Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 80B of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Rules 182(4)(vii) and 182(4)(viii)
  • sub-clause (viii) of Rule 182(4)
  • sub-clause (vii) of Rule 182(4)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 80,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • Section 80B of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act,
  • Rules 182(4)(vii) and 182(4)(viii)
  • sub-clause (viii) of Rule 182(4)
  • sub-clause (vii) of Rule 182(4)
  • sub-section (1) of Section 80,
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — Ramachandran Nair, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The Co-operative Service Examination Board, constituted under Section 80B of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, conducted examinations in 2003 to select Junior Clerks for appointment to various banks, including the appellant bank. A consolidated list prepared by the Examination Board resulted in a merit list published by the appellant-bank where the first respondent was ranked No. 6. Although six vacancies were notified initially, the first respondent was not appointed in the first round due to appointment by rotation.

The select list prepared by the society was valid until 10.11.2005. During the currency of that select list, additional vacancies arose. The appellant-bank refused to appoint further candidates from the select list on the ground that only the originally notified vacancies (six) could be filled from that list. The first respondent claimed eligibility for appointment since vacancies arose while the list remained valid.

The first respondent filed Writ Petition WPC 31511 of 2005; this Court (single Judge) on 6.1.2006 directed the Joint Registrar to consider her claim. The Joint Registrar, by order Ext.P2, directed the appellant-bank to appoint the first respondent. The appellant appealed to the Government under Section 83(1)(j) of the Act; the Government, by Ext.P4, cancelled the Joint Registrar's order. The first respondent then filed a further Writ Petition in this Court, which resulted in the single Judge cancelling the Government order on the ground that the Government had not given tenable reasons for interfering with Ext.P2. The appellant-bank filed the present Writ Appeal challenging that judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether vacancies arising during the currency of a select list (valid for two years as per Rule 182(4)(vii)) can be filled from that list even if the initially notified number of vacancies has already been filled.
  2. Whether the Joint Registrar had the authority to direct the appellant-bank to appoint the first respondent from the select list (i.e., whether the Joint Registrar or this Court can direct appointment from the select list when the bank failed or refused to fill subsequent vacancies).
  3. Whether delay or expiration of the select list after the vacancy arose prevents the Joint Registrar from directing appointment where the vacancy had arisen during the list's validity.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant-Bank's Arguments (as advanced by counsel Sri. George Poonthottam)

  • There is no provision allowing appointment of more than the originally notified vacancies from the prepared list; once the notified vacancies were filled, no further appointments could be made from that list even if the list remained valid.
  • Reliance on several precedents (two Division Bench decisions of this Court and decisions of the Supreme Court) for the proposition that only notified vacancies may be filled from a prepared list.
  • Even where the society failed to fill vacancies, neither the Joint Registrar nor this Court has power to direct appointment of a candidate from the select list (relying on certain Supreme Court authorities cited in the judgment).

First Respondent's Arguments (as advanced by counsel Sri. P.N. Mohanan)

