Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • GENERAL CLAUSES ACT
  • CONSTITUTION 74TH AMENDMENT ACT 1992
  • SECTION 21 GENERAL CLAUSES ACT
  • CONSTITUTION 73RD AMENDMENT ACT 1992
  • clause (d) of Article 243P and clause (2) of Article 243Q of the Constitution, read with clause (b) of sub-section (2) of Section 4 of the Municipality Act,
  • Municipality Act, 1994. Such provisions
  • Article 243Q and sub-section (1)
  • Section 4(2)(b) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994, hereinafter, the Municipality Act,
  • Section (4) of the Municipality Act,
  • Himachal Pradesh Act
  • Section 2(b)
  • Himachal Pradesh Municipality Act, 1968, referred
  • Sub-section (2) of Section 4
  • Section 10 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act
  • Kerala Panchayats Act, 1960, the Kerala Municipalities Act, 1960, the Kerala Municipal Corporations Act, 1961
  • Article 367(1) of the Constitution, the General Clauses Act, 1897
  • Article 367, the said rule
  • Municipalities Act, 1960,
  • Section 4 of the Municipality Act, 1994
  • Municipality Act, 1994
  • 1994 Act. However, Section 4(6)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Advocates
Judges
Acts
  • GENERAL CLAUSES ACT
  • CONSTITUTION 74TH AMENDMENT ACT 1992
  • SECTION 21 GENERAL CLAUSES ACT
  • CONSTITUTION 73RD AMENDMENT ACT 1992
  • clause (d) of Article 243P and clause (2) of Article 243Q of the Constitution, read with clause (b) of sub-section (2) of Section 4 of the Municipality Act,
  • Municipality Act, 1994. Such provisions
  • Article 243Q and sub-section (1)
  • Section 4(2)(b) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994, hereinafter, the Municipality Act,
  • Section (4) of the Municipality Act,
  • Himachal Pradesh Act
  • Section 2(b)
  • Himachal Pradesh Municipality Act, 1968, referred
  • Sub-section (2) of Section 4
  • Section 10 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act
  • Kerala Panchayats Act, 1960, the Kerala Municipalities Act, 1960, the Kerala Municipal Corporations Act, 1961
  • Article 367(1) of the Constitution, the General Clauses Act, 1897
  • Article 367, the said rule
  • Municipalities Act, 1960,
  • Section 4 of the Municipality Act, 1994
  • Municipality Act, 1994
  • 1994 Act. However, Section 4(6)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ petitions challenge notifications issued by the Governor and consequential notifications under the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994, which effectively "de-linked" certain areas that had previously been notified as "smaller urban areas" or "larger urban areas" (for purposes of Part IXA of the Constitution) and treated them as "village Panchayats" (for purposes of Part IX). The key impugned notifications are SRO No. 459/2005, SRO No. 460/2005, SRO No. 461/2005 and SRO No. 462/2005 (all dated 9-5-2005), which sought to notify, with effect from 1-10-2005, specified areas of several Grama Panchayats as village Panchayats and to issue consequential notifications under Section 4 of the Municipality Act excluding those areas from the municipal territories. The challenged actions reversed notifications issued in 1999 (SRO Nos. 974/99, 975/99, 976/99, 1056/99, 1057/99, 1058/99) that had declared those areas to be smaller or larger urban areas and had included them in specified municipalities and a municipal corporation. The petitions raise constitutional questions about whether an area that has transitioned from rural to urban can be re-transited to rural status and whether the statutory provision Section 4(2)(b) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994 permits such re-transit.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a rural area, after transition to an urban area thereby becoming a "smaller urban area" or a "larger urban area" under Article 243Q of the Constitution, can be re-transited to be a rural area.
  2. If such re-transit is possible, whether it can be effected under an exercise brought about for the purpose of the provisions of Part IXA of the Constitution.
  3. Whether the impugned "de-linking" of certain urban areas from municipalities, for being treated as rural areas, is unconstitutional.
  4. Whether such action (if constitutionally permissible) is susceptible to judicial review and, if so, whether the impugned action is vitiated by illegality, irrationality or procedural impropriety (the three recognised grounds of judicial review).
  5. Whether Section 4(2)(b) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994 is constitutional insofar as it is relied upon to exclude an area from a municipal area and (as argued) to permit a re-transit of an urban area to a rural area.

Arguments of the Parties

Arguments advanced by Advocate Sri V. Giri (on behalf of the respondents)

  • Invoked Article 367(1) of the Constitution to submit that the General Clauses Act, 1897 applies; therefore the Governor's power to notify under Article 243Q(2) includes power to de-notify, amend or alter such notifications by virtue of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act.
  • Relied on authorities including K.P. Khetan v. Union of India and Ranchhod Zina v. Patankar to support the contention that the General Clauses Act permits such modification of notifications.

Arguments advanced by Senior Advocate Sri T.P.K. Nambiar

  • Contended that the context here is one contrary to the application of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act; thus Article 367 and the General Clauses Act do not permit re-transit of an urban area to a rural area.

Arguments advanced by Senior Advocate Sri M.K. Damodaran

  • Contended that before issuing notifications under Section 4(2) of the Municipality Act, the requirements of Article 243Q must be complied with and that those requirements were not fulfilled in issuing the impugned notifications; thus the notifications issued under Section 4(2) are challengeable.
  • Urged that the public's right to be heard (principles of natural justice) applied and that the statutory process did not afford the necessary hearing.

