.

    10. In answer to a question put by counsel for Pritam Singh, Gurcharan Singh P.W 1 stated:—

    “It is incorrect to suggest chat I was quarrelling with Tarlok Nath accused when Pritam Singh accused asked the co-accused to offer bribe to me. I did not have any quarrel with any of the two accused.”

    11. Lambardar Pritpal Singh P.W 3 belongs to village Gumtala, situate at a distance of one and a half miles from Amritsar town. Lambardar Pritpal Singh was in Katra Kanhayan in Amritsar town on the 18th of August, 1953 as he had gone to the town to make purchases. That Lambardar Pritpal Singh was convicted in a dacoity case and sentenced to three months' rigorous imprisonment does not show that the evidence given by him is false.

    12. Not a syllable of evidence appears on the record to show that Head Constable Gurcharan Singh P.W 1, Ghasita Ram P.W 2 and Lambardar Pritpal Singh P.W 3 had any animus to falsely implicate Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath. Ghasita Ram and Lambardar Pritpal Singh were not known to Head Constable Gurcharan Singh before the 18th of August, 1953.

    13. Lal Chand D.W 1 gave evidence that on the 15th of August 1953 Pritam Singh had told him that he was to go to village Rajla, PEPSU State, to see his parents-in-law and that he remained absent from Amritsar for eighteen of twenty days. To similar effect is the evidence given by Sain Das. That on the 15th of August, 1953, Pritam Singh mentioned to Lal Chand and Sain Das that he was to go to village Rajla does not show that he was at Rajla on the 18th of August, 1953. No evidence from Kajla was examined.

    14. Lal Chand D.W 1 gave evidence that Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath work as jewellers and that his shop in Katra Kanhayan, Amritsar City, adjoins to the shop of Pritam Singh.

    15. Sain Das D.W 3 gave evidence that he could not say if the scale, Exhibit P. 1, belongs to Pritam Singh accused. In answer to Court question Sain Das stated that the police visited the shop of Pritam Singh accused and took into possession scale, Exhibit P. 1. Clearly the evidence examined in defence does not rebut the prosecution case.

    16. Mr. K.L Jagga urges that there can be no abetment of the offence punishable under section 165A of the Code.

    17. Explanation 4 to section 108 of the Code provides that the abetment of an offence being an offence, the abetment of such an abetment is also an offence. That being the position of matters I repel the argument raised.

    18. Basing himself on sections 18 and 37 of the Punjab Weights and Measures Act, 1941, Mr. K.L Jagga then urges that on the facts found by the Special Judge the case did not fall within section 165A of the Code. The argument raised is that Head Constable Gurcharan Singh was not in a position to show any favour to Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath by doing any official act as desired by them.

    19. Assuming that Head Constable Gurcharan Singh was not in a position to take action under sections 18 and 37 of the Punjab Weights and Measures Act, 1951, that would not affect the guilt of the appellants.

    20. section 161 of the Code provides:—

    “Whoever, being or expecting to be a public servant, accepts or obtains, or agrees to accept, or attempts to obtain from any person, for him self or for any other person, any gratification whatever, other than legal remuneration as a motive or reward for doing or forbearing to do any official act or for showing or forbearing to show, in the exercise of his official functions, favour or disfavour to any person, or for rendering or attempting to render any service or disservice to any person, with the Central or any State Government or Parliament or the Legislature of any State or with any public servant, as such, shall be punished with imprisonment of either description for a term which may extend to three years, or with fine, or with both.”

    21. From a perusal of section 161 of the Code it is plain that all that is necessary for the application of the section is that ‘gratification’ should have been offered to a public servant as a motive or reward for doing or forbearing to do any official act or for showing or forbearing to show, in the exercise of his official functions, favour or disfavour to any person. section 161 of the Code does not require that the public servant must in fact be in a position to do the official act, favour or service at the time.

    22. In Crown v. Phul Singh . I.L.R 23 Lah. 402, Bhide, J. said—

    “It is indeed difficult to see any principle on which a distinction should be made between cases in which the public servant is in a position to do the official act, or favour or service and those in which he is not in a position to do so, but is erroneously believed to be in that position. The heinousness of the act obviously lies in the intention of the bribe-giver to corrupt the public servant and I see no good reason, why the act should be considered to be less heinous merely because the public servant does not happen to possess the necessary power to do the required favour or service.”

    23. In State v. Mahadeo Daunappe Gunaki . 1954 B.L.R 153., Chainani, J. (Bavdekar, J. concurring) said—

    “It (section 161, Indian Penal Code) does not require that the public servant himself must have the power or must himself be in a position to perform the act, to show favour or disfavour or to render service or disservice for doing, showing or rendering which the bribe has been paid to him.”

    24. Illustration (c) to section 161 of the Code reads:—

    “A, a public servant, induces erroneously to believe that A's influence with the Government has obtained a title for Z and thus induced Z to give A money as a reward-for this service. A has committed the offence defined in this section.”

    25. In a case under section 161 of the Code the state of mind of the person who offers “gratification” has nothing to do with the question whether the public servant to whom illegal gratification is offered is or is not in a position to do or not to do the act for doing or for not doing which the amount is offered to him. In illustration (c) to section 161 of the Code. A who was convicted was not in a position to exercise influence with the Government to obtain a title. Indisputably, there can be no public servant whose official duty it is to exercise influence with the Government to obtain a title.

    26. No other argument was raised in Criminal Appeals Nos. 100 and 116 of 1954.

    27. For the foregoing reasons, I find that Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath have been rightly convicted.

    28. Having regard to the circumstances of the case, I reduce the sentence imposed upon Pritam Singh and Tarlok Nath to the period of imprisonment already suffered by them. In the result, while maintaining the conviction of Tarlok Nath under section 165A of the Code and that of Pritam Singh under section 165A read with section 116 of the Code, I reduce the sentence of imprisonment imposed upon the appellants to the period of imprisonment already suffered by them.

    29. Sentence reduced.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Pritam Singh (Convict) v. The State .
    (Apr 1, 1954)