  • Reliance on Rule 182(4)(vii) and 182(4)(viii) which, according to counsel, support the proposition that any vacancy arising during the currency of the validity of the list must be filled from that list.
  • Reliance on the Division Bench decision in SURESH v. M.G. UNIVERSITY (2009) 1 KLT 950 for the same proposition that vacancies arising during the validity period should be filled from the select list.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
RAJA MOHAN v. STATE OF KERALA, ILR (1997) 1 Ker. 199 Cited by appellant for the proposition that only notified vacancies can be filled from the list prepared. The court noted this decision was among earlier decisions relied upon by the appellant but observed that such decisions were for the period prior to the introduction of the specific rules (Rule 182(4)(vii) and (viii)) now relied upon; accordingly, these earlier decisions were not treated as determinative in the presence of the relevant Rules.
NAZER v. STATE, (1996) 1 K.L.T. 321 Cited by appellant for the proposition that only notified vacancies may be filled from the list. The court observed that the decision pre-dated the Rules relied upon and thus was not controlling in light of Rule 182(4)(vii) and (viii).
PREM SINGH v. HARYANA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD, (1996) 4 SCC 319 Cited by appellant (Supreme Court authority) for the proposition that only notified vacancies could be filled from the prepared list. The court recorded the citation but held that the decisions relied upon were for a period prior to the introduction of the Rules now under consideration, so those authorities did not override the express wording and purpose of Rule 182(4)(vii) and (viii).
STATE OF U.P. v. RAJKUMAR SHARMA, (2006) 3 SCC 330 Cited by appellant to contend that even where there was failure in filling vacancies, neither the Joint Registrar nor court could direct appointment from the select list. The court referred to this and other Supreme Court decisions but held that the relevant Rules (introduced after many of those decisions) are the determinative source for appointments to vacancies and vacancies arising during the currency of the list.
S. RENUKA v. STATE OF A.P., (2002) 5 SCC 195 Cited by appellant in support of the contention that appointment could not be directed by Joint Registrar or court beyond notified vacancies. The court observed that this authority was from an earlier period and that the Rules now quoted (182(4)(vii) & (viii)) are the relevant provisions governing the present appointments; thus, the earlier authority did not control the outcome.
STATE OF U.P. v. OM PRAKASH, (2006) 6 SCC 474 Cited by appellant to support the position that directions for appointment could not be issued by the Joint Registrar/court after failure to fill vacancies. The court recorded the citation but held that the statutory Rules introduced and relied upon in this case are the operative law; prior Supreme Court decisions were not treated as supplanting those Rules for the instant facts.
SURESH v. M.G. UNIVERSITY, (2009) 1 KLT 950 (Division Bench) Cited by the first respondent for the proposition that vacancies arising during the currency of the validity of the list should be filled from such list. The court noted reliance on this Division Bench decision in support of the respondent’s position. The court's ultimate reasoning aligned with the view embodied in the relevant Rules that vacancies arising during the list's currency can be filled from that list.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the relevant statutory scheme and Rules governing recruitment to societies covered by Section 80B of the Act, focusing on Rule 182(4)(vii) and (viii). The analysis proceeded along the following lines as expressly stated in the judgment:

  1. Identification of the controlling Rules:
    • Rule 182(4)(vii) provides that the rank list prepared by the society based on the Examination Board's list shall be valid for two years from the date of publication by the society.
    • Rule 182(4)(viii) requires that all appointments to the vacancies shall be made by the committee from the select list so published within one month from the date of such publication and shall be reported to the Examination Board.
  2. Purpose and plain meaning of the Rules:
    • The court interpreted the two-year validity in sub-clause (vii) as intended to enable societies to fill vacancies arising during that two-year currency from the select list prepared after the examination.
    • The court found the appellant's contention—that only the originally notified vacancies can ever be filled from the list—would nullify the purpose of preserving the list's validity for two years and would require repeated fresh examinations each time a vacancy arose, which was contrary to the rule's object.
  3. Precedents and chronology:
    • The court observed that the decisions cited by the appellant were rendered prior to the introduction of the Rules (182(4)(vii) & (viii)) and therefore were not the only relevant law now governing appointments to vacancies and vacancies arising during the currency of the list.
    • Consequently, the court held those precedents could not prevail over the explicit provisions and purpose of the Rules presently applicable.
  4. Authority of the Joint Registrar:
    • The court referred to Section 66 (specific powers) and Section 66A (inserted by amendment in 2000) which confers upon the Registrar general supervisory and direction-giving powers "in furtherance of the purposes of this Act."
    • On this basis the court concluded that the Joint Registrar had jurisdiction to issue directions ensuring societies comply with the Act and Rules, and thus was within power to direct the appellant to appoint the first respondent from the list which was valid when the vacancy arose.
  5. Delay and effect of expiry:
    • The court rejected the appellant's contention that the Joint Registrar could not direct appointment after expiry of the list, reasoning that eligibility is determined when the vacancy arises (while the list was valid), and a subsequent delay in passing orders does not affect that eligibility or the validity of the Joint Registrar's corrective direction.
  6. Conclusion of analysis:
    • Applying the Rules and the statutory supervisory power under Section 66A, the court held the Joint Registrar rightly directed appointment of the first respondent and that the single Judge's judgment vacating the Government's cancellation of that direction should be upheld.

Holding and Implications

Writ Appeal dismissed.

Consequences and direct effect on the parties:

  • The court upheld the single Judge's judgment vacating the Government's order (Ext.P4) and upheld the Joint Registrar's direction (Ext.P2) that the appellant-bank must appoint the first respondent from the select list prepared pursuant to the 2003 examination.
  • Because the matter had suffered delay, the court directed the appellant to appoint the first respondent within two weeks from the date of production of a copy of this judgment.
  • The court held that the Joint Registrar had authority under the Act (including Section 66A) to issue such directions to ensure compliance with the Act and Rules.