Arguments advanced by the Learned Advocate General

  • Submitted that even if part of the impugned exercise was void, the doctrine of severability (relying on R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla) could operate to sustain parts of the notifications rather than quashing them in entirety.

Other procedural/legality arguments referred to in the opinion

  • It was argued (and the opinion records submissions) that Section 4(2)(b) must be parsed carefully because of controversy as to its language and effect; a corrected English rendering of the provision is noted in the opinion.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of U.P v. Pradhan Singh Kshetra Samiti, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 305; AIR 1995 SC 1512 The Governor is not bound by any particular yardsticks in specifying "villages" for the purpose of Part IX. Used to differentiate Article 243(g) (no yardstick for villages) from Article 243Q(2) (which provides yardsticks for urban categories) and to support the view that once an area becomes a constitutionally-created urban area under Article 243Q, it cannot be re-transited to a village under Part IX by ordinary exercise.
T.M. Kanniyan v. ITO, AIR 1968 SC 637 Where the context is contrary, recourse to the General Clauses Act is not available; interpretation by reference to the General Clauses Act may be repugnant to the constitutional context. Relied upon to reject the submission that Section 21 of the General Clauses Act (permitting amendment/de-notification) applies to permit re-transit under Article 243Q; the Court held Section 21 inapplicable in this context.
K.P. Khetan v. Union of India, AIR 1957 SC 676 Cited by respondents' counsel to support the applicability of the General Clauses Act and the scope of power to amend notifications. Not accepted as persuasive in this context; Court concluded the constitutional scheme excludes such application of Section 21 where Article 243Q governs the creation of municipal areas.
Ranchhod Zina v. Patankar, AIR 1966 Gujarat 248 Cited by respondents' counsel in support of the proposition that statutory provisions permitting alteration could be read broadly. Court observed that the factual and statutory context of that case differed and did not support re-transit in the constitutional context of Parts IX and IXA.
M.K. Krishnan Nair v. State of Kerala, 1974 Ker LT 313 Referenced for the proposition that Section 21 of the General Clauses Act may apply by virtue of Article 367 even where the underlying power is conditional. Court distinguished that authority and held the context here excluded the application of Section 21 despite Article 367; Article 243Q's scheme governs.
Baldev Singh v. State of Himachal Pradesh, (1987) 2 SCC 510; AIR 1987 SC 1239 Where an exercise of power results in civil consequences, the rules of natural justice (right to be heard) apply unless statute rules them out. Applied to conclude that where governmental decisions had civil consequences (changing local self-government status), the public had a right to be heard; Court found defects in compliance with Article 243Q and related statutory procedure.
State of Orissa v. Sridhar Kumar Mallik, (1985) 3 SCC 697; AIR 1985 SC 1411 Referred in the context of whether statutory provisions provide for a right of hearing and the application of natural justice. Used as background (via Baldev Singh) to reinforce that where statute does not explicitly exclude natural justice, a hearing (which may be by inviting objections) is required.
State of Maharashtra v. Jalgaon Municipal Council, (2003) 9 SCC 731; AIR 2003 SC 1659 Principles on natural justice and the moulding of fair hearing; administrative acts affecting rights must comply with fair hearing norms. Cited to emphasize that procedural fairness is required and to explain how courts mould the requirements of fair hearing; contrasted with the facts of the present matter where statutory requirements were not met.
Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, (2000) 1 SCC 168; AIR 2000 SC 498 Legislative declarations of facts are not immune from judicial scrutiny; courts can examine the correctness of such declarations. Invoked to support the proposition that conditional legislation and executive/legislative declarations can be reviewed by courts and are not conclusive in the face of constitutional challenges.
Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, (1973) 4 SCC 225; AIR 1973 SC 1461 Principle that courts can "lift the veil" to examine the real nature of statutes and declarations where appropriate. Cited within the Indra Sawhney discussion as foundational authority for judicial scrutiny of legislative/administrative declarations.
Charles Russell v. R., (1882) 7 AC 829 Cited in the broader discussion about judicial scrutiny of legislative declarations (as referenced by judges in other cases). Referred to as background authority cited in Indra Sawhney; used illustratively in the opinion's discussion of judicial review of legislative fact-declarations.
Attorney General v. Queen Insurance Co., (1978) 3 AC 1090 Referenced in context of statements about the limits of legislative declarations and judicial scrutiny. Referred to as background authority within the discussion of judicial review.
R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla v. Union of India, AIR 1957 SC 628 Doctrine of severability — even if part of an enactment or action is void, it may be possible to sever the invalid portion and uphold the remainder. Relying on this, the Advocate General argued for severability; Court held severability inappropriate because the impugned notifications were fundamentally inconsistent with Article 243Q and thus could not be sustained in part.
State of Haryana v. State of Punjab, (2002) 2 SCC 507; AIR 2002 SC 685 Observation on the impropriety of successive governments undoing decisions unrelated to political philosophy, and the importance of continuity in governance. Quoted to note that repeated linking and de-linking by successive governments undermines the constitutional objectives of insulating local self-government institutions; used to criticize repeated governmental reversals.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeds from constitutional text and structure to statutory interpretation, applying doctrines of constitutional supremacy, separation of powers in the local government context, and procedural fairness.

