AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (4) of that section has elapsed.Section 27(1) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976
  • provisions of clauses (a) to (e) of sub-section (1) of S. 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908)
  • 29-2-93 sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Building Rules, 1990,
  • Section 5(3) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976
  • SECTION 28 URBAN LAND CEILING AND REGULATION ACT 1976
  • URBAN LAND CEILING AND REGULATION ACT 1976
  • sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of C.M.C Building Rules, 1990,
  • Regulation) Act, 1976 (33 of 1976),
  • Municipal Corporation Act, 1980.
  • Regulation) Act, 1976
  • Land Ceiling Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • sub-section (4) of that section has elapsed.Section 27(1) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976
  • provisions of clauses (a) to (e) of sub-section (1) of S. 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908)
  • 29-2-93 sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Building Rules, 1990,
  • Section 5(3) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976
  • SECTION 28 URBAN LAND CEILING AND REGULATION ACT 1976
  • URBAN LAND CEILING AND REGULATION ACT 1976
  • sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of C.M.C Building Rules, 1990,
  • Regulation) Act, 1976 (33 of 1976),
  • Municipal Corporation Act, 1980.
  • Regulation) Act, 1976
  • Land Ceiling Act
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Asok Kumar Chakravarty, J. (with Bhagabati Prasad Banerjee, J. concurring)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (Petitioner No.1), a limited company owning premises at 16, Alipore Road, Calcutta, submitted an application and plan for construction of a two-storeyed building to the municipal authorities on 24 September 1992, together with an application fee of Rs. 10. After an initial letter dated 13 December 1992 indicating further formalities, the petitioner submitted a revised plan on 22 December 1992. The municipal authorities did not sanction the plan and informed the petitioner that a 'no objection certificate' (NOC) from the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities had not been appended.

The petitioner challenged the requirement for such an NOC and filed a writ petition before the learned Trial Judge. By order dated 29 March 1993 the Trial Judge, on certain observations (including an erroneous observation that the petitioner had obtained clearance from the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities), directed the Municipal Authorities to produce records relating to the plan. By a subsequent order dated 7 April 1993 the Trial Judge directed the respondents to file affidavits-in-opposition by 26 April 1993, correcting the earlier observation.

Aggrieved by the order of 7 April 1993, the petitioner preferred this appeal, contending that (a) it did not hold land beyond permissible ceiling limits, and (b) the municipal authorities had no right under the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Building Rules, 1990 (CMC Rules) to insist on a clearance or NOC from the Land Ceiling Authorities before sanctioning the building plan.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Calcutta Municipal Corporation (respondent authority) could lawfully insist on production of a 'no objection certificate' from the competent authority appointed under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 as a precondition for sanctioning the petitioner’s building plan that was submitted on 24 September 1992.
  2. Whether a subsequent amendment (by notification said to substitute sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the CMC Building Rules, 1990) requiring such an NOC could be applied retrospectively to an application already submitted before the amendment.
  3. Whether the affidavit filed by the petitioner satisfied the statutory/formal requirements (i.e., whether noncompliance with the form prescribed in Schedule I of the CMC Rules could invalidate the petitioner’s submission).
  4. Whether any provision of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 obliges the competent authority to issue a 'no objection certificate' for the purpose of sanctioning building construction or otherwise empowers municipal authorities to refuse plan sanction on account of absence of such a certificate.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioners') Arguments