Broader implications: The court's decision rests on the construction and application of Rule 182(4)(vii) & (viii) (validity of the list for two years and the scheme for appointments) and on the Registrar's supervisory powers under Section 66A. The opinion notes that earlier authorities relied on by the appellant pre-dated these Rules, and it treats the Rules as the relevant governing provisions for the facts of this case. The judgment does not state that it establishes any broader legal rule beyond the application of the cited Rules and statutory powers to the facts before the Court.

    Kodakara Farmers Service Co-Operative v. Neena K.K.

    JUDGMENT

    Ramachandran Nair, J.

    Writ Appeal is filed by the Appellant-Bank challenging the judgment of the learned single Judge vacating the order of the Government in appeal, restoring the order of the Joint Registrar and directing the appellant to appoint the first respondent in the Writ Appeal as Junior Clerk pursuant to her inclusion in the select list prepared by the Appellate based on the examination conducted by the Co-operative Service Examination Board in the year 2003. We have heard Sri. George Poonthottam, counsel appearing for the Appellant-Bank and Sri. P.N Mohanan, counsel appearing for the first respondent.

    2. The Co-operative Service Examination Board constituted under Section 80B of the Kerala Co-operative Societies Act, conducted examination for selection of Junior Clerks for appointment to various Banks including that of the appellant. Pursuant to list of candidates prepared by the Examination Board, the appellant-Bank prepared merit list wherein the first respondent figured as rank No. 6. Even though six vacancies were notified for appointment as Junior Clerk, on account of appointment by rotation, the first respondent was not appointed in the first round. However, during the currency of the select list which was valid upto 10.11.2005, several vacancies arose for the post of Junior Clerk in the appellant-Bank. However, the Bank took the stand that vacancies arose during the currency of the merit list prepared on 11.11.2003 cannot be filled up with candidates therein and according to appellant-Bank, once notified vacancies, namely, six, were filled up no more vacancy could be filled up from out of the list prepared, no matter the list was valid during the period the vacancies arose. The claim of the first respondent is that since vacancies arose during the currency of the select list wherein she is next to be appointed, she is eligible to be appointed. Since the Bank did not take any action, the first respondent approached this Court with a Writ Petition for direction to the Bank to consider her claim for appointment, and this Court vide judgment in WPC 31511 of 2005 dated 6.1.2006 directed the Joint Registrar to consider first respondent's claim. The Joint Registrar vide Ext.P2 order directed the appellant-Bank to appoint first respondent. Against this order, the appellant approached the Government with an appeal under Section 83(1)(j) of the Act and the Government vide Ext.P4 order cancelled the direction issued by the Joint Registrar against which the first respondent filed the WPC. This Court though did not go into the Rules governing the validity of the list of selected candidates, cancelled the order of the Government stating that Government has not assigned any tenable reason for interfering with Ext.P2 order of the Joint Registrar. It is against this judgment this appeal is filed by the Bank.

    3. Counsel for the appellant has referred to various decisions of this Court and that of the Supreme Court and contended that there is no provision to appoint more than the notified vacancies from the list prepared. The decisions cited are two Division Bench decisions of this Court in RAJA MOHAN v. STATE OF KERALA, ILR (1997) 1 Ker. 199, and NAZER v. STATE, (1996) 1 K.L.T 321. Further counsel also relied on the decision of the Supreme Court in PREM SINGH v. HARYANA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD, (1996) 4 SCC 319 for the proposition that notified vacancies only could be filled up from the list prepared. The further contention of counsel based on the decisions of the Supreme Court in STATE OF U.P v. RAJKUMAR SHARMA, (2006) 3 SCC 330, S. RENUKA v. STATE OF A.P, (2002) 5 SCC 195 and STATE OF UP v. OM PRAKASH, (2006) 6 SCC 474 is that even if there is failure on the part of the appellant in not filling up the vacancies from the select list, still neither the Joint Registrar nor this Court has power to direct the appointment of the first respondent from the select list. Counsel appearing for the first respondent has relied on Rule 182(4)(vii) and (viii) and the decision of Division Bench of this Court in SURESH v. M.G UNIVERSITY, (2009) 1 KLT 950 for the proposition that any vacancy arising during the currency of the validity of the list should be filled up from such list.