Key steps in the Court's reasoning:

  1. Constitutional framework and distinct roles of Parts IX and IXA:
    • The Court emphasized that Part IX (Panchayats) and Part IXA (Municipalities) set up two distinct constitutional schemes: Panchayats are created under Article 243 (clauses (g), (c), (d), etc.) and Municipalities under Articles 243P–243Z (including Article 243Q).
    • Under Article 243, the Governor specifies villages and intermediate levels for Part IX; under Article 243Q(2), the Governor specifies transitional areas, smaller urban areas and larger urban areas with specified yardsticks (population, density, revenue, non-agricultural employment percentage, economic importance or other factors).
  2. Plain reading of Article 243Q(1) shows only transition from rural to urban:
    • The Court highlighted that Article 243Q(1) contemplates constitution of Nagar Panchayats for transitional (rural-to-urban) areas and Municipal Councils/Corporations for smaller/larger urban areas; Article 243Q does not provide for transition of an urban area back to a rural area.
    • Therefore, constitutionally there is no mechanism under Parts IX or IXA to re-transit an urban area into a village for purposes of Part IX.
  3. Effect on constitutional status of Municipalities and Panchayats:
    • Once an area is notified as a smaller or larger urban area under Article 243Q(2), a Municipality becomes a constitutional institution; such an institution cannot be abolished or converted into a Panchayat by ordinary legislation or executive action absent express constitutional authorization.
  4. Application of the General Clauses Act (Section 21) and Article 367:
    • Respondents' counsel argued Article 367 brings the General Clauses Act into play, allowing de-notification/amendment of notifications.
    • The Court rejected this in the present context, holding there is a "context to the contrary" that excludes application of Section 21 — because recognizing such a power would effectively permit re-transit of an area from Part IXA to Part IX contrary to the express constitutional scheme. The Court relied on principle in T.M. Kanniyan to hold that recourse to the General Clauses Act is unavailable where it is repugnant to the constitutional context.
  5. Construction of Section 4(2) of the Municipality Act, 1994:
    • The Court examined Section 4(2) which permits the Government to, among other actions, "exclude from a municipal area any specified area comprised therein and defined in such notification" (Section 4(2)(b)).
    • The Court read Section 4(2)(b) as permitting exclusion of areas from a municipal area (e.g., for transfer to another municipality or to re-arrange municipal boundaries) but not as authority to re-transit an urban area into a rural (Panchayat) area. The Court noted that the Act does not and cannot constitutionally provide for abolition of a Municipality into a Panchayat.
    • Consequently, Section 4(2)(b) must be understood as permitting exclusion only insofar as the area remains within the municipal framework (or is otherwise reorganized among municipalities), and not to convert it into a village Panchayat; to that extent the provision must be read down and cannot be applied to effect re-transit.
  6. Procedural requirements and compliance with Article 243Q:
    • The Court observed that the first proviso to Section 4(2) required that the requirements under Article 243Q be fulfilled before issuing a notification under Section 4(2). The Court found that those requirements had not been complied with prior to the impugned notifications, making them vulnerable to challenge.
  7. Natural justice / right to be heard:
    • Relying on Baldev Singh and related authorities, the Court recognized that exercises of power that have civil consequences require compliance with principles of natural justice (the right to be heard). The Court noted that objections and suggestions were to be considered for the consequential notifications, but concluded that the statutory and constitutional requirements had not been met in the process leading to the impugned notifications.
  8. Severability and overall validity:
    • The Advocate General invoked severability to suggest parts of the impugned notifications might be preserved if other parts were void. The Court held that because an exercise to re-transit urban areas to rural areas is impermissible under Article 243Q, any action that purports to do so cannot be sustained; thus the notifications could not be salvaged in part and had to be set aside in whole.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions are allowed. SRO No. 459/2005, SRO No. 460/2005, SRO No. 461/2005 and SRO No. 462/2005 are declared unconstitutional and are quashed.

Implications and consequences:

  • The Court held as a constitutional principle that a rural area which has been transitioned into an urban area (as a "smaller urban area" or "larger urban area" under Article 243Q) cannot be re-transited to be a rural area by executive action or under Part IXA or by the State legislation; there is no constitutional provision for an urban-to-rural transition.
  • Section 4(2)(b) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994 cannot be construed to permit the conversion of an already-constituted municipal area into a village Panchayat; the provision must be read down to exclude any such implication.
  • The impugned "de-linking" of the specified urban areas from municipalities for being treated as rural areas is unconstitutional and void; the notifications implementing that de-linking were quashed in their entirety.
  • The Court found inadequate compliance with Article 243Q and relevant procedural requirements (including aspects of fair hearing), and rejected the argument that the General Clauses Act rendered the impugned de-notifications valid.
  • No costs were imposed; the petitions were allowed (the opinion records "Petitions allowed.").

Note: The summary above is confined to the contents and conclusions explicitly stated in the provided opinion. No information has been inferred beyond what the opinion itself provides.

    K.P Raveendran And Another v. State Of Kerala And Others

    1. Can a rural area, after its transit to be an urban area, thereby becoming a “Smaller urban area” or a “larger urban area” in terms of Article 243Q of the Constitution of India, be re-transited to be a rural area? If so, can it be done under an exercise for the purpose of the provisions of Part IXA of the Constitution? Is the impugned “de-linking” of certain urban areas from the municipalities, for being treated as rural areas, unconstitutional? If such action is permissible in terms of the Constitution, could it be subjected to control by judicial review? If so, is the impugned action vitiated by illegality, irrationality or procedural impropriety, the three well recognized grounds? Broadly, these are the issues that arise for decision in these writ petitions. Section 4(2)(b) of the Kerala Municipality Act, 1994, hereinafter, the “Municipality Act”, for short, is also challenged in WP(C) No. 16997 of 2005, as unconstitutional.