  • Counsel for the petitioners relied on sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the CMC Building Rules, 1990, which requires, in cases covered by the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976, a declaration by the applicant that his exclusive right to erect, re-erect or alter is not affected under that Act — but does not in terms require a 'no objection certificate' from the Land Ceiling Authorities.
  • The petitioners had filed an affidavit declaring that they had no vacant land or other land with a building in any urban agglomeration covered by the Act, and that they would abide by any directions of the competent authority if the land were later declared in excess; on that basis they had satisfied the relevant requirement and there was nothing more to be done before sanction.
  • Accordingly, the municipal authorities lacked justification for withholding sanction of the plan.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Respondent No.2's counsel submitted that notification No. 189.CC/3R-8/C-2/92 dated 29-2-93 had substituted sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the CMC Building Rules, 1990 to require production of a 'no objection certificate' from the competent authority under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 for sites or plots measuring 5 sq. metres or above.
  • He contended that the municipal authority was entitled to insist on a 'no objection certificate' from the competent authority appointed under the Urban Land Ceiling Act and relied on a Division Bench decision of this Court (Ram Nath Mehra v. Calcutta Municipal Corporation) for the general proposition that the Municipal Corporation could not sanction without such production — although the opinion ultimately cites that authority to support the opposite view in the particular factual context.
  • He also argued that the affidavit filed by the petitioner was not in the exact form prescribed in Schedule I of the CMC Building Rules, 1990.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ram Nath Mehra v. Calcutta Municipal Corporation, (1988) 1 CLJ 295 Addressed the question of whether the Calcutta Municipal Corporation could insist on production of a 'no objection certificate' from the competent authority under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act. The opinion refers to this Division Bench decision to show that insisting on production of a 'no objection certificate' was held not to be appropriate; the court treated the production of such a certificate as wrongly insisted upon in the present case.
Maharao Saheb Sri Bhim Singhji v. Union of India, AIR 1981 SC 234 Supreme Court decision declaring Section 27(1) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 (which required previous permission in writing of the competent authority for specified transfers) to be ultra vires. The court relied on this decision to state that no permission is now required from the competent authority for transfer of urban or urbanisable land with a building within ceiling limits and that registering authorities cannot refuse registration where statutory requirements are met; this supports the conclusion that the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act does not create a precondition in the form of an NOC for plan sanction by municipal authorities.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded through a sequence of legal points drawn from statutory text, rule-making principles and precedent:

  1. Principle on retrospectivity of rules: The court reiterated the established rule that rule-making authorities do not possess implied power to make rules retrospective unless specifically empowered by the parent Act. Consequently, a rule or amendment made after the date of submission of an application cannot be applied retrospectively to affect rights acquired or applications already filed; a plan must be sanctioned in accordance with the rules and regulations prevailing on the date the plan was submitted.
  2. Application of the above principle to the facts: The plan was submitted on 24 September 1992. Respondent counsel relied on a notification (No. 189...) said to be dated 29-2-93 substituting sub-rule (4) of Rule 4; the court noted that the notification came into existence after submission of the plan (the opinion records a date of 29-3-93 in this connection) and therefore could not operate retrospectively to impose new conditions for sanction of the already-submitted plan.
  3. Content of sub-rule (4) and the affidavit: The court noted that sub-rule (4) (as originally framed) required, in cases covered by the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, a declaration by the applicant that his exclusive right to erect, re-erect or alter is not affected under that Act. The petitioner had filed an affidavit to that effect, also declaring that they would abide by any direction of the competent authority if the land were later declared in excess. On this basis the court held the petitioner had complied with the requirement as it existed on the date of submission.
  4. No statutory provision for an NOC in the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act: The court analyzed the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 and observed there is no provision envisaging the issue of a 'no objection certificate' for the purpose of making construction on any land. The court quoted Section 28 (which deals with registration formalities and conditions in specified transfers) and explained the statutory regime governing transfers and registration.
  5. Effect of Supreme Court decision on Section 27(1): The court observed that Section 27(1) (which required prior written permission of the competent authority for certain transfers) had been declared ultra vires by the Supreme Court in Maharao Saheb Sri Bhim Singhji v. Union of India. As a consequence, no permission is now required from the competent authority for transfers of urban or urbanisable land with a building within ceiling limits and registering authorities cannot refuse registration where the statutory formalities have been complied with.
  6. Distinction between construction and ownership; municipal competence: The court stressed that raising construction on land does not change ownership rights. Questions of whether land is in excess of the ceiling limit, or whether it vests in the State, are matters for the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities and not for municipal authorities. The municipal authority's role is confined to planning and ensuring construction accords with sanctioned plans; it has no jurisdiction to adjudicate proprietary questions or to impose conditions (such as requiring an NOC) that traverse the scope of municipal powers or the object of the plan-sanctioning scheme.
  7. On the affidavit/form issue: The court considered the objection that the affidavit was not in the precise form prescribed in Schedule I of the CMC Rules, but found the affidavit sworn according to statutory provisions and did not sustain the objection.
  8. Conclusion of analysis: Given (a) the absence of statutory support in the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act for an NOC as a precondition to plan sanction, (b) the timing of the rule amendment (which could not be applied retrospectively), and (c) the limited jurisdiction of municipal authorities, the Municipal Corporation's insistence on production of an NOC was held to be without jurisdiction and unjustified in the present case.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The appeal is allowed. The order of the learned Trial Court dated 7 April 1993 is set aside. Respondent No.2 is directed to accord sanction of the petitioners' plan within three weeks from the date of this judgment. The respondent authorities are restrained from giving effect to the letter issued by the competent authority under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 dated 23 February 1993.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on parties: The petitioner is entitled to sanction of the disputed building plan and the municipal authority is ordered to grant that sanction within the specified period; the municipal authority is prohibited from acting on the referenced letter of 23-2-93.
  • Scope of precedent: The opinion relies on existing statutory interpretation and an earlier Supreme Court decision (Maharao) and a Division Bench decision (Ram Nath Mehra) to resolve the present dispute. The judgment resolves the application of the amended rule prospectively and emphasizes that municipal authorities may not impose requirements (such as an NOC) not supported by statute for plans submitted prior to amendment. The opinion does not purport to lay down a novel general rule beyond resolution of the present dispute.