    4. After hearing both sides and after going through the relevant rules, we are of the view that the action of the appellant in not filling up the vacancies that arose during the validity of the list prepared pursuant to examination conducted by the Examination Board is not justified and Joint Registrar has rightly directed the appellant to appoint the first respondent, who was next in the list of selected candidates prepared by the appellant pursuant to examination conducted by the Board. Rules 182(4)(vii) and 182(4)(viii) which are relevant in this regard are extracted hereunder for easy reference:

    182. Classification under section 80(1):- (1) For the purpose of sub-section (1) of Section 80, the societies in the State shall be classified as shown in Appendix III:

    ……………………

    (4) In respect of recruitment to societies covered by Section 80B of the Act, the following procedure shall be followed:

    ………………

    (vii) On the basis of the cosolidated list so received from the Examination Board, the committee shall prepare the rank list of candidates and publish the same in the notice board of the society. The society shall send one copy of the rank list so published to the Examination Board also. The board shall examine the correctness of such rank list and report to the Registrar, the irregularities, if any. The list shall be valid for a period of two years from the date of publication of the same by the society.

    (viii) All appointments to the vacancies shall be made by the committee from the select list so published within one month from the date of such publication and shall be reported to the Examination Board.

    ………………..

    We find that sub-clause (viii) of Rule 182(4) requires the Society to fill up notified vacancies within one month from the date of publication of the list of candidates prepared by it from out of the list received from the Examination Board. It is pertinent to note that under sub-clause (vii) of Rule 182(4), the validity of the list is retained for a period of two years from the date of publication of the same prepared by the society. In our view, the very purpose of keeping the select list valid for two years prepared by the society based on examination conducted by the Examination Board is to enable the society to fill up the vacancies arising during the currency of the validity of the list from out of such list. If the contention of the appellant-Bank that only notified vacancies can be filled up from the list prepared is accepted, then we see no reason why the Rule provides for validity of the list valid for two years from the date of publication after it's preparation by the society under the Rules. Retention of validity of list is only for the purpose of enabling the society to fill up vacancies arising during the period of two years during which period, the list is kept valid by operation of the Rule. If the appellant's argument is accepted, each time when vacancy arises after filling up the notified number of vacancies from the prepared list, examination has to be conducted by the Board immediately after one round of selection, as and when vacancy arises. Therefore the argument of counsel for the appellant is defeative of the very purpose of sub-clause (vii) of Rule 182(4) by which the validity of list is retained for two years. All the decisions cited are for period prior to the introduction of rules above referred which are the only relevant rules for making appointment to the notified vacancies and vacancies arising during the currency of the validity of the list prepared by the Bank. We therefore uphold the judgment of the learned single Judge vacating the order in appeal passed by the Government and by upholding the direction issued by the Joint Registrar for first respondent's appointment.

    5. We are unable to agree with the contention of appellant's counsel that the Joint Registrar has no authority to issue direction to the appellant to appoint first respondent from out of the list prepared. Besides the specific powers under Section 66, it is pertinent to note that the Act was amended in 2000 incorporating Section 66A giving general powers to the Registrar which is as follows:

    66A. Powers of Registrar to give directions.-- Subject to the provisions contained in the Act and the Rules made thereunder the Registrar may issue general directions and guidelines to the Co-operative S ocieties in furtherance of the purposes of this Act.

    We are of the view that the purpose of Rule 66A is to give supervisory power to Registrar to ensure that societies are functioning in accordance with the provisions of the Act and Rules. In our view, the direction issued by the Joint Registrar to the appellant to appoint the first respondent from the select list is only to ensure that Co-operative Societies Rules are followed by the appellant in regard to filling up of vacancies of Junior Clerk. We therefore hold that Joint Registrar was within his powers to issue direction to the appellant to appoint first respondent from the list of selected candidates because the list was valid when the vacancy arose.

    6. The next contention raised by the appellant that direction could not have been issued by the Joint Registrar after expiry of the list is also not tenable because since the Bank failed to fill up the vacancy that arose during the currency of the list, what the Joint Registrar did was to correct the Bank which failed in their duty in terms of the Rule. The eligibility of the first respondent for appointment is to be considered only when the vacancy arises and not when the matter was considered by the Joint Registrar pursuant to the direction issued by this Court. Therefore the delay in passing orders for the first respondent's appointment does not affect the validity of the order issued by the Joint Registrar. We therefore reject this contention as well.

    Consequently Writ Appeal is dismissed. Since the matter is already delayed, there will be direction to the appellant to appoint the first respondent within two weeks from the date of production of a copy of this judgment.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Kodakara Farmers Service Co-Operative v. Neena K.K.
    (Jan 25, 2010)