    Relevant common facts:

    2. As per SRO No. 468/94 and SRO No. 469/94, respectively, the Governor notified the “villages” and the “intermediate levels”, for the purpose of Part IX of the Constitution, in exercise of the powers, in that regard, conferred by clauses (g) and (c) of Article 243. Each of the Villages so specified was to have the territorial area of the Panchayat that then existed, as shown against each of the Villages so notified. As per SRO No. 470/94, the Governor, in exercise of the powers, in that regard, conferred by clause (d) of Article 243P and clause (2) of Article 243Q, notified the “smaller urban areas” and the “larger urban areas”, so enlisted in Schedules I and II therein and further notifying that each area so specified shall be a municipal area for the purpose of Part IXA of the Constitution. SRO No. 468/94, SRO No. 469/94 and SRO No. 470/94 were published as per GO (P) No. 86/94.LAD dated 20-4-1994.

    3. By SRO No. 974/99 published as per GO(P) No. 224/99.LSGD dated 30-11-1999, the Governor notified the areas of Andoor, Kodiyeri, Perumpazhuthur and Ezhu-vathuruthy Grama Panchayats to be “smaller urban areas” and the areas of Ullor, Nemom, Attipra, Kadakampally and Thiruvallam Grama Panchayats to be “larger urban areas” for the purpose of Part IXA, with effect from 1-10-2000. The areas, Andoor, Kodiyeri, Ezhuvathuruthy and Perumpazhuthur were included in the Thaliparambu, Thalassery, Ponnani and Neyyattlnkara Municipalities respectively and the areas, Ulloor, Nemom, Attipra, Kadakampally and Thiruvallam were included in the Thiruvananthapuram Municipal Corporation. Consequential notifications, SRO No. 975/99, published as per GO(P) No. 225/99.LSGD dated 30-11-1999 and SRO No. 976/99, published as per GO (P) No. 226/99.LSGD dated 30-11-1999, were issued under the Municipality Act. As per SRO No. 1056/99, published as per GO (P) No. 253/99.LSGD dated 21-12-1999, the Governor notified, with effect from 1-10-2000, certain areas as “smaller urban areas”, thereby adding respectively, the areas of Arthatt Grama Panchayat and Ward No. 2, 3, 9, 11 and parts of Wards No. 1 and 10 of Chovannur Grama Panchayat to the Kunnamkulam Municipality; Wards No. 11 and 12 of Meppadi Grama Panchayat between Manikuni and Puthoorvayalthodu to the Kalpetta Municipality and the areas of Naderi Desam in Arikulam Grama Panchayat, comprising of 3 wards, to the Quilandy Municipality. Consequential notifications, SRO No. 1057/99, published as per GO (P) No. 254/99.LSGD dated 21-12-1999 and SRO No. 1058/99, published as per GO (P) No. 255/99.LSGD dated 21-12-1999, were issued under the Municipality Act.

    4. With effect from 1-10-2005, the “larger urban areas” of Nemom, Thiruvallam and Attipara of the Thiruvananthapuram City Corporation and the “smaller urban areas”, Andoor, Kodiyeri, Ezhuvathuruthy, Perumpazhuthur, Arthat and Naderi Desom in Thaliparamba, Thalassery, Ponnani, Neyyattinkara, Kunnamkulam and Quilandy Municipalities respectively, were notified by the Governor, as “village Panchayats” for the purpose of Part IXA of the Constitution. This is the impugned action. This has been done in exercise of powers conferred by clause (d) of Article 243P and clause (2) of Article 243Q of the Constitution, read with clause (b) of sub-section (2) of Section 4 of the Municipality Act, as per SRO No. 459/2005, published as per GO (P) No. 139/05.LSGD dated 9-5-2005. By SRO No. 460/2005, published as per GO (P) No. 140/05.LSGD, SRO No. 461/2005, published as per GO (P) No. 141/05.LSGD and SRO No. 462/2005, published as per GO(P) No. 142/05.LSGD, all dated 9-5-2005, the Government issued consequential notifications under Section (4) of the Municipality Act, after considering the objections and suggestions of the respective Municipal Corporations, excluding the areas among the aforesaid, which were parts of their territories.

    Evolution of the concept of local self government institutions under the Constitution and the Statutes relevant aspects:

    5. Among the Directive Principles of State Policy, Article 40 provides that the State shall take steps to organize village panchayats and endow them with such powers and authority as may be necessary to enable them to function as units of self government.

    6. In the national context, it can be noticed that the Balwant Rai Mehta Committee came to the conclusion that in the absence of democratic decentralization, no meaningful and sustained development could be expected. It was following the Mehta Committee report that certain States took legislative and administrative initiatives to set up Panchayat Raj Institutions.

    7. The Kerala Panchayats Act, 1960, the Kerala Municipalities Act, 1960, the Kerala Municipal Corporations Act, 1961 and certain other local statutes were made to give effect to this constitutional goal, thereby amending and consolidating laws modifying the relevant pre-constitutional laws.

    8. With the passage of time, it was observed that the Panchayat Raj Institutions had not been able to acquire the status and dignity of viable and responsive people's bodies, due to a number of reasons. Accordingly, drawing inspiration from Article 40 of the Constitution and in the light of the experience of over 40 years of post-constitutional India, in view of the short-comings which had been observed, it was found that there is an imperative need to enshrine in the Constitution certain basic and essential features of Panchayat Raj Institutions to impart certainty, continuity and strength to them. It was accordingly that the Constitution (73rd Amendment) Act, 1992 was passed by the Parliament and came into force on 24-4-1993.