Order: "All parties to act on a signed xerox copy of this judgment on the usual undertaking." (per the text of the opinion)

    West Bengal Properties Ltd. And Another v. State Of West Bengal And Others

    Asok Kumar Chakravarty, J.:—This appeal is directed against the Judgment and Order dated 7th April, 1993 passed by the Ld. Trial Judge in matter No. of 1993 (West Bengal Properties v. State of West Bengal).

    2. Facts giving rise of this appeal are as follows:

    Petitioner No. 1 which is a limited company with its Office 16, Alipore Road, Calcutta and is the owner of the said premises (hereinafter to be referred as the said premises), submitted a plan for construction of a two-storeyed building before the respondent authorities along with a deposit of Rs. 10/- on 24-9-92 as application fees. By letter dated 13-12-92, the said authorities informed that certain other formalities have got to be complied with and after due compliance of those formalities by its letter dated 22nd December, 1992 submitted a revised plan. Since the respondent authorities have not sanctioned the plan in spite of due compliance of all formalities, it enquired about the matter and came to know from the respondent authorities that the plan was not being sanctioned as ‘no objection certificate’ from the Land Ceiling Authorities have not been appended to the application for sanction of the plan. The petitioner has challenged that respondent authority has no legal justification for insisting on production of such certificate from the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities that there is no reason for withholding sanction of the building plan of the petitioner. The petitioner accordingly moved a writ petition before the Ld. Trial Judge and by his order dated 29-3-93 on the basis of his observations that the specific case of the petitioners being that the plan has obtained the clearance of the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities directed the Municipal Authorities to produce the records relating to the plan submitted by the petitioners. Ld. Trial Judge, however, by another order dated 7-4-93, directed to respondents to file their affidavit-in-opposition on 26-4-93 as the observations in his earlier order that the specific case of the petitioners was that the clearance certificate has been obtained from the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities was erroneous.

    3. Being aggrieved by the aforesaid order of the Ld. Trial Judge, the petitioners has preferred this appeal alleging, inter alia, that the petitioners have neither any land beyond its permissible ceiling limit nor the respondent authorities have any right or justification to insist upon the clearance or no objection certificate from the Land Ceiling Authorities under the relevant Calcutta Municipal Corporation Building Rules, 1990.

