AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 11 of Order 22 applies to appeals.8. Rules 3, 4 and 8
  • costs.16. Rule is made absolute.JC/K.S.B17. Rule absolute.
  • provisions of Order 22 including Rules 3, 4
  • 22, Rule 12 of the CPC, Rules 3, 4 and 8
  • Article 177 of the Limitation Act.11.
  • Rules 11 and 12 of the Code. Rule 11
  • Rule 12 of Order 22 of the CPC
  • Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22
  • Order 22, Rule 12 of the CPC
  • provisions of Rule 12
  • provisions of Rule 11
  • provision of Rule 11
  • Rule 12 of Order 22
  • Order 22 Rule 12
  • Order 21, Rule 90
  • 22, Rule 12
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Rule 11 of Order 22 applies to appeals.8. Rules 3, 4 and 8
  • costs.16. Rule is made absolute.JC/K.S.B17. Rule absolute.
  • provisions of Order 22 including Rules 3, 4
  • 22, Rule 12 of the CPC, Rules 3, 4 and 8
  • Article 177 of the Limitation Act.11.
  • Rules 11 and 12 of the Code. Rule 11
  • Rule 12 of Order 22 of the CPC
  • Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22
  • Order 22, Rule 12 of the CPC
  • provisions of Rule 12
  • provisions of Rule 11
  • provision of Rule 11
  • Rule 12 of Order 22
  • Order 22 Rule 12
  • Order 21, Rule 90
  • 22, Rule 12
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed by the judgment-debtors challenging an order of the Additional Subordinate Judge, Berhampur, which rejected the contention that the appeal as a whole had abated. The central procedural question was whether Rule 12 of Order 22 of the Civil Procedure Code (CPC) applies to appeals arising out of execution proceedings.

Facts (as stated in the opinion): Plaintiffs Jambeswar Dutta, Subal Dutta and Dasarathi Dutta obtained a joint decree for recovery of possession on 5 April 1941 in O.S. No. 208 of 1939 (Munsif, Berhampur) against the present petitioners. An execution proceeding (O.E.P. No. 121 of 1952) was filed by Lakshman Patnaik (arrayed as opposite party No. 2) claiming to hold a power of attorney for the decree-holders. The learned Munsif dismissed the execution case on 8 January 1953, holding that Lakshman Patnaik did not have the necessary power because it had not been filed in the execution proceedings.

Plaintiff No. 3, Dasarathi Dutta, appealed (Misc. Appeal No. 12 of 1953, District Judge, Ganjam). That appeal was dismissed for non-prosecution on 28 September 1954. Civil Revision C.R. No. 4 of 1955 was then instituted before this Court, and the rule was made absolute on 25 January 1957. During the pendency of the Civil Revision, the appeal stood dismissed as to Bhabagrahi Dutta (a minor son of Subal Dutta) by order dated 6 December 1956; the Court noted that any subsequent order would not affect Bhabagrahi's rights and liabilities in consequence of that dismissal.

After the Civil Revision was disposed, the appeal returned to the lower appellate court. The Additional Subordinate Judge, by order dated 20 March 1958, set aside the order of the Munsif and remanded the execution matter to the court below under Section 151 CPC. At that hearing it was argued that the appeal as a whole had abated because it had abated as to one of the decree-holders (Bhabagrahi). The Additional Subordinate Judge treated Order 22, Rule 12 as applicable to appeals arising from execution proceedings and concluded the appeal had not abated as a whole.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 12 of Order 22 of the Code of Civil Procedure applies to appeals arising out of proceedings in execution of a decree or order.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments (as presented by Mr. G.K. Misra)

  • Rule 12 of Order 22 does not apply to appeals arising out of proceedings in execution (whether of a decree or an order).
  • The only rule of Order 22 that applies to such appeals is Rule 11; since Rule 11 contains no exclusion, the provisions of Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22 are not excluded and hence apply to such appeals.