    9. In many States, local bodies had become weak and ineffective on account of various reasons, including the failure to hold regular elections, prolonged supersessions and inadequate devolution of powers and-functions and as a result, Urban Local Bodies were not able to perform effectively as vibrant democratic units of self-government. Having regard to the said inadequacies, it was considered necessary that provisions relating to Urban Local Bodies are incorporated in the Constitution, particularly for among other things, putting on a firm footing, the relationship between the State Government and the Urban Local Bodies with respect to different matters. Accordingly, Part IXA was introduced in the Constitution as per the Constitution (74th Amendment) Act, 1992 which came into force with effect from 1-6-1993.

    10. Thus, while Part IX deals exclusively with the Panchayats, Part IXA deals exclusively with the Municipalities.

    Panchayats

    11. Clauses (g) and (c) of Article 243 define, respectively, a “village” and “intermediate level” to be so as specified by the Governor, for the purpose of Part IXA of the Constitution. Article 243B provides that Panchayats shall be constituted at the village, intermediate and district levels in accordance with the provisions of Part IX. The making of law by the State under Article 243C is only regarding the composition and not as regards the constitution of the Panchayats which is a constitutional process by the Governor issuing a public notification in exercise of authority under Article 243(g) and Article 243B then comes into operation by virtue of which the Panchayat as defined in Article 243(d) comes into being. These provisions are referred to, to notice the genesis of a Panchayat and to differentiate the Panchayat conceived of Part IX from the Panchayat that was provided for by the statutory provisions before the introduction of Part IX into the Constitution. The Panchayats have thus become constitutional institutions and their birth and existence are dependent on the mechanism provided for, in the Constitution itself. All that was left to the States were to make laws regarding the composition of the Panchayats and other matters as are provided for from and inclusive of Article 243C onwards in Part IX.

    Municipalities

    12. Insofar as Municipalities in Part IXA are concerned, having regard to the population of the area as defined in Article 243P(g), the density of population therein, the revenue generated for local administration, the percentage of employment in non-agricultural activities, the economic importance or such other factors, as he may deem fit, the Governor may specify by public notification “a transitional area”, “a smaller urban area” or “a larger urban area”. On such notification being issued under Article 243Q(2), a Municipality”, meaning an institution of self-government as defined in Article 243P(e) comes into being. By the mechanism provided under Article 243Q(1), a Nagar Panchayat gets constituted for a transitional area, a Municipal Council gets constituted for a smaller urban area and a Municipal corporation gets constituted for a larger urban area. The constitution of such Municipalities is the mandate of the Constitution and does not depend on any.law made by the Legislature. As is in the case of Panchayats, the making of law by the State gets confined to subjects commencing only from the composition of Municipalities, as provided from and inclusive of Article 243R.

    13. Article 243Q(1)(a) provides for the constitution of a Nagar Panchayat for a transitional area, that is, an area in transition from a rural area to an urban area. Article 243Q envisages two types of urban areas, namely, smaller urban area and larger urban area. There is no transitional area contemplated where the transition is from a smaller urban area to a larger urban area. The constitutional context emanating out of Article 243Q conceives and envisages only the transition of a rural area to an urban area, be it as a smaller urban area or as a larger urban area. It does not contemplate or provides to the contrary, for the transition of an urban area into a rural area. This is what emanates out of a plain reading of Article 243Q(1) of the Constitution. There is no provision in either among Parts IX or IXA, for the transition of an urban area to a rural area.

    14. While Article 243(g) gives no constitutional yardstick for the Governor to ascertain and specify a village. Article 243Q(2) provides yardsticks to identify transitional area, smaller urban area and larger urban area. It has been held by the Apex Court in State of U.P v. Pradhan Singh Kshettra Samiti, 1995 Supp (2) SCC 305: (AIR 1995 SC 1512) that in specifying villages for the purpose of Part IX. the Governor is not bound by any particular Yardsticks. Article 243Q(2) provides the yardsticks for the three types of areas mentioned in Article 213Q(2) and the municipal area as defined in Article 243P(d) is the territorial area of a Municipality as is notified by the Governor. These provisions would show that there cannot be a transition of the constitutionally created smaller urban area, larger urban area and a transitional area, to be a village, to fall into Part IX of the Constitution and such an exercise cannot be done under Part IXA of the Constitution. This is because the Municipality, in relation to a transitional area or a smaller urban area, or a larger urban area, on its coming into existence, becomes a constitutional institution and cannot be abolished by an act of the Legislature without specific authorisation in that regard in the Constitution. All that could be done, if a situation demands, is to exclude any particular urban area from a Municipality to be made part of another Municipality or merger of municipalities or creation of a new municipality, either by the area being excluded or by merging such excluded areas.

    However, there cannot be a transition of an urban area as a rural area. I may at once notice that unlike the Municipalities Act, 1960, which had provided for the abolition of Municipalities, there is no such provision in the Municipality Act, 1994. Such provisions would be contrary to the constitutional provisions in Part IXA and hence, obviously, not made in the 1994 Act. However, Section 4(6) provides for handling the situation, owing to such abolition. The said provision is superfluous.