    4. Mr. Mukul Gopal Banerjee, Ld. Counsel appearing for the petitioners drew our attention to sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of C.M.C Building Rules, 1990, which runs as follows, “in case of a site or a plot covered by the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 (33 of 1976), the notice shall be accompanied by a declaration of the applicant that his exclusive right to erect, re-erect or alter any building or portion thereof is not affected under that Act”. For that purpose, our attention was drawn to the affidavit filed on behalf of the petitiorfers to the effect that there they have no vacant land or any other land with building therein in any of the Urban Agglomeration covered of the said Act and that in the event of the aforesaid land being declared to be in excess by the competent authority under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976, the petitioners shall abide by the direction of the competent authority under the Act. The petitioners have, therefore, nothing more to do in the matter of sanction of that plan and the respondent authorities, according to Mr. Banerjee, had no justification for withholding the sanction of the plan in question.

    5. Mr. Mihir Kr. Roy, Ld. Counsel, appearing for the respondent No. 2, however, had two-fold submissions to make in the matter. His first submission was that by the notification No. 189.CC/3R-8/C-2/92 dated 29-2-93 sub-rule (4) of Rule 4 of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation Building Rules, 1990, has been substituted and the ‘no objection certificate’ from the competent authority appointed by the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 (33 of 1976) is required to be accompanied with the notice for sanction of building plan in case of a site or a plot measuring 5 Sq. metre or above. In so far as this point is concerned it is clear that the plan in question was submitted to the respondent authorities on the 24th September, 1992. Since the notification referred to by Mr. Roy, came into existence long after the said date, i.e, 29-3-93, there cannot be any question of the applications of such notification in so far as the sanction of the building plan of the petitioner is concerned as that can have application only prospectively. One of the primary duties of the Calcutta Municipal Corporation is to regulate the building construction of the city and for that purpose to sanction plan according to the Rules framed under Calcutta Municipal Corporation Act, 1980. Since the Municipal Corporation has no authority under the law to enforce or administer the law relating to Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 and since there is no corresponding provision in Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 making it obligatory for the competent authority, appointed under the Act to issue a ‘no objection certificate’ whenever sought for by any person deciding to submit any building plan to the appropriate authority for sanction, absence of such certificate cannot be sine qua non for sanctioning any building plan. Had it been provided under the provisions of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act that the Calcutta Municipal Corporation shall not sanction any plan for construction coming within the Urban agglomeration without first obtaining the permission of the competent authority under the Land Ceiling Act the positions might have been different. The direction of the Municipal Corporation asking the petitioner to furnish ‘no objection certificate’ from the competent authority, in the above circumstances, is certainly without jurisdiction. In this connection, reference may be made to the Division Bench decision of this Court in Ram Nath Mehra v. Calcutta Municipal Corporation, reported in (1988) 1 CLJ 295, where it was held that the Calcutta Municipal Corporation cannot insist on the production of ‘no objection certificate’ from the competent authority. The production of the ‘no objection certificate’ accordingly was wrongly insisted upon in this particular case.

    6. Mr. Roy finally submitted that the affidavit filed by the petitioner is not also in the form as prescribed in schedule one of the C.M.C Building Rules, 1990. The notice itself is not before the Court and the affidavit produced before the Court shows that it has been sworn according to the provisions of the statute. This objection, therefore, cannot also be sustained.

    7. It is firmly established principle that unless the rule-making-authority are specifically conferred power in the Act to make rules retrospectively the rules cannot have any retrospective effect. Further a plan has to be sanctioned on the basis of the rules and regulations prevailing on the date when such plan was submitted. By making a rule subsequent to the filing of the application for sanction of a plan the Municipal authority cannot affect the rights of the applicant. The amendment of Rule 4(4) of the said rules cannot have any retrospective effect and relying on such subsequent amendment the applicant cannot call upon to comply with the same. That apart, there is no provision under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 for issue of a ‘no objection certificate’ for the purpose of making construction on any land. Section 28 of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 provides:

    “Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law for the time being in force, where any document required to be regisiered under the provisions of clauses (a) to (e) of sub-section (1) of S. 17 of the Registration Act, 1908 (16 of 1908) purports to transfer by way of sale, mortgage, gift, lease or otherwise any land, or any building (including any portion thereof)—

    (a) in the case of any transfer referred to in S. 26 no registering officer appointed under that Act shall register any such document unless the transfer or produces before such registering officer evidence to show that he was given notice of the intended transfer to the competent authority under that section and, where such transfer is by way of sale, the period of sixty days referred to in sub-section (2) of that section has elapsed

    (b) in the case of any transfer referred to in S. 27 no registering officer appointed under that Act shall register any such document unless the transferor produces before such registering officer the permission in writing of the competent authority for such transfer or satisfies the registering officer that the period of sixty days referred to in sub-section (4) of that section has elapsed.”

    Section 27(1) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 provides that no person should transfer any propertyxby way of sale, mortgage, gift or a lease for a period exceeding 10 years or otherwise of any urbanisable land with a building or a portion of such building except with the previous permission in writing of the competent authority. This provision of S. 27(1) has been declared ultra vires by Supreme Court in the case of Maharao Saheb Sri Bhim Singhji v. Union of India, AIR 1981 SC 234. Therefore no permission is now required from the competent authority for transfer of urban or urbanisable land with a building within ceiling limit and the registering authority cannot refuse to transfer deed of transfer of urban land and urbanisable land with a building or any part of such building provided all the forms for registration are complied with. It must be borne in mind that mere raising a construction on any land has nothing to do with the ownership of the land and that by making construction one does not become the owner of the land in question. If a land is excess of the ceiling limit under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 in that event the same vests to the State from encumbrances and that at any point of time if it comes to the notice of the authorities concerned that any land was in excess of the ceiling limit, the same shall stand vested to the State and a party cannot claim any right over the same. The Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 did not contemplate any restriction and/or condition for the purpose of making construction on any vacant land if the vacant land was beyond the ceiling limit, in that event by making more construction nothing wrong is done. Section 5(3) of the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 provides that no person holding a vacant land in excess of the ceiling limit shall transfer in excess limit and if such transfer is made, the same would be deemed to be null and void. Whether or not land is covered under the Land Ceiling Act or whether it was within the ceiling limit or not are matters for the Urban Land Ceiling Authorities and not for the Municipal Authorities. For obtaining the plan and making a construction does not and cannot change the nature of the right, title and interest in the land in question. If it is in excess of the Ceiling limit, even if construction is made on such land, the same should stand vested to the State. The Municipal authorities are only concerned with the planning of the cities and to see that no construction is made save in accordance with the sanctioned plan and after complying with the conditions and restrictions imposed under the municipal laws. It had no jurisdiction to adjudicate on the question of ownership of the land in question. The Municipal authorities are concerned with the prima facie title of the applicant in such land. The sanctioning of plan did not and could not create any right, title and interest in the land in question if it is not otherwise there and as such it is beyond the scope of the powers of the municipal authorities under the Act and lay down any procedure travelling the scope and ambit of the Act which had no nexus with the object sought to be achieved by sanctioning of such plan under the law.

    8. No other point was taken in the appeal, since both the objections on behalf of the respondents in justification for refusal of the sanction plan by the respondents are not tenable, the appeal must succeed.

    9. The appeal is accordingly allowed and the order of Ld. trial Court dt. 7-4-93 is hereby set aside. The respondent No. 2 is hereby directed to accord sanction of the plan of the petitioners within three weeks from this date and the respondent authority are hereby restrained from giving effect to the letter issued by the competent authority under the Urban Land (Ceiling and Regulation) Act, 1976 dated 23-2-93.

    10. All parties to act on a signed xerox copy of this judgment on the usual undertaking.

    Bhagabati Prasad Banerjee, J.:—11. I agree.

    Appeal allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    West Bengal Properties Ltd. And Another v. State Of West Bengal And Others
    (Jul 29, 1993)