Lower Appellate Court's Position (Additional Subordinate Judge)

  • The Additional Subordinate Judge took the view that Order 22, Rule 12 applies with equal force to appeals arising from execution proceedings, and therefore Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22 would not apply to those appeals. On that basis he concluded that the appeal had not abated as a whole.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hakim Syed Muhammad Taki v. Rai Fateh Bahadur Singh, AIR 1929 Pat 565 (Full Bench) Majority view: O.22, R.12 applies to appeals arising out of execution orders; Minority view: different procedures for suits, executions and appeals, so O.22, R.11 applies to appeals. Noted as representing a conflicting Patna High Court view; this decision was discussed but treated as not controlling the court's final conclusion in the present matter.
Mir Khan v. Sharfu Punnun, AIR 1923 Lah 560 Earlier Lahore High Court decision relied upon by Patna in support of the view that Rule 12 applies to appeals from execution. Referenced as the earlier authority relied on by the Patna Full Bench; later overruled by the Lahore Full Bench in Ajudhia Pershad.
Ajudhia Pershad Ram Pershad v. Sham Sunder, AIR 1947 Lah 13 (Lahore Full Bench) Overruled the earlier Lahore decision (Mir Khan) and dissented from the Patna view that R.12 applies to appeals arising from execution orders. Relied upon to show that the earlier Lahore view was reconsidered and a contrary position adopted.
Laxmi Narayan Singh v. Dipen Rai, AIR 1950 Pat 290 Held that proceedings to set aside a sale under Order 21, Rule 90 are proceedings in execution within the meaning of Order 22, Rule 12; accordingly an appeal in such proceedings does not abate. Noted as a Patna decision holding that certain proceedings under O.21 were within O.22, R.12's ambit; cited in the survey of authorities but not treated as altering the court's overall conclusion.
Raja of Kalahasti v. P. Jagannadha Rayanimgar, AIR 1932 Mad 574 Stated that an appeal against an order made in execution proceedings is not itself a proceeding in execution; Rule 12 does not apply to such appeals. Used to support the proposition that appeals from execution orders are governed by the general rules applicable to appeals and not by R.12's exclusion.
Subbavarapu Gangunaidu v. Murru Muttenna, AIR 1934 Mad 664 Application to bring on record legal representative of a deceased respondent in an appeal from an order in execution proceedings is governed by Article 177 of the Limitation Act. Referenced as an example where the Madras High Court treated appeals from execution orders as governed by normal appeal/limitation provisions.
Trimbak Narhar v. Gopal Naravan, AIR 1947 Bom 480 Held that Rule 12 applies to proceedings in execution properly so called and cannot be extended to appeals; Rule 11 applies to appeals and makes them subject to all provisions of Order 22 including Rules 3, 4 and 8. Adopted as authoritative support for the proposition that appeals from execution orders fall under R.11 and thereby remain subject to Order 22 generally.
Changa Mal v. Ram Dulare Lal, AIR 1933 All 388 Similar principle that Rule 12 does not apply to appeals from execution orders; appeals governed by Rule 11 and other provisions of Order 22. Listed among High Court decisions taking the same view as the Bombay High Court.
Arisen Elahi v. Mehr Elahi, AIR 1950 E.P. 302 East Punjab High Court view aligning with the principle that appeals from execution orders are governed by Rule 11 and not excluded by Rule 12. Included in the list of authorities adopting the same approach.
Bishnu Bijay v. Chandra Bijay, AIR 1955 Cal 281 Calcutta High Court decision taking the view that appeals from execution orders are not proceedings in execution and thus not within R.12. Used as part of the weight of authority showing consensus among several High Courts.
Balaram Karmakar v. Subodh Chandra, AIR 1956 Assam 9 Assam High Court decision holding that Rule 12 does not apply to appeals against orders made in execution proceedings. Part of the group of High Court decisions supporting the court's conclusion.
Madhaorao Narayanrao v. Baliram Narayan, AIR 1938 Nag 502 Nagpur High Court decision taking the same view as Bombay and others that appeals from execution orders are governed by Rule 11. Also cited among the consistent authorities adopted by the court in forming its view.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded by textual interpretation of Order 22, Rules 11 and 12 and by a survey of conflicting High Court authorities:

  1. Interpretation of the rules:
    • Rule 11 provides that, for the application of Order 22 to appeals, words in that Order are to be read as including appellants/respondents/appeals (i.e., the word "plaintiff" to include an appellant, "defendant" a respondent, and "suit" an appeal). Rule 11 contains no express limitation or exception.
    • Rule 12, by contrast, expressly states that nothing in Rules 3, 4 and 8 shall apply to proceedings in execution of a decree or order — i.e., it carves out an exclusion for execution proceedings.
  2. Survey of authorities:
    • The court reviewed divergent approaches. The Patna Full Bench (Hakim Syed) had a majority view that Rule 12 applies to appeals arising from execution orders; a minority view took the contrary position. An earlier Lahore decision (Mir Khan) supported the Patna majority but was later overruled by the Lahore Full Bench in Ajudhia Pershad.
    • Several High Courts (Bombay, Allahabad, East Punjab, Calcutta, Assam, Nagpur and Madras) had taken the position that Rule 12 applies only to proceedings in execution properly so called (i.e., the execution proceedings in the original court), and cannot be extended to appeals arising from such proceedings. To such appeals Rule 11 applies, thereby subjecting them to the full operation of Order 22 including Rules 3, 4 and 8.
    • Patna decisions were noted that in some contexts (e.g., proceedings to set aside a sale under O.21, R.90) the court treated those proceedings as execution proceedings within the meaning of Rule 12; the opinion records these decisions but treats them as not altering the broader interpretive conclusion.
  3. Synthesis and conclusion:
    • On a plain reading, Rule 12 excludes Rules 3, 4 and 8 from proceedings in execution, but Rule 11 contains no similar exclusion; therefore, appeals (which fall under Rule 11) are not brought within Rule 12's exclusion.
    • Because appeals against orders made in execution proceedings are not themselves "proceedings in execution" for the purpose of Rule 12, Rule 12 does not apply to such appeals, and those appeals remain subject to the ordinary rules on abatement applicable to appeals generally.
    • Given the weight of High Court authority supporting that view, the Additional Subordinate Judge's contrary approach could not be maintained.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the entire appeal had abated. As a result, the court set aside the judgment of the Additional Subordinate Judge and confirmed the judgment of the learned Munsif.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is that the appeal was treated as abated in its entirety and the Munsif's dismissal of the execution proceeding is confirmed.
  • No order for costs was made because there was no appearance on behalf of the opposite parties.
  • The opinion explains and endorses the view, adopted by several High Courts, that Rule 12 of Order 22 applies only to proceedings in execution properly so called and does not apply to appeals arising from such proceedings; instead Rule 11 governs appeals and so the general provisions of Order 22 (including Rules 3, 4 and 8) remain applicable to appeals. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent beyond applying and aligning with the cited High Court authorities; its immediate effect is the decision between the parties in this matter.

Disposition: Rule made absolute. Judgment of the Additional Subordinate Judge set aside; judgment of the Munsif confirmed. No costs ordered.

    Surendranath Patnaik And Others v. Dasarathi Dutta And Others Opposite Parties.

    Das, J.:— This is a petition on behalf of the judgment-debtors against an order of the Additional Subordinate Judge. Berhampur, disallowing their contention that the appeal as a whole had abated. The sole question thus for consideration in this case is whether Rule 12 of Order 22 of the CPC applies to appeals arising out of proceedings in execution of a decree or order.

    2. The facts leading up to this application, shortly stated, are these: Plaintiffs Jambeswar Dutta, Subal Dutta and Dasarathi Dutta obtained a joint decree for recovery of possession of the suit land on April 5, 1941 in O.S No. 208 of 1939 of the Court of the Muasif, Berhampur, against the present petitioners. Opposite Parties 3 and 4 are the sons of Jambeswar Dutta, plaintiff no. 1, since dead. Opposite party No. 5 is the son of Subal Dutta, plaintiff No. 2 who is also dead, Pursuant to this decree, execution was levied in the court of the Munsif of Berhampur which was numbered as O.E.P No. 121 of 1952; which was filed by one Lakshman Patnaik who was arrayed as opposite party no. 2 on the ground that he holds a power of attorney on behalf of the decree-holders and as such is competent to file the execution case.