    15. The aforesaid view that I take is also fortified by the nature of Section 4 of the Municipality Act, 1994 which provides for conversion of village Panchayat into a Town Panchayat or a Municipal Council, for conversion of a Town Panchayat into a Municipal Council and for conversion of a Municipal Council into a Municipal Corporation. This shows that it had never been in the contemplation of even the State Legislature while making the Municipality Act, 1994 that a Municipality could be converted to a village Panchayat. This was because it was wholly impermissible in the constitutional context in which Part IX and Part IXA have been separately provided, to govern two types of local self-government institutions.

    16. The aforesaid situation is sought to be met by Advocate Sri V. Giri on behalf of the respondents contending that by virtue of Article 367(1) of the Constitution, the General Clauses Act, 1897 would apply and that, therefore; the power of the Governor to notify under Article 243Q(2) includes a power to de-notify, amend or alter the said notification, by virtue of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act. Reference was made to the decision of the Apex Court in K.P Khetan v. Union of India, AIR 1957 SC 676 and the decision of the Full Bench of the Gujarat High Court in Ranchhod Zina v. Patankar, AIR 1966 Gujarat 248. Insofar as the decision of the Gujarat High Court is concerned, Section 10 of the Bombay Village Panchayats Act that fell for construction, did not provide for any transition from a rural area to an urban are a or vice-versa, as in this case. Reference was also made to the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in M.K Krishnan Nair v. State of Kerala, 1974 Ker LT 313: (1974 Lab IC 1170), to state that Section 21 of the General Clauses Act would apply by virtue of Article 367 of the Constitution even if the power under Article 237, which fell for consideration in the said case, is one of conditional legislation.

    17. In my considered view, as rightly urged by senior Advocate Sri T.P.K Nambiar, this is a context to the contrary, which excludes the application of Section 21 of the General Clauses Act and therefore, even in terms of Article 367, the said rule of interpretation does not apply to the situation in hand. This is so because unless the power to re-transit an area which has become smaller urban area or larger urban area, to be a rural area is not expressly provided for in the Constitution, it will result in conceding a power to re-transit an area from the operation of part IXA to part IX of the Constitution. Had it ever been the intention of the Parliament to provide for such a re-transit, a crucial process, there is no reason why such specific provision does not find a place in the Constitution itself. The very absence of such a provision leads only to the conclusion that such re-transit is impermissible. Therefore, the application of the provisions of the Section 21 will be repugnant to the context and situation governed by Article 243Q(2). In such situations, recourse to the General Clauses Act is not available (See T.M Kanniyan v. ITO, AIR 1968 SC 637).

    18. In the aforesaid context, the exclusive power of the State to make laws referable to the legislative head in Entry V of the List II of the Seventh Schedule is circumscribed by the provisions of Parts IX or IXA, as the case may be. While laws are made in relation to the panchayats, they stand circumscribed by Part IX and the law making in relation to Municipalities will stand controlled part IXA.

    19. Therefore, a rural area after its transition to be an urban area, thereby becoming a “smaller urban area” or a “larger urban area” in terms of Article 243Q of the Constitution of India, cannot be converted to be a rural area. Further, no such exercise can be done under the provisions of Part, IXA of the Constitution of India or otherwise. Hence, the impugned “de-linking” of certain urban areas from the municipalities, for being treated as rural areas is unconstinational and void.

    Provisions of the Municipality Act

    20. Chapter II of the 1994 Act does not provide for abolition of a municipality. Sub-section (2) of Section 4 reads as follows:

    “4. (2) The Government may, by notification,—

    (a) exclude any municipal area from the operation of this act; or

    (b) exclude from a municipal area comprised therein and defined in the notification; or

    (c) divide any municipal area into two or more municipal areas; or

    (d) unite two or more municipal areas; or

    (e) unite the territorial area of a Panchayat geographically lying adjacent to a Municipal area, with the Municipality; or

    (f) convert a Village Panchayat into a Town Panchayat or a Municipal Council; or

    (g) convert a Town Panchayat into a Municipal Council; or

    (h) convert a Municipal Council into a Municipal Corporation:

    Provided that, before issuing such a notification the requirements under Article 243Q and sub-section (1) shall be fulfilled and the suggestions and opinions of the Village Panchayat or Town Panchayat or Municipal council or Municipal Corporation concerned, shall be considered.

    Provided further that any notification issued under this sub-section shall not be brought into force except in such a way as to coincide with the expiry of the term of the existing Municipal Council or Village Panchayat in that territorial area.”

    The afore-quoted is from the Official English version of the Statute as published by the Government of Kerala. There was some controversy regarding the provision, Section 2(b) as quoted above. Hence, the Malayalam version of the same is extracted hereunder:

    (Vernacular matter omitted).

    The following is a proper English version of the same:

    (b) to exclude from the area of a municipality, any specified area comprised therein and defined in such notification, or

    21. As already noticed, the power to exclude any area from the municipal area cannot extend to re-transit the municipal area so excluded, to be a rural area. So much so, Section 4(2)(b) can be read to permit only the exclusion from a municipal area, of any area to continue to remain either as a smaller urban area or as a larger urban area and not to re-transit it to be a rural area. This is all the more so because, under an exercise under the Municipality Act, a rural area cannot be constituted. The rural areas come into being under Part IX of the Constitution by virtue of the exercise of notifying the villages. Such notification of villages insofar as a village area is concerned, does not survive after its transit as an urban area.

    22. This takes me to the argument advanced by Adv. Sri V. Giri to the effect that by the process of exclusion of an area from a municipal area, it cannot be treated to remain in a vacuum but has to be construed as falling into being a rural area for the purpose of Part IX and thereafter, all that needs to be done is the issuance of a notification under the Panchayat Raj Act to make it a panchayat area. As already noticed, a rural area under Part IX of the Constitution ceases to be so, the moment it is notified for transition as an urban area under the provisions of Article 243Q of the Constitution. Therefore, the mere issuance of any notification under Section 4(2)(b) cannot result in the municipal area becoming a panchayat area. Section 4(2)(b), otherwise, would be unconstitutional and hence, would be liable to be read down to that extent.

    23. Having regard to the arguments advanced, certain aspects need to be considered, though in the view that has been taken above, it may not be necessary to deal with the other questions raised.

    24. One of the relevant factors under Article 243Q(2) is the population of the area. “Population” is defined in Article 243P(g) to mean the population as ascertained at the last preceding census of which the relevant figures have been published. This is relevant not only for the purpose of Article 243Q of the Constitution but also as to whether the bench-mark as regards population in relation to the municipal corporation area has been attained. It is the admitted situation that though the population as ascertained as per the 2001 census has been published, the same was not relied on, but the previous data were acted upon.

    25. Since the impugned notifications include the exercise under Section 4 of the Act, it was further pointed out by Senior Advocate Sri. M.K Damodaran that the first proviso to Section 4(2) of the Act enjoins that before issuing a notification under Section 4(2), the requirements under Article 243Q ought to be fulfilled. He, therefore, contended, in my view, rightly, that the requirements of Article 243Q have not been complied with before issuing the notifications under Section 4. So much so, the challenge to the notifications, insofar as they are issued under Section 4(2) of the Act stands.

    26. The right to be heard before the impugned action was also urged. Sri Damodaran referred to the decision in Baldev Singh v. State of Himachal Pradesh (1987) 2 SCC 510: (AIR 1987 SC 1239) in support of the proposition that where an exercise of power results in civil consequences to citizens, unless the statute specifically rules out the application of natural justice, the rules of natural justice would apply and that the public has a right to be heard. The Apex Court in Baldev Singh's case, which related to interpretation of the Himachal Pradesh Municipality Act, 1968, referred to the decision of the Apex Court in State of Orissa v. Sridhar Kumar Mallik, (1985)3 SCC 697: (AIR 1985 SC 1411) and noticed that while the Orissa Act provided in clear terms a right of hearing, the Himachal Pradesh Act did not make any such provision and went on to hold as follows:—

    “………………….the settled position in law is that where exercise of a power results in civil consequences to citizens, unless the statute specifically rules out the application of natural justice, the rules of natural justice would apply. We accept the submission on behalf of the appellants that before the notified area was constituted in terms of Section 256 of the Act, the people of the locality should have been afforded an, opportunity of being heard and the administrative decision by the State Government should have been taken after considering the views of the residents. Denial of such opportunity is not in consonance with the scheme of the Rule of Law governing our society. We must clarify that the hearing contemplated is not required to be oral and can be by inviting objections and disposing them of in a fair way.”

    27. Reference was made to the decision in State of Maharashtra v. Jalgaon Municipal Council (2003) 9 SCC 731: (AIR 2003 SC 1659), to point out the following: (Paras 30 and 32)

    “It is a fundamental principle of fair hearing incorporated in the doctrine of natural justice and as a rule of universal obligation that all administrative acts or decisions affecting rights of individuals must comply with the principles of natural justice and the person or persons sought to be affected adversely must be afforded not only an opportunity of hearing but a fair opportunity of hearing. The State must act fairly just the same as anyone else legitimately expected to do and where the State action fails to satisfy the test it is liable to be struck down by the Courts in exercise of their judicial review jurisdiction.

    The caution of associating rules of natural justice with the flavour of flexibilities would not permit the Courts applying different standards of procedural justice in different cases depending on the whims or personal philosophy of the decision-maker. The basic principles remain the same; they are to be moulded in their application to suit the peculiar situations of a given case, for the variety and complexity of situations defies narration. That is flexibility. Some of the relevant factors which enter the judicial process of thinking for determining the extent of moulding the nature and scope of fair hearing and may reach to the extent of right to hearing being excluded are: (i) the nature of the subject matter, and (ii) exceptional situations. Such exceptionality may be spelled out by (i) the need to take urgent action for safeguarding public health or safety or public interest, (ii) the absence of legitimate expectation, (iii) by refusal of remedies in discretion, (iv) doctrine of pleasure such as the power to dismiss an employee at pleasure, and (v) express legislation. There is also a situation which Prof. Wade and Forsyth term as “dubious doctrine” that right to a fair hearing may stand excluded where the Court forms an opinion that a hearing Would make no difference. Utter caution is needed before bringing the last exception into play.”

    However, it was held in the said case that the requirements of principles of natural justice were satisfied.

    28. Since it was urged that the exercise undertaken as per the impugned notifications is conditional legislation, reference was made to the decision of the Apex Court in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, (2000) 1 SCC 168: (AIR 2000 SC 498) which laid down to the following effect: (Para 36)

    “It is now fairly well settled that legislative declarations of facts are not beyond judicial scrutiny in the constitutional context of Articles 14 and 16. In Kesavananda Bharti v. State of Kerala, (1973) 4 SCC 225: (AIR 1973 SC 1461) the question arose — in the context of legislative declarations made for purposes of Article 31-C whether the Court was precluded from lifting the veil, examining the facts and holding such legislative declarations as invalid. The said issue was dealt with in various judgments in that case, e.g judgments of Ray, J. (as he then was), Palekar, Khanna, Mathew, Dwivedi, JJ., and Beg, J. and Chandrachud, J. (as they then were) (see summary at pp. 304-L to O in SCC). The learned Judges held that the Courts could lift the veil and examine the position in spite of a legislative declaration. Ray, J. (as he then was) observed:

    “The Court can tear the veil to decide the real nature of the statute if the facts and circumstances warrant such a course.”