    3. The learned Munsif dismissed the execution case on January 8, 1953 holding that Lakshman Patnaik had not the necessary power since he did not file the same in the execution proceedings. Against this order plaintiff No. 3, Dasarathi Dutta, carried an appeal along with the aforesiad Lakshman Patnaik which was numbered as Misc. Appeal No. 12 of 1953 of the Court of the District Judge of Ganjam. This appeal was eventually dismissed for non-prosecution on September 28, 1954. Against this order a Civil Revision was carried to this Court which was numbered as C.R No. 4 of 1955. The rule in that case was made absolute by this Court on January 25, 1957. It appeared that during the pendency of that Civil Revision in this Court, it stood dismissed as against Bhabagrahi Dutta, a minor son of Subal Dutta, plaintiff no. 2, by order no. 16 dated December 6, 1956. It was contended in this court that so far as Bhabagrahi is concerned, the order of the District Judge has thus become final. Accordingly whatever order is passed in that application will not affect the rights and liabilities of Bhabagrahi Dutta. Consequently while disposing of this application it was stated:

    “I would accordingly, set aside the order of the learned District Judge and restore the appeal to its file. As I have stated earlier, it would not affect the rights and liabilities, if any, of opposite party No. 10 Bhabagrahi Dutta, minor; since the result of the dismissal of this petition against him would be that the order of the executing court as far as he is concerned is made final,”

    4. After the disposal of the Civil Revision No. 4 of 1955 when the matter went back to the lower appellate court, the appeal was heard by the Additional Subordinate Judge, Berhampur, who by his order dated March 20, 1958 set aside the order of the Munsif and remanded the case to the Court below under Section 151 of the CPC for disposal of the execution case. During the argument it was urged before the lower appellate Court that the appeal as whole had abated since it had abated against one of the decree-holders, Bhabagrahi Dutta. The Additional Subordinate Judge appears to have thought that Order 22, Rule 12 of the CPC applies with equal force to the appeals as to the execution proceedings. Accordingly in his opinion Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22 would have application to appeals. In this view of the matter he came to the conclusion that the appeal had not abated as a whole.

    5. Mr. G.K Misra, learned Counsel on behalf of the petitioners now contended that Rule 12 of Order 22 does not apply to appeals arising out of proceedings in execution whether of a decree or an order. The only rule of order 22 that applies to such appeals is Rule 11. There was some conflict of opinion as to the applicability of Rule 12 of Order 22 to appeals against orders passed in execution proceedings. It is now well settled that although rule 12 applies to execution proceedings and as such the operation of Rules 3, 4, and 8 of order 22 is excluded from these proceedings, yet so far as appeals arising out of execution proceedings are concerned. Rule 12 of that Order has no application. Since Rule 11 applies to such appeals the operation of Rules 3, 4 and 8 is not excluded.

    6. Before proceeding any further I would like to state as to what exactly was intended by Rules 11 and 12 of the Code. Rule 11 lays down that in the application of order 22 to appeals, so far as they may be, the word “plaintiff” shall be held to include an appellant, the word “defendant” a respondent, and the word “suit” an appeal. This explanation was necessary because of the fact that appeal was a continuation of the suit. No word of limitation, however, was put whereas Rule 12 clearly stated that nothing in Rules 3, 4 and 8 shall apply to proceedings in execution of a decree or order.

    7. It appears that the Patna High Court has taken one view whereas the Calcutta, Bombay, Madras, Allahabad, Lahore, Nagpur and Assam High Courts take another view. The matter came up before the Patna High Court in a Bench of three judges in the case of Hakim Syed Muhammad Taki v. Rai Fateh Bahadur Singh*, AIR 1929 Pat 565 (F.B); where the majority view was that Order 22 Rule 12 applies to appeals arising out of execution orders whereas the minority view in that case was that the Code of Civil Procedure has laid down different procedures for suits, executions as well as for appeals. Rules 3, 4 and 8 of Order 22 apply to suits by their own force whereas Rule 11 of Order 22 applies to appeals.

    8. Rules 3, 4 and 8 do not however apply to proceedings in execution as contemplated by Chapter 2 and O. 21 of the Code. Accordingly the minority view was since no distinction has been drawn in the Code between appeals arising out of execution proceedings and appeals generally and as the provision of Rule 11 is without qualification or exception, Rules 3, 4 and 8 apply to appeals in execution proceedings. The majority of Judges while taking the above view, Mr. Justice Kulwant Sahay made it clear that there was no decided decision on the point at the time their Lordships proceeded to deliver the judgment. The only case available on that date was a Lahore Case reported in Mir Khan v. Sharfu Punnun, AIR 1923 Lah 560 and the learned Judges naturally relied upon that decision.

    9. This Lahore decision has subsequently been, overruled by the Lahore High Court itself in a later decision of that Court by a Full Bench reported in Ajudhia Pershad Ram Pershad v. Sham Sunder, AIR 1947 Lah 13. In that case they also dissented from the Patna view in AIR 1929 Pat 565 (FB). In the case of Laxmi Narayan Singh v. Dipen Rai AIR 1950 Pat 290 their Lordships of the Patna High Court after a discussion of all their earlier decisions took, the view that the proceedings to set aside a sale under Order 21, Rule 90 are proceedings in execution within the meaning of order 22, Rule 12 and hence an appeal in a proceeding for setting aside a sale on the ground of fraud does not abate.

    10. Doubtless an appeal against an order made in execution proceedings is not a proceeding in execution of a decree or order. Therefore Rule 12 of Order 22 does not apply to such appeals. They are subject to the same rules in regard to abatment as any other appeals (vide Raja of Kalahasti v. P. Jagannadha Rayanimgar, AIR 1932 Mad 574) Thus the Madras High Court in the case of Subbavarapu Gangunaidu v. Murru Muttenna, AIR 1934 Mad 664 (1) held that an application to bring on record the legal representative of a deceased respondent, in an appeal from an order in execution proceedings, is governed by Article 177 of the Limitation Act.

    11. In the case of Trimbak Narhar v. Gopal Naravan, AIR 1947 Bom 480, a Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that the provisions of Rule 12 apply to proceedings in execution properly so called, that is to say, the execution proceedings in the original court which is concerned with executing decrees, and the said provisions cannot be extended to appeals arising from such proceedings. To such appeals the provisions of Rule 11 apply, with the result that they are subject to all the provisions of Order 22 including Rules 3, 4 and 8. A similar view was taken by the Allahabad High Court in Changa Mal v. Ram Dulare Lal, AIR 1933 All 388, by the East Punjab High Court in Arisen Elahi v. Mehr Elahi, AIR 1950 E.P 302, by the Calcutta High Court in Bishnu Bijay v. Chandra Bijay, (S) AIR 1955 Cal 281 and the Assam High Court in Balaram Karmakar v. Subodh Chandra, AIR 1956 Assam 9. Nagpur High Court had also taken the same view in Madhaorao Narayanrao v. Baliram Narayan, AIR 1938 Nag 502.

    12. Thus the ratio decidendi of all these decisions of the High Courts of Assam, Bombay, East Punjab, Madras, Allahabad, Lahore and Nagpur is, that an appeal against an order made in execution proceedings is not itself a proceeding in execution of a decree or order. Rule 12 does not apply to appeals against orders made in execution proceedings and such appeals are subject to the same rules in regard to abatement as any other appeals. On a plain reading of order 22, Rule 12 of the CPC, Rules 3, 4 and 8 are excluded in its application to proceedings in execution of a decree or order whereas legislature did not contemplate any such exclusion as far as Rule 11 of that order is concerned. Accordingly, Rules 3, 4 and 8 would apply to Rule 11. The appeals against an order passed in proceedings in execution of a decree or order does not stand in any other footing than the appeals generally provided for under order 41 of the CPC.

    13. All the decisions referred to by me in the previous paragraph had referred to the case in AIR 1929 Pat 565 (F.B) That decision, however, did not meet with any approval by the above High Courts. Thus, in this view of the Law, the judgment of the learned Additional Subordinate Judge cannot be maintained and the application is bound to succeed.

    14. In the result, I would hold that the entire appeal had abated. In that event I would set aside the judgment of the learned Additional Subordinate Judge and confirm that of the learned Munsif.

    15. Since there was no appearance on behalf of the opposite parties, there will be no order for costs.

    16. Rule is made absolute.

    JC/K.S.B

    17. Rule absolute.

    Order 22, Rule 12 of the CPC
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Surendranath Patnaik And Others v. Dasarathi Dutta And Others Opposite Parties.
    (Sep 4, 1959)