    *********

    A conclusive declaration would not be permissible so as to defeat a fundamental right.”

    (Emphasis supplied)

    Palekar, J. said that if the legislation was merely a pretence and the object was discrimination, the validity of the statute could be examined by the Court notwithstanding the declaration made by the legislature and the learned Judge referred to Charles Russell v. R., (1882) 7 AC 829 and to Attorney General v. Queen Insurance Co., (1978) 3 AC 1090. Khanna, J. held that the declaration could not preclude judicial scrutiny. Mathew, J. held that declarations were amenable to judicial scrutiny. If the law was passed only “ostensibly” but was in truth and substance, one for accomplishing an unauthorised object, the Court, it was held, would be entitled to tear the veil. Beg, J. (as he then was) held that the declaration by the legislature would not preclude a judicial examination. Dwivedi, J. said that the Courts retain the power in spite of Article 31-C to determine the correctness of the declaration. Chandrachud, J. (as he then was) held that the declaration could not be utilized as a cloak to evade the law and the declaration would not preclude the jurisdiction of the Courts to examine the facts.”

    29. Learned Advocate General, relying on the decision of the Apex Court in R.M.D Chamarbaugwalla v. Union of India, AIR 1957 SC 628, urged that even assuming that this Court comes to the conclusion that a part of the exercise is void, the same need not necessarily result in quashing the impugned notifications in their entirety. He rightly urged that in such circumstances, the doctrine of severability would come into play. However, as already found, no exercise under Section 4 of the Municipality Act could sustain, if the action purportedly taken under Article 243Q of the Constitution was impermissible. Having found that Article 243Q does not authorise the re-transit of an urban area to be a rural area, the question of sustaining the said action and striking off the remaining, on account of infraction of the statutory provisions of the Municipality Act, does not arise. The same has to go as a whole.

    Constitutionality of Section 4(2)(b)

    30. In W.P (C) No. 16997/2005 by an amendment to the writ petition, the constitutional validity of Section 4(2)(b) is sought to be challenged. Though the pleading as to constitutionality is confined to uncontrolled delegation of legislative power, the arguments predominantly revolved around the extension of the said provision to find an authority to re-transit a municipal area to a rural area. It having already been found that the said provision has to be read as not permitting any such authority, the said provision in the statute stands, however, that it has to be read as interpreted above.

    Standing

    31. Now, the objection of the State to the writ petitions, on ground of standing. It is urged by the learned Advocate General that the petitioners have no right to institute writ petitions challenging the impugned notifications. None has a case that the writ petitioners do not belong to the municipal areas that are being severed by reason of the impugned notifications. A reference to the decision of the Apex Court in Baldev Singh's case (AIR 1987 SC 1239) (supra) is sufficient to overrule the objections in this regard, raised by the State. I do so.

    32. The learned Advocate General had referred to various judgments of this Court, namely, O.P 5590/1992, W.A 519/1993 and O.P 9595/1989, to urge the proposition that similar exercise of linking areas to and de-linking them from municipalities has been upheld by this Court. In my view, those decisions related to situations available before the amendment of the Constitution as per the 73rd and 74th Amendments to the Constitution.

    33. As already noticed, the impugned notifications result in undoing what has been done in the year 1999. The materials on record would show that the areas which are sought to be carved out to re-transit as rural areas were notified as smaller urban areas or larger urban areas in 1999, after being subjected to earlier exercises of being ‘linked’ and ‘de-linked’. At any rate, it has to be presumed so. It is apposite, in this context, to notice a remark of the Apex Court in State of Haryana v. State of Punjab, (2002) 2 SCC 507: (AIR 2002 SC 685) (Para 17).

    “What really bothers us most is the functioning of the political parties, who assume power to do whatever that suits them and whatever would catch the vote bank. They forget for a moment that the Constitution conceives of a Government to be manned by the representatives of the people, who get themselves elected in an election. The decisions taken at the governmental level should not be so easily nullified by a change of Government and by some other political party assuming power, particularly when such a decision affects some other States and the interest of the nation as a whole. It cannot be disputed that so far as the policy is concerned, a political party assuming power is entitled to engraft the political philosophy behind the party, since that must be held to be the will of the people. But in the matter of governance of a State or in the matter of execution of a decision taken by a previous Government, on the basis of a consensus arrived at, which does not involve any political philosophy, the succeeding Government must be held duty-bound to continue and carry on the unfinished job rather than putting a stop to the same.”

    I quoted the above “only to notice that the repeated exercises of successive Governments could not be viewed to be in the interest of the public at large and against the very object of the 73rd and 74th Amendments to the Constitution, intended to give the Local Self Government Institutions, the status of constitutional authorities, insulating them from governmental intervention except to the extent referable to the Constitution.

    34. In the result, these writ petitions are allowed declaring SRO No. 459/2005, SRO No. 460/2005, SRO No. 461/2005 and SRO No. 462/2005 as unconstitutional. The said notifications are quashed. No costs.

    Petitions allowed.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    K.P Raveendran And Another v. State Of Kerala And Others
    (Aug 5, 2005)